Gams - Notion and Forms of Contact Karst
Gams - Notion and Forms of Contact Karst
Gams - Notion and Forms of Contact Karst
30/2
33-46
LJUBLJANA 2001
COBISS: 1.08
33
UDK: 911.2:551.435.88
Izvleek
Ivan Gams: Pojem in oblike kontaktnega krasa
Te oblike so prebojna dolina, slepa dolina, kra{ki ravnik, jama z alogeno reko, preto~no kra{ko polje, jama na
vododrni podlagi, podledeni{ki kras in jama v sendvi~u. Vloga klime in naplavine za zaprte kotanje je
prikazana s primerjavo semiaridnega Wombijskega krasa v Avstraliji in Velega polja v Julijskih Alpah
(Slovenija). V zmerni alpski humidni klimi je intenzivno mehani~no preperevanje na strmem in golem pobo~ju
nad Velim poljem (1580 m), ki se dviguje do 2200 m. Po nalivih ponika ob~asni Velski potok na 400 m {iroki
naplavni ravnici polja in pri tem odlaga gru{~, pesek in organske delce. Ta proces traja od zadnjega umika
ledenika pred 9 - 10.000 leti. Kljub starosti ve~ milijonov let in soto~ja dveh vodnih tokov iz okolice iz
magmatskih kamnin na junem koncu 3,6 km2 obsenega otoka iz ~istega wombijskega marmorja, prevladujejo
soteske, jame in ozke slepe doline brez {ir{ega naplavinskega dna in uravnav. Vse kae, da je za razlike kriva
predvsem semiaridna klima in odsotnost naplavine, ki drugod povzro~a {ir{i in dolgotrajnej{i vlani stik
naplavine z apneni{ko podlago.
Klju~ne besede: kras, kra{ka geomorfologija, kontaktni kras, kra{ke oblike, najglobja brezna, korozija,
Dinarski kras, Slovenija.
UDC: 911.2:551.435.88
Abstract
Ivan Gams: Notion and forms of contact karst
These forms are through valley, blind valley, karst plain, cave with allogenic river, overflow polje, cave on
the impermeable rock, subglacial karst and interstratal karst. Emphasized is the role of climate and alluvium
for closed basins by comparing Wombeyan cave area in Australia with polje Velo polje in Julian Alps
(Slovenia). In the temperate humid alpine climate is intensive mechanical weathering on the steep and bare
slopes above Velo polje (1680 m) and steep dry valley rising up to 2200 m. After heavy downpour the
periodical brook Velski potok is sinking on the 400 m wide bottom and depositing new sheet of rubble, sand
and organic particles. This process lasted since last glacier retreat 9 - 10,000 years ago. Despite age of many
hundred million years and confluence of two rivers from surroundings built of igneous rocks on southern
corner of 3,6 km2 large isolated Wombeyan marble there prevail gorges, caves and narrow valleys without
large alluviated bottoms, and the surface is not levelled. The main reasons for the difference are in this view
the semi-arid climate and the absence of alluvium causing larger and longer moist contact of alluvium with
limestone basis.
Key words: karst, karst geomorphology, contact karst, karst forms, deepest potholes, solution, Dinaric Karst,
Slovenia.
34
HISTORICAL INTRODUCTION
Conception of contact karst is in the world karst geomorphology partially covered by the
name karst of allogenic rivers. Its forms are mostly limited to blind valleys and dry valleys (Ford
- Williams, 1989). In Slovenian karstology allogenic rivers are called mostly sinking rivers. In the
fiftties of the last century the longest caves in Slovenia were attributed to them. The conception of
contact karst, first explained and classified in 1974, was elaborated after measuring the solution
rate within the 14 drainage areas of Dinaric and Alpine karst of Slovenia.. The rate was calculated
on the basis of mean total hardness of the river water and its yearly run-off. By comparing the
rates with grade of karstification (meant density of closed basins) on the karst surface no positive
relation was stated. As the solution measures proved a nearly uniform lowering of the surface, the
generation of closed basins was attributed to the accelerated corrosion which means the additional solution to the general surface lowering.
From the closed basins in Slovenia blind valleys have been researched at first. As their lengths
in limestone compared with their part in impermeable or semi-permeable rocks is greater at the
rivers with lower total hardness, solution was recognized as the main process. A remarkable
knowledge on the blind valleys in Slovenia has later been contributed by Andrej Mihevc. Further
studies resulted in recognition of the factors generating the contact karst forms. They can be a
consequence of the horizontal or vertical disposition of impermeable and permeable rocks. Both
of them are controlled by altitudinal differences, water quantity, chemistry, river load, depth of
piezometric level, permeability of karst rock, age of process and tectonics. From this point of
view some most prominent karst features in Dinaric Karst and in the world have been explained
as a combination of many favourable conditions (Fig. 1). Less known in the world are contact
forms caused by vertical litho-hydrological contact (cave river on impermeable base, subglacial
and proglacial karst, endokarst under perforated impermeable cover, interstratal endokarst). In
this paper some of them are explained more in details.
The role of the tectonics is especially evident in the Dinaric karst. Only three rivers cross the
mountains behind the Littoral Dinaric karst as tributaries to the Adriatic Sea. Their springs are in
the impermeable sediments (Triassic dolomite, sandstone, shales, marls, magmatic and metamorphic sediments) on the watershed between the distant Black Sea and the close Adriatic Sea. They
formed in the limestone magnificent, for river traffic important through valleys (gorges of Mora~a,
Neretva, Buti{nica - Krka). Their continuation on the Adriatic coastal area is dependent on the
Neogenics and Quaternary tectonics mostly. The Mora~a spread alluvial (now conglomeratic) fan
in the tectonically sinking Basin of Zeta, the Neretwa reaches the sea in a moist valley bottom
below Metkovi~. Between Krka (Dalmatia) and So~a (Isonzo) neotectonic uplifting was week
what made the levelling of the surface possible. The Krka (in earlier phase together with Zrmanja)
levelled the classic karst plain of Kistanje (Rogli, 1975) (Fig. 2). Pazin{~ica as an effluent of the
Trieste flysch syncline indicates with direction of its dry valley the tectonic inclination of Istrian
peninsula. In the sinking coast at Umag seams to develop recent formation of a new fluviokarst
plain. The role of flow concentration is evident in the 11 little blind valleys at the southern foot of
Brkini hills compared with the biggest blind valley of Vreme which ends with Vreme-Diva~a
karst plain and huge [kocjan Caves (Gams, 1959, 1962, 1965, 1966, 1974, 1986, 1992, 1994.
Mihevc, A., 1991, 1993).
35
The role of solution for contact karst forms was tested with sporadic measurements of water
chemistry (Postojna Cave, [kocjan Cave, in some blind valleys and border poljes). Water hardness along rivers in the through valleys has been measured in the gorges of the Kolpa, Kokra,
Bohinjska Bistrica, Paka, Hudinja in Slovenia and in some gorges in Austria (in Karinthia, Inn
gorge between Bischofshofen and Salzburg). But in the big rivers flowing in the long and deep
gorges the hidden springs bring water with different, mostly higher hardness which makes the
measurements of the hardness in the main river uncertain. The measured increase in the small
streams with hardness below 75 mg CaCO3/l (at it the pCO2 in water and in free air is almost
equilibrated) was later confirmed with standard limestone tablets exposed for some years (case
study Pasjek, Gams, 1995). A longer systematic measuring of chemistry of the little sinking
stream Predvratnica (at Velike La{~e, SE Slovenian Dinaric Karst) which flows from a blind
valley underground for 1150 m (and there through two caves) resulted in 61,5 tons of dissolved
limestone and dolomite in one year (Kogov{ek, J., A. Kranjc, 1992).
36
37
38
Fig. 3 (on page 38): Solution forms at the end of Triglav glacier. In the middle of the picture is an
elongated depression with snow field. In it sank water from ice field till the last decade when the
glacier fell to pieces. Between the slope (left) and the hill Glava (background) are entrances to
the Triglav pothole. Shallow basins in limestone (one is seen on picture) developed by solution
under glaciers after their retreat usually proclaimed as ice abrasion features (Photo I. Gams).
Sl. 3 (na strani 38): Korozijske oblike na koncu Triglavskega ledenika. Sredi fotografije podolgovata
kotanja s snei{~em. V njej je ponikala voda z ledenika do zadnjega desetletja, ko je ledenik
razpadel Med levim pobo~jem in gri~em Glava (v ozadju) so vhodi v Triglavsko brezno. Plitve
kotanje v apnencu (ena je vidna na sliki) nastale s korozijo pod ledeniki, po njihovem umiku
navadno progla{amo za abrazijske oblike (Foto I. Gams).
Fig. 6 (on page 38): Velo polje after new alluvium sheet spread by torrente from mountain on
right side. Seen are the filled up and the new dam, on the other side and left side of the polje
bottom buildings of the mountain pastures, behind Malo polje. Picture from sixties years of the
20th century (Photo I. Gams).
Sl. 6 (na strani 38): Velo polje po sveem nasipu hudournika z gorovja (iz Velske doline, desno).
Vidna zapolnjeni in novi zadrevalnik gru{~a , na zadnji in levi strani naplavnega dna planinski
stanovi, v ozadju Malo polje. Fotografija iz {estdesetih let 20. stol. (Foto I. Gams).
after percolation for 15 m through limestone in the pothole water is dissolving less than 39,1 mg
CaCO3/l and after percolation to the 1205 m lower spring further 34 mg CaCO3 /l. With the total
hardness of 4,3 GD the PCO2 in water in the spring is nearly equilibrated with the PCO2 in the
free air. As evident, the capability of melting water for solution lasted deep in the endokarst. This
is why the alpine plateau glaciated in the cold phases of Pleistocene reveal the dense and deep
potholes. In the Slovenian part of the plateau Kanin (Julian Alps, 1000 - 2400 m) the Slovenian
cave register contains 370 caves (potholes), their density is 14,8 potholes/km2. On the Slovenian
and Italian part of the same plateau five potholes are deeper than 1000 m, the deepest is -1370 m.
Many potholes in the once glaciated high Alps, Pyrenees and Caucasus are among the deepest in
the world.
Part of the melting water from high mountain glaciers is flowing also through crevasses in ice
and reaches the limestone basis far behind their end. Known worldwide is the inactive 387 m long
Castle Guard Cave under the Columbia icefield in Canadian Rocky mountains. Far below the
cave is the hypothetical course of melting water which begins probably under the central part of
the glacier (Ford, 1980). Where glacier moving stops, dolines underneath have been enlarged by
solution of melting water. On the plateaux (1400 - 1500 m of altitude below Mt. Snenik, 1696 m
(Dinaric karst in Slovenia), in the locality Planinc 264 m closed basins developed. One half of
them are larger than 100 m and deeper than 20 m, with volume between 50.000 and 72.000 m3
(Habi~, 1991).
39
Fig. 5: Wombeyan isolated karst (Australia). 1 - igneous rock, 2 - marble, 3 - perrenial stream,
4 - intermitent stream and dry valley, 5 - gorge, 6 - cave, 7 - alluvium (Reduced from a sketch in
the paper Jennings et al., p. 48, monograph Wombeyan Caves, Sydney, 1982).
Sl. 5: Wombijski izolirani kras (Avstralija). 1 - vulkanske kamnine, 2 - marmor, 3 - trajni vodni
tok, 4 - presihajo~i tok in suha dolina, 5 - soteska, 6 - jama, 7 - aluvij (Poenostavljeno po skici v
~lanku Jennings et al., str. 48, v monografiji Wombijski kras, Sydney 1982).
40
impermeable igneous rocks (granite, felsite, porphyry, quartz, gabbro, tuff). Two streams from
surroundings cross the karst and join at the southern corner before entering in the igneous rocks.
In limestone prevail gorges, dry and blind valleys and about 20 caves, some of them open to
tourists. There are many collapse dolines, rare solution dolines and other closed depressions. The
crests built of marble are lower than the relief in the surroundings (s. map in the monograph
Wombean Caves, p. 84, Fig. 5).
We compare the Wombeyan with the polje called Velo polje in Julian Alps, Slovenia. Its
altitude is 1690 m, the size of the level bottom is about 0,2 km2, rocky divide with Malo polje is
about 10 m high (Velo and Malo polje mean in local language Great and Little plain). It is
situated at the northern end of a dry valley like wide and 2,6 km long depression between Triglav
(2864 m) mountain and much lower river valley Voje (Bohinj).
Figure 5 is taken from the monograph Wombeyan Caves (Sydney 1982) and from there published articles J.N. Jennings, J.M. James, N.R, Montgomery: The Development of the Landscape,
65 - 64, and The origin and Evolution of the Caves, 83 - 120). The temperature in station near
Wombeyan Reserve is 12,3 C (July 4,5, January 19,0 C). Mean rainfall is 760 mm, potential
evapotranspiration 800 mm (!). The nearest and higher meteorological station, Kredarica, has
yearly 1994 mm of precipitation, potential evapotranspiration in Velo polje is presumable
300 mm, yearly temperature is about 1 C (January about -6, July 10 C). Snow cover lasts half of
the year. Tectonic rising of Wombeyan and begin of Wombeyan basin occur in late Carboniferous
times, in Tertiary times (50 - 35 millions years ago), and twice in Miocene. The recent solution in
Wombeyan between the ponor of Wombeyan Creek and when it comes out of underground is
7 ppm CaCO3 /l (as increased of total hardness from 40 to 47 ppm). But 750 mm of precipitation
permits a weak solution activity. The surface is not levelled despite the long development. Mechanical weathering in Wombeyan is weak, and river load limited to the short distance at the
entering of streams on limestone. In Velo polje were measured two springs in bare karst in the
altitude about 1900 - 2000 m. Their water jointly flows mainly below soil and scree on the slope
- rock is there less permeable - and reach Malo polje (it is close to Velo polje)
Total
4,8
6,8
6,1
7,0
Carbonate hardness in GD
4,3
6,4
5,7
6,7
* This spring is used for pipeline for the hut and its water is artificially joined with the second
spring.
** This perennial spring is the only one at the rim of rhe polje. Evident is the solution of 15,3 mg
CaCO3/l during the flow on Malo polje. Its narrow plain is built of pit, in the bed mixed with
some rubble.
Increase of hardness of streams flowing from barren to covered karst have been found also at
some other parts of the Alps. In Velo polje the water flow was not measured and solution quantity
is therefore unknown. In the surroundings of Velo polje the tree line is at the altitude 1850 1950 m, but patches of stony surface also appear lower.
41
Behind the upper end of Velo polje, the 2,5 km long dry valley Velska dolina begins rising to
the peaks above 2200 m. Mechanical weathering in the steep slopes and walls causes fall of
broken stones. During the snow melting and after downpour the torrente transported them dawn
and spread in form of a thin alluvial fan on the polje bottom, which is used in summer for mountain pasture for cattle. To protect the pasture the herdsmen in the last century built two dams to
stop the river transport before the plain (see Fig. 6). Recently they are abandoned. The sheet of
rubble, sand and organic particles are in the coarse of 1 - 2 years overgrown again by new grass.
High water from valley sinks in the alluvium and never forms a lake. Despite of often new
accumulations the plain is not rising. Contrary, in the local rocky slope 2-3 m above the bottom
are in some places seen subsoil forms proving the lowering of the accumulation plain. In some
years migrated collapse doline occurred and proved the active solution of the rocky base.
The solution in Velo (and Malo) polje is much more intensive than in Wombeyan, and its
rocky basin is much younger. Retreat of the glacial from Velo polje in the higher mountain has
been about 9 - 10,000 years ago. After that the present accumulation of alluvium began. During
the percolation of stream and precipitation water the PCO2 in the soil increased their PCO2 in the
water thus rising additional capability for solution.
During the last glaciation in the higher mountainous Dinaric karst behind the Adriatic Coast
(and elsewhere in the higher mountains in Europe) vegetation consisted of rare coniferous trees
and cold steppe ([ercelj, 1996). This climate was convenient for alluviation of the polje bottoms
and other closed basins of contact karst, so as today it is in Velo polje. In Wombeyan the alluvium
is limited to the first parts of gorges in the limestone and closed basins are therefore without
larger levelled bottoms.
Role of interstratal more soluble beds for caves
The solubility of gypsum in water is about 200 times greater than the solubility of limestone.
Therefore there is no wonder that the longest cave of Podolia - Bukovina (western Ukraina, left
side of the Dnester) is hollowed out in Tortonian gypsum. It is 10 - 30 m thick, based on Litotamnian
limestone; above are gypsum, Tortonian limestone (up to 8 m), homogeneous limestone of Ratin
(1-2 m), clays and loam, and somewhere alluvium on the surface. On our sketch (acc. to Dublanski,
Lomaev, 1980 - Fig. 7) is shown the plan and lithologic profill for the maize cave Mlinki
(19.100 m) developed in gypsum up to 16 m thick. In its western part passages with profile 0.2 x
1.5 m and in SW part rounded profiles predominate, in the rest of the cave are higher chambers.
The stream which generated the cave is lost and the cave is inactive. In Podolia is in gypsum also
the second longest cave of the world, the maize cave Optimisti~eskaja (165 km), with channels in
three levels, all in gypsum thick up to 20 m, above are limestone, clay and loam, thick to 50 m.
The cave covers 215.500 m2 of surface. In gypsum are also Cave Ozernaja (82 km), maize cave
(170.000 m2) Zalu{ka (82.000 km), built in up to 30 m thick gypsum, Kristalnaja (22 km), Verteba,
7.8 km) and some smaller ones (Dubljanski et al., 1980).
The longest cave in the world Mammouth Cave in Kentucky is a special kind of contact karst.
The accelerated solution of aggressive streams draining the slopes built of sand and shale is at
present limited to the limestone floored valleys in Chester Uppland. Many of them have been
essentially widened by growing closed basins together and by collapse dolines (Miotke, 1975,
s.139 - 149). In the late Tertiary and early Quaternary time, after sand and shales were progressively evacuated from the older limestone in Pennyroyal Plateau, their aggressive river water
42
Fig. 8: Cross section through the Mammoth Cave area (Acc. to Arthur N. Palmer, A geological
guide to Mammoth Cave National Park, 1981, p. 6).
Sl. 8: Profil skozi obmo~je Mamutske jame (Po: Arthur N. Palmer, Geolo{ki vodnik parka v
obmo~ju Mamutske jame, 1981, str. 6).
43
contributed to the generation of higher cave passages in the whole area and also under the present
ridges in Chester Upland where some knobs are still capped with impermeable rocks. In this
phase the Mammoth Cave area was a type of horizontal contact of impermeable and permeable
rocks. Later precipitation water dissolved the upper Girkin and higher limestone strata of Meramec
series and destroy upper channels in them. All six levels of the channels controlled by Green river
terraces remained under the rising Mammoth, Flint, Joppa and other small ridges where limestone channels have been protected by insoluble sand and shales on he top. The protective role of
this cap for cave conservation recognized both authors of cave monographs (Miotke, 1975, Palmer,
1981). The insoluble and impermeable cap hold back the percolation water through cave ceiling.
By this way break down and flowstone deposition in the old channels is limited to the slope area
built of limestone (Miotke, 1981, Fig. 38 on page 111). Development of the cave passages (530
km) is mostly the result of the horizontal and their conservation of the vertical disposition of
soluble and insoluble rocks.
REFERENCES
Dublanskij, V., N. Lomaev, A.A., 1980: Karstovie pe{~eri Ukraini, 177 p.
Ford, D., 1982: Castleguard. Ottawa.
Ford, D., P. Williams, 1989: Karst Geomorphology and hydrology.- London, 601 p.
Gams, I., 1961: Triglavsko brezno (Triglav pothole).- Na{e jame, 1-2, 21 - 22
Gams, I., 1962a: Dopolnilne raziskave Triglavskega brezna (Additional research in Triglav Pothole). - Na{e jame, 1 - 2, 21 - 22
Gams, I., 1962b: Slepe doline v Sloveniji (Blind valleys in Slovenia). - Geografski zbornik 7,
195 -162
Gams, I., 1963: Velo polje in problem pospe{ene korozije (Velo polje and problem of accelerated
solution).- Geografski vestnik, 35, 55 - 64
Gams, I., 1963: Faktorji in dinamika korozije na karbonatnih kameninah slovenskega dinarskega
in alpskega krasa (Factors and dynamics of solution in carbonatic rocks of Slovenian
Dinaric and Alpine karst).- Geografski vestnik, 38, 1962, 11 - 68,
Gams, I., 1983: [kocjanski kras kot vzorec kontaktnega krasa (Karst of [kocjan as a case of
contact kast). - Lipica (Seana), 22 - 26
Gams, I., 1986: Kontaktni fluviokras (Contact fluviokarst). Acta carsologica, 14 - 15
Gams, I., 1992: Contact karst in the Dinaric Karst area.- Geomorphology and Sea.- Proc. of the
Int. symposium and meeting of the geomorphological commission on the Carpatho - Balcan
countries. Zagreb, 187 - 193
Gams, I., 1994: Types of contact karst. Geografia Fisica e Dinamica Quaternaria. - Torino,
37 - 46
Gams, I., 1995: Die Rolle der beschleunigten Korrosion bei der Entstehung von Durchbruchthllern.
- Mitt. sterr. Geographischen Gesellschaft 137, 105 - 114
Habi~, P., 1991: Geomorphological classification of NW Dinaric karst.- Acta carsologica 20,
133 -164.
Jennings, J.N., J.M. James, N.R. Montgomery, 1982: The Development of the landscape. Wombeyan caves. Sydney Speleological Society, No 8, 45 - 64
44
45
~asu ve~jega obsega neprepustnih pe{~enjakov in skrilavcev na platoju Pennyroyal, pozneje skr~enih
na vr{ne lege holmov, so agresivne ponornice izvotlile zgornje hodnike v vi{avju Chester na
vodoravnem stiku neprepustnih in prepustnih kamnin. Ko je korozija padavinske vode zniala
okoli{ko povr{je iz apnenca pod Chester Upland, netopni in neprepustni pokrov slemen Mammoth, Flint in Joppa prepre~uje udore jamskega stropa in nastanek sigovih kop v hodnikih pod
njimi. Zato je vertikalni razpored neprepustnih in prepustnih kamnin lahko ohranil pod slemeni
prehodne rove jame, ki je z dolino 530 km najdalj{a na svetu.
46