IEEE STD 125-2007 PDF

IEEE Recommended Practice
for Preparation of Equipment

Specifications for Speed-Governing
of Hydraulic Turbines Intended
to Drive Electric Generators
Sponsored by the
Energy Development and Power Generation Committee
125
TM
IEEE Power Engineering Society
IEEE
3 Park Avenue
New York, NY 10016-5997, USA
26 October 2007
IEEE Std 125-2007

(Revision of
IEEE Std 125-1988)
Authorized licensed use limited to: UNIVERSIDADE FEDERAL DE MINAS GERAIS. Downloaded on July 13,2016 at 20:49:23 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
IEEE Std 125TM-2007

(Revision of
IEEE Std 125-1988)

Sponsor
Energy Development and Power Generation Committee

of the
IEEE Power Engineering Society
Approved 7 June 2007
IEEE-SA Standards Board
Abstract: This recommended practice is intended to assist users with the preparation of
procurement specifications for electric-hydraulic speed governors.
Keywords: control, digital, governor, hydraulic, hydroelectric, speed, stability
The Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, Inc.

3 Park Avenue, New York, NY 10016-5997, USA
Copyright 2007 by the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, Inc.
All rights reserved. Published 26 October 2007. Printed in the United States of America.
IEEE is a registered trademark in the U.S. Patent & Trademark Office, owned by the Institute of Electrical and Electronics
Engineers, Incorporated.
Print:
PDF:
ISBN 0-7381-5637-X
ISBN 0-7381-5638-8
SH95699
SS95699
No part of this publication may be reproduced in any form, in an electronic retrieval system or otherwise, without the prior written permission
of the publisher.
IEEE Standards documents are developed within the IEEE Societies and the Standards Coordinating Committees of
the IEEE Standards Association (IEEE-SA) Standards Board. The IEEE develops its standards through a consensus
development process, approved by the American National Standards Institute, which brings together volunteers
representing varied viewpoints and interests to achieve the final product. Volunteers are not necessarily members of the
Institute and serve without compensation. While the IEEE administers the process and establishes rules to promote
fairness in the consensus development process, the IEEE does not independently evaluate, test, or verify the accuracy
of any of the information contained in its standards.
Use of an IEEE Standard is wholly voluntary. The IEEE disclaims liability for any personal injury, property or other
damage, of any nature whatsoever, whether special, indirect, consequential, or compensatory, directly or indirectly
resulting from the publication, use of, or reliance upon this, or any other IEEE Standard document.
The IEEE does not warrant or represent the accuracy or content of the material contained herein, and expressly
disclaims any express or implied warranty, including any implied warranty of merchantability or fitness for a specific
purpose, or that the use of the material contained herein is free from patent infringement. IEEE Standards documents
are supplied AS IS.
The existence of an IEEE Standard does not imply that there are no other ways to produce, test, measure, purchase,
market, or provide other goods and services related to the scope of the IEEE Standard. Furthermore, the viewpoint
expressed at the time a standard is approved and issued is subject to change brought about through developments in the
state of the art and comments received from users of the standard. Every IEEE Standard is subjected to review at least
every five years for revision or reaffirmation. When a document is more than five years old and has not been
reaffirmed, it is reasonable to conclude that its contents, although still of some value, do not wholly reflect the present
state of the art. Users are cautioned to check to determine that they have the latest edition of any IEEE Standard.
In publishing and making this document available, the IEEE is not suggesting or rendering professional or other
services for, or on behalf of, any person or entity. Nor is the IEEE undertaking to perform any duty owed by any other
person or entity to another. Any person utilizing this, and any other IEEE Standards document, should rely upon the
advice of a competent professional in determining the exercise of reasonable care in any given circumstances.
Interpretations: Occasionally questions may arise regarding the meaning of portions of standards as they relate to
specific applications. When the need for interpretations is brought to the attention of IEEE, the Institute will initiate
action to prepare appropriate responses. Since IEEE Standards represent a consensus of concerned interests, it is
important to ensure that any interpretation has also received the concurrence of a balance of interests. For this reason,
IEEE and the members of its societies and Standards Coordinating Committees are not able to provide an instant
response to interpretation requests except in those cases where the matter has previously received formal consideration.
At lectures, symposia, seminars, or educational courses, an individual presenting information on IEEE standards shall
make it clear that his or her views should be considered the personal views of that individual rather than the formal
position, explanation, or interpretation of the IEEE.
Comments for revision of IEEE Standards are welcome from any interested party, regardless of membership affiliation
with IEEE. Suggestions for changes in documents should be in the form of a proposed change of text, together with
appropriate supporting comments. Comments on standards and requests for interpretations should be addressed to:
Secretary, IEEE-SA Standards Board
445 Hoes Lane
Piscataway, NJ 08854
USA
Authorization to photocopy portions of any individual standard for internal or personal use is granted by the Institute of
Electrical and Electronics Engineers, Inc., provided that the appropriate fee is paid to Copyright Clearance Center. To
arrange for payment of licensing fee, please contact Copyright Clearance Center, Customer Service, 222 Rosewood
Drive, Danvers, MA 01923 USA; +1 978 750 8400. Permission to photocopy portions of any individual standard for
educational classroom use can also be obtained through the Copyright Clearance Center.
Introduction
This introduction is not part of IEEE Std 125-2007, IEEE Recommended Practice for Preparation of
Equipment Specifications for Speed-Governing of Hydraulic Turbines Intended to Drive Electric
Generators.
This recommended practice assists users with procurement specifications for turbine governing systems for
hydroelectric generating units. It is recommended this document be used in conjunction with companion
document IEEE Std 1207. a This recommended practice is designed to be a reference document for
practicing engineers in the hydroelectric industry and offers guidance for what elements of a turbine
governing system need to be specified.
Notice to users
Errata
Errata, if any, for this and all other standards can be accessed at the following URL: http://
standards.ieee.org/reading/ieee/updates/errata/index.html. Users are encouraged to check this URL for
errata periodically.
Interpretations
Current interpretations can be accessed at the following URL: http://standards.ieee.org/reading/ieee/interp/
index.html.
Patents
Attention is called to the possibility that implementation of this recommended practice may require use of
subject matter covered by patent rights. By publication of this recommended practice, no position is taken
with respect to the existence or validity of any patent rights in connection therewith. The IEEE shall not be
responsible for identifying patents or patent applications for which a license may be required to implement
an IEEE standard or for conducting inquiries into the legal validity or scope of those patents that are
brought to its attention.
For more information about this IEEE standard, please see Clause 2.
iv
Copyright 2007 IEEE. All rights reserved.
Participants
At the time this recommended practice was submitted to the IEEE-SA Standards Board for approval, the
Energy Development and Power Generation Committee Working Group had the following membership:
David Apps, Chair
David L. Kornegay, Vice Chair
J. C. Agee
Terry Bauman
Steven R. Brockschink
Matthew T. Davis
Terry Deckman
Donald Evans
Russ Fostiak
George Girgis
Tony Griffiths
Randall C. Groves
James H. Gurney
Hans Naeff
Bernard Poulin
Douglas Seely
Chris Shultz
Philip Spotts
Winfried Stach
Wayne Timm
John B. Yale
The following members of the balloting committee voted on this recommended practice. Balloters may
have voted for approval, disapproval, or abstention.
William J. Ackerman
J. C. Agee
S. K. Aggarwal
David B. Apps
Ali Al Awazi
Steven R. Brockschink
Tommy P. Cooper
Luis M. Coronado
Matthew T. Davis
Bostjan K. Derganc
Gary R. Engmann
J. Travis Griffith
Randall C. Groves
James H. Gurney
Gary A. Heuston
David A. Horvath
Innocent Kamwa
Joseph L. Koepfinger
David L. Kornegay
Lawrence D. Long
Willaim Lumpkins
John W. Martin
Don G. McLaren
Gary L. Michel
Michael S. Newman
Bartien Sayogo
Gil Shultz
William W. Terry
Wayne Timm
James W. Wilson
Theodore C. Zeiss
When the IEEE-SA Standards Board approved this recommended practice on 7 June 2007, it had the
following membership:
Steve M. Mills, Chair
Robert M. Grow, Vice Chair
Don Wright, Past Chair
Judith Gorman, Secretary
Richard DeBlasio
Alex Gelman
William R. Goldbach
Arnold M. Greenspan
Joanna N. Guenin
Julian Forster*
Kenneth S. Hanus
William B. Hopf
Richard H. Hulett
Hermann Koch
Joseph L. Koepfinger*
John Kulick
David J. Law
Glenn Parsons
Ronald C. Petersen
Tom A. Prevost
Narayanan Ramachandran
Greg Ratta
Robby Robson
Anne-Marie Sahazizian
Virginia C. Sulzberger
Malcolm V. Thaden
Richard L. Townsend
Howard L. Wolfman
*Member Emeritus
Also included are the following nonvoting IEEE-SA Standards Board liaisons:
Satish K. Aggarwal, NRC Representative
Alan H. Cookson, NIST Representative
Jennie M. Steinhagen
IEEE Standards Program Manager, Document Development
Matthew J. Ceglia
IEEE Standards Program Manager, Technical Program Development
v
Contents
1. Overview .................................................................................................................................................... 1
1.1 Scope ................................................................................................................................................... 1
1.2 Purpose ................................................................................................................................................ 1
1.3 Disclaimer............................................................................................................................................ 1
1.4 Use of IEEE Std 125............................................................................................................................ 2
2. Normative references.................................................................................................................................. 2
3. Definitions .................................................................................................................................................. 3
4. Functions and characteristics...................................................................................................................... 4
4.1 Control actuator position ..................................................................................................................... 4
4.2 Control actuator stroke ........................................................................................................................ 4
4.3 Control actuator time ........................................................................................................................... 4
5. Equipment specifications............................................................................................................................ 5
5.1 General specifications.......................................................................................................................... 5
5.2 Governor and auxiliary functions ........................................................................................................ 7
5.3 Other optional functions .................................................................................................................... 14
5.4 Hydraulic pressure supply system ..................................................................................................... 16
5.5 New installation considerations ......................................................................................................... 21
5.6 Replacement and conversion considerations ..................................................................................... 22
5.7 Redundancy ....................................................................................................................................... 23
5.8 Failsafe features................................................................................................................................. 23
5.9 Dual-regulated turbines ..................................................................................................................... 24
5.10 Additional governor-controller functions ........................................................................................ 26
5.11 Environmental specifications........................................................................................................... 27
5.12 Software........................................................................................................................................... 28
5.13 Interface to other plant systems ....................................................................................................... 29
5.14 Operator interface ............................................................................................................................ 30
5.15 Personnel safety features ................................................................................................................. 30
5.16 Spare parts and accessories.............................................................................................................. 31
5.17 Product support................................................................................................................................ 32
6. Performance specification ........................................................................................................................ 32
6.1 Stability.............................................................................................................................................. 32
6.2 Permanent speed droop...................................................................................................................... 34
6.3 Deadband........................................................................................................................................... 34
6.4 Deadtime............................................................................................................................................ 35
6.5 Governor damping adjustments ......................................................................................................... 35
7. Information provided by the manufacturer............................................................................................... 36
7.1 Information to be provided at the time of submission of proposals................................................... 36
7.2 Information to be provided after contract award ............................................................................... 36
7.3 Test procedures.................................................................................................................................. 37
7.4 Rehabilitation and conversion considerations ................................................................................... 38
8. Governor testing ....................................................................................................................................... 38
8.1 Factory acceptance testing................................................................................................................. 38
8.2 On-site acceptance testing ................................................................................................................. 39
vi
9. Information provided by the specifier ...................................................................................................... 41

Annex A (informative) Bibliography ........................................................................................................... 44
Annex B (informative) Glossary .................................................................................................................. 46
Annex C (normative) Mode control logic .................................................................................................... 47
C.1 Droop mode control logic ................................................................................................................. 47
C.2 Governor mode control logic ............................................................................................................ 47
Annex D (normative) Tables ........................................................................................................................ 49
vii

1. Overview
1.1 Scope
This document recommends performance characteristics and equipment for electric-hydraulic governors for
all types of hydraulic turbines intended to drive electric generators of all sizes. This recommended practice
is applicable to new governors and rehabilitation of existing governors.
1.2 Purpose
This recommended practice is intended to assist users with the preparation of procurement specifications
for electric-hydraulic speed governors.
1.3 Disclaimer
This recommended practice is intended to help users develop the technical portion of procurement
specifications for electric-hydraulic speed governors. It does not cover the commercial portion of the
procurement specification. It does not cover governor equipment installation procedures.
1
IEEE Std 125-2007

IEEE Recommended Practice for Preparation of Equipment Specifications
for Speed-Governing of Hydraulic Turbines Intended to Drive Electric Generators
1.4 Use of IEEE Std 125

This recommended practice should be used in conjunction with IEEE Std 1207. 1 IEEE Std 125 provides
recommendations regarding performance characteristics and equipment specifications relating to turbine
governing systems for controlling hydroelectric units. IEEE Std 1207 provides application insight for
applying these systems to hydroelectric units and offers experience-based guidance on the impact upon
system performance of various specification parameters of turbine governing systems. In addition to
providing recommendations regarding performance characteristics, it is the intent of the IEEE Std 125 to
provide aid in preparing technical specifications for turbine governing systems for controlling hydroelectric
units. Incorporation of the technical specifications contained in IEEE Std 125 into a user organizations
specification document is left to the user's discretion with respect to organization and sequence.
Features and tests detailed in Clause 5, Clause 6 and Clause 8 of this document are considered either
recommended or optional. The appearance of the words should implies this feature, function or test
is recommended for all installations. The appearance of the words may implies this feature, function or
test is optional (at the specifiers discretion). Optional items are often not implemented in the majority of
installations, but may be required by some purchasers depending on their operating experience and design
philosophy.
The following example shows typical wording for a recommended feature:
The governor-control system should provide a means for controlling the turbine-control actuators
manually. (See 5.2.9.)
The following example shows typical wording for an optional feature:
A governor-control strategy may be specified in accordance with the anticipated performance
requirements of the installation. (See 5.2.1.2.)
This document applies to new governors and governor conversions. IEEE Std 1147 contains a general
overview of governor conversions. Only those paragraphs in IEEE Std 125 that apply to the specific
equipment to be purchased should be used when preparing the procurement specification.
2. Normative references
The following referenced documents are indispensable for the application of this document (i.e., they must
be understood and used, so each referenced document is cited in text and its relationship to this document is
explained). For dated references, only the edition cited applies. For undated references, the latest edition of
the referenced document (including any amendments or corrigenda) applies.
IEEE Std 1010, IEEE Guide for Control of Hydroelectric Power Plants. 2, 3
IEEE Std 1147, IEEE Guide for the Rehabilitation of Hydroelectric Power Plants.
IEEE Std 1207, IEEE Guide for the Application of Turbine Governing Systems for Hydroelectric
Generating Units.
1
Information on references can be found in Clause 2.
The IEEE standards or products referred to in Clause 2 are trademarks owned by the Institute of Electrical and Electronics
3
IEEE publications are available from the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, 445 Hoes Lane, Piscataway, NJ 088551331, USA (http://standards.ieee.org/).
2
IEEE Std 125-2007

3. Definitions
For the purposes of this recommended practice, the following terms and definitions apply. The glossary in
Annex B and The Authoritative Dictionary of IEEE Standards [B17], 4 should be referenced for terms not
defined in this clause.
3.1 control actuator limit: A maximum limit within the governor system which prevents the turbinecontrol actuator from opening beyond the position for which the device is set. May be operator-adjustable.
3.2 control actuator velocity limiter: A device that functions to limit the control actuator velocity in either
the opening, closing, or both directions, exclusive of the operation of the slow closure device. See also:
slow closure device.
3.3 executable code: The software code that resides in the digital controller and executes the control
sequence/strategy in real time.
3.4 governor controller: A device or system that compares the turbine speed, along with any applicable
intermediate feedbacks, to a reference set point and processes the resultant error signal to produce a
command signal to the turbine-control actuator.
3.5 governor conversion: Replacement of the governor controller components of an existing governor,
typically with a digital controller and new speed and turbine-control actuator position-sensing equipment.
3.6 grid connected: The condition where the turbine-generator unit is electrically connected to a large
power grid consisting of many turbine-generator units operating in parallel.
3.7 hydraulic power unit (HPU): The pumps, means for driving them, sump tank, and associated
accessory devices.
3.8 hydraulic pressure supply system (HPSS): The hydraulic power unit (HPU), pressure tank(s), valves,
and piping connecting the various parts of the governing system.
3.9 main servomotor: The primary servomotor used to control the primary turbine-control device. For
reaction turbines, the main servomotor controls the wicket gates. For impulse turbines, the main servomotor
controls the deflectors. For dual-regulated turbines, the main servomotor is typically larger and faster than
the secondary servomotor.
3.10 programming computer: The computer that generates and stores the source code. It is also used to
download the executable code and operate the various software tools and utilities.
3.11 settings: The various user-adjustable parameters that reside in the digital controller such as time
constants, gains, thresholds, etc. These are also known in the industry as tunables or constants.
3.12 slow closure device: A cushioning device that retards the closing velocity of the control actuator from
a predetermined control actuator position to zero control actuator position.
3.13 speed-sensing elements: The speed responsive elements that determine speed and influence the action
of other elements of the governing system. Included are the means used to transmit a signal proportional to
the speed of the turbine to the governor.
3.14 speed error: The algebraic difference between the speed reference and the measured turbine speed.
The numbers in brackets correspond to those in the bibliography in Annex A.
3
IEEE Std 125-2007

3.15 turbine-control actuator: A device or system that controls the position of a turbine-control device in
response to a command signal from the governor controller. Examples include: electric motor-driven
actuator; hydraulic-control actuator and associated distributing valve.
3.16 turbine-control device: An adjustable device that directly affects the operation of the hydraulic
turbine. Some examples of turbine-control devices are wicket gates, runner blades, flow-controlling orifices
(or nozzles), and deflectors.
3.17 turbine-control actuator rating: The turbine-control actuator rating is the flow rate in volume per
unit time that the turbine-control actuator can deliver at a specified pressure drop. The pressure drop should
be measured across the terminating pipe connections to the turbine-control actuators at the actuator. This
pressure drop is measured with the specified minimum normal working pressure of the HPSS delivered to
the supply port of the actuator distributing valve.
4. Functions and characteristics

For purposes of this document, the functions and characteristics discussed in 4.1, 4.2, and 4.3 apply.
IEEE Std 1207 should be referenced for functions and characteristics not defined in this clause.
4.1 Control actuator position

The instantaneous position of the turbine-control actuator measured from its zero position expressed as a
percentage of the control actuator stroke. This is commonly referred to as gate position, nozzle position,
blade position, or deflector position, although the relationship between control actuator stroke and the
position of the controlled device may not always be linear.
4.2 Control actuator stroke

Travel of the turbine-control actuator (in inches or mm) from minimum (zero without squeeze) position to
maximum position (without overtravel). This is sometimes referred to as effective control actuator stroke.
For a gate or nozzle control actuator this is defined as the travel of the control actuator required to change
the gate or nozzle position from no discharge to maximum discharge. For a blade control actuator this is
defined as the travel of the control actuator required to change the blade position from flat to steep. For
a deflector-control actuator this is defined as the travel of the control actuator required to change the
deflector position from the no deflection position to the full flow deflected position with maximum
discharge under maximum specified head, including overpressure due to water hammer.
4.3 Control actuator time

The elapsed time for one full control actuator stroke (either opening or closing) at maximum control
actuator velocity. The control actuator time is equal to 100 divided by the maximum control actuator
velocity (velocity expressed in units of percent per second) and is typically measured over a reduced range
(for example, 25% to 75%) to eliminate the effect of cushioning.
4
IEEE Std 125-2007

5. Equipment specifications
5.1 General specifications

5.1.1 Interface to other plant equipment
For new unit supply, the manufacturer of the governor equipment should cooperate to the fullest extent
possible with the manufacturers of the turbine and generator equipment to ensure that the purchaser is
furnished with a complete and properly coordinated governor-control system capable of functioning to
properly regulate the speed and power output of the turbine and generator.
For governor replacements and conversions, the manufacturer of the governor equipment is responsible for
ensuring that the equipment will interface both mechanically and electrically to the existing plant
equipment. Visits to the site by the manufacturer may be required to confirm compatibility between
existing and proposed equipment and to confirm dimensions shown on existing plant equipment drawings.
5.1.2 Governor operation
Unless otherwise specified, the governor-control system should be supplied as a complete system,
including speed-sensing elements, governor-control cabinet, governor hydraulic-control valve, HPSS, and
all specified parts and accessories required to control the speed and generation of the hydroelectric
generating unit. The rating of the governor hydraulic-control valve should be sufficient to operate the
turbine-control actuators within the specified control actuator timing parameters.
This recommended practice primarily focuses upon using hydraulic turbine-control actuators, which are
very commonly used for hydroelectric turbines. However, the functional characteristics specified also apply
to any other type of turbine-control actuator that may be used in a particular application (e.g., electric
actuators).
5.1.3 Governor cabinet construction
The governor-control equipment should be housed in a cabinet that provides physical protection, electrical
shielding and protection from contaminants such as dust and oil. The specification writer may include
detailed requirements related to cabinet size, material, paint type and color, grounding, cable access,
seismic withstand, wiring and wire termination. Steel and aluminum are commonly specified cabinet
materials. The governor electronic control cabinet may either be mounted on the hydraulic power unit, or it
may be mounted at a separate location.
5.1.4 Nameplate
A permanent metal nameplate should be provided on each governor-control cabinet, clearly marked or
stamped to indicate the following information:
Manufacturers name and address
Serial number of the governor-control system
Model number and type number of the governor-control system
Date of manufacture
5
IEEE Std 125-2007

Maximum working hydraulic supply pressure
Minimum normal working hydraulic supply pressure
Rated hydraulic fluid flow at the minimum normal working hydraulic supply pressure
5.1.5 Electrical power

The purchaser will make available uninterruptible direct current (dc) or alternating current (ac) control
power from the stations battery or UPS system within a specified range of voltage. All critical control
devices including solenoids, relays, electronic controls, and power supplies used within the governorcontrol system should be operable within the stated control power voltage range.
The purchaser will also make available three-phase and single-phase station service ac (SSAC) power
within stated voltage ranges. These SSAC power sources will be subject to transient overfrequency and
overvoltage conditions following a separation of the station from the interconnected power system. All
governor-control system components utilizing the SSAC power sources should be designed to withstand
these transient conditions without damage and without mis-operation.
Assuming that adequate hydraulic pressure exists and control power is available, it should be possible to
start the turbine generator without SSAC power.
5.1.6 Power supplies
A reliable power supply system should be provided for powering the governor electronic control circuitry.
The preferred power supply system should include redundant power supplies connected to separate power
sources within the station such that the failure of any one regulated output voltage should cause
instantaneous transfer to a redundant supply without affecting normal governor operation in any way.
Alarm indication should be provided to indicate the failure of one of the redundant power supplies. If nonredundant power supplies are specified, proper fail-safe operation of the governor control in the event of a
power supply failure should also be specified. The manufacturer of the governor system should provide full
details of the proposed power supply system for approval by the purchaser. A common design philosophy
for redundant power supply systems powers one redundant power supply from the station service ac source,
and one redundant power supply from the station dc battery system. This approach accommodates the fact
that the ac power source is not considered secure, and the dc power source is always available to act as a
backup to the ac power source.
5.1.7 Test facilities
5.1.7.1 Isolation and test switches
The specifier may specify isolation and test switches to facilitate testing during commissioning or
maintenance. The quantity, circuit location and physical location should be clearly indicated.
5.1.7.2 Signal monitoring
If a digital controller is specified, analog outputs may be provided for purposes of monitoring internal
variables with the purchasers recording device. The bandwidth of each analog output should be specified
(10 Hz or higher typical). Alternatively, this capability may be provided by way of having the governor
controller automatically record the internal variables. The recording rate should be user adjustable. The
fastest recording rate (10 samples per second typical) and the minimum number of samples (1000 typical)
should be specified.
6
IEEE Std 125-2007

It should be possible for the user to select any combination of variables for recording from a preset menu or
list. The quantity and variable names should be clearly indicated. The following variables are typical:
Main turbine-control actuator (gate or deflector) position
Main turbine-control actuator (gate or deflector) set point
Blade or nozzle servomotor position (if applicable)
Blade or nozzle servomotor set point (if applicable)
Speed
Speed error (input to damping element)
Turbine-control actuator limit setting
5.1.7.3 Signal injection

A specified quantity (typically two) of analog inputs may be specified for purposes of external live-signal
injection for test purposes. The bandwidth of the analog inputs should be a minimum of 10 Hz. It should be
possible to sum the injected signal at various user-selectable points inside the governor controller. Typical
injection points include the following:
Speed-error summing point
Active-power summing point (if applicable)
5.2 Governor and auxiliary functions

5.2.1 Governor control
5.2.1.1 Speed error
Measurement of turbine speed is a basic requirement of a speed-governing system. The governors specified
in accordance with this recommended practice should measure the speed of turbine rotation and compare
this measured speed with the governor speed reference to produce a speed error. The speed error is used to
develop a controlling output to the turbine-control devices according to the chosen governor-control
strategy in order to regulate the speed and power output of the hydraulic turbine/generator to satisfy the
specified performance criteria.
NOTEThe term speed reference is also commonly known as a speed changer or speed set point. 5
5.2.1.2 Governor-control strategy

A governor-control strategy is a basic requirement of a speed-governing system. A governor-control
strategy may be specified in accordance with the anticipated performance requirements of the installation.
The strategy consists of processing the speed error signal (see 5.2.1.1), applying speed droop and finally
Notes in text, tables, and figures of a standard are given for information only and do not contain requirements needed to implement
this standard.
7
IEEE Std 125-2007

applying a suitable damping scheme, which is used to control the turbine-control actuator(s). The strategy
may include switching between different control modes (see 5.2.3).
Some common damping strategies are:
Temporary dropp controller
Proportional, integral, derivative (PID) controller
Double derivative controller
Lead/lag controller
For details regarding damping and control strategies, see Agee et al. [B1] and Eilts et al. [B6] in Annex A
and IEEE Std 1207.
Some manufacturers may offer only one of the above damping strategies whereas others many offer more
than one strategy. Specifying one particular damping strategy may reduce the competitiveness of the
tendering process.
5.2.2 Speed droop
Speed droop is a basic characteristic of a speed-governing system. The speed droop for the governorcontrol system should be adjustable over the range specified for the application. This adjustment should be
adjustable at the governor-control cabinet, and it may be specified to be adjustable from a remote location.
The range adjustability is typically 0 to 10%
The speed droop parameter may be derived by control actuator position feedback (historically referred to as
simply speed droop), in terms of active power feedback (historically referred to as speed regulation or
sometimes power droop), or in terms of flow feedback. For the remainder of this recommended practice,
the historical terms will be dropped in favor of the following more precise terms:
Speed droop-position (speed droop derived via position feedback)
Speed droop-power (speed droop derived via power feedback)
Speed droop-flow (speed droop derived via flow feedback)
5.2.3 Control modes

5.2.3.1 Position control
For projects where position control is required, the governor should compare the measured to the desired
turbine-control actuator position, multiply this error signal by the droop parameter, and inject the resultant
signal into a summing point to adjust the turbine-control actuator(s) accordingly. The measured position
typically comes from an analog or digital actuator position-measuring transducer.
5.2.3.2 Power control
For projects where power control is required, the governor should compare the measured to the desired
power, multiply this error signal by the droop parameter, and inject the resultant signal into a summing
point to adjust the turbine-control actuator(s) accordingly. The measured power typically comes from watt
8
IEEE Std 125-2007

transducers. The user should specify what automatic actions the governor will take if the power signal is
lost.
NOTEAn alternate method of achieving power control is to implement position control via an inner loop and apply
the power error signal to an outer loop.
5.2.3.3 Flow control

For projects where flow control is required, the governor should compare the measured to the desired flow,
multiply this error signal by the droop parameter, and inject the resultant signal into a summing point to
adjust the turbine-control actuator(s) accordingly. The measured flow typically comes from flow meters or
from a look-up table that uses total head along with either wicket gate position or power output to
determine the actual flow. The user should specify what automatic actions the governor will take if the flow
signal is lost.
NOTEAn alternate method of achieving flow control is to implement position control via an inner loop and apply the
flow error signal to an outer loop.
5.2.3.4 Head pond and tail pond control

For projects where head pond or tail pond level control is required, the governor controller should compare
the measured pond level to the desired pond and inject this error signal into a summing point to adjust the
turbine-control actuator(a) accordingly. The control process should take into account the physical layout of
the water system and time delays due to water passage. Due to the critical nature of the feedback from the
pond, care should be taken to ensure the reliability of the pond level signal. The user should specify what
automatic actions the governor will take if the pond level signal is lost.
5.2.3.5 Pumped storage
A pumped storage facility has additional requirements that should be accurately described in the
specification. The following is a list of some of the items that may be required:
A means of manually controlling gate position while in pump mode
Gate control actuator positioning as a function of operating head
Separate control acutator velocity adjustments for pumping operation
For further details of pumped storage controls, see IEEE Std 1010.
5.2.4 Speed reference
The speed reference should be operator-adjustable over the range specified for the application. Typically,
the specified range is from 85% of rated speed at no load and zero speed droop to 110% rated speed at
maximum control actuator position/power and maximum speed droop. If remote control of the speed
reference is required, the time to change the power output setting from maximum to zero or vice versa
should be specified. An adjustment range of 20 s to 60 s is typical.
9
IEEE Std 125-2007

5.2.5 Control actuator limit

The governor-control system should provide a means of limiting the maximum allowable position of the
turbine-control actuators, which should be adjustable from zero to full control actuator stroke. The control
actuator limit should also be adjustable from a remote location. The provision of an adjustable minimum
control actuator position limit may also be specified. The minimum control actuator position limit may be
activated or de-activated under certain specified operating conditions such as overspeed, operating with the
unit circuit breaker open or while in synchronous condenser mode.
5.2.6 Control actuator velocity or time adjustment
A control actuator velocity adjustment should be provided. Both the maximum opening and closing
velocities of the turbine-control actuator should be independently adjustable. Typically, these maximum
velocities are expressed in control actuator full stroke operating times. The method of operation should be
such that operation of any control, automatic device, or auxiliary device should be able to move the turbinecontrol actuator at a velocity no greater than that set by these adjustments. The method of adjustment
should be specified and should be secure, thereby minimizing the chance of accidental misadjustment.
Typical methods include adjustable distributing valve stop nuts, flow restricting orifices and flow control
valves.
The opening and closing travel times should be specified and are normally dictated by the permissible
water-hammer effect in the water conduit and the permissible overspeed following load rejection. The
closing time may also be dictated by the possibility of draft tube water column separation. The opening
time may also be dictated by the possibility of surge tank (or surge shaft) air entrainment.
5.2.7 Control actuator position feedback
Control actuator position feedback is a basic requirement of a speed-governing system. The position
feedback system is used to transmit the position of the turbine-control actuators to the governor-control
system. The response time of the position feedback system should be compatible with the governor
performance requirements as specified in Clause 6. The accuracy and resolution of the position feedback
system should be specified and should be guaranteed over the operating temperature range specified in
5.11.1. Values of 0.1% for accuracy and 0.02% for resolution have been found through experience to
provide acceptable performance.
The position feedback system should be designed such that any failure in the mechanism will cause the
turbine-control actuators to respond in the manner specified (for example, force the turbine-control device
to fully close).
5.2.8 Speed-sensing source
Speed sensing is a basic requirement of a speed-governing system. The range and response time of the
speed-sensing source should be compatible with the governor performance requirements (as specified in
Clause 6) and as required for the adjustment range of the speed switches. The accuracy and resolution of
the speed-sensing source should be specified and should be guaranteed over the operating temperature
range specified in 5.11.1. Values of 0.03% for accuracy and 0.003% for resolution have been found through
experience to provide acceptable performance.
Two common approaches to measuring turbine speed are the measurement of the generator output
frequency (via voltage transformers for synchronous generators) and speed-measuring devices either
coupled to or surrounding the turbine shaft or to the upper end of the generator shaft [for example, toothed
wheels using proximity pickups or optical photoelectric sensors or permanent magnet generator (PMG)].
10
IEEE Std 125-2007

Any speed-measuring device that is coupled to a shaft should be capable of withstanding, without damage,
a specified overspeed condition for the turbine.
If the turbine speed is measured via the frequency of the generators voltage transformer output, the speedmeasuring circuitry should be of sufficient sensitivity to measure the turbine speed down to a specified
minimum speed, relying only upon residual voltage output from the generator (i.e., without field excitation
applied). Appropriate filtering should also be included as part of the generator frequency measurement
system to prevent false speed measurements from being computed from high frequency transients that may
appear on the generators voltage transformer, either during off-line or grid-connected operation.
5.2.9 Manual control
The governor-control system should provide a means for controlling the turbine-control actuators manually.
When manual control is selected, the control of the turbine-control actuators should respond only to the
position set-point command, without any response from the turbine speed or generation level. Transfer
between normal governor control and manual control should be accomplished smoothly, without a
disturbance in the turbine-control actuator position. It should be possible to move the turbine-control
actuators through full stroke in both directions in not more than the maximum time and in not less than the
minimum time specified.
If required, a governor in manual indication circuit may be provided to the purchasers protection system
to force a shutdown if the turbine is being operated outside the normal governing speed range (i.e., above
approximately 105% speed).
5.2.10 Automatic shutdown
The governor-control system should provide the capability of one or more turbine-generator shutdown
sequences upon the occurrence of specified operator actions or system occurrences.
An emergency shutdown sequence should be provided. Emergency shutdown should initiate

immediate turbine shutdown and immediate opening of the generator breaker.
A quick shutdown sequence may be provided. Quick shutdown should initiate immediate turbine
shutdown and open the generator breaker at speed-no-load.
A partial shutdown sequence may be provided. Partial shutdown should initiate rapid closing of the
turbine-control actuator to the speed-no-load condition.
Typical shutdown sequence initiations are detailed in 5.2.11 and 5.2.15.

5.2.11 Emergency stop
Provisions for manual emergency stopping of the turbine should be provided. A common arrangement is to
provide an emergency stop pushbutton at the governor cabinet and possibly at one or more other locations
inside the powerhouse.
A common arrangement is to connect each pushbutton to the purchasers protection equipment. The
protection system should stop the turbine-generator unit by either the emergency shutdown sequence or the
quick shutdown sequence (see 5.2.10).
11
IEEE Std 125-2007

5.2.12 Generator braking system

Manual and automatic brake control may be specified. Automatic operation of the generator brake valve
should only be allowed when the turbine-control actuator is fully closed and the turbine speed has
decreased below a specified speed. The generator brake control should apply the brakes
(continuously/intermittently) until the turbine has come to a complete stop.
An automatic control valve, with provisions for emergency hand operation, should be provided for
controlling the operation of the generator braking system. The automatic control valve should be an
energized to apply circuit and should have power provided by dc (or battery backed ac). The emergency
hand operation of the generator brake control should allow latching the brakes in their applied position.
5.2.13 Set-point feed forward
A set-point feed forward function should be provided. This feature provides a faster response to set-point
(for example, power reference) changes while allowing governor gains to be independently tuned for stable
operation.
5.2.14 Switches
All switches should have electrically-separate contact circuits. The form of the contacts should be form A,
form B, or form C in accordance with the specifiers specifications. The contact circuits should be suitable
for continuous duty over a specified range of ac or dc voltages (as required by the specifier), and should be
capable of interrupting non-inductive circuits at an amperage level as required by the specifier (alternately
inductive circuits with specified L/R ratio and amperage). When specified to be readily adjustable, a device
should be provided with a method of adjustment that does not require special tools. Where ready
accessibility is required, the device should be accessible without the need for removing panels or other
equipment.
5.2.14.1 Overspeed switch
A main overspeed switch should be provided that operates at a specified percent of rated turbine speed, and
resets at not less than 105% of rated turbine speed. This main overspeed switch may be implemented in a
speed switch subsystem that is independent from the main governor-control system. The main overspeed
switch may either be mechanically driven from the turbine shaft, or it may be electrically operated by an
independent or redundant speed-sensing system. Alternatively, a mechanically-driven hydraulic shutdown
system may be specified.
5.2.14.2 Speed switch
A specified number of electrical speed switches should be provided that operate and reset at specified
turbine speeds. The operate and reset speeds for each speed switch should be independently adjustable,
and all speed switches should be independently adjustable. Speed switches may be mechanically driven or
electrically operated by a speed-sensing system. Some typical speed switches are:
Generator brake application control
Excitation system starting and stopping control
Thrust bearing lift pump starting and stopping control
12
IEEE Std 125-2007

5.2.14.3 Turbine-control actuator position switch

The specifier may require a number of electrical contacts that operate at specified turbine-control actuator
positions, such as fully closed, synchronous no-load position, or fully open. These control actuator position
contacts may be specified to be driven from the control actuator position transducer used by the governor
controller, or they may be specified as separate, mechanically-driven switch assemblies. Each control
actuator position switch should be readily adjustable to operate at any desired position throughout the full
range of control actuator travel. Individual switch adjustments should be readily accessible.
5.2.14.4 Hydraulic pressure supply system switch
Adjustable switches to indicate specific oil pressures, oil levels, and oil temperatures within the HPSS
should be specified. Switches may be either individual devices (for example, pressure switch) or contact
outputs from the governor controller, driven by appropriate transducers. The specifier's preference (if any)
should be indicated.
5.2.14.5 Brake supply pressure switch
The specifier may require provision of an electrical contact to indicate when the pressure supply for the
generator brake is below normal pressure. The specifier should further specify if a separate pressure switch
is required, or if contact outputs from the governor controller, driven by a pressure transducer, are
acceptable.
5.2.14.6 Turbine-control actuator limit coincidence switch
The specifier may specify provision of an electrical contact or alarm to indicate when the turbine-control
actuator equals the control actuator position limit setting. This contact may be used to block raise
commands from affecting the governor set point, thus preventing windup of the governor set point
beyond a level where the governor is able to respond.
5.2.15 Turbine shutdowns
A safe and orderly shutdown of the turbine should be executed for specified conditions. The following is a
typical list of conditions requiring shutdown:
Failure of the governor controllers main CPU
Failure of all power supplies
Failure of all speed signals
Failure of main control actuator (gate or deflector) position transducer
Failure of nozzle control actuator position transducer (impulse turbines only)
Failure of blade control actuator position transducer (adjustable-blade turbines only)
Nozzle control actuator position mismatch (impulse turbines with two or more nozzles only)
Oil temperature critical high
Sump oil level critical low
Oil pressure critical low
13
IEEE Std 125-2007

Accumulator oil level critical high
Accumulator oil level critical low
Overspeed
Electrical and mechanical protection systems external to the governor
5.3 Other optional functions

5.3.1 Rotor creep detection
A rotor creep detecting function may be provided to give an alarm and to initiate protective control action
when, upon braking, the rotor of the generator does not come to a complete stop after a suitable time delay,
or after having come to a complete stop begins to creep due to brake failure or excessive water leakage, or
both. Upon activation, the creep detection function should sense a subsequent angular displacement of 3 of
arc or less, without reference to rate of movement. The creep detection system should be immune to
turbine-generator unit vibration. It should respond to the creep condition by activating its output and
sealing-in until reset by external circuitry. The action upon creep detection will depend on both user
practices and the design features of the turbine and turbine-generator bearings. Typical actions include one
or more of the following:
Automatic turbine-generator unit start-up
Release generator air brakes and start lift pump
Opening cooling water valve
Alarm
5.3.2 Deadstop detection

A deadstop sensing function may be provided for indication to an operator that the turbine has reached a
deadstop condition. Other possible uses of the deadstop sensing function may include the following:
Alarm if the turbine should fail to reach a deadstop condition within a preset time
Automatic shutoff of turbine-generator unit auxiliaries such as a lift pump
Arming the creep detector
5.3.3 Fire protection system

The specifier may specify the provision of an automatic fire protection system within the governor-control
cabinet or the HPSS. The automatic fire protection system may include specified sensors, discharge
equipment, and control/alarm system components. The specifier should further specify the applicable
standards to which the automatic fire protection system is to be designed, including any requirements
imposed by insurers and fire regulations or codes. The design of the system should be coordinated with
other fire protection equipment located in the powerhouse.
14
IEEE Std 125-2007

5.3.4 Turbine-control actuator timing function

A turbine-control actuator timing function may be provided to assist with calibration of the turbine-control
actuator velocity limiting device or devices. The timing function should calculate the time it takes for the
turbine-control actuator to travel from a preset starting position to a preset end position. The start and end
positions should be user-adjustable. The timing function should be operational with the turbine running (for
example, load rejection) or during penstock de-watered conditions.
5.3.5 Intelligent alarms
The user may wish to specify one or more intelligent alarms. Intelligent alarms in this context are defined
as any alarm that requires some degree of mathematical computation (either simple or complex) in order to
determine if an abnormal condition exists. Examples of intelligent alarms include the following:
Position mismatch between nozzle servomotor positions (impulse turbine) as a method of detecting
sticking nozzles.
Failure of turbine-control actuator feedback to track turbine-control actuator set point.
Excessive HPSS pump operation or excessive pump operating time.
Abnormal startup or abnormal shutdown time.
Isolated operation detection.
Servomotor pressure unbalance as a method of detecting sticking shift ring (Francis turbine
equipped with two or more control actuators). Requires a pressure transducer on each control
actuator.
Value plausibility test, if a value changes faster than theoretically possible.
5.3.6 Fast breakaway

A fast start-up feature may be specified for the purpose of accelerating the turbine at a faster than normal
start-up rate. This feature may be used when starting the turbine while the thrust bearing oil lift pump is out
of service so as to avoid damage to the thrust bearing.
5.3.7 Isolated operation control
An isolated operation on/off control may be specified for the purpose of operating the turbine-generator
unit isolated from the grid. The isolated control may be a manually operated on/off control. Alternately,
there may be an isolation detector that automatically places the governor into isolated mode. When in
isolated mode, a separate set of gains may be applied and the set-point feed forward (if equipped) should be
disabled.
5.3.8 Automatic synchronizing
For the purpose of aiding automatic synchronizing, an automatic speed matching feature may be specified.
In addition, automatic voltage-matching and breaker synchronous closing features may be supplied. The
speed-matching function is typically accomplished by substituting the governors normal speed reference
with an external speed reference. The external speed reference is typically derived from a switchyard
voltage transformer.
15
IEEE Std 125-2007

The voltage-matching function is typically accomplished by computing an error voltage by subtracting

voltages on opposite sides of the open unit circuit breaker. The error signal is used to produce voltage raise
and lower pulses which are sent to the exciter.
The synchronous closing function is typically derived by phase angle comparison of the voltages on
opposite sides of the open unit circuit breaker. Compensation for breaker closing delay should be specified.
5.3.9 Efficiency optimization
Turbine efficiency optimization may be specified for adjustable-blade units. The efficiency optimization
function should monitor the operating head, the generated power, and the flow through the turbine while
manipulating the operating gate/blade relationship. When the optimum efficiency for the turbine is
achieved, the adjustments to the gate/blade relationship should be stored and utilized by the governor for all
future operation of the turbine in the operating region that was optimized.
5.3.10 Trending
The specifier may require a trending feature for purposes of recording and displaying trends of specified
variables as a function of time. All required variables (for example, gate position, speed, etc.), the sampling
rate, the minimum trend record length, and the minimum quantity of stored records should be specified.
5.4 Hydraulic pressure supply system

Except for turbine-control devices which are electric-motor driven, an HPSS is a basic requirement for a
speed-governing system. The HPSS provides the hydraulic pressure used to operate the turbine-control
actuators. The HPSS comprises the pressure pumps, the pressure pump motors and starters, the pressure
accumulator tank, the sump tank, the automatic gas admission system (if used), and the associated controls,
hydraulic piping, and fittings.
5.4.1.1 Pressure pumps and unloaders
The pressure pumps, unless otherwise specified, should be motor-driven, direct-connected positive
displacement-type pumps. A pressure relief valve should be provided at the discharge side of each pressure
pump that is capable of passing the full delivery flow of the pump to the sump tank when the discharge
pressure of the pump exceeds 110% of the nominal system pressure. For critical turbine-generator units
(see 5.7 for definition), two main pressure pumps should be provided as part of the HPSS. For non-critical
turbine-generator units, a single main pressure pump may suffice. The combined flow capacity of the
pressure pumps should be not less than 25% of the flow required by all of the turbine-control actuators
combined when traveling at their maximum achievable rate (20% for impulse turbines with a deflector time
of less than 2.5 s). A larger flow capacity may be required if the plant is expected to run isolated from the
grid. If a continuously-running makeup pump (also known as a jockey pump) is provided as part of the
HPSS, the flow of this makeup pump may be included in the combined flow capacity of the pressure pumps
when evaluating the pumping capacity of the system. The flow output of the makeup pump, if provided,
should be sufficient to supply the steady-state oil consumption of the turbine governing system such that
the main pressure pumps will not be required to start during steady-state operation of the turbine. Makeup
pumps are most commonly provided on large turbines.
Each pump driven by a motor rated at 7.5 kW or larger should be provided with an unloader valve which
returns oil directly to the sump when in the unloaded state. Starting and stopping of the pumps should be in
the unloaded condition, thus minimizing the backpressure loading to the pump discharge. All transitions
between loaded and unloaded operation of the pump should be timed such that the transition occurs
16
IEEE Std 125-2007

smoothly in both directions, without any significant impulse loading upon the pump or motor. As an
alternative to an unloader valve, each pump may be equipped with a soft start motor starter (for example,
reduced voltage starter, variable frequency drive) or a pressure-compensated (variable positive
displacement) pump.
5.4.2 Pressure pump motors and starters
All requirements for electric motors, motor starters, and related equipment should be specified. As a
minimum, the supply voltage available for powering the HPSS should be specified. All electric motors and
auxiliary equipment should be capable of withstanding, without damage, expected overvoltage and
overfrequency conditions under the following conditions:
Maximum load rejection of the turbine-generator unit
Sustained operation of the station, isolated from the interconnected power system
5.4.3 Pump controls

The pump(s) should start automatically when a specified physical quantity (typically pressure) reaches a
preset value. Where two main pumps are specified, they should be configured in a lead/lag control strategy.
For a pressure-actuated design, the lead pump should start when the system pressure drops to
approximately 90% of the nominal system pressure, and stop when the system pressure reaches the nominal
system pressure. The lag pump should start when the system pressure drops to approximately 85% of the
nominal system pressure, and stop when the system pressure reaches the nominal system pressure.
Provision should be made for pump shutdown under conditions of either high oil temperature or low sump
oil level.
Provision should be made for selecting either of the pumps to operate as the lead pump.
The pump control(s) should be designed to automatically restart the pumps after a temporary loss of power.
5.4.4 Motor protection
The pump motors will require branch circuit over-current protection and motor overload protection. Details
should be specified and should be in accordance with electrical codes and regulations. Other motor
protection functions such as phase reversal, open phase, phase unbalance, and undervoltage may be
specified.
5.4.5 Pump control modes
Each pump should have a control to select its mode of operation. The modes of operation available should
be as follows:
Off. In the Off mode, the pump is prevented from running.
Auto. In the Auto mode, the pump will automatically start and stop as a function of the system
pressure and its lead/lag control selection.
Continuous. In the Continuous mode, the pump will run continuously, loading and unloading as a
function of a specified variable (typically pressure) and its lead/lag control selection.
17
IEEE Std 125-2007

5.4.6 Black start

If the turbine-generator unit is required to have black start capability, a pump supplied by uninterruptible
power (battery backed dc or ac) may be specified to be able to build hydraulic pressure sufficient to start
the turbine-generator unit during a black start condition. This pump should have sufficient pumping
capacity to build the hydraulic pressure up to its nominal system pressure in an acceptable period of time to
meet the needs of the black start requirement. Once ac station service has been established, the
uninterruptible power pump should be shut down, and the ac-powered pumps should resume normal
operation.
5.4.7 HPSS operation on turbine shutdown
Generally, the HPSS runs continuously, maintaining the hydraulic pressure within its normal operating
range. This assures that pressure is available to maintain a safe operating and shutdown condition. If the
turbine has a fail-safe shutdown device, such as an inlet valve, the HPSS may be shut down after the
turbine reaches deadstop and the inlet valve is fully closed. This type of operation reduces the energy
consumed by the HPSS, but it also introduces a delay time when starting the turbine-generator unit.
5.4.8 Pressure accumulator tank design
The pressure accumulator tanks should be of welded construction, designed, built, and tested in accordance
with the appropriate pressure vessel code (see Annex A for ASME and IEC pressure vessel codes) that is in
effect at the time of preparing the specifications for the system to be designed. The supplier of the pressure
accumulator tanks should be responsible for obtaining certification of the pressure accumulator tank by the
authority of jurisdiction at the site of the installation. The authority of jurisdiction should be specified. If
the requirements of the authority of jurisdiction are more stringent than the pressure vessel code, then the
authoritys requirements shall take precedence.
The pressure accumulator tanks should be supplied with a suitable pressure indication and pressure relief
valve.
For gas-over-oil pressure accumulators, a float valve or other positive means of preventing the cushioning
gas from entering the hydraulic piping system should be provided as part of the pressure accumulator tank.
Appropriately-sized access doors should be provided on the pressure accumulator tank for the purposes of
inspecting and cleaning the tank. A tank liquid level indication should be provided.
For transfer barrier accumulator tanks, an anti-extrusion valve should be provided at the bottom of each
tank to prevent the barrier from being extruded into the oil port when the barrier has bottomed out. Transfer
barrier accumulator tanks include bladder accumulators and piston accumulators.
5.4.9 Pressure accumulator tank sizing
The pressure accumulator tank should be designed such that the hydraulic supply pressure remains above
the maximum servomotor differential pressure of the turbine-control actuators at all times when the oil
level within the pressure accumulator tank is above the active oil cut-off level (above the float valve closure
level in a gas over oil accumulator or bottoming out of the transfer barrier in a transfer barrier accumulator
tank).
The pressure accumulator tank should be designed to meet a number of criteria, as detailed in the following
list.
18
IEEE Std 125-2007

a)
Stroke criteria. The pressure accumulator tank should provide a specified minimum number of full
strokes (closing direction) of the turbine-control servomotors, commencing at the turbine shutdown
pressure, and without any pumps running, before reaching the oil cutoff level. Some common
specifications are:
1)
For a gas-over-oil or piston accumulator, the pressure accumulator tank should provide
1.5 servomotor volumes of oil under these conditions (for a single-regulated turbine), or
1.5 wicket gate servomotor volumes plus one blade servomotor volume in the shutdown
direction (for an adjustable-blade turbine), or 1.5 deflector servomotor volumes plus one
combined closing nozzle servomotor volume (for an impulse turbine).
2)
For a bladder barrier accumulator, the pressure accumulator tank should provide
2.0 servomotor volumes of oil under these conditions (for a single-regulated turbine), or
2.0 wicket gate servomotor volumes plus one blade servomotor volume in the shutdown
direction (for an adjustable-blade turbine), or 2.0 deflector servomotor volumes plus one
combined closing nozzle servomotor volume (for an impulse turbine).
NOTEAll accumulators follow a polytropic gas law as the gas expands during maximum servomotor velocity
conditions. The gas law exponent for bladder barrier accumulators tends to be a higher value than for gas-over-oil
accumulators. This is due to the thermal insulating effects of the bladder. For this reason, the classic 1.5 servomotor
volume criteria may be insufficient for bladder barrier accumulators.
b)
Minimum pressure criteria. The pressure accumulator tank should provide a specified minimum
pressure at the active oil cut-off level. A typical value for the minimum pressure is 75% of nominal
pressure (where nominal refers to the pump stop pressure) or 15% above the maximum servomotor
differential pressure of the turbine-control actuators, whichever is higher.
c)
Pump cycle time criteria. The pressure accumulator tanks system should be designed such that the
minimum pump cycle time is greater than a specified value when the governor is controlling in
steady-state operation. A value of at least 10 min is recommended. In no event should the number
of pump starts per hour exceed the pump motor rating.
NOTE 1Pump cycle times are generally a limiting factor with high-pressure systems, where the total control actuator
volume is smaller, and the steady-state oil consumption is higher. Pump cycle times may also be a limiting factor with
dual-regulated turbines, due to expected higher oil consumption rates resulting from the greater quantity of valves and
the oil head leakage on adjustable-blade turbines.
NOTE 2The pump cycle time criteria do not apply to an HPSS equipped with a continuously operating makeup
(jockey) pump.
IEEE Std 1207 may be consulted for additional details.

5.4.10 Sump tank
The sump tank should be of cast or welded construction and provided with fine mesh screen strainers that
are readily accessible for cleaning. The size of the mesh strainer should be specified. An oil level indicator
should be incorporated into the design of the sump tank. The sump tank volume should not be less than
110% of the total volume of hydraulic fluid that can be returned to the sump tank by system pressure and
by gravity. Necessary access doors should be provided for the purposes of cleaning and inspection. The
sump tank should be designed to provide an adequately long return path of the hydraulic fluid from the
control valve return to the pressure pump inlet to allow the release of entrained gas before reaching the
pressure pump. This is particularly important in high-pressure systems (typically 2.5 MPa and above) using
air-over-oil gas cushion in the pressure accumulator tank, where blackening of the hydraulic oil can occur
as a result of compression-induced combustion of the oil with the entrained air.
19
IEEE Std 125-2007

5.4.11 Oil cleanliness control

The HPSS should include a system for continuously maintaining the cleanliness of the hydraulic fluid. A
typical approach is to use a continuously running kidney-loop filtering system. Kidney-loop pumps are
typically low pressure recirculating pumps. Alternatively, a high pressure makeup (jockey) pump may be
used for continuous oil filtration purposes (for systems so equipped).
Indication, either a mechanical indicator or an electrical contact, should be provided to alert personnel
when it is time to change the filtering element.
5.4.12 Oil temperature control
An oil temperature control system may be incorporated into the HPSS to maintain a minimum oil
temperature which is typically the higher of 40 C or 5 C. above ambient. Oil heating provides benefits of
minimizing sump condensation, providing consistent performance (for example, deadband, control actuator
velocity limits) and enhancing trapped air (or gas) release. The latter is particularly important in highpressure systems using air-over-oil gas cushion in the pressure accumulator tank, where blackening of the
hydraulic oil can occur as a result of compression-induced combustion of the oil with the entrained air.
Either thermostatically-controlled electrical heaters or low-intensity heating by a continuously running
pump discharging through a restriction may be used to accomplish the oil warming. If electrical heaters are
specified, they should be a low intensity design to avoid hot spot induced oil blackening.
5.4.13 Automatic gas admission system
An automatic gas admission system may be specified to automatically maintain the proper fluid-to-gas ratio
within a gas-over-oil type of pressure accumulator tank. The automatic gas admission system should be
complete, with the necessary compressed gas supply system, piping, pressure sensors, and level sensors.
Typically, either compressed air or compressed nitrogen is used to provide the gas-over-oil cushion within
the pressure accumulator tank.
Typically, the automatic gas admission cycle should be initiated when the pressure accumulator oil level
reaches a specified level above its normal level at the nominal system pressure. Proper interlocks should be
provided to assure that the compressed gas supply pressure is sufficient to guarantee that gas will be
admitted to, rather than drained from, the pressure accumulator tank. The automatic gas admission cycle
should terminate when the relationship between the hydraulic pressure and the oil level in the pressure
accumulator tank is within normal limits.
5.4.14 Pipings and fittings
All piping and tubing should be suitable for use over a temperature range of 30 C to +65 C. Piping
should conform to the edition in effect at the time of system specification of ANSI/ASME Std B31.1-1986
[B3], or other international standard. All joints should be of the bolted, flanged type. Threaded pipe should
not be used in new installations due to concerns with oil leakage. Threaded pipe should be used only where
necessary in governor replacement or conversion applications. Piping should be cleaned inside and out to
remove mill scale. For adjustable-blade turbines, provision should be made to prevent the flow of electric
currents within the piping to the runner blade control actuator.
Tubing should be hydraulic-line seamless tubing conforming to the edition in effect at the time of system
specification of ANSI Std B93.11M-1981 [B4] or other international standard. Tubing fittings should be of
a leak-resistant design suitable for an industrial environment. The following types of fittings have been
used successfully:
20
IEEE Std 125-2007

Flare-less sleeve fittings
O-Ring face seal braze-on fittings
37 flare-less fittings
If required by the purchaser, piping and tubing joints should be certified by the authority of jurisdiction at
the site of the installation.
Flexible hoses should be limited to locations where it is required for purposes of vibration isolation or to
absorb component movement. Flexible hoses should be kept as short as practical. Instances where flexible
hosing is acceptable include the following:
Connections to the HPSS pumps
Final connections to the actuator control actuators
The total pressure drop along the piping (or tubing) from the distributing valve to the turbine-control
actuators and back should be no more than 8% of nominal system pressure with the control actuator
traveling at its maximum velocity limits.
For adjustable-blade turbines, a bypass line may be installed across the blade control actuator open-andclose lines and as close as practical to the oil head. This may be required to prevent a vacuum being drawn
into one of the lines when the servomotor is squeezed at either the fully open or fully closed position.
5.4.15 Filtration of trapped oil
In some cases, the volume of oil in the piping (or tubing) from the distributing valve to the turbine-control
actuators and back may be greater than the combined volume of all turbine-control actuators. As a result, a
portion of this oil will not return to the HPSS for filtration. The following methods may be used to
overcome this problem:
Locate the distributing valve as close as possible to the turbine-control actuators.
Decrease the piping (or tubing) diameter, subject to the piping pressure drop criteria in 5.4.14.
Install a bypass line, with orifice, between the control actuator open and close lines. The orifice size
should allow a flow of one pipe volume every 20 min to 60 min, subject to the pump cycle time
restrictions detailed in item c) of 5.4.9.
Install a bypass line, with manually operated valve, between the control actuator open and close
lines.
Install a bypass line, with solenoid operated valve, between the control actuator open and close
lines. The valve may be cycled by the controller using a low duty cycle.
5.5 New installation considerations

5.5.1 Hydraulic pressure supply system (HPSS)
For installations of new HPSSs for new turbine/generator installations, the manufacturer should coordinate
the design of the HPSS with the design of the turbine and generator. Some key areas to address include the
following:
21
IEEE Std 125-2007

Nominal hydraulic supply pressure
Turbine-control actuator dimensions
Maximum loading of the turbine-control actuator
Maximum rate of travel of the turbine-control actuator
Adjustment range for rate of travel of the turbine-control actuator
5.5.2 Governor
For installations of new governor-control systems for new turbine/generator installations, the governor
manufacturer should coordinate the design of the governor-control system with the design of the turbine
and generator. Some key areas to address include the following:
Rated turbine speed
Method of speed sensing
Method of overspeed detection
Method of turbine-control actuator position sensing
Rotating inertia of the turbine/generator combination
Inertia of the water column, both upstream and downstream of the turbine
5.6 Replacement and conversion considerations

For existing turbine/generator installations, the purchaser may choose to replace the governor or implement
a digital conversion. In addition, the HPSS may be replaced. Replacement or conversion decisions are
typically based on the following considerations:
Lack of spare parts
Reduced maintenance associated with newer technology components
Enhanced performance
To take advantage of the economic or environmental benefits of a higher pressure system
IEEE Std 1147 may be consulted for additional details.

5.6.1 Hydraulic pressure supply system (HPSS)
For installations of new HPSSs for existing turbine/generator installations, some key areas to address
include the following:
Evaluation of the condition of the existing turbine-control actuators and piping
Full-stroke dimension of all existing turbine-control actuators
Diameter of all existing control actuator pistons and piston rods if control actuators are to be
replaced
Maximum loading of the turbine-control actuators (may require a differential pressure test)
Evaluation of environmental considerations of the total volume of oil in the HPSS

22
IEEE Std 125-2007

5.6.2 Governor
For conversions or installations of new governor-control systems for existing turbine/generator
installations, some key areas to address include the following:
Evaluation of the condition of the existing HPSS
Evaluation of the condition of the existing governor distributing valve
Other items listed in 5.6.1
5.7 Redundancy
Critical turbine-generator units typically require a higher degree of component redundancy in order to
achieve high unit availability or to ensure an automatic shutdown in the event of a component failure.
Cases where this may be required are large turbine-generator units with a high commercial value, single
unit plants, run-ofthe-river plants, plants with environmental sensitivities, or plants with fishery
considerations.
The amount of component redundancy should be specified. The following is a list of components that may
be specified to be redundant:
Power supplies
Speed switches
Overspeed switch
Gate or deflector position switches
Protection functions (for example, HPSS low pressure shutdown)
Digital controller main processor module
Digital controller input/output modules
Sensors (for example, speed, pressure, control actuator position)
Electro-hydraulic valves including shutdown valve
HPSS pumps, motors, unloaders
5.8 Failsafe features

A variety of failsafe features should be specified. Some commonly specified features are detailed in 5.8.1,
5.8.2, 5.8.3, and 5.8.4.
5.8.1 Shutdown solenoid valve
A shutdown solenoid valve should be provided. When de-energized, the solenoid should hydraulically
force all control actuators to their failsafe position, irrespective of the governor controllers electrical
command signals. Typically, the design will force control actuator closure when the solenoid is electrically
de-energized. The shutdown solenoid should be powered from an uninterruptible source (battery backed dc
or ac).
23
IEEE Std 125-2007

5.8.2 Actuator lock

An automatic locking feature may be provided to freeze the turbine-control actuator in its last position upon
failure of certain control signals, such as speed sensing or power sensing. This locking feature should allow
closure of the turbine-control actuator via a normal or protective shutdown of the turbine-generator unit.
5.8.3 Open circuit detection
An alarm may be raised in the event of an open circuit condition on any analog input, any analog output, or
both. The alarm should clearly identify exactly which input or output is open circuited. A shutdown may be
generated for inputs or outputs deemed to be critical.
5.8.4 Power transducer failure
Failure of the power transducer, for governors so equipped, should transfer the governor to position control
mode. An alarm should be raised. See Annex C for a typical logic implementation.
5.9 Dual-regulated turbines

Dual-regulated turbines include adjustable-blade turbines and impulse turbines.
5.9.1 Adjustable-blade turbines
Adjustable-blade turbines include separate control actuators to control both the wicket gates and the runner
blades. Governor-control systems for adjustable-blade turbines include two governor-control valves, one
for the wicket gate control actuator control and one for the runner blade control actuator control.
5.9.1.1 Blade control
In order to achieve maximum operating efficiency of an adjustable-blade turbine, along with minimum
cavitation damage and possibly maximum fish survivability, the runner blade angle should be positioned as
a three-dimensional function of the wicket gate position and the operating head of the turbine. The
governor manufacturer should make provisions for updating this blade control relationship based upon
subsequent index testing of the turbine. The governor controller should maintain the steady-state blade
position within 1% of the computed optimal blade position under any operating conditions.
For turbines that experience unusually large hydraulic instabilities, it may be necessary to specify an
intentional delay time (fixed or variable) in the blade control strategy to suppress undesirable blade
movement. Details of the strategy should be specified.
5.9.1.2 Blade locking
The specifier may require a blade locking function to prevent further movement of the blade control
actuator under specified operating conditions. This locking feature may either be implemented within the
governor controller by freezing the blade control actuator position set point, or it may be implemented
using automatic isolating valves in the blade control actuator hydraulic-control piping. Some typical
conditions that activate a blade locking feature include the following:
24
IEEE Std 125-2007

Low hydraulic supply pressure
Blade position switch operation
High or low turbine operating head
Excessive oil head leakage detected
5.9.1.3 Blade tilt

The specifier may require a blade tilt function to tilt the runner blades to a specified adjustable position
under specified operating conditions. A typical application tilts the runner blades to their maximum steep
position (i.e., parallel to the water flow) when a specified overspeed condition is experienced. Tilting the
blades in this manner more rapidly returns the turbine to its normal operating speed. The runner blades
should be returned to their normal operating position at or above the normal rated speed of the turbine.
5.9.1.4 Manual blade control
The specifier may require the capability of manually setting the runner blade position, independently from
the wicket gate position or the operating head level.
5.9.2 Impulse turbines
Impulse turbines incorporate one or more flow-control nozzle control actuators, along with a deflectorcontrol actuator to achieve rapid reduction in power developed by the turbine when required. Governorcontrol systems for impulse turbines include a control valve for the deflector-control actuator control and a
control valve for each flow-controlling nozzle.
Typically, the timing of the flow-controlling nozzles is too slow to achieve acceptable unloading rates
under time-critical operating conditions.
Multiple modes of operation are achievable with an impulse turbine equipped with deflectors, including
water-saving and water-wasting modes of operation. The governor-controller strategy should provide
separate damping adjustments to accommodate the active mode of operation. Additionally, a nozzlesequencing mode of operation may be specified.
5.9.2.1 Water-saving operation
The water-saving mode of operation describes the operation of an impulse turbine when the deflectors are
out of the water stream under steady-state conditions, thus no water is wasted by being deflected away
from the turbine runner. The water-saving mode of operation is typically used when the generator is gridconnected. The governor manufacturer should provide a tunable relationship between the flow-controlling
nozzle position and the deflector position. The purpose of this tunable relationship is to position the
deflectors just outside the water stream during steady-state conditions to minimize the travel time required
to bring the deflectors into the water stream during transient conditions. Under water-saving operation, only
the flow-controlling nozzles will have an effect upon the operation of the turbine (except during overspeed
conditions when the deflectors move into the stream).
5.9.2.2 Water-wasting operation
The water-wasting mode of operation describes the operation of an impulse turbine when the deflectors are
continuously in the water stream, deflecting part of the water flow away from the turbine runner. The
25
IEEE Std 125-2007

water-wasting mode of operation is typically used either to limit the speed of the turbine following a load
rejection, or to achieve better frequency stability when operating isolated from an interconnected power
system. It can also be used for improved frequency control following cold load pick-up if operating
isolated. The amount of load that can be accommodated without an unacceptably large deviation in
generator frequency is determined by how much water the deflectors are diverting away from the turbine
runner. Under water-wasting operation, the controlling action of the deflectors is dominant, and the
controlling action of the flow-controlling nozzles is generally insignificant.
5.9.2.3 Nozzle-sequencing operation
The efficiency of a multiple-nozzle impulse turbine is affected both by its generation level and by the
number of flow-controlling nozzles in service. In certain applications, the efficiency of a multiple-nozzle
impulse turbine can be improved by closing one or more flow-controlling nozzles during low-power
operation. The radial balancing of the water forces upon the turbine guide bearings should be considered if
a nozzle-sequencing operation is specified. The deflector positioning algorithm should be coordinated with
the number of nozzles in service. The transition between different numbers of nozzles in service should be
designed to minimize transients in speed and generation.
During nozzle sequencing operation, the radial balancing forces should be continuously calculated based
upon the positions of all in service nozzles. An alarm should be generated if the radial forces become
unbalanced for a user adjustable time period. In addition, a trip may be specified if the radial forces become
unbalanced for a user adjustable time period.
5.10 Additional governor-controller functions

The functions described in 5.10.1, 5.10.2, 5.10.3, and 5.10.4 were historically provided by hardware
external to the governing system. The flexibility and power of modern digital controls has opened the
possibility of integrating these functions into digital controller based speed-governing systems. Which
functions to integrate will depend upon the users operating and maintenance practices as well as design
philosophy. Careful consideration should be given to failure modes and effects prior to deciding which
functions to integrate. The following clauses apply primarily only to digital controller based governors.
5.10.1 Starting and stopping control of turbine-generator auxiliaries
The specifier may require that starting and stopping of turbine-generator (unit) auxiliaries be under the
control of the governor controller. The sequence of auxiliary device starting and stopping should be
specified. A set of pre-start permissives should be satisfied in order for the operator initiated start-up
command to allow auxiliary device start-up. Each step of the start sequence should be interlocked with the
preceding step. In other words, if a particular step did not successfully complete (for example, an auxiliary
pump fails to start), then the succeeding step should be blocked from starting. Details of the pre-start
permissives and the sequence interlocks should be specified.
In the event that all auxiliaries do not successfully start within a pre-determined time interval, an alarm
should be raised and an orderly shutdown of auxiliaries should be initiated.
Adoption of this additional feature results in significant increases in the input/output hardware and
governor-controller software requirements with subsequent increases in cost and complexity.
In the event of a governor controller failure, it should be possible for the turbine-generator to be shut down
safely by the automatic protection system (supplied by others). Sufficient hardwired circuitry external to
the governor controller should be provided to meet this failsafe requirement.
26
IEEE Std 125-2007

For further details of unit auxiliary start/stop controls, see IEEE Std 1249-1996 [B21] and
IEEE Std 1010.
5.10.2 Draft tube air depression control
Reaction turbines designed to operate in synchronous condenser mode may be equipped with draft tube air
depression capability. The specifier may require control of the air depression equipment (for example, air
valve or valves, blower, cooling water valve, etc.) via the governor controller.
The air depression control sequence should be specified in detail by the specifier. For further details on air
depression controls, see IEEE Std 1010.
5.10.3 Hydraulic pressure supply system (HPSS) control
Specifiers may wish to embed the HPSS pressure pump or gas admission control logic into the governor
controller. Control of the lead and lag pressure pumps should function as described in 5.4.3. Control of the
automatic gas admission device should function as described in 5.4.13.
5.10.4 Turbine pressure regulator valves and bypass valves
If the turbine is equipped with a pressure limiting device, such as a pressure relief valve (PRV),
synchronous bypass valve (SBPV), or similar equipment, the control of these devices may be integrated
into the governor controller. The purpose of the pressure limiting device is to maintain the penstock water
pressure within acceptable upper and lower limits. A PRV is typically operated as a defined function of the
penstock pressure. An SBPV is typically operated as a defined function of primary turbine flow control
device (for example reaction turbine wicket gates) position and velocity. The desired functionality and
failsafe design features of the pressure-limiting device should be fully specified.
To protect the penstock from excessive positive or negative pressures, it is important to ensure that the
PRV (or BPV) position stays synchronized with the primary turbine flow control device. An independent
method of detecting loss of synchronization or penstock pressure or vacuum limits violated may be used to
initiate appropriate failsafe protective action. Typical actions include restricting the wicket gate and PRV
(or BPV) control actuator velocities to safe values (for example, activating throttle valves or restricting
distributing valve spool movement) and hydraulically forcing the control actuators to their failsafe
positions.
During reaction turbine overspeed conditions (for example, load rejection), the flow of water into the
turbine may be reduced as a result of the throttling effect of the turbine blades which are moving at
abnormally high velocity. This throttling effect should be taken into consideration when developing a
strategy for the synchronization of the wicket gates and PRV (or BPV).
5.11 Environmental specifications

5.11.1 Temperature
All solid-state devices and components should be rated for industrial or military grade duty, suitable for
operation at temperatures between 0 C and 55 C.
27
IEEE Std 125-2007

5.11.2 Transient immunity

The governor-control system should be immune from false operation or failure from high voltage, high
frequency transients that may be introduced into the control circuitry and power supplies both internal to
and external from the governor-control system. To reduce the introduction of transient noise into the
governor control circuitry, the governor manufacturer should use properly shielded cable for connection to
external equipment, should use optically- or transformer-isolated amplifiers for signals to and from the
governor-control circuitry, and should assure that properly-rated surge suppression devices are installed on
all inductive devices connected to, or in proximity to, the governor-control equipment. The governorcontrol system should be designed and tested for surge withstand capability in accordance with IEEE or
IEC standards such as IEEE Std C37.90.1-2002 [B22], IEC 60255-22-1 Ed. 2.0b (2005-03) [B10],
IEC 60255-22-4 Ed. 2.0b (2002-04) [B11], IEC 60255-22-5 Ed. 1.0b [B12].
The governor-control equipment should be designed and tested to be insensitive to radiated high frequency
interference such as that coupled from portable radio transmitters. A field strength withstand level may be
specified for the governing system. Typical values range from 10 V/m to 20 V/m over the frequency range
of 25 MHz to 1000 MHz. As a minimum, tests should be conducted at 150 MHz band, 400 MHz band, and
in some countries, 900 MHz band. Alternatively, the power rating and frequency of the purchasers
transceivers and the desired minimum operating distance between transceiver and governor equipment
location may be specified.
See also IEEE Std 1207 for other references on electromagnetic interference.
5.11.3 Seismic
Seismic design requirements may be specified. If seismic requirements are necessary, they should be
considered on a plant-specific basis. The seismic requirements should either be referenced or included in
the governor specification.
5.12 Software
Where a digital governor controller is supplied, a complete set of program and data base files and software
configuration and programming tools should be provided for all digital devices installed in the system. As a
minimum, the following should be provided:
The source code, program or function file that defines the control sequence/strategy for a specific
installation.
The configuration programming software tool that is used to create and modify the source code
and executable code.
Any utilities required for uploading and downloading of the executable code and setting
parameters.
Any utilities required for viewing and modifying the setting parameters with the turbine either
running or stopped.
Any utilities required for viewing of real time variables.
28
IEEE Std 125-2007

The following utilities are considered optional:
Real-time trending tool
Event-logging software
Any utilities required for comparing the software residing in the programming computer with the
software residing in the governor controller.
All source code should be identified with the revision date, revision number, and appropriate revision
notes. All source code should be extensively documented.
There should be adequate access security (for example, password) for the following operations:
Uploading and downloading of all software.
Modifying all settings.
The executable code should reside in non-volatile memory to prevent loss of function in the event of
governor controller power loss.
Software upgrades and technical support may be specified based on the purchasers requirements.
The governor controller should have provisions to execute time critical functions at a guaranteed rate. A
periodic execution schedule of at least once every 10 ms is typically specified. The areas of code that are
considered time critical should be specified.
A warning mechanism should be provided when the size of the executable file has reached the limit of the
governor controllers memory capacity or processing capacity.
5.13 Interface to other plant systems

The interface requirements to other plant systems which are remote from the governor should be specified.
These systems may include:
Unit controller
Plant controller
Central control room console
Plant monitoring system
Remote terminal unit for off site control
The interface to these systems should be specified as either communication interfaces or discrete hardwired
interfaces. Discrete interfaces are required when interfacing a new governor to a system without
communications capabilities. Discrete interfaces offer advantages of greater security and a more
deterministic response under heavy data traffic conditions.
If a communications interface is specified, the physical layer and protocol requirements should be
specified. If a discrete interface is specified, the specific requirements should be detailed (for example,
raise and lower relay contacts, analog voltage set point).
The type and scaling of all signals provided for remote indication should be specified (for example,
voltage, current, bipolar, uni-polar, range and scaling).
29
IEEE Std 125-2007

A list of quantities required for remote control purposes should be specified. Typical quantities are shown
in Annex D, Table D.1.
For further details on interfaces to other plant automation systems, see IEEE Std 1010 and
IEEE Std 1249-1996 [B21].
5.14 Operator interface

Details of the local operator interfaces should be specified including any preferences for either
conventional controls and indicators or a digital operator interface terminal (OIT). Conventional controls
typically include pushbuttons or switches. Conventional indicators typically include discrete meters and
either lamp or LED indicators.
Quantities required for local control purposes should be specified. Typical quantities are shown in
Annex D, Table D.1. All critical controls should be conventional hardwired controls.
Where an OIT is supplied, it should be powered by an uninterruptible source (battery-backed dc or ac). The
OIT should have the following user specified minimum capabilities:
Number of lines of alphanumeric text on each screen or page.
Number of characters of alphanumeric text on each line.
Number of separate screens or pages.
A detailed list of alarms may be specified. Annex D, Table D.1, provides a typical list. Digital governors
typically have a much greater quantity of alarms in comparison to older governors. This is efficiently
handled with a communicated interface to other plant systems. If a discrete alarm interface to other systems
is required (for example, alarm contacts for connection to a remote alarm annunciator), the specifier may
require alarm grouping. A typical scheme is to group alarms into categories of urgent, semi-urgent and nonurgent.
5.15 Personnel safety features

Subclauses 5.15.1 through 5.15.5 include safety features that are typically included in speed-governing
systems. It is by no means an exhaustive and comprehensive list of safety features. It should not be
considered to be an authoritative treatment of safety features, nor a substitute for national, state, provincial,
regional or corporate safety codes.
5.15.1 System grounding
The Governor cabinet and HPSS should be designed for grounding to the station ground mat. Two parallel
ground connections may be specified for the HPSS for added security due to higher available ground fault
levels. All equipment in the governor should be electrically bonded to the cabinet or frame ground.
For electrical noise suppression purposes, a common practice is to create a separate electronic circuit
ground bus, which is connected to the cabinet at a single point. In some cases, further improvements in
regard to noise suppression may be obtained by isolating the cabinet ground from the electronic ground. If
isolation is deemed necessary, care should be taken to avoid violating electrical safety requirements. The
expected ground potential rise under ground fault conditions should be accounted for when specifying the
isolation scheme or method.
30
IEEE Std 125-2007

Adjustable-blade hydraulic oil piping should have electrical isolation at the oil head to prevent circulating
currents through the generator shaft. Speed measuring equipment should be electrically isolated from the
generator shaft.
See IEEE Std 1010 and IEEE Std 665-1995 [B18] for further details on grounding.
5.15.2 Automatic gate actuator lock
An automatic wicket gate servomotor lock (gate lock) may be specified as part of the turbine-control
actuator. The lock may incorporate an automatically controlled valve to operate the locking device when
the wicket gates reach the fully closed position during a turbine shutdown. The purpose of the automatic
lock is to prevent an inadvertent turbine rotation if the HPSS hydraulic pressure is lost. If the lock also
serves as a personnel safety feature while the hydraulic system is charged, the lock should be designed to
withstand full hydraulic pressure. Limit switches to indicate the position of the control actuator locking
device may also be specified. A gate lock fail to apply alarm may also be specified.
Nozzle control actuator locks are not generally specified unless there is a possibility of the nozzles opening
due to the influence of penstock pressure.
5.15.3 Manual control actuator lock
A manual wicket gate servomotor locking facility may be specified. This may be required where an
automatic locking facility is not supplied, where the automatic facility is incapable of withstanding full
hydraulic pressure or where the automatic facility is not considered to be sufficiently safe and secure. The
manual control actuator lock should lock the gates in the fully closed position. In some instances, locking
the gates in a partially open or fully open position may be specified. For impulse turbines, manual control
actuator locks may also be specified for deflector or nozzle control actuators.
5.15.4 Hydraulic isolation valves
Hydraulic isolation valves may be specified to be installed on appropriate hydraulic lines. Bleed valves
may also be specified for installation on the safe (non-source) side of the isolation valves for purposes of
returning oil to the sump. The quantity and location of these valves should be specified. Valve locking
provisions may also be specified.
5.15.5 Electrical safety switches
Safety isolation switches may be specified to be installed at appropriate locations such as on the pump
motors. The quantity and location of these switches should be specified. Switch locking provisions may
also be specified.
5.16 Spare parts and accessories

The manufacturer of the governor-control system should provide a list of recommended spare parts, along
with a list of any special tools or accessories necessary for the operation and maintenance of the system
being provided.
31
IEEE Std 125-2007

5.17 Product support

Recent experience has shown that the service life for some digital governors is relatively short compared to
historical experience. Users may wish to take the following precautions to mitigate the problems of early
product obsolescence:
Purchase two or more spares for each part
Avoid the purchase of technology that is in the late stages of its life cycle
Avoid the purchase of technology that is considered at risk of failing to gain wide market
acceptance
Guarantees of product support from the manufacturer
Specify the use of standard interface signals and protocols
Specify the use of widely available components and avoid the use of tailor made solutions
Ensure adequate product documentation is supplied in case the manufacturer ceases to support the
product
6. Performance specification
6.1 Stability
The governor system should be capable of controlling, in a stable manner, the speed and power of the
turbine at all power outputs between zero and maximum power output inclusive. This applies when the
generating unit is operating isolated, or when the generating unit is operating in parallel with a large
interconnected power unit.
The range of conditions covered by stability requirements includes sustained conditions, load rejection, and
sudden changes of isolated load, both large and small.
6.1.1 Sustained conditions
Steady-state stability indices may be specified. If specified, the purchaser should recognize that persistent
oscillatory mechanical power surging may occur as a natural result of the water passage or turbine design.
This natural surging must be accounted for when determining the governors ability to maintain steadystate stability.
a)
The steady-state governing speed band (also called speed stability index) under either speed-noload or loaded conditions should be no more than 0.1% with the generator off-line and operating at
5% speed droop (position, power, or flow).
b)
The steady-state governing load band (also called power stability index) should be no more than
0.4 % with the turbine-generator unit operating at 5% speed droop (position, power, or flow) and
operating outside of the turbine rough zone.
NOTESome digital governors are capable of damping out any turbine-induced natural power surging. This damping
may come at the expense of excessive wear on the governor, control actuator, or turbine-control device. If this occurs,
the steady-state governing speed band may be increased; however, it should not exceed 0.3%.
32
IEEE Std 125-2007

6.1.2 Load rejection

Following rejection to zero of any load within the capability of the governed turbine, speed should be
returned to the speed reference as may be modified by speed droop (position, power, or flow), with no more
than one under-speed deviation not to exceed 5% and one overspeed deviation not to exceed 5%
subsequent to the initial overspeed deviation. This specification presumes that the turbine-control actuator
cushion retards control actuator movement only in the closing direction and at control actuator positions
less than speed-no-load.
NOTERetardation by the turbine-control actuator cushion system of control actuator movement in the opening
direction may degrade recovery of speed control following rejection to zero load. Inclusion of this paragraph will
require turbine model data and may require additional hardware.
6.1.3 Speed control, fluctuating isolated load basis

This requirement pertains to the suitability of the principal damping elements of hydraulic turbine
governors. Performance for this isolated load condition is separately specified, since adequacy of the
damping system for this condition is not ordinarily revealed by performance under grid-connected
conditions or by the no-load condition following load rejection.
6.1.3.1 Damping capability
The range and effectiveness of the damping elements of the governor should be capable of providing
suitably damped control of speed when the turbine-generator unit serves an isolated resistive load. Suitably
damped control of speed should be demonstrated while the turbine-generator unit is carrying an isolated
resistive load of approximately 90% of rating. The hydraulic head should be within plus or minus 10% of
rating for this demonstration.
Suitability of damping of the speed deviations in the time domain should be shown following a sudden load
change (increase or decrease) of not more than 5% of rating. Suitably damped control will be shown by
attenuation of the second speed deviation of the same sign as the first deviation to not more than 25% of the
first deviation.
In the frequency domain, the suitability of damping should be shown by a frequency response test
performed at the operating point detailed above with signal levels within the linear response range of the
governing system. The frequency response of interest is the open-loop response from the turbine shaft
speed input to the governor to turbine shaft speed. This can best be obtained by cascading the frequency
response taken from the governor shaft speed input to gate position, with the response taken from gate
position to shaft speed under isolated conditions. Suitably damped control will be shown by an appropriate
phase margin at unity gain crossover and an appropriate gain margin. Refer to IEEE Std 1207 for phase and
gain margin guidelines.
NOTE 1An open-loop criteria is considered to be a necessary condition for stability. Experience has shown it may
not be a sufficient condtion in all cases. Both an open-loop and a closed-loop stability criteria may be specified.
NOTE 2The control of a resistive load is the historical standard of performance capability. It represents the strongest
dependence upon the governor damping system likely to be needed in normal service. Evaluation may be achieved by
tests, by computation, or by a combination of tests and computation as may be agreed upon between the purchaser and
manufacturer.
33
IEEE Std 125-2007

6.1.3.2 Damping for non-resistive load

If the users load conditions are known to differ from characteristics of the resistive load, the evaluation of
adequacy of damping may be based upon such load characteristics by mutual agreement between the
purchaser and the manufacturer. For this condition the purchaser should specify the inertia of the load and
its load regulation characteristic (ordinarily the voltage will be maintained constant by the voltage
regulator, and voltage dependency of the load need not be considered). The same degree of damping for the
specified load should be achieved as for the reference resistive load.
6.1.4 Stability studies
As a result of the complex interrelated effects between the penstock, generator, turbine, governor, and
power system, it may be desirable that a mathematical simulation of the entire system be performed. This is
of particular importance if a large percentage of the system generation is supplied from one turbinegenerator unit or if the physical characteristics of any parts of the system raise concern. The following text
may be added to the procurement specification if a simulation study is required to be performed by the
governor supplier:
The supplier should simulate, using appropriate methods, the interaction of penstock, turbine,
generator, load, and governor in order to prove that the system is stable under all load conditions
when adequate adjustments of the governor parameters are set and the pressure and transient
speeds after load rejection are within the specified limits when the gate closing time is
appropriately adjusted. The stability studies should cover the operating range between
maximum and minimum net heads with the discharge corresponding to the full load under each
respective net head. Studies should be conducted for conditions including parallel operation
with an infinite system, supply of an isolated resistive load, and supply of isolated loads with
special speed regulation characteristics specified. The studies should indicate the setting range
of the governor parameters for which the control circuit remains stable after any disturbance.
The quality of regulation should be demonstrated in diagrams indicating the transient response
of the frequency of the isolated system to load variations (increase and decrease) for various net
heads and the transient response of power for changes of the speed or generation reference when
supplying an infinite system.
6.2 Permanent speed droop

The permanent speed droop (position, power, or flow) should be capable of adjustment to values between 0
and 10%. The speed-versus-feedback parameter (position, power, or flow) curve should be substantially
linear over the full range of the feedback parameter; that is, the change in speed should be substantially the
same for equal increments of the feedback parameter.
6.3 Deadband
The speed deadband at rated speed should not exceed 0.02% of rated speed at any gate setting.
For adjustable-blade turbines, the blade control deadband should not exceed 1.0%.
34
IEEE Std 125-2007

6.4 Deadtime
IEEE Std 1207 defines governor deadtime as the elapsed time between a change in speed and the first
corrective action. The intended corrective action and the maximum allowable deadtime should be specified.
Typically, the specified corrective action is the onset of movement of the primary speed regulating turbinecontrol actuator (wicket gate actuators for reaction turbines or deflector actuators for impulse turbines). For
both wicket gates and deflectors, a maximum value of 0.2 s for a speed change of 0.1 Hz or larger is
typical.
For impulse turbines, the deadtime associated with nozzle servomotors may be specified if it is deemed to
be necessary. In many cases, it is not specified or measured since it does not typically have an impact on
speed control. For adjustable-blade turbines, the blade deadtime should be specified. The blade deadtime is
defined as the elapsed time from a required change in blade position until the onset of blade movement.
This definition allows for the inclusion of intentional blade delays such as described in 5.9.1.1.
A maximum blade deadtime of 0.5 s is recommended. A lesser value may be required for turbines equipped
with fast acting blades (for example, blade control actuator time of less than approximately 30 s).
For governor conversions, the total deadtime should be specified in a manner which includes the
cumulative delay effects of only those components to be supplied by the manufacturer.
6.5 Governor damping adjustments

The various damping parameters should be provided with the following range of adjustment for temporary
droop, PID, and double-derivative type strategies. Separate sets of damping parameters should be provided
for on line and off line conditions. A third set of damping parameters may be specified for isolated or
islanded operation.
6.5.1 Temporary speed droop adjustments
The decay time constant of the damping system should be continuously adjustable from 0 to 30 s. The
temporary speed droop should be continuously adjustable from 0 to 150%.
6.5.2 Proportional, integral, and derivative (PID) adjustments
The proportional gain should be continuously adjustable from 0 to 20. The derivative gain should be
continuously adjustable from 0 to 5 s. The integral gain should be continuously adjustable from 0 to 10 per
second. The proportional, integral, and derivative gains are defined from governor speed input to governor
system output.
6.5.3 Double derivative or lead-lag adjustments
The lead and lag time constants should have a continuously adjustable range from 0.01 to 10 s. The
derivative gains should be continuously adjustable from 0 to 10 s.
35
IEEE Std 125-2007

7. Information provided by the manufacturer
7.1 Information to be provided at the time of submission of proposals

7.1.1 Technical submissions
The manufacturer should furnish diagrams or drawings of the speed-governing system together with a
written description clearly explaining the principle of operation. This information should include outline
drawings showing major dimensions and appropriate mathematical models for use in dynamic computer
studies.
7.1.2 Long-term maintenance
The manufacturer should provide documented assurance that the equipment will be supported by the
manufacturer for a specified time period. A time period of 20 years to 40 years is typical. This support
should include the availability of proprietary spare parts, availability of software, troubleshooting support,
and resolving any design flaws. The purchaser may require the manufacturer to hold in escrow certain
proprietary information such as software source code and drawings.
7.2 Information to be provided after contract award

The following are suggested as reasonable requirements for furnishing of drawings and materials by the
manufacturer. The specification writer should modify the requirements to suit his particular needs,
including the times allowed for submission.
7.2.1 Drawings and software
After contract award, the manufacturer should submit drawings and software to the purchaser in a specified
time frame for approval or usage as follows. CAD drawing files may also be supplied.
General arrangement drawings showing confirmed overall dimensions and weights of the principal
parts of the governor, sufficient to allow concrete foundation work in the powerhouse to proceed.
Drawings showing full details of foundation requirements, required erection procedures, required
erection provisions, hydraulic schematics, functional descriptions, and electrical schematic
diagrams for all parts of the governor system, including all necessary components and auxiliary
devices to make a complete system.
Application software source code listing (if required) and wiring drawings.
At the completion of commissioning, all software as defined in 5.12 and all final drawings.
Purchasers may also require drawings and software after the completion of the factory test.
7.2.2 Installation instructions

The manufacturer should provide installation instruction describing in detail the recommended procedure
for installing the governor and all its components. The instructions should include procedures for on-site
acceptance and inspections.
36
IEEE Std 125-2007

7.2.3 Operation and maintenance manuals

The manufacturer should provide operation and maintenance manuals describing in detail the
recommended procedure for assembling, dismantling, maintaining, troubleshooting, and operating the
governor and all its components.
Without restricting the generality of the foregoing, the manuals should include at least the following:
Technical and design data including weights of all major components.
All pertinent bulletins and instruction manuals prepared by the various manufacturers of component
parts of the governor. Manufacturers bulletins should be suitably annotated to clearly indicate
those items that form a part of the complete assembly.
Procedures for assembling, dismantling, operating, diagnosing trouble, and maintaining the
governor.
Procedures and technical data required to properly adjust the governor.
Lubrication requirements, including a list of recommended lubricants for all components of the
governor.
A complete index of all the contractors drawings and a list of all assembly bulletins and drawings
prepared by the manufacturers of components of the governor.
A selected set of arrangement, schematic, and wiring drawings for the governor, reduced in size to
suit the instruction manuals.
A set of assembly drawings or printed bulletins that show all individual components of the
equipment and that indicate and identify each component item number, including the common
commercial designation.
Instructions on the use of all software tools including procedures for uploading and downloading
of executable code or settings and for modifying the executable code.
List of recommended spare parts and consumables.
The specified number of copies of the manual should be submitted in draft form to the purchaser for
approval prior to delivery. Following approval by the purchaser, the specified number of suitably bound
copies and one copy of the electronic file in non-volatile media (file format and media to be specified) of
the manual should be supplied.
Should the manufacturer find it appropriate or necessary thereafter to amend such instruction manuals, he
should, after obtaining purchaser's approval, promptly provide the specified number of any such
amendments plus an updated electronic file.
7.3 Test procedures

Test procedures for factory acceptance testing and site acceptance testing should be provided by the
manufacturer for approval. The factory test procedure should indicate which steps of the factory acceptance
testing are for customer witnessing. The site acceptance test procedures should be written in accordance
with the purchasers local safety rules and procedures.
37
IEEE Std 125-2007

The following test and inspection reports should be provided by the manufacturer after test completion:
Factory acceptance tests
Commissioning tests
Site acceptance tests
7.4 Rehabilitation and conversion considerations

Particular attention should be paid to the mechanical interface between existing equipment and new
equipment. Dimensional information shown on existing plant equipment drawings should be confirmed or
updated by the manufacturer. This may require a visit to the site by the manufacturer. Dimensional
drawings showing details of the interface between existing equipment and new equipment should be
provided no later than two months after contract award.
8. Governor testing
Governor performance tests are typically required to demonstrate that the governor system meets the
specified performance criteria. Some tests are typically performed at the governor equipment
manufacturers factory, and certain tests are typically performed on-site after installation of the equipment.
Suggested target values for some performance criteria are provided below or in some cases in Clause 5 and
Clause 6 of this recommended practice. These target values may be pre-empted by system operator
requirements.
Further details regarding some of the tests described below are provided in standard IEEE Std 1207.
The tests listed below do not comprise an exhaustive set of tests. For more complete testing requirements,
references ANSI/ASME Std PTC29-1965 [B1] and IEC 60308 (1970-01) [B13] should be consulted.
8.1 Factory acceptance testing

Certain tests should be performed at the governor manufacturers factory to demonstrate that the governor
equipment complies with the specified governor performance parameters. The specifier of the governor
equipment may require additional factory tests to be performed.
8.1.1 Speed and blade deadband test
The manufacturer of the governor equipment should demonstrate that the governor is capable of meeting
the required speed deadband and, if applicable, the required blade deadband.
8.1.2 Deadtime test
If the control actuator control valve is part of the governor-control system being provided, the governor
manufacturer should demonstrate that the governor is capable of providing a movement of the main speed
regulating turbine-control actuator (wicket gate or deflector) within a specified deadtime after a turbine
speed change, such as would be experienced after a sudden load change of 10% or more of the turbinegenerator units rated generation while operating isolated from an interconnected power system.
38
IEEE Std 125-2007

If the control actuator control valve is not part of the governor-control system being provided, the governor
manufacturer should demonstrate the deadtime of only those components to be supplied.
For adjustable-blade turbines, the blade deadtime should also be demonstrated. This may be achieved by
using a recording device which plots both blade setpoint and blade position during an event which causes a
sudden change in blade set point.
For impulse turbines, the nozzle deadtime may be demonstrated if desired.
8.1.3 Speed droop test
The manufacturer of the governor equipment should demonstrate that the governor responds to changes in
simulated turbine speed according to the specified permanent speed droop characteristic for the governor.
8.1.4 Damping verification test
The manufacturer of the governor equipment should demonstrate that the range of adjustment of the
damping system gains and time constants meet the purchasers specifications.
8.1.5 Start/stop sequence test
The manufacturer of the governor equipment should demonstrate that the governor responds in the
specified manner to start and stop commands. The functionality of all other remote and local controls
should also be demonstrated.
8.1.6 Model verification test
If required by the purchaser, the system frequency response, time response, or both, may be tested to
demonstrate that the governor-control system responds in a manner consistent with the specified
mathematical governor-control system model.
8.1.7 Transient immunity test
If required by the purchaser, the manufacturer may conduct radio frequency interference (RFI) tests or
surge-withstand capability tests on the governing system equipment. IEEE Std C37.90.1-2002 [B22] is
commonly specified for surge withstand testing.
8.1.8 Accuracy tests
If required by the purchaser, the manufacturer may conduct accuracy tests on specified analog inputs such
as control actuator position feedback, speed feedback or active power feedback. If supplied by the
manufacturer, the associated sensors and transducers may also be tested for accuracy.
8.2 On-site acceptance testing

Certain tests should be performed at the installation site to demonstrate that the governor equipment
complies with the specified governor performance parameters. The specifier of the governor equipment
39
IEEE Std 125-2007

may require additional on-site tests to be performed depending on past experience or to meet regulatory
requirements.
8.2.1 Control actuator timing test
The installation supervisor on-site should demonstrate that the maximum-rate timing of the turbine-control
actuators complies with the specified timing, within specified tolerances. Typically, this control actuator
timing is initially demonstrated with the turbine dewatered, and repeated with the turbine watered up.
Required adjustments should be made so the turbine-control actuator timing complies with the governor
system specifications with the turbine watered up.
The purchaser may specify that timing tests be performed at both nominal and minimum HPSS pressure.
The tests should be performed over the full range of actuator positions to verify cushioning requirements
(for actuators so equipped).
8.2.2 Governor speed control damping test
The damping of the governor control of turbine speed should be demonstrated at-site by inducing a
disturbance, while operating isolated from the interconnected power system, and recording the gate position
and speed while recovering from the induced disturbance. The induced disturbance may be implemented by
applying the gate limit to reduce the operating speed of the turbine, and suddenly raising the gate limit out
of the way, by connecting or disconnecting an isolated load from the generator or by injecting a speed
signal small step change.
8.2.3 Deadtime tests
The governor deadtime may be measured by rejecting a load of at least 10% of the rated generation of the
turbine-generator unit, and measuring the elapsed time between the opening of the unit breaker and the first
movement of the main speed regulating turbine-control actuator. For adjustable-blade turbines, the blade
deadtime may be measured using a method similar to that specified in 8.1.2.
For impulse turbines, the nozzle deadtime may be demonstrated if desired.
8.2.4 Load rejection test
The governor response to a load rejection may be demonstrated by recording the actuator position and the
turbine-generator unit speed in response to tripping the unit breaker at various specified loads, typically
25%, 50%, 75%, and 100% of the rated generation. The maximum overspeed experienced at each level of
load rejection is determined by the deadtime of the governing system and the rate of closure of the actuator.
The number and magnitude of speed deviations after the initial overspeed transient is an indication of the
governor control damping.
8.2.5 Steady state stability tests
A speed stability index test and a power stability index test may be specified. If such tests are specified, the
limitations detailed in 6.1.1 should be recognized.
40
IEEE Std 125-2007

8.2.6 Other control tests

8.2.6.1 Speed reference range test
The speed reference range adjustment specified in 5.2.4 should be demonstrated.
8.2.6.2 Gate limit control test
The controller actuator limit specified in 5.2.5 should be demonstrated.
8.2.6.3 Manual control test
The manual control functionality specified in 5.2.9 should be demonstrated.
8.2.7 Online set-point response test
The response to a set-point change may be demonstrated by changing the governor set point with the unit
operating online while recording key variables such as active power and control actuator position. The
specifier may require that tests be performed with the governor operating in more than one mode of
operation.
8.2.8 Online simulated speed step test
The response to a simulated speed step change may be demonstrated by creating a simulated speed step
change and recording the control actuator time response. The results may be used to judge the overall
governing system response and to verify governor model parameters.
8.2.9 Model verification test
The model verification testing described in 8.1.6 may also be done as an on-site test. For online tests, the
impact upon the interconnected grid should be taken into consideration. The model verification testing may
be required to meet regulatory requirements. For further details, refer to IEEE Std 1207.
8.2.10 Communication tests
Where communication between the governor and other devices is specified, the complete functionality of
the communications interface should be demonstrated by sending and receiving data between devices.
9. Information provided by the specifier

The following list of information is based on the assumption that control actuators are to be provided by
others or already exist.
Rated turbine output.
Net head (including variations).

41
IEEE Std 125-2007

Rated speed.
Rated discharge.
Type or types of set parameter(s) (set-point references).
Ambient conditions.
Seismic requirements.
Surge tank dimensions and type.
Water inertia time (penstock, spiral case, and draft tube).
Relief valve capacity under full head.
Turbine-generator unit mechanical inertia.
Station service ac and dc voltages including ranges of variation, for governor-control and power
circuits.
Powerhouse drawings showing suggested location of equipment.
Combined gate control actuator volume and stroke.
Deflector-control actuator volume and stroke.
Nozzle control actuator volume and stroke, when governor-operated.
Runner blade control actuator volume and stroke.
Control actuator design (nominal) operating pressure.
Turbine-control actuator connection sizes.
Control actuator travel direction to close.
Minimum differential pressure required to move control actuators.
Maximum pressure control actuators are capable of withstanding.
Gate shaft or deflector shaft direction and angular travel to close.
Main control actuator (gate or deflector) time: opening and closing.
Runner blade or nozzle control actuator times : opening and closing.
Results of turbine index tests or model tests, if available.
Type, size, and any special characteristics of equipment to be supplied with the governor for
remote mounting, if required (examples include speed sensors, turbine-control actuator position
sensors, switchboard instruments).
Current carrying capacity and operating rpm of speed and overspeed switches.
Preferred or required HPSS gas medium.
Brake actuating medium and pressure.
Required interfacing for purchaser furnished controls including required electrical ratings.
Dimensional drawings showing the mechanical interface between existing equipment and new
equipment supplied by the manufacturer.
Special design considerations, e.g., electric governor, joint control, 3D cams.
Required initial adjustments for selected governor parameters that have a range of adjustment.
42
IEEE Std 125-2007

Complete four quadrant prototype turbine data or turbine model data together with model to
prototype scaling. These data should cover the range of zero to full gate opening.
Site specific safety rules and procedures.
Unit operation conditions (for example, isolated operation, expected load variations, frequency
boundaries).
Unit sequences (for example, special start-up or shutdown sequences, turbine re-start during coastdown).
Anticipated hydraulic oil specifications, including type and viscosity.
The authority of jurisdiction regarding pressure tank certification.
The authority of jurisdiction regarding piping certification (if required).
Applicable fire regulation codes or standards (if any).
Other applicable regulatory requirements.
43
IEEE Std 125-2007

Annex A
(informative)
Bibliography
[B1] Agee, J.C., Vu, Hoa D., and Volk, James, Installation and testing of a prototype digital governor at
Mt. Elbert Power Plant, IEEE PES Winter Meeting Transactions, Paper no. 0-7803-4403-0/98, 1999.
[B2] ANSI/ASME Std PTC29-1965 (Reaff 1985), Speed-Governing Systems for Hydraulic Turbine
Generator Units. 6
[B3] ANSI/ASME Std B31.1-1986 (SI Edition 1983), Power Piping.
[B4] ANSI Std B93.11M-1981, Seamless Low Carbon Steel Hydraulic Line Tubing.
[B5] ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code, Section VIII, Rules for Construction of Division 1 Pressure
Vessels.
[B6] Eilts, L.E. and Schleif, F.R., Governing features and performance of the first 600-MW
hydrogenerating unit at Grand Coulee, IEEE Transactions on Power Apparatus and Systems, vol. PAS-96,
no. 2, March/April 1977.
[B7] EN 13445 (2002), Harmonization European Code for Unfired Pressure Vessels. 7
[B8] EN 13480 (2003), Harmonized European Code for Piping.
[B9] IEC 60041 (1991-11), Field acceptance tests to determine the hydraulic performance of hydraulic
turbines, storage pumps and pump turbines. 8
[B10] IEC 60255-22-1 Ed. 2.0b (2005-03), Electrical relaysPart 22-1: Electrical 163.00 disturbance tests
for measuring relays and protection equipment1 MHz burst immunity tests.
[B11] IEC 60255-22-4 Ed. 2.0b (2002-04), Electrical relaysPart 22-4: Electrical 28.00 disturbance tests
for measuring relays and protection equipmentElectrical fast transient/burst immunity test.
[B12] IEC 60255-22-5 Ed 1.0b, Electrical relaysPart 22-5: Electrical 71.00 disturbance tests for
measuring relays and protection equipmentSurge immunity test.
[B13] IEC 60308 (2005-01), Hydraulic turbinesTesting of control systems.
[B14] IEC 60545 (1976-01), Guide for Commissioning, Operation and Maintenance of Hydraulic
Turbines.
[B15] IEC 61116 (1992-10), Electromechanical equipment guide for small hydroelectric installations.
[B16] IEC 61362 (1998-03), Guide to specification of hydraulic turbine-control systems.
[B17] IEEE 100, The Authoritative Dictionary of IEEE Standards Terms, Seventh Edition. 9,
10
[B18] IEEE Std 665-1995, IEEE Guide for Generating Station Grounding.
6
ASME publications are available from the American Society of Mechanical Engineers, 3 Park Avenue, New York, NY 10016-5990,
USA (http://www.asme.org/).
7
EN publications are available from the European Committee for Standardization (CEN), 36, rue de Stassart, B-1050 Brussels,
Belgium (http://www.cenorm.be).
8
IEC publications are available from the Sales Department of the International Electrotechnical Commission, Case Postale 131, 3, rue
de Varemb, CH-1211, Genve 20, Switzerland/Suisse (http://www.iec.ch/). IEC publications are also available in the United States
from the Sales Department, American National Standards Institute, 11 West 42nd Street, 13th Floor, New York, NY 10036, USA.
9
The IEEE standards or products referred to in this bibliography are trademarks owned by the Institute of Electrical and Electronics
10
IEEE publications are available from the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, 445 Hoes Lane, Piscataway, NJ 088551331, USA (http://standards.ieee.org/).
44
IEEE Std 125-2007

[B19] IEEE Std 1020-1988 (Reaff 1994), IEEE Guide for Control of Small Hydroelectric Power Plants.
[B20] IEEE Std 1248-1998, IEEE Guide of the Commissioning of Electrical Systems in Hydroelectric
Power Plants.
[B21] IEEE Std 1249-1996, IEEE Guide for Computer-Based Control for Hydroelectric Power Plant
Automation.
[B22] IEEE Std C37.90.1-2002, IEEE Standard Surge Withstand Capability (SWC) Tests for Relays and
Relay Systems Associated with Electric Power Apparatus.
[B23] IEEE Std C37.90.2-2004, IEEE Standard for Withstand Capability of Relay Systems to Radiated
Electromagnetic Interference from Transceivers.
45
IEEE Std 125-2007

Annex B
(informative)
Glossary
damping: A measure of the stability of a closed-loop control system when recovering from a transient
disturbance and returning to steady-state operation. Damping increases with the value of the damping ratio.
A damping ratio of 1.0 or greater is highly damped, and exhibits no oscillatory action when recovering
from a transient disturbance. A damping ratio between 0.0 and 1.0 is under damped and exhibits some
decaying oscillatory action when recovering from a transient disturbance. A damping ratio of 0.0 or less
exhibits continuous oscillatory action, and will not achieve steady-state operation.
distributing valve: The element of the turbine-control actuator that controls the flow of hydraulic fluid to
the turbine-control actuator(s).
source code: The software that defines the control sequence/strategy for a specific installation. It may be
ladder logic, function block code, sequencing logic or a similar type of software code. In some cases, it
may be a simple settings file. The source code resides in the memory of the programming computer.
46
IEEE Std 125-2007

Annex C
(normative)
Mode control logic
C.1 Droop mode control logic

Some specifiers require both speed droop-position (position feedback) and speed droop-power (or speed
droop-flow) including a means of automatically transferring between these two modes of operation. The
automatic transfer is typically based upon operator selection, feedback signal quality (for example, power
or flow signal is good or signal is failed) and possibly whether the turbine-generator is operating grid
connected, islanded or isolated. The mode transfer method should be specified. Figure C.1 illustrates a
typical logic implementation.
Figure C.1Droop mode control logic
C.2 Governor mode control logic

The logic should be designed such that certain modes of operation take priority over other modes. As well,
the logic should ensure that there is always one mode selected, regardless of the states of the mode
selection inputs (i.e., the situation where no mode is selected must be avoided). Figure C.2 shows one
method of achieving this design criteria.
47
IEEE Std 125-2007

Figure C.2Governor mode control logic
48
IEEE Std 125-2007

Annex D
(normative)
Tables
Table D.1 provides a list of typical input and output quantities and alarms that may be specified to be
incorporated into the governor to allow interface with the operator interface as described in 5.1.4 and the
interface with other plant systems described in 5.1.3.
Table D.1Typical local and remote control and display quantities
49
IEEE Std 125-2007

Table D.1Typical local and remote control and display quantities (continued)
50
IEEE Std 125-2007

Table D.1Typical local and remote control and display quantities (continued)
NOTE 1Control used in this column is intended to encompass the inputs to the operator interface, or conventional
controls and indicators, or interface with other plant systems (for example, supervisory or plant control system) that may
be necessary to affect control actions.
NOTE 2Analog quantities derived from direct measurement may be measured by either an analog transducer or a
digital transducer.
NOTE 3Status quantities may be either two-state (for example, on/off) or multi-state (for example,
stopped/starting/running/stopping).
51

IEEE STD 125-2007 PDF

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

IEEE STD 125-2007 PDF

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

IEEE STD 125-2007 PDF

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

IEEE Recommended Practice

for Preparation of Equipment

IEEE Power Engineering Society

IEEE Std 125-2007

IEEE Std 125TM-2007

IEEE Recommended Practice

Energy Development and Power Generation Committee

IEEE-SA Standards Board

The Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, Inc.

9. Information provided by the specifier ...................................................................................................... 41

IEEE Recommended Practice

IEEE Std 125-2007

1.4 Use of IEEE Std 125

Information on references can be found in Clause 2.

IEEE Std 125-2007

The numbers in brackets correspond to those in the bibliography in Annex A.

IEEE Std 125-2007

4. Functions and characteristics

4.1 Control actuator position

4.2 Control actuator stroke

4.3 Control actuator time

IEEE Std 125-2007

5.1 General specifications

Manufacturers name and address

Serial number of the governor-control system

Model number and type number of the governor-control system

IEEE Std 125-2007

Maximum working hydraulic supply pressure

Minimum normal working hydraulic supply pressure

5.1.5 Electrical power

IEEE Std 125-2007

Main turbine-control actuator (gate or deflector) position

Main turbine-control actuator (gate or deflector) set point

Blade or nozzle servomotor position (if applicable)

Blade or nozzle servomotor set point (if applicable)

Speed error (input to damping element)

Turbine-control actuator limit setting

5.1.7.3 Signal injection

Speed-error summing point

Active-power summing point (if applicable)

5.2 Governor and auxiliary functions

5.2.1.2 Governor-control strategy

IEEE Std 125-2007

Temporary dropp controller

Proportional, integral, derivative (PID) controller

Double derivative controller

Speed droop-position (speed droop derived via position feedback)

Speed droop-power (speed droop derived via power feedback)

Speed droop-flow (speed droop derived via flow feedback)

5.2.3 Control modes

IEEE Std 125-2007

5.2.3.3 Flow control

5.2.3.4 Head pond and tail pond control

A means of manually controlling gate position while in pump mode

Gate control actuator positioning as a function of operating head

Separate control acutator velocity adjustments for pumping operation

IEEE Std 125-2007

5.2.5 Control actuator limit

IEEE Std 125-2007