Psychology and Crime - David Putwain
Psychology and Crime - David Putwain
Psychology and Crime - David Putwain
Crime
Debates in Psychology
Andy Bell
Psychopathology
John D. Stirling and Jonathan
S.E. Hellewell
Therapeutic Approaches in
Psychology
Susan Cave
BIO-PSYCHOLOGY
Awareness: Biorhythms, sleep and
dreaming
Evie Bentley
Theoretical Approaches in
Psychology
Matt Jarvis
SOCIAL PSYCHOLOGY
Interpersonal Relationships
Diana Dwyer
Cortical Functions
John Stirling
Social Cognition
Donald C. Pennington
Social Influences
Kevin Wren
COGNITIVE PSYCHOLOGY
Attention and Pattern Recognition
Nick Lund
Language and Thought
Nick Lund
Memory and Forgetting
John Henderson
Perception: Theory,
development and organisation
Paul Rookes and Jane Willson
DEVELOPMENTAL PSYCHOLOGY
Adulthood
Evie Bentley
Early Socialisation: Sociability and
attachment
Cara Flanagan
Social and Personality Development
Tina Abbott
PERSPECTIVES AND RESEARCH
Cognitive Development
Lisa Oakley
Controversies in Psychology
Philip Banyard
COMPARATIVE PSYCHOLOGY
Animal Cognition
Nick Lund
Determinants of Animal
Behaviour
Jo-Anne Cartwright
Evolutionary Explanations of Human
Behaviour
John Cartwright
OTHER TITLES
Health Psychology
Anthony Curtis
Psychology and Crime
David Putwain and Aidan Sammons
Psychology and Education
Susan Bentham
Psychology and Work
Christine Hodson
Sport Psychology
Matt Jarvis
STUDY GUIDE
Exam Success in AQA-A Psychology
Paul Humphreys (forthcoming)
David Putwain
and Aidan Sammons
Contents
xiii
xv
1 Introduction
WHAT IS CRIMINOLOGICAL PSYCHOLOGY? 2
Applying psychological principles to crime 3
Different types of criminological psychology 4
Forensic psychology 5
Offender profiling 7
13
vii
CONTENTS
Burglary 22
Vehicle theft 23
Violent crime 23
The effects of victimisation 23
Belief in a just world 24
Locus of control 25
Fear of crime 25
Chapter summary 26
3 Biologically oriented explanations of
criminal behaviour
CONSTITUTIONAL THEORIES OF CRIMINALITY 30
Lombrosos theory of criminal types 30
Evaluation of Lombrosos theory 30
Sheldons theory of somatotypes 31
Evaluation of Sheldons theory 31
RECENT GENETIC RESEARCH INTO CRIMINALITY 32
Family studies 33
Twin studies 33
Adoption studies 34
Evaluation of genetic research 36
BIOLOGICAL RESEARCH INTO CRIMINALITY 37
Structural brain abnormalities 37
EYSENCKS PERSONALITY THEORY 38
Evaluation of Eysencks theory 39
Chapter summary 40
29
CONTENTS
63
6 Offender profiling
81
PRINCIPLES OF OFFENDER PROFILING 82
The FBI approach: crime scene analysis 84
Evaluation of crime scene analysis 86
Offender profiling in the UK: investigative psychology 88
Evaluation of investigative psychology 91
Biases and pitfalls in offender profiling 92
Chapter summary 94
ix
CONTENTS
95
121
CONTENTS
139
10 Study aids
157
IMPROVING YOUR ESSAY WRITING SKILLS 157
Question One: OCR specimen question 2000 158
Question Two: Edexcel specimen question 2000 162
xi
CONTENTS
xii
173
179
197
Figures
1.1 Psychological approaches that can be applied to
crime and the legal system
1.2 The forensic psychologist in his/her clinical role
1.3 The forensic psychologist in his/her experimental
role
1.4 Brussels profile of the New York City Mad Bomber
1.5 Psychological autopsy report
6.1 The Narborough Inquiry
6.2 A fictional case study
6.3 Two major approaches to offender profiling
6.4 Canters approach to profiling: The Railway Rapist
7.1 Summary of research into the effects of misleading
questions
7.2 An example of a face reconstructed by a witness
using identikit and photofit techniques
7.3 The four stages of the cognitive interview
8.1 Some examples of two-part contrasts and threepart lists
8.2 Stereotypes of criminals and non-criminals
8.3 Characteristics of genuine and false accounts of
sexual abuse using child witnesses
4
6
7
8
9
81
83
84
90
110
114
117
125
132
136
xiii
Tables
1.1 Coverage of the different A-level specifications
in this book
4.1 Thinking errors in Yochelson and Samenows
criminal personality
4.2 Levels and stages of moral development in
Kohlbergs theory
5.1 Inhibitors and facilitators of effective communication
in interviews
5.2 Interrogation techniques
5.3 Police interview tactics
5.4 Types of false confession
5.5 Important factors in assessing the reliability of
confessions
6.1 Organised and disorganised murderers
6.2 Different types of rapist
7.1 Ways in which witnesses may assist the police
8.1 Comparison of adversarial and inquisitorial trial
procedures
8.2 Summary of the Yale Model of persuasion
8.3 Stages in jury decision making
8.4 Group processes which may affect jury decisions
xiv
10
54
56
69
71
73
75
76
85
87
96
122
124
129
130
Acknowledgements
xv
1
Introduction
INTRODUCTION
Figure 1.1 Psychological approaches that can be applied to crime and the
legal system
INTRODUCTION
There is some debate over what the term forensic psychology actually
refers to. It has been taken by some to refer to clinical psychologists
who primarily work with offenders. This is not surprising when it is
considered that a substantial number of people who call themselves
forensic psychologists are clinical psychologists working in the prison
and probation services and in special hospitals (Blackburn 1996). In
this capacity they may be involved in the assessment and treatment
of particular types of offender, for example, sex offenders. They may
also play a role in assessing the risks that may be involved when an
offender is released. The Committee on Ethical Guidelines for Forensic
Psychologists (1991) defines forensic psychology as:
All forms of professional psychological conduct when acting,
with definable foreknowledge, as a psychological expert on
explicitly psycho-legal issues, in direct assistance to courts,
parties to legal proceedings, correctional and forensic mental
health facilities.
Although it is rather longwinded, this definition captures a broader
range of activities than the simple definition of clinical psychologists
working with offenders. In fact, any kind of psychologist (clinical,
educational or social, to name but a few) could be considered to be a
forensic psychologist when they apply their expertise to legal questions.
According to Blackburn (1996), no matter what kind of background
5