Data Center Transformations
Data Center Transformations
Abstract
Changes in information technology (IT) can be split into two broad categories. Moves, additions and changes
(MAC) are day-to-day IT activities which involve adding and removing end-user personnel, changing end-user locations such as when an employee moves to a different cubicle and upgrades services. Build outs, consolidations and
acquisitions (BOCA) are large-scale projects which can be very disruptive and require careful planning and implementation to maintain operations. Key considerations are the complexity and risks such data center transformations
bring with them and establishing a process that ensures success. This white paper examines the BOCA process and
what is required to meet IT goals and objectives and maintain business continuity.
Implementing an effective BOCA project requires progress through five basic stages: assess, plan, build, stabilize
and optimize. This paper will discuss each of the five stages and how the right remote access and IT infrastructure
management tools, deployed early and used for monitoring and management throughout the process, will dramatically improve overall efficiency. Furthermore, by minimizing the need to travel and reducing cycle times these tools
can play a critical role in successfully implementing a BOCA project in a timely, productive and efficient manner.
Does the senior business management team understand what they are asking of the IT department?
Does the business realize that IT transformation logistics planning are critical in order to maintain IT services?
Are key interdependencies identified and rationalized between the business and IT?
Have the risks been assessed and contingency plans been developed?
Implementing an effective BOCA project progresses through five basic stages: assess, plan, build, stabilize and optimize. This paper will discuss each of the five stages and how the right remote access and IT infrastructure management tools, deployed early and monitored throughout the process, will dramatically improve overall efficiency.
By installing robust out-of-band KVM (Keyboard, Video, Mouse) switches and serial console servers early on, the
BOCA team gets the benefits of detailed network information and remote access early in the project. Beyond a
traditional IT equipment focus, intelligent power distribution tools that optimize the consumption and distribution
of power can dramatically improve the total operational efficiency.
Raritan.com
Raritan.com
Page 1
Simplicity: proliferation of complex systems makes it more important than ever to have a management
tool that reduces the number of touch points needed to monitor and respond to network events.
Continuity: developing robust fault tolerant infrastructure by identifying, prioritizing and managing risks.
Partnership: align the business and IT managers to a common and well-defined outcome.
Transparency: milestone reporting to up-stream managers that flags problems before they become disasters.
An IT department won't make a move until they are confident that real-time availability, security and mean time to
repair (MTTR) will not be adversely affected. In fact, one of the planning goals, perhaps even the reason for the
move, is likely to be that these areas improve.
Raritan.com
Page 2
A Window of Opportunity
The build stage of data center transformations offers windows of opportunity to upgrade to better equipment or
facilities and to simplify operations. Often the two go hand in hand. A BOCA allows IT and facility managers to
standardize on one or a few hardware and software platforms. This makes the data center more manageable and
reduces the number of vendors which further simplifies matters. For example, IT managers might opt for a
particular model of server and facility managers might opt for a particular model of equipment rack. With the right
information, IT and facility managers can coordinate their efforts, for example, ensuring appropriate cooling and
power distribution schemes.
Raritan.com
Page 3
A data center transformation is also an opportunity to implement or refine business continuity and disaster recovery
(BCDR) plans. Such plans often involve remote locations and multiple systems, cutting across a variety of organizations. Security, a key issue in its own right and in BCDR plans, must be maintained during the transformation and,
hopefully, improved as one of the transformation goals. One way this can be accomplished is by creating a lights-out
data center limiting physical access to only hardware upgrades and repairs and by restricting access with policybased KVM over IP for server management and access to intelligent PDUs for power monitoring and control.
Power management has become a major issue for data center managers. As the global price of fossil fuels increase
and the per-unit increase in thermal output rises and IT tools become smaller and faster, power management is
quickly rising to the top of do-more-with-less issues for the IT industry. Minimizing equipment by implementing
virtualization can reduce power demands, though for some applications virtualization drives servers hard so the
power savings may not be as great as anticipated. Reducing power consumption reduces the amount of heat and
thus the cooling required. Virtualization also conserves scarce rack space. But when multiple services are running
on one server it becomes even more critical that IT administrators be able to access and fix problem devices quickly.
The many potential pitfalls in the build stage of a transformation can lead to increased and unnecessary costs from
duplication of efforts, duplication of equipment and the costs associated with missing service level agreements
(SLAs).
Raritan.com
Page 4
Heat Removal
Cooling requires careful analysis of the data center as a whole including air flow, vents, air conditioning, the racks
and which equipment is in which racks. Sometimes, the interactions of these various factors are not obvious or may
even be counterintuitive. For example, adding additional air conditioning might cause some racks to become hotter,
not cooler. This can happen if circulation patterns change, e.g., the new air conditioning creates hot air eddy currents instead of allowing hot air to reach return ducts.
A data center is an ecosystem unto itself. Cable and components deployed in the space will have an effect on the
overall climate control capabilities of the space. The cables cannot be installed in a random manner; they must be
placed with a minimal impact on airflow paths and heated air removal.
Proper selection, configuration and deployment of data center enclosures should be viewed with a keen eye to any
effects on room climate control. Enclosures supporting termination and network hardware will have lower heat
loads (even for large switches) than those supporting rack mount servers. But with the large number of cables
running into termination and network enclosures, care must be taken not to create installations that block air
supply and discharge paths. Once in the enclosures, the large volume of cable can act as air dams possibly
preventing adequate airflow and circulation.
There are a variety of products for heat removal - passive and active air solutions as well as water cooled cabinets
or components. Care must be taken to route cables so as not to interfere with the deployment of these systems.
Server enclosures are most likely to be affected but there could also be an impact on network enclosures.
Cable bundles cannot be placed in potential airflow paths which can be almost anywhere within the enclosure
footprint, but most likely in the rear door for exhaust fans in rack mount server cabinets, base or roof surfaces for
chimney air removal systems or front and rear sides for water cooled cabinets. It may not be practical to keep all
these spaces clear, but a forward looking program will reduce the impact if and when these systems are deployed.
Enclosures & BOCA
As a continuing part of the BOCA process, enclosure selection and deployment must also be given careful
consideration. The enclosures containing passive and active components along with all related connectivity and
power cables have an underappreciated yet vital role in the cable management system and BOCA process.
For simplicity, data center enclosures can be divided into three basic categories - Termination, Network and Server each supporting different components and services. As the names imply, the Termination enclosure will support
patch panels and related cable management hardware. The Network enclosures support active components, e.g.,
switches, routers, etc. Server enclosures hold rack mount server and storage components and related ancillary
hardware. Each of the three can have different configurations based on the type of cable, e.g., copper or fiber
optic, and cable density, types and number of installed components and climate control needs. When selecting
enclosures to support these applications, footprint and maximizing the use on internal spaces becomes critical.
In a perfect data center, it would be ideal to have the enclosures identified and deployed according to this scheme
patch panels in termination cabinets supporting network enclosures providing connectivity out to rows of server
enclosures (See Figure 1). While many new data centers are laid out along these lines, this is not always achievable
for existing data centers with limited floor space and pre-installed infrastructure. But, even these sites can benefit
from a properly implemented BOCA process.
Raritan.com
Page 5
Raritan.com
Page 6
Raritan.com
Page 7
The Solutions
Secure, remote access is an important feature to consider for any data center but it is particularly relevant for a
BOCA project. Since there are different approaches to remote access it is important to choose the right one while
the window of opportunity is open.
Software-based remote access products work unless the application becomes corrupted, the operating system
hangs or the device itself needs to be power cycled. Better remote access solutions provide enterprise-grade
security, BIOS-level (Basic Input/Output System) and console-level access to IT infrastructure and support for remote
power cycling and monitoring. Best-in-class solutions support both in-band and out-of-band network management.
The main purpose of a KVM switch is to enable a single KVM console to access and control multiple devices.
KVM switches eliminate the need for separate keyboards, video monitors and mice freeing up valuable physical
space and reducing demand for electric power and cooling. They also allow out-of-band access, control and
management of servers even if the network is down. A KVM switch, integrated with intelligent PDUs for power
management, allows a complete system reboot. Remote access via KVM over IP makes possible geographicallydistributed lights-out data centers with highly-secure limited physical access.
Remote access has the obvious advantage of reducing travel time and costs and as a result collapses cycle times.
The costs of managing servers and other devices in complex networks are now twice the costs of the servers and
devices themselves. By virtually bringing together geographically-dispersed subject matter experts cycle times can be
further reduced due to the benefits of collaboration. If IT staff can access troubled devices from wherever they are
with at-the-rack access then two or more IT subject matter experts can work together solving problems. A further
refinement to collaboration is support for limited, policy-based access. For example, a Cisco expert might only be
given access to Cisco devices.
By allowing one or more users to access and control multiple servers or other target devices, KVM switches enable
businesses of all sizes to realize reduced costs, improved business continuity and more robust security. There are
many other advantages too such as less IT staff turnover and improved end-user customer satisfaction.
Raritan solutions include remote out-of-band and in-band access. BIOS-level out-of-band access is provided by
the Dominion KX KVM-over-IP switches and the Dominion SX secure serial console servers. Remote in-band
monitoring of an entire network is provided by CommandCenter NOC. Remote power control is supported by the
Raritan Dominion PX intelligent PDU which can be integrated with the other tools to create a complete solution.
Policy-based permissions and access to, and consolidation of, all these solutions is provided by the CommandCenter
Secure Gateway.
Michael Carpinella, Technical Services Director of the law firm Duane Morris, LLP summed up the offering as follows,
"The Raritan solution provided a great way for us to simplify and accelerate many of our data center work processes, as well as to reduce our incident response times." "Software installation, troubleshooting problems, reconfiguring network cards, server installation - all these things are done more quickly now through CommandCenter Secure
Gateway. Being able to see every server from one console is the ideal situation."
Raritan.com
Page 8
Conclusion
This white paper presented a disciplined approach to BOCA projects consisting of five phases: assess, plan, build,
stabilize, and optimize. Techniques and tools were discussed that can make a BOCA project less complex and less
time consuming thereby making it easier for IT administrators to overlay the project on top of their already hectic
and stressful day-to-day network management tasks.
IT administrators should take advantage of the window of opportunity a BOCA project offers for improved IT
productivity and efficiency while enabling peace of mind for the business because disruption of mission critical
process can be managed and avoided. While the chance to upgrade equipment and address environmental
issues such as cooling are obvious, the chance to implement new processes and procedures that can lead to
better end-user satisfaction and cross-functional teamwork are not so obvious. Choosing the right tools and
thinking through the best ways to deploy them is important for the success of the transition and for meeting
ongoing goals and objectives of the new, or at least modified, data center. As discussed in this paper, remote
IT infrastructure management is a critical tool and can positively impact many aspects of a BOCA project and
a data center's operations.
About Raritan
Raritan is a leading provider of management solutions that simplify IT operations. Based on KVM (Keyboard, Video,
Mouse) switches, serial console servers, management software, power management and remote connectivity,
Raritan's secure solutions drive data center and branch office efficiency and productivity in more than 50,000 locations around the world. Raritan also serves the OEM market by developing advanced, hardware-based, remote-management components based on KVM-over-IP and IPMI technologies. Founded in 1985, Raritan today has 38 offices
worldwide, and its products are distributed in 76 countries. For more information, please visit Raritan.com
Herb Villa, Field Technical Manager of Rittal Corporation, contributed to this document.
2007 Raritan, Inc. All rights reserved. Raritan, When you're ready to take control, CommandCenter and Dominion are registered trademarks
of Raritan, Inc. or its wholly-owned subsidiaries. All other marks are registered trademarks or trademarks of their respective owners.
Raritan.com
C1012