Employee Training and Development System of Banking Sector of Bangladesh: An Empirical Study On Eastern Bank LTD
Employee Training and Development System of Banking Sector of Bangladesh: An Empirical Study On Eastern Bank LTD
Employee Training and Development System of Banking Sector of Bangladesh: An Empirical Study On Eastern Bank LTD
1 June, 2014
1. Introduction
Human resources are critical for effective organizational functioning (Griffin, 2006).
Training and development enable employees to perform their present job effectively and
to prepare for future jobs. The current business environment is constantly changing, so it
is crucial that organizations train and develop their employees to stay ahead of the
competition. However, many organizations have failed to recognize the number of
benefits that exceeds the costs associated with having untrained and under-developed
employees. Most organizations put training and development to pursue other strategies.
Yet, the majority of organizations continue to reap little benefit due to their lack of
training and development initiatives. Training can have a major influence on
organizational behavior in two aspects.
The first aspect is that training and development allow the employee to effectively
perform his or her job. As an employees abilities increase there is a high potential that
1
Assistant Professor, Department of Management, Faculty of Business Studies, University of Dhaka. Email:
[email protected]
35
the organizations performance will increase. Therefore, training and development does
have a positive relationship with organizational success. And what is even better is the
fact that better trained and developed employees are more motivated. The second aspect
of how training and development can influence the behavior of organizational members is
that it increases the employees ability to make more effective decisions. Employees are
more willing to accept responsibility for their decisions and have strong desire to place
the organizational objectives above their own. Both training and development are forms
of learning that apply to any business. Training, on the other hand, is teaching people
skills that they lack. Together they can help develop an organizational culture that fosters
employee commitment.
2. Training Ideas and Outline Process
Here is a relatively simple overview of typical reference models, processes and tools
found in the effective planning and delivery of organizational training.
There are many different training and development methods. On-the-job training,
informal training, classroom training, internal training courses, external training courses,
on-the-job coaching, life-coaching, mentoring, training assignments and tasks, skills
training, product training, technical training, behavioral development training, roleplaying and role-play games and exercises, attitudinal training and development,
accredited training and learning, distance learning - all part of the training menu,
available to use and apply according to individual training needs and organizational
training needs.
More importantly, training - or learning, to look at it from the trainee's view - is anything
offering learning and developmental experience.
Development isn't restricted to training - it's anything that helps a person to grow, in
ability, skills, confidence, tolerance, commitment, initiative, inter-personal skills,
understanding, self-control, motivation, and more.
Some theoretical discussion on Training and Development: A brief note about
training and development is given below:
2.1 Definition of Training
Training is the process of developing individuals knowledge, skills and abilities in order
to bring a change in attitude so as to improve present and future organization
performance. Training teaches skills for use in the present and near future. It is TASK
oriented. Where T=training, A=Attitude, S=Skill, K= knowledge.
When an employee can bring a desired change in attitude about a particular subject by
acquiring knowledge and skill through training one can easily say that the employee
becomes trained. Thus training is a continual process of helping employees performs at a
high level and it is a life long process for self-development.
36
Daffodil International University Journal of Business and Economics, Vol. 8, No. 1 June, 2014
Training
Non-managers
Technical / Mechanical
Operation
Specific
job
related
information
Short
term
Development
Managers
Theoretical / conceptual
ideas
General knowledge
Long term
3. Literature Review
Training and development refers to the practice of providing training, workshops,
coaching, mentoring, or other learning opportunities to employees to inspire, challenge,
and motivate them to perform the functions of their position to the best of their ability
and within standards set by local, state, tribal, federal and licensing organization
guidelines. Training and development activities provide all involved system with the
tools they need to develop professionally, increase their knowledge, effectively work
with family, and build their capacity to perform the tasks associated with their positions
within the system of care. Training is the activities that are designed to provide learners
37
with the knowledge and skills needed for their present jobs whereas development is the
learning that goes beyond todays job and has more long-term focus (Mondy, 2008).
Development is an attempt to improve current and future management performance by
imparting knowledge, changing attitudes or increasing skills (Dessler, 2003).
Employee training and development has enormous impact on organizational
effectiveness. It is observed that more investment in training and development has led to
more profitability of the private sector industrial enterprises of Bangladesh (Hoque 1994).
A training needs analysis is to understand what training employees really need (Cekada,
2010). Fred and Warmerdem (1997) identified that many organizations show remarkable
differences with respect to the basic processes of their training systems: the shaping of
training policies, the development of training programmes and the execution of training
activities. In practice, training systems are much more organization-specific than training
literature usually suggests.
Thang and Buyens (2008), after reviewing 66 studies conducted in different countries,
concluded that training leads to improved knowledge, skills, abilities, attitudes, and
behavior of employees that ultimately enhance excellent financial and non-financial
performance of the organizations. Moreover, Mexican companies consider employee
training and development as their sources of competitive advantages to face the
challenges of globalization (Ruiz & Germain 2008). In addition, training activities have
noteworthy influence on employees organizational commitment in manufacturing firms
in India (Agarwala 2008). Distinctive HRM practices have enabled Japan in becoming
one of the most industrially developed countries of the world through creating
competitive advantages (Hoque 1990; Mohiuddin & Mahmood 1999).
Training research has begun to draw heavily upon theory from related research domains
(Tannenbaum & Yukl, 1992). For example, influences from cognitive and differential
psychology are having a significant impact on training research. This relatively recent
work is extending the conceptualization of learning and individual change beyond the
prescriptions of classic principles of learning that have dominated training design for over
three decades
This integration is encouraging. It promises to revolutionize
conceptualization of the process by which expertise develops. This work, however,
continues to reflect the dominant individual level orientation of training. Training is
being conceptualized as integral to the strategic goals of the organization (Schuler &
Walker, 1990), as a component of the human resource planning process (Jackson &
Schuler, 1990), and as an activity that is constrained by organizational environment
features (Baldwin & Ford, 1988).
Although it is axiomatic that psychological change is rooted in individuals, this narrow
orientation neglects the constraining influence of contextual factors at higher levels of the
organizational system. The need for change, the implementation of interventions, and the
transfer of trained skills are embedded within the context of work team, sub unit, and
organizational levels. These contextual features and processes ultimately facilitate or
inhibit the expression of trained skills.
38
Daffodil International University Journal of Business and Economics, Vol. 8, No. 1 June, 2014
40
Daffodil International University Journal of Business and Economics, Vol. 8, No. 1 June, 2014
The other two courses are based on the respective department. Examinations and results
both held and published via internet. Every department has to follow an employee
performance measurement method devised by the HRD. This performance measurement
form is filled out and signed by the supervisors and respective Department Heads. Based
on these performance reviews, training needs are identified for different employees.
6.4 Stages of training procedure of EBL: Some certain stages are followed before and
after training. Stages can be defined in following format:
(i) Stage 1-Analyzing employees
In this stage the bank evaluates employee based on their accomplishment and skill. The
Bank evaluates employee skill based on their performance, background, job related
experience and educational achievement mainly. After assessing employees if the
organization finds that employees are skilled enough and they can do their job
efficiently than the bank. let them move to do their job. If they finds that employees are
not skilled enough than management continue to the next stage.
(ii) Stage 2-Training needs assessment
After evaluating employees skill deficiency the Bank identifies the area in which the
employees are not skilled. Need assessment is done by examining employees
performance and career background.
Normally peoples of this organization face problems in using IT software, managing
assets and accounts related books. So based on their performance and organizational
position the skill criteria are identified and after assessing their skill deficiency
management move on to the next stage.
(iii) Stage 3-Providing Training
After assessing the training criteria the Bank divides employees (selected for training) in
two groups. (1) The employees who have theoretical knowledge about the training
criteria; only practice is arranged for them. (2) Employees who does not have theoretical
knowledge: Employees who do not have theoretical knowledge; formal training is
arranged for them.
(iv) Stage 4-Evaluation of performance
After providing training employees move to their job. Then management evaluates their
performance. If management finds employee performance is satisfactory then training
procedure comes to an end and he or she can continue with their job. If management
finds some deficiency in employees performance then the employee goes through the
training procedure again.
6.5 Evaluation of training programs
Various methods can be used to collect data on the outcomes of training. Some of these
are:
a. Questionnaires
Comprehensive questionnaires could be used to obtain opinions, reactions, and views
of trainees.
41
b. Tests
Standard tests could be used to find out whether trainees have learnt anything during
and after the training.
c. Interviews
Interviews could be conducted to find the usefulness of training offered to operatives.
d. Studies
Comprehensive studies could be carried out eliciting the opinions and judgments of
trainers, superiors and peer groups about the training.
e. Human resource Factors
Training can also be evaluated on the basis of employee satisfaction, which in turn
can be examined on the basis of decrease in employee turnover, absenteeism,
accidents, grievances, discharges, dismissals, etc.
f.
g. Feedback
After the evaluation, the situation should be examined to identify the probable causes
for gaps in performance. The training evaluation information (about costs, time spent,
outcomes, etc.) should be provided to the instructors, trainees and other parties
concerned for control, correction and improvement of trainees' activities. The training
evaluator should follow it up sincerely so as to ensure effective implementation of the
feedback report at every stage.
7.0 Findings and Analysis
Based on the analysis of training and development methods in EBL, the following major
findings are originated:
Training and development system
1.Orientation
2.Internal Training programs
3.External Training programs
4.Mentoring
5. Manager Development
6.Peer or Supervisor coaching
7.Job specific training
8.Evaluation
EBL
Well defined orientation training.
Organized as per specific requirements.
Organized regularly with collaboration of relevant
employee participation.
Not provided at EBL.
No such training is existent at EBL.
Provided occasionally at EBL.
Very specific training program at EBL as job rotation is
not frequently practiced.
Mainly individual evaluation based on supervisors
reports, for some training programs written exams are
taken & the results are published online.
42
Daffodil International University Journal of Business and Economics, Vol. 8, No. 1 June, 2014
Based on a well defined program which containsemployee analysis, Training needs assessment, Providing
Training & performance evaluation.
Variety of trainings provided focusing on the behavioral
traits to job specific technical trainings.
For the research it has sample size of 50 from the concerned population for the research,
it took a survey on 50 employees. The survey was made by the closed ended structured
questionnaire containing 15 items or questions with five point Likert scale in order to
measure the perception about the employee training and development system of Eastern
Bank Ltd. The total population was classified into five classes and the responses had been
collected according to these classification. The research took place at different branches
of Eastern Bank Ltd. After finishing the survey all the questionnaires were gathered and
put all the data from the questionnaires into Microsoft Excel. Then by using the software
it came up with the findings, which helped to explain the necessity of employee training
for the development of the employees in the Eastern Bank Ltd.
As mentioned earlier the questionnaire had 15 items and each item had five point Likert
scale. Which means under each item or question one employee had to respond any of the
points among the five Likert scale.
7.1 Findings and analysis of the individual items or questions
Percentages of the responses on each of the five different scale points calculated from the
total responses of 100 customers on each item or question.
Training is very essential for conducting banking business.
25
20
15
10
5
0
Officers
Senior Officers
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
Neutral
Agree
Agree
Strongly
Executive Officers
Principal Officers
Managers
The mean value regarding all the responses is 3.7, which means the employees
perception regarding this statement is good. The standard deviation 1.10 proves that the
mean 3.7 can vary 1.10 more or less. This shows that the findings regarding this are not
so reliable.
Training is necessary in every year.
50
40
Officers
Senior Officers
30
Executive Officers
20
Principal Officers
Managers
10
0
Strongly
Agree
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
30
Executive officers
20
Principal officers
Managers
10
0
Strongly
Agree
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
44
Daffodil International University Journal of Business and Economics, Vol. 8, No. 1 June, 2014
The statement states the satisfaction level of the employees according to the training
quality. 30% of the respondents agreed that they were satisfied about the service quality
while training. . Among this 30% officers & principal officers, 20% senior officers and
23% were managers, the rest were equally responded. About 5% executive officers
disagreed with the statement. About 10% employees were strongly satisfied and about
2% were strongly dissatisfied. The mean value regarding all the responses is 3.12, which
means the employees perception regarding this statement is agreed. The standard
deviation .90 proves that the mean 3.12 can vary .90 more or less. This shows that the
findings regarding this are reliable.
Employees are interesting about the training system of Eastern Bank Ltd.
50
40
Officers
Senior Officers
30
Executive Officers
20
Principal Officers
Managers
10
0
Strongly
Agree
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
45
The training system of Eastern bank ltd. can successfully train the newly appointed
employees.
50
40
Officers
Senior officers
30
Executive Officers
20
Principal Officers
Managers
10
0
Strongly
Agree
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
30
Executive Officers
20
Principal officers
Managers
10
0
Srtongly
Agree
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Dtsagree
46
Daffodil International University Journal of Business and Economics, Vol. 8, No. 1 June, 2014
The statement states that if the lectures provided to trainee are easy to understand. About
28% of the employees are neutral about their satisfaction level. This comprises 28% of
principal officers, 23% of officers, 15% of senior officers and executive officers and 10%
managers. 20% of the employees are satisfied with the quality of lectures provided in the
training courses.
This includes 20% of managers and senior officers & 18% of executive officers. About
8% employees are dissatisfied with the quality of the lectures. About 15% of the
managers are strongly satisfied with the quality of the training lectures. About 5% of the
senior officers and executive officers are strongly dissatisfied with the quality of lecture.
Most of the principal officers, officers and executive officers are neutral, where managers
and senior officers are satisfied with the quality of lectures. The mean value regarding all
the responses is 3.23, which means the employees perception regarding this statement is
neutral. The standard deviation 1.04 proves that the mean 3.7 can vary 1.04 more or less.
This shows that the findings regarding this are not so reliable.
You feel safe in your training institute
50
40
Offficers
Senior Officers
30
Executive Officers
20
principal officers
Managers
10
0
Srtongly
Agree
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Dtsagree
47
When you face a problem, Eastern Bank Ltds authority shows sincere interest in
solving it.
50
40
Offficers
Senior Officers
30
Executive Officers
20
principal officers
Managers
10
0
Srtongly
Agree
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Dtsagree
30
Executive Officers
20
Principal Officers
Managers
10
0
Strongly
Agree
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
48
Daffodil International University Journal of Business and Economics, Vol. 8, No. 1 June, 2014
The statement states whether the bank provides all the services that are needed to the
trainees. About 20% officers are neutral about the range services. This includes 20% of
officers, 18% of senior officers, 15% of principal officers & 10% of executive officers
and managers. 8% of the senior officers are dissatisfied with the range of services. This
includes 7% of the officers, 6% of principal officers, 5% managers & 4% executive
officers. 20% managers and executive officers and 18% senior officers and 15% principal
officers and 12% officers are satisfied with the range of services. About 5% executive
officers are strongly dissatisfied with the range services. Most of the employees are
satisfied. The mean value regarding all the responses is 2.55, which means the
employees perception regarding this statement is good. The standard deviation .91
proves that the mean 2.55 can vary .91 more or less. This shows that the findings
regarding this are not reliable.
The internal environment of Eastern Bank training institutes is visually attractive.
50
40
Officers
Senior Officers
30
Executive Officers
20
Principal Officers
Managers
10
0
Strongly
Agree
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
49
Materials associated with the service are easily understandable and visually
attractive.
50
40
Officers
Senior Officers
30
Executive Officers
20
Principal Officers
Managers
10
0
Strongly
Agree
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
30
Executive Officers
20
Principal Officers
Managers
10
0
Strongly
Agree
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
50
Daffodil International University Journal of Business and Economics, Vol. 8, No. 1 June, 2014
The statement refers that how much the bank is providing IT based training to its
employees. And the graph shows the satisfaction level of its employees regarding this
service. Most of the employees are agreed with the statement. This comprises 21% of
principal officers, 20% executive officers, 15% of the other ranks equally. 10% are
strongly agreed with the statement. About 15% of customers are neutral about the
service quality. It comprises 3% of officers & employees and 4% of each of the
remaining three classes of customers. About half of the employees are neutral with the
service. 3% employees are strongly dissatisfied with this service.
The mean value regarding all the responses is 2.25, which means the customers
perception regarding this statement is bad. The standard deviation 1.06 proves that the
mean 2.25 can vary 1.06 more or less. This shows that the findings regarding this are
reliable.
It is an important criterion for employee development.
50
40
Officers
Senior Officers
30
Executive Officers
20
Principal Officers
Managers
10
0
Strongly
Agree
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
51
30
Executive Officers
20
Principal Officers
Managers
10
0
Strongly
Agree
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
30
Executive Officers
20
Principal Officers
Managers
10
0
Strongly
Agree
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Strongly
Disagree
52
Daffodil International University Journal of Business and Economics, Vol. 8, No. 1 June, 2014
The statement shows how the employees of the bank treat with the trainees. And the
graph shows the level of trainees perception regarding the statement. About 25%
employees are neutral regarding the statement. This comprises 25% of principal officers,
23% of officers, 20% of managers & 18% of the senior officers and 16% of the executive
officers. 20% trainees are satisfied with the manner of the bank employees. 8% trainees
are dissatisfied with the manner of the bank employees. And 3% are strongly dissatisfied
with the manner of the bank employees. The mean value regarding all the responses is
3.08, which means the customers perception regarding this statement is neutral. The
standard deviation .93 proves that the mean 3.08 can vary .93 more or less. This shows
that the findings regarding this are reliable.
8. Conclusion
Training & development is a need for every organization. The entire training department
should be well informed regarding their goal and objective. It is essential to execute
company objective into individual target. EBL management can be involved more in
internal training which will increase the effectiveness of these training and decrease the
need for their house training program.
This paper will help one to be familiar with the specific training & development
programs of the banking organizations both locally & internationally. The researcher has
also analyzed the training and development system with some recommendations for the
bank. This project can be helpful for us if we are to work with training & development
program in the future, we would know where to start & the scopes for possible
improvements.
References
1.
2.
Alexander & Gasparishvili (2001). Human resource development in an industry in transition: the case of
the Russian banking sector. Academy of Human Resources Development, 4(1).
Annual Report Eastern Bank Ltd 2006-2011.
Annual Report HSBC Ltd 2005-2010
3.
4.
5.
Blair, E., & Seo, D. (2007). Safety training: Making the connection to high performance. Professional
Safety, 52(10), 42-48.
6.
Cekada, L. T. (2010). Training needs assessment: Understanding what employees need to know.
Professional Safety, 28-33.
Debnath, R. M. (2003). Bank and legal environment (1st ed.). Dhaka: Nabajuga Prokashani.
7.
8.
Decenzo, D. A. & Robbins, S. P. (1999). Human Resource Management, New York: John Wiley &
Sons, Inc.
10. Dessler, Gary: Human Resource Management (9th Ed.). Pearson Education, 204.
11. Eighteen, R. (1999). Training Need Analysis for IT Training, 31(4), 149-153.
12. Ferdous, Tahmina & Razzak, B.M. (2012). Importance of Training Needs Assessment in the Banking
Sector of Bangladesh: A Case Study on National Bank Limited (NBL). International Journal of Business
and Management, 7(10), 63-73.
53
54
Daffodil International University Journal of Business and Economics, Vol. 8, No. 1 June, 2014
Appendix
1. Questionnaire
A study to determine the training and development system of Esatern Bank Ltd.
This survey is being conducted to determine the training and development system of
Eastern Bank Ltd. It may take approximately 6 to 8 minutes to complete this
questionnaire. There is no right or wrong answer provided. Participation in this survey is
completely voluntary. You can rest assured that all your given information will be kept
strictly confidential. Please try to fill in the entire questionnaire.
Please tick () the best answer as per your opinion.
5
Strongly
Agree
4
Agree
3
Neutral
2
Disagree
1
Strongly
Disagree
Name:
Age:
Sex:
Occupation:
Male
Teacher.
Female.
Student.
5
5
5
4
4
4
3
3
3
2
2
2
1
1
1
5
5
5
4
4
4
3
3
3
2
2
2
1
1
1
5
5
5
5
4
4
4
4
3
3
3
3
2
2
2
2
1
1
1
1
Officer or Employee.
55
Other.
QUESTIONS
RANKINGS
Level of
training
Senior
Officer
02
Senior
Officer
03
Assistant
General
Manager
04
Senior
Officer
05
Senior
Principal
Officer
06
Principal
Officer
Training
method
Investment and
Merchant
Banking
Micro and
Small
Enterprise
Financing
Corporate
Governance
and Corporate
Social
Responsibility
Appraisal and
Management
of Working
Capital
Financing
Management
of NonPerforming
Loans and
Recovery
Strategies
Human
Resource
Management
For Executives
Title of the
course
Lecture, Group
Discussion and
Case Study
Lecture, Group
Discussion, Case
Study and Project
Visit
Panel Discussion
and Formulation
of
Recommendation
Number
of trainee
01
Duration
01
3 working
days
Head office
and rural
office
01
2 working
days
Head office
Lecture, Group
Discussion and
Case Study
02
60 days
training
Staff
college
Lecture, Group
Discussion, Case
Study, Panel
Discussion and
Formulation of
Recommendation
Lecture, Group
Discussion and
Case Study
01
3 working
days
Head office
01
2 working
days
Head office
2 working
days
Training
Place
Head office
Source: Attendance records and books from the Eastern Bank Head office
56