Journal of Information Engineering and Applications

ISSN 2224-5782 (print) ISSN 2225-0506 (online)

Vol.4, No.11, 2014

www.iiste.org

Automated Students Result Management System Using Oracles

Database, Forms and Reports
Akinmosin James
Department of Physics
Faculty of Natural and Applied Sciences
Nasarawa State University, Keffi
E-mail: [email protected] Tel: 08054909403.
The research was financed by the researcher.
Abstract
This research is focused on creating an automated students result management system using oracles database,
forms and reports. This is a computerized examinations results management system for tertiary students
examination records. The manual method of students academic result processing was found to be tedious,
especially when carried out for a large number of students, this makes the entire process time-consuming and
error prone. The system designed is meant to register students as soon as they have paid their departmental
registration and only then will they be able to view their results. The system presents a single platform that will
be used to manage the processing of all examination records within the institution. The data used for testing was
obtained from the Department of Physics, Nasarawa State University and an empirical evaluation of the system
shows that the system expedites the processing of students examination results and the reporting of it.
Keywords: Oracle Database, Oracle forms, Oracle
1.0

Background.

Eludire (2011) noted that the data generated by organizations are usually created in files for use by different
departments/units within the organization. If the data contained in these files are not carefully delineated it is
very likely that the same data will appear on several of these files. That is these files would contain redundant
data for example the University registry file and college or department file would contain the name and address
of a student. This would mean that a simple change of address has to be processed in two and probably three or
four places, depending on the number of other files on which these data appears. This results in data redundancy.
Vecchioli (1999) noted that organizing and managing student records into a cohesive and efficient system might
seem like an impossible task. This study was carried out to verify the manual process involved in generating
students examination result and to seek a way of automating the system for effective operations. It is pointed out
in the research work Student Examination Result Processing System (2012) that the effort expended in the
process of registration of students and computation of their examination results is enormous. Hence, the need to
evolve a computerized process that will effectively and efficiently capture all the important data associated with
the registration and examination result processing within the University.
Barrett (1999) notes that in an effort to efficiently document and maintain accountability data, schools are
relying more on technology in the form of Student Management Information Systems (SMIS). This system is
designed to efficiently handle processes like inputting scores, storing results, automatically calculating grade
points, and interpreting the students overall result. The usual manual process has now reached a level where it is
difficult for the available man power to cope with the magnitude of examination work, in the given time. The
imbalance between man power availability and the magnitude of work to be done in processing examination
results, leads to the delay in the declaration of examination results. An effective measure, which can improve the
efficiency of the examination result processing is therefore the introduction of computerization, especially with
the use of examinations result processing software. Computerized relational database systems (RDBMS) like
Oracle database, Microsoft SQL server, MySQL etc. were developed with goal of reducing data redundancy.
Brian (2009) stated that databases are collections of interrelated data of such a nature that the collections can be
represented as a number of files but not a single file. Garcia-Molina et al. (2008) also stated that depending on
the Database Management System (DBMS) used, these files may be integrated permanently into a single
connected structure or integrated temporarily for each interrogation, known as a query. Nearly all departments
within an organization require data to be processed into information in a timely manner. Timely information
processing and dissemination leads to efficiency and customer satisfaction. Schools are organizations as well and

Journal of Information Engineering and Applications

ISSN 2224-5782 (print) ISSN 2225-0506 (online)
Vol.4, No.11, 2014

www.iiste.org

timely information processing and dissemination is needed to run a school efficiently. Many schools have their
own system to manage students profile and assessments. Common practice as earlier stated is by recording the
student information in a record book(s). Students information is obtained from the registration forms obtained
from the practices that have always been used. This practice has some weaknesses such as it takes a longer time
to search the students profile, the possibility of misplacing these record books and the vulnerability of students
record as the records could be accessed by unauthorized persons. Eludire (2011) stated that other problems
associated with manual course system management include; improper registration, late release of students
results, Inaccuracy due to manual and tedious calculation, Retrieval difficulties/inefficiency. It is unfortunate that
most educational institutions in the developing world still operate the manual methods of record keeping and
computation. Although the manual methods still works, it is prone to errors. Automation of school
administration processes should be encouraged computers can be used for this automation process and
processing students results can be done quickly and efficiently to the satisfaction of the students, lecturers,
parents and school authority.
My research focuses on the design and implementation of an application where student results can be stored,
users can access this software from anywhere as long as the computer they are working on is on the network
same as the application server. This application enables users with the right permission to insert new user details,
students examination records as well as updated these records whenever necessary. The tools which I used in
designing this application is oracles database for keeping the records (data), oracle forms for creating the user
interface and oracle reports for presenting information to the user. This research seeks to provide an alternative
to the manual system of presenting results to students
1.1 literature review.
Information systems used to manage student data have been referred to in various ways: Student Information
Systems (SIS), Student Management Information Systems (SMIS), Student Data Systems (SDS), Student Data
Warehouse (SDW), Student Academic Information Systems (SAIS), or Student Information Management
Systems (SIMS), (Ngoma, 2009). Barrett (1999) encapsulates the essence of a student information system. He
defines SMIS as an integrated software package that maintains, supports, and provides inquiry, analysis, and
communication tools that organize student accountability data into information to support the educational
process (p. 4). A result management system (RMS) is only an aspect of a complete SIS package. The U.S.
Department of Education (2008) views student data systems as encompassing hardware and software that
provide many different functions to users, such as storing current and historical data, rapidly organizing and
analyzing data, and developing presentation formats or reporting interfaces(p. 2). My aim is to design and
implement a Universitys RMS, this system will have the capability of storing current and historical data,
organize and analyze this data as required and the software will have the ability to be integrated with other SIS
packages if the need arises.
1.2 Historical Perspective.
In the Early 1970s the first automated Integrated Student Information System using punch card input is
implemented.
In 1984 Punch-card system replaced by a database system on an Intercom platform. In 1988 Intercom system
replaced by an Integrated Database Management System (IDMS) database system. An IDMS is primarily a
network database management system for mainframe computers, (Wikipedia, 2014).
1988 through to 2005 IDMS systems were continually enhanced and modified to meet new requirements and
changing technology using the Internet, hundreds of interfaces have been built and extracts created to service a
large number of independent systems across colleges and campus, (North Carolina State University, 2006).
1.3 Theoretical framework
Emmanuel and Choji (2012) stated that the introduction of computer into information technology has massively
improved the information need of organizations. Anigbogu (2000) defined a computer as an electronic device
capable of accepting data and instructions, processing the data based on the instructions to generate results or
output in such a manner that is yet to be equaled by any other known machine to mankind. Since the computer is
capable of accepting data and instructions, store this data and often time this instructions and then generate an
output, it is therefore necessary that we harness this quality and use it to our advantage. The process of school
administration and in this case result processing is as already stated a time consuming and strenuous exercise

Journal of Information Engineering and Applications

ISSN 2224-5782 (print) ISSN 2225-0506 (online)
Vol.4, No.11, 2014

www.iiste.org

prone to errors, if done manually, hence the need for us to seek out ways to lift this burden from the individuals
involved in this exercise. Obiniyi and Ezugwu (2010) observed that Student enrolment in tertiary institutions is
increasing at a very alarming rate. The increase in students population over the years has made the work of
administrative officer in charge of processing students result a very tiresome exercise to deal with. The rise in
the number of students in schools today has made it imperative that we continue to seek out the best and most
efficient ways to handle schools and school administration. Mohini and Amar (2011) indicated that Publication
of students results in the manual system takes a very long time owing to which students remain idle for months
together. Sometimes the delay in declaration of result cause heavy losses to the students as generally they cannot
join further studies or appear in competitive exams or join jobs because of the nonavailability of examination
result in time. Nmaju et al. (2013) also observed that many higher institutions in Nigeria still adopt the manual
method of managing students data which is time consuming and demanding, and are often prone to a variety of
errors and disasters. Hence, it brings to the fore the need to properly address how these shortcomings could be
resolved and improved. They further stated that the solution to these shortcomings lies in an efficient information
management system, or simply, information system. Okonigene et al. (2008) further stated that, with the use of
computers for information processing, the following are possible: instant access to students personal and course
information, instant student information updating, automatic computation of the Grade Point Average (GPA),
generation of the graduating students list, monitoring of failed courses, keeping an up-to-date record of the entire
student body in the University, storing course information such as course code, course description, course unit,
and scores for the purpose of GPA computation, and producing user friendly data entry screens for ease of use.
There exist several programming Languages, programming packages and database management systems that can
be used to develop a result processing software. Java is a programming language used to build programs that can
work on stand-alone computers and on the internet, its primary features are that it is object-oriented and a cross
platform language. By cross platform, I means that the programs can run across several platforms such as
Microsoft Windows, Apple Macintosh, and Linux etc. Oracles Procedural Language/Structured Query
Language (PL/SQL) is the choice of programing language used in the development of this application, because
its Oracle Corporation's procedural extension language for SQL and the Oracle relational database. PL/SQL's
general syntax resembles that of Pascal. It is also one of three key programming languages embedded in the
Oracle Database, along with SQL itself and Java. PL/SQL supports variables, conditions, loops and exceptions.
Arrays are also supported, though PL/SQL collections. Implementations from version 8 of Oracle Database
onwards have included features associated with object-orientation. Once the program units have been stored into
the database, they become available for execution at a later time.
1.4 Materials and Methods
Hardware requirements;
i.

HP Proliant Micro Server with 6GB Memory, Processor speed of 1.5GHz, 250GB HDD and 1Gbps NIC.

ii.

Client computer with 2GB Memory, Processor speed of 2.5GHz, 250GB HDD and 100Mbps NIC.

iii.

Two Monitor Units.

iv.

Two pairs Keyboard and mouse.

v.

A Network Switch.

vi.

A pair of 3 yards of Ethernet cables.

Software Requirements;
i.

Windows Server 2003 operating system.

ii.

Windows XP professional operating system

iii.

Oracle database 11gr2 software

iv.

Oracle Web Logic server 10.3.5

v.

Oracle forms and report 11g.

vi.

Adobe reader 11.

1.5 Research design

In my work I will make use of both the traditional waterfall approach to software development and incremental
build model. As my work is designed in a sequence from the start to finish. Ukem and Ofoegbu (2012) referred

Journal of Information Engineering and Applications

ISSN 2224-5782 (print) ISSN 2225-0506 (online)
Vol.4, No.11, 2014

www.iiste.org

to the Waterfall software life-cycle model as a traditional model because it was the first widely used software
development life cycle. They stated that it is part of Structured Software Engineering or the Structured Paradigm,
which is the older of the two earliest approaches to formal software engineering. I will also acknowledge that at
every stage of the development, improvements were made based upon the tests I carried out on the application
being developed, until I got my expected outcome. This research is about gathering students results to a
centralized location for users of the application to have access to. Hence in trying to address the identified
problems, as well as the deficiencies in the existing manual methods of students results management, I
interviewed stakeholders at the Nasarawa State University Keffi (NSUK), surveyed and analyzed the different
academic documents in use in the school, reviewed best practice literature regarding information technology
projects, I reviewed other Students Information Management Systems (SIMS) to gain in-depth understanding of
what my system should look like, I also collected comprehensive academic records from the Physics
Department, Nasarawa State University Keffi (NSUK) which I used for testing the system. This application must
be accessible to users from anywhere on campus so I had to make use of what I will classify as design models. I
made use of two levels of system design models. The first model is the logical model and the second model is
the physical model.
The logical model is about the database tables, data within these tables and the relationship between the tables
that make up the application. They logical model identifies entities (i.e. data), and what these entities are, can be
shown in a normalized and fully attributed entity-relationship diagram (ERD) representing the data model. An
entity-relationship diagram (ERD) is a data modeling technique that creates a graphical representation of the
entities, and the relationships between entities, within an information system, (Searchcrm, 2014). The entities
identified in my design are; faculties, departments, students, users, academic sessions, students registration and
academic courses registration. I will be going through these in details in chapter four of this dissertation.
The second model, physical model, and defines how the system is physically and technically implemented. The
output of the physical modeling is the database model. The database model contains the database table which
holds the data as described in the logical model, it also contains the physical datafiles in which the database
tables together with their data will be stored. I will be designing an application software utilizing oracles
database, forms and reports. This application will run on a server (computer) with network connectivity to the
client systems. It is recommended that both the application server and database server be on separate computers,
but because of the cost implication we will run both applications on the same computer, which is also fine. A
local area network (LAN) or intranet for this research will be set up for connectivity between the application
server, database server and client computers. Data will be stored in database tables, users will be able to key in
data to tables though forms which have been designed for this purpose, these forms will be the interface between
users and the database. These forms will run in web browsers, preferably internet explorer or Mozilla Firefox.
Users will be authenticated at the Welcome and Login pages before they can interact with the application and
database, therefore usernames and passwords will be required from users at the point of login, once successfully
authenticated by the system at login, users are re-directed to the appropriate page, depending on their system
defined privileges, where they can perform whatever actions their user privilege is entitled to perform. Student
records from the manual process already in use will be utilized in order to obtain data for testing the application.

Journal of Information Engineering and Applications

ISSN 2224-5782 (print) ISSN 2225-0506 (online)
Vol.4, No.11, 2014

www.iiste.org

Fig1. Application flowchart

1.6 Database Tables

i.

ADMINISTRATOR Table
This table holds the profile information of the application super users otherwise known as system
administrators. They have control of the software meaning that they can perform additional tasks that
other users cannot ordinarily perform. Every software of this nature has such users and this one is no
exception. The table contains the following columns; ADMIN_ID, TITLE, FRIST_NAME,
LAST_NAME, and DEPARMENT_ID. The column ADMIN_ID is the primary key column (primary
key disallows duplicate values and nulls in a column) every table should have a primary key column,
as this acts like table indexing.

ii.

ALL_COURCES Table
This table keeps the courses offered by students in different departments in the school. The table
contains the following columns; COURCE_ID, COURCE_TITLE, and COURCE_CODE. The
COURCE_ID is the primary key column.

iii. APP_USER_A Table

This table contains application login details for application administrators. The table columns are;
USRNAME, PASSWD and ADMIN_ID. The column ADMIN_ID is the primary key column.
iv.

APP_USER_L Table

Journal of Information Engineering and Applications

ISSN 2224-5782 (print) ISSN 2225-0506 (online)
Vol.4, No.11, 2014

www.iiste.org

This table contains application login details for application lecturers. The table columns are;
USRNAME, PASSWD and LECTURER_ID. The column LECTURER_ID is the primary key
column.
v.

APP_USER_S Table
This table contains application login details for application students. The table columns are;
USRNAME, PASSWD and MATRIG_NO. The column MATRIG_NO is the primary key column.

vi. DEPARTMENTS Table

This table holds information about the schools departments. The table contains the following columns;
DEPARTMENT_ID and DEPARTMENT_NAME. The column DEPARTMENT_ID is the primary
key column.
vii. GRADES Table
This is more like the main table in the database as all other tables relate to this table directly or in
some other way. This table holds students examination records. The table contains the following
columns; GRADES_ID,
SESSION1, REG_NUMBER, DEPARTMENT_ID, LEVEL1,
MATRIG_NO, FRIST_NAME, LAST_NAME, COURCE_CODE, GRADE, CREDIT_UNIT,
SCORE, LECTURER_ID and GRADE_POINT. The column GRADES_ID is the primary key
column.
viii. LECTURERS Table
This table holds the profile information of the application lecturers. The table contains the following
columns; LECTURER_ID, TITLE, FRIST_NAME, LAST_NAME, and DEPARMENT_ID. The
column LECTUTER_ID is the primary key column.
ix. REG_TABLE Table
This table contains students registration details i.e. if a student is registered for the semester this table
is used to store that information. The table contains the following columns; REG_ID,
REG_NUMBER, MATRIG_NO, FRIST_NAME, LAST_NAME, LEVEL1, DEPARTMENT_ID and
SESSION1. The column REG_ID is the primary key column.
x.

STUDENTS Table
This table holds the profile information of the application students. The table contains the following
columns; MATRIG_NO, TITLE, FRIST_NAME, LAST_NAME, and DEPARMENT_ID. The
column MATRIG_NO is the primary key column.

1.7

Application forms
i.

Welcome Screen
To access the application a web browser (internet explorer, Mozilla etc.) short cut with the address of
the application server will be placed on the desktop of all computers (computers to access the
application have to be on the same network with the application server) that will be accessing the
software for easy access to the application. Upon double clicking this short cut the welcome page will
be displayed.

Journal of Information Engineering and Applications

ISSN 2224-5782 (print) ISSN 2225-0506 (online)
Vol.4, No.11, 2014

www.iiste.org

Fig. 2 Welcome Screen.

The display in figure 2 is the applications welcome screen. As can be read from the screen if the user to log in
were to be a student, then the check box with student written beside it will be checked, before the continue
button is pressed. Otherwise if the user to log in was a lecturer or an administrator then the student check box
should be left unchecked.
1.8 Administration screen
If the student check box is left unchecked and the continue button is pressed then the administration screen is
displayed as shown in Fig 3.
1.9 Login Screen
On the application login screen as shown in figure 4, should a user fail to provide a valid username or password
he or she gets the Invalid username or password error message shown in figure 5
1.10

Result Screen

Once a student logs in he or she is presented with the result screen where the student result can be accessed as
shown in figure 4.5

Journal of Information Engineering and Applications

ISSN 2224-5782 (print) ISSN 2225-0506 (online)
Vol.4, No.11, 2014

www.iiste.org

Fig. 3

Fig. 4 Login Screen

Journal of Information Engineering and Applications

ISSN 2224-5782 (print) ISSN 2225-0506 (online)
Vol.4, No.11, 2014

www.iiste.org

Fig. 5 Invalid username or password message

1.11 Other forms used in the application are;
The Administrator form, this is the system administrators main form from where they can perform
administrative tasks, such as creation of new student, lecturer and other administrators profile with the
Student/lecturer/administrator profile forms also the administrator can edit these profiles with the
Student/lecturer/administrator profile edit forms. Also there are the Student Registration from, for
registering students, Course Menu form, for academic courses. Grades form for inputting student grades.
Grades Edit form for editing erroneously entered grades.
1.12 Summary of the Findings
Clearly this report has helped to emphasis the necessity of an automated student result system in schools, as it
simplifies the process of compiling and presenting students results. Computerization of this process reduces the
time, human involvement and errors that could occur while making use of the manual method. Most student
information systems in use today are server-based, with the application residing on a central computer server and
being accessed by client applications at various places within and even outside the school (Nmaju et al., 2013).
My application is no different as it utilizes an applications web and database server. The application runs as
already stated using a multitier architecture.
The application is meant to ease the processing of students results in tertiary institutions. The application was
successfully developed, tested, and found to be working as expected. It is capable of storing and retrieving
academic records with high speed and accuracy, and presenting useful information to its users. Its qualities are
the reduction in the cost of processing students results (an example would be the cost of purchase of papers)
reduction in the time spent in the computation of students grades and the elimination of duplication of
duplication of resources in terms of manpower and infrastructure. The system is flexible and runs in a web
browser. It is reasonably secure, enforces data integrity from the use of a relational database management
system, it also minimizes data redundancy and is user-friendly. With this application, the processing of students
results is automated, thereby reducing processing time and increasing accuracy. Automation Minimizes
Redundancy: The use of Relational Database Management System for storage of students data will help in
minimizing the redundancy in database in addition to maintain consistency, integrity and security of data.
(Ezenma et al., 2014).
1.13 Conclusion.
During the course of my dissertation, I found out that a computer aided information management system makes
information management much more convenient and efficient, it also makes for a more accurate information

Journal of Information Engineering and Applications

ISSN 2224-5782 (print) ISSN 2225-0506 (online)
Vol.4, No.11, 2014

www.iiste.org

management system in schools. This is opposed to the manual method, which is stressful, time consuming prone
to mistakes due to excessive dependence on the human element involved.
1.14

Recommendations

Having highlighted the usefulness of a computer based students result management system to schools, I
recommend the following to be implemented in schools;
i.

They should computerize all the department of the school, to ensure easy flow of information in the
schools.

ii.

They should ensure that all the staff of the user department are adequately trained to ensure smooth
implementation of the new system.

iii.

Even after computerization of the whole department, they must ensure that all the system are linked to one
central local network, protected with high security measures

Appendix.
Sample student result

10

Journal of Information Engineering and Applications

ISSN 2224-5782 (print) ISSN 2225-0506 (online)
Vol.4, No.11, 2014

www.iiste.org

References
Amar, J. S. and Mohini, B. (2009). Single Portal for Integrated Examination System. Journal of Emerging
technologies in e-Governance, (pp. 287-293).
Anigbogu, S.O. (2000). Computer Application and Operation, (1st ed., Vol. 1, No.2, pp. 30-39). Awka:
Optimum Press.
Barrett, S. (1999). Informations Systems: An Exploration of Factors Influencing Effective Use. Journal of
Research on Computing in Education, (Vol. 32, No. 1, pp. 4-16).
Brian, P. (2009). Oracle Database 11g: PL/SQL Fundamentals, (Vol. 10). Redwood City, California: Oracle
University Press.
Ekpenyong, M. E. (2008). A Real-Time IKBS for Students Results Computation. International Journal of
Physical Sciences, (Vol. 20, No. 3).
Eludire, A.A. (2011). The Design and Implementation of Student Academic Record Management System.
Research Journal of Applied Sciences, Engineering and Technology, (Vol.3, No. 8, pp. 707-712).
Emmanuel, B. and Choji, D. (2012). A Software Application for Colleges of Education Students Results
Processing. Journal of Information Engineering and Applications, (Vol. 2, No.11).
Ezenma, A. A., Emmanuel, B., and Choji, D. N. (2014). Design and Implementation of Result Processing
System for Public Secondary Schools in Nigeria. International Journal of Computer and Information
Technology, (Vol. 2, No 1, pp. 121-122). Retrieved from: http:// www.ijcit.com/
Ngoma, S. (2009). An Exploration of the Effectiveness of SIS in Managing Student Performance. (A final year
Dissertation in the School of Post Graduate Studies, Marlboro College, Vermont, USA). Retrieved from:
http://www.marlboro.edu/
North Carolina Department of Public Instruction. (2009). North Carolina Public Schools Complete
NCWISE Deployment; NCWISE is Largest Technology Project in Public Schools History. News Releases
2008-09. Retrieved from: http://www.dpi.state.nc.us/newsroom/news/2008-09/20090401-01
Searchcrm.
(2014).
Entity
Relationship
Diagram,
(Vol.
http://searchcrm.techtarget.com/definition/entity-relationship-diagram

1).Retrieved

from:

Student Examination Result Processing System. (2012). Retrieved from: http://15projects.com/projects/wpcontent/uploads/2012/06/Student-Examination-Result-Processing-System.docx

U.S. Department of Education. (2008). Computer and the Education System. U.S. Department of Education,
Washington, D.C. Retrieved from: http://www.ed.gov/
Ukem, E. O., and Ofoegbu, F. A. (2012). A Software Application for University Students Results Processing.
Journal of Theoretical and Applied Information Technology, (Vol. 35, No.1). Retrieved from:
http://www.jatit.org/
Vecchioli, L., (1999). A Process for Evaluating Student Records Management Software. Practical Assessment,
Research and Evaluation
Wayman, J.C., Stringfield, S., and Yakimowski, M. (2005). Software Enabling School Improvement through
Analysis of Student Data, (Vol. 2, No.2, pp. 17-42). Center for Research on the Education of Students
Placed at Risk (CRESPAR), U.S. Department of Education, Washington, D.C. Retrieved from:
http://www.ed.gov/
Wikipedia.
(2014).
Student
information
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Student_information_system

11

system.

Retrieved

from:

The IISTE is a pioneer in the Open-Access hosting service and academic event
management. The aim of the firm is Accelerating Global Knowledge Sharing.
More information about the firm can be found on the homepage:
http://www.iiste.org
CALL FOR JOURNAL PAPERS
There are more than 30 peer-reviewed academic journals hosted under the hosting
platform.
Prospective authors of journals can find the submission instruction on the
following page: http://www.iiste.org/journals/ All the journals articles are available
online to the readers all over the world without financial, legal, or technical barriers
other than those inseparable from gaining access to the internet itself. Paper version
of the journals is also available upon request of readers and authors.

MORE RESOURCES
Book publication information: http://www.iiste.org/book/

IISTE Knowledge Sharing Partners

EBSCO, Index Copernicus, Ulrich's Periodicals Directory, JournalTOCS, PKP Open
Archives Harvester, Bielefeld Academic Search Engine, Elektronische
Zeitschriftenbibliothek EZB, Open J-Gate, OCLC WorldCat, Universe Digtial
Library , NewJour, Google Scholar