3/24/2017 11:48 AM FILED IN OFFICE OF TIFFANY MOORE RUSSELL CLERK OF CIRCUIT COURT ORANGE COUNTY FLORIDA INTHE CIRCUIT COURT QETHY QO JUDICIAL CIRCUTT, IN AND FOR ‘COUNTY, FLORIDA case. UO keese Zucne' ae Pelion, and MARSHALL PeLSTO tespondent PETITION FOR INJUNCTION FOR PROTECTION AGAINST STALKING | ul legal name)_(ARE Fe ZAC APA peing sworn, cert thatthe following statements are true: SECTIONL PETTONER (This section is about you. It must be completed; however, if you require that your address be ‘confidential for safety reasons, you should complete and file a Request for Confidential Filing of Address, Florida Supreme Court Approved Family Law Form 12.980{h), and write confidential in the space provided on this form for your address and telephone number.) 4. Petitioner resides atthe following address (addres, city, state, zipcode) HW. EL +89 {Indicate If applicable} Petitioner seeks an injunction for protection on behalf ofa minor child Petitioner i the parent or legal guardian of {full legal name} ' minor child who is living at home. N/A 2. Patton atoms name, adres, and telephone numberis__PONE {if you do not have an attorney, write "none.") ‘SECTION. RESPONDENT (This section is about the person you want to be protected from. it must be completed.) 1. Respondent resides at the following address: {provide last known street address, city, state, and 2ip code} UNKNOWN a Florida Supreme Court Approved Family Law Form 12,980), Petition for Injunction for Protection Against Stalking (ays)2. Respondent’ lst known place of employment: __UW/ Kalo WAL Employment address: Working hours of Respondent: 3. Physical description of Respondent: pace: Wl_sex: M_mate_@ Female C) oat oth: inl KO 1 Heich()5“7weignt: 120 tye Color:__ Hair Colo Distinguishing marks and/or scars: Vehicle: (make/model) Color: Tag Number (if known), UNKWOW N 4, Other names Respondent goes by (aliases or nicknames): 5. Respondent's attorney's name, address, and telephone numberis:__ Lu a(S OW NC (Ifyou do not know whether Respondent has an attorney, write “unknown.” If Respondent does not have an attorney, write "none.") ‘SECTION Ill. CASE HISTORY AND REASON FOR SEEKING PETITION (This section must be completed.) 1. Has Petitioner ever received or tried to get an injunction for protection against stalking against Respondent in this or any other court? OQ, ves @ No tyes, what happened in that case? fInclude case number, if known} 2. Has Respondent ever received or tried to get an injunction for protection against stalking ‘against Petitioner in this or any other court? -Q ves Pio tyes, what happened in that case? {Include case number, if known} 3. Describe any other court case that is either going on now or that happened in the past between Pettioner and Respondent fide ase umber, known). A/D ALE Florida Supreme Court Approved Family Law Form 12.980(t), Petition for Injunction for Protection Against Stalking (1/35)4 Petitioner isa victim of stalking because Respondent has: (please mark all sections that apply} ‘Committed stalking; b reviously threatened, harassed, stalked, cyberstalked, or physically abused the Petitioner; c ‘Threatened to harm Petitioner or family members or individuals closely associated ‘with Petitioner; d. Intentionally injured or killed a family pet; e Used, or threatened to use, against Petitioner any weapons such as guns or knives; f. __AZZA criminal history involving violence or the threat or violence, if knows e ‘Another order of protection issued against him or her previously from another Jurisdiction, if known; h, Destroyed personal property, including, but not limited to, telephones or other ‘communication equipment, clothing, or other items belonging to Petitioner. Below is a description of the specific incidents of stalking or cyberstalking: {for cyberstalking, please include a description of al evidence of contacts and/or threats made by Respondent in Voice messages, texts, emails, or other electronic communication} On {dates} the following incidents of stalking occurred at the following locations: {the locations! may include, but need not be limited to, a home, school, or place of employment} 6 Please indicate here if you are attaching additional pages to continue these facts. ‘Additional formation JK SOW AV Respondent owns, has, and/or is known to have guns or other weapons. Describe weapon(s) and where they may be located, if known: Florida Supreme Court Approved Family Law Form 12.980(t), Petition for injunction for Protection Against Stalking, (35)IR Infopath Form - 17-130 HARASSMENT 2017-03-22 Page 1 of 2 CAMPUS SAFETY DEPARTMENT - ROLLINS COLLEGE ROLLINS GENERAL REPORT Case #4 17-130 Dae cle as Drie Oar Deri Rese — wesnany | 94017 ack eco agra Lesion: on een tl ecu ae Sera of Repo: Cornell Social Science/ CSS 0900 Oves Ono sano iin TS [Bae Omer sex ae a ojo Select] es Fegan Number ape 75 [Bade Oar [ea Tage Maal Foon oO | @ [Grnan im [onero96 hades: Fepioe Rumi 7 Clenenne Way Orandn FSIAT9 rani lateobot:_ [J "7 [CL Frurther tnvestigation Reg: [CD [Poti Report #: |Res-Life Notified: | Cl |Res-Life Otcer: [Time: Hate Crime: Disposition: Select. Nera Oe Wedel Mach 317d acnaralon wi Por uta Cops ile ce ut sone Conring enor en oft sen Maral Poaon Dreyer oneaten Potccoriaat haeraarae ieee | itcge i Foaon whew qe chalzglggunenaive an drupe aome singin cnet er scent he syed fap at td dept Ses word wal hea ed owe welders hs beeps owed erst pneay oer sas mia Folon er is re td st Profesa Za an ems on Tusa, Mar 9330pm tn tiem son vasgote | cial o oecn Zt heriooncigr te esses er resorts asa a ear the | mal carge ever cay end see: Boon he nfreten tod sgufsteonen Se ee goon ont ked bt AD Mees uke sn te Proyan Deco De Cook stn ene scouts ong ha td Cok me it Pokion uso cso nf! on eaon bu esas ut ss ered rtsone of tected comments Pun mate nd how he css ede nce behest cy men Sn |grade she assigned him. | 1 love w external cicunstances andthe ting of Spring Break, | was not bl to speak with olson before the scheduled break My | Inca wast flow op irs tahoe resumed on esa ara | Ken Miter to pee] sano Az Dates a BirstrApprout Ni Dan A | omeclQ OY” [posal [Pitts KT Provert hutps:/frshare.rollins.edu/sites/Campus_Safety/_layouts/15/Print.FormServer.aspx. 37232017IR Supplement Form - 17-130 501Supp2 2017-03-22 Page 1 of 2 CAMPUS SAFETY DEPARTMENT ROLLINS ROLLINS COLLEGE REPORT SUPPLEMENT [case #: [17-130 late: _| 3722/2017 leace w: [2 Fowwis:[ Micowmusnioxor oon Classisrnc orricens nevowr _ C)INVESTIGATIVE SUPPLEMENT ‘Clery: C1 Geography: Hate Crime: C7 Disposition: Cleared |On Saturday, March 18, 2017, we received an email from a student, QBNNENM Who slated that she hed concerning interactions with Polston. She shared that before Spring Break, Polston conffonted her about not accepting his "friend" request on Facebook and alleged thatthe reason was due to his political views. SMB stated that she did not see the request and would accept it. On the morning of Saturday, March 18, she received a Facebook messenger message from Polston that was confusing and threatening. WMI wanted to share this information with us before she returned to campus so that we could take the appropriate steps to ensure her safety and address the issue As students retuned from Spring Break on Monday, March 0, I was able tohave a conversation with Polson concerning both situations. During our meting, he shred the general frustration with Profesor Zufari and some of the challenges he had in her class. We ultimately spoke about the email he sent her on Wareh'. Afier some time, while he stated that he didnot confi Rer or ry to CRATE her ea, he dd as structed by stain the Hot School and sent her an email, We discussed the appropriateness of the email and Polson shared that he was frustrated withthe grade, didnot think he could bring the overall grade up, and decided to are NOW He RET Ter Wi er He conceded the email was not professional, consistent withthe values ofthe campus community, or consistent with his stated goal of excelling scademically and graduating fom Rollins. We also discussed the message he sent to Ismail, which he seemed to not remember sending. shared with him a copy ofthe mesage and he didnot recall sending it, but did acknowledge frustration over the original rend request being denied and his conversation with mStar Spring Brea Feuonsagsscd at whee was tavcng i Fence over Spang Ree one possible that he ether sent the message while intoxicated or friends that he was with may have wed his phone and sen the message from his account. shared with him that ultimately, he was responsible forthe message since om his account and, combined with the previous conversation, it seemed very reasonable that he was sl stated ith Pease see attached emails and messages. REPORTING OFFICER: AME: _ [Ken Miller [ono. [so IGNATURE: | [SUPV. SIGNATURE: [PIR SIGNATURE: I hitps:/share.rollins.edu/sites/Campus_Safety/_layouts/15/Print. FormServer.aspx 3/23/2017From: Ken Miller Sent: Wednesday, March 08, 2017 9:54 AM To: ‘Meghan Harte Weyant; Maeghan Rempala; David Tellera; Meribeth Huebner; Nick Georgoudiou ce: Gabriel Barreneche; Mamta Accapadi; Maria Martinez Subject: Marshall Polston Good morning all. So quick recap —my apologies to those of you who already heard part ofthis, ‘This morning, Professor Zufari came into the CS office, looking pretty shaken. She started speaking with Becca about a student, Marshall Polston, who isin her Middle East Humanities class on Thursdays. She shared that he has been disruptive, argumentative, and overall pretty creepy since the start of the term. She sald that she shared this with Holt ‘administrative offices and that Meribeth and David met with him about two weeks ago, where “the fear of god was placed into him”. However, he had to turn a paper in recently, which she graded to be a 50%. She has not given him the ‘paper yet — tomorrow, but is afraid of his reaction. She wanted CS present, usto have her phone number, and since he doesn’t bring anything to class ~ laptop, backpack, etc, if he came to class with a backpack, she Is running out of the class. | spoke with her, got her calmed down, got her information about RAVE Guardian, told her CS would be in the area during the class, etc. She then shared that since she teaches Middle Eastern classes, she has some contacts with the FBI and shared the students name with them. They stated that he has had previous problems at UF dealing with similar Issues. We ended the conversation on good terms and | told her that | would work through our support services folks to see how we can help her further and to see what else we could find out. | eft 2 VM with Nick G. to see what was on his application and did he disclose anything. ' spoke with David T. and he shared more about the conversation he and Meribeth had with the student. | shared this information with Penelope so he could be included in CARE teamnotes, ' called folks that | know up at UF PD and received the following information: —— Pow (oud = -Gurrently has holds on his accounts due to incomplete sanctions aeks = _ Is currently on a deferred suspension until December 2017 Volenes. - Had confrontational issues with others at UF and went through their Conduct office There isan active investigation involving his behavior towards a female student (Title IK?) While he has not been violent, he does have a track record and we do have a very scared faculty member. ‘Anecdotally, Professor Zufari had an issued when she taught a RCL class last semester. The person in her class supposedly belonged to and ant-slamic group and specifically joined her class to cause problems. Also, Polston has an ‘Arabic language class that meets M-H and is taught by Professor £1 Hamouly ~is he displaying the same behavior in that class? Can we follow up with her to see what his behavior in that class is? Happy Wednesday. Best.Ken Mi From: Meribeth Huebner Sent: ‘Thursday, March 09, 2017 4:31 PM To: Ken Miller Subject: FW: Essay Grade Ken, do you have a moment to discuss this situation? My number is 497-691-1349. Sorry for a second email. I am reading the email rather then skimning over it as I did earlier. And I want security. I want the equivalent of a restraining order. I don't want him anywhere near me, Aree} Zufari From: Areeje Zufari Date: Thursday, March 9, 2017 at 3:56 PM ‘To: Tom Cook, Meribeth Huebner ‘Subject: Fwd: Essay Grade | think this email pretty much confirms he needs to be removed from the class. choose not to respond. So Dr. Cook, Fm {gonna leave this one to you. ‘Areej Zufari Begin forwarded message: From: Marshal Polston ‘Date: March 9, 2017 at 3:50:10 PM EST To: "[email protected]" Subject: Essay Grade ‘We need to talk as soon as possible over phone or in your office because you have been extremely unfair to ‘me and pursuit @ ruthless program of hostility in your recent grading simply due to the fact that | disagree with you on your inherent bias and clandestine theological apologies. 'mactvallya nice person but not when ''m viciously attacked. I'd be just as happy to go to the dean about this issue. ''m emalling you about the first essay in your Rollins class. You recently falled me with a 52% despite the fact ‘that! followed all the guidelines listed, covered all the topics and asked you directly about the problem areas. | specifically asked you about sources in person as a result of your request that the paper be an analysis and ‘ot research. Everything | wrote came from personal memory and research or first hand experience in my travels with the government, personal visits with friends, teaching experiences or philanthropic efforts in the Middle East. ‘Quite frankly the grade you assigned to me exposes your a true agenda which isto sllence me in cass. As told you before I'm not interested in speaking anymore. But since you've decided to carry a blitzkrieg out ‘against me | may have to speak up in regards to your extreme bias and not necessarily to the class but to the dean. You're one of the most incompetent professors | have ever seen inmy entice life, 1It’s very dear you have absolutely no idea what you're talking belongiina reform schoo! First ou conflate the immaculate conception and the virgin birth which are totally different. Then you state that middle eastern Jews were Sephardic when infact they are mostly Mizrahi. Sephardic Jews only temigrated from Spain to North Africa and istanbul and we're NEVER native, 1 could goon and on and’on. Everybody knows that you're a failure asa Professor ~ Rest assured Fm not the ‘only onelll Ihave dozens of examples to pull from that I've noticed during the class | thinkit’s great to be a theological apologist but not in a secular setting ~ | don't know whether this was just is mistake or not sol give you the benefit of the doubt. In order to stop a textual embarrassment in the ‘Quran from coming to light in class you proceeded to ignore the facts when asked a pertinent question Spout Mohemmed. He had an adopted son which divorced his wife so he could marry him and although you finally admitted it was twisted, ittook until! looked up the verse that you believed me. ‘Your bias is blatantly evident in your misinformation about the historical Jesus and moreover manifested in the lack of discussion about Wellhausen’s documentary hypothesis (with you taking the theological position ‘that Moses wrote the first five books of the Torah). No one takes either postion that you gave in the archaeological or secular biblical fields. session about sharia law at the United States of Rolins ignores what the vast majority Egypt and iraq realy believe in regards to misogyny, homophobia or religious .org/2013/04/30/the-worlds-muslims-reliion-poits-society-beli sharia | agree that sharia law can be reformed but n the context ofthe seventh century [e's not jump to utopian ‘conclusions about sharia law's original implementation in society. I understand that you are much more Toeral Muslim which is great but qute frankly it astonishes me your hypocrisy. On the ane hand you report ne to the dean for correcting you while you were indoctrinating students with fase information. On the ‘ther hand a Muslim student in lass cracks a joke about chopping someone's body parts off and you do thing Yes | have witnesses ~ I'm not the only one who has a concern about your agenda and over bias It's really cowardly of you to shut me down in the middle of class oF le tothe dean but | should be careful when saying that because that would be insulting to cowards. ‘There's something seriously wrong and depraved about you when you think my intellectual conversation is hore threatening than the dispicable comments about decapitation made by the student in question! SICK! hope we don't have to escalate this isue and you'l stop this crusade against me. would really hate to get in contact with some national media personalities that I'm good friends with but 'm going to have to take it there or pursue legal options if you don't stop your harassment toward me.Ken Miller frome Roath ves) Sent: Thursday, March 09, 2017 10:56 PM To: Ken Miller Subject: Marshall Polston hesocti ake Bean's deport ‘Before the 6:45 class tonight, Professor Zufari emailed me and told me she would not step foot on campus as long as Marshall was going to be there and that she wanted something lke a restraining order. | spoke with Dean Weyant, who told me she ‘could pull together a Beta team meeting asap, and we agreed that | would cancel class since the teacher wasn't coming. It was 100 late to notify students before arriving to class. Dr. Cook (program director) and I planned to come to the class in person. | arrived at the class about 10 minutes early, and ‘campus safety was already there. | spoke with Fernando abit and then went to the class to let the students know that class ‘was cancelled, Marshall was not there yet. The students seemed surprised but nothing unusual. Two of them stayed in the classroom for a few minutes and discussed their essay grade. It seemed like neither of them did well, but they were not disgruntled or upset. One male student said he was okay with his grade because he knew It wasn't his best work. The other ‘guy commented that he knew she would be tough, but she was sure “one tough cookie.” They didn’t seem upset or overly frustrated by the scores, yet one of them had a fairly low grade. | decided to walt ouside of he classroom and at 646, Dr. Cook arrived, We wate for awhile and chatted andalitl after oso, campus safety eh. Or. Cook and were about to leave when I saw Marshal come tothe dassoom, He realized no ‘one was there and didn’t enter the classroom but he also saw me sitting thére and asked, "Tguess you are here for me?” 1 told him was there to cancel cass forthe profssr, and Rat yes, wos there fr him and that tried cali ear to discuss hw he handled his grade dspute. We aed fora whl, ond explained to him there were better ways to handle disogrement. He mentioned several mes how ts evidence of bia gars im because a fundamentlt musim student in floss talked about chopping of hands and di get in trouble, but he, Marshal disagrees wth the professor and gts in trouble, Herglatd to the idea tat he'd mentioned bringing gun to school or sooting someone Inthe tg he would have gotten Ta Hoable- He mentioned Ue gun example a couple ot ins and aus ats abou Hs Tends ars pir school, “who were Mormans and went to church; $6 they Weren't going to do anything wrong,” got arrested because they were cwerheard talking about gurs, and yet the profesor dt complain abou the stm gy inclss who talked about choping aft hands and heeds, He mentioned that he has lao musim ends, but they ae bral musi, ad that thee are good tones and bd ones just ike with Cision. He aimed to have tied fundamentalism (or something) for 15 years soe Knows what staking about. He said hc has seen peopl without hands in themida east Iwas basal ust alto talk onand on. ‘At no point did he threaten anyone openly, but | was very uncomfortable by his continued reference to guns, generalized ‘categories of people by religion, and his obvious nervousness and GistaNt for the promessor and the muslim student in class, although he also said he thought the professor was a very “good” Pron. The example about chopping off hands was mentioned rumeros tines whch wa interesting becute Dr.Cokhappned a ein das forth emda take ‘the comments by the muslim student inthe same way as did MaTShal Marshall said his email directly tothe professor was what David Telleria and | had asked him to do if he questioned something about the professor, but that is not what we told him. We told him that fhe hadissues or concerns with her to not confront her and to come to us. The professor was already upset by his behavior and further confrontation was only going to make things worse. He didn’t seem to understand that his email was not an appropriate way to resolve his disagreement wit the grade he recel corte Paper. Fe Iso sae tat te rreW Tad to Side with the professor, and informed him that was not ‘true, and that we have appropriate ways of expressing disagreement with a professor and that we could schedule an appointment for the following morning to talk through his options. I wanted to de-escalate the situation at ths point. He told us that he’s never experienced anything like this before, and that he findsit odd that both times he's had an issue (meeting with me and David Telleriaa few weeks ago and then this), she cancels class. He said that makes it clear that she is‘overreacting. BETA|s at noon tomorrow, and the appointment time Is at 11:00. I'm going to try to reschedule him for later so BETA has time to meet first. remember anything else from the conversation, I'l forward that 2s well. ‘Meribeth Huebner, Associate Dean Hamilton Holt Schoo! Rollins College [email protected](Fr (Orlando Heals Internal Medicine Faculty Practice 2 W. Cokumbia St Suite 201 ORLANDOLEALTH1 Orlando, F1.82405 ww 2aLsAloas ta ‘edandohealh.com Date: March 2, 2017 Areeje Zufari DOB: 4/20/74 To Whom It May Concern; This letter is to certify that this patient is under my care for all medical issues and at present, it should be noted that she is experiencing a significant flare of her fibromyalgia of which seems to be related to the ‘situation at her work surrounding security and student issues. Furthermore, it seems that these issues are also resulting in the recurrence of her PTSD of which is complicating her fibromyalgia flare. If there should be any questions, concerns, or need for clarification, please do not hesitate to call my office and we can discuss the matter further. Thank you. in, MD, MPH, FACP. Orlando Health Internal Medicine Faculty Practice Internal Medicine Clerkship Director and Clinical Assistant Professor Florida State University College of Medicine, Orlando Campus @ ORLANDO REGIONAL MEDIC C28: HEN FOR CH © MD ANDERSON CANCER Cent Pasacats Hosen4/3 From: Areeje Zutari Sent: Friday, February 3, 2017 8: To: Tom Cook Subject: Problem student Dear Dr. Cook, Thave a disruptive student in my class. His name is Marshall Polston. He has disrupted class twice now (we have only had 2 classes) with antagonizing interjections, contradicting me, and monopolizing dass time. His attitude is contemptuous. Even after my attempt to darify what I expect in the classroom, he continued disregarding other students’ class time by interrupting and interjecting. I can provide you with more details below. But the Important point here is I do not want this student in my class. Please let me know the procedure for removing this student from my class. I spoke with him before class last night, 2/2, to clarify my problem with his behavior, but rather than respond to my questions regarding his interjections, he continued his argument from the previous week. There was no response to my ‘questions addressing classroom behavior and civil disagreement. When I ‘emphasized with the words, "Right now, I want to know how you and I are going to go forward this semester." He turned and walked away and said the word for “fine” in Arabic. ass began, and he continued antagonizing and repeatedly interrupting me. really appreciate your help. Aree} 407-310-1198 Areej Zufari Professor of Humanities ‘Coordinator- Humanities Speakers SeriesAd ning Pb on Wapen ante BE ye From: Merbeth Husbner MHUEENER@ cine cau © Subjct: Marahall Polson ato: February 8, 2017 at 733 PM "Tr Tom Cook TeookRling edu, Are] Zula AZUFARI@ Ring eas Hi Aree) and Tom. We spoke with Marshall today about his behavior in class. He has agreed to modify his behavior so that he is not disruptive and that if he has alternative ideas that he wants to present, to do so in a more appropriate manner, including after class, email, or during pre-arranged ‘meeting times with the professor. ‘Tom, we did not tell him that you would be attending class this week, but Iam sure he will guess as to why you are there. ‘Areej, please know that you have the right to ask a student to leave your class if that student is being disruptive and/or causing undue interference with your teaching/classroom management. If the student refuses to leave, please call security. 407.646.2999 of x2999 Let me know how class goes and if there is any improvement. Perhaps we can talk on Friday? Meribeth Huebner Associate Dean Hamilton Holt School Rollins College.aaa Aw of ax goer oO have not noticed security coming by. Are the officers still checking in? ‘we Thank you all, Areej Aree) Zufari Professor of Middle of Middle Eastern Humanities Rollins College 407-310-1198 From: David Telleria Sent: Wednesday, February 22, 2017 9:26:21 PM ‘To: Meribeth Huebner; Areej Zufari Ce: Tom Cook Subject: Re: Marshall Hello Areej, Ifyou can please give us a summary of the next class as well. Ifneeded we may have to intervene again, especially if other students are cutting Marshall off. ‘Thanks, David Telleria Director of Student Services Rollins College 407.646.1938 From: Ares} Date: Wednesday, February 22,2017 at 3: 16 PM ‘To: Meribeth Huebner Ce: Tom Cook Subject: Re: Marshall think your talk with him made an impact. He was very controlled and almost looked scared and nervous in class. But he definitely restrained himself and his comments and questions ‘were appropriate. ‘Thanks again for your help, Aree} Areej Zufari On Feb 22, 2017, at 1:54 PM, Meribeth Huebner wrote: How did last Thursday go with Marshall? Meribeth Huebner Hamilton Holt School Rollins College mbuebner@rollins eFrom: Aree Zul AZUFARI@Rotins 2s ‘Subject: Re: Marshal ‘Date; March 2017 at 557 PM "To: Merbth Hustner HHUEENERGRoins adv, David Tteria OTELLERIAG Palin a (Ce: Tom Cook Teook@ Robins oe ‘The class has been really great the last two weeks. I think I have relaxed and we are further into the content, so the students have more questions really good, hard ones. The first essay is due this week, so I will get a chance to evaluate students’ work more closely. ‘Take care, Aree} Aree) Zufari Professor of Middle of Middle Eastern Humanities Rollins College ‘AzZufari@Rollins. edu 407-310-1198 From: Meribeth Huebner Sent: Sunday, March 05, 2017 10:23:07 PM To: Areej Zutari; David Telleria. ‘Tom Cook ‘Subject: Re: Marshall ‘Campus safety is available if you need them to be. 1 made them aware of the concerns, but | did not ask them to come by your class regularly. | believe they are waiting for you to ask for assistance beyond the intial concerns, if you need it. However, I'm not sure there is anything we can do or say about what you describe. It sounds as if Marshall didn't do anything and none of the students complained. David, what do you think about just reaching out to Marshall to see how things are going from his perspective? We should probably do that anyway. ‘Thanks for staying in touch about the class, Aree). Other than that, how is the class going? Is. everything else going well? Any other concems at all? Meribeth Huebner Hamilton Holt School Rollins College [email protected] 407-691-1349, From: Areej Zufari Date: Sunday, March 5, 2017 at 5:13 PM ‘To: David Telleria, Meribeth Huebner (Ce: Tom Cook Subject: Re: Marshall Hello all, Last Thursday night's class was interesting, Marshall arrived about 30 minutes late. And in the time he was not present, I found students more engaged and enjoying themselves. When he arrived, our discussion continued, but he did participate whatsoever. aso noticed that the female student Dr. Cook noticed Marshall was speaking with sat on the ‘opposite side of the room with no empty seats around her. Before last Thursday, she always WaFrom: Area Zee Azvsrisrotins ody ‘Subject: cue update ‘Date: Marc 7, 2017 at 5:42 PM “To: Meroe Huebner muster rong ed, Tom Cook Teook@ Rating es Dear Dean Huebner and Ot. Cook, [hough i was relevont fol you know that Ihave jst graded Marshal's ist essay, and he received 26/50 points. The ‘swe wilh his paper was thal i rombed and txonched of info too many cfferen lonics withou! lect, coherent focus, | want fo keep you informed of what he grade and that he igh be upset {ko would appreciae If you did fake a auick ook 0 s00 | was objective based on my citer. lam attaching he FOF of his paper with my comments sing Tumi. Lam vary wave of FERPA laws anc am shaing this lefermation ont with you. ‘am ako copying bebo the information that war given fo skudents The end of he document includes my utc fr assessment with my comments. {hope Lom not wasting your Hime. But do think there's the posslty he wil complain about his grade there is any contention about his grade, may Irefer him lo one of you rather han engaging wih i Thank you for youre Aree Qdays \ater - 3- 4 - ow Swoeeind Sweeter We neous, omad - TECHN..2.pdf Inirveton on Backboard: Essay 1 instructions @ ¥ Sa ‘The impact of lslam on the Middle East. ‘Analyze how Islam impacted Middle Eastern culture and/or society during the Medieval Era (800-1200) focusing on 3 specific examples. Examples include: law, women's rights, standards of ving, architecture, visual art, titerature, etc. ‘Morality and religion are obvious. f you want to discuss these aspects, delve into a particular facet in depth, This is an analysis paper-NOT a research paper. Analyze your 3 examples using primary ‘sources and your knowledge of the topic. ‘Your paper must be in MLA format. Insivictionsin the Coune Sybabus: Analy Exc: Each essay will be assigned on a specific topic. The information will be posted in Blackboard. Essays are due by submission through Blackboard by midnight of the due date. I suggest you go to the writing center at least one time duting this process. Papers that have been through the writing center process always tum out to be better papers. The writing center is located in the Olin Library. All essays must be typed, double spaced, 12-point font, and proofed for ‘rammar, spelling, coherence, etc. Please use MLA style for writing vour paper{see hitp://owLenglsh purdue.edu/owl/resource/557/01/ if you plagiarize your paper, it will fail and you will fail the class. You will be turned in to the honor council.FRIDAY 3/)3 REPORT fom navpetantn a que: Subject: ‘Date: March 33, 2017 at 152 PM To: Keath @ Malmos kmakmoevaloncacaege edu, reenzulan@ao\com, abuoravameer@ao| con Groat news! Bul please keep emall privat, ‘ree! Duo Begin lowarded message: fram Ton Cook ane ia J vwerined forrabentna, ena Date: arch 12 2017 at 11208 OT efi cals iaencaseneaa Oo 3 14 sl? __ pobre Soucy Book The big committee met late on Friday, and while they did not dismiss Marshall from the College, they did remove him from your class. I think he will have the ‘opportunity to complete some version of the dass by independent study if he so chooses (details yet to be decided). Needless to say, you will not be called upon to participate in that in any way. The main thing ~- in terms of our concem about the dass moving forward and learning something ~ is that he will no longer be a student in your class. I am very glad to see that result, and hope that you are as well. If he wants to complain further about his paper grade, he will have to take it up with me or with the Dean, Hi, Areej, May this be the end of the distractions and disturbances, and may the class Proceed smoothly, learning about and celebrating the arts of the Middle East. Hope you're enjoying the week off from the Rollins class. Are you guys on break at Valencia as well? Peace,. Re: Marshall Polston--Urgent gx “y oy Le From: Areej Zufari [email protected] To: Meribeth Huebner [email protected], Tom Cook [email protected] Date: Wednesday, March 22, 3:54 PM 'have just been contacted by a central Florida journalist who wants a comment from me. He texted my cell phone with this: Specifically - Id like to know if you reported some very serious remarks made by a student about sharia law and advocating violence towards gays, those who commit adultery, etc. And were you aware that it made several students feel extremely uncomfortable? Do you think it was appropriate not to swiftly denounce such hate speech considering what happened at Pulse and today’s events from radical muslim extremists? (Dr. Cook, this would be the class you observed. The class on Islamic law.) This is evidence of Poiston carrying out his threat. | urgently need to know what steps the college is __ taking to address Polson and the journalist and my safety. Areej Zufari | Professor of Humanities From: Areej Zufari [email protected] To: [email protected] Date: Wednesday, March 22, 3:56 PM | Aree) Zufari Professor of Humanities From: Meribeth Huebner [email protected] To: Tom Cook [email protected], Areej Zufari [email protected] Date: Wednesday, March 22, 4:06 PM /Areej, you are under no obligation to respond to media. | am reporting this to the appropriate people at Rollins. 1/4” Meribeth Huebner, Associate Dean | Hamilton Holt Schoot Rollins College [email protected] 407-691-1349 From: Areej Zufari [email protected] To: Meribeth Huebner [email protected] Date: Wednesday, March 22, 4:08 PM Got it. Thanks. ‘Areej Zutari | Professor of Humanities From: Meribeth Huebner [email protected] To: Areej Zufari [email protected] Ce: Tom Cook [email protected] Date: Wednesday, March 22, 4:15 PM You will ikely hear from Ken Miller who will probably want the phone number, name of the journalist, and screen Shot. | am really sorry about all ofthis. You should not have to endure this kind of behavior, Meribeth Huebner, Associate Dean Hamilton Holt Schoo! Rollins College [email protected] From: Areej Zufari azufari@rollins. edu To: Meribeth Huebner [email protected] Cc: Tom Cook [email protected] Date: Wednesday, March 22, 4:18 PM 2/4Great. Here is the number +1(231) 360-1411 You know | would almost be laughing if | could summon the humor. In my real life I'm actually a Pretty boring person. Areej Zufari From: Meribeth Huebner [email protected] To: Aree) Zufari [email protected] Ce: Tom Cook [email protected] Date: Wednesday, March 22, 4:21 PM Hmm... 'm not sure that is a reporter's number. Did he ‘Say who he was and who he was with? Meribeth Huebner, Associate Dean Hamilton Holt School Rollins College ‘[email protected] 407-691-1349 From: Meribeth Huebner [email protected] To: Areej Zufari [email protected] Date: Wednesday, March 22, 4:24 PM Jacob Engel? Meribeth Huebner, Associate Dean Hamilton Holt School Rollins College [email protected] 407-691-1349 From: Areej Zufari [email protected] To: Meribeth Huebner [email protected] 3/4Date: Wednesday, March 22, 4:28 PM Yes. This is his introduction: This is Jacob Engels with the Central Florida Post. I'm investigating some dangerous remarks made during one of your classes on deadline. Please call or text if you care to comment ! received this text now too: So that is no comment? School officials have been notified. Do you approve of those comments and think they have a place in your classroom or on campus at all? Areej Zufari Professor of Humanities From: Tom Cook [email protected] To: Meribeth Huebner [email protected], Areej Zufari [email protected] Date: Wednesday, March 22, 8:01 PM "Hi, Areej, _I'm entirely in agreement with Meribeth -- that you have no Obligation to communicate with any reporters. On the substance of the matter: Yes, | was present in that class, and | do not recognize the description in the "reporter's" text as depicting any event that | witnessed. The description seems to me a thoroughly twisted version of what seemed to me a Pretty innocuous exchange, possibly intended to be light-hearted. But in any case, certainly not "hate speech.” Glad to hear that Ken is going to address it. Let me now if | can help. Tom 10 Emails 4/4SECTION IV. INJUNCTION. {This section must becompleted} Petitioner asks the Court to enter a TEMPORARY INJUNCTION for protection against stalking that will be in place from now until the scheduled hearing in this matter, which will immediately restrain Respondent from committing any acts of stalking, and which will provide any terms the Court deems necessary for the protection of a victim of stalking, including any injunctions or directives to law enforcement agencies. 2. Petitioner asks the Court to enter, after a hearing has been held on this petition, a FINAL JUDGMENT for protection against stalking prohibiting Respondent from committing any acts of stalking against Petitioner and: ‘a. prohibiting Respondent from going to or within 500 feet of any place Petitioner lives, fr to any specified place regularly frequented by Petitioner and any named family member Se ee loca be Ff plysiced stalking . prohibiting Respondent from going to or within 500 feet of Petitioner's place(s) of ‘employment or the school that Petitioner attends; the address of Petitioner's places) of employment and/or schoo! is: LE WOK = prohibiting Respondent from contacting Petitioner by telephone, ma writing, through another person, or in any other manner; by e-mail, in d. ordering Respondent that he or she shall not have in his or her care, custody, possession, or control any firearm or ammunition; prohibiting Respondent from knowingly and intentionally going to or within 100 feet of Petitioner’s motor vehicle, whether or not that vehicle is occupl 3. Petitioner asks the Court to enter any other terms it deems necessary to protect Petitioner from stalking by Respondent, Florida Supreme Court Approved Family Law Form 12.980(t), Petition for Injunction for Protection Against Stalking ays)UNDERSTAND THAT BY FILING THIS PETITION, | AM ASKING THE COURT TO HOLD A HEARING ON ‘THIS PETITION, THAT BOTH THE RESPONDENT AND I WILL BE NOTIFIED OF THE HEARING, AND THAT | MUST APPEAR AT THE HEARING. | UNDERSTAND THAT IF EITHER THE RESPONDENT OR | FAIL TO APPEAR AT THE FINAL HEARING, WE WILL BE BOUND BY THE TERMS OF ANY INJUNCTION OR ORDER ISSUED AT THAT HEARING. | HAVE READ EVERY STATEMENT MADE IN THIS PETITION AND EACH STATEMENT IS TRUE AND CORRECT. | UNDERSTAND THAT THE STATEMENTS MADE IN THIS PETITION ARE BEING MADE UNDER PENALTY OF PERJURY, PUNISHABLE AS PROVIDED IN SECTION 837.02, FLORIDA STATUTES. Dated: (24 |4ore- AZ G ‘Signature of Pe STATE OF FLORIDA countvor_ ORANGE ‘Sworn to or affirmed and signed before me «3 2u H by Areete ———_ Personally known Produced identification ‘Type of identification produced £ LOL Florida Supreme Court Approved Family Law Form 22.980(t), Petition for injunction for Protection Against Staking. (avis)