Environmental Manager

Reduce Hazards in
Process Vacuum Systems

Stanley S. Grossel
Process Safety and Design
Consultant

acuum conditions for many

unit operations including
distillation, evaporation, drying, crystallization, filtration
and more are typically achieved
using the following three approaches:
Steam ejector systems
Mechanical vacuum pumps
Integrated vacuum systems (which
combine steam ejectors and mechanical vacuum pumps)
This article is the second part of a
two-part series,1 and provides practical guidance for addressing during
design and operation some of the
most commonly encountered hazards
and maximizing the overall safety of
these systems.
This section reviews the potential
hazards that can occur with process
vacuum pumps and systems. These
include chemical sources of hazards,
explosion-related hazards and physical sources of hazards. They are discussed below, and are based on material in Reference 1.

Chemical sources of hazards

Chemical reactions and explosions. All possible chemical reactions
that a vacuum system might encounter at any point in mechanical vacuum
pump systems should be considered
particularly those that could result in
a fire or explosion (deflagration). And
such an analysis should consider these
scenarios during normal use, potential
misuse and failure conditions.
For instance, experience has shown
that explosions have occurred in situations involving materials that were
not originally considered by the system designer, and in which the failure
mode of that particular scenario had
not been taken into account. During
this analysis, the reactions that should
be considered include homogeneous,
heterogeneous and abnormal reactions. Two other sources of chemical
hazards are toxic and corrosive mate1. Editors note: Part 1 of this two-part article appeared in the September 2012 issue (pp. 5966).

Reduce explosion risks, and chemical

and physical hazards, to ensure safer operation
of vacuum pumps and related systems
rials. Each of these chemical sources
of hazards is also discussed below.
Homogeneous reactions. Homogeneous
reactions occur in the gas phase between two or more gas molecules. If
such reactions are possible in a given
manufacturing process, the process
pressure and reactant concentrations
must be carefully controlled to prevent excessive reaction rates.
Heterogeneous reactions. Heterogeneous reactions require a solid surface
(a catalyst) to occur. Most heterogeneous reactions become homogeneous
at higher pressures, normally at pressures well below atmospheric pressure.
This means that the way in which the
gases react inside the process equipment will not necessarily relate to the
way that they react when compressed
by a mechanical vacuum pump.
Abnormal reactions. Abnormal reactions can occur when chemicals come
into contact with gases or materials
that the designer did not anticipate.
This can occur, for example, when
there is a leak that either allows atmospheric gases (air) to leak into the system, or toxic, flammable, or explosive
gases to leak into the atmosphere.
To prevent the occurrence of abnormal reactions, high-vacuum applications should typically maintain a leak
tightness of 1 105 mbar-L/s (1
103 Pa-L/s), or lower. It must be ensured that all valves in the system are
leak-tight across their seats.
In estimating an acceptable airleakage rate, do not overlook the implications of process contamination
by air leakage. If leakage into the
vacuum system could in any way adversely affect the process, or create a
safety hazard, the acceptable air leakage may be considerably less than
that presented in Ref. 1, pp. 8386, for

medium- and high-vacuum systems.

Consideration should be given to the
fact that gases that do not normally
come into contact with each other during the process cycle may be mixed in
the pumping system and exhaust piping. It is possible that water vapor or
cleaning solutions may be present in
the process equipment after routine
maintenance procedures due to the
equipment having been washed and
cleaned. Water vapor may also enter
the system from exhaust ducts and
exhaust scrubbers.Where solvents are
used to flush process deposits from the
vacuum system, it is important to ensure that the selected solvent is compatible with all the process materials
in the vacuum system.

Explosion-related hazards
Explosions can occur in vacuum
pumps. The most common causes of
violent rupture of a vacuum system
due to an explosion results from the
ignition of flammable materials, or the
blockage or restriction of the pump exhaust. In general, the source of explosion hazards in vacuum systems fall
into one of the these categories:
Oxidants
Flammable materials
Pyrophoric materials
Unstable materials
Oxidants. Oxidants, such as oxygen,
ozone, fluorine and others are often
pumped using vacuum pumps. Oxidants readily react with a variety of
substances and materials. The reaction often produces heat and an increased gas volume with a potential
for fire and overpressure in the pump
or exhaust system. The practices discussed below are recommended to
minimize the potential for an explosion in pumps handling oxidants:

CHEMICAL ENGINEERING WWW.CHE.COM OCTOBER 2012

47

Environmental Manager
1. Always use perfluoropolyether
(PFPE) lubricant in pumps that are
used to pump oxygen in concentrations above 25 vol.% in an inert gas.
Although PFPE lubricants are preferred, hydrocarbon-based lubricants
may be used if a suitable inert purge
is used to guarantee that the oil is not
exposed to unsafe levels of oxidant.
2. If it is not desired to use PFPE lubricants in oil-sealed rotary vane or
piston vacuum pumps, dilute the oxidant to a safe concentration using an
inert gas (dry nitrogen). However, this
approach is only feasible for relatively
low flowrates of oxidant gases.
3. One must install safety features in
a mechanical pump system to ensure
that the minimum flow of the dilution
gas required to reduce the oxidant
concentration to a safe level is always
available, and to ensure that the flow
of oxidant does not exceed the maximum allowed flowrate. The safety system must be designed so that the flow
of oxidant stops immediately if these
conditions are not met.
Flammable materials. Many gases
are flammable and can explode (deflagrate) if they are within the flammability limits, and there is an ignition
source of sufficient energy available
(for instance, from a localized heat
source). It may be possible to reduce
the explosion hazard if the concentration of flammable gases is lowered
by introducing an inert gas at several
points within the pump or system.
Another way to reduce the probability of an explosion is to eliminate potential ignition sources. It may be difficult to eliminate all ignition sources
because there is often a possibility of
static discharge or friction hot spots
where rotating machinery is used.
Where it is not possible under abnormal conditions to avoid the flammable
zone, the equipment must be designed
to contain any resulting explosion
without rupturing or transmitting a
flame to the environment. This is typically achieved by installing a flame arrester on the exhaust piping.
Pyrophoric materials. A number of
gases (such as silane, phosphine and
others) are pyrophoric that is, they
are spontaneously flammable in air at
atmospheric pressure, so combustion
could occur if the gases were to come
48

in contact with air anywhere in the

vacuum system. This can happen if
air leaks into the system, or if the system exhaust comes in contact with the
atmosphere. In a confined space (such
as an exhaust duct, a dust filter, or an
oil box of a mechanical pump) combustion can cause an explosion.
If, in addition to pyrophoric materials, an oxidant is also present in the
process, the probability of an explosion
occurring at both atmospheric and process conditions increases greatly. Similarly, if oxidants from other processes
are vented through a common extraction (treatment) system, combustion or
an explosion could result. It is necessary, therefore, that an independent
extraction system be used when pyrophoric materials are pumped.
While the use of PFPE lubricants in
the pump will not prevent the ignition
and explosion of pyrophoric materials, it
will help to minimize the risk of a subsequent oil fire. However, PFPE lubricants can absorb process gases which,
in the case of pyrophoric materials, can
lead to local ignition when the lubricant is exposed to air. The probability of
this occurring can be reduced by using
a dry vacuum pump, which contains no
lubricant in the swept volume.
Unstable materials. Sodium azide is
occasionally used in the preparation of
products for freeze drying and other
manufacturing processes. Sodium azide
can produce hydrozoic acid, the vapors
of which can react with heavy metals to
form unstable metal azides, which may
then explode spontaneously.
Brass, copper, cadmium, tin and zinc
are commonly used in many components in vacuum pumps, accessories
and piping. If ones process system uses
or produces sodium azide, it must be ensured that the gas path in the process
system does not contain heavy metals.
Toxic materials. Toxic materials are
not necessarily explosive in nature, but
they are hazardous to ones health, and
thus require special care. The following
methods for handling them in vacuum
pump systems should be considered:
Gas dilution: Systems can be installed to allow the dilution of toxic
process gases as they pass through
the vacuum pump and into the exhaust piping. Dilution may be used
to reduce the concentration of the

CHEMICAL ENGINEERING WWW.CHE.COM OCTOBER 2012

gas to below its toxic limit

Leak detection: Many vacuum pumps
are generally designed to be leak
tight to a level of < 1 103 mbarL/S (< 1 101 Pa-L/s). However,
the leak-tightness of the adjoining
process system cannot be ensured
and thus should be checked with a
reliable leak-detection method (such
as helium mass-spectrometry leak
detection) to confirm the integrity of
the vacuum and exhaust systems
Shaft sealing (dry pumps): Many
vacuum pumps use a gas purge to
ensure that process gases do not
enter the gearbox, and thereby, potentially escape into the atmosphere.
The integrity of the purge gas supply must be ensured when handling
toxic gases. Non-venting regulators
must be used in combination with a
non-return check valve
Shaft sealing (other pumps): Oilflooded shaft-seal designs (for instance, for mechanical booster pumps
and rotary vane pumps) minimize
the risk of process gas leakage (or, of
the in-leakage of air), and can provide a visual warning (oil leakage or
oil level reduction) before a hazard
arises. Other seal designs may not
give adequate warning of failure
Magnetic drives: Where total hermetic sealing is required, dry vacuum pumps can be fitted with a
magnetic drive employing a ceramic
containment vessel (housing); this
eliminates the need for shaft sealing
on the motor input shaft
If pressure-relief valves or rupture
disks are used to relieve excess pressure, ensure that they are safely
vented into a suitable exhaust system
to prevent the toxic gas from escaping
into the atmosphere and possibly coming in contact with people.
Corrosive materials. Corrosive gases
generally attack the material they are
in contact with by the mechanism of
ion exchange, a process that can only
happen in the presence of a suitable
liquid solvent (such as water). This
mechanism cannot occur when the
material is in the vapor phase, even if
a suitable solvent is present.
The possibility of corrosion occurring in mechanical vacuum pumps
should be considered when carrying
out a hazard analysis.

Edwards Vacuum Pumps

FIGURE 1. Prudent design, operating and maintenance strategies are needed to

minimze the potential hazards associated with all types of vacuum systems

Many vacuum pumps are not designed to resist wet corrosive materials. Therefore, the following points
should be considered:
Anhydrous materials: The removal
of a liquid solvent (water) will prevent corrosion. However, special
care must be taken to prevent the
ingress of wet air from the exhaust
of the vacuum pump, especially
when the pump is stopped and air
is sucked back into the pump. An
inert purge should be used as part
of the shutdown procedure in order
to flush corrosive vapors out of the
system prior to shutdown
Dilution: Use a suitable dilution gas
to prevent condensation of corrosive
vapors and thus prevent the possible resulting corrosion
Temperature: Increase the pumpand exhaust-line temperature to
prevent condensation and, therefore,
corrosion. Where the low temperature of the incoming gas flow could
lead to condensation and subsequent
corrosion, an inert gas purge should
be used to avoid condensation
Corrosion of safety equipment: Where
safety critical equipment (such as
flame arrester elements, temperature sensors, safety relief valves and
so on) could be damaged by corrosive
products in the process gas flow, their
materials of construction must be selected to avoid this hazard
Phase changes: Unplanned phase
changes can result in condensation
and possible corrosion. Consideration
of changes in temperature and pressure is required to avoid this hazard
Unplanned reactions: These can lead
to the generation of corrosive products. Careful consideration should
be given to the possibility of cross
contamination when equipment is
used for more than one purpose
To minimize hazards from chemical
sources and to minimize explosion hazards, attention should be paid to the

items listed below to ensure safe operation of vacuum pumps and systems:
Consider all possible chemical reactions within your system
Make allowance for abnormal chemical reactions, including those that
could occur under fault conditions
Refer to material safety data sheets
when you assess the potential hazards associated with your process
materials
Use dilution techniques to minimize
reactions with oxidants and flammable materials
Use dry vacuum pumps if flammable
materials could enter the flammable
zone under abnormal conditions
Use the correct type of lubricant in
your pump when you pump oxidants,
and consider the use of a dry pump
Do not use heavy metals in the gas
path of your system if your process
uses or produces sodium azide
Take specific care when handling
toxic, corrosive, or unstable materials
Ensure that the concentration of
flammable materials in the vacuum
system does not permit these materials to enter the flammable zone.
During operation, there should be
a suitable supply of inert gas (nitrogen) to achieve dilution to a safe
level under all foreseeable operating
conditions and failure modes
Ensure that exhaust blockages cannot occur during operation, either
because of mechanical components
(such as valves or blinds) or because
of process materials or byproducts
depositing in pipelines, filters and
other exhaust components
Use only PFPE (perfluoropolyether)
oils to lubricate pump mechanisms
that are exposed to high concentrations of oxygen or other oxidants.
Other types of oils sold as nonflammable may only be suitable for
use with concentrations of oxidants
up to 30% v/v
Ensure that the accidental overpres-

sure of a deliberately closed and isolated vacuum system cannot occur,

for instance, as a result of a fault in
a pressure regulator or purge control system
Where the pumped product can react
violently with water, it is recommended that a cooling fluid other than
water (for example, a heat transfer
fluid) be used in the cooling circuit

Physical sources of hazards

Exhaust system over-pressure. The
most common physical hazard is an
over-pressurized exhaust due to a
blockage or restriction in the exhaust
system. All high-vacuum pumps are
specifically designed to operate with
high outlet-to-inlet compression ratios. They are designed to exhaust to
atmospheric pressure, or to a pressure
only slightly higher. If the exhaust is
restricted or blocked, many typical vacuum pumps can generate an exhaust
pressure in excess of 7 barg (101.6 psig).
This can lead to failure of the pump or
other components in the system.
In addition to the potential overpressure caused by the operation of
the pump, the introduction of a compressed gas (such as a purge or dilution gas) can also over-pressure the
system if the exhaust system is restricted or blocked.
Where a vacuum pump is fitted with
a flame arrester on the exhaust side, it
is essential that the exhaust back pressure does not exceed the maximum
limit stated in the vacuum system's
instruction manual. A regularly scheduled maintenance program should be
instituted to ensure that process deposits do not block the exhaust system
and flame arrester. In addition, it may
be desirable to install a pressure sensor located between the pump and the
flame arrester to detect if a blockage is
occurring and to sound an alarm.
Phase change. Another cause of
overpressure is sublimation or phase
change, which can lead to blockage of
process piping. The instruction manual
supplied with a vacuum pump should
be read for information on the maximum and recommended continuous
backpressure, and the exhaust system
should be designed so that these limitations can be met.
Some recommendations for oil-

CHEMICAL ENGINEERING WWW.CHE.COM OCTOBER 2012

49

Environmental Manager

sealed rotary vane and piston pumps,

dry pumps, and exhaust system design
are summarized below:
For oil-sealed rotary vane and piston
pumps, design the exhaust system
so that the pump is never subjected
to a back-pressure greater than 1
bar gauge (14.5 psig). Under normal operating conditions, the pump
should not run continuously with a
back-pressure of more than 0.35 bar
gauge (5.1 psig)
Many dry pumps also generate high
exhaust pressures when the exhaust
system is blocked or restricted. One
well-known dry-pump manufacturer
recommends that its dry pumps
should not be operated with an exhaust pressure higher than 0.3 bar
gauge (4.4 psig). If there is a risk of
high exhaust pressures occurring,
this vendor recommends that the
system incorporate an exhaust pressure switch to shut down the pump
and prevent the recommended pressure from being exceeded
It is recommended that the exhaust
system be designed to withstand
an internal pressure of at least 1.3
bar gauge (18.9 psig) for oil-sealed
pumps and at least 10 bar gauge
(14.5 psig) for dry pumps, unless
over-pressure relief is provided.
If a vacuum pump exhaust system
contains accessory components that
might cause restrictions or blockages
the protection methods shown in the
Table (p. 53) should be provided.
Inlet overpressure. The most common cause of over-pressure in vacuumpump inlet piping is the introduction of
compressed gas (such as purge gases)
when the pump is not operating. If
components in the inlet piping are not
suitable for the pressures that result,
the piping will rupture and process
gases will leak from the system.
Care must be taken before connecting compressed gas supplies to the
vacuum system through pressure regulators, which are designed to provide
a low-pressure flow so that the regulated pressure is within the pressure
rating of the vacuum system. The nonventing regulators most commonly
used will cause the pressure within
the vacuum system to rise to the pressure of the gas supply to the regulator, if operated under conditions where
50

there is no process gas flow through

the system. These two methods can
help to prevent over-pressurization:
Reduce the pressure and allow the
gases to bypass the pump into a
freely vented exhaust volume
Monitor the pressure of the vacuum
system and use a positive-closure
valve to shut off the supply of compressed gas at a preset pressure level
Inlet overpressure can also result from
incorrect vacuum pump operation,
and special precautions must be taken
until it has been established that the
pump is operating correctly.
If the direction of rotation of the
pump is incorrect and the pump is
operated with the inlet blocked or restricted, the pump will generate high
pressure in the inlet piping. This could
result in rupture of the pump, the piping and components in the piping.
Always use a blanking plate (line
blind) loosely secured by screws to the
pump inlet until it has been established that the direction of rotation for
the pump is correct.
Operation at high rotational speeds
could result in pump break-up. Do not
operate the pump at rotational speeds
above the maximum designed speed of
rotation; this is particularly important
where frequency inverters are used for
speed control.

General design practices

More details about the design practices
described below can be found in Ref. 1.
Pressure ratings in a system. Vacuum systems and piping are designed
to operate with internal pressures
below atmospheric pressure. In practice, however, it is necessary to design
the system (pump and piping) for use
with internal pressures above atmospheric pressure as well. It may be necessary to incorporate pressure relief
devices to prevent over-pressurization.
Exhaust systems must always be designed to produce the smallest possible
backpressure to the pump during operation. It is important, however, to design
the exhaust system with an adequate
pressure rating; it must be suitable for
the pressures that can be generated by
the pump and by the introduction into
the system of a compressed gas, and be
suitable for use with the overpressureprotection measures used.

CHEMICAL ENGINEERING WWW.CHE.COM OCTOBER 2012

Where the vacuum system is used to

handle a vapor or gas mixture in the
flammable range, and where there is
a potential ignition source, the pump,
piping and associated vessels should
have a minimum design pressure of
10 bar gauge (145 psig).
Eliminate stagnant volumes. A stagnant volume is any closed volume in a
vacuum pipe or component that is not
subjected to a through flow of gas. Examples are the gear box of a mechanical booster pump or the gauge head of
an instrument. Valved piping and nitrogen-gas inlet pipes can also become
stagnant when they are isolated.
Stagnant volumes must be taken
into account when one considers the
mixture and reaction of process gases
that are not normally present together
in the process vessel. A stagnant volume is not purged and may be filled
with process gases as the pressure in
the system rises and falls. In this way,
gases that pass through the system at
one stage of the process can be retained.
These may then react with gases from
a subsequent phase of the process.
Thorough evacuation of the process
chamber between episodes involving
the introduction of incompatible gases
will lower the risk of an explosion.
Special care must be taken when
considering cross-contamination in
stagnant volumes, especially when the
pressure is relatively high (close to atmospheric pressure) and the gases are
potentially explosive. In particular, one
should consider the hazard of buildup
in filters and separators. Where appropriate, use high-integrity, continuous
flows of inert purge gas to reduce the
probability of cross-contamination.
When pumping flammable gases, it
is possible for stagnant volumes to fill
with potentially explosive gases or vapors that cannot be removed by normal
purging. When an ignition source may
also be present, specific purging of the
stagnant volume should be considered.
Sources of potentially explosive gas
or vapor mixtures. When a flammable
gas or vapor is mixed with the correct
concentration of oxygen or other suitable oxidant, it will form a potentially
explosive mixture, which will ignite in
the presence of an ignition source.
While it is generally apparent if a
pumped gas or vapor is potentially

TABLE. OPTIONS FOR PROTECTING

VACUUM PUMP EXHAUST SYSTEMS
Component
Valve in
exhaust
Exhaust
scrubber
Flame
arrester
Oil mist filter

Protection method
Interlock the valve so that its piping is always open when the pump is operating
Incorporate a pressure relief bypass
Incorporate a pressure relief bypass
Incorporate a pressure monitor or sensor and interlock this with the pump motor
so that the pump is shut down when the exhaust pressure is too high
Provide an exhaust pressure measurement or a differential-pressure measurement
Incorporate a pressure-relief device

explosive, there are some conditions

where a potentially explosive mixture
is produced due to conditions that
were not considered when the process
was designed. One must identify all
possible sources of potentially explosive mixtures that could be generated
by the process vacuum equipment. Examples are listed:
Cross-contamination. Where a vacuum pump is being used for a number of duties, it is possible that its
use with individual gases or vapors
is safe, but if the pump is not purged
before use with another gas or vapor,
then cross-contamination could occur
with unexpected reactions
Cleaning fluids. An application may
be viewed as benign, but the use of
flammable cleaning fluids and the
subsequent drying by evacuation
through the vacuum pump can create a potentially explosive mixture
Unexpected material. On house
vacuum duties where the vacuum
pump is used to provide a distributed vacuum system, it is possible
to pump flammable gases or vapors
that were not considered during system design. These gases or vapors
may have autoignition temperatures
that are lower than the internal
temperatures of the vacuum pump
Dissolved vapors. Low autoignitiontemperature vapors generally have
high vapor pressures. Pumping
these vapors at pressures above the
vapor pressure will generally result
in internal dry-pump stage temperatures below the autoignition point.
However, it is possible for these vapors to become absorbed in a liquid
with a lower vapor pressure, and for
them to be released as the pressure
falls below the vapor pressure of the
dissolved vapors. At this lower pressure, it is possible for the internal
dry-pump stage temperature to exceed the autoignition point
Air leakage. The accidental ingress
of air or oxidant into a vacuum system may change the concentration
of a flammable gas or vapor and create a potentially explosive mixture

Flammable sealing liquids. Where a

flammable liquid is used as the sealing liquid in a liquid-ring vacuum
pump, air ingress will create a potentially explosive internal mixture
Avoiding the flammable zone. A
flammable gas or vapor will only create a potentially explosive atmosphere
if it is combined with sufficient air or
oxygen (or another oxidant, such as
chlorine) and the concentration of the
vapor in the mixture lies between the
lower flammability limit (LFL) and
the upper flammability limit (UFL).
To be potentially explosive, it is
also necessary for the concentration
of oxygen to be above the limiting oxidant concentration (LOC). There are
several strategies that can be used to
avoid operating with gas mixtures in
the flammable region. The choice of
strategy will depend on the outcome of
the hazard analysis for the process and
the pumping system. Recommended
strategies include the following:
Maintain the flammable gas concentration below the LFL. This is
accomplished by diluting the flammable mixture with an inert gas
(usually nitrogen) that is introduced
into the pump inlet and/or purge
connections. Refer to NFPA 69 [2]
for recommendations as to what
percentage of the LFL the flammable concentration should be maintained. The required integrity of the
dilution system and of any alarms or
interlocks will depend on the nature
of the hazards that would result if
the dilution system were to fail
Maintain the oxidant concentration
below the LOC. This mode of operation requires the use of oxygen-concentration monitoring of the pumped
gases to ensure safe operation. To
minimize the risk of flammable gas
accidentally entering the flammable
zone, a safety margin below the LOC
should be maintained. NFPA 69
[2] presents recommendations for
these safety margins. The preferred
method of maintaining the oxidant
(usually oxygen) level below the
LOC is to carry out both rigorous ex-

clusion of air and oxygen from

the process and pump system,
and dilution of the pumped gas
with an inert purge gas (usually nitrogen) that is introduced into the pump inlet or purge
connections, if needed. The required
integrity of the air/oxygen-exclusion
measures (for example, purging)
and of any alarms or interlocks will
depend on the hazardous zone that
would result, were the exclusion and
dilution systems to fail
Precautions typically required to rigorously exclude air from the process and
pump system include the following:
Eliminate air leaks. Use a leak detector or conduct a pressure-rise test
Remove all air from the system before
the start of the process. Before any
flammable gas is admitted into the
process, the system should be fully
evacuated and purged with an inert
gas (usually nitrogen) to remove all
air from the system. At the end of
the process, repeat this procedure
before the system is finally vented
to the atmosphere
Maintain the integrity of shaft-seal
gas. For dry-vacuum pumps, ensure
that any shaft-seal gas cannot be
supplied with, or contaminated by,
air under any circumstances (for
dry-vacuum pumps). In addition,
ensure that any gas ballast port is
either sealed, or only used to introduce inert gas
Follow instructions and maintain
proper lubrication. For wet vacuum
pumps (rotary piston or rotary vane
pumps), maintain the shaft seals in
accordance with the manufacturers
instructions, and use a pumped, pressurized oil-lubrication system with
an alarm that indicates the loss of oil
pressure. This system may comprise
an external accessory to provide filtered and pressurized lubricating oil,
with a pressure switch. Ensure that
any gas ballast port is either sealed,
or only used to introduce inert gas.
Provide an adequate purge of inert
gas to the oil box, to remove air before
the start of the process
Maintain the drive-shaft seal for
vacuum booster pumps (such as the
Roots pump). Maintain the primary
drive shaft seal fully in accordance
with the manufacturers instruc-

CHEMICAL ENGINEERING WWW.CHE.COM OCTOBER 2012

51

Environmental Manager
tions, and ensure that any purge or
breather port connections can only
be used to introduce inert gas
Guard against reverse flow. Ensure
that the system operating procedures and protective equpment protect the system from any reverse air
flow that might result from a pump
failure. Ensure that any pumped
flammable gases are safely disposed of at the final vent from the
pump exhaust. Ensure that flammable gas mixtures cannot occur in
the exhaust piping. This is done by
using suitable inert-gas purging of
the piping before the start of, and
after the end of, the flammable gas
process, and by the use of adequate
inert-gas purging during operation,
to prevent turbulent back-mixing of
air down the exhaust
Maintain the flammable gas concentration above the UFL. Where the
flammable gas concentrations are
very high, operation above the UFL
can be used. Procedures for doing this
are given in NFPA 69 [2]. To maintain
the oxygen at a safe level, rigorous
exclusion of air and oxygen from the
process and pump system is required.
This can be accomplished by dilution
of the pumped gas with an inert gas
(usually nitrogen) or by addition of
enrichment flammable gas (NFPA
69 discusses the use of methane for
this), introduced into the pump inlet
and/or purge connections
Use of flame-arrester protection
systems. When dry vacuum pumps
are used for pumping gases or vapors
that could enter the flammable zone
under abnormal conditions, exhaust
flame arresters should be installed to
quench any resulting flame front in
the event of an ignition. Flame arresters should be closely coupled to the exhaust connections.
Where there is the possibility of continuous burning within a dry vacuum
pump, special precautions should be
taken. Such conditions could occur due
to a continuous ignition source resulting from the accidental pumping of a
gas or vapor with an auto-ignition temperature lower than the internal pump
temperatures. In this case, one must
use a PT100 or equivalent temperature-sensing device on the pump side
of each flame arrester to detect a burn
52

condition, and adopt a suitable flamesuppression strategy to make the system safe in the event of a burn being
detected. The suitable strategy depends
on the application, but could include
the following:
Stopping the supply of fuel. Closing
a valve located on the inlet of the
dry vacuum pump will prevent the
supply of fuel (process gas or vapor)
into the vacuum pump
Stopping the source of ignition. Stopping the pump by turning off power
to the motor will bring the pump to
a halt in approximately 10 seconds
Inerting the area of the burn. The
rapid addition of inert gas into the
area of the burn (typically, but not
always located in the exhaust manifold of the pump) will eliminate the
flame. Note that it is possible for a
flame to reignite if the source of ignition is not removed

Piping design
This section discusses design practices for piping components used with
mechanical vacuum pumps.
Bellows. Bellows are short, thinwalled components with deep convolutions. They are used to reduce the
transfer of vibration from a pump to a
vacuum system. They are available in
metal, rubber or plastic construction.
Always install bellows in a straight
line with both ends rigidly constrained. When installed correctly, the
bellows can withstand a small positive
internal pressure (refer to the Instruction Manual supplied with the bellows
for details). Note: Do not use bellows
on dry vacuum-pumps exhausts: use
braided flexible bellows (see below).
Braided flexible bellows. Braided flexible bellows are bellows with an outer
protective layer of woven stainlesssteel braid. They are suitable for use
as exhaust connections on dry pumps
and other applications where there is
significant gas pulsation or the possibility of high gas pressures.
Braided flexible bellows are intended
for installation in static systems. They
are not suitable for repeated flexing, as
this could cause fatigue failure. When
a braided flexible bellows is installed,
one must comply with the minimum
bend radius given in the manufacturerss instruction manual.

CHEMICAL ENGINEERING WWW.CHE.COM OCTOBER 2012

Flexible hoses. Flexible hoses have

a thicker wall section and shallower
convolutions than bellows. Flexible
hoses provide a convenient method
for the connection of vacuum system
components and help to compensate
for misalignment or small movements
in rigid vacuum piping. Flexible hoses
can be formed into relatively sharp
bends that will hold their position.
Flexible hoses are intended for installation in static systems. They are
not suitable for repeated flexing, as
this could cause fatigue failure. When
flexible hoses are used, use the shortest possible length and avoid unnecessary bends. Do not use flexible hoses
on dry pump exhausts.
Anchor points. Piping and piping components must be anchored correctly. For
example, if bellows are anchored incorrectly, they will not reduce the vibration
generated by the pump, and this could
lead to fatigue in the piping.
Seals. Where there is the possibility of positive pressure occurring in
any part of the vacuum system (even
under failure conditions), one must use
trapped O-ring type seals, which are
capable of withstanding the expected
vacuum and positive pressures.

Physical over-pressure
protection
Over-pressure can be caused by a restriction or blockage in the vacuum
system or in one of its components.
The over-pressure may also occur as a
result of compressed-gas flow from the
pump or from external compressed gas
supplies (such as those for a dilution
system). There are two main methods
of over-pressure protection, as follows:
Pressure relief. Rupture disks or
pressure-relief valves may be used
to relieve an overpressure situation.
These devices must be provided with
discharge piping to convey the relief
device discharge fluid to a safe location
(where plant personnel are not usually
located), and the vent line should have
no restrictions. If the process produces
solid byproducts, the pressure-relief
devices must be inspected on a regularly scheduled basis to ensure that
they are not blocked or restricted.
Over-pressure alarm or trip. This
method of protection is used by several
vacuum-pump system manufacturers.

This type of protection can be used for

any vacuum-pump system, but it is
particularly suitable for systems that
produce solid byproducts.
Since the use of an alarm or trip
system forms part of a primary safety
system, it must incorporate a design
of high integrity. One should not rely
on a simple pressure switch or sensor
installed in a flow line, as the condensation of solid particles or corrosion of
the sensor can cause the device to fail
without indication of the failure.
It is also recommended that a sensor be used that incorporates a nitrogen purge flow to the sensor. A purge
flow keeps the sensor relatively free
from blockage, and such a sensor is designed so that, if the sensor is blocked,
the nitrogen supply pressure is high
enough to operate the pressure alarm
and trip. The normal settings for such
devices are usually no higher than 0.3
bar gauge (4.35 psig) and no greater
than 0.4 bar gauge (5.80 psig).

The control system should be designed so that both the pump and any
gas inlets (which are capable of pressurizing the system above its maximum operating pressure) are shut
down when the trip point is reached.
Purge systems. The correct use of
a purge (usually nitrogen) can ensure
that corrosive products are removed,
preventing them from damaging the
vacuum pump, and also from plugging
or damaging protective systems such
as flame arresters. In addition, the
removal of process gases ensures that
undesired and potentially dangerous
chemical reactions do not occur between process gases and vapors used
in different process cycles.

Edited by Suzanne Shelley

References
1. Edwards Ltd., Safety Manual-Vacuum Pump
and Vacuum (corporate manual).
2. NFPA 69, Standard on Explosion Prevention
Systems, National Fire Protection Association, Quincy, Mass., 2008.

Acknowledgements
The author wishes to thank J.L. Ryans of Eastman Chemical Co. (Kingsport, Tenn.) for his review of the draft of this article and for his helpful comments and recommendations. I should
also like to acknowledge the assistance of the
following people, who provided technical information used during the development of this article: Peter N. Lodal (Eastman Chemical Co.),
John Campbell (SIHI Pumps Americas), Mark
Nichols (Edwards Ltd.), and Eric Johnson (Graham Manufacturing Co.).

Author
Stanley S. Grossel is president of Process Safety
and Design, Inc. (4 Marble Court, Unit 9, Clifton,
N.J. 07013-2212; Phone: 973-779-3668; Email:
[email protected]). He provides consulting services related to process safety and loss prevention,
storage and handling of bulk solids and powders,
air pollution control, and process design of batch
plants. Prior to his 1993 retirement, Grossel spent
25 years in the Engineering Dept. of Hoffman-LaRoche, in a variety of roles. He was honored as the
only Senior Engineering Fellow ever to be designated by Hoffman-LaRoche. Grossel is a fellow of
AIChE, and holds AIChEs Norton Walton/Russell Miller Award for outstanding contributions to
loss prevention. He has lectured and been published widely, and has authored major standards
and guidelines. Grossel is also a contributor on
process safety to the 7th Ed. of Perry's Chemical
Engineers Handbook. He holds a B.S.Ch.E. from
City College of New York and an M.S.Ch.E. from
Drexel Inst. of Technology, and has completed
courses toward a doctoral degree.

Get Chemical Engineerings plant cost index to improve plant cost estimates
and delivered in advance of the print edition!
For more than 37 years, chemical process industries professionals- engineers, manager and technicians, have used
Chemical Engineerings Plant Cost Index to adjust process plant construction costs from one period to another.
This database includes all annual archives (1947 to present) and monthly data archives (1970 to present). Instead
of waiting more than two weeks for the print or online version of Chemical Engineering to arrive, subscribers can
access new data as soon as its calculated.
Sep 06
Prelim.

Aug 06
Final

Sep 05
Final

CE Index

513.1

510.0

467.2

Equipment

606.5

602.3

541.2
509.2

510

500

Heat Exchanges and Tanks

565.1

560.9

Process Machinery

559.6

556.2

521.7

Pipe, valves and fittings

734.7

731.7

620.8

Process Instruments

441.4

437.2

379.5

Pumps and Compressions

788.9

788.3

756.3

Electrical equipment

418.9

414.2

374.6

Structural supports

643.7

637.7

579.3

Construction Labor

314.7

312.9

309.1

Buildings

476.9

475.2

444.7

Engineering Supervision

350.7

351.9

346.9

490

480

470

460
Jan

Feb

Mar

Apr

May

Jun

Jul

Aug

Sep

Oct

Nov

Dec

Resources included with Chemical Engineerings Plant Cost Index:

Electronic notiication of monthly updates as soon
as they are available
All annual data archives (1947 to present)

Monthly data archives (1970 to present)

Option to download in Excel format
17817

Subscribe today at www.che.com/pci

CHEMICAL ENGINEERING WWW.CHE.COM OCTOBER 2012

53