Process Instrumentation 1
Process Instrumentation 1
VUT
Vaal University of Technology
2/10
1. INTRODUCTION TO INDUSTRIAL
INSTRUMENTATION
" when you can measure what you are speaking about, and express it in
numbers, you know something about it;....."
Lord Kelvin (1824-1907), Institute of Civil Engineers, London, 3rd May 1883
1.1 MEASUREMENT
Measurement is defined as the determination of the existence or magnitude of a
variable for monitoring and controlling purposes.
kilogram (mass)
ampere (current)
second (time)
candela (luminous intensity)
Scale and
pointer
Bulb
Tube
Link and
gears
Figure 1-1
A temperature change results in a pressure build-up within the bulb because of the
constrained thermal expansion of the filling fluid. This pressure is transmitted through
the tube to a Bourdon type pressure gauge, which converts pressure to displacement.
This displacement is manipulated by the linkage and gearing to give a larger pointer
movement. We can now recognise the following basic functional instrument elements,
using this liquid filled thermometer as an example:
In summary then, the interconnection between the various functional elements for this
particular thermometer instrument, is shown in Figure 1-2. It must be stressed though,
that different instruments are not necessarily composed of all these elements or may
not adhere to the same order of interconnection, as depicted in Figure 1-2.
Temperature
Measured medium
Bulb
Primary element
(Variable conversion element: temperature to pressure)
Tube
Bourdon tube
Secondary element
(Variable conversion element: pressure to motion)
Functioning element
(Data presentation: indicating function performed by
moving pointer over scale)
Observer
Figure 1-2
Output span
yMIN
(0 %)
xMIN
(0 %)
Input span
xMAX
(100 %)
Input x (%)
Accurate
and precise
Inaccurate
but precise
Accurate on
average but
imprecise
Inaccurate and
imprecise
Figure 1-4
Two concepts related to precision, are repeatability and reproducibility. Repeatability
is basically a measure of the instrument precision when the same operator in the same
laboratory or the same environment, measures a constant input repeatedly, over a short
time. Reproducibility is a measure of the instrument precision when a constant input is
measured repeatedly, but these experiments are performed in different laboratories or
locations with different ambient conditions and over a longer time span.
Repeatability
Repeatability is the closeness of the instrument readings when the same input is
applied repeatedly under the same conditions over a short period of time.
Reproducibility
Reproducibility is the closeness of the instrument readings when the same input
is applied under different conditions over a long period of time.
Resolution
Resolution is the smallest variation in the measured variable that can still be
measured.
For example, the resolution of an ordinary digital wristwatch is normally 1 second as
it can measure the flow of time to a maximum fineness of 1 second.
Gross errors are mistakes made, for instance, by the operator in gross misreading
of a scale. These errors can be minimized by care and self-discipline.
Systematic errors:
Systematic errors affect all readings in such a way that the error of measurement
has a fixed sign throughout the whole range of the instrument. These errors are
usually caused by an error in the instrument, poor calibration, improper technique
of the operator or loading of the instrument. Normally systematic errors are
corrected by careful recalibration of the instrument.
Random errors:
Random errors occur because of unknown and unpredictable variations that exist
in all measurement situations. This results in slightly different values obtained for
each repeated measurement (scattered evenly about the mean value) of the same
input. The influence of random errors on the integrity of measurements can be
reduced with statistical methods and refined experimental techniques.
Non-linearity is the maximum deviation from a straight line connecting the zero
and full-scale calibration points.
Note: A straight line connecting
the minimum and maximum inputoutput operating points, would
represent perfect linear operation
of the instrument. The actual static
calibration of the instrument will
normally deviate from this line.
Non- linearity can be expressed in
a variety of ways but a widely used
method is to determine the
maximum deviation of the output
from this line, as shown in Figure
1-5.
Non-linearity
is
then
expressed as a percentage of the
maximum output value.
Output y
yMAX
Actual static
calibration
Maximum
non-linearity
yMIN
xMIN
xMAX
Input x
Figure 1-5
Drift
Drift is the change in instrument indication over time while the input and ambient
conditions are constant.
Note: A typical error because of
drift is a change in sensitivity. This
will cause an error across the
whole range of the instrument as
indicated in Figure 1-6. An error
because of drift is an example of a
systematic
error.
As
was
mentioned before, systematic
errors may normally be corrected
with routine calibration of the
instrument.
Output y
yMAX
Range error
yMIN
xMIN
xMAX
Figure 1-6
Input x
Hysteresis is the difference between the readings obtained when a given value of
the measured variable is approached from below and when the same value is
approached from above.
Note: It is possible to find that
when
performing
a
static
calibration for an instrument
starting from the minimum input
value to the maximum input value
(also called the upscale direction),
that the calibration curve obtained
in this way, may differ from the
static calibration obtained when
the input variable is allowed to
vary from the maximum value
down to the minimum value (also
called the downscale direction).
This phenomenon, illustrated in
Figure 1-7, is called hysteresis.
This is usually caused by friction
or backlash in the gearing of the
instrument.
Hysteresis error
for input x0
Output y
yMAX
Downscale
static
calibration
Upscale
static
calibration
yMIN
xMIN
x0
xMAX
Input x
Figure 1-7
Dead band
Dead band is the largest change of input to which the instrument does not
respond due to friction or backlash effects
Note: Dead band error is normally
associated with hysteresis. Dead
band operation is sometimes
intentionally built into the
instrument for instance in a room
temperature regulator to prevent
excessive on-off switching. As an
example of dead band behaviour in
an
instrument,
Figure
1-8
illustrates instrument insensitivity
near zero input, typically because
of friction.
Output y
yMAX
Insensitivity
near zero
input
yMIN
xMIN
xMAX
Figure 1-8
Input x
a)
b)
c)
a)
b)
.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
16.5
32.0
44.0
51.5
55.5
58.0
60
50
Maximum nonlinearity 47-33
= 15 mV
40
30
20
10
x displacement
in cm
0
0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
The maximum deviation from the straight line connecting the range values
appears to occur when the displacement is 1.7 cm. The non-linearity at this
point is approximately 48 33 = 15 mV. Non-linearity expressed as percentage
of full scale is (15/58)100 26 %.
c)
Sensitivity at x = 1 cm, is equal to the slope of the line tangent to the curve
y
at x = 1 cm. K =
= 60 4 = 29.5 mV/cm
x 1.9 0
Analysis
Alarm
Burner or combustion
Users choice*
Users choice
Control
Users choice
Voltage
Flow rate
User's choice
High
Current
Indicate
Power
Time schedule
Control station
Level
Light / Low
Moisture or humidity
Middle
Users choice
Users choice
Users choice
Orifice, restriction
Pressure or vacuum
Quantity
Radiation
Record or print
Speed or frequency
Switch
Temperature
Transmit
Multivariable
Multifunction
Vibration or viscosity
Weight or force
Well
Unclassified
Unclassified
Relay or compute
Position, dimension
Primary element
Table 1-1
* The users choice entry in the table may be used to denote a particular meaning, and
the user must describe the particular meaning(s) in the legend accompanying his
drawing.
The letter Y in the second position has an extended meaning of variable manipulation,
and some of this instrument functions are given in table 1-2.
Symbol
Xn
K -K
> < > <
D or d/dt
X/Y
Function
Add, subtract, multiply and divide
Raise to power, square root, bias
Proportional reverse proportional
High select, low select, high limit, low limit
Integral, derivative
Convert X to Y with X and Y selected from:
P=Pressure, E=Voltage, I=Current, H=Hydraulic
O=Electromagnetic or sonic, A=Analog, D=Digital
Table 1-2
1.7.2
Pneumatic transmitter
Process
output
100%
20mA (5V)
Electronic transmitter
100%
100kPa
75%
80kPa
75%
16mA (4V)
50%
60kPa
50%
12mA (3V)
25%
40kPa
25%
8mA (2V)
0%
20kPa
0%
4mA (1V)
output
Example 1-4
A 20 - 100 kPa output pneumatic transmitter is used to monitor the water level inside a
tank. The calibrated range is 100 to 200 cm. of water above the base of the tank.
Calculate the output of the transmitter when the water level is at 175 cm. above the
base of the tank.
Span (difference between the upper and lower limit) of the transmitter output
= 100 kPa - 20 kPa = 80 kPa
Fraction of measurement = (175 100)/(200 100) = 0.75
Output Signal = (Fraction of Measurement) (Signal Span) + Live Zero
= 0.7580 + 20 = 80 kPa
Example 1-5
An electronic transmitter with an output of 4 - 20 mA is calibrated for a pressure range
of 70 - 150 kPa. What pressure is represented by a 12 mA signal?
Span of transmitter = 20 mA - 4 mA = 16 mA
Fraction of Measurement Change = (Output Signal - Live Zero)/Signal Span
= (12 4)/16 = 0.5
Actual Process Change = (Fractional Change) (Process Span)
= 0.5(150 - 70 kPa) = 40 kPa
Actual Process Value = Base Point + Process Change
= 70 + 40 kPa = 110 kPa.
Note: One advantage of a pneumatic system is that sparks will not be produced if a
transmitter malfunction occurs, making it much safer when used in an explosive
environment. The biggest problem with pneumatic systems is that air is compressible.
This means that a pressure transient representing a process change will only travel in
the air line at sonic velocity (approximately 300 m/sec.). Long signal lines will cause
substantial time delays, which is a serious drawback. Electronic signals on the other
hand, travel at speeds which approach the speed of light and can therefore be
transmitted over long distances without the introduction of unnecessary time delays.
1.7.4 Power supply abbreviations
AS Air supply
ES Electric supply
SS Steam supply HS Hydraulic supply
GS Gas supply
WS Water supply
NS Nitrogen supply
Instrument symbols
Instrument mounted
locally
(field mounted)
Instrument mounted
behind board
(mounted behind panel
in control room, not
accessible to operator)
Instruments sharing
common housing
(measures two
variables or single
variable with two
functions)
Valve
Valve with
diaphragm actuator
Valve with
hand actuator
Butterfly valve
Orifice plate
flowmeter
Venturi
flowmeter
Rotameter
flowmeter
Instrument mounted
on board
(panel mounted in
control room)
Electric
motor
1.7.6
Schematics
4
The key to instrument
identification, is given
in Figure 1-9
1
6
2
7
Figure 1-9
Example 1-6
Identify the following instruments:
a)
TRC
b)
FY
Exercise
Identify the instrumentation blocks in the heat exchanger below
Product stream
to be heated
PR
1a
PIT
1b
FIT
2a
FY
2b
Steam supply
PIC
3
M
TRC
4a
TSH
4b
TAH
4c
FR
2c
2. PRESSURE MEASUREMENT
The purpose of this chapter is to introduce students to the definitions and units of
pressure related quantities and to discuss typical methods to measure pressure.
F
A
Equation 2-1
Weight
100 N
Area
0.1 m2
P = 1000 Pa
Same force,
different area
different pressure
Area
P = 10000 Pa
0.01 m2
2.1.2 Density
Density of a substance is defined as the mass of a unit volume of a substance. The
SI unit is kilogram per cubic meter (kg/m3).
=
M
V
Equation 2-2
water = 1000 kg/m3
mercury = 13600 kg/m3
transformer oil = 864 kg/m3 air = 1.2 kg/m3
substance = substance
water
substance = 1000substance
Equation 2-3
(Note: If the substance is a gas, the relative density is defined as the ratio of the density
of the gas to the density of air at the same temperature, pressure and dryness.)
Atmospheric
pressure
Patm
Differential
pressure
Pvacuum
Absolute
pressure
Pabs
h
Figure 2-1
A
Volume of the liquid = V = cross-sectional areaheight = Ah.
Mass of the liquid = m = volumedensity = V = (Ah).
Weight of the liquid = w = mg = (Ah)g.
Pressure on the bottom of container due to weight of the liquid = wA
= Ahg/A = hg
We conclude therefore that the pressure (pascal) caused by a liquid column h meter
high and with density kilogram/meter3, is given by:
P = hg
Equation 2-4
where g is the gravitational acceleration. We will always use g = 9.81 m/s2 in pressure
calculations.
Note: If the absolute atmospheric pressure, exerted on the surface of the liquid, is P0
pascal, the total pressure acting on the bottom of the container is Ptotal = P0 + hg
Example 2-1
a) Convert a pressure of 150 cm. water, to a pressure expressed in pascal.
P = hg = 1000(15010-2)9.81 = 14715 Pa.
b) Convert a pressure of 10 kilo pascal to a pressure expressed as meter water.
P = hg 10000 = 1000h9.81 h = 1.019 meter
Therefore 10 kPa = 1.019 meter H2O.
c) Convert a pressure of 760 millimeter mercury to a pressure expressed in pascal.
P = hg = 13600(76010-3)9.81 = 101400 Pa = 101.4 kPa.
d) Convert a pressure of 50 kPa to a pressure expressed as millimeter mercury.
P = hg 50000 = 13600h9.81 h = 0.3748 meter
Therefore 50 kPa = 374.8 mm Hg.
Patm
Patm
Zero level
Figure 2-2
Example 2-2
A U tube manometer is half filled with mercury. A
pressure of 200 kPa is applied to the left hand leg and
a pressure of 100 kPa is applied to the right hand leg.
Calculate the reading h on the manometer.
200 kPa
100 kPa
P2
h
X
P1-P2 = hg
Gauge pressure.
The arrangement to measure gauge pressure,
is shown in Figure 2-3 (b). A pressure P1,
larger than atmospheric pressure, is applied
to one leg, and atmospheric pressure to the
other. The reading h will be indicative of the
pressure difference P1 Patm or the gauge
pressure.
Comparing pressures in the XY plane:
P1 = Patm + hg
P1 Patm = hg
Patm
P1
h
X
Zero level
Y
Pgauge = hg
Absolute pressure.
In order to measure absolute pressure, it is
necessary to compare the unknown pressure
with zero pascal, as shown in Figure 2-3 (c).
For that purpose, all the air must be removed
from one leg, to form a perfect vacuum.
That leg is then sealed. The two mercury
levels will take on their zero line position,
only if zero pascal is applied to the open leg.
Zero level
Vacuum
(0 Pa)
Pabs
h
X
Zero level
Y
Figure 2-3 (c)
Example 2-3
A u-tube manometer is filled with two liquids, one
liquid with a relative density of 1 and the other with a
relative density of 13.6. Calculate the pressure
difference, P1 P2 , applied across the manometer.
=1
0.5 m
1m
P2
Y
=13.6
579mm
10 kPa
434.25mm
7.5 kPa
289.5mm
5 kPa
144.75mm
2.5 kPa
100 kPa
1m
200 kPa
Px
1-(h/2)
h/2
X
Y
When 200 kPa is applied to the left hand tube,
the pressure in the sealed tube, will rise to a
new, higher than 100 kPa, pressure which we
will call Px. If the cross sectional area of the
tube is A, we may use Boyles law to obtain an expression for Px. The volume of
the air in the right hand tube is 1A when open to 100 kPa and sealed, with 200
kPa applied to the left hand tube, it is (1-h/2)A. Using Boyles law, P1V1=P2V2:
Px = 100103/[1-h/2] . (1)
100103[1A] = Px[(1-h/2)A]
Comparing pressures on the XY line:
200103 = Px + 13600h9.81 . (2)
(1) in (2): 200103 = 100103/[1-h/2] + 13.6103h9.81
200 = 100/[1-h/2] + 13.69.81h 200 = 100/[1-h/2] + 133.4h
200(1-h/2) = 100 + 133.4h(1-h/2) 200-100h=100+133.4h 66.71h2
{ax2+bx+c=0 x=[-b(b2-4ac)]/2a}
66.71h2 233.4h + 100 = 0
h = [233.4(233.42-466.71100)]/266.71 = 0.5 m or h=3m (unacceptable)
Cross sectional
Area of tube = A2
P1
High
Zero level
X
Y
A2
A1
Manometer liquid
density =
Cross sectional
Area of well = A1
Figure 2-4 (a)
When the two limbs are open, as shown in Figure 2-4 (a), the manometer liquid
meniscuses will fall on the zero line. If a pressure differential, P1 - P2 (P1 > P2), is
applied to the instrument, in Figure 2-4 (b), the rise and fall of the manometer liquid in
the two limbs will be different (h > d). The level h, in the glass tube, to which the
manometer liquid rises above the zero line, can be measured, while the fall in the
liquid level d, in the well, can not be observed, and as such, will be eliminated from
our equations below.
Comparing the pressures in the two limbs, on level XY, in figure 2-4 (b):
P1 = P2 + (h+d)g (1)
Also, the volume of manometer liquid, leaving the well, is
equal to the volume of manometer liquid, entering the tube:
A1d = A2h
d =
(2) in (1):
2 h .. (2)
A
1
A
P1 = P2 + h + 2 h g
A
P1 P2 = hg 1 + 2
A
1
Equation 2-5
P1
High
Zero level
X
Y
Cross sectional
Area of well = A1
Cross sectional
Area of tube = A2
Figure 2-5
Deriving the relationship between the applied pressure differential P1-P2, and the
manometer reading L, is very similar to that of the well type. The only difference is
that the tube and horizontal does not form an angle of 90, but an angle .
Comparing the pressures on level XY, in figure 2-5:
P1 = P2 + (h+d)g (1)
Equating rise and fall of manometer liquid:
A1d = A2L
d =
2 L .. (2)
A
1
2
L g
P1 = P2 + Lsin +
A
1
P1 P2 = Lg sin + 2
A
1
Equation 2-6
b)
D 2 (3 10 2 ) 2
D 2 (12 10 3 ) 2
-6
1
A1=
=
=706.910 and A2= 2 =
=113.110-6
4
4
4
4
Example 2-7
The reading h on a well type mercury manometer, is 73 cm when measuring a pressure
of 100 kPa.
a) Calculate the ratio of well diameter to the diameter of the tube.
b) Determine the change in level that the well mercury experiences.
a) From equation 2-5:
P1 P2 = hg 1 + 2
A
1
d=
A2
h
A1
d = 0.0277310-2
= 19.71 mm.
Relative density:
Applications:
Advantages:
Disadvantages:
2.3.5.2
Aniline
Relative density:
Applications:
Advantages:
Disadvantages:
2.3.5.3
Advantages:
Disadvantages:
Advantages:
Disadvantages:
2.964
Useful when measuring higher pressure differences. Suitable for pressure
measurement in ammonia gas installations.
Evaporates slowly. High density.
Bromoform
Relative density:
Applications:
Advantages:
Disadvantages:
2.3.5.7
1.605
Useful when measuring higher pressure differences. Suitable for measuring
pressure in chlorine gas installations.
Not attacked by chlorine.
Not easily seen. Readily evaporates.
Tetrabromoethane
Relative density:
Applications:
2.3.5.6
1.047
Suitable for pressure measurement in ammonia gas installations.
Does not mix with water.
Carbon Tetrachloride
Relative density:
Applications:
2.3.5.5
1.025
Suitable for pressure measurement in low pressure gas or air installations,
with the exception of ammonia and chlorine.
Low density for measuring small pressure differences. Evaporates slowly.
Does not mix with water. Can be easily seen.
Attacks paint. Poisonous, penetrates the skin and causes blood poisoning.
Aniline darkens on contact with air.
Dibutylphathalate
Relative density:
Applications:
Advantages:
Disadvantages:
2.3.5.4
0.864
Useful when measuring small pressure differences. Suitable for pressure
measurement in ammonia gas installations.
Low density for measuring small pressure differences. Unaffected by
ammonia. Can be easily seen. Does not readily evaporate.
Tends to cling to inside of tubes. Density of transformer oil varies.
2.9
Useful where pressure measurement demands manometer liquid with density
between water and mercury.
Density that falls between water and mercury.
Density uncertain. Poisonous. Freezes easily. Subject to attack. Attacks rubber.
Mercury
Relative density:
Applications:
Advantages:
Disadvantages:
13.6
Pressure measurements in compressed gas, and in water and steam
applications.
High density. Can be easily seen. Mercury does not: i) evaporate, ii) mix
with other liquids, iii) wet sides of tubes.
Expensive. Mobility and density are affected by contamination.
15
10
5
20
25
30
Hairspring
Adjustable link
Bourdon tube
Range adjust
Pinion gear
Pivot point
Sector gear
Pressure connection
Figure 2-6
Bellows element
P2 Low pressure
Moving end
Spring
P1
High pressure
Pressure indication
Differential pressure
The bellows element may also be used to measure gauge pressure if P2 is equal to
atmospheric pressure, as depicted in Figure 2-7 (b). Absolute pressure may be
measured, see Figure 2-7 (c), if all air is removed from the bellows enclosure, so that
the pressure in the bellows, acts against a vacuum (0 Pa).
Atmospheric pressure
P1
Vacuum (0 Pa)
P1
Pressure indication
Figure 2-7 (b) Gauge pressure
Pressure indication
Figure 2-7 (c) Absolute pressure
Figure 2-9 (a), shows a diaphragm used to measure a pressure difference, P1 - P2,
while in Figure 2-8 (b), the same function is fulfilled with a diaphragm capsule.
Diaphragm
P2
P1
P2
Capsule
P1
Pressure indication
Figure 2-9 (a) (Diaphragm)
Capsules are sometimes
filled with silicone oil and a
solid plate mounted in the
Pressure
center of the capsule to
protect against over-pressure. indication
Pressure is then applied to
both side of the diaphragm
(Figure 2-10) and it will
P1
deflect towards the lower
pressure. Most pneumatic (High pressure)
differential pressure transmitters (discussed in section Backup plate
2.6) are built around the
pressure capsule concept.
Pressure indication
Figure 2-9 (b) (Capsule)
Force bar
Seal and pivot
Silicone oil
P2
(Low pressure)
Capsule
Figure 2-10
Screw
Oil
Figure 2-11
Example 2-8
A dead weight tester has a primary piston with a diameter of 1.5 cm. The mass of the
platform and primary piston together, is 300 gram. Calculate the mass m, of the mass
pieces, that must be placed on the platform to check a gauge at 150 kPa.
Pressure =
150103 =
(1.5 10 - 2 ) 2
-6
(15010 )(176.710 ) = 9.81m + 2.943 9.81m = 26.51 2.943
9.81m = 23.57 m = 2.403 kg.
The total mass of the mass pieces to be placed on the platform is therefore 2.403 kg.
3
Restriction
Regulated
air supply
Nozzle
Pilot
relay
Cross flexure
A
Pivot point
(range wheel
adjust)
L1
Feedback
bellows
L2
Range bar
Output pressure
P0
Force bar
Pivot and seal
Zero adjustment
(20 kPa)
Capsule
flexure
Liquid filled
diaphragm
capsule
Low pressure (P2)
L
1
L
2
The ratio L1/L2 is adjusted during calibration, by changing the position of the range
wheel, to ensure that P0 equals 100 kPa when (P1-P2) reaches its maximum value.
Setting this ratio equal to m, we can rewrite equation (1) as:
P0 = m(P1 P2) + 20 kilopascal
Equation 2-7
In Equation 2-7, the variables P0, P1 and P2, must be expressed in kilopascal. A
graphical representation of Equation 2-7 is given in Figure 2-13
Output P0
[kPa]
P0 = m(P1 P2) + 20
where m = 80/(P1-P2)MAX
100
80
Figure 2-13
20
(P1-P2)MAX
0
(P1-P2)MAX
Input (P1-P2)
[kPa]
Example 2-9
A differential pressure transmitter is correctly calibrated for a process variable that
varies from 0 kPa to 170 kPa. Determine the output of the DP transmitter when the
process variable reaches 90 kPa.
Air
supply
Restriction
Flapper and
nozzle
Pivot
Output
Feedback
bellows
Figure 2-14
stem
(cone)
When the force F moves the flapper towards the nozzle, the airflow through the
nozzle will be reduced, thereby causing a smaller pressure drop across the
restriction, so that more of the supply pressure will arrive at the diaphragm
Backing material
Grid
Figure 2-16
Solder tabs
Force
Cross sectional
area decreases
Force
Length increases
Figure 2-17
The fractional change in length / is called the strain , so that the gauge factor
may be expressed as:
where
GF = R/R ,
Equation 2-8
= l .
l
Equation 2-9
F
R2
R1
E
V0
R3
+
R4
Strain gauge
Figure 2-18
Using the voltage division rule, the output voltage of the bridge is easily obtained as:
R3
R4
E.
R
R
R
R
+
+
4
1
3
2
V0 =
R
R
3
4
=
(which implies
R + R
R + R
2
4
1
3
R
R
4 = 2 ), the voltage output V0 will be zero. Under these
R
R
1
3
conditions, the bridge is said to be balanced. Any change in resistance in any arm of
the bridge will now result in a nonzero output voltage. Therefore, if we replace R4 in
Figure 2-16 with an active strain gauge, any change in the strain gauge resistance will
unbalance the bridge and produce a nonzero output voltage, related to the stress. Let us
assume that when the bridge is in balance, the nominal values of the bridge arms are
R1 = R, R2 = R, R3 = R and R4 = R. Now if R4 is put under tension (stress), R4 will
change its value to R + R and the bridge output will become:
that R1R4 = R2R3 or
(R + R)
R E = R + R 1 E
2R + R 2
R + (R + R) R + R
V0 =
2(R + R) (2R + R)
E
2(2R + R)
V0 =
V0 =
R
E
4R + 2R
V0 =
(GF)
41 + (GF)
2
Equation 2-10
Equation 2-10 is the bridge equation for one strain gauge in the bridge or what is
known as a quarter bridge. Other structures are possible, such as one active and one
dummy strain gauge or two active strain gauges (half-bridge) or four active strain
gauges (full bridge).
The bridge output voltage is typically very small and additional electronic circuitry is
needed to amplify the signal and condition it for a 4 to 20 mA or a 1 to 5 V signal.
Example 2-10
A strain gauge, imbedded in a silicone filled pressure capsule, is used to measure a
differential pressure P1 P2. The strain gauge is connected to a quarter Wheatstone
bridge arrangement shown in the figure below. Each of the resistors in the three fixed
arms, has a resistance of 120 . The strain gauge has a nominal resistance of 120
and the bridge is therefore in balance if the capsule experiences no stress. The gauge
factor of the strain gauge is two (GF = 2). The pressure cell is put under stress by
applying a differential pressure P1 P2 = 100 kPa which results in a strain of = 0.005
in the strain gauge. Calculate the amplifier gain required to produce an output of 1 volt
from the Wheatstone output voltage V0, when P1 - P2 = 100 kPa.
120
10 V
120
V0
+
Strain
gauge
120
P2
Pressure
capsule
P1
Output
3. FLOW MEASUREMENT
The purpose of this chapter is to introduce students to the definitions and units of flow
related quantities and to discuss typical methods to measure volumetric flow and
flowrate.
Equation 3-1
v
Distance cylinder travels in 1 second
3.2 VISCOSITY
Viscosity is a measure of a fluid's resistance to flow and is measured in
poiseuille (PI).
Note: Not all liquids are the same. Some are thin and flow easily. Others are thick and
sticky. Honey or syrup will pour more slowly than water. A liquid's resistance to flow
is called its viscosity. Imagine two layers of a liquid at a distance y from each other
and with layer area A, as shown in Figure 3-1. If we assume that the bottom plate is
the layer of stationary liquid molecules, clinging to the wall of the pipeline, then the
force F that we must apply to move the top plate at a constant velocity v relative to the
bottom plate, will be indicative of the fluids flow resistance.
F
v
y
Figure 3-1
The quantity
v
F
, is called the shear stress in the fluid and the ratio
is called the
y
A
velocity gradient (or shear rate). For typical liquids (Newtonian liquids), the shear
stress is proportional to the velocity gradient and the constant of proportionality is
called the viscosity of the liquid.
=
F/A
v/y
Equation 3-2
The SI units for viscosity are the poiseuille (PI) or pascal-second (Pa-s) or newtonsecond per square meter (N-s/m2). Another common (cgs) unit used to express
viscosity is the poise (1 poise = 0.1 PI).
Some examples of viscosity of liquids (at 20 C):
water = 0.001 PI
air = 0.00002 PI
honey = 100 PI
oil = 1 PI (typical)
mercury = 0.0015 PI
peanut butter = 2500 PI
Dv
Equation 3-3
where D is the pipe diameter (m), v is the flow speed of the fluid (m/s), is the
density of the fluid (kg/m3) and is the viscosity of the fluid (PI).
At low Reynolds numbers (generally below Re = 2000) the flow is streamlined while
at high Reynolds numbers (above Re =3000) the flow becomes fully turbulent.
Flow straighteners (straightening vanes)
When flow is measured and the flow is not streamlined, errors may arise in the
readings obtained. This problem can be prevented by installing flow straighteners
or straightening vanes, inside the pipe as shown in Figure 3-3.
Flow
Flow
Figure 3-3
Example 3-1
The average velocity of water at room temperature in a tube of radius 0.1 m is
0.2 ms-1. Is the flow laminar or turbulent?
Re = (0.20.21000)/0.001 = 40000 > 3000 hence turbulent.
R 4
(p p 2 )
8L 1
Equation 3-4
where q is the liquids flowrate (m3/s), R is the radius of the pipe (m), is the
viscosity of the fluid (PI), L is the length of the pipe (m) and p1p2 is the pressure
differential across the pipe (Pa).
The variables used in Equation 3-4, are
illustrated in Figure 3-4, and the typical
parabolic velocity profile associated with
laminar flow in a pipe, is also shown.
p1
p2
Figure 3-4
(0.075) 4
3
(102 103 100 103 ) = 0.2485 m /s.
8 (0.001) 100
p + 1 v 2 + gh = constant.
2
p1 + 1 v 2 + gh1 = p 2 + 1 v 2 + gh 2 .
2 1
2 2
2(p
p
)
stag
stat
.
Equation 3-7
A disadvantage of the Pitot tube is that it measures the flowrate only at one point.
An annubar flowmeter overcomes this problem by positioning several Pitot tubes
across the pipe diameter, providing a better average.
Note: The Pitot tube measures flowrate, by making direct use of Equation 3-6,
pdyn = pstag pstat v2 = pstag pstat v = [2(pstag pstat)/].
h1
Flowdirection
A1
p1
v1
A2
p2
v2
Flowrate = q
Referring to Figure 3-6, consider a unit volume in the flow stream with mass
(given that the density of the stream is ). Let us now follow this unit volume in the
flow stream, as it passes the point X (flow area A1), travelling with velocity v1 and
under pressure p1, and then later passing the point Y (with smaller flow area A2) at a
higher velocity v2 and under the influence of a smaller pressure p2.
According to Bernoullis theorem for a steady stream, the total energy content
(pressure energy plus kinetic energy) of the unit volume should stay constant.
1 2
1
v + p = v 2 + p .. Equation 3-8 (a)
1
1
2
2
2 2
And flow continuity demands that the flow rate q must be the same at X and Y:
q = A1v1 = A2v2, therefore v1 =
Using Equation 3-8 (b), v1 can be eliminated from Equation 3-8 (a), which will allow
us to obtain an expression for v2 and to determine the flowrate from q = A2v2.
1
1
[(A /A )v ]2 + p = v 2 + p (A 2 / A1) 2 v 2 + 2p1 = v 2 + 2p 2
2 1 2
1 2 2
2
2
2
2
2(p1 p 2 )
v 2 1 (A 2 / A1) 2 = 2(p1 p 2 ) v 2 =
2
2
1 - (A 2 /A1) 2
2(p1 p2 )
v2 =
1 (A 2/A1)2
2(p1 p2 )
q = A2
1 (A 2/A1)2
Equation 3-8 (e), expresses essentially what we wanted to show, namely, the flow
rate q varies with the square root of the pressure difference across the restriction.
Equation 3-8 (e) may be simplified further, if we choose to specifically measure the
pressure difference p1 p2 by allowing the liquid in the stream to rise up in the two
vertical tubes, as shown in Figure 3-6, and then take the reading h.
p1 = Patm + (h1 + h)g and
p2 = Patm + h1g.
p1 p2 = hg .... Equation 3-8 (f)
Using p1 p2 from Equation 3-8 (f) in Equation 3-8 (e):
q = A2
2hg
2hg
= A2
. Equation 3-8 (g)
2
2
1 (A 2 /A1)
1 (A 2 /A1)
q=k h
Equation 3-9
Note: Although we assumed a horizontal flow stream, it can be shown that Equation
3-9 is equally valid for inclined flow streams or even vertical flow streams. Please
remember that h in Eq. 3-9 still implies the pressure difference p1 p2 (pascal).
v2
v2
p2
A2
v1
p1
q
q
p1
0.005m2
A1
p2
0.004m2
0.001m2
Answer: There are two forces operating on the object, a gravitational force Fw pulling
it downwards and a drag force Fd caused by the water stream, pulling it upwards.
Fd
Fw
It is given that the flow rate q is 100% when the differential pressure h is 100%.
Using Equation 3-9, q = k h , 100 = k 100 k = 10
For h = 20%, q = 10 20 = 44.72%. For h = 40%, q = 10 40 = 63.25%
For h = 60%, q = 10 60 = 77.46%. For h = 80%, q = 10 80 = 89.44%
Flowrate q
(percent of full scale)
100
80
q = 10 h
or
h = 0.001q2
(y = ax2)
60
40
20
Differential pressure h
(percent of full scale)
0
20
kPa
20
40
60
36
kPa
52
kPa
68
kPa
80
84
kPa
100
100
kPa
Flow
Inlet cone
(19 23)
d Throat
d/2
D/2
Figure 3-7
3.9.2 Advantages and disadvantages of the venturi tube
Advantages
Highly expensive
Occupies considerable space.
Outlet cone
(5 15)
Flow
Figure 3-8
Tag
Flow
Orifice plate
Orifice
Packing
Pipe flange
Orifice plate
Flow
Drain hole
Figure 3-10 (a)
Vent holes:
Vent hole
Flow
Orifice plate
Figure 3-10 (b)
Orifice plates are cheap and easy to install. (A home made orifice is often
entirely satisfactory, whereas a venturi meter is practically always purchased
from an instrument dealer.)
Orifice plates are reliable and require a minimum amount of maintenance.
The orifice plate can easily be changed to accommodate widely different flow
rates, whereas the throat diameter of a venturi is fixed.
Disadvantages
The orifice meter has a large permanent loss of pressure because of the presence
of eddies on the downstream side of the orifice-plate; the shape of the venturi
meter, however, prevents the formation of these eddies and greatly reduces the
permanent pressure loss.
The higher pressure loss may be associated with higher cost and when an orifice
is inserted in a line carrying fluid continuously over long periods of time, the
cost of the power loss may be out of all proportion to the saving in first cost.
3.10.5 The vena contracta position in a flow stream
The point where the stream is at its smallest cross-sectional area is called the vena
contracta. At this point, flow velocity is a maximum and pressure is a minimum.
Flow
Figure 3-12
Vena contracta
The position of the vena contracta point, indicated in Figure 3-12, is of course not
stationary but varies with flow velocity. (It is useful here to think about a hosepipe
nozzle.)
3.10.6 Positions of the various orifice plate tap points.
Depending on the application to which the orifice plate is put, tap points can be
located at various positions. The following tap points are usually used:
Corner taps
Corner taps are mounted directly against the sides of the orifice plate, as shown in
Figure 3-13a. Corner taps are very sensitive and calibration is very easily affected
if the d/D ratio changes as a result of wear. These tap points are therefore not
recommended for liquids which contain solid particles.
Flow
D
d
Figure 3-13 (a)
Flange taps
Flange taps are mounted directly in the pipe flange 25 mm. upstream and 25 mm.
downstream, as shown in Figure 3-13b. They are usually accurately built into the
flange by the manufacturer.
25 25
mm mm
Flow
D
d
Figure 3-13 (b)
Radius taps
Radius taps are the most common type in use and are usually called D and D/2 taps
or throat taps. The high pressure tap is mounted one pipe diameter upstream and
the low pressure tap, one half pipe diameter downstream. These taps give a very
high differential pressure.
High pressure
tap
Flow
D
d
Figure 3-13 (c)
These taps, shown in Figure 3-13d, are much like radius taps. The high pressure
tap is also situated one pipe diameter upstream and the low pressure tap is situated
at the vena contracta point. A disadvantage of this system is that the vena contracta
point does not stay static at one point, its position varies with flow velocity. This
system does however provide the highest differential pressure of all other tap
positions. It is not recommended for conditions where there is a large variation in
flow rate.
D
High pressure
tap
Flow
D
d
Vena contracta
Pipe taps are mounted two and a half pipe diameters upstream and eight pipe
diameters downstream, as shown in Figure 3-13e. The differential pressure
developed is not very high however, but it is not affected very much by the rate of
flow or wear of the pipe walls or the orifice hole.
2D
8D
Flow
D
d
Figure 3-13 (e)
Other flow meters
The remaining flow meters that we will discuss are not specifically based on the flow
equation although the next two, the target meter and rotameter may still be considered
to be similar to the orifice plate in the sense that they cause a flow restriction with
associated pressure difference, but in the case of the target meter, the pressure
difference translates into a force (parea) that varies with the flow rate, while the
rotameter attempts to keep the pressure difference constant by varying its float
position with the flow rate.
Electronics
housing
Strain gauge
Force bar
Target
Figure 3-14
In Appendix 3-1 at the end of Chapter 3, it is shown that the flow rate q may be
determined from the measured force F exerted on the target, with the expression:
q=
(D 2 d 2 ) 8F
4
d 2
Equation 3-10
where D is the pipe diameter (meter), d the target diameter (meter), F the drag force on
the target (newton) and the fluid density (kg/m3)
3.12 ROTAMETERS
The rotameter (also called a variable area flow
meter) consists of a gradually tapered transparent
Scale
Fd
tube, mounted vertically in a frame with the large
end up, as shown in Figure 3-15. The fluid flows
upward through the tube and a metal displacer or
float, is suspended in the fluid. The float is the
Float
indicating element and the reading is taken on the
scale in line with the top of the float. The position
Fw
in the tube where the float reaches equilibrium,
Tapered
depends on the flow rate of the fluid. The greater
tube
the flow rate, the further up the tube the float rises.
The tube is often made of high strength glass to
allow for direct observation of the float position,
Figure 3-15
Flow
but if greater strength is required or if the liquid is
very dark or dirty, a metal tube is used and the float position detected externally.
The operation of the rotameter is discussed in Appendix 3-2. With the rotameter the
flow rate q may be determined from:
q = k(At Af).
Equation 3-11
where At is the tube area at the current float position (meter2), Af the float area
(meter2) and k a calibration constant (meter/second).
Vortices
(swirls)
Flow
d
v
Figure 3-16
Ultrasonic sensors
When an object (also called a bluff body or shredder bar) is located in a flow
stream, it causes an alternating series of vortices and whirls to be formed (or
shedded) downstream in the flow (called a von Karman vortex street), as shown in
Figure 3-16. The number of vortices passing downstream over a given interval of
time is proportional to the mean flow velocity. Vortex flow meters utilize this
phenomenon by counting the number of vortices, using different techniques such
as pressure sensors, capacitance sensors or thermistor temperature sensors built
into the bluff body. A popular technique is to use ultrasonic sensors placed outside
the pipe just after the shedder bar, which will send an ultrasonic beam across the
pipe. The vortices will modulate the frequency of the ultrasonic signal and the
vortices are then counted by electronic circuitry.
Note: A flag is a good example of vortex shedding. The flagpole
acts as the shredder bar that sheds the wind into vortices that makes
the flag wave. In spite of all the complex fluid dynamics involved
inside a flow stream, the formula for calculating the frequency of
the vortexes, is surprisingly simple and is given by, f = S t v , where v is the flow
d
velocity, d is the width of the vortex generator and St is a proportional constant called
the Strouhal number. The Strouhal number is a function of the shape of the vortex
generator but it is constant over a broad range of Reynolds numbers and flow
velocities. The measured vortex frequency may thus be utilised to calculate the flow
velocity v = fd/St, and from the flow velocity, the flow rate q = Av may be obtained.
Equation 3-12
where A is the unblocked flow area (meter2), f is the measured vortex frequency
(hertz), d is the width of the bluff body (meter) and St the Strouhal number
(dimensionless).
Flow
v
B
Magnet coils
Electrodes
Figure 3-17
Magnetic flow meters (magmeters) can measure the flow rate of any conductive
liquid while offering no obstructions to the flow stream. A simplified schematic
diagram of a magnetic flow meter is shown in Figure 3-17. Magnetic flow meters
are based on Faradays law of electromagnetic induction (e = Bv), which states
that when a conductor is moved through a magnetic field, an emf e (volt) will be
generated that is proportional to the velocity v (m/s) of the conductor, the length
(m) of the conductor, and the strength B (tesla) of the magnetic field. The section
of pipe that is part of the flow meter, contains the coils through which current is
passed to produce the magnetic field as well as the electrodes that produce the
voltage that is proportional to the flow rate. This section must be made of a
material that is non-magnetic so as not to distort the magnetic field and also a
material that is non-conductive so that the electrodes are not short circuited. To
ensure that the electrodes make contact with the liquid at all times, they should,
preferably lie in a horizontal plane.
Note: Faradays law can be applied to a flowmeter,
if one imagines the liquid to consist of a series of
v
liquid tubes moving through the magnetic field and
q = k D e.
B
Equation 3-13
where D is the distance between electrodes or pipe diameter (meter), B the magnetic
flux density (tesla), e the measured emf (volt) and k a calibration constant
(dimensionless).
Piezoelectric crystals
Figure 3-19
The fascinating principle of operation of the extremely accurate Coriolis mass flow
meter, is discussed in Appendix 3-5 at the end of Chapter 3
Bearing
Rotor shaft
Cone
Figure 3-21
Support and
flow straightener
and an alternating voltage is induced in the coil as the blades pass the coil. Each
voltage pulse represents a discrete volume of liquid that passed through the meter.
The total volume is obtained by counting the number of pulses generated.
Figure 3-22
Slide valve
Inlet
Outlet
(a)
Pivot
Slide valve
Inlet
Outlet
(b)
1
2
q = A2
=
[1-(A2/A1)2 ]
Target area=d2/4
p1
p2
F1=p1d2/4
F2=p2d2/4
F
2
(D 2 d 2 ) 8F
(D 2 d 2 ) 2(4F/d 2 )
=
4
4
d 2
The total distance the two have moved before they collided is clearly T and therefore
vt + ct = T or t = T/(v+c). Furthermore, during the same time interval t, wave
crest I has already moved a distance ct from the origin where it was reflected,
towards the receiver. Wave crest II is now also on its way back to the receiver and it is
again clear from the sketch that the distance between I and II (which is the wavelength
R, of the reflected sound wave with corresponding received frequency, fR = c/R) is
given by: R = ct - vt = (c v)t = (c v)T/(v + c) R(c + v) = T(c - v)
(c/fR)(c + v) = (c/fT)(c v) fT(c + v) = fR(c v) vfT + vfR = cfR cfT
v = c(fR fT)/(fT + fR).
Because fT fR, it follows that fT + fR 2fT, and we conclude that
the speed of the object is given by, v = (fR - fT)c/2fT. When we refer
c
back to Figure 3-18, we see that the sound waves are transmitted at
an angle into the stream. This means that we are not measuring the vcos
flow velocity v, but rather the magnitude of the velocity vector,
v
vcos, that is directly in line with the sound beam (see sketch). We
therefore replace v with its component vcos in v = (fR - fT)c/2fT, to obtain the flow
velocity v = c(fR fT)/2fTcos.
Appendix 3-4 (Transit time meter)
Referring to Figure 3-19, if the flow velocity is v meter/second, then the component of
v that is parallel to the beam path is vcos. If the speed of sound is c meter/second, the
upstream speed of the sound beam is c-vcos, as it is opposed by the flow. The
downstream speed of the sound pulse is c+vcos as it is assisted by the flow. The time
it takes a sound pressure pulse to move upstream from transducer 1 to 2 is then
t12=L/(c-vcos), where L is the distance between the transceivers, and the time it takes
a sound pressure pulse to move downstream from transducer 2 to 1 is t21=L/(c+vcos).
The difference of the inverses of the times is then, 1/t21-1/t12=(c+vcos)/L-(c-vcos)/L
and it follows easily that the flow velocity v = L[(1/t21)-(1/t12)]/2cos, from which the
flowrate q = Av may be determined.
Appendix 3-5 (Coriolis meter)
It is easy to demonstrate the tube twisting phenomenon.
If water is flowing in an elastic hosepipe and a section of
the hosepipe, formed in a loop, is swung slowly forward
and backward, the twisting of the lower section of the
hosepipe will immediately be observed.
The Coriolis force was first described by the French civil engineer Gaspard Coriolis
in 1843, who observed that the wind, the ocean currents and even airborne artillery
shells will always drift sideways because of the earths rotation. If one could imagine
a person standing in the centre of a rotating disk revolving in a clockwise direction, as
depicted in Figure A3-1 (a), and he rolls a ball straight from A to B, he would observe
that as far as he and his rotating disk is concerned, the ball is not moving in a straight
line but rather it is curling to the left. This person would come to the conclusion that
there is apparently a force present that is pushing the ball away.
A
B
A
B
the rotational frame, is the
angular speed of rotational
frame and v is the outward
speed of the mass body. If the
(a)
(b)
Figure A3-1
person would repeat the
experiment but this time rolling
the ball through an elastic
rubber pipe fixed at A and B,
B
A
Flow
Driver
Tube
Figure A3-3
The driver element (exciter) is at this moment rotating the tubes downward with an
angular velocity . The fluid moving into the entrance tube, now acts in the same way
as the ball rolling out from the centre of the disk and is bending the tube upwards. The
fluid moving in the exit tube behaves the same way as the ball rolling in from the edge
of the spinning disk and is bending the tube downwards. The total effect is a
clockwise twist of the tubes. When the driver element starts to push the tubes upwards
(the driver operates near the resonance frequency of the tubes), the whole scenario
changes around and the tubes will twist in an anti-clockwise direction.