Basil Chulev

ANCIENT MACEDONIA
PAIONIA

<><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><>

<><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><>
<><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><>

Skopje, Macedonia 2015

1
The intention of this essay is to provide simple and easy to understand overview of
periods from ancient Macedonian history and culture. It avoids substantial and detailed
explanations that consider wider historical background of the described events and
persons, and is written primarily for those approaching the topic for the first time. It also
avoids complex explanatory comments or insightful footnotes on the citations from the
sources. The given explanatory notes are prevalently etymological.

The introduction comprises the early periods of Macedonian history and presents a brief
overall retrospective of prehistoric Macedonia. The time-frame elaborated as a main
theme of this essay ranges from the beginning until the end of the 1st millennium BCE.
The interpretations given here are meant to enhance our understanding and appreciation
of a kingdom that became a superpower of the ancient world. They are focused strictly on
the Macedonian aspect of the story disregarding the wider geo-political perspective.

All the dates and references to centuries are BCE (Before the Common Era) except
where indicated otherwise. Throughout this essay, Macedonia/Macedonians generally
refer to the area of the mainland north of Mount Olymp (lat. Olympus), southeast of the
Mount ar (lat. Scardus) and west of the Rhodope Mountains. Macedonian peninsula
refers to what is called Balkans as of the 19th century, occupying the part of
southeastern Europe that lies south of the Danube and Sava rivers and forms a peninsula
bounded by the Adriatic and Ionian seas in the west, the Aegean and Black seas in the
east, and the Mediterranean Sea in the south.

Latinized/Anglicized names are given in parenthesis, some names and technical terms
are transliterated and these will be obvious when they appear. All terms and titles (e.g.
Iliad/Ilion) have been transliterated directly from their original ancient forms with as few
changes as possible: thus river Strumon rather then Strymon, and Stubera instead of
Stybera.

The terminology and concepts that are modern inventions (such as 'Hellenistic' or
'Greek') are altogether avoided. Such empirically wrong terms, used improperly by the
modern historiography, were originally meant to describe totally different categories
(such as the artistic periods) and were unknown to the ancient world. Their continued use
perpetuates misleading assumptions.

The modern-historiography 'privileged moments' are largely avoided too. For historians
today one such a privileged moment (of places and monuments as 'clasical') is 'Clasical
Athens', the Athens of the 5th and 4th centuries BCE. But when and why is so regarded?
Was 'Clasical Athens regarded as 'Clasical' already in antiquity? By whom?

The definitions, current meanings and related concepts of the words in English are
taken from the Oxford American Dictionary and Thesaurus (Mac OsX version 1.0.2 for
PowerPC) and/or Meriam-Webster online dictionary. For the words in Macedonian is
used the online ENCYCLOPDIA MACEDONICA (MAKEDONSKA
ENCIKLOPEDIJA) vol. 1 & 2, and online Macedonian dictionaries (idividi.com, etc.).

The sources that were used are listed in the References at the end of this essay.

2
Like the Carthaginians and the Spartans, the Macedonians are among the
silent people of the ancient Mediterranean basin. Almost everything that we
know about them derives from the written accounts of others, and as in the
case of the Carthaginians and the Spartans those written accounts were
either not well-informed or they were hostile, and occasional - E. N. Borza

3
 Introduction

Until 20 years ago ancient Paionian communities were known only from the facts based
exclusively on the records of the ancient authors. Needless to say that in the past centuries there
were numerous politic and other obstacles of the precise describing and determining Macedonia as
a geographic entity and in defining Macedonias borders to its neighbors, let alone in defining
Macedonian ethnic identity on the basis of a cultural geography of ancient Macedonic tribes.
Passages in the works of leading ancient geographers also show their difficulties in describing this
historical process. The very few known historical facts were that they are one of the oldest and
most developed ancient communities in the central and northern part of the Macedonic world,
their homeland was mainly along the valley of river Vardar (lat. Bardarios or Axius - the 'axis
river'), and whose troops were involved in the defense of Ilion (lat. Troy) against Danaan/Achaean
invaders in the Ilion War, and later in the campaigns of Alexander III of Macedon. They are
known to be the first who began with coins minting and were politically organized, and that their
rulers have been crowned with ritual bathing in the river Ateeboo (lat. Astibos, modern
Bregalnitsa), one of the Vardar tributaries. Their immediate neighbors and closest kin were the
Macedonian Brigii (i.e. Brygians/Phrygians) and Penesti on the west, Agrianians (i.e. Agrianes) to
the north, and Laiai and Maedoi on the east.

In book 4, Erodot (lat. Herodotus) distinguishes between three different warring parties in the
Peloponnesian War of the V century BCE: the Peloponnesian city-states (Athens, Thebes, Sparta,
etc.), the Gaul/Illyrian barbarians and the Macedonians, whom he judges at least in one passage to
be neither part of the city-states world nor barbarians. On the grounds of these ancient testimonies
the new scholarly emphasis on Macedonia developed. Supported in part from the many linguistic
and genealogical researches, and in part from the new archaeological finds that are revealed
almost on a daily basis. Much of our new appreciation of ancient Macedonic culture and society
came from the numerous recently excavated tombs of prominent Macedonians dating from the
remote ancient times, but also from the modern DNA-genealogical and linguistic researches that
also made a remarkable progress. These latest studies together with the fieldwork helped notably
to our understanding of the ancient Macedonic populations in Upper Macedonia, i.e. Paionia.
They recount the prehistoric relations between ancient communities and track down their
chronological and spacial coordinates with its sketchy borders.

Upper Macedonia, the original cradle of the Macedonian ethnos, where the kome (small town or
village) remained the basic unit of local government until well into Roman times, was the true
Borean (hence Hyperborean) ancestral homeland of the Macedonians. They gave the initial
impulse to the development and spread of the 5/4th millennium settlements in the regions of
Aegean and lower Danube, and further in the 3/2nd millennium toward today Ukraine/Russia and
as far as India (as 'Aryans'), and to Central-Western Europe (as Etrusci, Veneti and/or 'Gaul')1, as
well as in Asia Minor (Mushki and Phrygians) in the 2/1st millennium BCE. During their

1
Other nations also claimed their Macedonic roots. The Saxons trace their origin to Macedonia and
Alexander the Great, as survivors of Alexander the Great's army (the tribes of Lutii and
Bodrii/Obodriti) who fled the conquered lands after the fall of their Macedonic empire under Roman
occupation. Martin Luther (1483-1546) descended from the Macedonic stock of the tribe of Lutii. His
original ancestral name was Lyut (meaning harsh, angry in plain Macedonian).* His predecessors
were forced to Germanize their name to Lutyr, then Luthyr, and finally to Luther. Born in Lower
Saxony in a place which is today called Einsleben, earlier known by its Macedonic name, ibenica,
which is retained even today in the name of the 'old town' district called Siebenhitze. By a different
genealogical route, the wabians also claimed their Macedonian origin.
* Luta, the war-goddess of Macedonians as mentioned by Homer. Meaning furious in plain
Macedonian.
4
prehistoric movements these Pre-Aryan-Pelasgo-Macedonic ancestors brought with them their
culture and contributed to the creation and development of the early Indo-European centers in
antiquity.2

It has been convincingly demonstrated that the kingdom of Macedonia, as well as the later Roman
Provincia Macedonia, essentially remained a clearly distinguished political (or a military) concept.
While from a geographical point of view it was almost permanently a changing entity with yielding
borders, but roughly north of Mt. Olymp (lat. Olympus), limited by the Shar (lat. Scardus) mountain
range on the northwest, and by the river Mesta and Rhodope Mountains on the east. The northern
frontier was never clearly distinguished, because trespassed by the most frequented known ancient
corridor the rivers Vardar-Morava valley road, that is linked to the Danube junction on the north,
and from there further northwest to the Amber Road and eastward to the Black Sea and the Ukraine.
As a result of the progressive expansion of early Macedonians during the so-called archaic period,
all the other regional Macedonic tribes later fused together into a larger Macedonian unit. At the
beginning the Orestians (mkd. Gorani; eng. highlanders)3 from Argo (Argora), in western Lower
Macedonia (today Kostur-Klisoura region in Aegean Macedonia), together with other neighboring
Macedonic tribes living in Eordaia, Elimeia (Koani and Grevena), northern Timfaia (Hasia),
Lynkestia, Desaretia (Lerin-Prespa-Ohrid region), Elimiotia, Pelagonia and Paionia (i.e. Upper
Macedonia) began to form the Macedonian state, the first entity of that kind and scale on the
European soil. As from the late sixth century, after suffering a heavy defeat from Persians in the
Macedonian region of Paionia, Macedonia became a vassal state under Achaemenids until 479
BCE. During the Great Persian War of 480479 BCE Macedonia became an appendage and
tributary of the Persian empire, and the Macedonian troops had fought alongside those of Persia.
This old Macedon-Persian symbiosis remained very alive in the fourth century BCE during the
Macedonian campaign in Asia - Alexanders own prayer at Opis in 324 BCE clearly decrees the
established coalition between the two ruling classes of Europe and Asia: Macedonians and Persians.

2
Lepenski Vir, Vina, Kukuteni-Tripole, Sintata, etc.
3
Orestia highland, mountain forested highland, a region in Lower Macedonia; from archaic
"oro/ore", modern Macedonian: Gora [from gore - upstairs] mountain, 'highland'; Transcended
into modern Macedonian "orman" and 'Gora' both terms with meaning of forested
highland/mountain, adverbial: forest. Thus from 'Gora' - 'Gorani' - highlanders; also as personal
name Goran. Other examples: Orography - the branch of physical geography dealing with
mountains; Orogenesis - a geological process of forming a mountain range; "orangery" green
house; "orang-utan" forest person.
5
 ANCIENT UPPER MACEDONIA PAIONIA
Yntsi [y:ntsi; plural]4 - 'calfs', still in use as 'Yuntsi' (Cyrillic: ) calfs, youthful in all
Macedonic languages. This same word finds its exactly same resemblance in modern English word
'young(sters)' and German 'jung', with the same meaning 'junior', 'juvenile' (lat. juvenis); also in
'junoesque' [adjective] a (tall) young woman. It's the archaic Macedonian etymology of the name
for the ancient country of Paionia (lat. Paeonia)5, i.e. Upper-Ionia, or 'Pa-In-IA' in plain
Macedonian: 'Upper-Juniors-Land', along the river Vardar valley in what was also known in
antiquity as 'Upper Macedonia'. According to many ancient sources it is one and the same. For
example, Polybius tells us that the earlier name of Macedonia was "Emathia, formerly called
Paionia."6 This ethnonym is also the only plausible explanation why Persians called the people
across the Bosphorus and all the Aegean region - 'Yauna', or why these most ancient inhabitants
(that later colonised whole Asia Minor) are called 'Ionians' by the historians. At the end, we have
the topographical homonyms of the Ionian Sea on the west, Ionian Coast on the east, and in the
middle Upper Ionia (i.e. Paionia). If it's about coincidence it will be hard to believe:

Pausanias told us that Paion, the eponymous ancestor of the Paionians, was a brother of Epeios and
Aitolos, the eponymous ancestors of the Epeians of Elis and the Aietolians. Strabo tells us that the
Paionians once inhabited a territory that extended as far as Pelagonia (the area around Bitola) and
coastal Pieria east of the river Struma, and included much of what was later Macedonia. Pliny
describes the Paraxiaei, Aerdoeans, Almopians, Pelagones and Mygdonians as Paionian tribes too.7

4
Yunets/Ynets calf, youngster Macedonic; with hard-accented silent vocal (), like in 'earth'.
5
'Pa' upper. Examples: Papa (eng. the pope) - highness-highness; Palace (from lat. Palatium) up-
there-is, i.e. the Palatine hill of the emperor in Rome; Pataphysics [plural noun] over-metaphysic,
Patagon tall inhabitants of Patagonia;
'ion/in' young;
and 'ia' land. Examples: Croatia, Romania, Russia, etc.; comparable to -stan (Bulgaristan, Yunanistan,
Pakistan, etc.) or -land (Holland, England, etc.).
6
Polybius 23.10. "Philip's Desperate Measures"
7
Pliny Natural History IV, 10, 35.
6
The original ancient Macedonian genus emerged some 3 millenniums ago from the elements of a
Mediterranean prediluvian substratum of Pelasgians, Aeols/Boreans and Hyperboreans8, to which
prehistoric family all these Macedonic tribes belong. They contributed to the creation of
archetypical cultures of the second millennium BCE in the central regions of Macedonian peninsula
(Anti, Eneti, Brygii, Danuni, Kiti, Lapiti, Macedoni, Minii, Misiani, Mosiniki, Paioni, Pelasgi,
Penesti, Teucri, Trojans, etc.).9 The recent researches showed that the Genetic pool of todays
Macedonians still contains 30-40% of the original Proto-Macedonic genus of its ancestors.10

Above: Upper and Lower Macedonia (separated roughly with green-dashed line) around
360 BCE. The borders in yellow represents the general Geographic outlines of the wider
Macedonian territory. There's not precise known limit on its northern area, which in the
times of Filip II and Alexander III of Macedon reached as far as the Danube river. The
whole region range and the limits of different Macedonic kingdoms within also varied
during the passing millennia

The extension of the Paionian borders in the ancient times variated frequently due to internal
disputes within different Macedonian factions, as well as numerous foreign invasions and barbaric
intrusions. Consequently, among the territories that the Paionians held were: Emathia, Krestonia,

8
In Macedonic mythology, Boreas*, was the god of the North Wind of river Vardar, who had a
serpentshaped tail. The house of Boreas was located north of the river Struma (lat. Strymon) and his
protector was Ophion (mkd. Afion, now name for a poppy). In Macedonia the north wind is the strongest
of all winds and blows across the Hema (lat. Haemus, turk. Balkan) mountain range and along the
Strumon and Vardar valleys, causing storms in the Aegean Sea.
* Bura [borah] storm in plain Macedonian.
9
Old Europe - M. Gimbutas
10
National Geographic and A. A. Klyosov genetic researches conducted in 2005; Swiss iGENEA
genetic research conducted in 2009.
7
Mygdonia, Pelagonia, Pieria, and at some extent the land of the Agrianians as far as Mt. Pangaion.
However, the core of the ancient Paionia, or Pa-In-IA, was roughly where now is the central
section of the Republic of Macedonia, which by the way, is the only part of the whole region of
Macedonia that forms the independent Macedonian state today. The other larger parts of Macedonia
(Pirin and Aegean Macedonia, as well as the region of Pustec and Pogradec west of the Lake Ohrid)
undergone numerous invasions since the Roman times, and are until now under foreign occupation.

The most northern known cities of Paionia were Belazora (near Veles), Stoboi, and Skuopoi (later
Roman Scupi, today modern Skopje), even if their cultural presence intersected the Agrianian
territory (Polog/KosovoPole/SouthMorava/Skopje/Kumanovo/KrivaPalanka/Sofia) and is testified
as far north as the Grdelica Gorge and rchaeological site Kale at Krevica in today Serbia.
Recently a Paionian graveyard was discovered under the ruins of the Roman Scupi acropolis on the
outskirts of modern Skopje, thus confirming its pre-Roman Macedonic character. On the east was
their important town of Ateebo (lat. Astibus)11, mentioned in the Pevtinger table. On the banks of
the homonymous tributary of river Vardar, Ateebo (today Bregalnitsa), the Paionian kings took a
ritual bath at the time of their coronation. The name of the river and the eponymous city reflects
their unmistakable Macedonic character. Antigona was in the center toward south12, and the cities of
Gortinia, Atalantia and Amydon were on their southern flank, with the city of Ichnai as far south as
the Thermaic gulf, where they intermingled with other Macedonian regions from the Lower
Macedonia. Thukydides regards even the region of Macedonian capital Bela (lat. Pella)13 as
Paionian. Even today there's many Paionian toponyms and archaeological sites, as well as the
Municipality of Paionia in occupied Macedonian territories in northern Greece.

11
Today city of tip in the eastern part of Republic of Macedonia.
12
Today city of Negotino in the river Vardar valley, Republic of Macedonia.
13
Voicing Assimilation. The /b/ and /p/ are identical in pronunciation (both are bilabial stops), differing
only in their Voice-parameter; /b/ is Voiced, while /p/ is Voiceless (example: describe/description). In
Russian, for example, it's Regressive Assimilation - the Voice parameter of the final consonant in a
cluster becomes the parameter of the whole cluster. So the Russian preposition (v), meaning 'in', is
pronounced /f/ when its object starts with a voiceless consonant (example: vhotele is pronounced
/fhotele/)
8
 Above: Municipality of Paionia in Macedonian part of northern Greece, and
archaeological site Toumba Paionias near Axiochori, in the furthest south of the valley of
river Vardar close to Thermaic Gulf.14
Even Mt. Mesapion was also noted as the place where the Paionians hunted wild bisons.

14
Ole Christian Aslaksen, Global and local in Late Bronze Age Central Macedonia. Economy, mobility
and identity, p.63. Gothenburg University
9
The Macedonian towns in Paionia were developed centers already in the Bronze Age. They already
had a developed infrastructure at the beginning of the Iron Age, and later in the so-called Archaic
period, and during the early empire in Macedonia (Alexander I, 498-454 BCE). Also, it is worth
mentioning the city of Tranupara15, the famous minting center in Upper Macedonia. Even more
figurative and appealing is the name of yet another ancient town, on the road between Ateebo and
Tranupara, which was Zapara, literally 'for-the-money' (i.e 'toward-money', 'on the road to money').
On the west they bordered with their kin Brygians and Almopians, on the north with the Agrianians,
and on the east with Laiai, Doberoi and Maedoi. Different ancient sources and modern scholars
define them as Paionian-Macedonic tribes. Thus at the end of the 6th century we know of
Almopians, Brygians, Paionians, Siropaionians, Paioplai, Doberoi and Agrianes, and Thucydides
adds the Laiai. In the times previous to Persian invasion in the 5th century BCE, at the height of
their power, Paionian kingdoms held large parts of Thrace, whole Migdonia and Krestonia, and
even the territories in Asia Minor.16 According to the Assyrian records this Anatolian district of
Paionian kingdom was inhabited by the people of Mushki17 as from 700 BCE.18 And as we know
from the testimony of Erodot (lat. Herodotus) and from other ancient sources, the origins of the
Phrygian tribe Mushki and king Mydas are to be found among the Macedonic community of
Brygians, the closest neighbors and kin of Paionian Macedonians from northern Pelagonia. These
Brygo-Paionian settlers in Asia Minor even founded cities which resembled the names of the cities
from their ancestral Macedonian homeland: Bela, Ber (lat. Beroeia), Voden (lat. Eddessa), etc. E.
Petrova notes that: "The central Balkan region, especially its south-western section, is the territory
of an Early Bronze Age population from which the Proto-Brygian ethnic community later developed
[] This Proto-Brygian ethnic population who are mentioned in the works of the ancient period,
later spread over the major part of southern and south-eastern Albania, north-western Greece,
Pelagonia and Lower Macedonia." Polish linguist and historian W. Payakovsky utterly confirmed
these relation to the Proto-Brygians through the closeness of Paionian and Phrygian language. This
was also confirmed by the names on the territory of northern Macedonia that are neither Thracian
nor Gaul/Illyrian.

The earliest written memory of Paionia and Paionians is probably the one in Homer's Iliad , the epic
story of Ilion (lat. Troy) War, in which the Paionians with curved bows from Amydon, Paionian
capital in the lower reaches of river Vardar, fought against the Danaans/Achaeans on the side of
king Priam. Homers Paionians controlled a great swath of territory to either side of the Broad
Axios or Bardarios (today river Vardar), much of which they were to lose in the 6th and 5th
centuries due to the Persian invasion under rule of Achaemenid dynasty. Homer also mentions the
Paionian chelniks19 Pirem (lat. Pyraehmes) and Asterop, son of the king Pelagon.

15
Tranupara [exclamative] 'Of the coins' in plain Macedonian, 'minting place'. From Para 'coin', a
basic unit of the Macedonian coinage; 1 Denar = 100 pari, a monetary unit used in Macedonia, BiH,
Bulgaria, Croatia, Montenegro and Serbia, equal to one hundredth of a Dinar. Also a common noun for
'money' in all Macedonic languages: pari/pare [plural].
16
W.A. Heurtley, 'Prehistoric Macedonia: An Archaeological Reconnaissance of Macedonia (West of
Struma) in the Neolithic, Bronze and Early Iron Ages' (Cambridge, 1939), pp. 125,126,128.
17
Mushki manly,vigorous in plain Macedonian. Also endurable or strong: Zapni mushki push
hard.
18
See 'The Funerary Banquet of King Midas' by Patrick E. McGovern.
19
elnik [Tshelnik; noun] - which translates in English as foremost i.e. leader is a very interesting
case. The British historian Hammond mentioned its etymology and said that the word "Tshelniku" in the
ancient Macedonian language had a meaning of "leader of a group". Proof of this is yet another entry, of
the Romeian chronicle-writer Kekavmen, where he described the events surrounding the uprising of Petar
Deljan against Konstantinopolitana Nova Roma (eng. Constantinople) in 11th century. He wrote that in
10
Above: Paionian kingdom in 13-12th century BCE according to Homer

the language of the (Macedonian) rebels "the strategist is called Tchelnik"; from elo [tshelo]
forehead in plain Macedonian; and -nik noun suffix, one connected with or characterized by.
11
Below: Paionian kingdom in 7-6 century BCE

Further, Pelagon name resembles pure Macedonian etymology and it is the ethnonym for
Pelagonian plain in Upper Macedonia, also a homeland of Macedonian Bryges or Brygians. Thus
the Paionians in different ancient sources are also reported as Pelagonians and/or Brygians. This
sources show the intricate network of ancestral Macedonic relations which were very closely related
and often evidenced as one and the same. Appian mentions them too, as "different from Hellenes,"20
Homer, Herodotus and Strabo noted that the Paionian people are the Trojans relatives.

20
Appian Ill. IV.6
12
After 479, weakened by the Persian occupation they gradually re-entered again the sphere of the
larger Macedonian union. One of the Paionian chelniks (chieftains) from that period whose name
arrived to us, Agis, died in 359/358, in the time when the young Filip II of Macedon was asserting
his control over Macedonia. Its noted that before the dead of his brother Perdika (lat. Perdicas)
Filip expanded Macedonian army by recruiting and drilling local peasants into territorial regiments
commanded by royal officers precisely in the Paionian region, where he was assigned as governor.
Symnon who was the ruler in Paionia from 348 to 336 BCE was a great ally of Filip.
During the first half of the fourth century BCE, after the death of the rebel king Agis, Paionia was
once more incorporated in the Macedonian state by Filip II of Macedon. By 349 BCE, as epigraphic
and literary evidence makes it clear, Paionia was one of the several Macedonic kingdoms subject to
the burgeoning Macedonian empire. In 344 Filip swept the region of the upper Black Drim valley
and made war on the Gaul/Illyrian Ardiaioi21, invaders from the upper reaches of the Narenta River,
to reinforce earlier Macedonian possessions. Upper and Lower Macedonia were united again.22
Alexander himself retired somewhere in this region when fleeing from Bela (lat. Pella) with his
mother, after the quarrel he had with his father on Filips last (seventh) marriage to Cleopatra, the
niece of Attalus in 337 BCE. Since Alexander through his father Filip II and possibly through his
mother had relatives in Upper Macedonia, he probably sought refuge with part of his extended
family. Hammond makes the assertion that Paionia was annexed directly within the Macedonian
commonwealth. On that occasion the Macedonian Army was notably strengthened with numerous
and excellent Paionian cavalry. When Alexander III of Macedon launched his campaign on Persia,
the Macedonian Army from Amfipolion (lat. Amfipolis) in Lower Macedonia gathered with
Paionian, Brygian and Agrianian units from Upper Macedonia at Ateebo (lat. Astibus), one of the
ancient holy-cultural Macedonic centers, comparable to Dion and the isle of Samothrace. So, theres
no doubt that the Paionians, together with northern Agrianians, Brygians, Maedoi and Laiai
belonged to the larger group of Macedonic tribes from Upper Macedonia.
Nevertheless, tribes from Upper Macedonia (Agriania, Brygia, Paionia, Pelagonia and Lynkestia), as
closest kin to those from Lower Macedonia, always used to retain a certain measure of
independence, due to their relevance and pride, and also because of the relative weakness of the
Argead dynasty. On their side Argeads were also in many ways dependent on the relations with
Paionian and other Macedonian communities.23 Thukydides defines them "allies and subjects", in an
attempt to describe the hardly definable and constantly changing relations in the broader family of
Macedonic people. As evidence to this claim can be pointed out Filip II mother Evridika (lat.
Eurydice) from Lynkestia.24 The only plausible conclusion from all these ancient testimonies and
sources is that the Paionian tribes and comunities were distinctly Macedonic in their whole. They
also reaffirm this fact by mentioning the typical Macedonic territorial organizing through kome
(small town), which remained the basic unit of local government throughout the Macedonian realm,
on contrary to the Danaan/Achaean city-states from Peloponnesus.

21
Diodorus 16.69.7, Trogus Prologue 8.
22
This was due to the Filips previous position as appointed Chelnik in Upper Macedonia, i.e. Paionia,
during the rule of his father king Aminta and his brother Perdika II. He was noted as ruler of Pelagonia,
Gortinia, and as far as the river Struma (lat. Strymon). He used this mandate in Paionia for training and
equipping his new army that will be the backbone of his future Macedonian empire.
23
Filip II of Macedon mother-queen Evridika (lat. Eurydice) was from Upper Macedonia too (Lynkestia).
24
Historians accuse her of murdering Filip's father, the king Amynta III, as well as Filip's sister and older
brother Alexander II. After escaping back to her native Lynkestia she instigated a rebelion against her
last son, the newly crowned Filip II of Macedon. Knowing how dangerous his mother is, Filip captured
and executed her.
13
 PAIONIAN MACEDONIANS IN THE ARMY OF
MACEDON

As mentioned above, Paionians participated in the Ilion War on the side of Trojans of king Priam
(lat. Priamus). Homer's brief reference also explains this link between the Trojans and
Brygians/Phrygians in the 12th century BCE through the youthful feats of Priam, who aided the
Phrygians (i.e. Paionians) in their battles with the Amazons. In the passage of the Catalogue of the
ships and elsewhere in the Iliad we learn that the Paionians came in help of Ilion from the city of
Amydon, on the banks of river Vardar. The lower basin of the Vardar River in the time of Homer
was part of the Paionian kingdom, with its most important city of Amydon. Thus, from the ancient
sources it can be concluded that at the time of the composition of Iliad, Paionians controlled the
territory which comprised Lower Macedonia, the heartland of the Macedonian Kingdom.
Then we learn from Herodotus that at some time before 510 the Paionians attacked the city of
Perinth on the Marmara Sea. Other authors report their incursions as far as Asia Minor. But this can
easily be a presumption related to the Brygian migration (which in anyway were Paionians closest
neighbors and kin). From this and other sources we also learn that the Paionian Macedonians held
large parts of Thrace as well.

Ancient sources noted that Langar (lat. Langarus; died 335 BCE), king of the Agrianians25, the
most northern habitants of Paionian Macedonia, was a contemporary of Alexander III of

25
Agriani/Agrianes, another Macedonic tribe from Upper Macedonia, closely related to Paionian
Macedonians.
14
Macedon, with whom he ingratiated himself even before the death of Filip II of Macedon. His
realm comprised of today Kosovo Pole, South Morava and Polog valley, Skopje, Kumanovo,
Kriva Palanka26, Sredec (today Sofia) and Pautalia (today Kyustendil). Langar rendered important
services to Alexander during his expedition against the Gaul/Illyrians and Taulantii shortly after
his accession, when the Autariates from northwest (in what is today Sandak and Bosnia) were
preparing to attack by surprise the Macedonians on their march. Langar, following the tradition of
loyalty toward the ancestral Macedonic coalition, invaded their territory, preventing them from
carrying their vicious attack into effect.

Above: The territory of Paionians and Agrianians (rounded in red) northernmost

guardians of the Macedonian realm in the 6-5th century BCE according to dr. Victoria
Sokolovska
The Roman historian Quintus Curtius Rufus in his History of Alexander tells us about the link
between the Macedonians from Paionia in the Macedonian campaign in Persia. The example is one
well documented episode involving one of the Alexanders auxiliary units of Paionian cavalry. The
single Paionian ile27 under the command of a certain Ariston, a noted member of the Macedonian
ruling house from Paionia, was 150-200 strong when they crossed to Asia in 334 BCE. They appear
to have served principally as a light reconnaissance unit, and occupied a position on the Alexanders
right flank at the pitched battles at the Granik (lat. Granicus), Iss (lat. Issus) and Gaugamela, in
close proximity to the Macedonian king and his companions. Following Alexanders crossing of the

26
Latin: Curved Phalanx
27
Ile or ilai [military; Macedonic] - light detachment, reconnaissance company; adjective Maced.,
informal: daring, balky.
15
river Tigris in 331, the disordered Macedonian van was attacked by a one-thousand strong
contingent of Persian cavalry led by (the otherwise unknown) Satropat. Alexander ordered Ariston
and his ile to charge the Persians at full speed, and the latter broke in disarray and fled. The valiant
charge of the Macedonians from the house of Paion was praised highly, particularly the actions of
Ariston who slew the Persian commander personally. Satropat (lat. Satropates) was wounded in the
throat before being unhorsed and decapitated, his head presented by Ariston to Alexander amid
great applause. At that point, the narrative was picked up by Plutarch who maintained that when
Ariston presented the head to Alexander he stated - 'In my homeland, O King, such a gift is
rewarded with a golden cup.' - 'Yes', replied a laughing Alexander, 'an empty one; but I will pledge
your health with one which is full of neat wine.'

Above: Artistic illustration of the member of Macedonian cavalry from Paionia (Upper
Macedonia)

After the general weakening of the Macedonian empire due to Succession Wars Paionia separates
from the rest of Macedonia under the king Avdoleon, son of Patraos. Avdoleon is probably the most
famous Paionian king, partly because of his role in the forging of money, and partly because of the
legend that recounts how he escaped from the ceremony of his coronation (which included the
bathing in the waters of river Bregalnitsa,Vardar tributary). Avdoleon renewed his Paionian
kingdom in Upper Macedonia, and ancient sources mention that in 310 BCE he received military
assistance from his cousins in Lower Macedonia in yet another campaign against northwestern
Gaul/Illyrians. He too was following the tradition of his grandfathers and was loyal to the ancestral
Macedonian union as an ally to Kassander, son of Antipater. Avdoleon managed to expand his
territory by annexation of the Agrianian territory, which became part of his kingdom. The last king
from ancient Macedonic kingdom of Paionia known to historians was Dropion (250-230 BCE), son
of Leon of Paionia. He was noted by Pausanias when he gifted in Delphi a trophy of the famous

16
Paionian bisons, which were still a hunting prey in the Macedonian peninsula in the 3rd century
BCE: "A bronze head of the Paionian bull called the bison was sent to Delphi by the Paionian king
Dropion, son of Leon". After Dropion Paionia was governed by a local royal Macedonian officer
called Didas.
Roman destructive impact on the Adriatic coast in Dalmatia and Matia (or Mat, today northern
Albania) in the third and second centuries BCE triggered the migrations of various tribes, and the
lands of Paionian Macedonians were more frequently ravaged by the wagging barbaric tribes from
north and northwest. During the Second Macedonian War the Gaul/Illyrians and Tribalians
advancing from the northwest, under command of the Gaul/Illyrian chieftain Bato, created major
disruption in Macedonia. On the account of the Romans, with whom he allied, on 199 BCE Bato
backstabbed from north the Macedonians, with whose royal dynasty he was closely related.28

Above: Artistic, rather romanticist, illustration of the Gaul-Illyrian "Hairwrapped" warriors

from the later antiquity. The second from the left on his head wears the classical bronze
"Priest-helmet" (so-called "Etruscan"), an insignia of the chieftains and commonly used
as the ceremonial helmet in the Theocratic rituals and Shamanic traditions known
throughout all the Macedonic-Etruscan-Gaul-Illyrian-Venetic world.
Other famous dynasty from Upper Macedonia, were the Antigons (or Antigonids). The founder of
this dynasty, Antigon I the 'One-Eyed'29 (lat. Antigonus I Monophthalmus), the high rank general in
the army of Filip II of Macedon and later of his son Alexander III of Macedon, was from Elimeia in
Upper Macedonia. In 333 BCE he was appointed governor of Greater Phrygia. As part of the

28
Atenagor (lat. Athenagoras), Macedonian general of Filip V and Persej (lat. Perseus) had a difficult
time against Bato. But later, Batos brother Monunius I helmet was found in Ohrid with an inscription in
New Macedonic uncial koine, and silver coins bearing both the king's and Macedonian symbols that
indicates the Monunius inspirations for Macedonia.
29
His name being a endearname of the city Antigona or viceversa.
17
division of provinces after Alexander's death in 323 BCE, Antigon I
received Pamphylia and Lycia from the appointed regent of the empire, Perdika (lat. Perdiccas), at
the partition in Babylon. His nephew Antigon II Gonat (lat. Antigonus II Gonatus) , after strugling
together with Antioch (lat. Antiochus) in Macedonian Asia Minor, will regain the control of
European Macedonia and reign until his death in 239 BCE. Some sources claim that he's to be the
founder of the city of Antigona (or Antigoneia) on the shores of river Vardar in Paionian
Macedonia. Antigon III Dosson initially defeated the invading Dardanian tribes and regained control
over Macedonias northern border (Justin 28.3.14), but he had to return there immediately after the
Battle of Sellasia in 222 BCE upon word that new wave of Gaul/Illyrians had invaded Macedonia.
Antigon defeated them too, but died soon thereafter in 221 BCE.

Then Filip V of Macedon was also involved in military campaign against the invading Bastarnai
and Dardanians in Upper Macedonia in 220 and again in 217 BCE, when he commanded military
expeditions on the northern borders of Macedonia.30

Yet another recorded episode from Upper Macedonia worth mentioning is the military campaign of
king Perseus in the first half of the 2nd century BCE, during the Third Macedonian War with Rome
(171-168 BCE).31 Romans succeeded in occupying the western Macedonian city of Uscana. In the
winter of 170/169 BCE King Persei responded by moving with his army from Stubera (today
Chepigovo) in Pelagonia toward the region of Penestia in westernmost Upper Macedonia, in order
to put-down the Roman occupation of the city of Uscana. The combined force of 4000 Roman
soldiers and 500 Gaul/Illyrian tribesmen were no mach for the Macedonian Army of 10.000
Falanka (lat. Phalanx) infantry, 2000 light infantry and 500 Macedonian Royal Companions
cavalry. After short and futile resistence Romans negotiated but disarmed retreat, while the
Gaul/Illyrian marauders were captured and sold as slaves. The Macedonian stronghold of Uscana
was restored and city was additionally fortified by Persei.

30
Polybius 5.97.2
31
Titus Lyvius "History of Rome"
18
 PAIONIA UNDER ROMAN OCCUPATION

After the fall of the Macedonian empire in 169 BCE followed a large exodus of the Macedonic and
other communities in front of the Roman terror and plunder. What followed was waste destruction
and calamity for the whole Macedonia. Thus, in the time immediately after the Roman occupation
from ancient sources we have verification of some 100 cities in Macedonia, which number in the
late empire dropped to only 30. Macedonian monarchy was abolished and its enormous riches
transported to Italy. Four separated republics were founded, each forbidden to hold any official
political or even social contact with the others. But the direct Roman administration in Macedonia
was established only as from 148 BCE. And even a new calendar reckoning was introduced then.
The Macedonians became subjects of Rome, and their further history was determined by the
occupying power of Rome. Suffering large depopulation provoked by three centuries of almost
constant wars, followed by Roman occupation, independent Paionian kingdom disappeared from the
history as well. What was not destroyed in the wars was then largely looted, with extraordinary
thoroughness by the Romans.
The strategic importance of Paionia and wider Macedonian region was more than obvious to
Romans. Broadly speaking, this can be seen by the Roman armies which all the time were
positioned on the three cardinal points of the empire: one in the west (grouped on the Rhine
frontier), another in the Balkans, and a third in northern Mesopotamia covering the east.
When Polybius, Livy, Strabo and Pausanias wrote about the Paionian Macedonians, they recount of
a legendary people. And when Ptolemy composed his Geography in the second century AD, he
noted the cities of Paionia.32 Later, under the Roman occupation, Paionia around the river Vardar
formed the second and third districts respectively of the Roman province of Macedonia. In the 2nd
to 1st centuries BCE, the Romans, appropriated, selectively adopted and imitated Macedonian
culture, especially the court art of the Antigonid monarchy. There is scant evidence, however, for
the reverse, that is, for the Romanization of Macedonia at this time. Macedonians by contrast did
not choose to emulate the styles of their Roman antagonists and tyrants. They largely adhered to
traditional forms in depicting their gods, adorning the living and burying the dead. Centuries later,
under Diocletian, Paionia and Pelagonia formed a province called Macedonia Secunda (or
Macedonia Salutaris), as part of the Praetorian prefecture of Illyricum.

32
http://www.pasthorizonspr.com/index.php/archives/01/2011/bylazora-the-last-redoubt-of-the-
paionians
19
 ARCHAEOLOGICAL PAIONIA

The funeral ritual is one of the most important elements of religion, as the language is the most
important element in the definition of ethnicity. The religious artifacts not only testify the
uniqueness of Macedonic beliefs (mostly associated with the cult of the Sun), but also the Paionian
regional economic power, metallurgical knowledge, and extremely high aesthetic criteria. Large
amount of the unearthed findings from the Paionian graves in Macedonia offered valuable
retrospective of ancient Macedonic culture. Already in the early Bronze Age there was a distinctive
Macedonic style in bronzes, ceramics (Paionian gray pottery), Macedonic way of burial and
religion.33 The recent excavations of the Paionian graveyard near Skopje gave the further
confirmation of their Macedonic origin. Among the artifacts from the grave discovered under the
foundations of the ancient theatre in the later Roman acropolis Scupi, beside the other remains a
bronze Sun-disc of Macedonic type was found in a ceramic jar. There is a reference to this symbol
by Maximus of Tyre, a rhetorician from the 2nd century BCE, who stated that Paionians
worshipped the sun in the shape of a small disc attached to a long staff (Other similar artifacts also
confirm their worship toward the sun.

The archaeological excavations of Belazora, Pelagonia, Gorintia, and other ancient cities scattered
around Macedonia are ongoing on annual pace. The archaeologists of Macedonia dedicated the
whole 2014 summer to excavations of what they believe was the ancient capital city of the Brygians
Pelagonia. It's situated around the Visoka peak and Staro Bone. Archaeological finds from this
and other sites show unmistakable Macedonian character of the Paionian and surrounding cultures.
The bronze and ceramic artifacts resemble the typical triple pattern of the ornaments crafting, so
characteristic for all the Macedonic burials and other everyday items in ancient Macedonia.

Above: Some of the Paionian amulets and pendants, known as Macedonic Bronzes, with
classic Macedonian triple-pattern. From the necropolis of the ancient city of Gortinia, near
modern Gevgelia, Republic of Macedonia. 7th century BCE.
Another similar specific feature of the Macedonian burial rituals is the tripod funeral altar34 which
33
See Claude Rolley
34
This ancient trinity principle was preserved through ancient artifacts and Macedonian funerary rituals,
where is repeatedly found on the funeral altars and vessels, regularly positioned on three-legged
supports. In the grave 5 from the archaeological site of Koreshnica (robbed by illegal diggers in1996)
there were also three small bronze statues of warriors/deities situated around a huge bronze krater on a
20
is not found in the tombs of the Minoan and later Peloponnesus cultures, which used a sacrificial
bed, known as "kline" (or Klinai). In addition to these features from the necropolis in Gorenci /
Trebenite, metal containers were found that were unknown to the ancient Peloponnese. These and
other most important features were identified by renowned French expert Claude Rolley, after the
discovery of the necropolis at Sidon. "This proves that we are faced with two different funeral
rituals," concluded Rolley.
The remarkable continuity of the Macedonian ethnos in Paionia is verified by these and other
artifacts which are sufficient to vindicate in principle the legitimacy of such an approach. One of the
most decisive archaeological proofs from Upper Macedonian Paionia is the federal decree found at
the village of Chepigovo, in the ruins of ancient Stibera. It shows that the Macedonian communities
in Paionia were organized along closely related lines with the rest of Macedonia from oldest times
until the end of their principality. Another inscription from Delphi leaves little doubt that the
ancient Macedonian ethnos in Paionia survived not only as a recruitment unit in the case of external
threats, but also as a political organization closely related to the Argead dynasty. The onomastic
study of the names from numerous funerary steles, where we can read the typical Macedonic names
(Aristo, Iole, Mende, Meto, Naumen, Panta, Pero, Phila, Straton, etc.), or the cities and places
(Aineia, Belazora, Ber, Dober, Dikaia, Kalinda, Kos, Garekos, Ole, Stena, Stobi, Skuopoi, etc.)
underline their pure Macedonic essence beyond any doubt. Today, after numerous archaeological
findings from the Macedonic Iron Age communities (when they reached their development peak) in
Paionia, mainly along the rivers Vardar and Bregalnitsa (lat. Astibos), and in Pelagonia, it is
scientifically accepted that they were part of the larger Macedonic family with a unique and easily
recognizable culture, essentially different from the cultures of neighboring Gaul/Illyrians and
Tribalians. Across the whole Paionian territory typical Macedonic style of the cult items made of
bronze (amulets, pendants, figurines, etc.) and ceramic is easily recognizable, and in particular in
female (priestesses) burials from the VII century BCE.
Further, in light of their attributes, the warriors represented on the hoards of coinage may
conceivably be identified as Macedonian. They carry a Macedonian pelte35, wear a traditional
Macedonian hat kausia, and are shown in Macedonian clothing or heroic nudity. The warriors
wearing the kausia are almost always clad in a chiton or naked. Around 335, Patraos succeeded
Lykei as king of the Paionians. Like his predecessor, Patraos struck silver coinage (pari) in his own
name, produced on a local weight standard of c.12.93g. The last known ancient Paionian king
Dropion, in the district or city of Dober (lat. Doberus), minted different coins with both inscriptions
PAIONON and MAKEDONON on the reverse.

Archaeology has also revealed that the Macedonians didn't shared the Late Bronze Age material
culture of the southern Peloponnesian city-states. Immigrants from south, commercial trade and
goods were welcomed, but Macedonians remained a notoriously distinguished nation, speaking a
language unintelligible to the inhabitants of the Peloponnesus. Materially, ancient Macedonians
from Paionia in particular, appear to have been most closely related to the Macedonian
Bryges/Brygians (later Phrygians) who occupied much of the central Macedonian plain (Pelagonia)
and Polog valley long before the advent of Macedonian empire.

tripod. Also, this trinity patern is later found in the Slo-Venetic mythology, where we find the supreme
Trinity/all-in-one god "Svarogo" (abreviation of "Sveg-Roda-Gospod" of-all kin god) , which
consisted of "JAV" (visible material world that surrounds us) , "NAV" (celestial world) , and "PRAV" (the
spiritual world of wisdom and justice), known also as "Triglav" - triple-head; then through the Etruscan
triad of gods - Jupiter, Juno (i.e. Etruscan goddess Uni) and Minerva, this "Trinity" was subsumed by the
Romans, and presented in their Central Supreme Temple the Roman Capitol in the ancient Rome
central hilltop; and at the end this trinity was absorbed by the christianity (as "the Father, the Son and
the Holy Spirit").
35
Pelte Macedonian small round shield. Meaning Button in plain Macedonian.
21
Above: Different Macedonic bronze figurines (from left to right): Bronze Maenad from Tetovo, 6th
century B.C.E.; Dedal unearthed at Plaoshnik, Ohrid, 4/3rd century BCE; and a recently
sequestered from the looters bronze horse figurine of yet unknown period and site.

Below: Macedonian bronze sacramental statuette of Macedonic-Paionian/Phrygian goddess Kibela

(Cybele) on a cart pulled by two lions, 4/3rd century BCE (only small part of the 2nd century BCE
Roman plunder from Macedonia, today in Metropolitan Museum as part of the much recent WW2
American plunder from Italy); Next page: Another, much older, terracotta statuette of the same
goddess from the 6th century BCE, with tambourine (or sun-disc) and flanked by two lions, part of
30 feminine statuettes some of which resilient to the 5th millennium BCE, found recently at the
ancient holy locality of "Tsarevi Kuli " (Kings Towers) near Strumitsa, Republic of Macedonia.

22
23
Kings:
Bastareus, 400-380/78 BCE; known only from his coinage.
Sitalces: included Agrianes and Laeaeans in his Macedonian campaign in 429 BCE.
Agis, ?-359 BCE; founded the Paeonian kingdom; pretender to the Macedonian throne in a time
of instability.
Lycceius, 356-340 BCE; joined anti-Macedonian coalition with Grabos and Thrace in 356 BC.
Patraeus, 340-315 BCE; served as a general to Alexander the Great in 331 BCE.
Audoleon, 315-285 BCE; son of Patraeus, reduced to great straits by the Autariatae, but was
succoured by Cassander.
Ariston, 286-285 BCE son of Audoleon, loyal vassal of Macedonia; commanded a single
squadron of Paionians.
Leon, 278-250 BCE; consolidated and restored lost lands after the Gallic Invasions in 280-279
BCE.
Dropion, son of Leon 250-230 BCE; last known Paeonian king in 230 BC, of a dwindling
kingdom.

Other chieftains:
Pigres and Mantyes: two tyrant brothers which in 511 BCE persuaded Darius I to deport the
coastal Paionians to Asia.
Dokidan: of the Derrones; reigned during the 6th century BCE.
Dokim: of the Derrones; reigned during the 6th century BCE.
Euergetes: of the Derrones; reigned c.480-465 BCE, known only from his coinage.
Teutaos: reigned from c.450-435 BCE; known only from his coinage.
Teutamado: reigned from 378-359 BCE, known only from his coinage.
Symnon: great ally of Phillip II from 348-336 BCE.
Nicharchos: reigned from 335-323 BCE; son of Symnon.
Langarus: of the Agrianes; invaded the territory of the Autariatae in 335 BCE in coalition with
Alexander the Great.
Dyplaios: of the Agrianes; reigend around 330 BCE.
Didas: allied Philip V of Macedon with 4,000 warriors from 215-197 BCE.

Persian rulers:
Darius I: subjugated coastal Paionia in 511-512 BCE.
Xerxes: included Paeonians in vast Persian army of 481 BCE, for the Invasion of Greece.
24
25
References
1. Edward Holdsworth, "Remarks and Dissertations on Virgil, with some other Classical
Observations". Published, with several notes and additional remarks, by Mr. Spence, London,
1768.
2. Charles Rollin, "The Ancient History of the Egyptians, Carthaginians, Assyrians, Babylonians,
Medes, Persians, Macedonians, and Grecians". 1819.
3. Philip van Ness Myers, "Ancient History", 1888.
4. C.F. Hoffmann, "Die Makedonen, ihre Sprache und ihr Volkstum". Gottingen, 1906.
5. W.A. Heurtley, "Prehistoric Macedonia: An Archaeological Reconnaissance of Macedonia
(West of Struma) in the Neolithic, Bronze and Early Iron Ages", Cambridge, 1939.
6. J. K. Ellis, "Philip II and Macedonian Imperialism". 1986.
7. O. Picard, "Deux emissions de bronzes dAmphipolis", 1994.
8. M. B. Hatzopoulos "Macedonian institutions under the kings", a historical and epigraphic
study, 1996.
9. Eleonora Petrova, Paeonia in the 2nd and the 1st millennia BC, 1999.
10. Eleonora Petrova, "The Bryges in Central Balkans 2nd-1st millennium BCE", Museum of
Macedonia.
11. Ricard Bianco Lpez, "El poble Peoni: parent dels troians", 2001.
12. Anatoly Klyosov, "Otkud su se pojavili Sloveni i Indoevropljani? Odgovor daje DNK-
Genealogija." Ruski Vesnik No. 21, 2008.
13. Eftimija Pavlovska, "A coin hoard of the Paionian king Lycceius".
14. Eftimija Pavlovska, "The coinage of the Paionian kings Leon and Dropion", 2009.
15. Southeastern Europe Joint History, Workbook 2: Nations and States in Southeast Europe
CENTER FOR DEMOCRACY AND RECONCILIATION IN SOUTHEAST EUROPE, 2009.
16. Kenneth W. Harl, "Alexander the Great and the Macedonian Empire", 2010.
17. Nicholas L. Wright, "The Horseman and the Warrior: Paionia and Macedonia in the Fourth
Century BCE".
18. Petar H. Ilievski, "POSITION OF THE ANCIENT MACEDONIAN LANGUAGE AND THE
NAME OF THE CONTEMPORARY MAKEDONSKI"
19. Patrick E. McGovern, "The Funerary Banquet of King Midas".
20. Sneana FILIPOVA "Early Christian Kultural Centers in Republic of Macedonia along the Via
Egnatia."

26
27