Power Quality Improvement Using ZSI Based STATCOM in Radial and Weakly Meshed Distribution Systems
Power Quality Improvement Using ZSI Based STATCOM in Radial and Weakly Meshed Distribution Systems
Power Quality Improvement Using ZSI Based STATCOM in Radial and Weakly Meshed Distribution Systems
www.ijareeie.com
5365
Copyright to IJAREEIE
www.ijareeie.com
5366
Copyright to IJAREEIE
www.ijareeie.com
5367
Fig3b single line diagram of IEEE 33-bus radial distribution system with five tie-lines(weakly meshed)
(A)SIMULINK model of PI controller
SIMULINK model of PI controller is shown in Fig3c.The load voltage is fed to the summing point.
This voltage is compared with reference voltage(set at 5v) and the error is fed to PI controller(with KP=2 and
KI=0.5). Output of the PI controller is given to pulse generator to produce the required pulse width. These
pulses are given to the STATCOM to inject the voltage into the system for compensation.
Copyright to IJAREEIE
www.ijareeie.com
5368
s ignal
-K -
rm s
M ux
RM S -s
VPQ_S
1
m
line -s
V
I
i
+
-
+
-
-K -
PQ
P Qs
v
Vs
RL
+
-
s ignal
-K -
rm s
RM S -r
Vr
M ux
line -r
i
+
-
PQ
-K -
P Qr
R
2
.
Fig3f SIMULINK model of a single phase source
Copyright to IJAREEIE
www.ijareeie.com
5369
29-30
m
R
29
Load16
30-31
m
R
30
Load17
m
R
31-32
31
32-33
m
R
S
Load18
[B28]
[B27]
32
Load19
[B29]
m
R
33
Load20
[B30]
[B31]
[B24]
[B23]
mI/P
28-29
m
R
mI/P
27-28
27
Load14
[B26]
Load12
mI/P
m
R
25
24-25
mI/P
mI/P
m
R
mI/P
24
Load11
26-27
26
mI/P
m
R
23-24
Load10
mI/P
23
3-23
mI/P
m
R
Load13
m
R
mI/P
po we rgui
mI/P
6-26
S
Discre te ,
Ts = 5e -005 s.
[B33]
[B25]
[B32]
[B1]
source
m
R
10
9-10
Load25
m
R
11
Load26
12
m
R
10-11
m
R
11-12
Load27
[B9]
13
12-13Load28
m
R
14
13-14
Load29
[B10]
[B11]
m
R
15
14-15
Load30
[B12]
m
R
16
Load32
m
R
15-16
[B13]
17
16-17
Load33
m
R
18
17-18
Load34
[B15]
[B14]
[B5]
[B16]
[B17]
mI/P
Load24
[B4]
mI/P
8-9
[B8]
mI/P
m
R
Load22
[B3]
mI/P
7-8
mI/P
m
R
[B7]
[B2]
mI/P
Load23
[B1]
mI/P
6-7
mI/P
m
R
S
[B6]
mI/P
6
Load21
[B5]
mI/P
m
R
5-6
mI/P
Load4
[B4]
4-5
Load3
[B3]
mI/P
mI/P
m
R
3-4
Load2
mI/P
m
R
2-3
Load1
mI/P
m
R
1-2
33 BUS
VOLTAGES in PU
mI/P
m
R
m O/P
mI/P
[B18]
[B6]
[B7]
[B8]
[B2]
m
R
[B10]
19
Load9
20
m
R
19-20
mI/P
2-19
[B13]
Load8
m
R
S
mI/P
[B9]
[B11]
[B12]
20-21
21
[B14]
[B15]
22
m
R
[B20]
[B19]
[B16]
21-22
Load5
mI/P
Load7
[B19]
mI/P
[B17]
[B18]
[B20]
[B21]
[B22]
[B21]
[B22]
[B23]
[B24]
[B25]
[B26]
[B27]
[B28]
[B29]
[B30]
[B31]
[B32]
[B33]
Fig3g SIMULINK model of IEEE 33-bus radial distribution system without STATCOM
28
Load15
29-30
m
R
29
Load16
30-31
m
R
30
Load17
m
R
31-32
31
32-33
m
R
S
Load18
[B28]
32
Load19
[B29]
m
R
33
Load20
[B30]
[B31]
[B24]
[B23]
mI/P
28-29
m
R
[B27]
mI/P
27-28
27
Load14
[B26]
Load12
mI/P
m
R
25
24-25
mI/P
mI/P
m
R
mI/P
24
Load11
26-27
26
mI/P
m
R
23-24
Load10
mI/P
23
3-23
mI/P
m
R
Load13
m
R
mI/P
p o we rg ui
mI/P
6-26
S
Dis cre te ,
T s = 5e -005 s .
[B33]
[B25]
[B32]
[B1]
S1
S2
G
source
Subsystem1
m
R
10
9-10
Load25
m
R
11
Load26
12
m
R
10-11
m
R
11-12
Load27
[B9]
13
12-13Load28
m
R
14
13-14
Load29
[B10]
[B11]
m
R
15
14-15
Load30
[B12]
m
R
16
Load32
m
R
15-16
[B13]
17
16-17
Load33
m
R
18
17-18
mI/P
Load24
[B4]
mI/P
8-9
[B8]
mI/P
m
R
Load22
[B3]
mI/P
7-8
mI/P
m
R
[B7]
[B2]
mI/P
Load23
[B1]
mI/P
6-7
mI/P
m
R
S
[B6]
mI/P
6
Load21
[B5]
mI/P
m
R
5-6
mI/P
Load4
[B4]
4-5
Load3
[B3]
mI/P
mI/P
m
R
3-4
Load2
mI/P
m
R
2-3
Load1
mI/P
m
R
1-2
33 BUS
VOLTAGES in PU
mI/P
m
R
m O/P
mI/P
Load34
[B15]
[B14]
[B5]
[B16]
[B17]
[B18]
[B6]
[B7]
[B8]
[B2]
m
R
[B10]
[B11]
[B13]
Load9
20
m
R
19-20
mI/P
2-19
[B12]
19
Load8
m
R
S
mI/P
[B9]
20-21
21
[B14]
[B15]
22
m
R
[B20]
[B19]
[B16]
21-22
Load7
[B22]
[B21]
Load5
mI/P
[B19]
mI/P
[B17]
[B18]
[B20]
[B21]
[B22]
[B23]
[B24]
[B25]
[B26]
[B27]
[B28]
[B29]
[B30]
[B31]
[B32]
[B33]
Fig3h SIMULINK model of IEEE 33-bus radial distribution system with STATCOM at 6th bus
25-29
Tie Line
Load2
169.7
55.31
m
R
10.96
99.45
967.7
10.73
59.6
579.3
577.6
[B2]
10.56
226.8
64.06
Load4
[B4]
19
Load9
10.56
m
R
5-6
Load21
[B5]
487.9
10.7
863.6
774.5
526.1
484.4
20
m
R
19-20
Load8
31.95
10.62
10.61
10.64
57.2
56.14
28.57
18.7
404.9
217.9
125.2
31.85
7-8
123.4
6.878
10.56
10.52
-19.13
-34.65
205.5
62.2
m
R
Load22
8-9
Load24
m
R
10
9-10
Load25
[B19]
11
[B24]
10.94
10.45
89.1
86.08
10.44
39.57
38.23
[B25]
[B26]
m I/P
m I/P
m I/P
10.44
9.867
Load26
10.43
10.56
55.39
55.32
92.99
18.45
18.43
127.9
10.5
10.48
40.81
200.2
10.45
17.67
127.6
145.2
10.5
150.4
122.8
90.64
12
S
11-12
Load27
[B11]
10.56
186.2
93.26
17.68
90.84
[B9]
10.61
186.7
10.5
200.5
m
R
13
12-13Load28
m
R
14
13-14
Load29
m
R
14-15
Load30
90.88
10.44
90.96
m
R
16
10.52
32.26
54.93
90.79
m
R
15-16
Load32
55.37
27.64
17
16-17
Load33
m
R
18
17-18
Load34
[B15]
[B14]
54.77
91.07
109.4
[B13]
10.56
41.52
[B16]
[B17]
[B18]
10.5
10.5
109.6
54.71
10.48
10.45
10.44
72.96
9.115
54.54
54.17
81.09
18.17
18.04
36.01
32.01
10.65
9.853
10.45
145.6
108.9
15
[B12]
10.56
18-33
Tie Line
10.48
298.6
304.9
204.8
10.56
202.5
10.56
215.5
10.61
200.2
Load7
296.3
12-22
Tie Line
22
m
R
120.4
202.5
10.5
214.4
m
R
21-22
119.3
Load5
m
R
9-15
Tie Line
[B22]
[B21]
10.7
[B22]
[B23]
35.99
10.5
40.82
150.6
m
R
10-11
10.62
10.75
[B21]
10.43
10.52
-46.78
m
R
244
S
10.75
54.05
-18.78
10.94
[B20]
71.21
10.7
383.1
[B20]
10.48
[B17]
[B18]
[B8]
m
R
8-21
Tie Line1
302.6
[B19]
10.43
44.2
54.78
206.2
-46.78
10.56
-0.7017
m
R
-34.64
-19.13
10.56
138.2
m
R
10.56
-0.676
242.3
10.5
[B33]
10.43
89.98
10.56
6.879
10.65
21
10.5
[B16]
Load20
44.21
10.56
62.24
333.1
Load23
384.4
m
R
20-21
10.52
[B14]
[B15]
33
10.43
-18.77
[B32]
233.3
135.3
10.56
10.56
6-7
m
R
10.43
10.44
m
R
126.2
S
[B6]
10.73
777.5
76.81
10.75
134.5
[B31]
189.1
10.7
2-19
10.56
368.8
182.1
[B10]
10.75
115.4
538.1
m
R
10.56
BUS VOLTAGES
GRAPHS
[B13]
876.9
10.49
m I/P
[B10]
[B11]
[B12]
10.94
38.74
Load19
71.41
109.9
150.4
139.1
m I/P
[B9]
966
10.61
32
10.44
233.5
10.44
63.1
4-5
10.78
87.24
10.94
10.62
32-33
m
R
S
Load18
135.9
18.42
334.3
363.2
m I/P
10.96
10.78
31-32
31
10.49
[B30]
552.3
398.3
m
R
10.82
10.82
10.64
[B7]
[B8]
m I/P
[B4]
[B5]
[B6]
m
R
370.2
10.49
90.95
218.2
[B7]
10.96
[B2]
[B3]
30
Load17
227.7
10.52
326.5
11
[B1]
30-31
m
R
10.52
553.9
10.56
10.61
10.62
405.2
958.7
Load3
[B29]
10.52
55.88
10.64
10.64
477.2
[B3]
Load16
151.2
382.7
23.26
369.7
29
10.56
327.4
23.33
966.3
3-4
29-30
m
R
[B28]
10.56
10.61
m I/P
Load1
194.4
m I/P
33 BUS
VOLTAGES in PU
440.3
56.03
m I/P
1024
10.62
218
m I/P
10.73
1143
1097
2-3
496.9
[B27]
m I/P
10.78
2462
Load15
384.4
171.1
10.61
10.73
1751
1-2
28
10.61
194.7
183.8
3560
28-29
m
R
S
Load14
440.8
386.4
1027
400.3
m
R
27-28
27
10.62
10.78
479.6
m
R
[B26]
m I/P
186.7
26-27
26
Load13
m I/P
392.5
47.83
1148
1113
m
R
10.62
m I/P
1758
86.18
10.82
2493
m O/P
218.3
10.54
10.82
m I/P
source
10.63
1758
m I/P
497.4
m I/P
10.96
m
R
10.64
141.3
[B25]
10.76
10.96
m I/P
11
3572
Load12
m I/P
11
3572
[B1]
24-25
[B24]
[B23]
6-26
337.4
m I/P
Load10
338
10.52
m I/P
m I/P
Load11
25
m I/P
23-24
m
R
m I/P
23
3-23
24
141.9
10.54
325.7
m
R
m I/P
724.4
m I/P
10.54
m I/P
m
R
m
R
329.7
1122
516.4
m I/P
powe rgui
729.5
526
10.63
1220
573.8
m I/P
10.63
1134
10.76
m I/P
10.76
1227
578.7
m I/P
10.82
C ontinuous
10.65
10.7
10.65
10.76
85.26
84.52
10.63
37.86
37.53
10.54
[B27]
10.62
[B28]
10.61
[B29]
10.56
[B30]
10.52
[B31]
10.49
[B32]
10.44
[B33]
10.43
Fig3i SIMULINK model of IEEE 33-bus weakly meshed distribution system without STATCOM
25-29
Tie Line
m
R
27-28
27
S
m I/P
Load14
28-29
m
R
28
Load15
29-30
m
R
29
Load16
30-31
m
R
30
Load17
[B26]
Load12
m
R
31-32
31
S
Load18
[B28]
[B27]
32-33
m
R
32
m I/P
26-27
26
25
24-25
Load19
[B29]
m
R
33
Load20
[B30]
[B31]
[B24]
[B23]
m I/P
Load10
m
R
m I/P
m I/P
Load11
m I/P
24
23-24
m I/P
m
R
m I/P
23
3-23
m I/P
m
R
Load13
m
R
m I/P
6-26
S
powe rgui
m I/P
m
R
Discre te ,
Ts = 5e -005 s.
[B33]
[B25]
[B32]
m
R
[B1]
S1
18-33
Tie Line
S2
G
source
S
m
R
Load22
[B2]
[B8]
8-9
Load24
m
R
10
9-10
Load25
m
R
11
S
10-11
Load26
12
m
R
11-12
Load27
[B9]
m
R
13
12-13Load28
m
R
14
13-14
Load29
[B10]
[B11]
[B3]
m
R
15
14-15
Load30
[B12]
m
R
16
15-16
Load32
[B13]
[B4]
[B16]
[B7]
[B8]
[B13]
m
R
S
BUS VOLTAGES
GRAPHS
19
2-19
Load9
m
R
19-20
20
Load8
S
m I/P
[B2]
[B10]
m I/P
[B9]
[B11]
[B12]
[B15]
[B19]
16-17
Load33
m
R
[B17]
18
17-18
Load34
[B18]
m
R
8-21
Tie Line
m
R
[B20]
[B16]
m
R
22
12-22
Tie Line
S
21-22
m
R
Load5
m I/P
Load7
m I/P
[B17]
[B18]
[B19]
17
20-21
21
[B14]
m
R
[B15]
[B14]
[B5]
[B6]
m I/P
7-8
m I/P
m
R
m I/P
m I/P
[B7]
m I/P
Load23
m I/P
6-7
m I/P
m
R
S
[B6]
[B1]
m I/P
m I/P
[B5]
Load21
m I/P
5-6
m I/P
m
R
Load4
[B4]
m I/P
m
R
4-5
Load3
[B3]
3-4
Load2
m I/P
Load1
Subsystem1
m
R
2-3
m I/P
m
R
1-2
33 BUS
VOLTAGES in PU
m I/P
m
R
m I/P
m O/P
m I/P
m
R
9-15
Tie Line
[B20]
[B21]
[B22]
[B21]
[B22]
[B23]
[B24]
[B25]
[B26]
[B27]
[B28]
[B29]
[B30]
[B31]
[B32]
[B33]
Fig3j SIMULINK model of IEEE 33-bus weakly meshed distribution system with STATCOM at 6th bus
Copyright to IJAREEIE
www.ijareeie.com
5370
Case(b)
Load voltages
without
STATCOM(in pu)
0.99665
0.99653
0.99653
0.99652
0.98107
0.98030
0.98403
0.98042
0.97322
0.97197
0.97976
0.97073
0.96555
0.96379
0.97580
0.96120
0.94733
1.01422
0.96690
0.93333
0.94336
1.00997
0.96560
1.01206
0.93789
1.00412
0.96422
1.00657
0.93089
0.99662
0.96041
0.99875
10
0.92441
0.98969
0.959863
0.99543
11
0.92346
0.988671
0.959862
0.99513
12
0.92178
0.98688
0.960027
0.99471
13
0.91503
0.97964
0.95621
0.99103
14
0.91252
0.97696
0.95496
0.98994
15
0.91065
0.97495
0.95468
0.98978
16
0.90947
0.97334
0.95280
0.98714
17
0.9072
0.97096
0.94959
0.98172
18
0.90658
0.97025
0.94858
0.97994
19
0.99596
0.99584
0.99446
0.99634
20
0.99131
0.99185
0.97748
0.99598
21
0.99039
0.99026
0.97283
0.99718
22
0.98956
0.98944
0.96858
0.99615
Copyright to IJAREEIE
www.ijareeie.com
5371
0.97661
0.97584
0.97788
0.97870
24
0.96832
0.96755
0.96613
0.97706
25
0.96419
0.96343
0.96504
0.97974
26
0.94554
1.01231
0.96584
1.01893
27
0.94321
1.00981
0.96453
1.01534
28
0.93389
0.99839
0.95966
0.99762
29
0.92732
0.99280
0.95647
0.98483
30
0.92432
0.98462
0.95353
0.98214
31
0.91968
0.98462
0.94924
0.97891
32
0.91865
0.98352
0.94838
0.97847
33
0.91834
0.98318
0.94832
0.97905
V.CONCLUSION
This work presents the possibility of using Z-Source Inverter based STATCOM system. The 33-bus IEEE
radial and weakly meshed distribution systems are modeled and simulated using MATLAB/SIMULINK and results
are presented. The simulation results of 33-bus IEEE radial and weakly meshed distribution systems with and without
STATCOM are presented. Simulation studies were done using single phase model of balanced three phase system. It is
found that voltage compensation is done by connecting the STATCOM. Both IEEE radial and weakly mesh
distribution system have improved power quality. The radial distribution system with five tie-lines has further
improved reliability compared with radial distribution system. The scope for future work is simulation can also be done
using PSCAD or PSIM. The simulation studies can be extended to 64-bus and 128-bus systems. Testing can also be
done on extremely large real time power systems and also the laboratory model for STATCOM can be done using
Micro-controller or DSP processor.
REFERENCES
[1] N.G.Hingorani and L.Gyugyi, understanding FACTS, Concepts and technology of Flexible AC Transmission systems, Piscataway, NJ;
IEEE Press, 2000.
[2] A.Ghosh and G.Ledwich ,Power Quality Enhancement using custom power Devices, Kluwer Academic Publishers,2002.
[3]
Baran M.E and Wu F F.1989.Network Reconfiguration in distribution systems for loss reduction and load balancing. IEEE Transon
PERD,PWRD-(2),pp.1401-107,1989.
[4] Shirmohammadi D,Hong HW,Semlyen A,Luo GX.Compensation based power flow method for weakly meshed distribution networks.
IEEE Trans. On Power Syst.3(2):753-762,1988.
[5] S.Ghosh and D.Das Method for load flow solution of Radial distribution networks.IEE PartC,146(4):641,1994
[6
B.Justus Rabi and Arumugam, Harmonics study and comparison of Z-Source inverter with Traditional Inverters, American journal of
Applied sciences2(10):1418-1426,2005.
[7]
R.Mienski,R.Pawelek and I.Wasiak, Shunt compensation for power quality improvement using a STATCOM controller: Modelling and
simulation,IEEE Proce., vol.151,No.2,March2004.
[8]
S.Sivanagaraju,J.Viswanatha and M.Giridhar, A loop based load flow method for weakly meshed distribution network, ARPN J.of
Engineering and Applied sciences,vol.3,no.4,pp.55-59.Aug.2008.
[9]
N.Usha and M.Vijaya kumar Comparison of pus-pull and Z-source Inverter based STATCOM systems, International Journal of
Electronics and Electrical Engineering,Vol.6,Number1,pp.55-65,2013.
[10] N.Usha and M.Vijaya kumar Enhancement of power Quality in Thirty Bus system using ZSI based STATCOM International Journal of
Modern Engineering Research,vol.3,Issue.2 pp-773-778. March-April.2013
Copyright to IJAREEIE
www.ijareeie.com
5372