Legislative Drafting (Extract)
Legislative Drafting (Extract)
Legislative Drafting (Extract)
Consistent spelling
1
Latin expressions.
More words than necessary; For instance, all and singular, Aid and
abet, each and every, Full force of the law, null and void, will and
testament, unless and until, as to whether this happened, by reason
of, in lieu of, in relation to, in the event that (if), permitted to may)
Write:
Do not write:
offence.
Write:
Do not write:
Write:
Do not write:
A person who shall permit a dog to soil a pavement shall
commit an offence
Write:
A person who allows a dog to soil a pavement
commits an offence
Do not write:
Up to nine persons may be appointed by the Cabinet
Secretary to be members of the Advisory Committee
Write:
The passive voice places the receiver of the action before the main
person.
SHALL
The drafter should use shall to impose a duty or an obligation. That MUST
be performed for certain ends of justice to be attained.
Illustration:
A driver shall provide a license on demand.
Shall should not be used to predict the future. Where the intention is to
predict future action, the word to use is will
A drafter should avoid the use of shall to confer a right.
Illustration:
Do not write:
Write:
Do not use shall to state a rule of law or how it applies. This creates a
false imperative.
Illustrations:
Do not write:
Write:
Do not write:
Write:
Do not write:
It shall be unlawful.
Write:
It is unlawful.
ANY
Any means one or some.
It is often misused in a legislative sentence when one person or thing is
being referred to.
It can often be replaced by a, an
Illustration:
Do not write:
The Cabinet Secretary must consult any organization
which appears to the Cabinet Secretary to represent a substantial number
of coffee growers.
EACH
Each refers to two or more in a numerical context where there has been
previous identification. Used when referring or laying emphasis on an
individual from an identified pool.
Illustration:
There are ten attorneys in the Division. Each is a lawyer of ten years
standing.
EVERY
Every implies a class.
Illustration:
Every attorney is a lawyer.
The reference in this example is to each attorney of an identified class.
ALL
The word all is a spurious form of emphasis and should not be used. All is
used for purposes of determining collective responsibility.
Illustration:
All elected members hold office for three years.
SUCH
Such is misused in legislation and creates ambiguity.
It should be substituted with the word the, a or that.
SAME
5
Same is used as a preceding noun or phrase in legal jargon and does not
add to a legislative meaning.
It should not be used as it creates ambiguity.
The word it or them can be used as a substitute
AND
And is usually construed conjunctively and connotes togetherness.
A drafter should use and to connect two or more phrases, conditions or
events all of which must occur
Illustration:
The register includes;
a) each person who is seventy years or older;
b) each person who is permanently physically disabled; and
c) each person who has been declared mentally incompetent.
OR
OR is construed disjunctively and suggests a choice between two or more
options.
A drafter should use or to connect two or more phrases events,
conditions, when only one or more but not all need occur.
Illustration:
The register includes each person who:
a. Is seventy years or older, or
b. Is physically disabled or
c. Has been declared mentally incompetent.
WARNING
Never use and/or rather use A or B or both
A, AN, THE
6
DEEM
Deeming clauses should only be used to create a legal fiction.
It may be used to provide for the retroactive operation of an Act.
Example.
This Act is deemed to have come into force on the first day of January
2000.
WHERE
The use of the word where conveys a description of a factual situation;
suggesting a place or venue, referring to situations, to define a set of
circumstances.
Example:
Where dogs are running at large.
WHEN
The use of when in legislative drafting is to indicate a single or rare
concurrence or occurrence of a contemplated event. You are not certain
that the events will take place.
Example
When the fees has been paid
The drafter may use if to state a condition in a legislative sentence.
Example;
Section 10 which was amended in 1956 was repealed in 1966.
A non-restrictive clause does not need to be set-off by commas.
Words of Authority
Use words of authority with care.
When drafting rules, contracts, and other forms of legal documents, be
precise and consistent in using words of authority such as must, shall,
will, may, should and their negative forms, such as must not, and
will not.
Dont use shall for any purpose because it is simply too unreliable
PUNCTUATION
Punctuation is used by the drafter to assist the reader of the law to
understand the text easily.
There are general rules about punctuation as follows:
PUNCTUATION RULES
1. Punctuate sparingly and with purpose. Unnecessary punctuation
can be very distracting, the drafter should ensure that every
punctuation mark must serve a purpose.
2. Punctuate for structure and not for sound. A drafter should test
every punctuation mark to see whether it assist in explaining the
structure of the sentence.
3. Be conventional. While most other forms of prose writing admit a
measure of individuality, legislative drafting does not. The drafter
should adhere to the conventional use of punctuation marks.
4. Be consistent. Inconsistency is the most common error in the area of
punctuation. A haphazard use of punctuation marks, especially the
comma can destroy the value of punctuation.
After a heading.
After a number.
THE COMMA
A comma may be used to separate items in a series of words, phrases or
clauses.
Separating comma
Use a comma after introductory elements. Separating comma may separate
an introductory modifying clause or phrase from what follows.
Illustration;
When amount of compensation payable is determined, the Cabinet
Secretary must issue a certificate.
10
Illustration:
A person who willfully alters, conceals, destroys or refuses to produce a
register commits an offence and is liable.
Livestock means cattle, horses, goats, sheep and pigs.
(ii)
(iii)
Illustration:
In 1996, 16 subsidies were granted.
In 2005, one hundred chicken were sold.
Enclosing Commas
They only operate in pairs. If one is omitted, the other remaining bit is
useless.
Use commas to set off nonrestrictive elements.
The car, which is blue, ran the red light.
Use commas to set off parenthetical elements.
The presidents indictment was, to say the least, unexpected.
11
APOSTROPHES
Use apostrophes to form possessives.
Used to form the plural of some terms.
Illustration
(She got mostly Bs in school.)
Use apostrophes in contractions and abbreviations.
12
THE SEMI-COLON
The function of the semi-colon is to show a relationship between elements of
a sentence which a complete break into separate sentence may obscure.
It is a mark of co-ordination.
A semi-colon is used in two ways:
It may join in one sentence two independent clauses which are closely
related to make it desirable for purposes of showing their coherence
in one sentence.
13
HYPHEN
14
The hyphen should generally only be used when the words proper spelling
includes a hyphen.
The following are exceptions to this rule:
Illustration:
Anti-Semitic
Pre-1914
Follow common usage in hyphenating compound modifiers.
Use hyphens for compound numbers and fractions.
Use a hyphen to divide a word at the end of a line.
PARENTHESIS
Parenthesis is used for giving examples, explanations and illustrations that
are connected with the message of the sentence.
They must be used with care because they have a probability of diverting
attention.
(i)
Illustration:
No person may subdivide land, unless the subdivision is effected by a
transfer, exchange, or other disposition of land made by an order under
section 129B of the property law Act 1974 (which relates to the granting of
access to land locked land).
(ii)
(iii)
15
(iv)
Write:
Split infinitives
A split infinitive is a grammatical construction where a word phrase, usually
an adverb or adverbial phrase occurs between the maker to and bare
infinitive form of the verb.
In English, an infinitive verb fulfils the function of a noun and is formed with
to; for example, to take, to laugh and to be.
An example of a split infinitive is to boldly go where no man had gone
before.
The infinitive is to go and it is split by the adverb boldly
16
Example:
Childrens television
POSITIVE WRITING
The drafter should write positively; if an idea can be expressed either
positively or negatively, it should be expressed positively.
Example:
Do not write:
Write:
The use of several negatives in one sentence should not be used. A negative
can be expressed in positive from such as:
Did not remember
Left out
Forgot
Omitted
-
Ignored
CAPITALIZATION
17
(ii)
Example:
Ghana.
Lesotho.
(iii)
(iv)
(v)
(vi)
Example
Minister may by legislative instrument make regulation.
Do not write:
Write:
(v)
(vi)
Act of Parliament.
Names and titles of persons of considerable eminence, for example,
President, Chief Justice, Governor, Attorney General et cetera
For words of general significance if used in a special or technical
sense. For example, referring to a Dispute Tribunal
We do not use upper case for words such as ; quote, judge,
government unless they have a similar specific sense for example,
18
Example:
The doctor will treat each patient suffering from typhoid, fever and malaria
fever.
If the plural must be used in a compound word, the significant word takes
the plural as shown below:
Do not write
Write
Attorney-generals
Attorneys general
Notary publics
Notaries Public
Director-generals
Directors general
ABBREVIATIONS
19
COUPLETS
Where words have the same effect or the meaning of one word includes the
other, the drafter should not use word pairs.
Do not write
Write
Authorize or direct
Means or includes
Each or every
Null or void
Full or complete
LISTING
When listing membership of a body, a use comma as the sentence is
continuous. Use a colon at the end of the introductory words and semicolons at the end of each paragraph when listing objects and functions in
tabular form. After the penultimate item, use and or or as appropriate.
20
PARAGRAPHS
Short paragraphs improve the clarity of a provision. Each paragraph should
deal with a single topic. Lengthy, complex or technical provisions should be
split into a series of related paragraphs.
Fire fighter
Workman
Worker
The crew
21
Chairman
Chairperson
Draftsman
Draftsperson
Nurse
Health personnel
Do not write:
Write:
Do not write:
Write:
Do not write:
work done.
Write:
Do not write:
Write:
Write:
(3 marks)
ARCHAIC WORDS
Legalese in archaic words should be avoided as it mystery heretofore or
other similar words should not be used; a possible word hereby although
the phrase by this Act can be used as institute.
EXPRESSING NUMBERS
In legislation, numbers should be expressed in words. Wrong figures can be
typed accidentally if figures are used. In Schedules however, figures may be
used.
WORD ECONOMY
Verbosity should be avoided and legal language should be as direct as
possible.
REFERENTIAL LEGISLATION
Where reference is made in one legislation to another, it is important to
ensure that the imported legislation fits in.
There may be problems with the meaning of words where this has changed
due to judicial precedent.
In order to avoid the situation where reference is made to another
enactment to determine meaning, the provision from the referred text
should be repeated.
USES OF PRECEDENTS
Very few things are novel, the drafter can benefit from information gained
from the laws of other jurisdictions, more especially with the access
information communication technology had provided. This reference should
however be handled with caution since the circumstances in each country
differ. It may better to base a draft on precedent within the jurisdiction than
to modify foreign legislation carelessly.
Question 6; Study the following statutory provision and break it up
into separate legislative sentences, in your own words, but without
changing the meaning. Where possible each sentence should begin
with the relevant legal subject, then the legal action, and then the
context. Make sure that you use proper punctuation and in and out
denting.
Section 86A (5) Income Tax Act
Question 6(b) : If an intending appellant wishes to appeal against a
decision of the Tax Court to the Court of Appeal, the Registrar of the
Tax Court shall submit the notice or notices of intention to appeal
lodged under subsection (3) to the president of the Tax Court who
shall, having regard to the contemplated grounds of the intended
appeal or appeals as indicated in the said notice or notices, make an
24
Provision A
Section 86A (5) Income Tax Act
(5) if an intending appellant wishes to appeal against a decision of
the Tax Court to the Court of Appeal, the Registrar of the Tax Court
shall submit the notice or notices of intention to appeal lodged
under subsection (3) to the president of the Tax Court who shall,
having regard to the contemplated grounds of the intended appeal
or appeals as indicated in the said notice or notices, make an order
granting or refusing, as he sees fit, leave to appeal against such
decision to the said court and the order so made shall be final.
(7 marks)
Provision B
Section 43 (1) of the Customs and Excise Act, 1964
(amended by section 124 of Act 60 of 2001)
1) If entry of imported goods has been made under the
provisions of section 38
(a)
In the case of goods in a container depot,
within 28 days from the date the goods were landed;
or
(b)
In the case of any goods, on expiry of the
prescribed period, the master, pilot or other carrier,
container operator, person in control of a transit
25
(c)
26
1) Order 1
i) Rule 1
(a) Sub-rule (1)
1. Paragraph (1)
i. Subparagraph (i)
Principal provisions
Final provisions
Savings
Transitional provisions
Repeals and consequential amendments
Schedules
Arrangement of sections
The arrangement of sections is on a separate page immediate before the Act
The wording is the same as that used for the head notes or marginal notes
in the Act an\d serves as s useful index to the Act
It does not form part of the Act and is not subject to debate in Parliament
Arrangement of parts
A Bill should only be divided into parts when each Part stand alone to form
the subject of another Act, otherwise headings should be used in provisions
KEY!!!!!
Long title
This is the starting point of the Act and indicates the general purpose and
intention of the legislation. It must be introduced to Parliament as a Bill
first.
A BILL FOR AN ACT
28
The Preamble
It is an aid to construction to explain the reasons for an enactment
They are seldom used nowadays and are limited to Acts dealing with
constitutional matters or the application of international conventions or
Acts of historical or ceremonial nature.
Enacting formula
This is generally provided for in the Constitution, the Interpretation Act or
other legislation dealing with this and other matters concerned with the
procedure of Parliament.
ENACTED by Parliament as followsIt comes right after the long title.
Question 5: The Kenyan Government has
decided to establish a corporation to establish
a corporation to be known as the Nuclear
Atomic Commission. The Commissions primary
mandate shall be to prepare Kenya for the
production of nuclear energy and to manage
any such nuclear plants. The commission must
have between three and five members,
including the chairperson. The members must
be Kenyan and must be qualified in sciencerelated fields. At least one must be a lawyer to
provide guidance on legal matters.
You are a parliamentary counsel in the Drafting
Department. Prepare the draft Bill establishing
the commission. [15 marks]
Question;
[facts provided] Prepare the Bill establishing
the Commission. The Bill should establish the
Commission as a body corporate with all
attributes of a legal person. Provide for
appointment
of
Commissioners
by
the
President upon approval by parliament.
The Bill must clearly provide for:
a) appropriate title;
b) establishment of the Commission and its
composition;
c) objects and functions of the Commission;
d) term of office, and
e) clause on offences.
Do not include provisions on reporting and
finances.
(15
marks)
Question 5:
[Instructions given] Draft the Bill
(15
marks)
30