"Crime After Crime" Is Documentary About Deborah Peagler's Murder Conviction and The Campaign To Free Her

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 3

8/11/2016

CrimeAfterCrimeIsDocumentaryAboutDeborahPeaglersMurderConvictionAndTheCampaignToFreeHerJusticeDenied

CrimeAfterCrimeIsDocumentary
AboutDeborahPeaglersMurder
ConvictionAndTheCampaignToFree
Her
Categories:HabeasCorpus,Murder,Rape,SexualAssault,Torture,UnitedStates
byHansSherrer
July27,2011
DeborahDebbieDenisePeaglerwas23whensentencedto25yearstolifeinprisonin
Californiaaftershepledguiltyin1983tofirstdegreemurderinthedeathofOliver
Wilson,whowaskilledbytwogangmembers.
Becausetherewasnotrialitwasntpublicly
disclosedthatWilsonterrorizedPeaglerinto
prostitutingherselfbyphysicallybeatingher
andpsychologicalabusethatincluded
threateningtokillherandforcinghertoplay
RussianRoullette.Whenshetriedtoescape
Wilsonwouldtrackherdownandafter
beatingherandevenusingawhiponher,she
wouldbeforcedtoresumeprostituting
DebbiePeaglerwithherlawyersJoshua
herself.WhenPeaglerfoundoutthatWilson
SafranandNadiaCostabeforeher
abusedher6yearolddaughtershefled
releasefromprison.(LifeSentence
againandsoughtthehelpoftwogang
Films)
memberstomakeWilsonleaveherandher
daughteralone.Wilsonwaskilledduringa
violentencounterwiththetwogangmembersinapublicpark.Peaglerwasntpresent
whenWilsonwaskilled,butshewaschargedwithconspiracyandfirstdegreemurder.
PeaglerspublicdefenderconvincedhertopledguiltybecausetheLACountyDA
threatenedtoseekthedeathpenaltyifshewenttotrialandlost.
In2002Californiaenactedalawthatretroactivelyallowedabatteredwomanto
challengeherconvictionifevidencerelatedtoherabusehadntbeenconsideredwhen
shewasconvicted.AftertheCaliforniaHabeasProjectinterviewedPeaglerand
determinedshemightbeeligibleforreliefunderthelaw,NadiaCostaandJoshua
Safran,realestatelawyerswithnocriminallawexperience,agreedtotakePeaglers
caseprobono.Therewerethenabletoconvinceaprivateinvestigatortoworkonher
caseprobono.CostaandSafranworkedonPeaglerscaseforsevenyearsbeforeshe
wasreleasedin2009after27yearsofincarcerationfromthetimeofherarrest.
Sheshouldhavebeenreleasedfouryearsearlier,butin2005LosAngelesCounty
DistrictAttorneySteveCooleyrenegedonhiswrittenagreementsupportingthevacating
http://justicedenied.org/wordpress/archives/1365

1/3

8/11/2016

CrimeAfterCrimeIsDocumentaryAboutDeborahPeaglersMurderConvictionAndTheCampaignToFreeHerJusticeDenied

ofPeaglersfirstdegreemurderconviction
basedontheevidenceshewasabusedby
Wilson,andforittobesubstitutedwithher
guiltypleatovoluntarymanslaughteranda
sentenceoftimeserved.DACooleyeven
wrotethattheagreementservestheinterests
ofjustice.AfterCooleyrenegedPeaglers
lawyerssuedforenforcementofthe
agreement,buttheylost.
FreeDebbiePeaglerprotestersoutside
GovernorSchwarzeneggersLos
AngelesofficeonAugust19,2009.(Life
SentenceFilms)

In2007theinvestigatorworkingonPeaglers
caseobtainedacopyofamemowrittenon
October26,1983byanassistantdistrict
attorneythathadbeenkeptsecretfor24
yearsbytheDAsOffice.Thememodetails
thattheDAsOfficeknewtheinformantwhowasthekeywitnessagainstPeaglerandthe
twomalesaccusedofmurderingWilsoncommittedperjuryduringPeaglerspreliminary
hearingandthatitnotonlyunderminedhiscredibility,buthisperjuredtestimonywas
theonlyevidencethatsupportedseekingthedeathpenaltyagainsther.Also
underminingtheinformantscredibilitywasthememosstatementthatHewasalso
suspectedofdealinginnarcoticsandstolengoods.Althoughthememoincluded
informationthatcouldpossiblyresultinPeaglersacquittalbyajury,theDAsOffice
concealeditasitcontinuedtoputpressureonherlawyerthatshecouldgetthedeath
penaltyifhedidntconvincehertopleadguiltytofirstdegreemurder.Oneofthepeople
involvedinconcealingthememofromPeaglerwasFrederickP.Horn,aprosecutor
involvedinhercaseandwhoisnowanOrangeCountySuperiorCourtjudge.
PeaglerwasdiagnosedwithterminallungcancerinFebruary2009,andonJuly10,
2009theCaliforniaBoardofParoleHearingsfoundshewassuitablefora
compassionaterelease.DACooleysentalettertoGovernorArnoldSchwarzenegger
thatsuggestedPeaglershouldntbereleased.
OnAugust19,2009Peaglersfamilymembersand
othersupportersprotestedoutside
SchwarzeneggersLosAngelesoffice,demanding
herrelease.ThenextdaySchwarzenegger
declinedtoreviewtheparoleboardsfinding,which
allowedtheirdecisiontostand.Peaglerwas
releasedtwodayslateronAugust22.
DebbiePeaglerdiedonJune8,2010.Shewas50.
Beginningin2005filmmakerYoavPotashbegan
chroniclingtheeffortsofCostaandSafrantofree
Peagler.TheresultisthedocumentaryCrimeAfter
CrimewhichpremieredinJanuary2011atthe
SundanceFilmFestival.CrimeAfterCrimehas
CrimeAfterCrimeposter
gottenravereviewsfromLosAngelestoNewYork.
Onrottentomatoes.com89%oftheprofessional
reviewsarepositive,anditwaslikedby100%ofthepeoplewhosawitandregistered
theiropinion.TheNewYorkDailyNewsgavetheCrimeAfterCrime4starsandits
reviewstatesinpart:

http://justicedenied.org/wordpress/archives/1365

2/3

8/11/2016

CrimeAfterCrimeIsDocumentaryAboutDeborahPeaglersMurderConvictionAndTheCampaignToFreeHerJusticeDenied

Ifyourelookingforamovietoshakeyoutoyourcore,skipTransformers
andseekoutYoavPotashsgutwrenchingdocumentary,instead.Hegivesus
extraordinaryheroesandunbelievablevillains,mindbendingtwistsand
heartbreakingturns.
HissubjectisDeborahPeaglerwhosservingalifesentenceforkillingapimp
whoforcedherintoprostitutionandsexuallyabusedtheirtoddler.Her
devoted,probonoattorneysworkforyearstoexposetheineptitudeand
corruptionthathasseeminglyledtoanillegalimprisonmentPotash
chroniclesitallwithcompassion.
Thisstorydoesntgowellwithpopcorn,andyouwontbeabletoshakeitoff
likesomanyblockbusters.Thatsaid,itslikelytobethemostunforgettable
filmyouseeallsummer.
ClickhereforCrimeAfterCrimeswebsite.Thedocumentaryisbeingshowninalimited
numberoftheatersaroundtheU.S.ItwillbeshowninSeattlebeginningonAugust26.
Clickheretoseeifitisscheduledtobeshowninatheaterinyourarea.
ByHansSherrer
JusticeDenied
Tags:abuse,beating,California,CrimeAfterCrime,deathsentence,DebbiePeagler,
DeborahPeagler,documentary,hanssherrer,innocence,innocencenetwork,innocence
project,innocent,JoshuaSafran,justicedenied,justicedenied,LosAngeles,miscarriage
ofjustice,murder,NadiaCosta,rape,sherrer,wrongfullyconvicted,wronglyconvicted,
YoavPotash
Permanentlinktothisarticle:http://justicedenied.org/wordpress/archives/1365

http://justicedenied.org/wordpress/archives/1365

3/3

You might also like