International Journal of Innovative Research in Advanced Engineering (IJIRAE) ISSN: 2349-2163

Issue 03, Volume 4 (March 2017) www.ijirae.com

Design and Implementation of Hybrid Test Automation

Framework for Web Based Application
Sabastain Raju J, Vaidhehi V
Department of Computer Science, Christ University, Bangalore, India
Manuscript History
Number: IJIRAE/RS/Vol.04/Issue03/MRAE10097
Received: 07, March 2017
Final Correction: 20, March 2017
Final Accepted: 20, March 2017
Published: March 2017

Abstract -- There many ways to create Web application UI Test Automation Framework. This paper elaborates the creation
of the Hybrid Test Automation Framework, and explains the architecture and design of the framework. This Framework is
easy to use and incorporate the use of high level programming language allowing object oriented design, permits low level
access to the UL components and recover quickly for UI changes in the application under test. The architecture of the
framework as multi layer design which isolates the browser UI compounds and test scripts. This Framework Architecture is
a merged combination of Library and Data Driven Test Automation Framework. This Framework contents multi packages
with classes which isolates the reusable functions and involves the external database on fetching the data. In this
framework we can execute the same test case repeatedly in a loop to handle different test input which is retrieved from the
database.
Keywords Test Framework, Data driven Architecture, Library Test Architecture.

1. INTRODUCTION
In this paper we discuss about creating and overview of the architecture, design and implementation of a browser automatable
hybrid framework. The test framework is based on Library Architecture and Data Driven Architecture; both are simple and
effective architectures which are used for automation testing. Library Architecture framework are based on higher
implementation of Module Based Testing Framework, which is evolved after Module Based Testing Framework. Data Driven
Testing Framework helps the user separation of the test script code and the test input data from each other. It lets the user store
the test input data into a separate data file. Combination of both the framework would make am efficient and easy process to
automate a Web Based application using Selenium as the automation supporting tool.
The automation testing performed with the help of testing tools or some kind of programming languages to control the testing
class. The main idea behind automation testing is to automatically do the testing work without human interactions; it reduces
the cost and also makes testing more reliable and effective. Many tools are developed for this testing requirement.Selenium is
automation tool which supports the different way or approaches to test application. The entire suite of tools contains a rich set
of testing functions specifically for the needs of testing of web applications of all types. These operations are highly flexible,
having many options for locating UI elements and comparing expected test results against actual application behavior. One of
Seleniums features to support for executing ones tests on multiple browser platforms.
1.1 NEED OF TEST AUTOMATION
Software companies are not only required to test the software adequately, but also it is required to test thoroughly and quickly.
To perform this goal automation testing is needed. Manual testing is a time taken process and error prone, automation help to
overcome this drawback by running the test frequently increases confidence in the application. Execution the test cases will
also helps the user to understand the functionality. The set of automation tools can form a regression test suite. Automation
also helps in finding the problem in earlier stages and fixing it.
1.2 RELATED WORK
This section discusses various methods that have been used on creating the Hybrid Architecture; this section will also state the
related works which are done on different framework.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________
IJIRAE: Impact Factor Value SJIF: Innospace, Morocco (2016): 3.916 | PIF: 2.469 | Jour Info: 4.085 |
ISRAJIF (2016): 3.715
IJIRAE 2014- 17, All Rights Reserved Page -108
 International Journal of Innovative Research in Advanced Engineering (IJIRAE) ISSN: 2349-2163
Issue 03, Volume 4 (March 2017) www.ijirae.com

In [1], Chethan M. proposed a better framework approach then the Modular Based Testing Framework, He claimed using
Library Architecture Testing Framework is better as the code can be reused when saved in the methods or functions, the author
is also stated the advantages of using the Library architecture. In [2], Anbunathan, proposed Data Driven Architecture for
Android Mobile. He mentioned it is challenging task to generate Data Driven architecture. It required an external data base
provide input to the test scripts. In Data Driven the same test scripts are executed multiple times for different provided inputs.
They have explained the effectiveness of this method based on experimental result. In [3], Zeng Wandan, Jiang Ningkang,
Zhou Xubo, in this paper the author as introduce the new framework based on object feature set and dynamic searching policy,
using the obtained result it shows that the framework is more convenient and effective with less resources and time cost by
higher test coverage. [4] In the paper author Hari SankarChaini, have mentioned the process of test script design and execution
as well as failure analysis of the scripts. Author as also mentioned about the different failures which comes under false
positive.
II. LIBRARY ARCHITECTURE TESTING FRAMEWORK
Quality library architecture framework is very similar to the test script modularity structure and offers the same advantages, but
it splits the application-under-test into methods and functions (or items and methods with regards to the setup language) rather
than scripts. This kind of framework requires the creation of library files that represent modules, sections, and functions of the
application-under-test. These library files are then called directly from test case script. Many like script modularization this
framework also yields a high amount of modularization and adds to the overall maintainability of the testing. The basic
fundamental lurking behind the framework is to determine the common steps and group them into functions under a selection
and call those functions in the test intrigue whenever required [1].

Fig 1: Library Based Automation Framework

ADVANTAGES
Higher level of code reuse is achieved in Structured Scripting
It is less costly to develop as the higher code reusability achieved
Easier Script Maintenance
DISADVANTAGES
Technical expertise is required to write Scripts using Test Library Framework.
Time consuming to plan and prepare test scripts.
Test Data is hard coded within the scripts
III. DATA DRIVEN ARCHITECTURE FRAMEWORK
On automating or testing any application, sometimes it may be required to test the same functionality repeatedly multiple times
with the different set of input values. Thus, in such cases, we cant let the test data entered in the test script. Hence it is advised
to retain test data into some external data base or data files outside the test scripts. A data-driven framework is where test
input/output values are read from data files and are loaded into variables or manually coded scripts. In this framework,
variables are used for both input values and as well as output verification values. Navigation through the program, reading and
retrieving data from the data files, and loading of test status and information are all coded in the test script. This is similar to
table-driven testing in which the test case is containing in the data file and not in the script; the script is just a driver, or
delivery mechanism, for the data. In data-driven testing, only test data is contained in the data files [2].
ADVANTAGES
Less coding required as it covers all the possible combination of test scenario
Changes done on the test data will not affect the test scripts
Increases flexibility and maintainability
A single test scenario can be re executed with multiple test data
DISADVANTAGES
The process is complex and required additional efforts to create data sources and read mechanisms
______________________________________________________________________________________________________
IJIRAE: Impact Factor Value SJIF: Innospace, Morocco (2016): 3.916 | PIF: 2.469 | Jour Info: 4.085 |
ISRAJIF (2016): 3.715
IJIRAE 2014- 17, All Rights Reserved Page -109
 International Journal of Innovative Research in Advanced Engineering (IJIRAE) ISSN: 2349-2163
Issue 03, Volume 4 (March 2017) www.ijirae.com

Fig 2: DDA Based Test Automation Framework

IV. PROPOSED FRAMEWORK ON HYBRID ARCHITECTURE TESTING FRAMEWORK
In this section, architecture and design constraints of proposed Hybrid architecture based test automation framework is
discussed.
OVERVIEW OF THE HYBRID ARCHITECTURE TESTING FRAMEWORK
This Framework is being combination of Library Architecture and Data driven Architecture. This allows data driven scripts to
take advantage of the powerful libraries and utilities that usually accompany library architecture. The framework utilities can
make the data driven scripts more compact and less prone to failure than they otherwise would have been. The utilities can also
facilitate the gradual and manageable conversion of existing scripts. Here we have the function for each common step under a
common library and call it in the test scripts when ever required, it also contain the data file which provides the data from the
outside storage medium, like files, SQL or any data storage medium from which we can retrieve the data needed to test the
software.
ARCHITECTURE OF THE HYBRID FRAMEWORK
Hybrid framework is the existences of multiple frameworks forming one single framework. Here the library architecture is
merged with data driven architecture to form a hybrid architecture of the both architectures are very efficient in their own
ways.
Below is the description of the architecture flow.
FRAMEWORK FOLDER STRUCTURE

Fig 3: Folder Structure of Hybrid Framework

______________________________________________________________________________________________________
IJIRAE: Impact Factor Value SJIF: Innospace, Morocco (2016): 3.916 | PIF: 2.469 | Jour Info: 4.085 |
ISRAJIF (2016): 3.715
IJIRAE 2014- 17, All Rights Reserved Page -110
 International Journal of Innovative Research in Advanced Engineering (IJIRAE) ISSN: 2349-2163
Issue 03, Volume 4 (March 2017) www.ijirae.com

A. CUSTOM EXCEPTION FOLDER

This is a folder which contains the user defined exception class which extends the Exception class, which is mainly used to
handle the exception occurred at the time of execution. They are used to provide a simplified message for the users about the
errors occurred while executing. They are basically helps the users to understand the failure and for debugging effectively.
B. MAIN FOLDER
This folder contains the class which would call the XML file for evocation of the test scripts. They are TestNG xml file. This
can be used for setting the priority for test cases execution flow. They are the first class which would be executed.
C. OBJECT FOLDER
In this folder we have captured the various web elements or web element identifiers in the form of variables which can be
accessed in other places of the Framework.
D. REUSABLE FUNCTION FOLDER
The folder is constituted of the classes which contain functions and methods that can be shared and used amongst the multiple
classes. Very often, we are suppose to perform certain operation prior and before to the actual test execution like login to the
application, setting up environments, activities related to rolls, data manipulations, sending results, methods those perform
pre/post-conditions to other methods. Since we tend to perform these activities for all or most of the test script. Thus it is
always recommended to create a separate class for such activities instead of coding them repeatedly inside each of the test
script.
E. TEST CASES FOLDER
The "test" folder is constituted of majorly test suite and the folders representing the many modules of the software under test.
Thus, each of these folders is made up of the test scripts specific to the module that it is associated. Test suite is a logical blend
greater than one test scripts. Thus, the end user can mark an admittance of any of the test script within the test suite that he/she
wants to execute in the subsequent runs.
F. UTILITIES FOLDER
In this folder they are two classes one for the Read Properties which are having the code to read the properties file and send
the data to the test cases and as an input for the test steps, other is Properties file the static variables referencing to the paths
and other environmental details. These details can be Application URL, URL to the Databases, Credentials for Databases, and
URL to any third party tool being used. Properties class has the string data which would be accessed by the read properties
method.
G. REPORT FOLDER
[5] Reporting is the most important part of any test execution, as it helps the user understand the result of the test execution,
point of failure, and the reasons for failure. Logging, on the other hand, is important to know the execution flow or for
debugging in case of any failures. TestNG, by default, generates a different type of report for its test execution. This includes
an HTML and an XML report. TestNG also allows its users to write their own reporter and use it with TestNG. There are also
options to write your own loggers, which are notified at runtime by TestNG.
H. LIBRARY FOLDER
In the Library folder we have stored all the supporting jar files which are required by the project. These jar files are used by the
Java classes. [6] Jar files are in ZIP file format and is used for aggregating many files into one Jar. JARsare used as a general
archiving tools, the primary motivation for its development was so that Java applets and their components (.class files, images
and sounds) can be downloaded to a browser in a single HTTP instances, rather than opening a new connection for each time.
In our project we have used Selenium, TestNG Jars for accessing the functionality of these tools.
V. HYBRID ARCHITECTURE FRAMEWORK

Fig 4: Process flow for Hybrid Framework

______________________________________________________________________________________________________
IJIRAE: Impact Factor Value SJIF: Innospace, Morocco (2016): 3.916 | PIF: 2.469 | Jour Info: 4.085 |
ISRAJIF (2016): 3.715
IJIRAE 2014- 17, All Rights Reserved Page -111
 International Journal of Innovative Research in Advanced Engineering (IJIRAE) ISSN: 2349-2163
Issue 03, Volume 4 (March 2017) www.ijirae.com

Using Framework is it easy to structure our code and make maintenance quite easy. We would have placed out data and code
together which would rather be re usable nr readable without framework. Hence using the framework as provide various
benefits like code re-usage, higher portability, reduced script maintenance cost etc. In our Hybrid Framework, Firstly the
Main.class would be executed on calling the Main.class which calls the TestNG XML suite file, in which we have arranged the
order of testcase execution. When our first test case is been executed it would have the Predefined functions which are
retrieved from the Reusable function folder they are code which would be used in many places can be click event, enter the
text box value, select value from drop down box and many more. These function are been called in the Custom function, which
as the reusable functionality like login page, this class would contain the function which can be used for reusable
functionalities. They take the values from Object. class and Properties file. Object.class would have the variables of the web
element and where as Properties file would have the details of values which needed to enter like, application URL, Credentials
and etc,
On executing the test case if they are some error of failure occur in the execution flow they are indeed captured in the
CustomException.class. They are extending Exception.class and they are used to handle the exception which occurs in the
execution, they provide a meaning full message on every error which appears. On the completion of the execution finally the
report would be generated by the TestNG reporting feature [7]. TestNG, by default, generates multiple reports as part of its test
execution. These reports mainly include TestNG HTML report, TestNG email able report, TestNG report XML, and JUnit
report XML files. These files can be found under the output report folder

VI. CONCLUSION
Hybrid Framework is rugged, easy to implement, easy to use, easy to expand and easy to maintain. It is Technology and
Platform independent and it is also separate from the Test Design. Once it is created it improves the speed and maintainability
of automation Test Cases which uses the reusable libraries and reduces cost. In this paper we have explored the
implementation of Hybrid Test Automation Framework and the different advantages of independent architectures like Library
Architecture and Data Driven Architecture and how it can be effectively used during automation. We have also discussed
about the folder structure and the execution flow of the framework. The framework is easy to extended and maintain. In order
to support more complex tested cases, more kinds of applications will be researched in future work and it will also be checked
for mobile implementation. At the same time, the exception handling in testing will also be further researched and
implemented in more effective way.

REFERENCES
[1] Chethan M and Padma MC, Test Automation Framework on Library Architecture Department of Computer science &
Engineering, PES College of Engineering, Mandya
[2] Anbunathan R and AnirbanBasu, Data Driven Architecture Based Automated Test Generation for Android Mobile Test
Manager and Research Scholar, Bharathiar University Coimbatore, India
[3] Zeng Wandan, Jiang Ningkang, Zhou Xubo, Design and Implementation of a Web Application Automation Testing
Framework, Software institute of East China Normal University, Shanghai, China
[4] Hari SankarChaini and Dr. Sateesh Kumar Pradhan, Test Script Execution and Effective Result Analysis in Hybrid Test
Automation Framework, Department of Computer Science and Application Utkal University, Vani Vihar Bhubaneswar,
Odisha, INDIA
[5] CdricBeust, a senior software engineer at Google, about TestNG available at: http://testng.org/doc/documentation-
main.html
[6] ORACLE, Java Documentation about Jar files is https://docs.oracle.com/javase/8/docs/technotes/guides/jar/jarGuide.html
[7] TestNGtutorials for learning the usage of the toolhttp://www.tutorialspoint.com/testng/

______________________________________________________________________________________________________
IJIRAE: Impact Factor Value SJIF: Innospace, Morocco (2016): 3.916 | PIF: 2.469 | Jour Info: 4.085 |
ISRAJIF (2016): 3.715
IJIRAE 2014- 17, All Rights Reserved Page -112