22 - Renewable Energy Case Study ZA Kusakana
22 - Renewable Energy Case Study ZA Kusakana
22 - Renewable Energy Case Study ZA Kusakana
Renewable Energy
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/renene
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: This study investigates the possibility of using and developing hydrokinetic power to supply reliable,
Received 21 August 2012 affordable and sustainable electricity to rural, remote and isolated loads in rural South Africa where
Accepted 24 December 2012 reasonable water resource is available. Simulations are performed using the Hybrid Optimization Model
Available online
for Electric Renewable (HOMER) and the results are compared to those from other supply options such as
standalone Photovoltaic system (PV), wind, diesel generator (DG) and grid extension. Finally the paper
Keywords:
points out some major challenges that are facing the development of this technology in South Africa.
Hydrokinetic power
2013 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Renewable energy
Rural electrication
South Africa
HOMER
0960-1481/$ e see front matter 2013 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.renene.2012.12.051
Author's personal copy
Table 1
Hydropower potential in South Africa.
seriously in South Africa. No signicant development of hydropower The terms hydrokinetic encapsulate both tidal and river appli-
in the country has been noted for 30 years, except the new small- cations. Within the context of this paper, the focus is on river
scale installation of 7 MW capacity commissioned at the Sol Plaatjie application, since it is suitable for energy generation at remote and
Municipality Free State province. At the present the overall hydro- isolated locations.
electricity generation capacity represents only about 5% of present
total 45,500 MW installed generation capacity [5]. Table 1 below 3.2. The turbine
gives a summary of the hydropower potential in South Africa.
Most of the operation principles of the hydrokinetic turbines are
2.2. Where to look for hydroelectricity in South Africa based upon wind turbines, as they work in a similar way but with
the possibility of having close to 1000 time more energy from the
The rural communities in the Eastern Cape, Mpumalanga and hydrokinetic compared to the wind turbine of the same swept area
KwaZulu-Natal provinces have access to water resources with good [8]. The power available (Pa) in watts can be worked out using the
hydropower potential [6]. The development of small-scale tradi- following equation.
tional hydroelectric installation particularly for the commercial and
1
domestic consumption should be strongly promoted and sup- Pa A r V 3 Cp (1)
ported. Communities with hydropower potential and interest in 2
developing hydroelectricity needs a wide professional support
since any new hydropower installation is costly and requires A area in metres squared (m2)
technical and operational inputs from civil, mechanical and elec- r density of water (1000 kg/m3)
trical professionals. The gure below shows the areas where po- V velocity of water (m/s)
tential site for development of micro-hydropower as well as the Cp the power coefcient
location where they have already been implemented [7].
We have to notice that Fig. 1 and Table 1 do not take into con- The theoretical maximum power available from the river is
sideration the energy potentially available from hydrokinetic which expressed by the equation above using a power coefcient of 0.592
can represent a potential source of electric power even greater than or 59% efciency. But a small-scale river turbine has its own losses
the one from micro- and pico-hydropower plants. The ideal loca- which will reduce the power coefcient to around 0.25.
tion for a hydrokinetic turbine is to be located in deep strong From equation (1) above, it is noticeable that the power in-
owing rivers or immediately downstream from an existing con- creases in a cubed relationship to the velocity of the ow of water
ventional hydropower plant where electric transmission wires and
interconnection facilities are located, and also where the energy
remaining in the water current existing from the turbines in the
dam can be reused. Theoretically, a greater number of potential
sites to implement hydrokinetic power can be identied compare
the traditional small-scale hydropower.
3. Hydrokinetic power
3.1. Technology
No dam,
No destruction of nearby land,
No change in the river ow direction,
Reduction of ora and fauna destruction. Fig. 1. Small-scale hydropower distribution in South Africa.
Author's personal copy
Table 2 Table 4
Domestic power demand estimation. BTS load.
Equipment Amount Power (kW) Time (h) Energy (kWh/d) Items Power consumption (kW) Usage h/day
Light 5 0.006 6 0.18 Constant site load (BTS, TX) 2 24
Radio 1 0.020 5 0.1 Air-conditioner (12,000 BTU) 1.8 6
T.V. 1 0.07 5 0.35 Air-conditioner start-up 3.3 e
Iron 1 1 0.1 0.1
Kettle 1 1.5 0.05 0.075
Fridge 1 0.12 24 2.88
Phone charger 3 0.004 1 0.012 4.1.2. Resources assessment
The summary of the water velocity [14], wind velocity and solar
radiation [15] from the site is shown in Table 3.
past the turbine. Therefore it is important to nd the best ow to The theoretical potential power available from the hydrokinetic
get the best power output. turbine (Pa) can be found with the help of equation (1) using the
following characteristics from the selected stream:
3.3. Generator
Minimum water velocity in the worst month: 1.41 m/s
In order to reduce costs, and to be able to rely on locally-made Viable depth: 1.8 m
technology, permanent magnet generator can be used. The mag- Width: 5.2 m
nets allowed the speed of generation to be reduced, and lowered Cross sectional area: 9.36 m2
the cost of the equipment, which itself could be adapted to be Pa 1075 kW
a river turbine rotor and ultimately, tested and built [9]. Due to
lower generation speed, gearboxes or generators with high number A correction factor of 0.8 has been applied to the measured
of poles can be used [10]. values to accommodate friction effects along the bottom and sides
of the river on the current velocity [16]. With reasonable sizing of
the battery storage system, this available power can cover the load
4. System design
energy requirement without interruption. The selected site has
very good solar and wind resources as shown in Table 3, so the solar
The HOMER simulation program has been chosen as a tool for
PV system, wind and the standalone diesel generator can be com-
system design. HOMER was selected due to its capability to evaluate
pared to the hydrokinetic while supplying the same load to nd out
the best option by harnessing energy from a single or combination of
which one is the best supply option for the site.
various energy resources [11]. It is an economic model that provides
rational selection of the most cost effective option [12]. Fur-
thermore, its hourly energy ow approach offers a comprehensive 4.2. Case 2: base transceiver station
analysis of the system performance throughout a year. Two case
studies have been conducted on different sites from which the load 4.2.1. Load description
energy demand, the renewable energy resources, as well as the cost The medium-sized indoor base transceiver station used has an
of the supply options (hydrokinetic, solar PV, wind, diesel generator equipment power loading of 2 kW. The items and their power
and grid extension) have been used as input to HOMER. consumptions are given in Table 4. Normally the full load will only
be the constant site load and the air-conditioner running power (or
3.8 kW), or when temperatures permit the air-conditioners to be
4.1. Case 1: rural household
shut off, only the BTS load (2 kW) [17]. The total power required in
the worst case will be the full load plus the air-conditioner start-up
4.1.1. Load description
power (7.1 kW). Thus the load is 7.1 kW peak and 58.8 kWh energy
For this rst case, a typical rural household in the KwaZulu-
consumption per day.
Natal has been selected.
The site is situated at 30.6 Latitude South and 29.4 Longitude
4.2.2. Resources assessment
East.
The summary of the water velocity [14], wind velocity and solar
Table 2 gives domestic appliances, power demand and running
radiation [15] from the site is shown in Table 3 plus the air-condi-
times for an average typical household in rural South Africa [13].
tioner start-up power (7.1 kW). Thus the load is 7.1 kW peak and
The load is 3.4 kW peak and 9.5 kWh per day.
58.8 kWh energy consumption per day.
Table 3
Site 1 energy resources. Table 5
Site 2 energy resources.
Month Water speed Daily radiation Wind speed
(m/s) (kWh/m2/d) (m/s) Month Water speed (m/s) Daily radiation (kWh/m2/d) Wind speed (m/s)
January 5.31 6.23 4.1 January 6.410 8.44 6.6
February 7.25 5.83 3.9 February 5.270 7.50 5.9
March 6.09 5.21 3.8 March 3.830 6.22 5.8
April 1.81 4.46 3.9 April 3.120 4.66 5.1
May 2.67 3.81 4.1 May 2.470 3.43 4.9
June 2.18 3.33 4.5 June 2.160 3.01 5.3
July 1.84 3.62 4.5 July 1.580 3.21 5.1
August 1.54 4.29 4.6 August 1.220 4.10 5.3
September 1.41 5.08 4.8 September 1.710 5.33 5.6
October 1.69 5.41 4.6 October 2.430 6.82 6.2
November 2.83 6.00 4.3 November 4.190 7.96 6.2
December 5.27 6.35 4.0 December 6.600 8.51 6.0
Average 3.32 4.947 4.26 Average 3.047 5.76 5.7
Author's personal copy
1.0
0.8
Power Output (kW)
0.6
0.4
0.2
Table 7
Simulation results summary (Case 1).
Table 8
Diesel generator emissions.
Table 9
Simulation results summary (Case 2).
5. Conclusion [5] Baseline study on hydropower in South Africa. Pretoria: Department of Min-
erals and Energy; 2002.
[6] Hearn IR. Energy sources for remote area power supply e a review and
This paper aimed to investigate the possibility of using and assessment. In: Proceedings of the conference E-I 92 electricity beyond the
developing hydrokinetic power suitable to supply electricity to grid; 1992. p. 60e75.
rural and isolated loads in South Africa where reasonable water [7] Barta B. Status of the small-scale hydroelectric (SSHE) development in South
Africa; March 2010.
resource is available. [8] Arango MA. Resource assessment and feasibility study for use of hydrokinetic
The proposed hydrokinetic system is sized to meet the load turbines in the tailwaters of the priest rapids project. MSc dissertation.
energy requirement during the worst months. Simulations of the Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Washington; 2011.
[9] Susanto J, Stamp S. Local installation methods for low head pico-hydropower
hydrokinetic power have been performed with HOMER software in the Lao PDR. Renewable Energy 2012;44:439e47.
with a rural household and a BTS load as case studies under dif- [10] Grabbe M, Yuen K, Goude A, Lalander E, Leijon M. Design of an experimental
ferent demand and energy resources. The results have been com- setup for hydro-kinetic energy conversion. The International Journal on Hy-
dropower & Dams 2009;16(5):112e6.
pared with those from a diesel generator, wind turbine and [11] National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NERL). Hybrid optimization model for
standalone PV system while they are supplying the same load. The electric renewable (HOMER) [Online]. Available from: www.nrel.gov; 2005
comparison criteria were the Initial Capital, the Total Net Present [accessed 29.11.2011].
[12] Givler T, Lilienthal P. Using HOMER software, NREL micropower optimization
Cost, the Cost of Energy as well as the system Capacity Shortage. In model, to explore the role of Gen-sets in small solar powersystem: case study
summary, hydrokinetic power generation is the best supply option Srilanka [Online]. Available from: http://www.scribd.com/doc/6610003/Homer-
compared to the wind, PV and diesel generator where adequate Case-Study-Sri-Lanka?autodownpdf; 2005 [accessed 12.04.2012].
[13] Kusakana K, Munda JL, Jimoh AA. Economic and environmental analysis of
water resource is available. Apart for being very cost effective, the
micro hydropower system for rural power supply. In: PECon 2008, the 2nd
hydrokinetic system contributes to the reduction of the CO2 and IEEE power and energy conference, Johor Bahru, Malaysia; 1e3 December
green house gases in the atmosphere. 2008. p. 41e4.
The results of this study have led to the following further study [14] Kusakana K, Vermaak HJ. Feasibility study of hydrokinetic power for energy
access in rural South Africa. In: The fth IASTED Asian conference on power and
recommendations: energy systems (AsiaPES 2012); April 2e4, 2012, Phuket, Thailand. p. 433e8.
[15] Clean Energy Decision Support Center. RETScreen software. [Online]. Avail-
Identify more sites in addition to those already identied for able from: www.retscree.net. [accessed 17.06.2012].
[16] Twidell J, Weir T. Renewable energy resources. 2nd ed. New York: Taylor &
traditional micro-hydropower, and assess potential energy Francis; 2006.
available, [17] Kusakana K, Vermaak HJ. Hybrid photovoltaic-wind system as power solution
Develop policies supporting the development and deployment for network operators in the D.R.Congo. In: International conference on clean
electrical power (ICCEP), Ischia, Italy; 2011. p. 703e8.
of hydrokinetic power in South Africa. [18] Kunai S. Options for the electrication of rural villages in the Province of
Riau, Indonesia. MSc dissertation. School of Engineering and Energy, Murdoch
University; Perth, Australia: 2009.
References [19] Darrieus turbine. Alternative hydro solutions. Available from: http://www.
althydrosolutions.com [accessed 20.08.2012].
[1] Department of Minerals and Energy Affairs see South Africa Department of [20] 125 Watts and Higher Module Index. Retail price per watt peak. [Online]. Avail-
Mineral and Energy Affairs. Implementation of strategy for renewable energy able from: http://www.solarbuzz.com/Moduleprices.htm [accessed 07.06.2012].
in South Africa. Draft 2. Pretoria: Government Printer; 2000. [21] Ahmed A, Ziedan H, Sayed K, Amery M, Swify M. Optimal sizing of a hybrid
[2] DME. White paper on the energy policy of the Republic of South Africa. Pre- system of renewable energy for a reliable load supply without interruption.
toria: Department of Minerals and Energy; 2003. November 2003. European Journal of Scientic Research 2010;45(4):620e9.
[3] Wang L, Infante D, Lyons J, Stewart J, Cooper A. Effects of dams in river net- [22] Trojan battery L16p price. [Online]. Available from: http://www.solar-review.
works on sh assemblages in non-impoundment sections of rivers in Michi- com/reviews/read-review.cfm/id/8/ [accessed 07.11.2011].
gan and Wisconsin, USA. River Research and Applications 2011;27(4):473e87. [23] Barley DC, Winn BC. Optimal dispatch strategy in remote hybrid power sys-
[4] Department of Minerals and Energy Affairs (DME). Eskom and Counsil for tems. Solar Energy 1996;58(4e6):165e79.
Scientic and Industrial Research (CSIR) renewable energy resource GIS [24] Portable generators. Available from: www.peakpowertools.com/Portable-
Database; 2001. Generators-s/1.htm [accessed 20.08.2012].