SCF182 Simplifying Small Cell Installation
SCF182 Simplifying Small Cell Installation
RELEASE 9 .0 scf.io
DOCUMENT
182.09.01
Simplifying small cell installation:
Harmonized principles for RF compliance
February 2017
www.scf.io/ www.smallcellforum.org
SMALL CELL FORUM
RELEASE 9 .0 scf.io
We are not a standards organization but partner with organizations that inform
and determine standards development. We are a carrier-led organization. This
means our operator members establish requirements that drive the activities
and outputs of our technical groups.
Today our members are driving solutions that include small cell/Wi-Fi
integration, SON evolution and automation, virtualization of the small cell layer,
driving mass adoption via multi-operator neutral host, ensuring a common
approach to service APIs to drive commercialization and the integration of
small cells into 5G standards evolution.
The Small Cell Forum Release Program has now established business cases
and market drivers for all the main use cases, clarifying market needs and
addressing barriers to deployment for residential, enterprise, rural & remote,
and urban small cells.
The Small Cell Forum Release Program website can be found here: www.scf.io
All content in this document including links and references are for informational
purposes only and is provided as is with no warranties whatsoever including
any warranty of merchantability, fitness for any particular purpose, or any
warranty otherwise arising out of any proposal, specification, or sample.
If you would like more information about Small Cell Forum or would
like to be included on our mailing list, please contact:
Email [email protected]
RELEASE 9 .0 scf.io
The proposed installation classes are applicable for general public exposure limits
based on the 1998 guidelines of the International Commission for Non-Ionizing
Radiation Protection (ICNIRP) [2].
Currently, different types of rules are used in different nations and states which makes
it difficult for the telecoms industry to develop low-cost repeatable deployment
processes. In some regions, rules are based on high power macro sites which are
overly complex for low power small cells. In this paper, we recommend adoption of a
harmonized set of installation rules for RF compliance, with simplifications for lower
power sites. We support development of the IEC 62232 Ed.2.0 installation classes,
which define simple installation requirements based on the equivalent isotropic
radiated power (EIRP) of all equipment at the site, as shown in Figure A.
Figure A Installation classes simplify deployment rules needed for RF compliance of small
cell sites
The lowest power devices can be installed with the minimum of design constraints.
Touch compliant equipment such as residential small cells can be sited anywhere,
much like wireless access points. For higher power sites, manufacturers guidelines,
minimum height requirements (Hm) and exclusion zones (Dm) must be considered.
Site design parameters Dm and Hm should be provided in the products technical
documentation.
The SCF and the GSMA support development of the installation classes specified by
the IEC 62232 Ed.2.0 standard that are applicable to exposure limits based on
international guidelines (ICNIRP). Adoption of these harmonized and simplified rules
by regulators and policy makers will reduce administrative overheads for both
planning authorities and mobile operators. Regions using the IEC installation classes
will benefit from expedited small cell deployment and the social and economic benefits
of enhanced mobile broadband for all.
Table 21 Simplified installation requirements for base stations (from IEC 62232
Ed.2.0) .......................................................................................... 4
Table 31 Range of transmit power classes for 4G base stations (from 3GPP
36.104 and 25.104). ....................................................................... 6
Table 32 Typical mapping of installation classes for typical small cell
deployments. ................................................................................. 7
Table 41 Example of parameters for an E0 installation class. ............................. 8
Table 42 Example of parameters for an E2 installation class .............................. 9
Table 43 Example of parameters for an E10 installation class. ..........................10
Table 44 Example of parameters for an E100 installation class. ........................11
Table 45 Example of parameters for an E+ installation class. ...........................13
Figures
Small cells are low-power wireless access points that can be deployed in close vicinity
to where people live or work. At this stage, national and international regulations use
a broad range of criteria to address the RF compliance of low power equipment
installations. This has meant that there is no harmonized approach, which complicates
the deployment process for small cells and the rollout of new services.
Criteria for simplified installation processes are addressed in different ways through
current regulations. Mostly they use equivalent isotropic radiated power (EIRP)1 as
the key criteria as well as installation height but the parameters vary greatly between,
and sometimes within, countries. For example, the EIRP threshold above which a full
site assessment is required typically ranges from 2 W to 10 W but in one country it is
164 W where certain antenna height and separation distances are met. In addition,
different criteria may be applied for indoor versus outdoor installations operating at
the same EIRP. The technical rationale for the chosen parameters is often not
available. There has been no consistent approach between countries, which
complicates the task of network deployment and putting into service of new antenna
installations.
1
The definition of EIRP used in this report is equivalent isotropic radiated power, which is derived from
IEC 62232 Ed.2.0. Other terms, such as equivalent isotropically radiated power or effective isotropically
radiated power may be found in other documents and have the same meaning.
IEC 62232 is the main international standard for RF exposure assessment of base
stations. Over the last three years, IEC 62232 has been undergoing a complete
refresh in order to clarify the evaluation processes to be used for product compliance
evaluation, product installation compliance evaluation and in-situ measurement of
radio base station equipment.
IEC 62232 Ed.2.0 clarifies the simplified rules that can be used for the assessment of
product compliance and product installation compliance. The main revisions include:
Through parallel voting with CENELEC, IEC 62232 Ed.2.0 is expected to be adopted in
2017 as the main technical standard for the implementation of the European Union
(EU) Radio Equipment Directive (RED) 2014/53/EU [5] for base stations. Therefore, it
defines the basic principles to be used in the EU for regulatory compliance assessment
and provides a framework for the development of the general authorization regime
applicable to low power small-area wireless access points in the context of the
proposed European Electronic Communication Code.
Once the base station compliance boundaries have been defined by the entity placing
the equipment on the market, there is a need to ensure that RF exposure is below the
applicable limits when the equipment is installed in its operational environment, taking
into account ambient RF sources where relevant.
As represented in Figure 21, the objective of the installation classes defined in IEC
62232 Ed.2.0 is to provide simplified compliance criteria to be used for the evaluation
of small cells and other base station installations without a requirement to perform
field evaluation based on measurements or calculations.
Product
No installation Yes
criteria satisfied
?
Select an evaluation method
Uncertainty analysis
The general evaluation methods specified in IEC 62232 Ed.2.0 can always be used to
show compliance with the RF exposure limits if necessary.
While complying with the installation class criteria, the site operator must also ensure
that the installation complies with all other requirements related to the technology
used as defined by the 3GPP and other relevant bodies.
The installation classes are based on the available characteristics of the base station
installation, such as the EIRP, the direction of the main lobe of the antenna,
compliance boundary (Dm) and installation positions of the antennas with respect to
any accessible areas to the product (e.g. installation height, Hm) and other relevant
sources where applicable. Transmitted power, typical antenna gain and compliance
boundary dimensions should generally be available in the technical documentation.
When the product installation fulfils the installation class criteria defined in
IEC 62232 Ed.2.0 and reproduced in Table 21, RF exposure is deemed to comply with
ICNIRP limits for the general public [2]. These criteria have been derived from RF
evaluations of generic configurations. The detailed rationale is provided in Annex C of
IEC 62232 Ed.2.0.
E0 n/a n/a The product complies with IEC 62479 or the product
compliance boundary dimensions are zero. No specific
requirement for product installation.
Table 21 Simplified installation requirements for base stations (from IEC 62232 Ed.2.0)
a. Equivalent isotropic radiated power (EIRP) transmitted by the installed antenna(s) including all active
bands.
b. Dm is the compliance distance in the main lobe of the antenna (from Clause 6.1 of IEC 62232).
c. When such condition is not fulfilled the installation is still compliant if the sum of the EIRPs of the
product and nearby sources is less than 100 W. If the total EIRP is above 100 W then the product is still
compliant if it is installed at a minimum height of Hm meters above the general public walkway and at a
minimum distance from areas accessible to the general public in the main lobe direction of Dm meters,
where Hm and Dm are obtained using Equations (6.1), (6.2) or (6.3) of IEC62232 for the sum of the
EIRPs including those of nearby sources.
d. When such condition is not fulfilled the installation is still exempted from evaluations if the product is
installed at a minimum height of Hm meters above the general public walkway and at a minimum
distance from areas accessible to the general public in the main lobe direction of Dm meters, where Hm
and Dm are obtained using Equations (6.1), (6.2) or (6.3) of IEC 62232 for the sum of the EIRPs
including those of nearby sources.
Figure 22 shows that the lowest power devices can be installed with the minimum of
design constraints. Touch compliant equipment such as residential small cells can be
sited anywhere, much like wireless access points. For higher power sites,
manufacturers guidelines, minimum height requirements (Hm) and exclusion zones
(Dm) must be considered. Site design parameters Dm and Hm should be provided in
the products technical documentation.
3GPP BS classes do not map directly onto the installation classes because BS classes
are based on transmitter output into the antenna, whilst IEC installation classes are
mainly based on equivalent isotropic radiated power (EIRP), which additionally factors
in the antennas gain. Furthermore, the BS class ratings are per carrier, per antenna,
whilst installation classes are based on total power transmitted across all bands and
antennas from a given site.
Table 32 provides typical examples of small cell product configurations to show how
BS classes fit into the installation classes. We note that different configurations of the
same 3GPP BS class may correspond to a different installation class. We assume here
that no other pre-existing RF sources are within the specified distance of these small
cells.
Table 32 Typical mapping of installation classes for typical small cell deployments.
The GSMA has been contributing to the harmonization of ITU Recommendations with
international standards, in particular IEC 62232 and ITU K.100. The GSMA recognises
that small cell deployments are an important option for mobile networks as they
evolve to address the growing demand for mobile connectivity, improved capacity and
coverage. In a brochure titled Improving wireless connectivity through small cell
deployment [9], the GSMA has identified seven key policy recommendations to
enable small cell deployments:
Evolving the regulatory framework to support the deployment of small cells will mean
that industry and governments can deliver on the digital connectivity expectations of
citizens and paves the way to 5G.
The network operator provides an installation guide together with the equipment. The
installation guide includes general product safety guidelines. An example of installation
is provided in Figure 41.
A typical E2 scenario is consisting of a network operator (or any entity responsible for
putting into service) that is intending to deploy multiband LTE local area base stations
in indoor premises. The entity responsible for placing the small cell on the market
(e.g. small cell vendor) has provided the information included in Table 42 in the
technical documentation of the product.
The entity responsible for putting the equipment into service can deploy the
equipment without detailed RF evaluations provided that the installation is performed
in such a way that the general public cannot directly access within 1 cm of the
equipment antenna. An example of such installation is provided in Figure 42.
Upon request by the authorizing body, the entity responsible for putting the
equipment into service should be able to provide a technical file including the relevant
information about this product (derived from Table 42).
A typical E10 scenario is consisting of a network operator (or any entity responsible
for putting into service) that is intending to deploy a group of a multiband LTE local
area base station integrated in urban furniture advertisement panels in a large urban
area.
The entity responsible for putting the equipment into service ensures that the product
is integrated in the urban furniture in such a way that the antenna installation height
is 2.2 meters from ground level. The final installation design criteria are displayed in
Figure 43.
Urban
furniture
Antenna
Antenna
installation
height
2.2 m
The entity responsible for putting the equipment into service would be able to put all
similar equipment into service without field calculations or measurements. Upon
A typical E100 scenario is consisting of a network operator (or any entity responsible
for putting into service) that is intending to deploy a group of LTE medium range base
station integrated on a mast used for urban furniture (e.g. lamp post, traffic light...) in
a large urban area. The entity responsible for placing the small cell on the market
(e.g. small cell vendor) provides the information included in Table 44.
The entity responsible for putting the equipment into service ensures that the product
is integrated in the urban furniture in such a way that:
the antenna installation height is more than 2.5 meters from ground level
the general public cannot access the area within 50 cm in the main lobe of
the antenna
there is no pre-existing transmitter with an EIRP of 10 W or above within 2.5
meters from the small cell antenna.
The final installation design criteria for RF compliance are displayed in Figure 44. The
operator also ensures that the installation complies with all other requirements related
to the technology used as defined by the 3GPP.
No public
1m
access (0.5 m)
2.5 m
No preexisting RF source
within in this volume:
Radius: 2.5 m
Height: +/- 0.5 m Antenna
installation
height
> 2.5 m
Mast
The entity responsible for putting the equipment into service would be able to put all
similar equipment into service without field calculations or measurements. Upon
request, this entity would be able to provide a technical file including the relevant
information about the product (from Table 44) and the installation layout design
provide in Figure 44.
A typical E+ scenario is consisting of a network operator (or any entity responsible for
putting into service) that is intending to deploy a group of LTE medium range base
station integrated on a mast used for urban furniture (e.g. lamp post, traffic light...) in
a large urban area. The entity responsible for placing the small cell on the market
(e.g. small cell vendor) provides the information included in Table 45, based on IEC
62232 Ed.2.0 requirements.
The entity responsible for putting the equipment into service ensures that the product
is integrated in the urban furniture in such a way that:
the antenna installation height is more than 3.7 meters from ground level
the general public cannot access the area within 1.2 m in the main lobe of
the antenna
there is no pre-existing transmitter with an EIRP of 100 W or above within 6
meters from the small cell antenna.
The final installation design criteria for RF compliance are displayed in Figure 45. The
operator also ensures that the installation complies with all other requirements related
to the technology used as defined by the 3GPP.
Antenna
No public
2.4 m
access (1.2 m)
6m
No preexisting RF source
within in this volume:
Radius: 6 m
Height: +/- 1.2 m Antenna
installation
height
> 3.7 m
Mast
The entity responsible for putting the equipment into service would be able to put all
similar equipment into service without field calculations or measurements. Upon
request, this entity would be able to provide a technical file including the relevant
information about the product (from Table 45) and the installation layout design
provide in Figure 45.
SCF and GSMA support development of the installation classes specified by the
IEC 62232 Ed.2.0 standard [1] that are applicable to exposure limits based on ICNIRP
Guidelines [2]. Adoption of these harmonized and simplified rules by regulators and
policy makers will reduce administrative overheads for both planning authorities and
mobile operators. Regions using the IEC installation classes will benefit from expedited
small cell deployment and the social and economic benefits of enhanced mobile
broadband for all.
Mobile network operators (or any third party deploying small cells) will benefit from
applying similar rules from one country to another when installing high volumes of
equipment. This translates into lower uncertainty about local installation conditions
and faster deployment of more accessible networks to respond to their broadband
connectivity obligations and help in achieving the broadband targets at regional and
national level.
A complete small cell licensing framework would also consider simplified procedures
for matters such as building permits, notification requirements, administrative fees
and access to power and data back haul. Recommendations for regulatory authorities
are provided in the publication SCF190 Small cell siting: regulatory and deployment
considerations [8] and in the GSMA publication Improving wireless connectivity
through small cell deployment [9].