Estudo de Caso Ponte de Oresund - Saleema Hughes
Estudo de Caso Ponte de Oresund - Saleema Hughes
Estudo de Caso Ponte de Oresund - Saleema Hughes
Abstract: This paper aims to provide a critical analysis of The resund Bridge, connecting Copenhagen (Denmark) to
Malm (Sweden). The analysis will include a discussion on the aesthetic, structural design, foundations, construction
sequence, sustainability aspects of the bridge and the structural checks calculated under different load combinations.
Attention will be paid to the short fabrication and construction time of the bridge.
1 Introduction
The resund Bridge is the longest cable-stayed
bridge in the world which carries both rail and road
traffic, and connects the Danish capital Copenhagen to
Malm in Sweden. The resund Link crosses the
Baltic Sea and is made up of an artificial island
stretching 4 km, a 3.5 km underwater tunnel and a
bridge spanning 7.7 km. In 2003, the resund Bridge
was awarded the IABSE (International Association for
Bridge and Structural Engineering) Outstanding
Structure Award for the innovative planning and
construction
management
techniques,
and
environmental considerations.
2 Aesthetics
Analyzing the aesthetics of the resund Bridge is
purely subjective, however Leonhardt Fritzs ten rules
of aesthetics will be used to gain an objective view of
the bridge.
2.1 Fulfillment of function
The cable-stayed bridge is simple structure,
where the load paths can be seen clearly from the harp
shape formation of cables The symmetrical cables, all
at an inclination of 30 result in the pylons looking
balanced and in equilibrium. When drivers enter and
leave the high bridge the function of the bridge is clear,
without the cables interfering with the road line. The
principal horizontal girder makes a clear statement of
its structural purpose. The absence of a cross beam
above the road deck keeps the bridge design looking
free and ensures the cables are the most important
visual aspect when driving across the bridge.
2.3 Order
The resund Bridge is well ordered when
viewed in elevation. The pylons are evenly spaced at
160m apart from those nearest the pylons, which are
140m. The symmetry of the cables gives a clean
appearance. The width of the pier is only slightly wider
than the truss, and the deep girder lends itself to longer
2.4 Refinement
The angles of the warren truss are at the same angle as
the cable-stays, creating a visual refinement which can
be seen when the bridge is viewed in elevation. The
pylon legs are pentagonal shape in cross section, and
taper towards the top. The pylons are still able to
provide stability as the harp only delivers a small load
to the top of the pylon, creating a slender pylon that
does not look as visually imposing. The detailing of
the top of the piers, where connections only occur at
the edge of the truss, gives the piers a more slender
look (Fig 4). To give train users a clear view of the
resund Strait, a more open bracing system on the
trusses has been used, which in turn makes the
appearance of the bridge lighter.
3 Structural Design
3.1 Choice of Bridge Type
When deciding upon a design for the bridge, a
number of considerations had to be taken into account.
On the shoreline of Denmark was Copenhagen
International airport. Building high towers would run
The risk of a collision from airplanes. A bridge that
was built too low may cause ships to collide, so an arch
design was therefore ruled out. Designers decided
against a suspension bridge, as the flexibility would
result in the tracks bending, and trains would not
operate on tracks that are subject to deflection. A cablestayed bridge was the best option to achieve the
rigidity needed at an economical cost.
Component
Steel Girder
Steel Box Section
Concrete Railway
trough
Concrete Roadway
Deck
Total (per m)
Unfactored
Load (kN)
152,450
5,320
21,600
Factor
(fl)
1.05
1.05
1.15
Factored
Load
176,080
6,144
27,324
27,000
1.15
34,155
421 kN/m
498
kN/m
4.3.1 HA Loading
HA loading is made up on a uniformly- distributed
load (UDL) acting over the notional lanes of the bridge
plus a knife-edge load (KEL) acting at the most critical
location. The UDL can be worked out using Eq. 1
below (Ref x).
( )0.1
(1)
Weight (kN)
37.8
20
40
97.8 kN/m
188.3 kN/m
(2)
(3)
= x T x E
= 12x10-6 x 27 x 210,000
= 68 N/mm2
(7)
(4)
PLS = 0.5 q A3 CL
(5)
PLS = 0.5 x 604 x (245 x 23.5) x 0.4
PLS = 696 kN
5 Structural Analysis
4.5 Temperature
Temperature effects are important in bridges,
as fluctuations in temperature can cause cracking of the
concrete bridge deck, which can result in the bridge
experiencing significant stresses. There are two
temperature effects in bridges, overall temperature
increases and temperature difference between the top
and bottom deck.
4.5.1 Effective Temperature
The resund Bridge connects Sweden to
Copenhagen, and these two countries have slightly
different climates. The bridge may experience
temperature variation during different times of the year
or from one end of the bridge to the other. The
temperature range has therefore been taken as 40
degrees acting over the length of the bridge. The
coefficient of thermal expansion for steel is = 12x10-6
5.1 Deck
The analysis of the bridge deck will be
simplified by modelling it as a continuous beam with
rigid supports representing the cables. The bending
moment will be calculated with a UDL of dead and
superimposed loads applied across all lanes and a
knife-edge load applied at midspan. The bending
moment for the high bridge can be calculated using Eg.
8.
M = Wl2 + Pl
10
4
(8)
L = T x L x
(6)
L = 40 x 7,845 x 12x10-6
L = 2540mm
The stresses along the bridge can therefore be
calculated (Eq. 7) using 210,000 N/mm2 as the youngs
modulus of steel.
= My
I
(9)
= 20.5 x 10 6 x 5850
5.4 x 1014
= 2.2 x 10 -4
The small stress experienced by the deck shows the
rigidity of the warren truss.
The deck can also be modelled as a simply supported
beam with a fixed end at the pylon end and a pinned
end, where the dead load of the deck is taken by the
cables. The bending moment can then be calculated
with a UDL of live loads (HA and train loads) and a
point load acting 2/3 along the deck to produce the
worst possible case. Producing a maximum moment of
767.2 MNm
M = W(0.75leff)2 + Pa2b(2l+b)
8
2l3
(10)
6 Construction
The resund Bridge was constructed on time and
on budget, which is unusual for the size and
complexity of the project. Prefabrication was used
extensively to ensure quality and efficient construction,
with elements being of a high standard. Construction of
bridge sections on land, also reduced the amount of
time spent at the bridge line and the risk that the
marine enrinonement would be polluted or disturbed.
Construction of the resund Bridge started with
the 204m high towers, which were fabricated in Malm
harbour. The two towers were the only major elements
to be constructed in-situ . The tower was constructed in
4m sections every 7-10 days, using climbing
formwork. Ensuring one tower was always 12m taller
.
Figure 17: Svanen lifting the girder into the bridge line
6.1 Bearings
The truss girders are supported on pot
bearings, which consist of a rubber disk within a steel
cylinder, which allow for rotation. The approach spans
have longitudinal fixed bearings on two piers and the
high bridge also have longitudinal fixed bearings as
well as partially fixed bearings. Fixed bearings limit
longitudinal movements due to temperature variations
but are able to take longitudinal forces due to ship
collisions or earthquakes. Hydraulic units are installed
at the expansion joints between the approach spans and
side spans of the cable-stayed bridge, which allow for
movement from temperature variations and absorb and
transfer braking forces which would otherwise be taken
by the cable-stays and result in bending of the pylons.
7 Durability
The resund Bridge has a design life of 100
years, if maintained well. The smooth outer surfaces of
members ensure moisture and dirt do not accumulate.
It is likely that some structural elements will need
replacing if they become damaged or worn out.
7.1 Corrosion
9 Sustainability
Arup design and research team were
commissioned to develop the corrosion protection for
the resund Bridge. The brief was to provide the
maximum possible protection, by using a thick barrier
coat over a primer. Table 1 below details the
specification of the coatings used.
Table 3: Coating Specification [6]
Coating
Primer
Barrier 1
Barrier 2
Finish
Material
Zinc rich epoxy
Epoxy micaceous iron oxide
Epoxy micaceous iron oxide
Polyurethane
Thickness(m)
40
150
150
50
10 Serviceability
In 2000, shortly after the bridge had been opened the
bolts on the guard rail were seen to be corroding.
Preventing the bolts rusting through was an essential to
reduce the risk of failure. This required removing the
nuts from the 16,000 bolts, blasting the bolts clean and
coating the bolts with gel to prevent moisture ingress.
The resund Bridge was built to contain a large
number of dehumidifiers, which keep the air
temperature to 60% relative humidity. The lack of
15 Acknowledgments
Thank-you to Sven Junkers, Noel Morrin and Hakan
Camper (Skanska) for their help, information and
patience during this project. Thank-you also to Mark
Evernden for his help and advice during writing this
paper.
12 Future Improvements
The use of the resund Bridge is set to increase as
the region continues to prosper. From Figure 19, the
number of journeys made by cars has continued to
increase since the opening of the bridge. The two lanes
of traffic in each direction may not be able to manage
with this continued rise. Widening of the road is
possible, however the construction work needed for
improvement may result the flow of traffic being
interrupted , which would in turn affect the journeys of
thousands of commuters and bridge users.
15 References
[1] UCL Project Profile. The resund Link [Online]
Available at:
http://www.omegacentre.bartlett.ucl.ac.uk/studies/case
s/pdf/Oresund-20081010.pdf
[2] Oresundsbro Konsortiet, 2011. The Oresund Bridge
and its region [Online]
Available at:
http://uk.oresundsbron.com/page/34
[3] Nissen, J, Bridge Publication. The Oresund Bridge
Publications
[4] Bridge 2 Paper, 2010. A Critical Analysis of the
Puente De La Unidad, Mexico
[5] British Standards Institute ,2006. BS5400: 2006.
Steel, Concrete and Composite [Online]
Available at:
http://people.bath.ac.uk/cmb27/proceedings/proceeding
s.htm
13 Conclusions
The resund Bridge has successfully connected
and integrated the two cities of Malmo and
Copenhagen, as well as improving the development
and economic growth of the region. Around 17,000
people commute across the bridge on a daily basis, and
the reduced journey time between Copenhagen and
Malmo has alleviated the labour shortages in Denmark
and has improved the housing market in Sweden.
The programme trained unemployed workers in skills