Requirements of The Presenting Group
Requirements of The Presenting Group
The group will have 25 minutes max to present without interruption. The group
may include PowerPoint, video clips, flip chart, photographic or poster material
as part of their presentation. The presentation should address the prescribed
reading material and the chosen article using the headings below as a guide
(this is also the marking scheme marks are awarded on the basis of a A-E scale
[A=Outstanding B=Above Average C=Average D=Below Average - E/Poor].
Evidence of practical application of the ideas and concepts is a priority. This will
help to avoid an overly descriptive delivery. The hard copy should be submitted
prior to the class presentation Please annotate your slides for clarity.
Requirements of attendees
Following the presentation, there will be a five minute discussion period where
other groups in the class will discuss the topic and put questions to the
presenting group.
Key criteria
Criteria for critique Notes
1 Overview/Business Issue: Try to avoid flat
Provides self-contained synthesis of the summaries but rather
business issue/s, theory and implications of employ critical thinking
the topic for innovation management What is the justification
Evaluates the commercial and/or for examining the
organisational implications citing examples ideas/constructs
from business
2 Desk research/Fit of selected articles: What justifies its inclusion
Justification of the paired article selection. in the critique?
Does the chosen article present arguments
in support of/contrary to the original?
Check journal ranking
3 Exposure of theoretical issues, models What are the contrasts
and frameworks: between the two? Are
Demonstrates knowledge and there differences in terms
comprehension of frameworks and fit to the of emphasis or
business context conclusion?
4 Linking theory and practice: Is there anything to add in
Shows evidence of the links respect of relevance to
Ideally one group company example of business practice?
application
One general example of application
5 Referencing, communication and Evidence that slide/notes
presentation: limit is used efficiently and
Critique delivered in a logical, non- the critique is coherent.
descriptive style. APA referencing of all
Well-structured and referenced. materials (n.b. cite page
Delivered on-time (soft copy uploaded to numbers when using
Web Courses and hard copy prior to direct quotes)
presentation).
Deliverable: Please submit your analysis 20 Marked out of 20%
pages (max) PowerPoint using the notes including ability to field
function (font 12 1.5 line spacing) in support questions.
[Type here] [Type here] [Type here]
1 | Page