Continuing Case Part 1
Continuing Case Part 1
Continuing
Case: Cory
and Tisha
Dumont
Part 1
Summary:
Cory and Tisha Dumont have become concerned about their personal finances after
reading a Money article recently. After reading they have sought help to help arrange their
finances. Cory and Tisha are 31 and 30 years old respectively. They were married six years ago,
and have a son named Chad, age 4, a daughter Haley, age 2, and a fat tabby cat named Ms. Cat.
Cory is a store manager making $45,000 a year, and Tisha is an accountant earning $53,000 a
year. The Dumonts currently are renting a three-bedroom townhome for $2,000 per month, but
are hoping to purchase a home within the next three to five years. For their wedding, they
applied all gifts and family contributions to a market index mutual fund which, last checked, has
a balance of $13,000. Neither Corey nor Tisha know whether the amount of taxes they are
paying are correct. They have home, automobile, and life insurance, but have always chosen the
lowest premiums without regarding how much coverage comes with. Tishas life insurance
policy is $1,800, and she pays a premium of $720 annually. They are unsure whether they
should swap their credit cards with new ones that come with low interest rates and other bonuses.
They make $100 payments for their credit cards every month, and their credit card balance is
typically around $1,300. They typically use credit cards to cover daily expenses, but tend to
have about $100 of cash on hand. They have a savings account with a balance of $2,500 that
earns 3% interest annually, and a checking account with a balance of $1,800 that earns interest of
0.75%. The checking account balance requires a minimum of $1,000. Cory and Tisha are
concerned about paying for college for their children, because they both are still paying off
student loans. Both Dumonts participate in a qualified retirement plan at work, but do not fully
understand what that means. The only retirement account they own is Corys 401k account that
was left with his former employer. When he left the company, the account had a balance of
$2,500. Cory is not a fan of financial surprises, but Tisha is willing to take calculated risks. The
Dumonts not done any estate planning. They both enjoy outdoor activities with the family, and
enjoy playing golf. The Dumonts are considering joining a country club that costs $250 a month.
Chad will need braces and glasses within the next few years.
Additional Information:
Clothing $3,300
Entertainment $2,400
Savings $1,200
Miscellaneous $2,400
Other Assets:
Automobile No. 1
o 2 year-old, midsize SUV with a fair market value (FMV) of $14,800.
o Amount Owed: $12,925 (36 months remaining on the loan)
o Monthly Payment: $405
Automobile No. 2
o 4 year-old, 2 door coupe with an FMV of $7,800
o Amount Owed: $0
Household Furniture, electronics, and other personal property worth amount $12,000
Antique Jewelry
o Tisha received this as an inheritance from her grandmother and said that she
would never part with it. The jewelry has an estimated value of $19,700
When Tisha turned 21, her father gave her 100 shares of the Great Basin balanced Mutual
Credit card debt (Visa, MasterCard, Discover, American Express and several store cards)
o $1,300 revolving outstanding balance
o $50 minimum monthly payments (approximate)
o $100 actual monthly payments
Student loan debt (for Cory)
o $8,200 balance
o $196 monthly payment (48 months remaining on the loan)
o $652 interest payment for 2007
Furniture company loan
o $5,300 balance
o $210 monthly payment (30 months remaining on the loan)
1. Identify the stages of the life cycle that best describes Cory and Tisha today. What
Cory and Tisha are still in stage one of the financial life style, which is typically between
the ages of 18 and 55 years old. Cory and Tisha, who are the ages of 31 and 30 respectively, fall
in between the ages of 18 and 55, were married six years ago, and have two children, Chad age 4
and Haley age 2. There are a number of financial planning issues that Cory and Tisha need to
address while in this stage. One issue that they are currently working on is the purchase of a
house. Within the next three to five years, the Dumonts plan on purchasing a home, using their
market index mutual fund as a down payment. Currently, that fund holds $13,000. Additionally,
the Dumonts need to understand that retirement planning begins in this stage. They have already
begun some retirement planning with Corys 401k account, which holds $2,500, but consistent
reevaluation of their retirement plan is important. The Dumonts have already begun forming a
family, which is good, because they can now prepare to plan for their familys future. They have
begun researching college education expenses for both Chad and Haley, which is a positive sign.
Cory and Tisha are still on the hook for $8,200 of student loans, and they need to continue to pay
them off. Because Cory and Tisha are now married with children, it is incredibly important to do
a couple of things to ensure their familys protection. First, Cory and Tisha need to form a will
so that, in case of a tragic accident, the Dumont estate will be handled in the way that Cory and
Tisha wish. Also, Cory and Tisha need life insurance, which Tisha has acquired. Currently, their
life insurance account holds $1,800, and the family should look into increasing the account.
Finally, in this stage in life, it is essential for Cory and Tisha to begin making as much money as
possible while building up savings. This will allow them to prepare, plan, and execute what they
2. Based on the issues identified in Question 1, and your knowledge of the Dumont
household, help Cory and Tisha complete Worksheet 1 to identify their short-term,
DESIRED
health,
PRIMARY 3 months
disability, and liability
insurance
Purchase a major item SECONDARY
Finance a vacation or some After 6 months'
Secondary
time-share unit
Finance a major vacation
Secondary
(overseas)
Other intermediate-term
goals (specify)
Continue saving for
Secondary
retirement
Increase months' living
Primary 2-3 years $ 37,748.50
expenses to 6
large enough
to supplement your
Primary 19 $18,00/year
pension so that
current standard
Take care of your parents
Secondary
after they retire
Start your own business Secondary
Other long-term goals
(specify)
Downsize Secondary
Final Expenses Secondary
Expenditures $
4. Develop a balance sheet for the Dumonts using Worksheet 4. Do they have a positive or
After completing the balance sheet for the Dumonts, it has been determined that they have a
positive net worth. The Dumonts have a total asset accumulation of $78,300, while their total
liabilities reach a total of $28,050. This results in the Dumonts having a net worth of $50,250.
5. Using the information from the income and expense statements and the balance sheet,
minimum of 2.0.
The Dumonts have a months living expense cover ratio of 0.6, which is far below the
c. Debt ratio
The Dumonts debt ratio is 35.82%, but when factoring out the priceless antique
The long-term debt coverage ratio for the Dumonts is 3.73, which is above the
e. Savings ratio
The Dumonts have a savings ratio of -11.19% which is far below the suggested
minimum of 10%.
6. Use the information provided by the ratio analysis to assess the Dumonts financial
health. What recommendations would you make to improve their financial health?
After examining the Dumonts income statement, balance sheet, and expense reports, a
number of useful financial ratios can be determined. To start, the current ratio will identify how
liquid the Dumonts assets are, and typically a current ratio over 2 is a good sign. The Dumonts
have a current ratio of 2.71, which puts them in a good position going forward. The second ratio
that should be examined is the months living expense cover ratio, which determines how many
months of expenses can be covered using the monetary assets the Dumonts have saved. At the
minimum, one should hope to cover six months, but unfortunately, the Dumonts are barely
covering half a month. This is a dangerous sign, because if something were to happen in which
their income would cease, their savings would not carry them for a long period of time. Cory
and Trisha need to find a way to either cut some expenses, begin focusing more on contributing
more of their income into their savings, or preferably both. The debt ratio will help determine
the level of debt one has based off of the amount of assets they own. When looking at the
Dumonts debt ratio, they have a ratio of 35.82%, which could a promising sign. Compared to
the amount of assets they have, the Dumonts debts are relatively low. However, what needs to
be accounted for is that the Dumonts most expensive asset is a set of jewelry that Tisha received,
and would never part with. This needs to be factored out, since it will almost certainly never be
sold or put up as collateral. Therefore, a more accurate debt ratio for the Dumonts is 47.87%,
which is beginning to look high, especially since they do not have any highly expensive tangible
assets and wish to become more indebted with the purchase of a house. The long-term debt ratio
shows how far ones income before expenses can cover their long-term debt obligations. At the
minimum, a solid goal is to have a 2.5 long-term debt ratio. The Dumonts have a ratio of 3.73,
which is a good sign for the family. The most troublesome red flag the Dumonts have is their
savings ratio. The savings ratio determines how much of ones after-tax income will be able to
go towards savings after expenses. Typically, you would want a savings ratio over 10%, but the
Dumonts have a savings ratio of -11.19%. This shows that their expenses are not being covered
by their after-tax income, and the family is having to eat into their savings in order to cover
expense costs. This is far from ideal, because they will not be able to sustain this level of
spending. The Dumonts need to cut expense in order to bring up this ratio, starting with their
recreational expenses. Cory and Tisha are spending $2,400 a year on entertainment, which is
having a large negative impact on their ability to save. Unfortunately, golfing may need to be cut
out because they need to drastically decrease this as a start. Their biggest expense at the
moment, is daycare. Currently, they are spending $10,000 a year for daycare, and if this expense
could be cut out entirely, they will be able to begin saving. With Chad being 4, he is about to
begin kindergarten which will decrease the expense, but the Cory and Tisha should look to move
both Chad and Haley out of daycare immediately, because it is constricting their ability to save
for the future. They should look into the possibility of seeking out a family member to supervise
the children while Cory and Tisha continue to work. Eliminating these two expenses will allow
them to change their savings ratio from a -11.19% to a 7.07%. Though 7.07% is still not ideal, it
is much better figure than what they are at now, and a good starting point to build off of.
Additionally, if the Dumonts are able to slash these expenses and increase their savings, their
7. Do the Dumonts have an emergency fund? Should they? How much would you
The Dumonts would have a hard time claiming that they have an emergency fund at the
moment. They only have $2,500 in their savings account, which, as previously discussed, would
not go far towards their yearly expenses. They could liquidate their mutual fund accounts (total
of $15,300), which would have a substantial impact in case of an emergency, however, a large
portion of those accounts comes from the market index fund. They are planning on using this
fund within the next three to five years as a down payment towards a home. This drastically
limits their abilities due to the fact that they will either be relieved of that money within the next
few years, or an emergency will drastically hinder their goals of owning a home. Cory and Tisha
do need to create an emergency fund in order to prepare for the unpleasant surprises life can
bring. With a solid emergency fund, Cory and Tisha will be able to adapt more efficiently if an
emergency arises. To start, they need to increase their monetary assets by enough to cover six
months of their expenses. This would require saving about $33,334. Luckily, they both have
health and auto insurance coverage, but they have minimum plans. They should look into opting
for a little more expensive plan that will allow them more coverage. Similarly, they have a low
level life insurance plan. This has resulted in high premiums with low coverage. Trisha should
investigate more beneficial plans, since her current one does not seem to be worth the level of
coverage it is providing.
8. According to the Money article that Cory and Tisha read, they can expect to pay
$100,000 in tuition and other college related expenses when Chad enters college, and
even more for Haley. The Dumonts are hoping that Chad will receive academic
scholarships that will reduce their total college costs to $40,000. Assuming the Dumonts
start a college saving program today and manage to earn 9 percent a year, ignoring taxes,
until Chad is 18, how much will they need to save at the end of each year? How much
will the Dumonts need to save if Chad does not receive scholarships?
In order to pay for Chads tuition, whether he receives scholarships or not must be accounted
for. Chad is about 14 years away from college, which gives the Dumonts plenty of time to begin
saving for him. It is being assumed that Cory and Tisha will earn 9% on their sons college
investment. Therefore, in order to reach $40,000 in 14 at a rate of 9%, the Dumonts need to
begin saving $1,57.33 a year at the end of this year. In case Chad does not receive his
scholarships, the Dumonts need to save $3,843.32 a year for 14 years to reach $100,000.
9. How much will the Dumonts need to save at the beginning of each year to accumulate
$40,000 for Haley to attend college, if they receive 9% on their savings? Assuming the
Dumonts need an accumulation of $110,000 to fund all of Haleys college expenses, how
much do they need to save at the beginning of each year? If, instead, they save money at
the end of each year, how much will they need to put away to reach the $110,000 goal if
If the Dumonts are trying to start saving now for Haleys college education, and are
predicting that Haley will be able to receive academic scholarships, they will have to begin
saving $1,111.92. This is if their future value is $40,000, the time it will take in order to reach
the goal is 16 years (assuming Haley begins college at 18), they continue gaining 9% returns on
their investment, and they begin making payments into the account at the beginning of each year.
If Haley does not receive the scholarships, and the Dumonts have to pay the full predicted
$110,000, they need to begin making payments of $3,057.79. This is if the future value is
$110,000, the time to save is 16 years, they continue receiving a return of 9%, and they make
payments at the beginning of the year. Finally, if the Dumonts need to reach $110,000 in 16
years, using a rate of return of 9% compounded annually, they will need to make payments of
$3,332.99 a year.
10. How much will Tishas Great Basin Balance Mutual Fund shares (currently valued at
$2,300) when Chad enters college, assuming the fund returns 7% after taxes on an
annualized basis? How much will the shares be worth when Haley turns 18 years old?
What will be the value of the shares when Tisha retires at 67 years old, assuming, a 9%
after taxes return and no deductions from the account? What has been the annualized rate
Tishas current Great Basin Balance Mutual Fund has a current account balance of $2,300. If
the account is able to continue making a rate of return of 7%, once Chad reaches college after 14
years, the mutual fund account will amass a total of $5,930.63. This is by using the future value
formula, using $2,300 as the present value, 14 years as the time, and the rate being 7%. If Tisha
holds onto the shares until Haley turns 18, the shares will be worth a total of $6,789.98. This can
be found using the future value function, and using $2,300 as the present value, the time being 16
years, and the rate continuing to be 7%. If, however, Tisha holds onto the shares until she retires
at the age of 67, and the shares are able to generate 9% returns annually, the shares will increase
in value to a price of $55,783.82. This is if it is assumed that the present value is $2,300, the
time is 37 years, and the rate of return is 9%. Finally, Tisha has been able to receive and
annualized rate of return of 9.7% on the Great Basin Balance Mutual Fund since it was given to
her at the age of 21. This was found by determining that the rate of return on the investment was
130%. Therefore, to find the annualized rate of return, one needs to add one to the 130%, then
raise the sum to one divided by the number of years (9), and finally subtract one. This resulted in
9.7%.
11. Recall that the Dumonts set up a savings fund for future down payments with gifts and
contributions from their wedding. How much will the market index fund valued at
$13,000 be worth in 3, 5, and 7 years if they can earn a current rate of return of 6%?
How much will the fund be worth in 3, 5, and 7 years if they can obtain an 8% rate of
return?
The Dumonts received cash gifts for their wedding, and they chose to invest their gifts into a
market index mutual fund. Currently the shares of the fund that the Dumonts own are worth
$13,000. The intent with these shares is to sell them within three to five years in order to make a
down payment towards a home. If the Dumonts wish to begin purchasing their home using these
shares in three years, and the fund obtains a return of 6%, these shares will be worth $15,483.21.
If the shares have the same return, but the Cory and Tisha wish to wait for five years, the shares
will be worth $17,369.93. Finally, if the shares still earn 6% and they wait seven years before
cashing out the shares for their home down payment, the shares will be worth $19,547.19. If the
fund is able to earn 8%, however, and the Dumonts wait three years to make their down
payment, the shares will be worth $16,376.26. If they are able to generate 8% returns on the
fund and wait five years, the shares will be worth $19,101.26 after that five years. Finally, the
shares will be worth $22,279.72 if Cory and Tisha wish to wait seven years before cashing out
12. Assuming an 8% return for the current year for the market index fund valued at $13,000
and a 15% federal marginal tax rate, how much will the Dumonts pay on their
investment, either from their savings or their current income this year? By how much,
Assuming that the market index fund the Dumonts own returns 8% for the current year, it
can be determined that the fund gained $1,040. This is taxable income under the federal tax
laws. Currently the federal marginal tax rate is 15%. This means that the Dumonts are required
to pay 15% of the $1,040 gained by the market index fund towards the government. This results
in a tax liability of $156 (1040*.15). After factoring out the federal tax liability of the market
index fund, the Dumonts will grow by $884, resulting in the account totaling $13,884 after taxes.
13. Assuming that Cory does nothing with his 401k retirement account from his former
employer and the government grows at a rate of 5% annually, how much will Cory have
when he retires at age 67? If instead, Cory takes control of the money and invests it in a
tax-deferred IRA earning 10% annually, how much will he have at age 67?
If Cory wishes to leave his 401k account, which amounts to $2,500, with his previous company,
and allow it to grow at a rate of 5% annually, his account will come to a total of $14,479.54 after
36 years, which is how long it will take for him to reach the age of 67. However, if Cory decides
to take control of his account, and invest it into a tax-deferred IRA with an earnings rate of 10%
annually, he will be able to save a much greater sum. After 36 years at 10% in the tax-deferred
IRA, Cory will have a total of $77,281.70 for retirement. This is a significantly greater amount
of money, and it is highly suggested that Cory takes control of his 401k account, and switches it
14. Using the income and expense estimates provided by Tisha, calculate the Dumonts
taxable income using the 2014 tax information provided in the text.
a. Do the Dumonts have enough tax-deductible expenses to itemize reductions?
The Dumonts should not consider itemized reductions when preforming their taxes. This
is due to the fact that they could only reduce their taxes based on their medical and dental
payments and their charitable donations. The medical and dental bill reaches a total of $850,
which amounts to 1% of the total AGI. This allows them to deduct them, however, when added
to the charitable contributions of $2,400, they could only itemize a total of $3,250. This is
substantially lower than the standard reduction of $12,400. Therefore, the standard reduction
Since Cory is still paying off interest on his student loans, the interest amount is allowed
to be deducted from the gross income. This means that before the federal tax liability is
calculated, the gross income of $98,000 can be reduced by the $652 of interest owed. This,
along with the 401k contributions, will reduce the gross income to the adjusted gross income of
c. How much Social Security and Medicare taxes are withheld from Corys and
Tishas income?
In order to determine the taxes withheld from Corys and Tishas income, the Social Security and
Medicare tax rates must be known. As of 2014, the tax rate for Social Security is 6.2%, and
Medicare is 1.45%. Therefore, after multiplying the gross income by these rates, the taxes
The Dumonts tentative federal income tax liability comes to a total of $8,729.70. This can be
found by determining their adjusted gross income by taking out the 401k contributions and
interest paid on student loans. This results in an AGI of $92,448. If the Dumonts opt for the
standardized reductions, they can also subtract $12,400 from the AGI. The Dumonts can also
take advantage of personal tax exemptions, which is $3,950 per person, equaling a total of
$15,800. This gives a final adjustment of $64,248. This puts Cory and Tisha into the 15% tax
bracket, which means that their federal tax liability will be equaled to $1,850+($64,248-
$18,150)*15%. This results in a tentative tax liability of $8,729.70. After the tentative tax
liability is calculated, tax credits can be reduced. The Dumonts have a tax credit total of $2,000
due to receiving the child tax credit which allows fillers to take $1,000 off of their tentative tax
liability for every child under their care under the age of 18. This gives the Dumonts a final total
e. Do the Dumonts qualify for the child tax credit? If so, how will it affect their
The Dumonts do qualify for a child tax credit. This means they will receive tax credits of $2,000
for their two children, since they are both still under the age of 18. This will reduce their income
tax liability from $8,729.70 to $6,729.70. The Dumonts will still require a payment because they
do not have enough reductions and tax credits to reduce their total federal income tax liability to
a negative. If they had more credits earned than tax liabilities, then Cory and Tisha would
receive a tax refund. However, the Dumonts still owe the federal government taxes.
15. Based on the total social security tax, Medicare tax, and federal income tax liabilities
calculated above, how close did Tisha come in estimating their total tax liabilities? How
does the difference between the estimated and actual tax liabilities change their financial
Cory and Tisha will pay a total of $14,226.70 of Social Security, Medicare, and federal
income tax liabilities. Tisha, luckily, did not come close to estimating their total tax liabilities of
$22,000. The difference in the estimated and actual total tax liabilities is $7,773.30. This
changes their financial situation drastically. This will allow them to have a positive income
available for saving and investment after their expenses. This will allow Cory and Tisha to
continue with daycare for both Chase and Haley, because they will no longer be eating into their
savings in order to cover their expenses. However, they still need to greatly reduce the amount
of rounds of golf they play, because they need to increase their savings quickly. This is due to
the fact that their months living cover expense ratio is still so drastically low. Additionally, Cory
and Tisha now have a positive savings ratio of 0.26%, but they still need to continue to cut costs
16. Calculate and interpret for Cory and Tisha the difference among their marginal average,
and effective marginal tax rates. How might these rates change with life events, such as
Cory and Tisha have a marginal average tax rate of 14.52%. This is calculated by dividing their
total tax liabilities of $14,226.70 by their gross income of $98,000. This means that 14.52% of
their total income is going towards taxes. However, their effective marginal tax rate is the rate
that they will be taxed one the next dollar they earn. The Dumonts gross income comes out to
$98,000, which would put them decently inside the 25% tax bracket, therefore with this number
the effective marginal tax rate would be 25%. However, the adjusted income that was used to
calculate the federal income tax will put Cory and Trisha within the 15% tax bracket. If another
dollar was earned, the Dumonts would still be in this 15% bracket. These will change, though,
with certain life events. If there is a great enough salary increase, it can be assumed that both the
marginal average and effective marginal tax rates will both increase. When the Dumonts
eventually purchase their house, with no other changes, only the marginal average tax rate could
potentail decrease. This is due to the fact that they will be able to itemize the mortgage, which
could allow them to deduct more than just the standard deduction.