Insider's Guide 37
Insider's Guide 37
Insider's Guide 37
INSIDERS GUIDE
Interpretation and treatment:
Organic acid Energy and
oxidative markers and treatment
By Ron Grisanti, D.C. & Dicken Weatherby, N.D.
http://www.FunctionalMedicineUniversity.com
The citric acid cycle is the all important metabolic pathway which uses a series of enzyme-
catalysed chemical reactions involved in the conversion of carbohydrates, fats and proteins
into carbon dioxide and water to generate a form of usable energy.
Other relevant reactions in the pathway include those in glycolysis and pyruvate oxidation
before the citric acid cycle, and oxidative phosphorylation after it.
Glycolysis is the sequence of reactions that converts glucose into pyruvate with the
concomitant production of a relatively small amount of adenosine triphosphate (ATP).
Pyruvate decarboxylation is the biochemical reaction that uses pyruvate to form acetyl-CoA,
releasing reducing equivalents and carbon dioxide.
As food in the cells is gradually oxidized, the released energy is used to re-form the ATP
so that the cell always maintains a supply of this essential molecule
In short, the Citric Acid Cycle supplies the body with its primary energy needs. Any metabolic
glitches or blocks in the citric acid cycle or impairments in any of these processes may lead to
chronic fatigue, muscle pain and fatigue, accelerated cell breakdown, and unhealthy aging.
Because enzyme cofactors are involved in virtually every system in the body, insufficiencies in
these vitamins or minerals can affect a wide range of functions, including immunologic,
endocrine, musculoskeletal, and metabolic.
Many organic acids result from the metabolic pathways, or chemical reactions, your body uses
to transform food into energy, growth, maintenance, and repair of body tissue. Like spark plugs
that ignite fuel in a car engine, vitamins and other essential nutrients are necessary for these
High levels of many organic acids can indicate which nutrient insufficiencies may be affecting
your patients health.
Adipate, Suberate, and Ethylmalonate are all functional markers for deficiency of carnitine
Carnitine is needed to move fatty acids into the mitochondria where they are converted to
energy using vitamin B2. When insufficient levels of carnitine or vitamin B2 slow down this
process, other parts of the cellular machinery take over and make adipate and suberate. A
similar block in another pathway causes high ethylmalonate. Since most of your bodys energy
is produced from the burning of fatty acids, your muscles and brain suffer when this cellular
energy pathway is blocked.
Anything that interferes with the normal fatty acid oxidation may reveal high levels of these
metabolites. Rule out environmental toxin exposure, excessive aspirin use
If HIGH
Consider supplementing with carnitine and vitamin B2. Lysine being a precursor of carnitine, it
may also be of value. Carnitine supplementation has been documented to improve
Alzheimers, age-related cognitive decline, and cardiac function.
Lactate is the principal product of glucose metabolism in skeletal muscle and is a major player
in anaerobic energy production and gluconeogenesis. High levels are commonly associated
with coenzyme Q10, biotin and lipoic acid deficiencies. The following should be ruled in or out
to determine the underlying reason why lactic acid is elevated: overwhelming infection,
hypoxia, high intake of acetaminophen, increased consumption of alcohol, cocaine, increased
iron levels, drug side effects (metformin). Rule out diabetes. High lactate can cause muscle
cramping, fatigue and brain fog.
If HIGH
Consider supplementing with CoQ10, Vitamin B1, B2, B3, B5, Lipoic acid and Biotin.
Gluconeogenesis is a metabolic pathway that results in the generation of glucose from non-
carbohydrate carbon substrates such as pyruvate, lactate, glycerol, and glucogenic amino
acids.
Pyruvate is another major player in anaerobic energy production and gluconeogenesis. May
be elevated when B1, B5 and lipoic acid are insufficient.
Suspect lipoic acid deficiency when the combination of lactate and pyruvate are high. Many
studies have shown that lipoic acid is helpful in treating diabetes and for assisting the liver with
removing toxins from the body.
When the pyruvate marker is high, it is important to quickly scan to see if alpha-ketoglutarate,
alpha-ketoisovalerate, alpha-ketoisocaproate, and alpha-keto-beta-methylvalerate are
also high. All of these analytes share a common enzyme complex all relying on the same
coenzymes: Vitamin B1, B5, lipoic acid, B2, and B3. (in descending order of significance).
Lactate elevations, alone (meaning, not in combination with elevated Pyruvate) suggests
CoQ10 deficiency.
Vitamins B1 (thiamin), B3 (niacin), and B5 (pantothenic acid) are necessary for energy
pathways of all of the cells in your body. As your food is broken down, specific compounds are
formed at steps that require B vitamin assistance. Ketoglutarate, a-Ketoisovalerate, a-
Ketoisocaproate, and a-Keto--methylvalerate are some these compounds. Alpha-
ketoisovaleric Acid, Alpha-ketoisocaproic Acid and Alpha-keto-betamethylvaline
Acid are metabolites of amino acids valine, leucine, & isoleucine, respectively. The production
of these metabolites require vitamins B1, B3, B5 and lipoic acid.
If HIGH
Impaired metabolism due to cofactor insufficiencies or toxic metals; OR maple syrup urine
disease (if markedly elevated).
Supplement cofactors (vitamins B1, B2, B3, B5, Mg, cysteine, or lipoic acid); remove toxic
metals (As, Hg, Sb, Cd)
If LOW
Possible low B6; OR secondary to low branched-chain amino acids.
Clinical Note: If patient is on Clofibrate (Clofibrate is a lipid lowering agent used for controlling
the high cholesterol) this marker might have diminished sensitivity.
If HIGH
Consider supplementing with chromium, vanadium, and lipoic acid.
If HIGH
Impaired metabolism due to toxic metals (Fl, Hg, As, Sb) OR low cofactors (Fe, GSH
depleted in oxidative stress); OR high amounts of dietary citric acid; OR metabolic acidosis (if
mildly increased cisaconitic acid but markedly increased citric acid).
High Citrate and Cis-aconitate can indicate arginine insufficiency for ammonia clearance
through the Urea Cycle
Consider supplementing with arginine
Rule out toxic metals; glutathione, N-acetylcysteine, Mg, or L-glutamine; consider anti-
oxidants; rule out pancreatic insufficiency (can lead to metabolic acidosis from deficient
bicarbonate).
If LOW
Low or high pyruvic acid or low acetyl CoA (from fatty acid oxidation)
Arginine is a conditionally essential amino acid that is critical for your cardiovascular health
and detoxification functions. The amino acid, arginine, is used to make the powerful blood
vessel regulator, nitric oxide. Nitric oxide acts to lower blood pressure. Too little arginine can
lead to high blood pressure.
If HIGH
Impaired metabolism due to low cofactors (B3, Mg, Mn) or inhibition by aluminum.
High Isocitrate can indicate arginine insufficiency for ammonia clearance through the
Urea Cycle
Consider supplementing with arginine
Rule out Al toxicity; consider vitamin B3, Mg, Mn supplementation.
If LOW
2 to subnormal upstream metabolites; OR same causes of high cisaconitic acid
Succinate, Fumarate, and Malate are used in the bodys metabolic pathway that generates
cellular energy the Citric Acid Cycle. Higher levels of these compounds in urine indicate
inefficiencies in energy production. If ketoglutarate is elevated along with succinate, malate,
and fumarate, you may need additional CoQ10.
Succinate, Fumarate, and Malate are all involved in mitochondrial oxidation. Succinate,
Fumarate are metabolites of the amino acids leucine & isoleucine and phenylalanine &
tyrosine respectively.
Common symptoms of high levels of the above may include: fatigue, weakness, myocardial
degeneration, neurological degeneration.
If HIGH
Consider supplementing with CoQ10, riboflavin (B2) and magnesium.
SPECIAL CONSIDERATION
Succinate metabolism may be impaired due to low cofactors (Fe or B2); OR bacterial
degradation of glutamine.
If LOW
Consider over-utilization of the Citric Acid Cycle. Fatigue and weakness are common
symptoms.
Consider supplementing with L-Leucine, L-Isoleucine and Vitamin B12 with low succinate,
tyrosine & phenylalanine with low fumarate and balanced amino acid blend with low malate.
Hydroxymethylglutarate (HMG)
-Hydroxyisovalerate
Methylmalonate is a functional marker of vitamin B12 and a metabolite of the amino acid
valine. High levels indicate insufficient vitamin B12. Increased alcohol consumption, dysbiosis,
aging and HIV infection will all have a detrimental impact on B12 absorption.
Common symptoms may include: Anemia, fatigue, elevated homocysteine, ischemic heart
disease, stroke, deep vein thrombosis, paresthesias and GI disorders
Consider supplementing with B12 sublingual or IV B12 (if oral is ineffective). Stop alcohol and
address dysbiosis.
p-Hydroxyphenyllactate
2-Hydroxphenylacetic Acid
Metabolite of phenylalanine
If HIGH
Excessive phenylalanine (dietary or PKU) or tyrosine; OR reduced oxygenation (e.g., iron
deficiency anemia, pulmonary disorder); OR low tetrahydrobiopterin (BH4), which may result in
low neurotransmitters and/or nitric oxide
CONSIDER
Amino Acid Analysis is recommended to rule out excessive phenylalanine &/or tyrosine.
Correct oxygenation if relevant.
Supplement vitamin C (increases BH4 levels in body).
5-MTHF (from folic acid) may help nitric oxide production when BH4 is low
4-Hydroxphenylpyruvic Acid
IF HIGH
Impaired metabolism due to cofactor insufficiency (iron, vitamin C, O2); OR alkaptonuria (rare)
CONSIDER
Supplement iron (if low), vitamin C, improve oxygenation
Consider NAC to protect enzyme
(Made from tryptophan and lysine via alpha-aminoadipic acid, also a byproduct of yeast;
precursor of glutaric acid)
If HIGH
May be secondary to high glutaric acid (check glutaric level); OR impaired metabolism due to
cofactor insufficiencies OR toxic metals (As, Hg, Sb, Cd); OR may be secondary to yeast or
fungal infection (derives from alphaaminoadipic acid)see yeast markers.
CONSIDER
Supplement cofactors (vitamins B1, B2, B3, B5, Mg, cysteine, or lipoic acid); remove toxic
metals (As, Hg, Sb, Cd)
Antifungals, anti-yeast diet, probiotics, if relevant Alpha-ketoadipic Acid (AKAA)
Glutaric Acid
Pyroglutamic Acid
Adipic Acid
b-OH-Butyric (BHBA)
Credit is contributed to the following labs for their advancement in the field of functional
medicine:
Metametrix Clinical Laboratory
3425 Corporate Way
Duluth, GA 30096
800-221-4640
www.metametrix.com
Genova Diagnostics
63 Zillicoa Street
Asheville, NC 28801
800-522-4762
www.gdx.net