Helical Spring Design
Helical Spring Design
Definition of spring
A spring is an elastic object used to store mechanical energy. Springs are elastic bodies
(generally metal) that can be twisted, pulled, or stretched by some force. They can return to their
original shape when the force is released. In other words it is also termed as a resilient member.
A spring is a flexible element used to exert a force or a torque and, at the same time, to store
energy.
The force can be a linear push or pull, or it can be radial, acting similarly to a rubber band around
a roll of drawings.
The torque can be used to cause a rotation, for example, to close a door on a cabinet or to provide
a counterbalance force for a machine element pivoting on a hinge.
Objectives of spring
To provide Cushioning, to absorb, or to control the energy due to shock and vibration.
Car springs or railway buffers to control energy, springs-supports and vibration dampers
To Control motion
Maintaining contact between two elements (cam and its follower) Creation of the necessary
pressure in a friction device (a brake or a clutch)
To Measure forces
Spring balances, gages
Chrome Vanadium
This alloy spring steel is used for high stress conditions and at high temperature up to 2200C. It is
good for fatigue resistance and long endurance for shock and impact loads.
Chrome Silicon:
This material can be used for highly stressed springs. It offers excellent service for long life,
shock loading and
for temperature up to 2500C.
Music wire
This spring material is most widely used for small springs. It is the toughest and has highest
tensile strength and can withstand repeated loading at high stresses. It cannot be used at subzero
temperatures or at temperatures above 1200C.
Stainless steel:
Widely used alloy spring materials.
Phosphor Bronze / Spring Brass:
It has good corrosion resistance and electrical conductivity. it is commonly used for contacts in
electrical switches. Spring brass can be used at subzero temperatures
Springs can be classified according to the direction and the nature of the force exerted by
the spring when it is deflected.
uses
Types of springs
Push
Helical compression spring, Belleville spring, Torsion spring, force acting at the end of
torque arm. flat spring, such as a cantilever spring or leaf spring
Pull
Helical extension spring, Torsion spring, force acting at the end of torque arm. Flat spring,
such as a cantilever spring or leaf spring, Draw bar spring (special case of the compression
spring) constant force spring.
Radial
Garter spring, elastomeric band, spring clamp, Torsion spring, Power spring
torque
HELICAL SPRING
Definition
It is made of wire coiled in the form of helix having circular, square or rectangular cross
section.
There is an important parameter in spring design called spring index. It is denoted by letter C.
The spring index is defined as the ratio of mean coil diameter to wire diameter. Or
C = D/d
In design of helical springs, the designer should use good judgment in assuming the value of the
spring index C. The spring index indicates the relative sharpness of the curvature of the coil.
A low spring index means high sharpness of curvature. When the spring index is low (C < 3), the
actual stresses in the wire are excessive due to curvature effect. Such a spring is difficult to
manufacture and special care in coiling is required to avoid cracking in some wires. When the
spring index is high (C >15), it results in large variation in coil diameter. Such a spring is prone
to buckling and also tangles easily during handling. Spring index from 4 to 12 is considered
better from manufacturing considerations.
Therefore, in practical applications, the spring index in the range of 6 to 9 is still preferred
particularly for close tolerance springs and those subjected to cyclic loading.
There are three terms - free length, compressed length and solid length that are illustrated in the
figure. These terms are related to helical compression spring. These lengths are determined by
following way
1) Solid length: solid length is defined as the axial length of the spring which is so
compressed, that the adjacent coils touch each other. In this case, the spring is completely
compressed and no further compression is possible. The solid length is given by.
Solid length = Nt d
Where Nt = total number of coils
2) Compressed length: Compressed length is defined as the axial length of the spring that is
subjected to maximum compressive force. In this case, the spring is subjected to maximum
deflection . When the spring is subjected to maximum force, there should be some gap or
clearance between the adjacent coils. The gap is essential to prevent clashing of the coils.
The clashing allowance or the total axial gap is usually taken as 15% of the maximum deflection.
Sometimes, an arbitrary decision is taken and it is assumed that there is a gap of 1 or 2 mm
between adjacent coils under maximum load condition. In this case, the total axial gap is given
by,
Total gap = (Nt-1) x gap between adjacent coils
3) Free length: Free length is defined as the axial length of an unloaded helical compression
spring. In this case, no external force acts on the spring. Free length is an important dimension in
spring design and manufacture. It is the length of the spring in free condition prior to assembly.
Free length is given by,
Free length = compressed length + y
= solid length + total axial gap + y
The pitch of the coil is defined as the axial distance between adjacent coils in uncompressed state
of spring. It is denoted by p. It is given by,
The stiffness of the spring (k) is defined as the force required producing unit deflection
Therefore
Active coils are the coils in the spring, which contribute to spring action, support the external
force and deflect under the action of force. A portion of the end coils, which is in contact with
the seat, does not contribute to spring action and called inactive coils. These coils do not support
the load and do not deflect under the action o external force. The number of inactive coils is
given by,
Inactive coils = Nt N where N = number of active coils
Helical spring
The figures below show the schematic representation of a helical spring acted upon by a tensile
load F and compressive load F. The circles denote the cross section of the spring wire.
The cut section, i.e. from the entire coil somewhere we make a cut, is indicated as a circle with
shade.
If we look at the free body diagram of the shaded region only (the cut section) then we shall see
that at the cut section, vertical equilibrium of forces will give us force, F as indicated in the
figure. This F is the shear force. The torque T, at the cut section and its direction is also marked
in the figure.
There is no horizontal force coming into the picture because externally there is no horizontal
force present. So from the fundamental understanding of the free body diagram one can see that
any section of the spring is experiencing a torque and a force. Shear force will always be
associated with a bending moment.
However, in an ideal situation, when force is acting at the centre of the circular spring and the
coils of spring are almost parallel to each other, no bending moment would result at any section
of the spring ( no moment arm), except torsion and shear force.
The cut sections of the spring, subjected to tensile and compressive loads respectively, are shown
separately in the figure.
The broken arrows show the shear stresses (T) arising due to the torsion T and solid arrows
show the shear stresses (F) due to the force F.
It is observed that for both tensile load as well as compressive load on the spring, maximum
shear stress (T + F) always occurs at the inner side of the spring. Hence, failure of the spring,
in the form of crake, is always initiated from the inner radius of the spring.
The radius of the spring is given by D/2. Note that D is the mean diameter of the spring. The
torque T acting on the spring is
.. (1)
If d is the diameter of the coil wire and polar moment of inertia,
.. (2)
Average shear stress in the spring wire due to force F is
.. (3)
Therefore, maximum shear stress in the spring wire is
. (4)
The above equation gives maximum shear stress occurring in a spring. Ks are the shear stress
correction factor. The resultant diagram of torsional shear stress and direct shear stress is shown
From the above equation it can be observed that the effect of direct shear stress i.e.,
Is appreciable for springs of small spring index C Also the effect of wire curvature is neglected
in equation (A)
The inner length a-b being smaller compared to the outer length c-d, the shear strain yi at the
inside of the spring will be more than the shear strain yo at the outside of the spring. Hence, for a
given wire diameter, a spring with smaller diameter will experience more difference of shear
strain between outside surface and inside surface compared to its larger counterpart. This
phenomenon is termed as curvature effect.
So more is the spring index (C = D /d) the lesser will be the curvature effect. For example, the
suspensions in the railway carriages use helical springs. These springs have large wire diameter
compared to the diameter of the spring itself. In this case curvature effect will be predominantly
high.
To take care of the curvature effect, the earlier equation for maximum shear stress in the spring
wire is modified as,
Where, KW is Wahl correction factor, which takes care of both curvature effect and shear stress
correction factor and is expressed as,
.. (6)
Deflection of helical spring of circular cross section wire
Total length of wire = length of one coil x number of active coils
We know,
The Fig. (a) And (b) shows a schematic view of a spring, a cross section of the spring wire and a
small spring segment of length dl. It is acted upon by a force F. From simple geometry we will
see that the deflection, in a helical spring is given by the formula,
Here we conclude on the discussion for important design features, namely, stress, deflection and
spring rate of a helical spring.
Expression for strain energy in a body when the load is applied gradually
The strain energy stored in a body is equal to the work done by the applied load in stretching the
body. Figure shows load extension diagram of a body under tensile load up to elastic limit.
The tensile load F increase gradually from zero to the value of F, And the extension of the body
increase from zero to the value of y. The load F performs work in stretching the body. This work
will be stored in the body as strain energy which is recoverable after the load F is removed.
Let
F = gradually applied load
Y = Extension of the body (spring)
A = Cross section area
l = Length of body
V= Volume of the body
E = Youngs modulus
U = Strain energy stored in the body
= Stress induced in the body
Now, work done by the load = Area of load extension curve
= Area of le OAB = Fy
Load, F = stress x area = A
Extension, y = strain x length
. (1)
Since work done by the load in stretching body is equal to the strain energy stored in the body,
.. (2)
Proof Resilience
The maximum energy stored in the body without permanent deformation [i.e., upto elastic limit]
is known as proof resilience. Hence in equation (2) if is taken at elastic limit, then we will get
proof resilience.
V = Volume
m = Mass of the spring
= Mass density of the spring
y1 = Initial deflection or initial compression
Modes of loading i.e., whether the spring is subjected to static or infrequently varying
load or alternating load.
Economy desired.
Considering these factors the designer select the material and specify the wire size, spring
diameter, number of turns spring rate, type of ends, free length and the surface condition.
A helical compression spring, that is too long compared to the mean coil diameter, acts as a
flexible column and may buckle at comparatively low axial force.
Springs which cannot be designed buckle- proof must be guided in a sleeve or over an arbor.
This is undesirable because the friction between the spring and the guide may damage the
spring in the long run.
It is therefore preferable, if possible, to divide the spring into buckle proof component
springs separated by intermediate platens which are guided over a arbor or in a sleeve.
1) Diameter of wire:
Shear stress
D = cd
Do= D+d
Di= D - d
Axial Deflection
where i = Number of active turns or coils
4. Free length
Where,
y = Maximum deflection
Clearance a = 25% of maximum deflection or a = xdi, for x value refer figure in DHB
Assume squared and ground end
Number of additional coil n = 2
5. Stiffness or Rate of spring
6. Pitch
Let us consider a spring subjected to external fluctuating force, that changes its magnitude from
to Fmax to Fmin in the load cycle. The mean force and the force amplitude Fa are given by
The mean stresses (m) are calculated from mean force by using shear stress correction factor
(ks). It is given by,
Where,
Ks are the correction factor for direct shear stress and are applicable to mean stress only.
For torsional stress amplitude (a), it is necessary to also consider the effect of stress
concentration due to curvature in addition to direct shear stress. Therefore,
Where, K is the Wahl factor, which takes into consideration the effect of direct shear stress as
well as the stress concentration due to curvature.
There is a basic difference between the rotating-beam specimen and fatigue testing of spring
wires. A spring is never subjected to completely reversed load, changing its magnitude from
tension to compression passing through zero with respect to time. A helical compression spring
is subjected to purely compressive force.
On the other hand, the helical extension spring is subjected to purely tensile force. In general, the
spring wires are subjected to pulsating shear stresses which vary from zero to (
se), as shown in
fig. se is the endurance limit in shear for the stress variation from zero to some maximum value.
The data regarding the experimental values of endurance strength of spring wires is not readily
available. In absence of such values, the following relationships suggested by H.J.Elmendorf can
be used,
For patented and cold-drawn steel wires (grades 1 to 4)
se = 0.21 ut
sy = 0.42 ut
For oil-hardened and tempered steel wires (SW and VW grade)
se = 0.22 ut
sy = 0.45 ut
Where, ut is the ultimate tensile strength.
The fatigue diagram for the spring shown in the above fig. the mean stress m is plotted on
abscissa, while the stress amplitude a on the ordinate.
Point A with coordinates with
The line DC is parallel to line BA. Any point on line CD, such as X, represents a stress situation
with the same factor of safety. Line CD is called design line because it is used to find out
permissible stresses with a particular factor of safety.
Considering the similar triangles XFD and AEB,
1 = 2
Also Y1=Y2,
i.e.
. (2)
. (3)
Spring in series
F=
y=
Springs in parallel
Therefore
Where
Concentric springs
D1 = Mean diameter of coil of outer spring
D2 = Mean diameter of coil of inner spring
d1 = Wire diameter of outer spring
d2 = Wire diameter of inner spring
Lo1 = Free length of outer spring
Lo2 = Free length of inner spring
F = Total load on the springs
F1 = Load on the outer spring
F2 = Load on the inner spring
Leaf springs
Characteristics
1. Sometimes it is also called as a semi-elliptical spring; as it takes the form of a slender arc
shaped length of spring steel of rectangular cross section.
2. The center of the arc provides the location for the axle, while the tie holes are provided at
either end for attaching to the vehicle body.
3. Supports the chassis weight
4. Controls chassis roll more efficiently-high rear moment center and wide spring base
5. Controls rear end wrap-up
6. Controls axle damping
7. Controls braking forces
8. Regulates wheelbase lengths (rear steer) under acceleration and braking
Leaf Springs
In the cantilever beam type leaf spring, for the same leaf thickness,
h, leaf of uniform width, b (case 1) and, leaf of width, which is
uniformly reducing from b (case 2) is considered. From the basic
equations of bending stress and deflection, the maximum stress
max, and tip deflection max, can be derived.
[Type
The max is replaced by design stress des similarly, max is replaced by des. E is the material
property and depends on the type of spring material chosen.
L is the characteristic length of the spring.
Therefore, once the design parameters, given on the left side of the above equation, are fixed the
value of plate thickness, h can be calculated.
Substitution of h in the stress equation above will yield the value of plate width b.
In the similar manner h and b can be calculated for leaf springs of different support conditions
and beam types.
Laminated springs
One of the difficulties of the uniform strength beam, say Lozenge shape, is that the value of
width b sometimes is too large to accommodate in a machine assembly. One practice is that
instead of keeping this large width one can make several slices and put the pieces together as a
laminate. This is the concept of laminated spring. The Lozenge shaped plate is cut into several
longitudinal strips, as indicated in the figure.
The central strip, marked 1 is the master leaf which is placed at the top. Then two pieces, marked
2 are put together, side by side to form another leaf and placed below the top leaf. In the similar
manner other pairs of strips, marked 3 and 4 respectively are placed in the decreasing order of
strip length to form a laminated spring. Here width of each strip, bN is given as;
Cantilever Beam
Constants
C1
C2
Uniform Width
Non-Uniform Width
The values of the constants C1 and C2 for simply supported beam case
Simply Supported Beam
Constants
C1
C2
Uniform Width
Non-Uniform Width
To prove that stress developed in the full length leaves is 50% more than that in the
graduated leaves.
Step1: Bending stress and displacement in the graduated leaves
For analysis half the spring can be considered as a cantilever. It is assumed that the individual
leaves are separated and the master leaf placed at the center. Then the second leaf is cut
longitudinally into two halves, each of width (b/2) and placed on each side of the master leaf. A
similar procedure is repeated for rest of the leaves
The graduated leaves along with the master leaf thus can be treated as a triangular plate of
thicknesst as shown in figure 1.
Fig 1
Let,
For cantilever triangular plate, the deflection at the point of application of force is given by:
Fig 2
The bending stress developed in the full length leaves will be:
For a cantilever rectangular plate, the deflection at the point of application of force is given by:
Step 3:
Since the graduated leaves and the full leaves are clamped together the deflection for both should
be the same.
Also
Solving we get;
Hence proved.
Substituting
The stress in the full length leaves is 50% greater than the stress in the graduated leaves.
To distribute this additional stress from the full length leaves, pre-stressing is done. This
is achieved by bending the leaves to different radii of curvature, before they are
assembled with the centre bolt
The full length leaves are given in greater radii of curvature than the adjacent one. Due to
the different radii of curvature, when the full length leaves are staked with the graduated
leaves, without bolting, a gap is observed between them. This gap is called Nip
The nip eliminated by tightening of the center bolt due to these pre-stresses is induced in
the leaves. This method of pre-stressing by giving different radii of curvature is called as
nipping.
By giving a greater radius of curvature to the full length leaves than graduated leaves
before the leaves are assembled to form a spring.
Nip: C
The value of the initial Nip C is nothing but the difference in deflection between the full
length and the graduated leaves
Solving, we get;
Problem 20
Determine the width and thickness of a flat spring carrying a central load of 5000N.The
deflection is limited to 100mm. The spring is supported at both ends at a distance of
800mm. The allowable stress is 300N/mm2 and modulus of elasticity 221GPa. The
spring is of constant thickness and varying width.
Free length (L) should be less than 4 times the coil diameter (D) to avoid buckling for most
situations.
For slender springs central guide rod is necessary.
A guideline for free length (L) of a spring to avoid buckling is as follows,
For steel, where, ce is the end condition and its value is given below
ce
End condition
2.0
1.0
0.707
0.5
If the spring is placed between two rigid plates, then end condition may be taken as 0.5. If after
calculation it is found that the spring is likely to buckle then one has to use a guide rod passing
through the center of the spring axis along which the compression action of the spring takes
place.
The fundamental frequency can be obtained from the relationship given below.
Fundamental frequency:
Both ends within flat plates
Where K is the spring rate and Ws is the spring weight and d is the wire diameter, D is the coil
diameter, N is the number of active coils and is the specific weight of spring material.
The operational frequency of the spring should be at least 15-20 times less than its fundamental
frequency.
This will ensure that the spring surge will not occur and even other higher modes of frequency
can also be taken care of.
SPECIAL SPRINGS
The helical torsion spring resists the bending moment which tends to wind up the spring. The
primary stresses in this spring are flexural in contrast with torsional shear stresses in compression
or extension springs. The torsional moment on a spring produces a bending stress in the wire, the
bending moment on the wire being numerically equal to torsional moment. In addition to this
stress, there is a direct tensile or compressive stress due to the force F that is tangential to the
coil.
Each individual section of the torsion spring is considered as a curved beam.
Therefore using curved beam principle bending stress in torsion spring considering stress
concentration factor is
The stress in torsion spring taking into consideration the correction factor K
Where
Mt = Twisting moment
c = Spring Index
F = Force applied
i = Number of active coil
D = Mean diameter of coil
d= Wire diameter
L= Length of wire = Di
A = Cross sectional area of wire =
Z= Section modulus =
I = Moment of Inertia =
E = Modulus of Elasticity
Belleville Spring
Disc spring, also called Belleville spring are used where high capacity compression springs must
fit into small spaces.
Each spring consists of several annular discs that are dished to a conical shape as shown in
figure.
Where
C1 and C2 are constraints
t = thickness
h = height of spring
M = constant
F = axial force
do= outer diameter
di = inner diameter
= Poissons ratio
E = Modulus of elasticity
y = axial deflection
The ratio
Torsion springs
They are used in any application where
torque is required, such as door hinges,
automobile starters, etc