Measurements and Testing of I.C.Engines
Measurements and Testing of I.C.Engines
Measurements and Testing of I.C.Engines
bearings, as well as by the loss incurred by driving the essential accessories, such as water
pump, ignition unit etc.
Following methods are used in the laboratory to measure friction power:
(i) Willans line method;
(ii) From the measurement of indicated power and brake power;
(iii) Motoring test;
(iv) Retardation test;
(v) Morse Test.
2.3.1.1. Willans Line Method:- This method is also known as fuel rate extrapolation method.
In this method a graph of fuel consumption (vertical axis) versus brake power (horizontal axis)
is drawn and it is extrapolated on the negative axis of brake power (see Fig. 2.1).The intercept
of the negative axis is taken as the friction power of the engine at
1.0
Fuel
0.8
consumption
(g/s)
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
5
10
15
20
25
Brake power (kW)
Friction Power
Fig. 2.1. Willans line method
that speed. As shown in the figure, in most of the power range the relation between the fuel
consumption and brake power is linear when speed of the engine is held constant and this
permits extrapolation. Further when the engine does not develop power, i.e. brake power = 0, it
consumes a certain amount of fuel. This energy in the fuel would have been spent in
overcoming the friction. Hence the extrapolated negative intercept of the horizontal axis will
be the work representing the combined losses due to friction, pumping and as a whole is
termed as the frictional loss of the engine. This method of measuring friction power will
hold good only for a particular speed and is applicable mainly for compression ignition
engines.
The main draw back of this method is the long distance to be extrapolated from
data between 5 and 40 % load towards the zero line of the fuel input.The directional margin of
error is rather wide because the graph is not exactly linear.
2.3.1.2.From the Measurement of Indicated Power and Brake Power:- This is an ideal
method by which friction power is obtained by computing the difference between the indicated
power and brake power. The indicated power is obtained from an indicator diagram and brake
power is obtained by a brake dynamometer. This method requires elaborate equipment to
obtain accurate indicator diagrams at high speeds.
2.3.1.3.Morse Test:- This method can be used only for multi cylinder IC engines. The Morse
test consists of obtaining indicated power of the engine without any elaborate equipment. The
test consists of making, in turn, each cylinder of the engine inoperative and noting the
reduction in brake power developed. In a petrol engine (gasoline engine), each cylinder is
rendered inoperative by shorting the spark plug of the cylinder to be made inoperative. In a
Diesel engine, a particular cylinder is made inoperative by cutting off the supply of fuel. It is
assumed that pumping and friction are the same when the cylinder is inoperative as well
as during firing.
In this test, the engine is first run at the required speed and the brake
power is measured. Next, one cylinder is cut off by short circuiting the spark plug if it is a
petrol engine or by cutting of the fuel supply if it is a diesel engine. Since one of the cylinders
is cut of from producing power, the speed of the engine will change. The engine speed is
brought to its original value by reducing the load on the engine. This will ensure that the
frictional power is the same.
If there are k cylinders, then
Total indicated power
k
when all the cylinders are working = ip1 + ip2 + ip3 + ...+ ipk = ipj
j=1
..(2.1)
j=1
where ipj is the indicated power produced by j th cylinder, k is the number of cylinders,
Bt is the total brake power when all the cylinders are producing power and Ft is the total
frictional power for the entire engine.
If the first cylinder is cut off, then it will not produce any power, but it will have frictional
losses. Then
k
..(2.2)
j=2
..(2.3).
Similarly we can find the indicated power of all the cylinders, viz., ip2, ip3, ..ipk. Then the
total indicated power is calculated as
k
(ip)total = ipj
.(2.4)
j=1
(2.5)
The procedure is illustrated by some examples worked out at the end of the chapter.
2.3.2. Measurement of Indicated Power: Indicated power of an engine tells about the health
of the engine and also gives an indication regarding the conversion of chemical energy in the
fuel into thermal energy. It is an important variable because it is the potential output of the
cycle.Hence the measurement of indicated power must be very accurate. For obtaining
indicated power the cycle pressure must be determined as a function of cylinder volume. It is
of no use to determine pressure accurately unless volume or crank angle is accurately
measured.
Following methods are usually adopted to estimate the indicated power of an IC engine:
(i) using the indicator diagram
(ii) by measuring brake power and friction power and adding them to give indicated power
(iii) By conducting Morse test (applicable only for multi-cylinder engines).
(i) Method using Indicator diagram:- Indicator is a device which measures the variation of the
pressure in the cylinder over a part or full cycle and the plot of such information obtained is
called an indicator diagram. Indicator diagram gives a very good indication of the process
of combustion. Also the losses occurring in the suction and exhaust stroke can be studied using
this diagram.
.(2.6)
involves the determination of the torque and the angular speed of the engine output shaft. The
torque measuring device is called the dynamometer.
Brake power is usually measured by attaching a power absorbing
device to the output shaft of the engine. Such a device will set up forces (which can be
measured) counteracting the forces delivered by the engine. The measured force is usually
referred to as the braking force, W. If r is the distance from the centre of the output shaft and
the point of acting of Fb ( r is also called the lever arm),
then braking torque = T = W r
.(2.7)
bp = 2NT / 60,000
kW
..(2.8)
.(2.10)
2.3.4. Measurement of Fuel Consumption: There are two basic types of fuel measurement
methods namely (i) volumetric method and (ii) gravimetric method.
In volumetric method the time taken for the engine to consume a known volume of fuel is
measured and knowing the specific gravity of the fuel the mass flow rate of fuel consumed is
calculated as follows:
Let t = time in seconds for the engine to consume y cc of fuel, and
s = specific gravity of the fuel.
y x 10 6
Mass of fuel consumed per second = m = -------------- x s x 1000
t
.
ys
.
m = ----------- kg/s.(2.11)
1000 t
Or
Indicated Specific Fuel Consumption: This is defined as the mass of fuel consumption per
hour in order to produce an indicated power of one kilo watt.
.
3600 m
Thus, indicated specific fuel consumption = isfc = --------------- kg/kWh ..(2.12)
ip
Brake Specific fuel consumption:- This defined as the mass of fuel consumed per hour, in
order to develop a brake power of one kilowatt.
.
3600 m
Thus, brake specific fuel consumption = bsfc = --------------- kg/kWh
bp
..(2.13)
2.3.5. Thermal Efficiency : There are two definitions of thermal efficiency as applied to IC
engines. One is based on indicated power and the other on brake power.The one based on
indicated power is called as indicated thermal efficiency, and the one based on brake power
is known as brake thermal efficiency.
Indicated thermal efficiency is defined as the ratio of indicated power to the energy available
due to combustion of the fuel.
Indicated Power in kW
Thus ith = ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------(Mass flow rate of fuel in kg/s) x (Calorific value of fuel in kJ/kg )
ip
ith = --------------..(2.14)
m x CV
Similarly brake thermal efficiency is defined as the ratio of brake power to energy available
due to combustion of the fuel.
Or
Or
bp
bth = --------------m x CV
..(2.15)
2.3.6.Mechanical Efficiency: Mechanical efficiency takes into account the mechanical losses
in an engine. The mechanical losses include (i) frictional losses, (ii) power absorbed by engine
auxillaries like fuel pump, lubricating oil pump, water circulating pump, magneto and
distributor, electric generator for battery charging, radiator fan etc., and (iii) work requited to
charge the cylinder with fresh charge and work for discharging the exhaust gases during the
exhaust stroke. It is defined as the ratio of brake power to indicated power. Thus
bp
mech = -------(8.16)
ip
2.3.7. Volumetric efficiency: Volumetric efficiency is the ratio of the actual mass of air drawn
into the cylinder during a given period of time to the theoretical mass which should have been
drawn in during the same interval of time based on the total piston displacement, and the
pressure and temperature of the surrounding atmosphere.
.
Thus
mactual
v = ----------------mth
where
m = a n Vs
(2.17)
.(2.18)
where n is the number of intake strokes per minute and Vs is the stroke volume of the piston.
2.4. Illustrative examples:
Example 2.1:- The following observations have been made from the test of a four cylinder, two
stroke petrol engine. Diameter of the cylinder = 10 cm; stroke = 15 cm; speed = 1600 rpm;
Area of indicator diagram = 5.5 cm2; Length of the indicator diagram = 55 mm; spring
constant = 3.5 bar/cm; Determine the indicated power of the engine.
Known: d = 0.1 m; L = 0.15 m ; No. of cylinders = K = 4; N = 1600 rpm; n = N (two stroke);
a = 5.5 cm2; length of the diagram = ld = 5.5. cm; spring constant = ks = 3.5 bar/cm ;
Find: indicated power, ip.
a ks
Solution: Indicated mean effective pressure = pim = --------------- =
ld
= 3.5 * 10 5 N/m2
pim LAnK
3.5 x 105 x 0.15 x (/4) x 0.12 x 1600 x 4
ip = ---------------- = -------------------------------------------------------- = 43.98 kW
60,000
60,000
Example 2.2:- A gasoline engine (petrol engine) working on Otto cycle consumes 8 litres of
petrol per hour and develops 25 kW. The specific gravity of petrol is 0.75 and its calorific
value is 44,000 kJ/kg. Determine the indicated thermal efficiency of the engine
Known: Volume of fuel consumed/hour = y/t = 8 x 10 3 / 3600 cc/s ;
ip = 25 kW; CV = 44,000 kJ/kg;
Specific gravity of petrol = s = 0.75
Find: ith ;
ys
8 x 10 3 x 0.75
Solution: Mass of fuel consumed = m = ----- = --------------------- = 1.67 x 10 3 kg/s.
1000 t
1000 x 3600
.
ip
25
Indicated thermal efficiency = ith = -------------- = -------------------------- = 0.3402 = 34.02%
m CV
1.67 x 10 3x 44000
Example 2.3:- The bore and stroke of a water cooled, vertical, single-cylinder, four stroke
diesel engine are 80 mm and 110 mm respectively.The torque is 23.5 N-m.Calculate the brake
mean effective pressure.
What would be the mean effective pressure and torque if the engine rating is 4 kW at 1500
rpm?
Known: Diameter = d = 80 x10 3 = 0.008 m ; stroke = L = 0.110 m; T = 23.5 N-m;
Find (i) bmep ; (ii) bmep if bp = 4 kw and N= 1500 rpm.
Solution: (i) Relation between brake power (bp) and brake mean effective pressure (bmep) is
given by
2NT
(bmep)LAn
bp = ------------ = --------------60,000
60,000
Hence bmep = (2NT) / (LAn) = (2NT) / {(Ld2 /4) N/2} =
= 5.34 x 10 5 N / m2 = 5.34 bar
60,000 x 4
bmep =
,
.
60,000 bp
60,000 x 4
or T = ---------------- = -------------------- = 25.46 N m.
2N
2 x x 1500
Example 2.4:-Find the air fuel ratio of a four stroke, single cylinder, air cooled engine with
fuel consumption time for 10 cc is 20.4 s and air consumption time for 0.1 m3is 16.3 s. The load
is 7 N at the speed of 3000 rpm. Find also the brake specific fuel consumption in kg/kWh and
brake thermal efficiency.Assume the density of air as 1.175 kg/m3 and specific gravity of the
fuel to be 0.7. The lower heating value of the fuel is 43 MJ/kg and the dynamometer constant is
5000.
Known: y = 10 cc ; t = 20.4 s ; Va = 0.1 m3; ta = 16.3 s ; W = 7 N ; N = 3000 rpm;
a = 1.175 kg/m3; s = 0.7 ; CV = 43 x 10 3 kJ/kg; Dynamometer constant = C = 5000.
Find:- (i) ma / mf ; (ii) bsfc ; (iii) bth.
0.1 x 1.175
Solution: (i) Mass of air consumed = ma = ---------------- = 7.21 x 10 3 kg/s.
16.3
ys
10 x 0.7
Mass of fuel consumed = mf = --------- = ------------------ = 0.343 x 10 3 kg/s
1000 t
1000 x 20.4
ma
7.21 x 10 3
Air fuel ratio = --------- = ------------------- = 21
mf
0.343 x 10 3
7 x 3000
(ii) Brake power = bp = WN / C = ------------- = 4.2 kW
5000
mf x 3600
0.343 x 10 3 x 3600
bsfc = ------------------- = ---------------------------- = 0.294 kg/kWh
bp
4.2
bp
4.2
(iii) bith = --------------- = ----------------------------------- = 0.2848 = 28.48 %.
mf CV
0.343 x 10 3 x 43 x 10 3
10
Example 2.5:- A six cylinder, gasoline engine operates on the four stroke cycle. The bore of
each cylinder is 80 mm and the stroke is 100 mm. The clearance volume in each cylinder is 70
cc. At a speed of 4000 rpm and the fuel consumption is 20 kg/h. The torque developed is 150 Nm. Calculate (i) the brake power, (ii) the brake mean effective pressure, (iii) brake thermal
efficiency if the calorific value of the fuel is 43000 kJ/kg and (iv) the relative efficiency if the
ideal cycle for the engine is Otto cycle.
Known: K = 6 ; n = N /2 ; d = 8 cm ; L = 10 cm ; Vc = 70 cc ; N = 4000 rpm ; mf = 20
kg/h ; T = 150 N-m ; CV = 43000 kJ/kg ;
Find:- (i) bp ; (ii) bmep ; (iii) bth ; (iv) Relative.
Solution:
(i)
2 NT
2 x x 4000 x 150
bp = ------------ = -------------------------60,000
60,000
= 62.8 kW
60,000 bp
60,000 x 62.8
(ii) bmep = -------------------- = -------------------------------------------LAnK
0.1 x ( / 4) x 0.08 2 x (4000/2) x 6
= 6.25 x 10 5 N/m2 = 6.25 bar
bp
62.8
(iii) bth = ----------------------- = ------------------------------ = 0.263 = 26.3 %.
mf CV
(20 / 3600) x 43,000
(iv) Stroke volume = Vs = ( / 4) d2 L = ( / 4) x 8 2 x 10 = 502.65 cc
Vs + Vc
502.65 + 70
Compression Ratio of the engine = Rc = ------------ = --------------------- = 8.18
Vc
70
Air standard efficiency of Otto cycle = Otto = 1 (1/ Rc 1)
1
= 1 ---------------------- = 0.568 = 56.8 %
8.18 0.4
Hence Relative efficiency = Relative = bth / Otto = 0.263 / 0.568 = 0.463 = 46.3 %.
Example 2.6:- An eight cylinder, four stroke engine of 9 cm bore, 8 cm stroke and with a
compression ratio of 7 is tested at 4500 rpm on a dynamometer which has 54 cm arm. During
a 10 minute test, the dynamometer scale beam reading was 42 kg and the engine consumed 4.4
kg of gasoline having a calorific value of 44,000 kJ/kg. Air at 27 C and 1 bar was supplied to
11
the carburetor at a rate of 6 kg/min. Find (i) the brake power, (ii) the brake mean effective
pressure, (iii) the brake specific fuel consumption, (iv) the brake specific air consumption, (v)
volumetric efficiency , (vi) the brake thermal efficiency and (vii) the air fuel ratio.
Known: K = 8 ; Four stroke hence n = N/2 ; d = 0.09 m; L = 0.08 m; Rc = 7; N = 4500
rpm; Brake arm = R = 0.54 m ; t = 10 min ; Brake load = W = (42 x 9.81) N
.
Find:- (i) bp ; (ii) bmep ; (iii) bsfc ; (iv) bsac ; (v) v ; (vi) bth ; (vii) ma / mf
Solution:
2 NT
2 NWR
2 x x 4500 x (42 x 9.81) x 0.54
(i) bp = ----------- = ------------ = -------------------------------------------60,000
60,000
60,000
= 104.8 kW
60,000 bp
60,000 x 104.8
(ii) bmep = ------------- = -----------------------------------------------LAnK
0.08 x ( / 4) x 0.09 2 x (4500 / 2) x 8
= 6.87 x 10 5 N/m2 = 6.87 bar.
.
mf
26.4
Brake specific fuel consumption = bsfc = ----------- = ------------- = 0.252 kg / kWh
bp
104.8
.
ma
6 x 60
(iv) brake specific air consumption = bsac = ------------- = -----------------bp
104.8
= 3.435 kg / kWh
(v) bth
bp
104.8
= --.-------------- = ----------------------------- = 0.325 = 32.5 %.
mf CV
(26.4 / 3600) x 44,000
.
12
= ------ x (0.092) x 0.08 x (4500 / 2) x 8
4
= 9.16 m3 / min.
.
ma Ra Ta
6 x 286 x 300
Volume flow rate of air per minute = Va = ------------- = -------------------pa
1 x 10 5
.
= 5.17 m3 / min
.
13
Bt
20.9
(ii) mech = ------------- = --------- = 0.833 = 83.3 %
(ip)total
25.1
60,000 Bt
60,000 x 20.9
(iii) bmep = --------------- = -------------------------------------------------LAnK
0.09 x ( / 4) x 0.075 2 x (3000 / 2) x 4
= 5.25 x 10 5 N / m2 = 5.25 bar.
Example 2.8:- The following observations were recorded during a trail of a four stroke,
single cylinder oil engine.
Duration of trial = 30 min ; oil consumed = 4 litres ; calorific value of oil = 43 MJ/kg ;
specific gravity of fuel = 0.8 ; average area of the indicator diagram = 8.5 cm2; length of the
indicator diagram = 8.5 cm; Indicator spring constant = 5.5 bar/cm; brake load = 150 kg;
spring balance reading = 20 kg; effective brake wheel diameter = 1.5 m ; speed = 200 rpm ;
cylinder diameter = 30 cm ; stroke = 45 cm ; jacket cooling water = 10 kg/min ; temperature
rise of cooling water = 36 C. Calculate (i) indicated power, (ii) brake power, (iii) mechanical
efficiency, (iv) brake specific fuel consumption, (v) indicated thermal efficiency, and (vi) heat
carried away by cooling water.
Known: t = 30 min ; y = 4000 cc; CV = 43 x10 3 kJ/kg; s = 0.8 ; area of the diagram = a =
8.5 cm2; length of the diagram = ld = 8.5 cm ; indicator spring constant = ks = 5.5 bar /
cm; W = 150 x 9.81 N ; Brake radius = R = 1.5 / 2 = 0.75 m; N = 200 rpm ; d = 0.3 m ;
.
Find:- (i) ip ; (ii) bp ; (iii) mech ; (iv) bsfc ; (v) ith ; (vi) Qw
Solution:
a
8.5
(i) pim = ------- ks = ----------- x 5.5 = 5.5 bar = 5.5 x 105 N/m2
ld
8.5
pim L A n K
5.5 x 10 5 x 0.45 x ( / 4) x 0.32 x (200 / 2) x 1
ip = ------------------- = ---------------------------------------------------------------- = 29.16 kW
60,000
60,000
2 N(W S) R
2 x x 200 x (150 20)x 9.81 x 0.75
(ii) bp = ----------------------- = ---------------------------------------------------- = 20.03 kW
60,000
60,000
14
Vtotal = 7.5 m3; hence V = 7.5 / 40 = 0.1875 m3/min; pgauge = 136 mm of water (gauge);
Tatm = 17 + 273 = 290 K; (CV)NTP = 19 x 10 3 kJ/ m3 ; Tw = 45 C;
.
15
(i)
pim L A n K
5.8 x 10 5 x ( / 4) x 0.252 x 0.45 x 80.75
ip = ------------------ = ------------------------------------------------------- = 17.25 kW.
60,000
60,000
2 N W R
2 x x 202 x (80 x 9.81) x 0.8
bp = --------------------- = ------------------------------------------ = 13.28 kW
60,000
60,000
Pressure of gas supplied = p = patm + pgauge = 760 + 136 / 13.6 = 770 mm of mercury
.
100.00
Heat equivalent of bp
896.4
26.4
796.4
23.4
Heat equivalent of fp
238.2
7.0
Heat unaccounted
(by difference)
1465.15
43.2
16
Total
3396.25
100.0
3396.25
100.0
Example 2.10:- A test on a two-stroke engine gave the following results at full load.
Speed = 350 rpm; Net brake load = 65 kg ; mean effective pressure = 3 bar ; Fuel
consumption = 4 kg/h ; Jacket cooling water flow rate = 500 kg/h ; jacket water temperature
at inlet = 20 C ; jacket water temperature at outlet = 40 C ; Test room temperature = 20 C ;
Temperature of exhaust gases = 400 C; Air used per kg of fuel = 32 kg ; cylinder diameter =
22 cm ;stroke = 28 cm; effective brake diameter = 1 m ; Calorific value of fuel = 43 MJ/kg ;
Mean specific heat of exhaust gases = 1 kJ/kg K.
Find indicated power, brake power and draw up a heat balance for the test in kW and in
percentage.
Known: Two stroke engine. Hence n = N ; N = 350 rpm ; W = (65 x 9.81) N ;
.
= 11.68 kW.
Heat lost to cooling water = mw (Cp)w [Two Twi] = (500 / 3600) x 4.2 x [40 20] = 11.7 kW
.
17
kW
47.8
100
Total
47.8
100
Heat Expenditure
kW
Heat in bp
11.68
24.4
11.70
24.5
13.90
29.1
Unaccounted heat
(by difference)
Total
10.52
47.80
22.0
100
18