Agriculture and Food Security in Gicumbi District, Northern Province of Rwanda
Agriculture and Food Security in Gicumbi District, Northern Province of Rwanda
Agriculture and Food Security in Gicumbi District, Northern Province of Rwanda
International
Academic
Journal
of
Social Sciences
ISSN 2454-3918
www.iaiest.com
Abstract
This study presents a micro-analysis of agriculture and food security in Gicumbi District in Rwanda using
secondary data from National Institute of Statistics of Rwanda, Ministry of Agriculture and districts
reports. Data were analysed using SPSS and MS Excel. Findings indicated that environmental
characteristics favour agricultural activities in this district. Land is highly fragmented with 44% of the
population owning plots of less than 0.3ha. Most of the population (78%) own livestock mainly cows.
Main crops include Irish potato, beans, banana, and maize whereas the production of wheat and sorghum
was seen to have declined. The share of vegetables and fruits is small with 0.4% and 1% respectively.
Additionally, the proportion of households using agricultural inputs is still low where 11% used organic
manure, 16.5% applied chemical fertilizers, 27% used pesticides and 35% used improved seeds. Further,
results indicated that, within a household, most of adult people (82%) take meals twice a day while it is
thrice a week for a half of children (50%) and 58.3% of them had to rely on less preferred food in case of
inability to get enough food. Dietary needs are not met as food composition is unbalanced and largely
composed of food energy, moderately with proteins and poorly with lipids. This resulted in reduced status
of health and nutrition: anemic women (17%), anemic under-five children (37%), and stunted and
malnourished under-five children (47%). Findings suggest necessary programs on increasing the use of
agricultural inputs. It informs intervention aimed at improving on intakes of food like meat, dairy
products, legumes, vegetables and fruits in Gicumbi District.
Introduction
76
The farming sector occupies 73% of active population out of which 82% are women in rural areas.
According to EICV3 report (NISR, 2012), most of households in Rwanda own livestock which include
goats (53%), cattle (47%), and 46%). Self-employment in agricultural sector accounts for 60% whereas
(63%) obtain more than half of their income from agricultural sector (NISR and GMO, 2013; NISR and
MINECOFIN, 2014).
In recent years, there has been much improvement in agriculture sector. For example, farm mechanized
operations increased up to 13% in 2013; 83.7% of the farmers used fertilizers; and the total consolidated
land area, under crop intensification program, increased by 18-fold between 2008 and 2011. These have
resulted in increase, when compared to the base levels in 2007, in total production of maize by about 5
fold; wheat and cassava by about 3 fold; Irish potato, soybean and beans by about 2-fold; and rice by 30%
(Kathiresan, 2012).
Rwanda has reduced the proportion of the population below the poverty line from 59% in 2001 to 45% in
2011 due to the above performance in agriculture sector. However, despite government efforts to promote
the agriculture sector, high poverty coupled with poor food consumption, which represents an extremely
insufficient and unbalanced diet as well as prevalence of chronic malnutrition among children still remain
daunting challenge for economic development in Rwanda. The extreme poverty is still high at a rate of
24.1% and highest among households who obtain more than half of their income from farm wage work
(NISR, 2012, and MINECOFIN, 2014).
The combination of improved production in crop and animal related products has improved the
availability of both food and increased nutrition intake and energy gains. For instance, in Rwanda, an
increase in kcal/person per day since 2008 throughout the 2010 agricultural seasons was observed. The
estimated energy intake (kcal/ capita per day) was 2,675 and 2,938 for the respective seasons A and B of
2011 (NISR and WFP, 2012).
The food insecure households are typically poor, rural, living in small crowded homes and always
providing casual farm labour. According to NISR (2012), 64% of households are poor with borderline
food consumption, with 4% having an extremely insufficient and unbalanced diet. At district level,
Ngaruroro District is ranked the highest among households with unacceptable consumption with 44%
whereas Gakenke, and Nyaruguru Districts are among districts whose households (at least 70%) are poor
or have borderline food consumption. The prevalence of chronic malnutrition among children still stands
at 43% (NISR and WFP, 2012; NISR, 2012; NISR and MINAGRI, 2014).
There is inadequate empirical research on agriculture and food security in Rwanda and especially at
district level. Existing studies focused on macro and regional perspectives and did not deepen their
analysis at household and community levels. These include the Comprehensive Food Security and
Vulnerability Analysis and Nutrition (NISR and WFP, 2012); study on agriculture situational analysis
(IPAR, 2009); EICV 3 Thematic Report Agriculture (NISR, 2012). The aim of this paper is to assess the
current trends in agricultural production and food security in Gicumbi District, Northern Province in
Rwanda. The remainder of the paper is organized as follows. Section 2 presents data sources and analysis.
The context of the study area is presented in Section 3, Section 4 presents conclusion.
77
II.
This paper relies on secondary data from the National Institute of Statistics of Rwanda (NISR), the
Ministry of Agriculture (MINAGRI) and districts reports. Data are presented in two ways: (1) data from
published reports and (2) raw data from the NISR on Comprehensive Food Security and Vulnerability
Analysis and Nutrition in Rwanda. The raw data were collected in 2012 during survey on 864 households
from Gicumbi District. The assessment of food security is based on some indicators such as poverty,
agricultural productivity, calories per capita, diet diversity and nutrition of children as these indicators are
interrelated (FAO, 2008; Headey and Ecker, 2012). Agriculture is involved for its contribution to
reducing hunger and food insecurity through increasing the availability of food at prices that poor people
can afford and providing improved jobs and incomes that give poor people the means to access food
(Wiggins, 2004; Nile Basin Initiative, 2012). Data were analyzed using SPSS and MS Excel.
III.
This section provides key findings of this research in the context of the study area. It presents (i) land and
environmental characteristics; (ii) social, economic, and demographic characteristics of the population;
(iii) agricultural production features; and (iv) the status of food security and nutrition of the population
with emphasis on women and under-five children.
3.1 Land and Environmental characteristics
Gicumbi District is characterized by a relief with steep slopes and a mountainous topography. The area is
hilly with lateritic soils and granites in difference to Eastern part which is composed of valleys with
altitudes between 1,500 and 1,800 m. These environmental characteristics are meant to favour agricultural
activities in Gicumbi District (Table 1).
Land is an important asset in Rwanda. The total cultivated land area in Gicumbi District is 54,000 ha
equivalent to 4.4% of the national cultivated land area. Land is highly fragmented. For example, the
average arable land per household is 0.49 ha in Gicumbi District while about 44% of its population own
plots with less than 0.3 ha per household (NISR, 2012). About 90% of land in this district is protected
against erosion. Some of the techniques used to control erosion include terraces, ditches and trees planting
(Gicumbi District, 2013). However, the proportion of land irrigated and land affected by land use
consolidation is still low (Figure 1).
Table 1: Environmental characteristics in Gicumbi District
Gicunbi District
Altitude
1,500-1,800 m
Average Temperature
Main soil type
15-16C
Rwanda
900- 4,507 m
16 - 23C
Tropical
Tropical temperate
Rainfall
1,200-1,500mm
Source: Gicumbi District (2012; 2013), MINERENA (2011)
78
700-2,000 mm
Gicumbi
Rwanda
89.8
100
Percentages
78.1
80
60
44.4
45.8
40
20.8
20
0.1
11.5
0
% HHs with <
0.3 Ha
Land protected
against soil
erosion (%)
Land irrigated
(%)
% land affected
area by LUC
Rwanda
Percentage
50
40
44.8
35.9
32.3
30
45.7
32.7
26.8
26.2
31
27.2
20
8.7
10
34.5
10.1
0
Non-poor
Vulnerable Moderately
poor
79
Severely
poor
% Poor
people in
2002
% Poor
people in
2012
With regard to employment, the employment rate is 86% (Figure 3a). The majority of the population
(67%) earns their income form small scale agriculture farmers compose. They are followed by those
earning their income in non-farm sector (16.5%) as indicated in Figure 3b.
90
Gicumbi
Rwanda
85.9 84.2
80
60
Percentages
Percentage
70
60
50
40
30
50
40
30
16.516.9
20
13.5 15
20
10
Gicumbi
Rwanda
66.6
61.8
70
8.9 9.9
10
0.7 0.9
7.2
9.7
0.8 1.8
b. Income sources
a. Employment status
Fig 3. Employment and income sources in Gicumbi District
Source: NISR (2012), Gicumbi District (2013)
80
25
Percentages
20
15
20.3
18.8
12.6
12.7
10.4
12.2
18.7
Gicumbi
Rwanda
20.4
13.6
10.3
10
5
0
Maize
Ordinary
beans
Climbing
beans
Crops
Banana
Irish potatoes
81
Gicunbi
Rwanda
35
40
Percentages
28.9
30
27.1
30.5
18.8
16.5
20
10.8
9.3
10
0
Organic fertilizer Chemical fertilizer
Pesticides
Improved seeds
82
Gicumbi
Rwanda
25.0
20.9
19.5
13.6
10.0
5.0
60
50
40
30
17
20
10
0.0
Staple
crops
79
70
15.0
Overall
87
80
Percentages
Percentages
20.0
90
19.7
19.3
17.3
Gicumbi
Rwanda
Fruits and
Vegetables
12
1
0
Poor
Borderline Acceptable
83
Adult (>15years)
100.0
Children (<15years)
82.1
Percentages
80.0
50.2
60.0
34.0
40.0
20.0
15.2
13.2
2.5
2.8
0.0
0.0
1
2
3
Number of times
>3
41.7
6.1
9.0
8.8
8.6
3.0
2.0
20.8
100.0
56.8
11.6
9.0
6.1
4.9
2.5
0.5
8.6
100.0
57.1
5.9
8.6
7.9
5.8
1.9
0.1
12.8
100.0
64.5
9.3
7.2
6.6
3.4
1.4
0.3
7.4
100.0
57.8
8.1
6.7
4.7
5.4
1.7
0.3
15.2
100.0
Other
Source: NISR and WFP (2012)
89.2
0.9
0.1
1.3
0.9
0.1
0.2
7.2
100.0
Total
Dietary diversity
According to MINAGRI (2013) an adult person should consume a diet composed of food energy (2,100
kcal/capita/day), proteins (59 g/capita/day) and lipids 40g/capita/day). The production of food energy in
Gicumbi District, between 2006 and 2012, is indicated in Figure 8a. It indicated that, generally, the level
of food energy production in this district (2,625.8 Kcal/capita/day) exceeds the national production level
(2,347.7 Kcal/capita/day) with a statistically significant difference at 5% (Pr=0.0189), and all above the
Pr means p-value
84
standard level of 2,100 Kcal/capita/day. The difference between districts level of food energy production
and standard level was statistically significant at 1% (Pr=0.0057).
Protein_
Gicumbi
100
Protein & Lipids (g/capita/day)
Energy (Kcal/Capita/day)
4,000
90
3,500
80
3,000
Protein_
Rwanda
70
2,500
60
2,000
50
1,500
Protein_
Adult
humans
requireme
nt
Lipids_
Gicumbi
40
1,000
30
500
20
10
2006B
2007A
2007B
2008A
2008B
2009A
2009B
2010A
2011A
2012A
2006B
2007A
2007B
2008A
2008B
2009A
2009B
2010A
2011A
2012A
Agricultural seasons
Gicumbi
Rwanda
Adult humans requirement
Lipids_
Rwanda
Agricultural seasons
85
Types of shocks
manner they were accustomed to or affected what their households owned. Some of these situations are
highlighted in Figure 9 and they include droughts, serious illness or accident of household member, and
unusual high level of human diseases.
Other
Hailstones
3.2
Insecurity/Violence
0.4
Robbery of productive resources
1.6
Death
5.7
Serious illness or accident of HH member
Reduced income of a HH member
1.2
Loss/reduced employment for a HH member
2.4
Unusually high cost of agricultural inputs 0.4
Unusually high price for food
2.4
Unusually high level of human diseases
Unusually high level of livestock diseases
0.8
Unusually high level of crop pests & diseases
5.7
Landslides/Erosion
5.3
Floods
3.2
Drought/Irregular rains, prolonged dry spell
0.0
11.3
10.0
19.8
12.6
33.2
20.0
Percentages
30.0
40.0
86
Gicumbi
Rwanda
40
36.7
38.1
50
46.6
Gicumbi
44
Rwanda
45
35
40
Percentages
Percentages
30
25
17.3
16.6
20
15
35
30
25
20
15
10
10
8.4
11
1.4 3
0
Women
Stunted
U-5 Children
a. Anemia Prevalence
Figure 10: Nutritional Status in Gicumbi District
Source: NISR (2012)
IV.
b.
Wasted
Underweight
Conclusion
The aim of this study was to present a micro-analysis of agriculture and food security in Gicumbi District
located in Nothern Province of Rwanda. Environmental characteristics favor agricultural activities in this
district. Though land is highly fragmented with about 44% of its population having plots with less than
0.3 ha per household, the main crops found in this district include Irish potato, beans, banana, and maize.
The production of crops such as wheat and sorghum has considerably declined as their shares remain 4%
and 0% respectively. Further, the share of vegetables and fruits is too small (0.4% and 1% respectively).
Of the total population, 77.8% of the households own farm animals, mainly cattle, which contribute
largely to the daily production and to the welfare of the population in Gicumbi District. The proportion of
the households that apply different types of agricultural inputs is still low. There is a room for improving
the application of fertilizers (mainly inorganic fertilizers) and use of improved seeds in this district.
The diversity in food crop production indicates that the districts populations preferences can be met.
However, dietary needs are not met in Gicumbi District. Food composition is not balanced and is largely
composed of food energy, moderately composed of proteins and poorly composed of lipids. There is a
need to improve on intakes of foods such as meat, dairy products, legumes, vegetables and fruits.
The unbalanced diet had affected negatively health and nutrition status of the population. About 17% of
women were anemic, while the anemia prevalence rate among under-five children was 37%. Further, the
proportion of under-five children who were stunted and chronically malnourished was high at 47%,
followed by underweight children at 8.4% and wasted children at 1.4%. Findings suggest necessary
measures to improve on nutrition in Gicumbi District.
87
Acknowledgment
Authors of this paper are grateful to the National Institute of Statistics of Rwanda (NISR), to the Ministry
of Agriculture (MINAGRI) and to Gicumbi District for making data accessible. Without access to data
and reports from these institutions, the objective of this study would not have been achieved.
Reference
Booth, D., and Golooba-Mutebi, F. (2012). Policy for agriculture and horticulture in Rwanda: A different
political economy? FAC/ PEAPA Working Paper 038
Clay, E. (2003). Chapter 2: Food security: concepts and measurement. The Overseas Development
Institute, London, UK, for the FAO Expert Consultation on Trade and Food Security:
Conceptualizing the Linkages, Rome, 11-12 July 2002.
FAO [Food and Ahriculture Organization] (2008). An Introduction to the Basic Concepts of Food
Security.
The
EC
FAO
Food
Security
Programme.
http://www.fao.org/docrep/013/al936e/al936e00.pdf
Gicumbi District (2012). District Development Plan (2013-2018. The Northern Province
Gicumbi District (2013). Districts Potentialities Assessment for the Integrated and Self-Centered Local
Economic Development. The Northern Province
Headey, D., and Ecker, O. (2012). Improving the Measurement of Food Security. The IFPRI Discussion
Paper 01225
IPAR [Institute of Policy Analysis and Research] (2009). Rwandan Agriculture Sector Situational
Analysis: An IPAR Sector Review. Kigali, Rwanda
Jones, A. D., Ngure, F. M., Pelto, G., and Young, S. L. (2013). What Are We Assessing When We
Measure Food Security? A Compendium and Review of Current Metrics. Adv Nutr vol. 4: 481505
Kathiresan, A. (2012). Farm land use consolidation in Rwanda: Assessment from the perspectives of
agriculture sector. The Ministry of Agriculture and Animal Resources
MINAGRI [Ministry of Agriculture and Animal Resources] (2012). Annual Report FY 2010/2011. Kigali,
Rwanda
MINERENA (Ministry of Natural Resources] (2011). Water Resources Management Sub-Sector Strategic
Plan (2011 2015). Kigali, Rwanda.
Nanama, S., and Souli, K. (2007). Two Methods for Measuring Household Food Security and
Vulnerability - Evidence from the Zondoma Food Security Initiative, Burkina Faso. Africare
Food Security Review
Nile Basin Initiative (2012). Agriculture, Food Security, and Livelihoods in the Nile Basin.
http://nileis.nilebasin.org/system/files/Nile%20SoB%20Report%20Chapter%205%20%20Agriculture.pdf
NISR [National Institute of Statistics of Rwanda] (2012). EICV3 Thematic Report: Income. Kigali,
Rwanda
88
NISR [National Institute of Statistics of Rwanda] (2012). The evolution of poverty in Rwanda from 2000
to 2011: Results from the household surveys (EICV). Kigali, Rwanda
NISR [National Institute of Statistics of Rwanda] (2012). The Third Integrated Household Living
Conditions Survey (EICV3): Main Indicators Report. Kigali, Rwanda
NISR [National Institute of Statistics of Rwanda] and GMO [Gender Monitoring Office] (2013). National
Gender Statistics Report 2013. Kigali, Rwanda
NISR [National Institute of Statistics of Rwanda] and MINECOFIN [Ministry of Finance and Economic
Planning] (2014). Fourth Population and Housing Census, Rwanda, 2012: Thematic ReportLabour force participation
NISR [National Institute of Statistics of Rwanda] and WFP [World Food Program] (2012).
Comprehensive Food Security and Vulnerability Analysis and Nutrition on Survey. Kigali,
Rwanda
NISR [National Institute of Statistics of Rwanda] (2010). Demographic and Health Survey (DHS). Kigali,
Rwanda
Rwanda Agricultural Board [RAB] (2014). Estimates presented at the Rwanda Civil Society Platform at
SERENA Hotel, 3rd February, 2015. Kigali, Rwanda
Wiggins, S. (2004). Agriculture, hunger and food security. The UK Department for International
Development (DFID)
89
Annex
Annex 1: Production of various crops for season 2013 A in Gicumbi District
90