Scribd
Upload
201 views2 pages

Statistical Tolerance Analysis

Statistical tolerance analysis calculates how variation in input features affects variation in output measurements. It considers the distributions of input tolerances rather than just worst-case values. A 1D tolerance stackup analyzes features in a straight line. Root-sum squared analysis assumes normal distributions and linear relationships, while second-order analysis incorporates higher moments and non-linear functions, providing more accuracy that better reflects real-world manufacturing. The appropriate method depends on how well each matches the assembly's manufacturing and inspection processes.

Uploaded by

Selvaraj Balasundram
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
201 views2 pages

Statistical Tolerance Analysis

Statistical tolerance analysis calculates how variation in input features affects variation in output measurements. It considers the distributions of input tolerances rather than just worst-case values. A 1D tolerance stackup analyzes features in a straight line. Root-sum squared analysis assumes normal distributions and linear relationships, while second-order analysis incorporates higher moments and non-linear functions, providing more accuracy that better reflects real-world manufacturing. The appropriate method depends on how well each matches the assembly's manufacturing and inspection processes.

Uploaded by

Selvaraj Balasundram
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 2

Understanding Statistical Tolerance Analysis

Definition of Statistical Tolerance Analysis


A statistical tolerance analysis is when you take the variation of a set of inputs to calculate the expected variation of an output of interest. In
mechanical engineering, a product design is composed of multiple features, each with tolerance values that control the variable aspects of
those features. Statistical tolerance analysis is used to understand how these tolerances contribute the various performance characteristics of
the design.

1D Tolerance Stackup
The simplest form of tolerance analysis is the single direction, 1D Tolerance Stackup. A 1D Tolerance Stackup is created by creating a cross
section of a model and adding the tolerance values for each feature in a straight line. The variation in each contributes to the overall

output/outcome.

Worst-Case Analysis vs RSS (Root-Sum Squared) Statistical Analysis

In a Worst-Case Analysis, each dimension will have a minimum and maximum value that represents the range of acceptability for that
dimension. Worst-Case answers the question, if I take the maximum range on each input, what is the maximum range for the measurement
of interest or stackup? We are therefore dealing with the limits of acceptability and not probability.

RSS (Root-Sum Squared) Statistical Analysis does not focus on the extreme values, but focuses on the distribution of the variation for each
dimension. Each dimension will have a unique distribution of values based on the manufacturing process. Tool wear, operator differences,
changes in material and environment all contribute to variation in the dimension value. Each dimension has its own distribution curve.

When you combine the probabilities for each dimension (each separate curve) you get the probability for the total and therefore the
distribution curve of the total. Statistical analysis answers the question, given the distribution of variation on each dimension what is the
probability that my performance characteristic will fall within defined acceptable limits. The limitation of RSS is that it assumes all inputs
are normally distributed and all performance characteristics have a linear relationship with the dimension. These assumptions do not account
for the breadth of conditions that exist in typical scenarios found in manufacturing.

Second Order Tolerance Analysis

Because manufacturing methods vary for different types of parts, the distribution moments or parameters change as well. RSS only uses
standard deviation and does not include the higher moments of skewness and kurtosis that better characterize the effects tool wear, form
aging and other typical manufacturing scenarios. Second Order Tolerance Analysis incorporates all distribution moments:
Second Order Tolerance Analysis is also needed to determine what your output is going to be when the assembly function is not linear. In
typical mechanical engineering scenarios kinematic adjustments and other assembly behaviors result in non-linear assembly functions.
Second order calculations are much more complex so hand calculations are not advisable but the computation accuracy is greatly improved
and becomes viable within a tolerance analysis software package.

Summary of Statistical Tolerance Analysis for practical useage


The choice in tolerance analysis method is based on many factors, but the can be summarized as Which method best matches the
manufacturing and inspection process of the assembly. For simple fit problems, a 1D stack-up may be sufficient. RSS is sufficient for the
small number of scenarios where the inputs are normal and the assembly relationships are linear. For all other scenarios, Second Order
Tolerance Analysis is required to address the real world of manufacturing.

You might also like