Alternative To Coursework Notes
Alternative To Coursework Notes
Recent Changes
Members
Homepage
IB Optional Topics
Hazards and disasters - risk assessment and response
Freshwater - issues and conflict
Leisure, sport and tourism
As a IGCSE geographer it is possible to carry out coursework on many aspects of the course.
Possible topics and areas of study may include:
Rivers
Changes in channel depth, width, cross-section and wetted perimeter from source to
mouth
Changes in pollution along a rivers' course (you need proper equipment for this)
Coasts
Changes in pedestrians
Changes in the quality of the environment or pollution levels (may look at the impact of
industry)
Changes in globalisation
Changes in wealth or population density (will have to use some secondary data)
Weather
Changes in rainfall
Changes in humidity
Sensible dress (remember you will be representing your school, but you should also wear
clothes that don't draw attention to yourself
Always tell an adult or teacher where you area carrying out coursework
Never do coursework near a river or the sea without an adult or teacher and without them
checking that it is safe
Check that your study area is safe. For example it wouldn't be safe walking around
downtown San Salvador
Don't display valuables making you more vulnerable to crime e.g. if you have a camera
or a phone keep it out of sight
Introduction
Hypothesis: A hypothesis is a prediction or statement that you make before your data collection.
A hypothesis is normally based on theory. During your investigation you attempt to prove or
disprove your hypothesis. A piece of coursework may have more than one hypothesis and it does
not matter if you prove or disprove it.
A hypothesis should always be SMART. If your hypotheses are not SMART then it can be
impossible to prove or disprove them.
S = Specific
M = Measurable
A = Achievable
R = Realistic
T = Time-related
The width of a river will increase as you move from the source to the mouth
The amount of traffic will increase as you move from the rural-urban fringe to the CBD
The amount of vegetation will increase as you move inland from the sea (distance =
200metres)
The hottest part of the day will be between 1200 and 1400.
Data Collection
Whenever you are doing data collection, the aim is to be as objective as possible. Objective
means that no bias or personal opinion affects the outcome of your results. The opposite to be
objective is being subjective. Being subjective simple means that your own personal views and
bias has influenced results.
Objective: This is when data collection is not influenced by people's personal opinion. This is
very hard to achieve because even the design of data collection forms are influenced by people's
opinion. However, it is possible to try be as objective as possible by following a sampling
technique, collecting data in groups and following the methodology closely.
Subjective: This is when your personal opinion has an influence on the outcome of the data
collection. Everyone has personal bias, so this is not necessarily bad, but you should recognise
this in your methodology and evaluation.
Primary data: Any data that is personally collected by you (this does not mean collecting off the
internet). Primary data may include traffic counts, pedestrian counts, environmental indexes,
questionnaires or land use surveys.
Secondary data: Any data that has been collected by someone else. Secondary data collection
maybe found in books, on the internet, in academic journals, etc. Probably the most useful
secondary data is census data.
Census: The census is a survey carried out by nearly all countries every 10 years. The census is a
very detailed survey that is compulsory for everyone to fill in. It includes a lot of data including
family size, income, house size and car ownership.
It is up to date (current)
You know how the data has You can study temporal changes e.g.
been collected i.e. what how population has changed over a
technique number of years
Disadvantages The data may include some It is out of date, especially if it has
personal bias been printed in a book.
Quantitative data: This is any data that involves figures. Quantitative data is very easy to
present and analyse. Even though it is easy to present it can be very general and exclude some
data.
Qualitative data: This is is more written data or even photographs or pictures. It tends to me
individual and personal, but it can be very hard to present and analyse. Qualitative data often
comes about as the results of interviews with open-ended questions.
Pilot Survey: This is basically a test that you carry out before your data collection. It is very
important that you test your data collection forms to ensure that you ask all the right questions
and your collection forms contain all the right categories. It is too expensive and too time
consuming to going and collect data a second time, if you missed it the first time.
Sampling: As a Geography student you will only have a limited amount of time and money to
carry out your coursework. Therefore it will probably be necessary to only investigate a sample.
A sample is simply a section or part of the entire study area or study population. The two main
types of sampling are; systematic and random.
Systematic Sampling: This is when you collect data in a regular pattern. For example you may
ask a questionnaire to every 10th person that passes you, or you might only record the land use
every 50 metres or every 5th building. When recording changes in river depth, beach profile or
changes in vegetation you may only take a sample every 5 metres.
Random Sampling: This is when every area or person in your study area has an equal chance of
being selected or asked. Random sampling can be done by pulling names out of a hat, by using a
random number table or a random number generator on a calculator.
Advantages Disadvantages
Because you are
following a pattern you Because you are selecting the systematic
will get better coverage of technique, there is some bias
an area or sample group. (subjectivity). You decide how often to
take a sample.
Systematic Even though you pick the
Sampling technique, once it is Even with a systematic sample you may
picked, there is no bias in end up with an unrepresentative sample
who gets selected. e.g. you ask every 10th person to fill in a
questionnaire, but every 10th person turns
It is very simple to out to be female.
understand and carry out.
Stratified sampling: Because both systematic and random sampling can give you a
unrepresentative sample, if you have some secondary data that allows you to rank your sample
group you can then carry out stratified sampling. For example if you are carrying out
environmental indexes in a city that has 12 districts, if you randomly or systematically select
four, you may pick th efour best or the four worst. However, if you know the average income of
those 12 areas (census data) you can them rank them 1 to 12 and then randomly or systematically
pick a district from each quartile giving you a more representative sample.
Specification: Enquiry skills to collect data: Questions on this paper will test knowledge and
application of the methodology used in the following range of data collection enquiry skills.
Decide on your questions (what do you need to find out and what type of question are
you going to ask)
Whether to do the questions orally or give them in written form (you may have to think
about translations)
How you are going to record the answers (record them, write them down, trying to
remember is unreliable)
Remember that you are representing yourself and the school - be polite
Remember people don't have to answer questions and they may be sensitive about some
e.g. age groups and income groups.
When actually designing your questions you have two real choice; open or closed:
Open ended questions: These are questions that have infinite numbers of answers. The
respondent has no restriction on how they might answer e.g. What have you enjoyed about El
Salvador?
Closed questions: These are when there is a limited number of responses. These questions are
often multiple choice in style e.g. What have you enjoyed about El Salvador? A: The people B:
The weather C: The beaches D: The Colonial Villages E: Other
Advantages Disadvantages
Open ended You are getting the Some responses might not be relevant
questions respondents personal to your research
opinion. They are not
limited in their response. Respondents may not understand the
question and give you an irrelevant
response
Results are very hard to analyse using
graphs or tables
Land use: Land use survey are a very common form of data collection. When carrying out a land
use survey you first need to think of appropriate categories e.g. restaurants, clothes shops, banks,
houses, etc. You then then need to decide whether you are just looking at total numbers or spatial
distribution. If you are just looking at total numbers then you can make a simple tally chart, if
you look at spatial distribution you need a base map and an appropriate key. When doing a land
use survey you also need to decide if you are surveying every building or just taking a sample.
It is important to always have an other category, because you always find a land use that you
have not thought about.
For information on when and how to use field sketches, sketch maps and maps refer to the
IGCSE skills page: IGCSE Skills (Paper 2)
Photographs are an increasingly common form of data presentation. Using photos is now a lot
easier in the digital era when you can crop, manipulate and annotate photographs. However, a
common mistake is still to include photos that aren't relevant to answer your hypothesis. Many
people include photographs that aren't even referred to in their text and are not properly labelled.
Advantages of Photographs Disadvantages of Photographs
Specification: Counts Pedestrian and traffic counts are two significant examples of this
enquiry skill. Appropriate methods for recording the counts should be discussed including the
layout of recording sheets, instructions and the necessary information required to identify the
sheet following the count (i.e. time, date, location and name of recorder).
The two most common types of count are traffic count and pedestrian count. When designing
traffic and pedestrian counts keep the forms simple. Have an area for the tally and an area to add
up the total. It also is very important to have a place to mark down the date, time and location of
the count. This is important for when you return to the classroom and start data presentation and
making comparisons. When ever doing a count you need to find a safe location and carry it out
for 10 minutes. If you are comparing different locations you should and do the counts at the same
time, this makes comparisons fair. For example if you did one traffic count at 08.00am when
everyone was travelling to work and one at 11.00am when everyone is at work then the
comparison is unfair. Tallies are usually used when doing counts because they are quick and
simple.
DATE:
TIME:
LOCATION:
Total (add up your tally after you have done the data
Tally
collection
Cars 102
Bikes
Buses and
coaches
Lorries (trucks)
Taxis
Other
TOTAL
As well traffic and pedestrian counts environmental and globalisation indexes are also very
common and simple forms of data collection. Indexes normally use bi-polar scoring. This simply
means the score goes from negative to positive with 0 being the average. Indexes are quite
subjective (one person might think one crisp packet is a lot of litter while enough might think it
is hardly ant litter), therefore, to keep the indexes consistent for comparisons you should do them
in groups and one group should do all the same index e.g. group 1 only does environmental
indexes. Like with counts, it is very important that you write down the date, time and location of
the index and that where possible indexes are done at the same time.
Environmental index: This is a type of survey that looks at the quality of the environment. Your
survey may focus on any aspect of the environment e.g. air or noise pollution, greenery, litter,
graffiti.
Globalisation index: This is a type of survey that looks at how globalised a settlement or a
section of a settlement is. The survey make look at any aspect of globalisation including
language, signage, businesses and people.
With both environmental and globalisation indexes you use bi-polar scoring. Once you have
completed the index you add up the marks to give an area an overall score.
DATE:
TIME:
LOCATION:
-2 (minus -1 (minus 0 +1 (plus +2 (plus
two) one) (zero) one) two)
Lots of litter * No litter
Lots of noise e.g. cars,
* No noise (silence)
factories and people
Broken windows and Newly painted and
*
graffiti new windows
No greenery, only Lots of trees, parks
*
concrete and green areas
TOTAL SCORE = 2
Weather Equipment
Ranging poles, look like a javelin and are normally used for
Ranging Pole measuring slope angle with a clinometer. However, they can
also be used for measuring things like the depth of a river.
Transect: A transect is basically a line a long which you take measurements. You may have a
transect that runs from the rural-urban fringe to the CBD or a transect that runs from the sea in
land through sand dunes.
Methodology
In a real piece of coursework, you would explain how all your data was collected. In your
description you would probably contain the following information:
Group size
Description and copy of data collection forms used e.g. questionnaires or counts
Explanation of how the forms were used e.g. sample size, count period, count technique,
etc.
Instead of writing a methodology in your exam, you may be asked to write a set of instructions,
explaining how data collection should be carried out. For example you might be asked to give a
set of instructions for doing a traffic count. You might say:
Find a safe location near the road your are counting traffic
A tally should be used for counting because this is easy and quick
At the end of 10 minutes count up the totals for each type of vehicle.
You may also be asked about how your data collection could be improved. Improvements may be
made in some of the following ways:
Do counts, surveys and indexes on different days of the week (including weekends)
Get two groups doing the same survey, index or count so that an average may be taken
Data Presentation
You will probably be asked to complete a graph, diagram or table in the coursework
examination. Therefore you should remember the same equipment as paper 2:
Pencil
Ruler
Eraser
Sharpener
Protractor
Compass
Calculator
If you are asked to complete a graph or table, all the data will be there for you so read the data
carefully and complete the graph/table/diagram carefully.
You may also be asked the advantages (strengths) and disadvantages (weaknesses) of a particular
data presentation technique. Strengths and weaknesses may include:
Shows spatial distribution e.g. dot map Can disguise intra-region or intra-country
variations e.g. choropleth map
Shows variations between regions and
countries e.g. choropleth map
For further information on different data presentation techniques go the skills page of the wiki:
IGCSE Skills (Paper 2)
Data Analysis
Specification: Analysis: Candidates should be able to describe the patterns in data presented in
graphs and tables of results. Reference to relevant geographical knowledge and understanding is
often required in the interpretation of the data. Practice of this skill will improve success in Paper
4 questions.
You maybe asked to do some basic data analysis of graphs, tables, maps, photographs or
sketches. When doing data analysis remember the following:
Look for trends and correlations (if there is not a overall trend, look for smaller trends)
Look for anomalies (things that don't fit the general trend)
When ever you refer to trend and anomalies you must support with evidence e.g. facts
and figures from graph or table.
Try and explain trends (refer back to theory or other information that you have
discovered in your investigation)
Conclusion: This is basically a summary of your investigation. If you are asked to write a
conclusion remember the following:
Refer to theory (if mentioned in introduction) - do your findings agree or disagree with
theory
Evaluation: In an evaluation you state what went well in your research, but also how it can be
improved or extended in the future. If you are asked to write an evaluation, think about the
following:
Any problems with data collection e.g. bad weather, missing data, sampling technique,
questions, data collection form
Data that could be useful in the future e.g. secondary data from government, more
questionnaires (bigger sample)