ROTONDAS
ROTONDAS
ROTONDAS
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.7708/ijtte.2016.6(2).07
Sv. Kliment Ohridski University, Faculty of Technical Sciences, Depatment for Traffic and Transport,
Boulevard 1st of May B.B., Bitola 7000, Republic of Macedonia
Abstract: The turbo roundabout is an innovative design of the two lane roundabout that has
revolutionised roundabout design. According to the international research, it is determined
that the turbo roundabout has a higher level of traffic safety because of the lower number
of conflicts and the use of raised lane dividers. In addition, compared with the conventional
two lane roundabout, turbo roundabout has higher capacity. Due to these advantages, the
reconstruction of intersections into turbo roundabouts has become a kind of global trend
nowadays. The first turbo roundabout in the Republic of Macedonia was designed in Skopje
in 2011, without tracking the performances. This was exactly the motive to investigate the
performances of this type of intersections.
In this research three intersections in sequence located in Ohrid (two signalized and one
non-signalized intersection) and the performances are determined for the current situation
and the situation with increased flows by using the software tool SIDRA. A reconstruction
of the intersections has been made into turbo roundabouts. The performances for two
different cases (current situation and the situation with increased flows, with and without
the pedestrians influence) are determined with the use of both VISSIM and analytical model
by Brilon&Wu. The analysis has proven that with the input parameters, turbo roundabouts
offer better performances compared to the existing intersections. Thus, the reconstruction
of the intersections is justified.
Keywords: turbo roundabouts, capacity models, performances, pedestrian impact.
1. Introduction
When comparison is drawn between the
intersections either signalized or nonsignalized, and the roundabouts, the latter
display a series of advantages over the
former ones when capacity, level of service,
and traffic safety are at question (Tollazi,
2015). However, at the roundabouts with
multiple lanes and two-laned approaches
and exits, conflictual situations arise when
3
196
International Journal for Traffic and Transport Engineering, 2016, 6(2): 196 - 211
197
Gredoska N. et al. An Evaluation of Turbo Roundabout Performances: Case Study of the City of Ohrid
198
International Journal for Traffic and Transport Engineering, 2016, 6(2): 196 - 211
Fig. 1.
Macro Location of Intersections
Source: Google Map
Table 1 displays the geometry of the existing
intersections in SIDRA, the newly designed
turbo roundabouts, and the data for road
traffic volume according to direction. As
the town of Ohrid is a tourist place, the
199
Gredoska N. et al. An Evaluation of Turbo Roundabout Performances: Case Study of the City of Ohrid
Table 1
Geometric Features and Traffic Volume at the Intersections
Existing intersections
Turbo roundabouts
Traffic volume
1.
2.
3.
200
International Journal for Traffic and Transport Engineering, 2016, 6(2): 196 - 211
C=
(1)
Where:
- C = basic capacity of one entry (PAE/h)
- qk = traffic volume on the circle (PAE/h)
- nc = number of circulating lanes
- ne = number of entry lanes the number of
entrance lanes
- tg = critical gap (s)
- t f = followup time (s)
- t min = minimum gap between succeeding
vehicles on the circle (s)
The following table displays the values of
the time headway applied in this research
for German drivers.
Table 2
Values of the Time Headway for German Drivers
Intersections
Entry type
IN1
Critical
headway tc (s)
follow-up
time t F (s)
Min. gap on
the circle to (s)
4.5
2.5
1.9
4.5
2.5
1.9
4.3
2.8
2.0
4.0
4.5
2.6
2.7
1.9
2.0
IN4
Left lane
Right lane
201
Gredoska N. et al. An Evaluation of Turbo Roundabout Performances: Case Study of the City of Ohrid
Table 3
One - Lane Entry Capacity Adjustment Factor for Pedestrian
Case
fped =1
Else
Source: HCM (2010)
Where:
- f ped = entry capacity adjustment factor for pedestrian
- nped = number of conflicting pedestrians per hour (pedestrians/hour)
= conflicting vehicular flow rate in the circulatory roadway (PAE/hour)
Table 4
Two - Lane Entry Capacity Adjustment Factor for Pedestrian
Case
Else
202
International Journal for Traffic and Transport Engineering, 2016, 6(2): 196 - 211
Fig. 2.
Roundabout Design Created in VISSIM
Source: Gredoska (2015)
The basic element of a VISSIM traffic network
is a link representing a single (or multiple) lane
roadway segment with a specific direction of
flow. When the traffic network is designed
203
Gredoska N. et al. An Evaluation of Turbo Roundabout Performances: Case Study of the City of Ohrid
Fig. 3.
Vehicle Inputs
Source: Gredoska (2015)
Furthermore, the routes from each approach
and from each entr y lane are defined.
Fig. 4.
Defining the Flow Routes
Source: Gredoska (2015)
Fig. 5.
Setting Vehicles and Pedestrians Priorities
Source: Gredoska (2015)
204
International Journal for Traffic and Transport Engineering, 2016, 6(2): 196 - 211
Fig. 6.
Defining the Reduced Speed Areas
Source: Gredoska (2015)
The next step is defining the reduced speed areas (Fig. 6), and the last one is setting the
conflict areas (Fig. 7).
Fig. 7.
Setting the Conflict Areas
Source: Gredoska (2015)
205
Gredoska N. et al. An Evaluation of Turbo Roundabout Performances: Case Study of the City of Ohrid
Fig. 8.
Simulation in VISSIM
Source: Gredoska (2015)
5. Analysis of the Performances of services, and the average travel speed. Table 5
the Existing Intersections and Turbo shows a graph displaying the obtained results
regarding the average delay at separate
Roundabouts
After the conducted analysis, data was
obtained about the average delay, the level of
Table 5
Graph Display of Average Delay at Existing Intersections and Turbo Roundabouts with and without
Pedestrians Flow Impact
Average delay (with pedestrians flow impact)
60
60
50
50
40
40
Delay (s)
Delay (s)
30
20
10
30
20
10
0
0
1
Aproach
Aproach
206
80
80
60
60
Delay (s)
Delay (s)
International Journal for Traffic and Transport Engineering, 2016, 6(2): 196 - 211
40
20
40
20
0
0
1
200
150
150
Delay (s)
Delay (s)
Aproach
Aproach
100
50
100
50
0
0
1
Aproach
Aproach
207
Gredoska N. et al. An Evaluation of Turbo Roundabout Performances: Case Study of the City of Ohrid
Table 6
The Level of Service at Approaches and the Average Travel Speed
The level of service and the average travel speed
Intersection 1
intersection 2
The level of service and the average travel speed
Intersection 3
A turbo roundabout 1
A turbo roundabout 3
A turbo roundabout 2
208
International Journal for Traffic and Transport Engineering, 2016, 6(2): 196 - 211
1400
1400
Brilon
VISSIM
HCM/Brilon (pedestrian)
VISSIM (pedestrian)
1000
800
600
400
200
0
Brilon
VISSIM
HCM/Brilon (pedestrian)
VISSIM (pedestrian)
1200
1200
1000
800
600
400
200
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
1400
1600
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
1400
1600
Brilon
VISSIM
HCM/Brilon (pedestrian)
VISSIM (pedestrian)
1200
1000
800
600
400
200
0
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
1400
1600
c) 500 pedestrians
Fig. 9.
Dependence of the Entry Lane Capacity on the Volume of the Circulating Flow and of the Pedestrians
Flow (50, 250, 500 Pedestrians) According to the Model by Brilon and the One in VISSIM
Source: Gredoska (2015)
As the graph displays, at a rarer circulating
f low and when pedestrians are not taken
into consideration, the entry lane capacity
according to the VISSIM model has higher
values than Brilons model. With the increase
of the circulating flows, the two models give
nearly same values.
With a volume of 250 pedestrians, the
VISSIM model (pedestrian) displays higher
values of the entry lane capacity than the
209
Gredoska N. et al. An Evaluation of Turbo Roundabout Performances: Case Study of the City of Ohrid
6. Conclusion
The choice of intersection control mode is
one of the most important decisions to be
reached by traffic engineers. When making
decision the traffic safety and capacity are
key factors. When turbo roundabouts are in
question, the research conducted worldwide
shows that the advantages over the other
types of intersections are the following:
increased capacity, lower average delay,
increased safety, etc.
On the bases of the conducted analysis with
this research, it can be concluded that turbo
roundabouts performances (delay, level of
service, average travel speed, entry lane
capacity) depend on the density of entry
flows, the circulating flows, and the density
of pedestrians flows.
At intensive traffic and pedestrians flows,
pedestrians do influence the capacity. Thus,
a jam occurs on the circulating lane flows,
which causes saturation flow of vehicles on
the entry lanes and increase of delays.
According to the used parameters, the
analyzed turbo roundabouts offer better
performances than the existing signalized
intersections and two way STOP controlled
intersection.
210
References
Bovy, P.H. 1991. Zusammenfassung der schweizerischen
Kreiselhandbuchs. Summary of the swiss guide to
roundabouts. Available from Internet: uuid:05ae95bf5f8b-4ca6-9370-4d194ce96126.
Brilon, W. 2008. Turbo Roundabout an Experience
from Germany. In Proceedings of the National Roundabout
Conference, 1-18.
Brilon, W.; Bondzio, L.; Wu, N. 1997. Unsignalized
Intersections in Germany a State of the Art. Turbo
Roundabout an Ex perience from Germany.
In Proceedings of the 2nd International Symposium for
Unsignalized Intersections, 61-70.
Campbell, D.; Jurisich, I.; Dunn, R. 2012. Improved
multi line roundabout designs for urban areas,
Auck land Transpor t, Depar tment of Civ il and
Environmental Engineering.
For tuijn, L .G.H.; Har te, V.F. 1997. Multi lane
Roundabouts: An Exploration of New Forms (in Dutch).
Verkeerskundige werkdagen, CROW, Ede, Netherlands.
Fortuijn, L.G.H. 2009. Turbo roundabouts, Estimation
of Capacity, Transportation Research Record: Journal of the
Transportation Research Board, 2130: 83-92.
Fortuijn, L.G.H. 2009. Turbo Roundabouts: Design
Principles and Safety Performance, Transportation
Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research
Board, 2096: 16-24
Giuffr, .; Guerrieri, .; Gran, . 2010. Turboroundabout general design criteria and functional
principles: Case studies from real world. In Proceedings
of the 4th International Symposium on Highway Geometric
Design, 1-12.
International Journal for Traffic and Transport Engineering, 2016, 6(2): 196 - 211
211