Transient Analysis on Second Arc Current and

Recovery Voltage of UHV Series Compensated

Transmission Line
Zhang Yuanyuan, Ban Liangeng, Xiang Zutao, Han bin, Zheng bin, Ma wenyuan

Abstract-- State Grid Corporation of China plans to install At present, EHV series compensation system in China
series compensation on UHV transmission line in Changzhi- usually use "MOV parallel gap combination" as overvoltage
Nanyang-Jingmen UHV AC demonstration project of China in protection of series compensation as shown in Fig. 1. When
2011. When series compensated line occurs single-phase ground
the current or energy of MOV reaches the setting value, spark
fault, a low-frequency oscillation circuit is composed of series
compensation, shunt reactor and arc resistor of short-circuit gap will be forced to trigger and by-pass switch to close. The
point. And at the circumstance, residual charge on series fault-phase series compensation and MOV will be bypassed.
compensation discharges through the circuit, which increases low This protection strategy will be adopted in UHV series
frequency component to second arc and recovery voltage, compensation system.
extends extinguishing time to second arc, and also has influences
in single phase reclosing success rate. By using EMTP, this article
researched the transient second arc current and recovery voltage
of UHV series compensated line in Changzhi-Nanyang-Jingmen
UHV AC demonstration project, calculated the impact of fault
location and operation characteristics of UHV series
compensation protection such as MOV, spark gap and by-pass
switch. A linkage measure is also proposed in this article that by-
pass switch of fault-phase series compensation is commanded to
be closed while line protection monitors single-phase fault and
commands line breaker to trip.. Under this measure, the fault-
phase series compensation shall be bypassed during single phase
reclosing, thus the low frequency components of second arc Fig.1. The basis configuration of series compensation protected by MOV,
current and recovery voltage will quickly decay, and second arc spark gap and by-pass switch
extinguish faster. When a line occurs single-phase ground fault, second arc
1
current and recovery voltage of the faulty point should be
Keywords: UHV, series compensation, second arc current, limited to low level[1]. In this way, the second arc can
recovery voltage, linkage measure.
extinguish by itself and ensures single phase reclose. But
series compensation and its protections such as MOV, spark
I. INTRODUCTION
gap and by-pass switch, make the problem of second arc self-

U HV transmission technology is one of the cutting-edge

technologies in world power science. The put into
operation of Changzhi-Nanyang-Jingmen UHV AC
extinguishing more complicated. The research concentrated in
second arc current of series compensated transmission lines
has been carried out in domestic and foreign country. As a
demonstration project of China is a significant breakthrough result, the linkage measurement is proposed to be taken, which
for the countrys UHV transmission development, brought the is while line protection monitors single-phase fault and
country to the forefront of the world power transmission commands line breaker to trip, by-pass switch of fault-phase
technology. In order to develop transmission capacity of UHV series compensation is commanded to be closed.
AC line, State grid corporation of China plans to install series This paper uses EMTP to analyze the influence of second
compensation on Changzhi-Nanyang-Jingmen UHV line, as arc during single-phase ground fault and the characteristics of
the first case in the world. second arc under linkage measure after installation of series
compensation on Changzhi-Nanyang-Jingmen UHV line.
Zhang Yuanyuan, member of China Electric Power Research Institute
II. CHANGZHI-NANYANG-JINGMEN UHV AC SYSTEM
Haidian District Beijing 100192 China (e-mail:
[email protected]). CONDITION
Ban Liangeng, member of China Electric Power Research InstituteHaidian The system configuration of Changzhi-Nanyang-Jingmen
DistrictBeijing 100192China (e-mail: [email protected]). UHV AC demonstration project of China in 2012 is shown in
Xiang Zutao, member of China Electric Power Research InstituteHaidian Fig. 2. 1000kV bus voltage, transmission power, line length,
DistrictBeijing 100192China (e-mail: [email protected]). and shunt reactor capability have been marked in the figure.
 Changzhi-Nanyang and Nanyang-Jingmen lines have been low frequency component to second arc and recovery voltage,
installed 40% fixed series compensation. Series compensation and extends extinguishing time of second arc, which may lead
of Changzhi-Nanyang line has been installed on both sides of to failure in single phase reclose. So it is very necessary to
the line, and series compensation of Nanyang-Jingmen line is research the transient of second arc current and recovery
focused on Nanyang side as shown in Fig. 1. voltage for a line with series compensation.

Fig.3. The low-frequency oscillation circuit of series compensated

Fig.2. The sketch of Changzhi-Nanyang-Jingmen UHV AC system transmission system on the situation of single phase ground fault

A. Research condition
III. POWER FREQUENCY COMPONENT OF SECOND ARC CURRENT
In this paper, transient characteristics of UHV lines second
AND RECOVERY VOLTAGE
arc current and recovery voltage, are analysed under the
Power frequency components of second arc current and following three operation modes of series compensation, when
recovery voltage during single phase reclosing, are shown single-phase ground fault occurred along Changzhi-Nanyang
under the two situations of faulty-phase series compensation and Nanyang-Jingmen line.
with or without bypassing respectively by Tab. 1 and Tab.2 1) Series compensation do not bypass, expressed as SC not
In the two tables, Lcn represents Changzhi-Nanyang line, and bypassing in the following waveforms.
Lnj represents Nanyang-Jingmen line. 2) Series compensation permits bypass under consideration
Conclusion can be drawn from the comparision of Tab. 1 of series compensation protections such as MOV, spark gap
and 2 that fault-phase series compensation with or without and by-pass switch in Fig. 1, expressed as SC permitted
bypassing have little effect on power frequency components bypass in the following waveforms. Under this condition, if
of secondary arc current and recovery voltage. the current or energy of MOV reaches the setting value, spark
TABLE I
UNDER THE SITUATIONS OF FAULTY-PHASE SERIES COMPENSATION WITHOUT
gap will be forced to trigger and by-pass switch to close. The
BYPASSING, POWER FREQUENCY COMPONENT OF UHV LINES SECONDARY fault-phase series compensation and MOV will be bypassed.
ARC CURRENT AND RECOVERY VOLTAGE 3) A linkage measure is added that by-pass switch of fault-
maximum recovery maximum secondary arc phase series compensation is commanded to be closed while
lines voltage/kV current/A
name line protection monitors single-phase fault and commands line
head side end side head side end side
breaker to trip, expressed as SC linkage with breaker in the
Lcn 140.3 66.0 26.8 12.2 following waveforms.
Lnj 95.5 61.5 13.3 8.6 Faulty timing: single-phase ground fault occurs at 100ms,
TABLE followed by faulty-phase breakers of lines two sides trip at
UNDER THE SITUATIONS OF FAULTY-PHASE SERIES COMPENSATION BYPASSING, 150ms, finally the fault disappears at 200ms. Under the
POWER FREQUENCY COMPONENT OF UHV LINES SECONDARY ARC CURRENT
linkage measure, fault-phase series compensation is bypassed
AND RECOVERY VOLTAGE
maximum recovery maximum secondary arc
after fault occurring 20ms.
lines voltage/kV current/A Different fault points along Changzhi-Nanyang and
name Nanyang-Jingmen line are showed by Fig. 4 and Fig. 5
head side end side head side end side
Lcn 130.5 62.1 27.5 12.7 respectively.
Lnj 89.3 53.2 13.5 7.8

IV. TRANSIENT OF SECOND ARC CURRENT AND RECOVERY

VOLTAGE

When single-phase ground fault occurs in line with series Fig.4. Faulty points along Changzhi-Nanyang line

compensation installed, and short-circuit current flowing

through series compensation is too little that its protection
fails to operate, and series compensation is not bypassed.
Residual charge on series compensation discharges through a
Fig.5. Faulty points along Nanyang-Jingmen line
low-frequency oscillation circuit composed of series
Arc model: before line circuit breakers opening, primary
compensation, shunt reactor and arc resistor of short-circuit
arc is simulated as 1ohm resistor; after they opening, second
point as shown in Fig. 3. This action significantly increases
arc is simulated as 100ohm resistor by using EMTP.
 B. Second arc current of Changzhi-Nanyang line
When the fault happens on different faulty points along
Changzhi-Nanyang line, the max second arc current after two
side breakers tripping 0.5s, is shown in Fig. 6. Series
compensation is abbreviated as SC in the figure.

(a) Time domain analysis

Fig.6. The max second arc current of Changzhi-Nanyang line after two side
breakers tripping 0.5s
When the fault happens on line side of Changzhi series
compensation (SCcz fault point), second arc current waves
(time and frequency domain ) of faulty point under three
operation modes of SC after two side breaker tripping 0.35s, is
showed by Fig. 7 to Fig. 9. (b) Frequency domain analysis
Fig.8. When the fault happens on SCcz point and SC with bypassing, second
arc current wave after two side breaker tripping 0.35s

(a) Time domain analysis

(a) Time domain analysis

(b) Frequency domain analysis

Fig.7. When the fault happens on SCcz point and SC without bypassing, (b) Frequency domain analysis
second arc current wave after two side breaker tripping 0.35s Fig.9. When the fault happens on SCcz point and SC links with breaker,
second arc current wave after two side breaker tripping 0.35s
 From above results, the conditions about Changzhi- compensations protection, short-circuit current is high only
Nanyang line can be summarized: on the fault location near Nanyang series compensation. So
1) On the condition of fault-phase series compensation that the protection of fault-phase series compensation can
without bypass, second arc current on all faulty points is quite operate to make fault-phase series compensation bypass. And
large except for the point of line end. And most fault-point second arc current reduces obviously to the level that equal to
second arc current is over 60A. In Fig. 7, second arc current series compensation linking with breaker. But on other
on SCcz point is 5.1Hz low-frequency oscillatory wave, of locations, series compensations protection can not operate
which characteristics are slow-decaying and fewer-zero, with since second current is still large as showed in Fig. 11, which
result of disadvantage to second arc self extinguishing. 0.5s is same to series compensation not bypassing.
after line breaker tripping, the peak of current is 146.1A. And 3) Under the linkage measure, fault-phase series
second arc can not self extinguish. compensation can bypass. So low-frequency harmonic
2) Considering the action characteristics of series component of second arc current decays quickly as showed in
compensations protection, series compensation permits Fig. 12. After line breaker tripping 0.5s, the maximum current
bypassing when the energy or current of MOV exceeds setting on different locations along the line does not exceed 15.1A,
value. Short-circuit current is high only on the fault location which is obviously lower than series compensation without
near Changzhi or Nanyang series compensation, thus the bypassing.
protection of fault-phase series compensation near faulty point
can operate to make fault-phase series compensation bypass.
And second arc current reduces little. But on other locations,
series compensations protection can not operate since the
current is still large, which is same to series compensation
without bypassing. In addition, even if series compensation
near faulty point can be bypassed, its contralateral series
compensation can not. So the second arc current remains a
higher proportion of low-frequency harmonic component as
showed in Fig. 8. For example, the peak current on SCcz
faulty point reduce to 64.8A from 146.1A after line breaker
tripping 0.5s. But the current is still high that second arc can
not self extinguish either.
3) Under the linkage measure, that series compensation
protection links with line breaker, fault-phase series
compensation of both sides can bypass. So low-frequency Fig.10 The maximum second arc current of Nanyang-Jingmen line after two
sides breaker tripping 0.5s
harmonic component of second arc current decays quickly as
showed in Fig. 9. After line breaker tripping 0.5s, the
maximum current on different location along the line does not
exceed 32.2A, which is obviously lower than series
compensation without bypass.
C. Second arc current of Nanyang-Jingmen line
When the fault happens on different points along Nanyang-
Jingmen line, the maximum second arc current after two side
breaker tripping 0.5s, is shown in Fig. 10.
When the fault happens on the position of 80km from SC,
second arc current waves (time and frequency domain) of
fault point under three operation modes of SC after two sides
breaker tripping 0.45s, is shown in Fig. 11 and Fig. 12.
From above results, the conditions about Nanyang-Jingmen (a) Time domain analysis
line can be summarized:
1) On the condition of fault-phase series compensation
without bypass, second arc current on all fault points is quite
large, exceeding 60A. In the Fig. 11, second arc current on the
fault point of 80km from SC is 6.1Hz low-frequency
oscillatory wave. After line breaker tripping 0.5s, the peak
current is 89A. And second arc can not self-extinguish.
2) Considering the action characteristics of series
 When fault-phase series compensation does not and links
with line breaker, the maximum recovery voltage on different
fault points along Nanyang-Jingmen line after second arc
extinguishing, is calculated as showed in Fig. 13. And the
waves of recovery voltage on line head are showed by Fig. 14
and Fig. 15. Then the following conclusions can be drew:
1) On the condition of fault-phase series compensation
without bypassing, its residual charge makes recovery voltage
higher than series compensation bypassing under linkage
measure.
2) Recovery voltage of series compensation without
bypassing, is a beating wave which is same to series
compensation bypassing. But even it has a certain proportion
(b) Frequency domain analysis of low frequency component as a result of series
Fig.11. When the fault happens on the position of 80km from SC and SC is compensation. So recovery voltage decays slowly. For
not bypassing, second arc current wave after two sides breaker tripping 0.45s
example, the frequency of recovery voltage is 4.1Hz as shown
in Fig. 14. Whereas there is no this low frequency component
on the condition of series compensation linking with line
breaker as shown in Fig. 15.
Summarily, fault-phase series compensation will increase
low frequency component to recovery voltage and slow down
its decay rate. Linkage measure should be adopt to make the
series compensation bypass.

(a) Time domain analysis

Fig.13 The maximum recovery voltage along Nanyang-Jingmen line after

second arc extinguishing

(b) Frequency domain analysis

Fig.12. When the fault happens on the position of 80km from SC and SC links
with breaker, second arc current wave after two sides breaker tripping 0.45s

D. Recovery voltage
After second arc extinguishing, residual charge of fault
phase and the coupling of non-fault phases make fault point
recover voltage. Series compensation will increase low
frequency transient component to the voltage, which is
disadvantageous to second arc self extinguishing. (a) Time domain analysis
Take Nanyang-Jingmen line as an example , the influence
of series compensation to recovery voltage, is researched as
follows.
 (b) Frequency domain analysis
Fig.14. When SC is not bypassing, recovery voltage wave of Nanyang-
Jingmen line head after second arc extinguishing Fig.16. When the fault happens on the position of 80km from SC and SC is
not bypassing, second arc current waves after two sides breaker tripping 0.45s
In the figure, second arc current under the series
compensation degree of 20%, 40% and 60%, are about 2~8Hz
low-frequency oscillatory waves. The lower series
compensation degree is, the lower frequency is and the slower
the second current decays. So the second arc current under the
series compensation degree of 20% is larger than other
conditions, which reaches to 148Apeak after two sides breaker
tripping 0.45s.
But on the condition of series compensation linking with
line breaker, the second current has no low frequency transient
component on any compensation degree. Because three-phase
series compensations have been bypassed during single phase
(a) Time domain analysis
reclosing.

V. CONCLUSIONS
Series compensation installed on UHV line in Changzhi-
Nanyang-Jingmen UHV AC demonstration project of China,
increases low frequency component to second arc current and
recovery voltage when single phase ground fault occurs. It has
characteristics of slow-decaying and fewer-zero, which are
disadvantageous to second arc self extinguishing.
Although the protection of series compensation can operate
to make series compensation bypass on some fault locations,
only the series compensation near fault point can be bypassed
and its contralateral series compensation still can not do so.
And on the location of small short-circuit current, the series
(b) Frequency domain analysis compensation can not be bypassed either. There will be a
Fig.15. When SC links with breaker, recovery voltage wave of Nanyang- problem of second arc extinguishing. So a measure must be
Jingmen line head after second arc extinguishing
taken.
E. Sensitivity analysis for different compensation level Under linkage measure that series compensation protection
Different compensation level of series compensation has links with line breaker, fault-phase series compensation of two
effect to transient of second current and recovery voltage sides can both bypass. So low-frequency harmonic component
when SC is not bypassed. Take Nanyang-Jingmen line as an of second arc current and recovery voltage decay quickly.
example, sensitivity analysis is researched as follows. After line breaker tripping 0.5s, the maximum current on
When the fault happens on the position of 80km from SC, different location along the line can be limited to a lower level,
second arc current waves of fault point under series which is obviously lower than series compensation without
compensation degree of 20%, 40% and 60% after two sides bypass.
breaker tripping 0.45s, is shown in Fig. 16. Summarily, UHV series compensated transmission line
should take linkage measure to limit second arc and recovery
voltage during single phase ground fault in order to make
single phase reclosing success.

VI. REFERENCES
[1] Cao Rongjiang, Gu Nihong, Sheng YongThe Simulation Research on
Secondary Arc Extinction Characteristics in Power System
[J]Proceedings of the CSEE, 1996, 16(2)73-78 (in Chinese)
[2] Zhou Xiaoxin,Guo Jianbo, Lin Jiming, Gu Shouyuan Power System
Thyristor Control Series Compensation [M] Beijing Science
Publishing House, 2009 (in Chinese)
[3] Lu Wei, Jin XiSecondary Arc in FSC Transmission Lines and Its
Restraining Measure [J]High Voltage Engineering, 2007, 33(7)49-
51 (in Chinese)
[4] Niu Xiaomin, Wang Xiaotong, Shi Wei, Wang QipingSecondary
Arc Current and Recovery Voltage of Series Compensation Line
[J]Power System Technology, 1998, 22(9)9-12 (in Chinese)

VII. BIOGRAPHIES
Zhang Yuanyuan (1982) obtained the M.Sc. degree
on electrical engineering from North China Electric power
University in 2008. Her key research area is electromagnetic
transient simulation for power system.
Ban Liangeng (1960) professor level senior engineer,
his key research area is electromagnetic transient simulation
for power system.
Xiang Zutao (1976) obtained the Ph.D. degree on
electrical engineering from Tsinghua University in 2005. His
key research area is electromagnetic transient simulation for
power system.
Han Bin (1983 ) obtained the M.Sc. degree in
electrical engineering from Tsinghua University in 2007. His
key research area is electromagnetic transient simulation for
power system.
Zhen Bin (1982 ) obtained the M.Sc. degree on
electrical engineering from North China Electric power
University in 2006. His key research area is electromagnetic
transient simulation for power system.
Ma Wenyuan (1986) obtained the bachelor's degree
on International Economica law from Shanghai International
Studies University in 2009.