Solid Conveying in Vane Extruder For Polymer Processing: Effects On Pressure Establishment
Solid Conveying in Vane Extruder For Polymer Processing: Effects On Pressure Establishment
Solid Conveying in Vane Extruder For Polymer Processing: Effects On Pressure Establishment
Jin-Ping Qu,1,2 Gui-Zhen Zhang,1,2 Hui-Zhuo Chen,1,2 Xiao-Chun Yin,1,2 He-Zhi He1,2
1
The National Engineering Research Center of Novel Equipment for Polymer Processing, South China
University of Technology, Guangzhou 510640, Guangdong, China
2
The Key Laboratory of Polymer Processing Engineering of Ministry of Education, South China University of
Technology, Guangzhou 510640, Guangdong, China
The pressure establishment in the solid conveying sec- based on shear ow where the solid materials are trans-
tion of a vane extruder was theoretically and experi- ported by frictional drag, which is dependent on the mate-
mentally studied in the present article. Based on the rial properties and on the friction between the materials
structural and conveying characteristics of the vane
extruder, a four-plate model was developed. The
and the parts, such as the screw and the barrel [1]. In
effects of the device geometry (eccentricity e and dis- addition, a long thermo-mechanical history is needed for
charge port b), the polymer properties (different materi- solid conveying completion based on frictional drag,
als), and the operating conditions (temperature and which entails high energy consumption. To overcome
rotating speed) on the pressure were also studied these disadvantages, Qu [2] designed a novel nonscrew
using a visual experimental device. The results showed equipment known as vane extruder for polymer process-
that the experimental data were highly consistent with
the theoretical data, which indicated that the theoreti-
ing, which was composed of a number of vane plasticat-
cal model was sensible. Considering the optimization ing and conveying units (VPCUs). A positive displace-
design of the device and its processing parameters, ment-type ow dominates the solid conveying mechanism
the eccentricity e and the discharge port b of the dis- of the vane extruder, and the solids are not only
charge bafe should be appropriately selected, and the compacted but also transported irrespective of the
setting temperature of the feeding section should be material properties, which can remarkably shorten
set to a low value. The rotating speed of the rotor had
no signicant inuence on the pressure establishment.
the thermo-mechanical history and improve suitability of
In addition, the thermo-mechanical history of the vane the materials [3].
extruder was shorter than that of the conventional In the solid conveying section, the solids are com-
screw extruder. POLYM. ENG. SCI., 00:000000, 2012. pacted and transported from bulk materials to a solid plug
2012 Society of Plastics Engineers to attain a certain solid conveying ratio, and the pressure
is simultaneously established. The pressure establishment
in the solid conveying section is benecial for proper
INTRODUCTION compaction of the solid plug, which can improve heat
transfer efciency and reduce solid conveying uctuation.
Most polymer processing instruments are based on
In the vane extruder, the bulk solids undergo forced com-
screws, such as screw extruder, screw injection molding
paction. However, on the analysis of the compaction and
machine, and so on. In general, screw-based plasticating
the pressure establishment process is very difcult. In par-
and conveying extruder can be divided into three func-
ticular, the particulate solid properties vary greatly during
tional zones: solid conveying, melting, and metering sec-
consolidation, and the variation is difcult to be described
tions. However, the screw solid conveying mechanism is
quantitatively and qualitatively. Moreover, the stress elds
can be obtained only in the limiting case of steady ow
Correspondence to: Jin-Ping Qu; e-mail: [email protected] or in a state of incipient ow when friction is fully mobi-
Contract grant sponsor: National Nature Science Foundation of China;
lized [1]. Considering these difculties, many researchers
contract grant numbers: 10872071, 50973035, 50903033.
Contract grant sponsor: Fundamental Research Funds for the Central have carried out encouraging experiments. Aimed at stress
Universities; contract grant number: NO.2011ZM0063. eld research, Long [4] presented the characteristic of the
Contract grant sponsor: National Key Technology R&D Program of ratio of axial to radial stresses in solid compaction.
China; contract grant numbers: 2009BAI84B05, 2009BAI84B06.
Schneider [5] completed the rst attempt to account for
DOI 10.1002/pen.23176
Published online in Wiley Online Library (wileyonlinelibrary.com). the nonisotropic nature of stress distribution in solid con-
V
C 2012 Society of Plastics Engineers veying mechanism; for polyethylene (PE), for example, a
FIG. 2. Solid compaction process with the rotor rotating in the rst VPCU.
FIG. 4. Force analysis on the materials between the vanes. FIG. 6. Schematic diagram of the visual experimental device.
(9)
where l is the length of the vanes. P0 z
Fn is the component force of the pressure at the inner
surface of the stator to the microunit in the y-direction. According to the research results of Hyun and Spalding
[15], the relationship between the bulk density of the solid
Fn Fz K Px l dx (4) material and the pressure is
lnrm ra lnrm r
Fw is the friction force at the inner surface of the stator to P (10)
C0
the microunit in the x-direction.
C0 b0 b1 T b2 T 2 b3 =Tg T (11)
Fw K fw Px l dx (5)
According to the geometric relations, z is where P is the pressure acting on the solid materials, rm
is the maximum bulk density at innitely high pressure
fd d p which is assumed as the solid-phase density of the mate-
z L f (6)
2 2 2
Fx Fx dFx Fw 0 (7)
The conditions
The factors T (8C) e (mm) b (8) Materials n (rpm) The variables
Thus
4ra a ra rm p
f> (20)
4rm
Similarly,
edl
Vf 4f p (16)
8
ma 4a p
rf r (17)
Vf 4f p a
Materials
The experiments used a low-density polyethylene
(LDPE) with qm 920 kg m23, qa 520 kg m23, and Tg
2138C, provided by China Petroleum & Chemical Cor-
poration, and a general purpose polystyrene (GPPS) with
qm 1040 kg m23, qa 530 kg m23 and Tg 1008C,
supplied by Hongkong Petroleum & Chemical Corporation.
Experimental Devices
A visual experimental device was designed to study
the solid conveying and compaction mechanism of the
FIG. 12. Effects of the properties of the materials (LDPE and PS) on vane extruder, as shown in Fig. 6. The equipment consists
pressure as a function of angle w at 1608C. of the driving and the compaction systems. When the
rotor is rotating, the torque sensor can measure the total
Tg). Two pressure distributions are presented in the angle torque of the rotor. The compaction system is composed
/ and in the distance x (x0 is the dimensionless distance of one group of VPCUs, and the eccentricity e between
characterized by the rotor diameter d), as shown in Fig. 5. the rotor and the stator can be adjusted from 0 to 3 mm.
The pressure on the solid materials increases sharply with To observe the compaction process, the VPCU bafe is
the reduction of /. When / reduces to 1 rad, the pressure made of quartz glass, and the discharge port is along the
is close to its limiting value, i.e., the density of the mate- circumferential direction of the rotor. Photographs of the
rials approaches to that of the solid particle. Simultane- compaction system were taken from the B direction, as
ously, the pressure increases slowly with the rising of x0 . shown in Fig. 7. The experimental phenomena can be
When the pressure is established, it exerts a torque to observed through the visualization window. In this
the rotor. M0 is the torque of P0 to the latter vane, and equipment, there are four stators with different angles of
ML is the torque of PL to the front one. The pressure is discharge port b (25, 30, 35, and 408), which can be
assumed to act on the center of the cantilever part of the accordingly installed to study the effects of different dis-
vanes. According to the torque calculation formula and charge ports on the pressure establishment. The length
ignoring the frictional torque, the relationships between of vane l is 35 mm, and the diameter of the rotor d in
the torque and the pressure are the device is 40 mm.
1
M0 dH1 H1 lPo (22)
2 Experimental Programs
1 As the motions of the four cavities were the same, one
ML dH2 H2 lPL (23)
2 cavity lled with materials was chosen to carry out the
experiments. Many factors affected the pressure establish-
The total torque on the rotor is ment, including the geometry of the device (eccentricity e
and discharge port b), the polymer properties (different
M M0 ML (24) materials) and the operating conditions (temperature and
rotating speed). In each experiment, one variable was var-
In the theoretical model, the pressure distribution of ied under the same conditions. The experimental pro-
the angle / is seen to be much larger than that of the grams with ve variables (eccentricity, discharge port, dif-
dimensionless distance x0 . Therefore, the pressure distribu- ferent materials, temperature, and rotating speed) were
tion in distance x can be ignored, and P0 can be consid- shown in Table 1. In Experiment no. 1, the variable was
ered as the average pressure of the materials at angle /. eccentricity, which changed from 1 to 3 mm. In Experi-
ment no. 2, the variable was the discharge port, which
2M varied from 258 to 408. In Experiment no. 3, the variable
PP0 (25)
p e
el d 4ae was the different materials, which were LDPE and GPPS.
In Experiment no. 4, the variable was the temperature,
According to Eq. 25, the pressure can be derived from which varied from 100 to 1808C, and in Experiment no.
the total torque M of the rotor. Therefore, the pressure 5, the variable was the rotating speed, which varied from
establishment in the rst VPCU can be studied by meas- 1 to 50 rpm. At the start of each experiment, lling the
uring the total torque M of the rotor. cavity full of materials up to the maximum volume was
necessary. Then, the experiments were started, and the In fact, the solid particle movement is merely a spatial
total torque of the rotor was recorded. Finally, according rearrangement of the materials, leading to the slow rising
to Eq. 25, the pressure was obtained as a function of the of the pressure. During the prepressure period, a relatively
angle w, dened as w 3/4p 2 /. dense material system is established, and few voids exist
between the polymer particles. In the compaction period,
the elastic deformation of the materials rst occurs near
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION the point of high stress, leading to the sharp rising of the
pressure. Upon further compression, plastic deformation
of the solid particles takes place, and some particles are
Theoretical and Experimental Pressure
even ruptured. At this condition, the pressure also
The comparison of the theoretically calculated pressure increases, although not sharply. Finally, the solid materi-
and the experimental pressure of the LDPE materials at a als are completely compacted. In other words, the pre-
temperature of 1008C is shown in Fig. 8. In the theoreti- pressure period is the no-deformation stage, and the com-
cal data, the parameters are as followings: C0 7.4 3 paction period is the elastic and plastic-deformation stage.
1028/Pa [17], K 0.4, fw 0.2, e 3 mm, d 40 mm, The results show that the theoretical model is rational and
l 35 mm, and a 3/4p rad. agrees with the experimental results. The comparison
It shows that the theoretical and experimental pressures between the theoretical and experimental results demon-
have the same trends, and the two curves are relatively strates that the vane extruder can establish high pressure
matched, especially with small angle w. According to this in short distance along the axial direction of the rotor (35
trend, the solid compaction process is divided into pre- mm of the experimental device). It can greatly reduce the
pressure period (w \ 0.17 rad) and compaction period (w solid conveying section in the vane extruder and shorten
[ 0.17 rad). In the prepressure period, the pressure is low the thermo-mechanical history compared with the conven-
and increases slowly. But in the compaction period, the tional screw extruder.
pressure is high and increases drastically. The changes in
the pressure in the two periods are related to the variation
Geometry of the Device
of the solid materials when the rotor is rotating. In the
prepressure period, the solid materials are loosely stacked The rotor eccentricity to the inner stator is one of the
in the cavity, and many voids exist between the materials. innovative designs in the vane extruder, as it allows the
According to the theoretical analysis, under the same Equations 11 and 28 yield bo 0.43 MPa21, b1
condition, the pressure decreases when k increases. How- 8.45 3 1023 (MPa21 8C21), b2 4.6 3 1025 (MPa21
ever, this result is contradictory to the experimental 8C22), and b3 0 (8C/MPa) in the vane extruder.
results, which could probably be due to the various mate- In Experiment no. 5, the effects of the rotating speed
rial properties that can affect the solid compaction pro- on the pressure establishment were studied. The results
cess, such as glass transition temperature Tg, melting are shown in Fig. 16. At low rotating speed (1 rpm), the
point Tm, and so on. Hyun and Spalding [15] suggested pressure is established at smaller rotating angle w of 0.2
that semicrystalline polymers with low Tg, such as PE, rad, whereas in high rotating speeds (20, 30, 40, and 50
can be easily compacted. Under the same experimental rpm), it is established in larger rotating angle of 0.35 rad.
conditions, Tg of the GPPS material is higher than that of At low rotating speeds (1 and 10 rpm), the peak value of
LDPE, therefore, the GPPS pressure is higher than that of the pressure increases with the rising of the rotating
LDPE. speed, but at higher speeds (30, 40, and 50 rpm), the peak
value remains invariant at 25 MPa. In addition, high
rotating speed can establish higher pressure than low
Operating Conditions
rotating speed because at low speed, the materials experi-
The changes of the LDPE materials at 1008C are shown ence long residence and heating course so that a low pres-
in Fig. 13. The square cavity near the condition of the maxi- sure is established. The results indicate that the rotating
mum volume is completely lled with LDPE materials in speed has no signicant inuence on pressure establish-
Fig. 13a. When the rotor is rotating, the volume becomes ment in high rotating speed in the actual process.
smaller, and the cloudiness of the materials is observed to
become transparent, as shown in Fig. 13b. Figure 13c
CONCLUSIONS
shows that when the volume further decreases, the materi-
als are completely transparent. Then, the materials are dis- The pressure establishment in the solid conveying section
charged, as shown in Fig. 13d. Interestingly, the discharged of the vane extruder has been analyzed using a convergent
materials are not signicantly different from the feeding wedge slot model. The analytical solution of the four-plate
materials. In general, the melting point Tm of LDPE is model was obtained according to some assumptions. The
approximately at 1101378C, and the materials do not vane extruder has been shown to establish a high pressure
become transparent at 1008C. This condition may be due to in the rst VPCU when the rotor rotates a cycle. The
the failure of the crystals in the materials under high pres- theoretical results show that the pressure establishment is
sure. However, the failure of crystals is reversible accord- related to the geometry, the operating conditions and the
ing to the phenomenon that no signicant difference exists polymer properties. Two pressure distributions exist for
between the discharge and feeding materials. angle / and the dimensionless distance x0 , showing that
In Experiment no. 4, the effects of temperature on the pressure increases sharply with the reduction of /
pressure establishment were studied. The results are and increases slowly with the rising of x0 .
showed in Fig. 14. In the initial period of 00.17 rad, the Experimental and theoretical research demonstrates that
effects of temperature on the pressure are not obvious, a higher pressure and shorter thermo-mechanical history
and the pressure is low, which corresponds to the prepres- are achieved due to the positive displacement-type convey-
sure period. In the second period of 0.170.34 rad, the ing characteristics of the vane extruder compared with the
pressure increases rapidly, and a peak value exists. The traditional screw extruder. The geometry of this device (ec-