Rotary Seal Guide
Rotary Seal Guide
Rotary Seal Guide
Brought to you by
Question? 800.822.4063
History................................................................................................................................................................................7
Why PTFE....................................................................................................................................................................... 10
Shaft Considerations.................................................................................................................................................. 26
3
Question? 800.822.4063 Question? 800.822.4063
4 5
Question? 800.822.4063
PTFE History
The discovery of PTFE (polytetrafluoroethylene) resin dates back to 1938, but it was not until
the 1950s that PTFE gained considerable attention as a possible material for rotary lip seals.
Unfortunately, during the 1950s and 1960s PTFE seals proved to be inconsistent and unreliable
performers in many applications. In more recent decades, however, there has been significant
progress made in the areas of PTFE lip seal design and material processing.
The following is aimed at providing the application engineer with a better understanding of PTFE
as a material, some insight into the seal design and manufacturing practices, and a background on
applications where PTFE has proved to be an excellent radial lip seal compound.
The successful application of PTFE radial lip seals is dependent upon a thorough understanding of the
basic properties and functional characteristics of PTFE resins, and in turn applying these criteria to the
areas of product design and manufacturing methods.
The PTFE lip seal provides to the end user; a sealing device that is compatible with virtually all fluids
and additives, functional throughout a broad temperature range, and a low wear-rate enabling it to
exceed todays required warranty periods.
7
Question? 800.822.4063 Question? 800.822.4063
Why PTFE?
Temperature Range for Typical Sealing Materials Before Breakdown
600 40
Extreme temperature Used at greater extremes
M
PM
RPM
M
0 RPM
30,000 RP
- Shaft OD, RPM, etc.
RP
RP
RP
->270C (520F)
00 R
00
00
00
00
M
400
PM
M
RP
6,0
->270C (-450F)
15,00
7,0
8,6
RP
9,0
35
10,0
0R
M
0
0 Covers the same
00
50
RP
50
3,
4,
4,
00
200 Acids operating ranges as nitrile,
5,0
Degrees Farenheit
30 PM polyacrylate, and FKM...
00R
Chemicals PTFE 3,0 combined
0
PTFE FKM HBNR EPDM NITRILE FKM
Figure: 1 NITRILE
5 500 RPM
0
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 110 120 130 140 150 160 170 180 190 200
Shaft Diameter (mm)
Figure: 2
10 11
Question? 800.822.4063 Question? 800.822.4063
-The high thermal expansion rate and compressive Creep characteristics of PTFE resins tend to
upset the desired contact pattern area of a seal when it is exposed to heat and/or load conditions.
-PTFEs high flexural modulus results in a stiff sealing element when compared to present-day
elastomer elements, and therefore PTFEs ability to follow eccentric shaft movement can be
limited.
-The stiffness and apparent hardness of PTFE resins to make seal elements vulnerable to
damage in handling and at installation.
12 13
Question? 800.822.4063 Question? 800.822.4063
A great amount of literature has been printed by both PTFE resin suppliers and product 18
fabricators regarding wear, and for most product applications this data will prove to be acceptable 16
for usage in compound selection.
14
However, for radial lip seal products, wear rate testing must also take into account the process
cycle of the PTFE material, and final method of element fabrication. It is recommended that the 12
% Weight Loss
Virgin
test specimen for lip seal wear data closely resemble the final element configuration.
10 5% Carbon
To illustrate the wear performance of various filled PTFE compounds, five filled compounds were 15% Carbon
8
processed per the same molding pressure cycle, and sintered on the same time/temperature 15% Glass
testing span. Identical conventional Wafer elements were then machined from the billets of 6 15% Graphite
material and tested on a wear test fixture as shown in Table 1.
4
Physical ASTM Standard Virgin 15% Glass 25% Glass 15% Graphite 5% Glass 60% Bronze 2
Properties 5% Molybdenum
Flexural Modulus, D 747-61T 0.90 x 10^5 1.62 x 10^5 2.38 x 10^5 1.92x 10^5 - 1.97 x 10^5 Figure: 3
PSI
Hardness, D 1706-59T 58 64 66 64 62 70
Durometer, D Figures 3 and 4 show the rate of wear by weight loss after 12, 24, and 72 hour running intervals.
Compressive D 695-54T 750 1250 1400 1200 1100 1700 Note: unfilled virgin PTFE was also tested to illustrate effect of filler on wear rate.
Strength, PSI 1%
Strain
Wear data representing filled PTFE compounds in lubricating media is not shown, since the
Deformation at D 621-59 (ref.) 14.6 7.8 6.7 7.5 8.1 5.8
78 F, 2000 PSI,
24 hours %
presence of lubricant extends the noticeable wear point to beyond 1000 hours, and even then the
Coefficient Linear D 696-44 7.03 x 10^-5 3.12 x 10^-5 4.10 x 10^-5 4.67 x 10^-5 - 4.40 x 10^-5 wear rate difference between compounds is minimal unless factors such as speed, pressure, and
Expansion (per
Deg f)
Table: 1
temperature are greatly increased.
14 15
Question? 800.822.4063 Question? 800.822.4063
8 Light duty service, FDA approved, Excellent for cryogenic and low molecular
TP-3115 -195 to 232 Lowest
weight gas service.
7 General purpose. Good wear in soft shaft applications. high speed & lower
TP-3102 -195 to 232 Low
pressures.
6 TP-3100
Excellent resistance to heat and wear. Recommended for dry or semi-dry
-195 to 260 Low
% Weight Loss
Virgin applications. Good in liquids and steam. Graphite added for lubricity.
5 5% Carbon Excellent wear and heat resistance. High pressure applications, good in
TP-3113 hydraulic oil. Abrasive in rotary service against soft metals unless lubricated. -156 to 287 Moderate
15% Carbon Molybdenum added for lubricity.
4
15% Glass FDA compliant. Exceptionally strong and prolongs life of the base PTFM.
TP-5114 -156 to 287 Moderate
3 15% Graphite Abrasive in rotary service against soft metals.
Excellent in dry service with low wear rate in vacuum and inert gases. Very low
2 TP-3105 abrasion to dynamic mating surface. Good in food applications and oil service. -267 to 260 Low
NOT good in water.
1 TP-5202
FDA compliant. Excellent wear and heat resistance. Excellent for high RPM
-195 to 260 Low
applications. Good in both dry and liquid applications.
0 TP-XXXX
We will custom blend, sinter, and mold a filled PTFE compound to provide
TBD TBD
you with the best material available for your application!!
0 24 48 72
Hours - % Weight Loss Running Dry
Table: 2
Figure: 4
T
he choice of filler type and material processing cycle is still largely dependent upon the results
obtained from empirical testing. Continued development and engineered approaches to PTFE lip
seal design and manufacturing methods is establishing filled PTFE resins as an acceptable sealing
element material.
16 17
Question? 800.822.4063 Question? 800.822.4063
Temperature: This is perhaps the most critical factor to consider when designing a PTFE lip seal. Due
to PTFEs high rate of thermal expansion, the pronounced change in flexural modulus at various
temperatures, and the compressive Creep characteristics, a controlled contact pattern and desirable
radial loading on the shaft surface are difficult to control. To achieve a satisfactory seal, the design and
material should be directed to the mean functional temperature range.
Shaft Speed: As a factor by itself, shaft speed has little effect on the PTFE lip seals, unless speeds
reach a level where severe temperature and wear are generated by the sealing element. Speed,
however, is a critical factor in seal design when the application is one that has a high degree of shaft
run-out, limited lubrication, or when a positive fluid pressure is present and the limiting PV range of
the material is approached.
18 19
Question? 800.822.4063 Question? 800.822.4063
Fluid Type and Fluid Level: These are determining factors that greatly influence seal design. Contamination: Contamination is less critical to PTFE resins than elastomer compounds. Whereas
Although PTFE is compatible with most lubricants and chemicals, careful selection of seal type elastomer materials act like a grinding wheel when abrasive particles becomes embedded, PTFE
and filler type are required for fluids that have no lubricant value. Since the majority of lip seal allows the particles to penetrate and then transfers a film over the particles, therefore minimizing the
applications are involved with the sealing of lubricating oils, type of lubricant generally receives abrasive action. PTFE radial lip seals have been used without excluder lip where contamination is light,
little attention. Experience with certain extreme pressure gear lubricants has shown a definite but an excluder is recommended where heavy contamination is present.
form of reversion and high wear rate when the EP fluid was exposed to temperatures beyond its Installation: Installation of the PTFE radial lip seal is an area that requires attention by both the seal
recommended limit. Fluid level and/or amount of fluid in the adjacent seal area is a determining engineer and end user. Because PTFE is a stiff material and does not possess the elastic properties
factor on usage of a spring or other means to increase radial load. of elastomers, possible damage to the element from sharp edges and burrs on the shaft must be
Dynamic Shaft Run-Out: Shaft run-out is an operational condition that heavily influences the PTFE avoided. In most instances, installation problems can be overcome by proper seal design selection. If
element design and method of processing the material. To offset the high flexural modulus and the application requires a element design with heavy interference, and installation onto the shaft is
enable the element to follow the shaft movement, special design considerations and processing against the PTFE element, an installation tool should be considered.
techniques are employed to obtain as flexible an element as possible.
Shaft Material and Finish: These requirements are essentially the same as applied to elastomer
seals. Because of PTFEs tendency to transfer a film onto the adjacent shaft surface, a finish of
16 Max rms is recommended for sealing lubricants. Applications in which water and chemicals
are to be sealed require a smoother surface finish of 8-12 rms, since normally no transfer to
PTFE is obtained. Steel and cast iron are the best shaft materials, and stainless steel is preferred
over chrome plated materials. It is important that all finishes be produced by plunge grinding,
or a process that will not produce a helical lead to the shaft surface. Helical leads on the shaft
surface have a greater influence on PTFE than elastomers because of the low frictional hardness
characteristics of PTFE resins.
20 21
Question? 800.822.4063 Question? 800.822.4063
22 23
Question? 800.822.4063 Question? 800.822.4063
The reasons for intentionally designing a wide contact into a sealing element are: Heat-Set the element ID is greater than the original fabricated dimension, and installation becomes
PTFE when exposed to elevated temperatures experiences a significant reduction in radial load. less troublesome. After the Heat-Set seal design is installed into the application, the initial heat
Therefore, to maintain the fluid film between the shaft and element, a wide contact area is generated from the friction will cause the element to attempt to return to its original ID.
desirable to prevent leakage.
T
he employment of a spring to a PTFE element is normally determined by the seal engineer and their
Since PTFE is prone to damage on installation and handling, minor nicks in the extreme ID surface
particular design practices. However, there are definite situations that will predict usage of a spring.
are offset with the wide contact area.
These are:
In applications where fluid pressure is evident, the wide contact area enables the load to be
-Excessive amount of shaft run-out and/or shaft and bore misalignment.
distributed over a greater area, and therefore reducing both element and shaft wear. The wide
contact area on the shaft surface also allows higher spring loads to be applied to the elements -Pressure application where the element takes a compression set, and a spring is required to
without increasing wear and/or shaft scoring. provide immediate response when pressure is suddenly reduced.
When the wide contact principle is employed in PTFE lip seal designs, and especially spring -Where loss of radial load, due to high temperatures, will result in leakage
activated elements, the design parameters of the seal must not allow Bell Mouthing to occur.
-To offset the high flexural modulus in low temperature environment
This affect, in figure 5, will create an oil wedge and produce high leakage rates.
The amount of interference between the element ID and shaft OD may vary from one design to
another. Heavy interference is normally associated with non spring-loaded element designs.
This interference provides greater radial load and enables the element to follow shaft run-
out. By incorporating a spring, the interference factor can be reduced. For designs that depend
upon large running interferences, and this can apply to both spring and non-spring designs, the
problem of installation damage becomes very critical. Although installation tools can be utilized,
it is preferable to take advantage of the Heat-Set characteristic of the PTFE material. Once the
desired sealing interference has been determined and the element is machined or molded to this
diameter, the element ID is then stretched over a predetermined diameter and the element is
exposed to a Heat-Setting operation. Heat-Set is nothing more than applying a specific amount
of heat to an element and allowing the element to cool on a mandrel of predeveloped size. After
24 25
Question? 800.822.4063 Question? 800.822.4063
-Mechanically formed to a diameter smaller Another variation of the dual element design. Elements are stacked
2 PTFE Elements 90 psi -65 to 500F
than shaft 600 (Same Direction) (0.621 MPa) (-54 to 260C)
together which allows sealing at higher pressures and high speeds in
abrasive media. Excellent for low pressure sealing as well.
26 27
Question? 800.822.4063 Question? 800.822.4063
Shaft Considerations
Proper surface finish is critical to ensure positive sealing, and achieve the longest seal life possible
in rotating applications. Rotating surfaces that are too rough can create leak paths and can be very
abrasive to the seal. Unlike elastomer contact seals, PTFE-based lips can run on very smooth surfaces
with or without lubrication. Due to the toughness and low coefficient of friction or PTFE, PTFE lip seals,
unlike seals made of other materials, slip over the high points of the mating surface and resist abrasion.
The optimal surface finish for PTFE Lip seal applications is summarized in the Table 3.
Surface Finishes
18 Ra
18 Ra
18 Ra
Table: 3
Dynamic surfaces with relatively rough finishes will result in higher wear rates, which decreases the seal
life and may compromise performance. Additionally, dynamic surfaces which have a finish smoother
than recommended may also decrease the seals effectiveness. The optimum surface roughness allows
a film of the fluid being sealed to flow between the seal and the mating surface, which effectively
lubricates and extends the life of the seal.
28 29
Question? 800.822.4063 Question? 800.822.4063
PTFE rotary seal applications require a hard running surface on the dynamic portion of the hardware. When hardness exceeds 45 Rc, the initial surface finish is even more critical to seal life. The hardness
The harder surface allows the use of higher reinforced seal materials that will increase the seal and of the dynamic hardware surface affects the wear rate of the seal. Additionally, some seal lip
hardware life. Softer running surfaces must use lower wear resistant materials that will not damage materials are abrasive and will wear softer metal shafts or dynamic components. In general, finer
the hardware and normally yield shorter seal life. A balance between seal material and dynamic surface finish results in better overall seal and hardware performance. The ideal hardness of the
surface hardness must be met to ensure that the seal remains the sacrificial component. Table 4 dynamic surfaces of the hardware is 50 to 60 Rockwell C. The actual hardness used is normally a
includes minimum surface hardness. balance between the additional cost associated with finishing harder materials versus the maximum
seal life that will be achievable.
Type of Surface
Rockwell C Hardness
Lubrication Shaft Tolerance for Inch Fractional
Motion Speed At 0 psi 150 500 1000 5000+
(0,0 Mpa) (1,0) (3,5) (6,9) (34,5+) Shaft Diameter Tolerance
Up to 100 Up to 4.000 +/- 0.003
Good 28 28 30 35 44
sfpm 4.001 to 6.000 +/- 0.004
Poor 30 30 35 40 50
(0,51 m/s)
Reciprocating 6.001 to 10.000 +/- 0.005
Over 100 Good 35 35 40 44 50 Over 10.000 +/- 0.006
Table: 5
(0,51) Poor 44 44 48 50 60
Shaft Tolerance for Metric
Up to 150 Good 35 44 50 65 70
(0,76) Poor 44 50 55 70 70+ Shaft Diameter Tolerance
Up to 10 mm +0 to-0.09 mm
30 31
Question? 800.822.4063 Question? 800.822.4063
Surface Shaft
Velocity
= Diameter
Shaft
RPM
0.262
32 33
Question? 800.822.4063 Question? 800.822.4063
Figure 5
34 35
Question? 800.822.4063 Question? 800.822.4063
All rotating shafts have eccentricity and runout to some degree. The risk of failure increases
significantly if a system has a considerable amount of both.
Application Areas for PTFE Radial Lip Seal
Because of PTFEs superior physical and mechanical properties and its chemical resistance, the
application areas where PTFE radial lips seals are being employed has increased rapidly. The only
Shaft Eccentricity limiting factor to PTFE being used throughout the majority of applications is cost. The following are a
few of the more popular applications for PTFE radial lip seals
Shaft Centerline
Diesel Engine Applications
-These consist of the front and rear crankshaft, accessory drive, blower and thermostat seals. PTFE
lip seals are being used and tested for these areas because of their ability to meet the performance
and life requirements of todays engines. Minimum wear, performance at high temperatures with
limited lubrication, resistance to abrasive contaminants, and fluid compatibility are the primary
factors for PTFEs approval in the above applications.
Bore Centerline
Hydraulic Applications
Seal Housing Cavity Diameter -Applications such as motors, pumps, and hydrostatic transmissions are using PTFE lip seals at an
(Bore) increasing rate. It is not unusual to apply a PTFE lip seal in pressurized applications where the seal
is exposed to pressure velocity values as high as 250,000 (250 psi and 1000 fpm) and achieve a
seal life of 5000 hrs. Besides performance, PTFE lip seals normally are less expensive than the
high pressure face seals currently being used, and can offer additional savings by the elimination of
ECCENTRICITY MISALIGNMENT costly venting methods that are employed to reduce pressure in the seal area.
Turbine Engines
-Turbines and their related gear box assemblies are presently incorporating PTFE lip seals because
With eccentricity, only static radial deflection is imposed on seal. of life and minimum leakage rates achieved when these seals are exposed to shaft speed of 6000
ft/min and temperatures of 400F.
Figure 6
36 37
Question? 800.822.4063 Question? 800.822.4063
-Poor shaft surface or low hardness D Hard Chrome Good corrosion resistance 0-1 Tool Steel (A, B, C, D)
38 39
Question? 800.822.4063 Question? 800.822.4063
Type of Application:
Bore Dia: Bore Material: Bore Finish:
Seal Width: Shaft Hardness: Method of Finish:
Can above seal gland dimensions be changed?: (How much?):
40 41
Brought to you by