Custom PC May
Custom PC May
THE BESTSELLING MAG FOR PC HARDWARE, OVERCLOCKING, GAMING & MODDING / ISSUE 128
Solid State
Showdown
Unleash your
PCs true speed
256GB OF HIGHSPEED
STORAGE FOR JUST 100
BOOT WINDOWS IN
UNDER 12 SECONDS
HOW TO
MOD AN ALLINONE
LIQUID COOLER
REVIEWED
NVIDIA GEFORCE
GTX TITAN BLACK
MAY 2014/5.99
23
SSDs TESTED
&< ,23 * ,* + 84? %
2 ,2)* 6, 3.2
*
,0"+ &!* *%* *$ *& &%.
%%& ! *! *% %&#*. !/ %$ !* - /*
(&6 (,*
,;2 =
((
Welcome
Custom PC Issue 128
Editorial
EDITOR
Ben Hardwidge
[email protected]
LABS
Matthew Lambert, Mike Jennings
MODDING EDITOR
Antony Leather
GAMES EDITOR
Rick Lane
MANAGING DIRECTOR
DENNIS TECHNOLOGY
John Garewal
ART EDITOR
Bill Bagnall
CEO
Ian Westwood
PRODUCTION EDITOR
Julie Birrell
CONTRIBUTORS
Gareth Halfacree, James Gorbold,
Jim Killock, Paul Goodhead,
Simon Treadaway, Tracy King
PHOTOGRAPHY
Antony Leather, Danny Bird,
Gareth Halfacree
Advertising
GROUP ADVERTISING MANAGER
Ben Topp
+44 (0)20 7907 6625
[email protected]
DEPUTY ADVERTISING MANAGER
Adam McDonnell
+44 (0)20 7907 6620
[email protected]
US ADVERTISING DIRECTOR
Matthew Sullivan-Pond
+1 646 717 9555
[email protected]
NEWSTRADE DIRECTOR
David Barker
FINANCE DIRECTOR
Brett Reynolds
GROUP FINANCE DIRECTOR
Ian Leggett
CHIEF EXECUTIVE
James Tye
CHAIRMAN
Felix Dennis
Subscriptions
You can manage your existing subscription
through www.subsinfo.co.uk this should be
your first port of call if you have any queries
about your subscription. Email: custompc@
servicehelpline.co.uk
Annual subs: UK 39.99
UK subs: 0844 844 0032
Overseas subs:
Europe 60, ROW 80
Overseas subs: +44 (0)1795 592 906
LICENSING, REPRINTS, EPRINTS
Wrights Media
0800-051-8327 (Toll Free)
Printed by BGP
Distributed by Seymour Distribution
Tel: 020 7429 4001
OVERSEAS NEWSSTAND
Geraldine Grobler
Seymour International Ltd
+44 (0)20 7429 4066
C U S TO M P C / ISSUE 128
Contents
Welcome to Issue 128
Cover story
40 Solid state showdown
We reckon every PC should be fitted
with an SSD now the difference
they make to your everyday
computing experience is massive,
from boot times to software and
game loading times, as well as
general responsiveness. Price isnt
a barrier any more either, with some
drives now dipping below 40p per
GB. Almost any modern SSD will be
a significant upgrade from a hard
disk, but that doesnt mean you
should rush out and buy the cheapest
one. NAND flash and SSD controllers
come in many flavours. Thankfully,
weve rounded up 23 of the latest
SSDs, from 240GB to a whopping
1TB, with a number of different
controllers, to help you find your
ideal solid state partner
Highlights
COVER STORY
PAGE 40
20
94
10 Online dating
Tracy King analyses press outrage
about children accessing online
dating sites.
20 Nvidia Maxwell
Nvidias new Maxwell GPU
architecture appears, in a surprisingly
cheap GPU.
88 Extreme Wi-Fi
62 PC head to head
Computer Planet and Falcon PC build
systems based on AMD Kaveri APUs.
98 AMD Mantle
AMDs new API is finally out, and
weve tried it out in Battlefield 4.
liquid cooler
All-in-one liquid coolers are great, but
they lack the good looks and flexibility
of custom loops. All is not lost though.
Antony Leather shows you how to
replace an all-in-one coolers tubing
and even add a reservoir.
41
88
116
Reviewed
this month
PRODUCTS
REVIEWED
Hardware
CPU COOLERS
19 Corsair Hydro H105
24 Deepcool Gamer Storm Lucifer
GRAPHICS CARDS
20 Nvidia GeForce GTX 750 Ti
22 Nvidia GeForce GTX Titan Black
102
78
MOTHERBOARD
26 Gigabyte GA-Z87-HD3
NAS BOX
28 Zyxel NSA325 v2
MOUSE
28 Ozone Neon
Custom kit
36 Booq Boa Nerve Graphite
36 Kingston 16GB DataTraveler
Locker+ G3
36 Elgato Smart Key
37 Robocup
37 Icy Box IC-SP001-BT
37 Microlab H50BT
110
Regulars
8
10
12
14
32
36
62
66
77
86
102
107
108
110
114
116
120
121
122 James Gorbold
Cover guide
40
88
42
42
42
43
43
43
44
44
45
45
48
48
48
50
50
52
52
52
53
53
54
54
54
Games
22
110
78
80
82
83
84
OPINION
WIFIDELITY
Intels Broadwell CPUs might be coming out soon, but Ben Hardwidge
is much more excited by Asus 802.11ac wireless kit
ireless accelerators. Thats what Id call Asus latest
802.11ac Wi-Fi adaptors (see p88). Thats because
network is a word that makes you yawn before youve
even finished reading it. Home networks might be standard now,
but networking is still up there with infrastructure and
enterprise in terms of words that end up in the same line as
tedious business jargon such as solutions.
Thats a shame, because networking is now anything but
dull, as weve found out in our Extreme Wi-Fi feature this month.
Asus Wi-Fi adaptors even have large pink heatsinks attached
to them they look like proper expansion cards that are worthy
of a PCI-E slot.
The bigger deal, of course, is Wi-Fi speeds,
which have come on a long way since the
11Mb/sec days of 802.11b. As we found out,
theyre not quite in the league of beefy
bandwidth claimed by the kit manufacturers,
and they still cant match Gigabit Ethernet,
but theyre still plenty fast enough for HD
video streaming and accessing network
storage, and thats what matters in the home.
I for one will now be upgrading my home
network, which currently involves various Cat 6 cables trailing
in front of doors, ready to trip up my already clumsy other half
while shes stumbling into the bedroom with a mug of tea. If
you own your home, and you have the DIY know-how, you can
of course wire up Ethernet sockets in the appropriate rooms,
getting high-speed network access without trailing cables across
the house. But that isnt an option for most of the folks who rent
their home.
Another option is a homeplug network, which cuts out cable
clutter, but means you end up with reduced network speeds. Also,
while Ive never had any trouble with homeplug networking,
various friends have reported problems with interference from
Ben Hardwidge is the editor of Custom PC. He likes PCs, heavy metal, real ale and Warhammer 40,000.
@custompcmag
0D[,PXV 9,
([WUHPH
2& 3DQHO
0D[,PXV 9,
+HUR
0D[,PXV 9,
0D[,PXV 9,
,PSDFW
)RUPXOD
0D[LPXV 9, 6HULHV
52* H[FOXVLYLW\ DW DQ
DFFHVVLEOH SULFH
0D[,PXV 9,
*HQH
ZZZIDFHERRNFRP$68652*8.
$686 7KH :RUOGV %HVW 6HOOLQJ DQG 0RVW $ZDUG :LQQLQJ 0RWKHUERDUGV
OPINION
BAD DATES
Should we worry about children accessing online dating?
Tracy King analyses the outrage in the press
f youre single then you may well be a member of an
Internet dating site. If youre not single, then its
increasingly likely that you met your partner online. I
met my boyfriend in a chatroom for science enthusiasts, a fact
he hid from his friends for many years.
Despite the ever-blurring lines between the Internet and what
I lovingly call the outernet, and others call meatspace, theres
still a stigma attached to finding romantic partners online.
However, Internet dating continues to rise and is now a global
industry worth 2 billion.
One of the latest members of the dating industry is super-app
Tinder. In the UK, its added a million new users since Christmas,
apparently offering you a quick way to hook
up with like-minded people. By like-minded
I mean also want to get laid, but the app
developers in a recent Guardian interview
were at pains to insist that isnt the case.
Co-founder Justin Mateen said, We never
intended it to be a dating platform. Its a social
discovery platform,facilitating an introduction
between two people, which I find funny
because I dont know anyone who doesnt
describe it as like Grindr, but not gay.
Theres even an app for threesomes, unpronouncably called
3nder. Of course, the original heterosexual Grindr is Blendr, but
that suffered from a lack of women. Basically, whatever variation
of word-ending-with-r you prefer, theres probably a website or
app to suit your dating requirements.
But of course, with great coding comes great responsibility,
especially when it comes to the wont someone think of the
children? question.
Its certainly true that children as young as 13 are using Tinder,
and although the app claims to block over-18s from viewing
underage profiles, getting access is as simple as lying about your
age. There are definitely causes for concern, but is there cause
for outrage?
The Times thinks so. In a shouty article this month, The Times
declared Tinder a dangerous minefield; this, as someone on
Twitter pointed out, is the very worst sort of minefield.
The Times helpfully pointed out that the NSPCC recently
reported a sharp rise in calls from children distressed by
experiences of dating apps, but failed to mention that the NSPCC
admits it doesnt have any actual figures.
That isnt to say it isnt worth ensuring new technology is safe.
The recent investigation by the OFT into in-app purchases,
coupled with Apples $32.5 million refund to the parents of kids
who got happy with the premium currency
button, shows that the industry is aware
that its partly accountable for the actions of
its customers, particularly when those
customers are kids.
Clearly, if those most easily exploited are
on a platform that makes it easy to exploit
them, we need to be mindful.
Awareness among developers and
storefronts (whose primary concern is profit),
parents and kids themselves are the key to safety. But where
there are curious teens, there will be sexting and hook-ups, and
if its the very nature of human curiosity that lobby groups seek
to change, they have a long battle ahead.
We know from biased reporting of the governments net
filtering projects that the press is happy to throw out the baby
with the bathwater when it comes to online censorship, so an
attempt to demonise dating apps isnt surprising.
If The Times had its way, presumably wed all hook up the
old-fashioned way. Its a shame so many people cant see that
apps such as Tinder are just the new, convenient version of filling
in a ladys dance card.
Gamer and science enthusiast Tracy King dissects the evidence and statistics behind popular media stories surrounding tech and gaming
10
@tkingdoll
F E E D B AC K
Letters
Please send us your feedback and correspondence to
[email protected]
Overscan, underscan
An issue has been bugging me for a
few years now, and for the life of me
I cant find any definitive answers
using my Google-fu. The issue is fullscreen gaming, or more specifically,
the lack of it in certain games. Most
recently, there are two main titles
that have been doing it to me
Rome: Total war II and Saints Row IV.
I have a Core i5-2500K, an Asus
Maximus Extreme-Z motherboard,
a GTX 670 and SSDs. I also have a
32in TV for my main monitor, and a
17in screen for my second monitor,
all set up in my front room. The main
screen runs at 1,920 x 1,080, and the
second runs at 800 x 600, just so I
can read everything on it from the
sofa. The main screen is manually
set in the Nvidia Control Panel, from
1,824 x 1,026 up to full HD, because
the screen overlaps the TV edge.
I can play most DX9 and DX11
games at full resolution, full screen,
with no issues and no overlap on the
TV edge. I can run Skyrim, Crysis 1,2
and 3, Borderlands 1 and 2 and so on,
all at full screen at on my main
display, with a selection of widgets
on my second screen for my
PEDANTS PARADISE
richardnpaul In Issue 127, p95, what card costs
<150? Also, on p65, the Cyberpower Crysis 3
results are probably the wrong way around.
MadmeccAndrew Hello, just reading your mag,
and on p95 you say the R9 290X only costs
under 150 - can I have one at that price please? LOL
Ben replies: Yes, sorry, the Cyberpower Crysis 3
graphs are indeed the wrong way around and yes,
ahem, the card on p95 was obviously supposed to be
the R9 270X. Id love an R9 290X for 150 too!
12
Magazine price
First, Id like to say that the revamped
mag looks great. However, in your
column you mentioned all the
changes in your mag apart from
the price increase from 4.50 to a
whopping 5.99, while going from
130 pages to 122. While your reply
would probably say that its in line
with other mags, in times when
people count every penny, I really
cant see any justification for a
nearly 150 per cent increase in price.
Im sure Im not the only one who
feels this way.
Ive been a great supporter of your
magazine, as it stood out
among others for value.
Give us back our value for
money price please. As of
now, Im afraid I cant
justify paying that kind of
price, and Im sorry to say I
will no longer be buying
your magazine.
GARY MORGAN
Twitter highlights
Follow us on Twitter at @CustomPCmag
Asus VG248QE
was the first monitor
weve seen to feature
Nvidias G-Sync tech
13
CO M I N G S O O N / NEW KIT
Incoming
We take a look at the latest newly announced products
Gigabyte adds
Broadwell support
Intel might not have officially launched
its Broadwell CPUs yet, which will be
based on Haswell with a die-shrink to
14nm transistors, but Gigabyte has already
enabled support for the new CPUs on its full range of
LGA1150 motherboards with 8-series chipsets, via BIOS
updates. If you own a Gigabyte board with an 8-series chipset,
and want to make sure it can handle Intels next CPUs, you can
download the new BIOS versions from http://uk.gigabyte.com
Lian Li showcases
desk chassis
Weve seen a fair few mods that involved
converting a desk into a PC chassis, or
building a desk-based PC from scratch,
but now Lian Li is attempting to make
building a desk PC much easier, using
a dedicated chassis. The company has
confirmed that its new DK01 chassis will
be showcased at the CeBIT trade show in
March this year, touting the ability to show
off your internal PC handiwork via the
tempered glass lid as a big selling point.
Little else is known about the DK01 yet,
except that it will be constructed from
aluminium, and Lian Li has also shown off
some monitor mounts for attaching one
or two displays to the top.
14
AMD unveils
R9 280
AMD has just lifted the lid on a new GPU
in its R-series product stack, which
takes aim at Nvidias GeForce GTX 760.
Called the Radeon R9 280, the GPU sits
between the R9 280X and R9 270X.
Like the 280X, which was basically a
rebadged Radeon 7970 GHz Edition,
the 28nm R9 280 has very similar
specifications to the older Radeon 7950.
It has 112 texture units, 1,792 stream
processors, 32 ROPs and 3GB of 5GHz
(effective) GDDR5 RAM with a 384-bit
memory interface.
Where it differs from the Radeon
7950 is in its core clock speed, with a
frequency of 933MHz, compared to
the 7950s 850MHz frequency clock,
which boosted to 925MHz. AMD says
cards based on the new GPU will have
a maximum TDP of 250W, and will
require one 6-pin and one 8-pin PCI-E
power connector.
N E WS
16
Toshiba steps in
In turn, Toshiba had the ability to make its
own NAND flash memory, and had already
begun making SSDs based on Marvell
controllers. However, if Toshiba really
wanted to compete with Samsung in this
arena, it also needed a full package. Toshiba
showed interest in OCZ for a number of
reasons, says Van Leeuwen. The brand for
its well-integrated position in both the
client and enterprise markets. The IP for its
controller technology, as well as software,
R&D, engineering and OCZs patents.
Shortly after OCZ filed for bankruptcy,
Toshiba acquired most of OCZs storage
assets. The result was a new subsidiary
called OCZ Storage Solutions, a Toshiba
company. OCZ is now able to include the
missing two elements in the mix flash and
cash, says Van Leeuwen, which now has a
full mix of controller technology, including
flash and proprietary firmware, while the
financial backup will allow the company to
really compete on a global scale.
Warranties
This brings up another question though
what happens to the warranties of OCZs
other products, including older SSDs?
According to OCZs website, while Toshiba
Corporation has acquired substantially all
the assets from OCZ
Technology Group,
most liabilities,
including outstanding
warranties, have been
excluded from that
acquisition. This
statement adds that OCZ
Storage Solutions is unable to provide
warranty support for discontinued
products including legacy SSDs, DRAM
memory and peripherals.
Thats bad news if you happen to own
one of those products, but OCZ says that
plenty of OCZ Technologys newer SSDs will
still be supported. The new organisation is
able to continue to support existing
customers with current SSD products, says
Brinkmann. This supports the vast majority
of consumers, and all enterprise customers,
as our top volume products, such as the
Vertex, Vector SATA and RevoDrive PCI-E
SSDs all continue to be supported. The
Agility Series is already on the tail end of
the lifecycle, and we are able to provide one
more year of support for this series.
The first result of Toshiba and OCZs
joint efforts is the Vertex 460, with OCZs
Barefoot 3 M10 controller and 19nm MLC
Toshiba NAND. See our review on p43.
0'
(
> -07D
> -07D
0. 999F
0. 9 9F
,,
Reviews
Our in-depth analysis of the latest PC hardware
Nvidia GeForce GTX 750 Ti
Hold on, wheres the PCI-E power
connector? Nvidias new Maxwell card
draws all its power from the PCI-E slot / p20
C P U CO O L E R
inc VAT
LGA2011
Corsairs latest closed-loop cooler oers a thick radiator and simple installation
SUPPLIER www.overclockers.co.uk / MODEL NUMBER CW-9060016-WW
Conclusion
If youre using an LGA115x chip, the H105 is overkill in most
instances. However, LGA2011 users can get more cooling
power from the H105 than any other cooler weve tested,
and it only takes a few minutes to install too. Just make sure
you have enough room in your case before you buy one.
MATTHEW LAMBERT
INTEL LGA1155
38C
34C
37C
39C
10
20
30
40
Lower is better
INTEL LGA2011
40C
42C
43C
44C
12
24
36
48
Lower is better
LG A 1 1 5 x
COOLING
DESIGN
80%
DESIGN
OVERALL SCORE
25/30
20/30
EASY
VALUE
OVERALL SCORE
FITTING
35/40
LG A 2 0 1 1
COOLING
39/40
26/30
27/30
EASY
VALUE
VERDICT
FITTING
92%
19
R E V I E WS / NEW KIT
GRAPHICS CARD
inc VAT
20
Nvidias tiny reference card has a basic cooler on the righthand side, which effectively makes it a dual-slot card, but
theres only a single-slot backplate, meaning that we could
see true single-slot third-party cards. The card doesnt
support SLI, however, so you wont find a bridge for it.
Fortunately, Nvidias G-Sync technology is supported,
provided you opt for a card with a DisplayPort output. Finally,
the on-board video encoder and decoder (which comes
with its own efficiency improvements), brings support for
ShadowPlay and streaming to Nvidia Shield.
Performance
In our standard 1080p tests, the GTX 750 Ti achieves
minimum frame rates of 22fps in Battlefield 4 and 23fps in
Crysis 3, which arent playable. However, dropping these
demanding games to their next best presets enables the
GTX 750 Ti to achieve smoother and playable minimums of
35fps and 34fps respectively, with minimal sacrifices to
visual quality. In Battlefield 4, this results in performance on
a par with the R7 260X, but in Crysis 3, its enough to be
noticeably smoother than both the R7 260X and GTX 650 Ti,
which cant maintain 30fps.
BioShock Infinite and Skyrim are easier to run, and the
GTX 750 Ti manages smooth frame rates at the best
possible settings at 1080p. Each of the four cards tested is
able to do the same, but the GTX 750 Ti excels in BioShock
Infinite, where its 25 per cent quicker than the R7 260X.
We hit the highest core clock speed possible in EVGA
Precision X when overclocking 1,155MHz. Under load, the
card consistently boosted to an incredible 1,285MHz. We
also overclocked the memory by 22 per cent to 1.65GHz
(6.6GHz effective). These are fantastic overclocks given
the reliance on PCI-E power. At these frequencies, the
card surpasses the GTX 660 in BioShock Infinite and
maintains borderline playable frame rates using Very
High settings in Crysis 3.
The power consumption figures really put everything into
perspective. The GTX 750 Ti has the lowest overall system
power consumption, and is especially strong against the R7
260X, which consumes 50W more, despite producing
slower frame rates in every benchmark. Better yet, its even
Conclusion
The GeForce GTX 750 Ti isnt the most exciting GPU in terms
of gaming performance, but you can still expect to play
modern games at 1080p with High settings, which isnt bad
for just 108 inc VAT, although of course, it limits future
proofing too. Its price/performance ratio is decent enough,
but if you can afford it, the R9 270X will perform better,
giving you enough headroom to push all your games to
their maximum settings at 1080p.
Maximum settings aside, however, the GeForce GTX 750
Ti is easily the fastest card available that doesnt require an
external PCI-E power connector, and would therefore make
a fantastic upgrade for an aging off-the-shelf PC, or an
ultra-small form factor build, without needing to worry
about power draw,. Were now eagerly waiting to see what
the rest of the Maxwell parts have in store.
MATTHEW LAMBERT
BA T T L E F I E L D 4
30 fps
37 fps
22 fps
Radeon R7 260X
18 fps
10
62 fps
22 fps 28 fps
27 fps
45 fps 58 fps
Radeon R7 260X
23 fps
37 fps 50 fps
20
30
40
35fps
Radeon R7 260X
35fps
0
12
24
47fps
20
40
Minimum
Average
60
UNIGINE V ALLEY
48
1,263
981
GeForce GTX 750 Ti
1,093
BI O S H O C K I N F I NITE
45 fps
57 fps
40 fps
GeForce GTX 750 Ti
32 fps
Radeon R7 260X
30 fps
15
45
60
CRYS I S 3
1,920 x 1,080, Very High detail, 0x AA
29 fps
23 fps
31 fps
Radeon R7 260X
103W
103W
0
18
27
SPEED
36
34fps
28fps
Radeon R7 260X
0
Stock speed min
12
42fps
VERDICT
36fps
24
Overclocked min
36
48
Overclocked avg
Load
1,400
174W
VALUE
187W
222W
227W
120
180
Overclocked
FEATURES
17/20
35/40
60
Idle
28/40
25 fps
18 fps 23 fps
103W
27 fps
21 fps
Radeon R7 260X
1,050
177W
35 fps
27 fps
700
100W
37 fps
350
36 fps
30
846
Radeon R7 260X
47 fps
46 fps 54 fps
848
80
44fps
36
79 fps
46 fps 59 fps
240
Lower is better
OVERALL SCORE
80%
21
R E V I E WS / NEW KIT
GRAPHICS CARD
inc VAT
22
the GTX Titan Black, so Zotacs model looks the same as any
other, although it includes three free Splinter Cell games, a
DVI to VGA adaptor and some power adaptors. Meanwhile,
all of the usual Nvidia features youd expect are present,
including G-Sync and 4-way SLI support.
A vapour chamber and heatsink cool the GPU, while a
metal contact plate with strategically positioned thermal
pads draws heat away from the 6+2 phase power VRMs and
half of the memory chips (the other half are left uncovered
on the PCBs rear). The radial fan at the side provides airflow,
blasting out its hot air through the rear I/O plate.
Performance
The GTX Titan Black is the new performance king, coming
top in all but the Battlefield 4 benchmark at 4K. That said, the
GTX Titan Black doesnt offer a massive benefit over the
GTX 780 Ti in games. The difference between them never
exceeds 2fps, which youre unlikely to notice when playing.
This should come as little surprise, as they share identical
specifications where it counts, other than the GTX Titan
Blacks marginally higher clock speed. Double precision
and FP64 performance is irrelevant in games, and the 6GB
frame buffer does nothing for the new card in games either
even at 5,760 x 1,080 and 4K, 3GB isnt a bottleneck. Even
compared to the GTX Titan, meaningful differences are rare,
although technically it does achieve borderline playable
status in Battlefield 4 at 4K, unlike the GTX Titan. It
outperforms the R9 290X too, in particular being noticeably
smoother in the BioShock Infinite tests.
The Unigine Valley rankings confirm what we see
elsewhere. The Titan Black has less than a 2 per cent lead on
the GTX 780 Ti, but is 8 and 26 per cent faster than the GTX
Titan and R9 290X respectively. As expected, power
Conclusion
For games, the Titan Black offers nothing over a GTX 780 Ti.
Instead, it targets professional graphics users Nvidia says
only around half the original Titans sold were used for
games. A cheaper, pre-overclocked and custom-cooled
GTX 780 Ti will outperform the Titan Black in games too.
MATTHEW LAMBERT
BATTLE FIE LD 4
CRYSIS 3
44 fps 54 fps
GeForce GTX Titan Black
43 fps
64 fps
54 fps
40 fps
0
16
64
36 fps 43 fps
0
13.5
27
40.5
54
26 fps
26 fps
34 fps
31 fps
18
24 fps 28 fps
24 fps 28 fps
25 fps 30 fps
23 fps 27 fps
27
36
29 fps
24 fps
33 fps
25 fps
36 fps 43 fps
48
53 fps
38 fps 46 fps
48 fps
32
42 fps
40 fps 49 fps
39 fps 47 fps
52 fps
7.5
15
22.5
30
28 fps
36 fps
25 fps
39 fps
25 fps
39 fps
23 fps
10
35 fps
20
30
22 fps
18 fps
22 fps
17 fps
17 fps
0
Stock speed min
22 fps
21 fps
12
18
Overclocked min
24
Overclocked avg
69 fps 81 fps
68 fps 79 fps
UNIGINE VAL L EY
2,560 x 1,440, Ultra Detail, 0xAA
61 fps 72 fps
56 fps
21
42
84
40 fps
38 fps
48 fps
47 fps
28 fps
12
36
35 fps 41 fps
34 fps 40 fps
30 fps 36 fps
27 fps
10.5
SPEED
21
Overclocked min
FEATURES
VALUE
19/20
15/40
30 fps
31.5
2,766
2,378
900
1,800
2,700
3,600
2,947
36 fps
24
3,484
Nvidia GeForce
GTX 780 Ti
Nvidia GeForce
GTX Titan
AMD Radeon
R9 290X (Uber)
36 fps 43 fps
3,000
Zotac GeForce
GTX Titan Black
62 fps
63
39/40
18 fps
40
BIOSHOCK INFINITE
108W
Nvidia GeForce
GTX Titan 53 fps
Nvidia GeForce
GTX 780 Ti
Zotac GeForce
GTX Titan Black
AMD Radeon
R9 290X (Uber)
OVERALL SCORE
73%
380W
106W
384W
114W
105
Idle
Overclocked avg
410W
111W
42
378W
Load
409W
210
Overclocked
315
420
Lower is better
VERDICT
Its interesting to see Nvidia develop the Titan
brand, but for the best gaming performance,
you should save yourself 250 and get a GTX
780 Ti instead.
23
R E V I E WS / NEW KIT
C P U CO O L E R
inc VAT
LGA115X AND
LGA2011
SUPPLIER www.overclockers.co.uk
/SPECIFICATIONS
Compatibility Intel: LGA775, LGA115x,
LGA1366, LGA2011; AMD: Socket
AM3+, AM3, AM2+, AM2, FM2+,
FM2, FM1
Size (mm) 140 x 136 x 168 (W x D x H)
Weight 1,079g
Fans 1 x 140mm
Stated noise 17.8 31.1 dB(A)
Conclusion
Deepcools Gamer Storm Lucifer can be
tricky to fit, but it offers very competitive
cooling and quiet operation for the
money. At this price, its over 30
cheaper than Corsairs H7, and also
makes air-cooling an overclocked
LGA2011 chip for under 30 a possibility.
ANTONY LEATHER
24
INTEL LGA1155
Deepcool Gamer
Storm Lucifer
Thermalright
True Spirit 120M
Arctic Freezer i30
44C
44C
50C
40C
13
26
39
52
Lower is better
INTEL LGA2011
Deepcool Gamer
Storm Lucifer
Thermalright
True Spirit 120M
Arctic Freezer i30
48C
60C
55C
47C
15
30
45
60
Lower is better
LG A 1 1 5 x
COOLING
DESIGN
85%
DESIGN
OVERALL SCORE
24/30
28/30
MEDIUM
VALUE
OVERALL SCORE
FITTING
33/40
LG A 2 0 1 1
COOLING
33/40
24/30
28/30
MEDIUM
VALUE
VERDICT
FITTING
85%
),1$//<
:,), ,1 $1< 5220
$ UHYROXWLRQ LQ VLPSOLFLW\
:L)L DQ\ZKHUH
%HVW UHFHSWLRQ IRU VPDUWSKRQHV DQG WDEOHWV
5HTXLUHG EURDGEDQG ,QWHUQHW FRQQHFWLRQ URXWHU DQG DFWLYH SRZHU VRFNHWV ZLWKLQ RQH SURSHUW\
R E V I E WS / NEW KIT
LG A 1 1 5 0 M OT H E R B OA R D
Gigabyte GA-Z87-HD3/80
inc VAT
Theres no stark
blue PCB, and the
VRMs even sport
a large heatsink
26
Performance
In our Media Benchmarks, there was little to distinguish the
GA-Z87-HD3 from more expensive motherboards. Its
image editing score of 2,072 was on par with MSIs Z87-G45
Gaming, which scored 2,081, and its video encoding score
was only a little off the pace at 3,596 compared to 3,661 for
the MSI board. However, you can also say the same for MSIs
similarly cheap Z87-G43. Thanks to an equally competitive
multi-tasking score, the overall score of 2,437 was less than
30 points behind the Z87-G45 Gaming, although the topscoring Asus Maximus VI Formula managed a lofty 2,535. It
lost little in terms of SATA 6Gbps speed either, with its read
speed of 537MB/sec and write speed of 508MB/sec being
a little slower than the top-scoring motherboards, but far
from the slowest weve seen.
The GA-Z87-HD3s EFI can be a little busy, confusing and
laggy, especially with a mouse it certainly isnt as slick as
the EFI systems found on MSI boards. However, the ability to
customise the view with settings you use most frequently is
handy, and all the tweaks youll need are well laid out, if a
little cluttered at times. We set the absolute voltage to our
usual 1.27V, but sadly, the GA-Z87-HD3 wasnt able to
handle our Intel Core i7-4770K at 4.7GHz here.
There was a little thermal headroom available, so we
bumped up the vcore to 1.272 and increased the loadline
calibration to its high setting. This still didnt get an entirely
stable system, so we had to drop down to 4.6GHz and keep
the voltage at 1.27V. This was 100MHz lower than the MSI
Z87-G45 Gamings top speed, but the same as the top
Conclusion
Gigabytes GA-Z87-HD3 offers all the essentials, including
half-decent overclocking, a tidy layout and fast
performance. Its EFI could do with being less busy, but
once you find your way around, youll be pushing your CPU
close to its limits in no time. However, it has a very close
competitor in the form of MSIs Z87-G43, which costs a
similar amount of money. Both boards managed the
same overclock, and both also omit SLI support and an
S/PDIF output.
This makes it a close judgement call between the two
boards the MSI is slightly quicker at stock speed, while the
Gigabyte is generally quicker when overclocked. However,
the MSIs slightly superior EFI system, and its slot layout,
with one PCI-E 1x slot positioned above the top graphics
card slot so you can still use it with two graphics cards
installed, just gives it the edge. Its very close, though, and
if you cant find the MSI board, you certainly wont be
disappointed with the Gigabyte Z87-HD3 either.
ANTONY LEATHER
T HE E L DE R S C R O L L S : S K Y R I M
G IM P IM A G E E D IT I N G
2,072 2,445
Gigabyte GA-Z87-HD3
91 fps
2,081 2,498
Gigabyte GA-Z87-HD3
2,047 2,420
MSI Z87-G43
0
700
1,400
2,100
2,800
3,596
4,341
3,693 4,161
MSI Z87-G43
0
1,100
2,200
3,300
4,400
107 fps
Gigabyte GA-Z87-HD3
1,644 1,763
1,647 1,763
MSI Z87-G43
1,668 1,717
450
900
1,350
1,800
2,437 2,850
2,463 2,876
2,469 2,766
MSI Z87-G43
0
40
80
750
Stock speed
1,500
2,250
3,000
Overclocked
120
160
28 fps
35 fps 42 fps
29 fps 35 fps
MSI Z87-G43
33 fps
0
SPEED
41/45
42 fps
28 fps 35 fps
33 fps
34 fps
11
22
FEATURES
17/30
41 fps
33
Overclocked min
VERDICT
/TEST KIT
147 fps
T OT A L W A R : S HO G U N 2
OVE R A LL
Gigabyte GA-Z87-HD3
150 fps
141 fps
104 fps
Gigabyte GA-Z87-HD3
M U LT I- T A S K IN G
141 fps
91 fps
MSI Z87-G43
3,661 4,367
147 fps
91 fps
H A N D B R AK E H . 2 6 4 V I D E O E N C O D I N G
Gigabyte GA-Z87-HD3
140 fps
102 fps
44
Overclocked avg
VALUE
24/25
OVERALL SCORE
82%
27
R E V I E WS / NEW KIT
N A S B OX
inc VAT
28
Conclusion
As a basic NAS with a modicum of network media-sharing
abilities, the Zyxel NSA325 v2 does its job well, and the
Dropbox integration makes transferring files to it from other
devices easy wherever you are.
However, the whole operating system and many of the
features lack the finesse of Synologys DS213j, which is
easier to use and more flexible. You pay 60 more for the
privilege, but its worth it.
ANTONY LEATHER
SPEED
31/35
OVERALL SCORE
79%
FEATURES
26/35
VALUE
22/30
VERDICT
The NSA325 v2 has a great price,
but lacks the ease of use and slick
OS of pricier products from
Synology and QNAP.
R E V I E WS / NEW KIT
GAMING MOUSE
Ozone Neon/50
inc VAT
30
Conclusion
The Ozone Neon is a solid, well-built ambidextrous mouse,
with decent buttons. However, it lacks the satisfying size in
your hand that youd expect from a 50 mouse, and its basic
physical design doesnt offer anything new or unique over
established ambidextrous mice, such as the SteelSeries
Kana. If you have smaller than average hands, and find
other ambidextrous mice too big, then the Neon is a good
gaming mouse, but its small size will limit its appeal for
anyone else.
If youre in the market for an ambidextrous mouse, and
you arent bothered about the size, the SteelSeries Kana is
cheaper, better looking and just as good for most gamers.
PAUL GOODHEAD
DESIGN
35/40
OVERALL SCORE
73%
FEATURES
20/35
VALUE
15/25
VERDICT
A good ambidextrous mouse, but
it doesnt do enough to stand out
in the extremely competitive
peripherals market.
R E V I E WS / NEW KIT
How we test
Thorough testing and research is the key to evaluating whether a product
is worth buying, and deciding whether or not theres a better alternative
PROCESSORS
We judge CPUs on whether they offer sufficient speed for the price. Part of a CPUs speed score comes from how
overclockable it is. Every type of CPU is tested in the same PC, so all results are directly comparable.
INTEL LGA2011
INTEL LGA1150
+
Intel
LGA1150
CPU
Intel
DZ87KLT-75K
16GB Corsair
Vengeance Pro Silver
1,600MHz DDR3
120GB
OCZ Vector
Intel
LGA2011
CPU
+
Asus
X79-Deluxe
16GB Corsair
Vengeance Pro
1,866MHz DDR3
250GB
Samsung SSD
840 EVO
COMMON
COMPONENTS
AMD FM2+
+
AMD FM2+
APU
+
Gigabyte G1 Sniper
A88X
+
8GB G.Skill RipjawsX
1,600MHz DDR3
(CPU testing)
+
256GB Plextor
M5 Pro
Nvidia GeForce
GTX 680 2GB
Windows 7
64-bit
TESTS: We use the Custom PC Media Benchmarks, Cinebench R11.5 and a variety of games. We also test the resultant power draw of the
test PC with the CPU installed. These tests reveal a broad range of performance characteristics for the CPU, from image editing to gaming
and video encoding to 3D rendering. We run all the tests with the CPU at stock speed and again when overclocked to its highest frequency.
*Please note: We test AMD FM2+ APUs using the on-board graphics, not the Nvidia GeForce GTX 680 2GB 3GB
GRAPHICS CARDS
Graphics cards are mainly evaluated on how fast they are for their price. However, we also consider the efficacy and
quietness of the cooler. Every graphics card is tested in the same PC, so all results are directly comparable.
32
Asus Maximus V
Extreme
Windows 7
64-bit SP1
= SCORES
+
2.66GHz Intel Core 2
Duo E6750
+
2GB of Corsair 1,066MHz
DDR2
+
250GB Samsung
SpinPoint P120S
= 1,000
Asus P5K Deluxe WiFi-AP
MOTHERBOARDS
Motherboards are evaluated on everything from layout and features to overclockability
and value for money. Every motherboard is tested with the same components, so all
results are directly comparable.
INTEL LGA1150
Motherboard
16GB Corsair
Intel
120GB
on test Vengeance Pro Silver OCZ
Core
1,600MHz DDR3
i7-4770K
Vector
INTEL LGA2011
+
Intel Core
i7-4960X
+
AMD
A10-6800K
Motherboard
16GB Corsair
on test
Vengeance Pro Silver
2,133MHz DDR3
COMMON COMPONENTS
+
Nvidia GeForce
GTX 680 2GB*
The
Awards
EXTREME
ULTRA
AMD FM2+
Windows 7
64-bit
TESTS: We use the Custom PC Media Benchmarks and several games, and also test the speeds of
the boards SATA ports. We try to overclock every motherboard we review by testing for a maximum
QPI, base clock or HTT as well as overclocking the CPU to its maximum air-cooled level. We run our
tests at stock speed and with the CPU overclocked.
*Please note: We test AMD FM2 motherboards using the on-board graphics, not the Nvidia GeForce GTX 680 2GB 3GB
PREMIUM
GRADE
Premium Grade
products are
utterly desirable
wed eat nothing
but beans until we
could afford them.
PROFESSIONAL
Products worthy of
the Professional
award make you
and your business
appear even more
awesome.
APPROVED
Approved products
are those that do a
great job for the
money; theyre the
canny purchase for
a great PC.
CUSTOM KIT
TESTS: By using the fast PC detailed on the left, we can be sure that any limitations are due to the
graphics card on test. We test the four games (above) at their maximum detail settings, in their highest
DirectX mode, at several resolutions. High-end cards should be able to sustain playable frame rates at
2,560 x 1,440, while 1,920 x 1,080 is more important for mid-range cards; we also now test at 5,760 x
1,080 for three-screen setups, and 3,840 x 2,160 for 4K monitors. We also try to overclock every
graphics card we test to assess the performance impact.
33
R E V I E WS / NEW KIT
Custom Kit
Paul Goodhead checks out the latest gadgets, gizmos and geek toys
U S B ST I C K
Kingston 16GB
DataTraveler
Locker+ G3 / 13
L A P TO P B AG
inc VAT
Okay, so 132 is an eye-watering amount of money for a bag, but the Graphite is
certainly built to last; its construction oozes quality every which way you look at it.
Designed to be worn courier-style (high on the back), it can take a laptop with a 15in
screen in its strengthened, fleece-lined laptop pocket, and theres a dizzy array of extra
pockets and pouches for extra nick-nacks and gadgets. It also sports Booqs barcodebased Terrlinq system, meaning the bag can be identified, and returned to you should
you lose it. The only downside is the daft magnetic buckle on the strap, which simply
doesnt work properly, as the catch is too shallow, meaning it comes unclipped at even
the merest touch. Its a shame, as it mars an otherwise excellent (if pricey) bag.
LEAD
GRAPHITE
SUPPLIER www.colorconfidence.com
inc VAT
Approximately the size of a casino chip, the Smart Key syncs to an iOS device via Bluetooth, and alerts
you when youve strayed from the valuable item to which its attached. It worked reliably during our
testing, pinging our phone when the connection broke, although it isnt instant, as the phone checks
a couple of times to make sure the interruption is genuine.
Handily, the dedicated app provides a map of where the connection was lost. However,
without a data or GPS connection of its own, youre unable able to track your valuables if
someone else moves them. On the downside, 32 is a lot for such a
simple device, and constant use of Bluetooth will impact on
your battery life too, but it will be worth it if it prevents you
from losing your keys or bag even once.
STUPID
SMART
SUPPLIER www.morecomputers.com
36
inc VAT
MUG
Robocup /12.99
inc VAT
B LU E TO OT H S P E A K E R
STEREO SPEAKERS
inc VAT
Microlab H50BT / 87
inc VAT
The SP001 is Icy Boxs first stab at a Bluetooth speaker, and it bears
an uncanny resemblance to a boules ball. The effect is enhanced by
the heavy, chrome-finished metal chassis, which lends the SP001 a
well-built feel, albeit at the cost of portability; the SP001 is better
suited to staying at home than being out and about. At the mid to
high volumes at which youre most likely to be using the speaker, it
was more than comfortable filling a medium sized room, with little
distortion and a pleasant, balanced sound profile. However,
performance tailed off at lower volumes, possibly because the
speaker needs a fair amount of volume to drive it, with the audio
losing bass. This is an easily overlooked flaw, though, especially for
the comparatively cheap price and being able to lose speaker cables.
MARBLES
BOULES
SUPPLIER www.scan.co.uk
SUPPLIER www.ebuyer.com
37
8a
u N&
2==0 #==
N22 7=J
Q " ~ j j N
j
Q j
j ~
Q N u N
j
Q jj j
a j H j~ j
HcH2
J'S
=7H2S H0#N
=HN
cJ
2W8& =""J =82c
c j
7=J =HS'=8N
7=J NWNN
a'8 WNS=7JN
0H WNS=7JN
7b'7W7 NWJ'Sc
HJ="NN'=82
Q N c u N
~
Q j #
j j
j j N=
Q ~ S N
j j j ~
u
Q j u N
j
j j
Q N j
j WHN j
Q j "j~
Q Jj~ j
& jj jj
Q j j
H j j
j
Q Jj j &j
Q # ~j = j j jj
j j j
j HjHj
j
Q 'j j
j
Q N
j
SJ'2
7=8S&
22
SJc "=J
cN
N&=JS SJ7
=8SJSN
NH0 S=
8 bHJS
{u N jj j j ~j jj Nj u N
j j j ~ j
j H `S ` j j j
LABS TEST
Solid state
showdown
A solid state drive is one of the best upgrades you can give your PC.
Weve tested 23 of them to discover which ones deserve your cash
irtually every PC should have a solid state drive, as they
make a huge difference to your computing experience.
With no moving parts, the data throughput of NAND is
leagues ahead of the fastest hard drives. System boot times, game
and software loading times, as well as general responsiveness, all
receive a dramatic upgrade as a result. SSDs also draw less power,
produce less heat, and are silent and much smaller too.
The downside, of course, is cost mechanical disks are cheaper
per gigabyte than SSDs, and are thus still the better choice for highcapacity storage. That said, price as a barrier to entry continues to
peel away, as some drives are now dipping below 40p per gigabyte.
How we test
ur battery of SSD tests comprises
synthetic benchmarks, PCMark 7s
trace-based storage benchmark, a
boot time measurement and Iometers I/O
workload generator.
Prior to testing, we issue an ATA Secure
Erase command to each drive with the
Parted Magic (www.partedmagic.com)
Linux build. This tells the controller to
release all stored electrons within every
NAND module, erasing all data and resetting
the SSD to factory performance.
For synthetic tests, we use AS SSD
(http://tinyurl.com/ASSSDCPC) and
CrystalDiskMark (http://tinyurl.com/
CPCCDM). With these free benchmarks,
you can easily compare your own PCs
storage performance with that of the drives
on test. Both benchmarks perform a
theoretical test of a drives sequential read
and write performance, as well as its 4KB
random read and write performance, both at
single and high queue-depths (64-queuedepth in AS SSD, and 32-queue-depth in
CrystalDiskMark). Queue depth refers to
the number of pending I/O operations for a
volume of storage demanding software
uses greater queue depths.
While the two tests are similar, they
use slightly different data patterns, so
performance between them can vary.
AS SSD automatically performs multiple
runs and reports the average, while with
CrystalDiskMark, we use the 1,000MB file
size set to five runs, with the average again
reported. Sadly, though, SSD performance
isnt static and can degrade as the NAND
cells are filled. Nowadays, widespread TRIM
support helps to minimise this issue, but
nevertheless, we perform a full fill of each
drive, delete the data and then retest it in AS
SSD to ensure performance is maintained.
For real-world testing, we use PCMark 7s
Secondary Storage benchmark, which
loops three times and reports an average. It
uses recorded SATA traces (the exact traffic
over the SATA bus at the time of recording)
to simulate performance under a wide
range of circumstances. Were most
interested in the application and gaming
tests, as these will have the most
pronounced impact on everyday use. We
take the raw performance results from
each, which eliminate trace idle times and
THE SCORES
The speed score is taken from a weighted breakdown of the performance tests. AS
SSD and CrystalDiskMark account for 25 per cent each, while 40 per cent is allocated
to the PCMark 7 and BootRacer real-world tests, which are the most relevant for
everyday use. The final 10 per cent comes from Iometer, as the sustained high
queue-depth workloads are only applicable to the most hardcore users. The cost per
gigabyte is based on the pricing at the time of writing over the accessible formatted
capacity, while the bang per buck score is a ratio of the speed and cost per gigabyte.
41
/GB
38/50 18/20
BANG/BUCK
23/30
42
OVERALL SCORE
79%
Conclusion
/GB
40/50 18/20
BANG/BUCK
24/30
OVERALL SCORE
82%
VERDICT
Some nifty features and acceptable
performance, but the low cost per gigabyte
is the real highlight of the M500 series.
/GB
39/50 19/20
BANG/BUCK
25/30
OVERALL SCORE
83%
O C Z V E C TO R 1 5 0 2 4 0 G B
SPEED
/GB
43/50 16/20
BANG/BUCK
21/30
OVERALL SCORE
80%
O C Z V E C TO R 1 5 0 4 8 0 G B
SPEED
/GB
45/50 14/20
BANG/BUCK
19/30
OVERALL SCORE
78%
Conclusion
The poor to average performance observed in
PCMark, BootRacer and single-queue-depth
random shows that these drives arent the
best choice for the majority of home users
and enthusiasts. Theyre also costly the
480GB Vector 150 has the joint highest cost
per GB at 84p, while even the 63p Vertex 460
240GB is above average. Nevertheless, the
excellent high queue-depth and mixed
workload performance makes the Vector
150 drives fine candidates for heavy-use
scenarios, such as workstations or file
servers, where the high endurance rating is
also worth the extra cost. ML
VERDICT
These drives have some outstanding
performance, but theyre less impressive in
the most critical areas for home users.
/GB
42/50 16/20
BANG/BUCK
21/30
OVERALL SCORE
79%
43
44
Conclusion
Both these drives struggle to compete in
terms of speed, and the Intel 530 is also
hamstrung by one of the most expensive
pound-per-gigabyte figures on test. And,
while Transcends drive offers superb value
at 42p per gigabyte, that doesnt justify its
benchmark results its just too slow
compared to good-value competition.
The Samsung 840 Pro 256GB is a better
mid-sized drive than both these products in
terms of speed and bang per buck, while the
Crucial M500 240GB is a better drive if youre
on a tight budget. SandForces SF-2281
controller is clearly now past its best. MJ
VERDICT
The SandForce SF-2281 controller is
now past its best you can get better
performance and value for money.
/GB
39/50 15/20
BANG/BUCK
18/30
OVERALL SCORE
72%
TRANSCE N D SSD 3 4 0 2 5 6 G B
SPEED
/GB
34/50 19/20
BANG/BUCK
21/30
OVERALL SCORE
74%
/GB
37/50 14/20
BANG/BUCK
16/30
OVERALL SCORE
67%
Conclusion
Like the Intel and Transcend models, these
PNY drives rely on the old SandForce SF-2281
controller, and the use of 25nm NAND also
makes them outdated compared to the 19nm
and 20nm NAND used in drives elsewhere.
This outdated hardware results in
predictably uncompetitive performance,
and neither of these drives impress at the
checkout either the slower Pro drives
76p-per-gigabyte figure is the third highest
on test, and the standard XLR8s 84p-pergigabyte price is the highest on test.
If you need a mid-sized drive, the Samsung
840 Pro 256GB is a much better option; its
consistently far quicker and its much better
value for money too, thanks to its modern,
efficient components. Meanwhile, if youre
after professional-level performance and
endurance, OCZs new Vector 150 240GB is
cheaper and faster than the XLR8 Pro. MJ
VERDICT
These XLR8 drives dont live up to their
name, with uncompetitive performance and
high prices.
/GB
36/50 15/20
BANG/BUCK
16/30
OVERALL SCORE
67%
45
SA N D I S K E X T R E M E I I
480GB
SPEED
/GB
42/50 15/20
BANG/BUCK
20/30
48
OVERALL SCORE
77%
CrystalDiskMark results were similarly midtable in most tests, and its sequential read
result was, again, impressive only the two
Samsung Pro drives were quicker. However,
nCache doesnt seem to do much; the
Extreme II remained mid-table in most of
our small file write benchmarks.
In our real-world tests, the Extreme II
remained resolutely mid-table too. In
PCMarks pair of tests, it was beaten by a host
of Samsung and Toshiba drives, and its 11.99second boot time was half a second behind
the fastest drive.
Meanwhile, Plextors Marvell-based drives
returned mixed performance in AS SSD. The
two drives hit the top five when reading
sequential files, outpacing strong competition
from Samsung and Toshiba, and the 256GB
version excelled in the 64-queue-depth
Conclusion
Plextors M5 Pro drives are among the
quickest and most consistent drives on test,
but theyre hampered by poor pricing: the
256GB and 512GB models cost 68p and
67p per gigabyte. The SanDisk was
similarly afflicted its 70p-pergigabyte price is one of the highest
on test. Even with NAND tweaks, the
aging Marvell 88SS9187 controller cant
compete with Samsungs latest tech. MJ
VERDICT
All these Marvell-controlled drives are rapid
performers, but theyre expensive too.
P L E X TO R M 5 P R O E X T R E M E
256GB
SPEED
/GB
45/50 16/20
BANG/BUCK
22/30
OVERALL SCORE
83%
P L E X TO R M 5 P R O E X T R E M E
512GB
SPEED
/GB
44/50 16/20
BANG/BUCK
22/30
OVERALL SCORE
82%
50
/GB
38/50 18/20
BANG/BUCK
22/30
OVERALL SCORE
78%
Conclusion
Both these drives offer reasonable value for
money, with the Ultra Plus costing 50p per
gigabyte and the X110 costing 2p more. Thats
in the top half of our results table, but thats
the only area where these drives impress.
Theres plenty of competition around the
256GB mark, and the Samsung 840 Evo is
much faster and only a few pence per
gigabyte more expensive. MJ
VERDICT
Reasonable all-rounders, but that isnt
enough to cut it in the SSD market any more.
SA N D I S K X 1 1 0 2 5 6 G B
SPEED
/GB
38/50 17/20
BANG/BUCK
21/30
OVERALL SCORE
76%
*$' %
***,
SA M S U N G S S D 8 4 0
E VO 2 5 0 G B
SPEED
/GB
44/50 17/20
BANG/BUCK
24/30
52
OVERALL SCORE
85%
SA M S U N G S S D 8 4 0
E VO 5 0 0 G B
SPEED
/GB
45/50 18/20
BANG/BUCK
26/30
OVERALL SCORE
89%
Conclusion
The SSD 840 Evo drives have their limits,
but for the majority of home PC users,
including hardware enthusiasts, theyre
fantastic all-rounders.
The Samsung SSD 840 Evo 250GB comes
out a little slower and more expensive than
its bigger siblings, but equally, its price of 54p
per gigabyte is still very reasonable, making
it one of the best drives available at this
popular capacity. ML
VERDICT
Fast, attractively priced and backed by great
software, the Evo range is a deserving
winner of this months Labs.
SA M S U N G S S D 8 4 0
E VO 1 T B
SPEED
/GB
44/50 19/20
BANG/BUCK
27/30
OVERALL SCORE
90%
, )AFA ,
TO S H I B A Q 2 5 6 G B
SPEED
/GB
44/50 17/20
BANG/BUCK
23/30
54
OVERALL SCORE
84%
TO S H I B A Q 5 1 2 G B
SPEED
/GB
42/50 16/20
BANG/BUCK
21/30
OVERALL SCORE
79%
Conclusion
All three Toshiba drives had mixed starts, with
good sequential performance tempered by
poor small file pace, but real-world use
proved that these SSDs still have enough pace
to rival most of the drives on test. They all
offer reasonable value for money too, with
prices between 54p and 65p per gigabyte.
The best deal is the Q Pro 256GB, though,
which just creeps ahead in performance and
has a good price too. MJ
VERDICT
All three drives impress in real-world tests,
but its the Q Pro 256GB that takes home
an award.
TO S H I B A Q P R O 2 5 6 G B
SPEED
/GB
44/50 17/20
BANG/BUCK
24/30
OVERALL SCORE
85%
AS SSD
AS SSD
523.9
503.7
523.8
503.5
523.5
503.4
521.8
503.1
520.9
519.8
519.5
495.8
519.5
495.4
518.6
517.6
502.8
498.7
488.1
480.8
516.5
479.4
512.5
478.9
511.7
460.0
507.9
459.1
507.4
507.2
507.1
503.0
502.1
459.1
446.5
431.3
429.7
322.0
500.0
308.4
493.3
304.6
491.0
490.1
135
270
405
273.0
269.6
540
130
260
AS SSD
AS SSD
390
520
40.9
114.9
40.7
114.0
39.2
107.4
105.9
33.7
33.4
105.6
104.3
33.2
32.7
31.7
30.3
29.6
104.2
103.5
102.9
102.5
102.0
26.7
26.6
99.7
26.5
99.6
26.1
97.7
24.7
96.6
24.5
96.0
23.5
10.5
57.6
18.2
84.4
19.0
84.9
19.9
95.9
86.8
21.8
56
108.3
34.4
110.9
21
31.5
42
30
60
90
120
AS SSD
AS SSD
381.2
332.5
368.7
330.1
362.8
329.8
360.3
329.4
358.4
326.6
357.5
326.1
325.0
349.3
347.2
340.9
314.6
306.8
302.8
332.8
331.5
331.4
301.4
268.3
246.8
329.4
325.1
243.5
325.1
239.8
322.1
239.2
321.3
238.9
282.2
244.5
226.1
228.3
206.6
205.2
216.7
204.9
210.9
203.7
171.3
100
194.9
200
300
400
90
180
CRYSTALDISKMARK
CRYSTALDISKMARK
270
360
544.6
544.4
524.9
524.2
542.9
523.5
541.0
523.3
539.3
520.1
538.6
519.6
537.4
517.0
534.4
514.5
534.3
506.0
533.6
502.4
531.0
495.0
527.1
492.4
525.7
524.4
524.2
523.2
514.8
480.6
457.9
452.0
498.0
481.0
444.8
443.9
488.8
488.8
322.1
488.3
321.8
480.4
476.5
0
135
270
405
540
285.2
284.9
0
135
270
405
540
57
CRYSTALDISKMARK
CRYSTALDISKMARK
44.3
41.2
134.3
44.5
133.3
130.9
125.4
38.1
124.5
37.8
123.8
39.6
36.8
122.2
36.5
121.2
36.0
121.2
35.7
120.5
35.1
119.5
34.2
119.4
34.0
32.5
32.0
119.3
116.6
114.1
28.7
113.5
28.6
28.5
26.9
26.6
23.1
98.1
97.4
71.8
69.3
20.8
108.2
21.5
112.1
111.4
12
24
36
48
35
70
105
CRYSTALDISKMARK
CRYSTALDISKMARK
140
406.0
375.5
405.9
372.7
405.0
371.6
403.6
371.4
403.4
369.7
402.5
368.9
401.1
400.7
365.1
353.1
348.4
392.5
387.3
339.5
384.8
338.8
384.3
351.4
279.8
351.0
276.3
350.3
272.7
345.0
264.0
344.3
263.0
342.9
274.7
206.9
169.4
58
312.0
285.5
361.3
105
210
315
420
260.2
225.0
224.4
222.4
221.6
0
100
200
300
400
PCMARK 7
PCMARK 7
137.5
156.7
156.4
132.8
156.7
139.2
150.8
123.1
150.4
122.0
127.5
147.7
146.3
120.9
113.4
112.5
126.6
104.2
128.2
108.6
130.9
110.4
148.4
125.8
121.3
101.0
99.3
121.0
120.9
94.5
118.7
87.9
118.3
87.3
115.9
86.6
114.7
89.6
84.3
113.7
83.8
113.6
65.2
0
35
112.6
83.0
101.5
70
105
140
40
80
120
BOOTRACER
IOMETER
COST/GB
14.81
14.40
0.38
46,061
45,630
0.42
13.07
45,375
0.43
13.01
45,268
0.43
12.80
12.66
12.47
12.41
12.39
38,929
12.24
38,888
0.54
12.17
38,198
12.03
11.99
11.99
11.93
31,089
11.89
11.86
11.85
11.73
11.58
11.55
0.48
41,705
0.50
41,512
0.50
0.52
0.54
44,009
41,476
0.63
33,475
0.65
32,986
0.65
0.67
27,747
0.67
26,989
0.68
26,859
0.68
26,305
0.69
0.70
23,728
22,621
11.54
16,456
11.49
16,437
12
16
0.76
0.60
34,795
160
0.84
0.84
25
50
75
100
59
R E V I E WS / PC HEAD TO HEAD
AMD Kaveri
systems
This months contenders saddle up with AMDs new Kaveri APUs.
Can these chips form the basis of decent, all-round budget machines?
Computer Planet
GX-A7700/671
inc VAT
SUPPLIER www.computerplanet.co.uk
SUPPLIER www.falconcomputers.co.uk
62
Computer Planet
1
A Corsair H80i liquidcooler handles CPUcooling duties
COMPUTER PLANET/SPECIFICATIONS:
CPU AMD A10-7700K
liquid cooler, but wed argue that both systems get it wrong
when it comes to cooling; the Hydro is overkill for Kaveri, and
the Falcons quartet of fans are similarly overpowered. Both
cooling setups create excess noise, and the H80i needlessly
bumps up the price on what should be a budget machine.
Nevertheless, theres only one winner when it comes to
design and build quality, and thats Computer Planet; its
system is tidier, better-looking and well thought out.
The components
Falcon has opted for the top-end Kaveri part, the A107850K, in its PC, while Computer Planet has gone a step
down with the A10-7700K. Both chips have the same CPU
cores and TDP, although the latter runs at slightly reduced
base and turbo speeds (3.4GHz/3.8GHz compared to
3.7GHz/4GHz). Meanwhile, the flagships GPU is also more
powerful, as it has 512 stream processors compared to 384
in the A10-7700K.
This means the Falcon PC has more grunt available for
less money we recommend spending the extra 13 for an
63
R E V I E WS / PREBUILT PCs
Falcon PC
Performance
FALCON PC/SPECIFICATIONS
CPU AMD A10-7850K
Motherboard Asus A88XM-Plus
Memory 2 x 4GB Adata XPG 2,133MHz
DDR3
Graphics AMD Radeon R7 with 512 stream
processors
Sound On-board
64
With the faster APU at its disposal, the Falcon PC comes out
on top in the full suite of our Media Benchmarks. That said, it
also has 7W higher power consumption, which goes up to a
19W difference when the systems are stressed.
However, the difference in benchmark scores comes to
just 4 per cent overall neither machine is a powerhouse,
and youll struggle to notice a real difference between them
in CPU-bound tasks.
Compared to the calibre of SSDs in our Labs (see p40),
the 120GB SSD in Computer Planets system isnt amazing,
but its still a decent inclusion in a budget machine. Its flash
memory makes Windows feel much more responsive than
the mechanical parts upon which Falcon relies.
Kaveri offers the best currently available integrated
graphics system. As the detail settings for our games test
reveal, you cant expect to play at 1080p with all the eye
candy enabled, and the most demanding games such as
Crysis 3 will struggle to run either way. However, its clear
that the Falcon PC is capable of much better frame rates
than the Computer Planet system, and it does a better job of
keeping both Battlefield 4 and BioShock Infinite in the realm
of playable frame rates too. Two factors are at play here
the extra stream processors in the Falcon PCs APU, and the
faster memory.
With an extra 0.062V, we managed to overclock Falcons
A10-7850K to 4.1GHz, and also pushed its GPU to 820MHz.
This resulted in minor improvements to the scores of our
Media Benchmarks and game tests, where it extends its
lead on the Computer Planet PC. However, we struggled to
overclock the A10-7700K in the Computer Planet PC. We
only managed to push it to 3.9GHz, and the GPU to 800MHz
whether this is the fault of the motherboard or the CPU is
hard to say, but we managed a much better overclock in our
A10-7700K review (see Issue 127, p17. Needless to say,
improvements from overclocking this PC are very marginal.
Warranty
Falcons system offers two years of hardware cover and
three years of labour support, while the Computer Planet
machine has a three-year labour deal with a year of parts
and collection cover, making the Falcons deal slightly better.
Conclusion
Both of these machines offer similarly mid-sized tower
cases and mid-range specifications, and both have also
involved compromise.
G IMP IMAG E E D IT I N G
BATTLEFIELD 4
1,920 x 1,080, Low detail
1,033 1,052
Computer Planet
1,094 1,150
Falcon PC
0
300
600
900
HA N D B R AK E H . 2 6 4 V I D E O E N C O D I N G
2,401 2,443
Falcon PC
2,480 2,645
700
1400
22 fps 26 fps
24 fps 27 fps
Falcon PC
Computer Planet
21 fps 25 fps
Computer Planet
1,200
2,100
25 fps 29 fps
2,800
7.5
15
22.5
B I OS HO C K : I N F I N I T E
1,920 x 1,080, Low detail
M U LT I- T AS K IN G
Computer Planet
911 934
Falcon PC
890 955
0
250
500
750
22 fps 27 fps
Computer Planet
1,000
22 fps 27 fps
26 fps
Falcon PC
1,448 1,476
Computer Planet
400
800
1,200
11 fps
Computer Planet
C PU T E M PE R AT U R E
26 27
10
Stock speed
20
Overclocked
20 fps
14 fps
40
17 fps
13 fps
Falcon PC
30
36
16 fps
11 fps
35 38
Falcon PC
34 fps
27
1,600
Computer Planet
18
CRYSIS 3
1,510 1,562
Falcon PC
32 fps
27 fps
O V E R ALL
30
22 fps
12
18
Overclocked min
24
Overclocked avg
T O T A L SY ST E M P O W E R C ON S U M P T I O N
40 W
Computer Planet
37.5
Stock load
HARDWARE
VALUE
18/25 20/25
20/25 20/25
133W
48W
SPEED
121W
47W
Falcon PC
Stock idle
114W
43W
142W
75
Overclocked idle
112.5
150
Overclocked load
FALCON PC
OVERALL SCORE
78%
SPEED
DESIGN
HARDWARE
VALUE
19/25 18/25
18/25 22/25
OVERALL SCORE
77%
65
Elite
Our choice of the best hardware available
Build a budget PC
Core components
The parts youll need to build either PC. This kit list gives you a solid PSU, a decent quality case and the full retail
version of Windows 7 Home Premium.
PRICE
NAME
SUPPLIER
FEATURED
Xigmatek Midgard II
www.overclockers.co.uk
60
www.novatech.co.uk
53
www.scan.co.uk
36
Lite-On IHAS124-04
www.cclonline.com
12
www.overclockers.co.uk
70
66
(inc VAT)
All-purpose PC
The parts youll need to add to the core components to build a general-purpose PC. This machine will handle
general computing tasks with no trouble, and will also cope with basic gaming, although youll have to lower the
detail settings. It features high-speed memory to boost the performance of the AMD APUs graphics system.
PRICE
NAME
SUPPLIER
FEATURED
Gigabyte GA-F2A88XM-D3H
www.dabs.com
48
AMD A10-7850K
www.scan.co.uk
132
www.scan.co.uk
78
www.quietpc.com
24
TOTAL
(inc VAT)
513
Gaming PC
The parts youll need to build a budget machine capable of playing the latest games at maximum settings on a
1080p monitor. The machine has a discrete graphics card, a dual-core CPU and slower memory than the allpurpose PC, as its GPU doesnt use system memory. Meanwhile, the Z87 motherboard gives you headroom to
upgrade to a faster CPU later, as well as an additional graphics card.
PRICE
NAME
SUPPLIER
FEATURED
MSI Z87-G43
www.scan.co.uk
78
www.scan.co.uk
83
www.scan.co.uk
149
www.scan.co.uk
N/A
66
www.overclockers.co.uk
Issue128, p24
29
D
U PDATE
TOTAL
(inc VAT)
636
Recommended extra
A solid state drive will make a huge difference to the responsiveness of Windows, as well as boot-up times.
We strongly recommend adding one to any build.
NAME
Crucial M500 240GB
U PDATE
SUPPLIER
FEATURED
www.scan.co.uk
PRICE
(inc VAT)
106
67
Build a mid-range PC
Work PC
The parts youll need to build a solid quad-core PC with plenty of upgrade potential. This kit list gives you an allin-one liquid cooler and a K-series Core i5 CPU, meaning you can overclock it and get some serious processing
power. Weve managed to get our test Haswell CPU up to 4.7GHz using the motherboard in this list, so it has
some serious performance potential. Also included is a solid Antec PSU, a fast Samsung EVO SSD and 8GB of
high-speed memory. The core configuration assumes you wont be doing any serious gaming, however, and it
relies on Intels integrated graphics.
PRICE
NAME
SUPPLIER
FEATURED
www.overclockers.co.uk
98
www.scan.co.uk
105
www.scan.co.uk
168
www.novatech.co.uk
83
Corsair H75
www.scan.co.uk
65
www.cclonline.com
72
www.scan.co.uk
60
Lite-On IHAS124-04
www.cclonline.com
12
www.cclonline.com
126
www.overclockers.co.uk
70
TOTAL
(inc VAT)
859
Gaming PC
The graphics card youll need to play current games at their maximum settings at 1080p and 2,560 x 1,440.
68
PRICE
NAME
SUPPLIER
FEATURED
1,920 x 1,080
AMD R9 270X 2GB
www.scan.co.uk
149
2,560 x 1,440
Nvidia GeForce GTX 770 2GB
www.overclockers.co.uk
230
(inc VAT)
Build a performance PC
Work PC
The parts youll need to build a high-quality, fast PC thats ideal for multi-threaded workloads. This kit list
features a high-quality, beautifully built case, and has a Core i7-4770K CPU. This processors support for HyperThreading support effectively splits the resources of the CPUs four physical cores into a further four virtual
cores, meaning it can effectively handle eight threads at once. Theres also a solid 750W PSU, giving you plenty
of headroom for overclocking and adding multiple graphics cards, and a Corsair H80i all-in-one liquid cooler.
PRICE
NAME
SUPPLIER
FEATURED
www.scan.co.uk
185
Gigabyte GA-Z87-UD3H
www.scan.co.uk
131
www.scan.co.uk
240
www.novatech.co.uk
83
Corsair H80i
www.scan.co.uk
77
www.scan.co.uk
104
www.scan.co.uk
60
Lite-On IHAS124-04
www.cclonline.com
12
www.cclonline.com
235
www.overclockers.co.uk
70
U PDATE
TOTAL
(inc VAT)
1,197
Gaming PC
The graphics card youll need to play current games at their maximum settings at 2,560 x 1,440 and beyond.
PRICE
NAME
SUPPLIER
FEATURED
2,560 x 1,440
Nvidia GeForce GTX 770 2GB
www.overclockers.co.uk
230
www.scan.co.uk
322
(inc VAT)
*Note: Multiple graphics cards are required to run Crysis 3 smoothly at 5,760 x 1,080 and 3,840 x 2,160, and Battlefield 4 at 5,760 x 1,080.
Recommended
extra
A discrete sound card gives you higher-quality sound when playing back or recording music.
NAME
SUPPLIER
FEATURED
www.scan.co.uk
PRICE
(inc VAT)
73
69
NAME
SUPPLIER
FEATURED
www.cclonline.com
127
www.overclockers.co.uk
410
www.overclockers.co.uk
430
www.overclockers.co.uk
149
www.dabs.com
143
www.overclockers.co.uk
94
www.scan.co.uk
250
www.amazon.co.uk
400
www.scan.co.uk
60
Lite-On IHAS124-04
www.cclonline.com
12
www.scan.co.uk
105
U PDATE
TOTAL
(inc VAT)
2,180
4K gaming PC
This LGA2011 system has the advantage of being able to support multiple graphics cards with a decent number of
PCI-E 3 lanes, unlike many LGA1150 motherboards. As such, its also an ideal platform for building a machine for
high-resolution PC gaming, replacing the graphics card listed above with two or more high-spec cards.
NAME
SUPPLIER
FEATURED
www.scan.co.uk
TOTAL
70
PRICE
(inc VAT)
786
2,966
Build a mini PC
Core components
The parts youll need to build either PC. This kit list gives you a solid PSU, 8GB of RAM, an overclockable Haswell
cooler, an all-in-one liquid cooler and Windows 7 Home Premium. Also included is a graphics card that can play
current games at their maximum settings at 1080p.
PRICE
NAME
SUPPLIER
FEATURED
www.scan.co.uk
168
www.novatech.co.uk
83
Corsair H75
www.scan.co.uk
65
www.overclockers.co.uk
149
www.cclonline.com
126
www.scan.co.uk
60
Lite-On IHAS124-04
www.cclonline.com
12
www.cclonline.com
72
www.overclockers.co.uk
70
(inc VAT)
Mini-ITX PC
The parts youll need to build a pint-sized powerhouse
PRICE
NAME
SUPPLIER
FEATURED
www.scan.co.uk
72
MSI Z87i
www.scan.co.uk
97
See Issue 121, p92 for a full guide to building a mini-ITX PC with this case and motherboard
TOTAL
(inc VAT)
974
Micro-ATX PC
The parts youll need to build a mini PC that doesnt take up as much room as a full-sized desktop
PRICE
NAME
SUPPLIER
FEATURED
www.cclonline.com
71
www.overclockers.co.uk
150
TOTAL
(inc VAT)
1,026
71
Cases
PRICE
TYPE
NAME
SUPPLIER
FEATURED
Budget ATX
Xigmatek Midgard II
www.overclockers.co.uk
60
Sub-100
ATX quiet
www.scan.co.uk
80
Sub-100 ATX
performance
www.overclockers.co.uk
98
Sub-200 ATX
www.scan.co.uk
185
Water-cooling ATX
www.overclockers.co.uk
260
Mini-ITX tower
www.scan.co.uk
72
Mini-ITX cube
Antec ISK600
www.overclockers.co.uk
65
Micro-ATX
www.cclonline.com
71
(inc VAT)
Graphics cards
NAME
SUPPLIER
FEATURED
1,920 x 1,080
gaming
www.overclockers.co.uk
149
2,560 x 1,440
gaming
www.overclockers.co.uk
230
High-end gaming*
www.scan.co.uk
322
4K gaming
www.scan.co.uk
786
* Handles all games at 2,560 x 1,440 and some at 4K and 5,760 x 1,080
72
PRICE
TYPE
(inc VAT)
Power supplies
PRICE
TYPE
NAME
SUPPLIER
FEATURED
Budget 550W
www.novatech.co.uk
53
Mid-range 520W
www.cclonline.com
72
High-end 760W
www.ebuyer.com
156
High-end 1.2kW
www.scan.co.uk
250
Networking
(inc VAT)
D
U PDATE
PRICE
TYPE
NAME
SUPPLIER
FEATURED
Router
Asus RT-AC68U
www.scan.co.uk
180
Wi-Fi adaptor
Asus PCE-AC68
www.scan.co.uk
70
TYPE
NAME
SUPPLIER
FEATURED
Hard disk
www.scan.co.uk
60
250GB SSD
www.cclonline.com
126
1TB SSD
www.amazon.co.uk
400
NAS box
Synology DiskStation
DS213j
www.ebuyer.com
160
(inc VAT)
Storage
PRICE
(inc VAT)
73
Monitors
PRICE
TYPE
NAME
SUPPLIER
FEATURED
24in monitor
Dell U2412M
www.aria.co.uk
210
27in budget
monitor
Digimate IPS-2701WPH
www.aria.co.uk
330
29in monitor
Dell U2913WM
www.aria.co.uk
348
4K monitor
Asus PQ321QE
www.scan.co.uk
Issue123, p27
2,652
TYPE
NAME
SUPPLIER
FEATURED
www.scan.co.uk
73
www.dabs.com
340
2.1 speakers
Corsair SP2500
www.scan.co.uk
Issue118, p75
176
Headset
Qpad QH-90
www.scan.co.uk
77
(inc VAT)
Audio
74
PRICE
(inc VAT)
Peripherals
PRICE
TYPE
NAME
SUPPLIER
FEATURED
Budget mechanical
keyboard
Func KB-460
www.morecomputers.com
65
Mechanical gaming
keyboard
www.scan.co.uk
109
Mechanical MMO
keyboard
www.cclonline.com
124
Mouse
www.dabs.com
60
TYPE
NAME
SUPPLIER
FEATURED
(inc VAT)
Dream PC
www.scan.co.uk
6,999
Sub-1,300
gaming PC
www.cclonline.com
1,230
Mini-ITX PC
www.computerplanet.
co.uk
2,786
Gaming laptop
www.scan.co.uk
999
(inc VAT)
Systems
PRICE
75
Games
OPINION
BEN H
R IACRKDW
L AI N
DE
G E/ /INVERSE
FROM THE
LOOK
EDITOR
RESPECT
HEADING
HERE
MY
TIME
PLEASE
Standfirst here
please
Standfirst
here
Standfirst
here
Game
developers
need
toplease
think harder
about
theplease
time Standfirst
here
please
here please
commitments
they
ask Standfirst
of their players,
argues Rick Lane
his month
ow,
Id better
I spent
make
four
sure
days
I have
exploring
an Nvidia
the card
virtual
in 2014,
worldI
thought,
of
Tamriel
asin
I watched
Bethesdas
theupcoming
Witcher 3 PhysX
MMO demo
The Elder
last
proprietary
Scrolls
Online
GPU
(see
feature
p78). Well,
would
inactually
actuality,
persuade
I spent two
me
to goexploring,
days
with one companys
and two days
GPU
being
overso
anothers
bored that
since
a local
thecarpentry
3dfx days.
firm
Graphics
asked if
card
they
companies
could fashion
have been
me into
coming
a desk.
upThe
with
games
these
unique selourisown
introduction
agonisingly
judgment
protracted,
call, according
and it serves
to your
nopriorities.
purpose
What than
other
are your
to introduce
prioritiesthe
when.
player to the same mechanics that
MMOs have been using for the last 13 years.
Games are frequently accused of being too long, and theres
some truth to this charge. Many mainstream games could be
half the length, half the budget and half the
price, and would be better off for it. Even the
excellent Assassins Creed IVs campaign
dragged on for far too long. But the root of this
problem isnt a simple case of bloat, its more
that games have no yardstick for length.
With films, books and even board games,
theres a broadly accepted notion of when
they go on for too long or not long enough. Most books usually
have between 250 and 600 pages, most board games take
between 45 minutes and two hours to play, and most films run
from 90 minutes to three hours. Computer games, on the other
hand, can range from as little as a few minutes to hundreds of
hours of play time. Theres little understanding of when a game
needs editing.
Editing games is just as important as it is in any other creative
endeavour, but its a much trickier prospect than in other media.
Games arent always designed in a linear fashion that can be
neatly cut, and mechanical aspects, such as the length of time it
takes to resolve a particular action, can also affect game length,
W
T
films,
books and
CiWith
debis
vel iliquam
sam
board
games,
you
know
sam serovides doloris
whenutaque
they go
on too long
volectas
@custompcmag
77
G A M E S / PREVIEW
78
79
G A M E S / REVIEW
Nidhogg /11.99
inc VAT
OVERALL SCORE
70%
/ VERDICT
Nidhogg shines
with a brilliant
radiance, but it
burns out very
quickly if youre
not playing with
a partner.
80
G A M E S / REVIEW
inc VAT
OVERALL SCORE
72%
/ VERDICT
Weird, witty and
warm, Octodads
comical, physicsbased sandbox is
only let down by a
damp final third.
82
Jazzpunk/11.99
inc VAT
OVERALL SCORE
86%
/ VERDICT
Sticks a custard pie
in James Bonds
face and puts
George Smileys
underwear on its
head this
delightfully daft
spy parody will do
anything to make
you laugh.
83
G A M E S / REVIEW
Thief/29.99
inc VAT
70%
84
RICK LANE
85
OPINION
J I M K I L LO C K / DIGITAL RIGHTS
Should we ban
extremist content?
Banning extremist websites at the ISP level wont
stop terrorism, argues Jim Killock
ithout public debate, the
government has started to
censor websites it believes
promote extremist views. The list of
sites isnt published, nor put before a
court. Instead, Home Office officials
have created it. The secret list is then
used in universities, schools, libraries
government offices and hospitals to
restrict access to these sites.
Now, the government wants ISPs
to block sites on this list possibly
without a court order, citing the
voluntary method of blocking child
abuse images, via a list created by the
Internet Watch Foundation (IWF), as
the preferred model. In November,
The Guardian reported that David
Cameron, is understood to favour a
similar model [to the IWF] for terrorist
content. A government-funded body,
possibly within the counter-terrorism
referral unit, will order companies
including BT, TalkTalk, BSkyB and
Virgin Media to block websites,
according to industry sources.
Meanwhile, James Brokenshire MP
told The Daily Mail in February that
Terrorist propaganda online has a
direct impact on the radicalisation of
individuals and we work closely with
internet service providers (ISPs) to
remove terrorist material hosted in
86
Jim Killock is executive director of campaign organisation The Open Rights Group (www.openrightsgroup.org)
@jimkillock
87
F E AT U R E / ANALYSIS
EXTREME WI-FI
88
Powerline
networking is a
popular option
MAXIMUM THEORETICAL
SPEEDS
802.11a (5GHz)
54Mb/sec
802.11b (2.4GHz)
11Mb/sec
802.11g (2.4GHz)
54Mb/sec
802.11ac (5GHz)
1,300Mb/sec
89
F E AT U R E / ANALYSIS
Asus RT-AC68U
Asus RT-AC66U
HOW WE TEST
We carried out a simple file transfer test, LAN Speed
Test read and write tests (www.totusoft.com/
lanspeed.html) and PING tests using www.speedtest.
net, comparing them to a Gigabit Ethernet connection
in a typical usage scenario, with a 5m distance and
several walls between the adaptors and routers. We
connected two SSD-equipped PCs to either end to
measure the speed tests, eliminating bottlenecking,
and used the fastest router to test the Wi-Fi adaptors,
and vice versa.
90
BT Home Hub 5
The Home Hub 5 held up remarkably
well against the Asus routers at
5GHz. Its maximum speed of 337Mb/
sec (42.1MB/sec) in our file transfer
TrendNET TEW-812DRU
Unlike BTs Home Hub 5, the TEW812DRU sports a more elaborate
feature set, including QoS, printer
sharing via its USB 3 port
and multiple SSIDs,
although its still
basic compared to
Asus offerings.
At 5GHz, it
managed just
264Mb/sec (33MB/
sec) compared
to the Home
Hub 5s 337Mb/sec
(42.1MB/sec) in the
Zyxel NBG6503
Retailing at just 58, Zyxels NBG6503
is one of the cheapest 802.11ac
routers available. It has a fairly basic
feature set theres no USB port and
only basic software features in its
GUI, which also proved to be a little
laggy. It also doesnt offer full
802.11ac speeds, instead being
limited to 750Mb/sec, while all the
other routers on test were capable of
1,300Mb/sec. Its top speed of 100Mb/
sec (12.5MB/sec) in the 5GHz test was
pretty woeful, although it fared
better in the 2.4GHz test, being a
match for Zyxels 600Mb/sec
powerline adaptors.
Asus USB-AC56
Costing the same amount as the
PCE-AC68, you might wonder why
youd even consider the USB-AC56.
However, laptops and mini-ITX
systems may lack the ability to use
a PCI-E adaptor, and our speed tests
show the USB-AC56 is the next best
alternative to the PCE-AC68. Its
maximum speed in our 5GHz file
transfer test of 272Mb/sec (34MB/
sec) couldnt match the 464Mb/sec
(58MB/sec) of the PCE-AC68, but was
still much faster than any of the
other adaptors on test. It
ADAPTORS
Asus PCE-AC68
TrendNET TEW-804UB
The TrendNET TEW-804UB is even
cheaper than the TEW-805UB, but
unlike its sibling, which is rated at
867Mb/sec, the TEW-804UB only
offers 433Mb/sec of bandwidth.
Even so, it wasnt far behind, with
a maximum speed of 199Mb/sec
(24.9MB/sec) in our 5GHz test,
although it was much slower in the
2.4GHz tests. It also suffered from the
same need for TrendNETs wireless
utility, which often made connecting
to our router a pain. It might be
cheap, but Asus adaptors are faster
and hassle-free.
TrendNET TEW-805UB
At just 22, the TrendNET
TEW-805UB delivered
respectable speeds
for a USB 3 802.11ac
wireless adaptor,
maxing out at 216Mb/
sec (27MB/sec) in our 5GHz
file transfer test, and it
bettered the more expensive Asus
91
F E AT U R E / ANALYSIS
Zyxels powerline
adaptors
RESULTS
ADAPTOR RESULT S (5GHz)
116
Ethernet
24.9
22
3.5
30
60
90
120
PING (ms)
30
60
90
120
PING (ms)
14
Ethernet
14
Ethernet
Asus PCE-AC68
15
Asus PCE-AC68
15
Asus USB-AC56
15
TrendNET TEW-805UB
15
TrendNET TEW-805UB
15
Asus USB-AC56
15
Zyxel PLA5215
15
Zyxel PLA5215
15
17
TrendNET TEW-804UB
18
10
16
TrendNET TEW-804UB
18
15
20
Lower is better
75
24.3
Asus PCE-AC68
15
20
Lower is better
15.32
39.7
17 24
13.18
12.51
TrendNET TEW-804UB
12.6
21.6
11
15
10 11
2.9 3.3
11
Zyxel PLA5215 10
20
Write
Read
40
60
80
20
Write
Read
116
Ethernet
13
10.5
TrendNET TEW-812DRU
33
Zyxel NBG6503
9.3
BT Home Hub 5
8.7
Zyxel PLA5215
30
60
90
120
PING (ms)
80
116
Asus RT-AC66U
42.1
BT Home Hub 5
60
15.6
Asus AC68
54
Asus RT-AC66U
40
Ethernet
58
Asus RT-AC68U
75
33
Ethernet
41
18.3
Asus USB-AC56
TrendNET TEW-805UB
Zyxel PLA5215
10
33
Ethernet
12.7
30
60
90
120
PING (ms)
14
Ethernet
14
Ethernet
Asus RT-AC68U
15
Asus AC68
15
Asus RT-AC66U
15
Asus RT-AC66U
15
BT Home Hub 5
15
TrendNET TEW-812DRU
TrendNET TEW-812DRU
15
Zyxel NBG6503
15
Zyxel NBG6503
15
BT Home Hub 5
15
Zyxel PLA5215
15
Zyxel PLA5215
12
16
Lower is better
24.28
Asus RT-AC68U
17.91
Asus RT-AC66U
15
12
16
Lower is better
10 11
Read
10
Zyxel PLA5215
Write
9.63
29.3
20
15.32
10.62
75
33
Ethernet
41
30.7
16.89
TrendNET TEW-812DRU
75
29
15.6
BT Home Hub 5
Zyxel PLA5215
16
33
Ethernet
92
6.75
TrendNET TEW-804UB
TrendNET TEW-812DRU
13.9
TrendNET TEW-805UB
27
TrendNET TEW-804UB
15.6
Asus PCE-AC68
34
Asus USB-AC56
TrendNET TEW-805UB
116
Ethernet
58
Asus PCE-AC68
40
60
80
11
20
Read
Write
40
60
80
*$
#
!( !$
((
$
$
(!,$(! )$
% ) '# %
$, )!#$
& # #
& !
#( +(#$
(, $)#
# #
$#
#
%$
#
# ($ #
($ # #
(
#
#(
'%"
F E AT U R E / ANALYSIS
The first part of the worlds most ambitious Machinima project has just been released
for free online. Rick Lane goes behind the scenes with creator Hugh Hancock
to find out how it was made, and what lies in store for Part 2
here was a time in the mid2000s when Machinima,using
computer game engines to
make movies, seemed like the
next big thing. The success of shows
such as Red vs Blue, and mainstream
appearances, such as the use of the
Total War engine in the BBC TV show
Time Commanders, promised a whole
new way of utilising game tech to
make your own films and TV shows,
using nothing but your own computer.
But it hasnt really happened. The
website www.machinima.com is now
a generic host for all types of gaming
videos, and aside from that one
episode of South Park set in World of
Warcraft, when was the last time you
94
Hugh Hancock,
director of Death
Knight Love Story
Motion capture
Shot on location
Before any of that, filming begins in a
surprisingly traditional manner. The
first thing we do is go into World of
Warcraft and fly around the place. We
look for suitable locations, take
p h o t o g ra p h s , t a ke i n - ga m e
photography and then screenshot
those, Hancock explains. We
screenshotted those into an animatic
[a mock-up that follows the
storyboarding phase]. That was
basically just screenshots of WoW with
characters superimposed onto them.
This is one of the major advantages
Machinima has over traditional CGI.
Theres no need to spend millions of
pounds rendering your own sets.
Instead, locations are scouted out in
the same way as any director making
a live-action film. Hancocks reason for
choosing World of Warcraft specifically
as the basis of his film, aside from
being a regular player of the game, was
because of its vast range of landscapes
and consistent art style.
Once the scenery has been found,
the next step is to find the specific minimap square for that location, and then
implement a custom script for 3ds Max
that extracts the terrain data from
those coordinates and reassembles it
as a 3ds Max render. This is a gruelling
computational task. Hancock loads an
example scene that consists of around
600,000 polygons, and if the scene
95
F E AT U R E / ANALYSIS
Ray tracing
Remember kids,
when youre
playing with
swords, always
wear protection
96
F E AT U R E / ANALYSIS
AMD MANTLE
PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS
Matthew Lambert investigates the performance of AMDs
new graphics API in Battlefield 4 and Star Swarm
Mantle explained
As a graphics API, Mantle is like Direct3D, the graphics component of
DirectX. Its essentially a series of abstraction layers that grants
developers access to the various execution units and functions within
a GPU. However, APIs such as Direct3D and OpenGL have many layers
of abstraction, allowing programs to function across numerous GPUs
architectures from different manufacturers,which operate differently
at the hardware level. Mantle, however, is only designed with the GCN
architecture in mind, meaning fewer abstraction layers are needed,
which theoretically results in fewer overheads.
CPU draw calls essentially tell the GPU what to render. Hundreds or
thousands of calls can be needed to render even a single frame, which
can be costly with current APIs,especially with lots of on-screen action.
By thinning out the layers through which draw calls pass, and by
improving the ability to queue them across multiple cores and threads,
Mantle aims to significantly reduce draw calls as a bottleneck.
Therefore, the biggest gains should be seen in CPU-limited scenarios,
rather than GPU-limited ones, which are harder to combat at the API
level, although optimisations have been made in this respect too.
98
Battlefield 4
As FRAPS is incompatible with Mantle, were reliant on Battlefield 4s
built-in frame time recorder to test this game. Sadly, were only able to
accurately calculate and compare average frame rates from this data.
We use our standard single-player benchmark to keep it consistent.
Its a fast-paced scene with plenty going on,but multiplayer is still likely
to be more CPU-bound.
With our overclocked Core-i5 3570K installed, theres little difference
between D3D and Mantle. Even at Medium settings, the scene is still
predominantly GPU-limited, although the R9 290X improved by 6 or
7 per cent in both tests when using Mantle.
We then turned to a lower-end CPU, a stock-speed Core i3-3220. With
the Ultra detail test, it was the same story a small bump for the R9
290X and effectively equal results for the other cards.
However, with Battlefield 4 at Medium settings, we finally see
Mantle come into play. The similar results under D3D for the R9 290X
and R9 280X here tell us that performance is CPU-limited, and this
disappears with Mantle. The R9 290Xs performance improves by a
whopping 46 per cent, while the R9 280X and R7 260X see 16 and 6 per
cent gains.This also puts the AMD cards ahead of the competing Nvidia
hardware at each performance point. However, the big drawback is
that the gains are all but meaningless with such high frame rates
anyway, the unlocked performance doesnt result in any visible realworld differences.
We also tested the flagship Kaveri part in this game. At 1080p with
Medium settings, the scene is hugely GPU-limited for integrated
graphics,and the results are basically the same.At 720p with Low detail,
however, we see a 10 per cent increase and a slightly smoother
experience, as 60fps is hit more frequently.
BATTLEFIELD 4 RESULTS
12 fps
32 fps
18
54
54 fps
67 fps
36
77 fps
49 fps
71 fps
66 fps
72
52 fps
27 fps
9 fps
6 fps
13 fps
25 fps
10
20
38 fps
30
17 fps
60
52 fps
194 fps
16
Minimum
32
140 fps
139 fps
34 fps
76 fps
61 fps
48
80
184 fps
33 fps
40
12 fps
20
Medium detail, 0x AA
40
27 fps
16 fps
64
79 fps
Average
50
100
150
200
Star Swarm
Star Swarm is an Alpha demo of Oxide Games Nitrous engine, which
was built to exploit Mantle, and renders space battles with thousands
of ships in real time.We run the four preset scenes (which survey battles
from different viewpoints) three times each for two minutes,reporting
the average results, which include minimum frame rates.
With D3D, frame rates are universally poor and unplayable, even
with the top-end parts. Although frame rates can jump to beyond
100fps in less intensive sections, the more complex parts are very hard
work. The RTS scene is the clearest example, as it maintains a wide
view of the battle scene and constantly has thousands of ships in view.
With Mantle, the difference is massive. Although two of the scenes
still dip below 30fps with the R9 290X, the experience is far smoother
in the RTS scene, its minimum frame rate effectively quadruples.,
while the average frame rate here goes up by 180 per cent.
69 fps
74 fps
53 fps
54 fps
26 fps
26 fps
20
40
60
80
Medium detail, 0x AA
114 fps
166 fps
115 fps
132 fps
73 fps
77 fps
45
90
135
180
Conclusion
In Battlefield 4, Mantles real-world benefits are limited, and it works
best with higher-end GPUs were unsure how many people will be
pairing such cards with low-end CPUs. Still, free performance is free
performance, and we encourage you to try it out. Star Swarm, on the
other hand, is far more revealing.
Developers are currently used to designing games around API-based
draw call limitations, but Mantle widens the potential to show more
on screen at a time. Much remains to be seen, but this nonetheless has
interesting ramifications for game development, most obviously for
RTS games and shoot em ups, but also as a whole.
26fps
A10-7850K (D3D)
27fps
A10-7850K (Mantle)
0
7.5
15
22.5
30
55fps
A10-7850K (D3D)
60fps
A10-7850K (Mantle)
0
15
30
45
60
Average
99
F E AT U R E / ANALYSIS
AFTER THREE DECADES, THE AGING BIOS HAS FINALLY BEEN USURPED BY EFI, BUT IT WASNT AN EASY JOURNEY.
GARETH HALFACREE CATCHES UP WITH UEFI FORUM PRESIDENT MARK DORAN, TO FIND OUT WHAT WAS INVOLVED
100
Mark Doran,
president of the
UEFI forum
Consumer
motherboard
makers began
replacing BIOS
systems with
UEFI systems,
using its ability
to run a graphical
user interface as
a selling point for
early adopters
BIOS TIMELINE
source reference implementation on
http://tianocore.org. Conversations
about quality of implementation
tend to be discursive, rather than
prescriptive theyre more about
information sharing, Doran admits,
which can lead to issues such as
Samsungs early implementation,
which would brick laptops if too many
variables were written to its nonvolatile memory.
There are certainly documented
instances where implementations are
not in as good shape as I would wish to
see them, Doran candidly admits.
Happily, theyre relatively isolated
this isnt widespread. Clearly, it would
be better if implementations were
sound, robust and well screwed
together, and if the policies they
implemented were well thought out
ahead of time. Were in a transition; it
will take us a while before we have the
same history and experience among
the broad set of vendors that are
participating in the ecosystem with this
quote-unquote new technology.
And, you know, bugs do happen in that
kind of environment.
Security, too, is a concern at the
forefront of Dorans mind. Some of the
downsides about demystifying some
of what was historically spaghetti
code, which was obscure by nature in
the conventional BIOS, was that we
put a lot of extra light between the
firmware and the operating system in a
way that explained how the system all
worked to pretty much anyone willing
to sit down and read the public, open
documentation.
Lots of flexibility ensued, he
explains with a mixture of pride and
a hint of regret. We recognised that
there was the potential, in creating this
relatively open environment that was
well explained and well documented,
that wed also made a playground for
malware writers front and centre on all
of these machines.
The solution was Secure Boot,
which Doran animatedly describes as
a defence against malware inserting
itself into the boot flow. Its not about
DRM; its very strictly scoped to
prevent the insertion of malware in this
pre-OS space. While there were initial
1975
1981
1982
2006
Apple begins shipping its first Intelpowered machines, which use EFI in
place of the non-x86 Open Firmware
used on previous models.
1988
2007
1993
2008
1998
TODAY
2000
101
G A R E T H H A L FAC R E E S
Hobby tech
The latest tips, tricks and news in the world of computer hobbyism,
from Raspberry Pi, Arduino and Android to retro computing
T U TO R I A L :
102
1 Update Raspbian
I know I say this every time, but it always bears
repeating: always start each Raspberry Pi
project by updating the software catalogue
and installing any new upgrades that are
available. If you dont, you can run into
problems later. Type the following to kick
off the process:
sudo apt-get update && sudo
apt-get upgrade
2 Configure a static IP
By default, the Raspberry Pi gets a dynamic
IP address from your DHCP server like any
other client device. That isnt particularly
helpful if you want it to act as a server, though,
so set the Pi to a static address. Either set a
Any server needs to be easily found on the network, so give the Pi a static
address
4 Configure TOR
To make your Pi operate as part of the TOR
network, you need to edit its configuration file.
You need to change the configuration to set
TOR to run in relay mode with a pre-set
bandwidth limit for relay traffic, and a refusal
to run as an exit node. If youre not sure what
all that means, open the configuration file at /
etc/tor/torrc and read the comments
or just download my configuration file and
change the IP addresses to match your own:
sudo wget -O /etc/tor/torrc
http://freelance.halfacree.
co.uk/downloads/torrc
function FindProxyForURL(url,
host)
{
return SOCKS static.ip.
address:9100;
}
103
RETRO:
104
REVIEW:
Intel Galileo
he Intel Galileo is the first x86
86
product to receive certification
tion from
the Arduino project, offering
ng pinfor-pin compatibility with the common
on
Arduino Uno R3, and the first
commercial implementation of Intelss
low-power Quark system-on-chip
design. The result of the companys
partnership with Arduino, the
theory is that you can take any
existing Arduino software or
hardware, stick it on the Galileo, and
run it without modification.
Unlike the microcontroller-based Arduino
Uno, the Galileo boasts a fully fledged
microprocessor in the form of a 400MHz
single-core Intel Quark X1000 chip. Sitting in
the middle of the board, the Quark powers
the Galileo and gives it capabilities out of the
reach of the Arduino Uno. In particular, it runs
a fully fledged Linux distribution, albeit a cutdown one without a graphical user interface
a feature the Galileo couldnt use anyway,
thanks to its lack of video output. Coupled
with the units on-board Ethernet connection,
an SD card slot, USB host support and even
a mini-PCI-E slot, that gives the Galileo
considerable flexibility.
Getting started with the Galileo is pretty
easy, although no quick-start instructions
are provided in the box. However, a PDF
download gives Windows, OS X and Linux
users everything they need, including a
warning that attempting to power the board
from USB without its dedicated 5V 2A PSU
will result in damage. Particularly interesting
is the use of a modified Arduino IDE package
supporting just the Galileo and no other
Arduino hardware which provides a familiar
and friendly user interface for anyone already
used to Arduino-compatible products.
Speaking of compatibility, I was expecting
plenty from the Galileo after all, its an
officially licensed Arduino board. Sadly,
though, I quickly ran into trouble: lacking an
on-board microcontroller, the Galileo
achieves compatibility largely through bridge
chips and emulation, and its slow as a result.
A Sleepduino shield I had lying around
worked with the Galileo without hardware or
software modification, but the white noise
generator portion sounded like it was dying
due to a 230Hz-ish limit on IO. In short:
speed-dependent Arduino sketches, in
particular those that rely on the
NEWS IN BRIEF
105
MODDING:
Extreme Pi cooling
received what could well be the
most expensive item Ive ever
bought in terms of pounds-persquare-inch this month: an active heatsink
and fan assembly for the Raspberry Pi.
One of the biggest advantages of
embedded CPUs against mainstream chips
is that they generate a very small amount of
heat, which is only natural considering they
also draw considerably less power. The Pis
Broadcom BCM2835 processor is no
exception here: even sandwiched between
the PCB and a memory module, the chip
requires no additional cooling.
That hasnt prevented myself and others
from fitting heatsinks, of course. A passive
aluminium heatsink, such as the type typically
sold for adhering to BGA memory modules,
can drop the internal temperature of the
chip considerably. Also, it may or may not
help to prolong its life if youre venturing
into the realms of Turbo Mode or manual
overclocking, or enjoying the benefits of living
somewhere with a climate a little warmer
than sunny Blighty.
When my friend Andrew Back found and
rightly mocked an eBay auction for an active
heatsink with integral fan, however, I knew I
had to have one. When it finally cleared
customs, Im delighted to say I wasnt
disappointed: a black aluminium tower
heatsink is joined to the smallest fan Ive ever
owned through a piece of heatshrink tubing.
The latter is available in a variety of colours,
although sadly, I wasnt given a choice about
which colour I received. The package also
includes pigtail connectors that sit on the Pis
GPIO header.
The advantage of the latter is that they
make it possible to run the fan at two speeds,
by connecting it to the 5V or 3.3V pins. The
disadvantage is that the fan doesnt fit if you
have an add-on board thats hooked up to the
GPIO header. At least, not without snipping off
the connectors and doing some soldering.
To test the efficacy of the setup, I set up
a Raspberry Pi Model B in 900MHz Turbo
Mode, and took readings from the internal
temperature sensor. The results arent
surprising: in a room with an ambient
temperature of around 18C, the bare Pi
No heatsink
Heatsink,
fan disabled
Heatsink,
3.3V fan
Heatsink,
5V fan
41.2C
30.4C
37.9C
28.2C
26.6C
0
Idle
10
Load
20
31.5C
29.9C
30
40
50
Lower is better
Gareth Halfacree is the news reporter at www.bit-tech.net, and a keen computer hobbyist who likes to tinker with technology.
106
@ghalfacree
R E T R O T E C H / VINTAGE GAMING
DOOM
Ben Hardwidge reminisces about ids early 1990s action blockbuster
n February, id released a trailer for the new Wolfenstein
game. Its full of the robot Nazi alt-history nonsense youd
expect from the franchise, but theres a hint of something
else right at the end. If you pre-order Wolfenstein now, you get
access to the Doom IV Beta. I dont have a lot of hope for Doom IV.
Its been nearly ten years since Doom III, and that was a tedious slog,
but the announcement prompted a load of Doom memories.
Doom wasnt, as some people think, the original first-person
shooter, but it was the FPS that first made the genre really work.
Doom was also notable for having a free demo version that offered
a surprising amount of play time, the whole first chapter of the
game (Knee Deep In The Dead), in fact. This version came free on
various magazine cover disks, or you could buy it for a few quid.
This was a long time before hardware 3D acceleration (although
a Doom OpenGL patch came out later), so performance was wholly
dependent on the speed of your processor. I had a 20MHz 386 at the
time, which met the minimum system requirements, but the frame
rate was so bad wed say it was seriously unplayable today.
The only way to get it to run even vaguely smoothly on such a
machine was to set it to low detail, and then decrease the screen
size; a feature that gave you a mini screen of the Doom action in the
middle of your monitor, surrounded by a grey-blue wall effect
(pictured). Even this was enough for me to invite friends over to see
the game in action, enthralled by the fact you could see yourself
loading the shotgun when you ran out of ammo.
The action was barely discernible at these settings. Demons and
enemy grunts just looked like people who have been pixellated
beyond recognition on the news, and the small screen didnt show
up the scenery much either. Yet, I still loved it. Doom may have
looked primitive on my setup, but it was a whole new experience
a real-time 3D game that oozed atmosphere and blasted out a
corking soundtrack. The latter was a key facet of Doom. The MIDI
soundtrack, based on thrash riffs from the 1980s (look up Metallicas
No Remorse), even sounded good on an Ad-Lib card, but it sounded
even better on the Yamaha DB50XG I had at the time.
Doom marked the crossover between first-person shooters and
the 16-bit console era. At this time, people expected different levels,
each with a specific soundtrack, much like youd see in Sonic the
Hedgehog. This was before first-person shooters had stories or
movie-style soundtracks it was just all about the action. And thats
why I still hold a lot of affection for Doom today. Theres room for
storytelling in first-person shooters, but only if its done well.
BioShock Infinite got it right, but Doom III definitely didnt.
With its all-out action, ingenious level design and genuine scares,
Doom became a classic very quickly. It might have started out on
the PC, but it ended up being ported to almost every computer or
games system available, including the SNES and Amiga someone
has even made a ZX Spectrum version you can see on YouTube.
Doom offered a style of instant gratification that you sadly dont
see in first-person shooters now even Serious Sam didnt get the
balance of enemies right for me. Sadly, the last game to successfully
carry on the id FPS tradition was Quake II. Would people still play a
story-free, fast-paced action game with a stomping heavy metal
soundtrack today? I know I would.
We asked you for your favourite Doom memories on Twitter. Here are a few of them.
charles_6835
Hmm, being terrified LOL.
Donaldosaurus
Turning a corner and
being surprised by a pinkie
demon, falling off my chair in
shock and cracking my head.
NWheeler_CMP
The Doom door opening
sound, which has found its way
into every sci-fi franchise, ever.
johndavidread
Playing the 3.5in cover
disk of the Doom demo from PC
Review on a 486 in 1993 and
M_ILLSY Feb 20
I had an Escom p66 486
machine. It played okay, but
when the P120 came along it
was like HD!
ghalfacree
Prompted
by @Custom
PCMags
reminiscing, Im
having a quick
blast on the
Amiga port of
Doom.
107
MODDING
A N TO N Y L E AT H E R S
Customised PC
Case mods, tools, techniques, water-cooling gear
and everything to do with PC modding
Rigid tubing isnt for everyone
Every year, www.bit-tech.net holds
its annual modding competition
Mod of the Year. This years result
was quite interesting, especially for
anyone interested in building a
water-cooled PC. Many of the top
projects used rigid tubing, which I
spoke about last month. However,
it now seems that to get noticed,
especially at the top, rigid tubing is
a necessity. You can see this years
winning project in our Readers
Drives section this month (see p116),
and here are a few more from the
competition that put rigid tubing to
good use.
Have I used it in my PC? No for
the simple reason that I tinker with
it too much and its far more difficult
to work with rigid tubing than
standard, flexible PVC tubing.
However, for high-end system
builders, especially those that enter
future Custom PC Dream PC contests,
the use of flexible tubing will no
longer be an option if they arent
willing to lose eye-candy points.
One reason for sticking with
flexible tubing has been the fact that
the acrylic tubing most people have
been using is very brittle. That isnt
an issue if your PC is going to be
staying in one place, but if you take
it to LAN parties or modding events,
or if youre shipping a PC to a
108
Alphacools
Lighttower is
compatible with
practically every
pump, including
Phobyas DC12
range, most Eheim
and Hydor models,
and certain D5
models too
@antonyleather
109
M O D D I N G / HOW TO GUIDES
How to
Replace an
all-in-one liquid
coolers tubing
1 / IDENTIFY THE BARBS
TOTA L P R OJ E C T T I M E / 1 H O U R
ll-in-one liquid coolers such as Corsairs H80i are highly
desirable. offering cooling that matches or betters the best
air coolers, and theyre fairly compact and usually quiet too.
However, sometimes their tubes arent quite long enough for a
comfortable fit in certain cases.
Thankfully, many recent models use standard barbs to secure their
tubing, so its fairly easy to replace, meaning you can extend your
coolers reach as far as you like. You can even use clear tubing and a
coloured coolant, just like the more expensive custom water-cooling
kit. In the other guide this month (see p114), well go a step further and
add a reservoir, but if you just want to add some bling or extend your
tubing, follow the guide on this page.
TO O L S YO U L L N E E D
6/8mm tubing
(depending on your cooler) /
www.aquatuning.co.uk
Coolant /
www.aquatuning.co.uk
110
Use pliers to pull off the tubing if necessary. Bending it in the direction of the
cut you made should force it open and enable you to prise the tubing off the
barb without making excessive cuts.
7 / MOUNT HARDWARE
While youre removing the tubing, its a simple job to dismantle most pumps
to check for gunge build-ups that could hinder performance. The innards
of our pump are in good order, and the waterblock is free from detritus, so
theres no work to do here this should be the case with most coolers.
Youll need to find out the exact lengths of new tubing you need before you
fill the system with coolant again. Mount the hardware in your case and
loosely attach the tubing. This way, youll be able to find the exact lengths
youll need.
You can measure the barbs to find the right size of tubing you need, but
our Corsair H70 cooler required 6mm internal diameter (ID) tubing. This is
readily available as 6mm/8mm (the last figure being the outside diameter)
tubing. Go ahead and cut it to size.
As clamping the tubing will be difficult, its best to opt for tubing thats
slightly smaller than the barbs. Our barbs were 7mm in diameter, so using
6mm tubing allows you to heat it in boiling water first, so it shrinks back over
the barbs when it cools for a tight fit.
111
M O D D I N G / HOW TO GUIDES
Use boiling water to heat up the ends of the tubing youll need to warm
it up for a few minutes. This will then enable you to push and stretch the
tubing over the barbs on the radiator as far as possible. It will then cool and
provide a seal to prevent leaks.
Its now time to start filling the radiator and CPU section with your own
coolant. Use a pourer to fill the radiator and pump sections with as much
coolant as possible you might find it best to lay the radiator flat in a sink for
this job.
12 / SUBMERGE IN COOLANT
13 / CONNECT TUBING
As theres no fill port or reservoir, the only way to completely fill the system
is to submerge both sections in coolant, fill them to the brim, then connect
the pump section to the radiator section underwater. This will bleed any air
from the system.
You may need to heat the other ends of the tubing this time so that they
stretch over the barbs on the pump section. Youll then need to quickly put
them under the coolant and fit them before they cool.
15 / LEAKTEST SYSTEM
With your cooler now linked up again, tilt the radiator from side to side to
check for air bubbles. Small amounts of air are okay, but anything larger
than 1cm in the tubes may make your pump noisy.
Power on the pump and leak-test the cooler outside the case. This gives
you time to see if air has become lodged in the radiator, which might make
the pump gurgle. If it makes the same noise as before, and there are no
leaks after 24 hours, then your work is done.
112
M O D D I N G / HOW TO GUIDES
How to
Add a reservoir
to an all-in-one
liquid cooler
1 / CHOOSE BAY OR TUBE RESERVOIR
Depending on the size of your case, it may be easier to opt for either a tube
or bay reservoir. Mini-ITX systems are especially limited on space, so a bay
reservoir can be useful to tuck away in a spare 5.25in or 3.5in bay.
TOTA L P R OJ E C T T I M E / 2 H O U R S
ll-in-one liquid coolers might have brought some of the
benefits of water cooling to the masses, but they also lack
the finesse of a true custom water-cooling kit, as theyre
sealed units that dont use clear tubing or reservoirs. As such, they can
look a little bland. As we saw in the previous guide (see p110), though,
its possible to replace the tubing with clear flexible tubing so that you
can add some colour to the equation.
More importantly, you can also buy compression fittings to fit this
smaller tubing, meaning you can add a reservoir to your all-in-one
liquid cooler too. This will mean even more eye candy, while giving you
a much easier way to fill and bleed your water-cooling system too.
Youll even have the option to choose between a tube or bay reservoir,
and add a larger radiator too.
TO O L S YO U L L N E E D
6/8mm
compression fittings /
www.aquatuning.co.uk
6/8mm tubing /
www.aquatuning.co.uk
114
Coolant /
www.aquatuning.co.uk
Pliers and
Stanley knife /
Most hardware stores
Mount the reservoir pump section and radiator in the case so you can cut
the tubing to size and start fitting it. Its unlikely that youll be able to secure
it all together outside the case and then fit it internally without dismantling
it, and youll have to check for leaks first anyway.
Connect your 6/8mm compression fittings to the reservoir and tighten the
end nuts with pliers using a small amount of pressure. Youll then need to
thread the locking rings over the tubing before you fit it.
Check the flow of coolant around your loop if it isnt obvious which pump
ports are the inlet or outlet, then you may need to conduct some trial-anderror testing, but youre aiming to feed the pump from the reservoir. You
may need to heat the tubing too see the guide on p110 for more details.
Once all the tubing is connected, go ahead and fill the reservoir. Its a good
idea to use coloured coolant so that you can spot leaks. Cover every joint
with white tissue, so that leaks will be immediately evident.
9 / CHECK TEMPERATURES
As the tubing is small, the waters surface tension can make it hard to bleed
air from the system. You may need to tilt it to allow air to travel up to the
reservoir. Make sure the pump has plenty of coolant when its running, and
use an ATX jumper to switch it on without powering your other hardware.
All-in-one liquid coolers generally have much lower head pressures than
custom water-cooling pumps, so check your CPUs temperatures before
and after your changes to make sure its coping. Our bay reservoir worked
fine, but this is an essential test if youre adding a larger radiator.
115
MODDING
Readers Drives
Skyline GT-R
2013 BITTECH
MOD OF THE YEAR
WINNER!
116
AT
ECT LOG
J
O
R
P
L
T
FU L
SE E TH Eyurl.com/SkylineG
n
http://ti
117
MODDING
BE A WINNER
To enter your machine for possible inclusion in
Readers Drives, your mod needs to be fully working
and, ideally, finished based in the UK. Simply log on to
www.bit-tech.net and head over to the forums. Once
youre there, post a write-up of your mod, along with
some pics, in the Project Logs forum. Make sure you
read the relevant rules and advice sticky threads before
you post. The best entrant each month will be featured
here, where well print your photos of your project and
also interview you about the build process. Fame isnt
the only prize; youll also get your hands on a fabulous
selection of prizes see the opposite page for details.
118
Mayhems coolant
and dyes
VALUE 50 inc VAT /
MANUFACTURER www.mayhems.co.uk
The Phobya modding kit is designed with the modder in mind, offering
great value for money and quality products. The kit includes Nano-G 12
Silent Waterproof 1,500rpm multi-option fans,
which use an innovative fan-blade design.
As standard, the fans include braided black
cables to keep your case looking as neat as
possible. The fans are also supplied with a
special cable that lets you run the fan at 5V
rather than 12V, reducing the noise
emitted in order to help you to build
a silent system.
The kit also includes the
60cm Phobya 3-pin Molex to
4x 3-pin Molex Y-cable. This pre-
braided extension cable gives you extra routeing options in your case,
and it also enables you to run up to four fans from one compatible
motherboard header. Meanwhile, the Phobya SATA 3
cables included in the kit offer the same
great quality braiding as the rest of the
Phobya range, while also securing your
connection with latched connectors.
As well as this, the kit includes the
Phobya SlimGuide Controller,
which gives you the option to
whi
vary the speed of other fans in
va
your case, while the Phobya
yo
TwinLEDs let you shine a
light on your mods.
119
FOLDING
Folding@Home
Join our folding team and help medical research
Folder of the month / We catch up with: Coolamasta
CPC: So who is Coolamasta?
Coolamasta: My name is Rob,
and Im an IT manager for a
telecommunications company.
CPC: Why did you start folding?
Coolamasta: I came across the
folding section in Custom PC many
years ago, and then I read about how
protein folding was being studied
for areas such as cancer research
(among others), which appealed to
me. Plus, working in IT and having
suitable hardware was a bonus too.
CPC: What excites you most about
folding?
Coolamasta: Feeling like Im being
productive for good causes with the
technology available to me. I like
knowing I could play a part in
finding cures, especially as I know
people who have suffered from
some of the associated diseases.
Seeing large amounts of projects and
work units get completed with good
point returns makes it fun as well,
especially when we do the yearly
Chimps Challenge.
CPC: How many machines do you
have folding?
WHAT IS FOLDING?
Folding@home uses the spare processing cycles
from your PCs CPU and graphics cards for medical
research. You can download the client from http://
folding.stanford.edu and our teams ID is 35947. Once
you pass a significant milestone, youll get your name
in the mag. You can also discuss folding with us and
other readers on the www.bit-tech.net forums.
120
Team rank 3
World rank 97
Score 437,547,800
Work units 150,112
Daily points average 610,882
TOP FOL DER S: This months
shout-outs go to Oatyflapjack,
ChunkyBrother, Froskoy and Roveel.
If you fold under any of these names,
email [email protected]
POINTS
MILESTONE
USERNAME
POINTS
MILESTONE
USERNAME
POINTS
MILESTONE
USERNAME
POINTS
MILESTONE
Rhddrk
20000
Techie_Taylor
400000
SLOcaliKID
1000000
maniyer
9000000
hannettuk
30000
rhyswilliams999
500000
BurnedFastfood
3000000
David_Murphy
10000000
westie84
30000
MaverickOne
600000
Origami_Tsuki
3000000
Froskoy
10000000
Calum_brown
50000
Pickles
600000
Chicken76
4000000
Sparkymatt
10000000
okjorgensen
50000
siddallj
600000
davmonk
4000000
Dr.G
30000000
SirMaximum
50000
arcitech1
700000
DrJAG
5000000
KevinWright
50000000
atpark
60000
Clotten
700000
mmorr
5000000
JEE6
70000000
Philip_King
60000
conficient
700000
ChunkyBrother
6000000
Slavcho
70000000
Baxtee
80000
Evilpaperclip
700000
CopperHead1960
7000000
PC_Rich
100000000
Grimm808
80000
NoizDaemon666
700000
ITHelpDirect
7000000
The_M2B
100000000
vacant_machine
80000
Rogerater
700000
aingram86
100000
ejhunter
800000
DAILY POINTS
AVERAGE
TIME UNTIL
OVERTAKE
TSC! Russia
11,039,235,242
9,282,444
2.9 Years
Maximum PC
Magazine
9,975,594,023
9,477,120
1.5 Years
1000000
11,107,242
1000000
Hardware.no
17,885,109
9.1 Months
NavyBlue
100000
eplison3
800000
Thawn
100000
Liam266
800000
Catflaps
200000
Forquare
900000
happysam10
200000
crazystuntman
1000000
DJcarrot
400000
Nelio_
madmatt1980
400000
rvalkass
TOP 20 OVERALL
RANK
USERNAME
POINTS
7,251,215,993
TOP 20 PRODUCERS
DAILY POINTS AVERAGE
OVERALL SCORE
DocJonz
560,943,544
160,689
WORK UNITS
RANK
1
Nelio
USERNAME
2,701,101
370,522,058
Dave_Goodchild
447,983,678
114,753
DocJonz
917,584
560,943,544
coolamasta
432,265,159
150,059
StreetSam
806,013
223,501,964
Nelio
370,522,058
60,587
Scorpuk
715,270
230,938,698
phoenicis
250,044,587
95,660
coolamasta
659,623
432,265,159
Scorpuk
230,938,698
8,868
JEE6
508,143
74,520,254
StreetSam
223,501,964
80,201
piers_newbold
464,563
154,964,667
zz9pzza
211,014,628
15,794
Slavcho
451,436
77,340,442
Wallace
182,979,135
6,088
johnim
270,373
117,450,603
10
Ben_Lamb
157,654,038
2,615
10
PC_Rich
268,534
100,247,274
11
piers_newbold
154,964,667
26,469
11
Dr.G
230,850
30,419,159
12
Christopher_N._Lewis
152,197,972
35,787
12
Ben_Lamb
226,474
157,654,038
13
Lordsoth
131,985,635
80,518
13
Wallace
204,505
182,979,135
14
Lizard
131,878,662
60,132
14
KevinWright
177,959
50,558,932
15
johnim
117,450,603
72,965
15
LordBadger
122,871
77,041,069
16
r3x
106,384,516
17,267
16
Froskoy
119,908
13,146,560
17
CustomBitChimps
103,528,316
48,000
17
Roveel
109,295
16,097,816
18
The_M2B
102,253,299
47,218
18
ChunkyBrother
105,982
6,619,977
19
PC_Rich
100,247,274
60,426
19
Oatyapjack
101,783
13,052,872
20
BennieboyUK
91,328,166
5,768
20
The_M2B
92,557
102,253,299
121
OPINION
JA M E S G O R B O L D / HARDWARE ACCELERATED
IS IT STILL WORTH
OVERCLOCKING CPUs?
James Gorbold ponders the impact of CPU overclocking on gaming,
asking if massively overclockable GPUs would be preferable
y first experience of overclocking was back in the early
1990s when I discovered that, no matter how much
I spent on hardware (I upgraded twice in one day), I
simply couldnt get Wing Commander 3 to run smoothly on my
PC. However, after trawling through a myriad of contradictory
information on the Usenet (a now largely forgotten part of the
Internet), I eventually ended up with an answer overclocking.
After a fair bit of fiddling with the DIP switches and jumpers
on the motherboard, I eventually got my shiny new 33MHz 486
running at a heady 50MHz, thereby boosting the frame rate in
Wing Commander 3 to a playable level. The
only problem was that the CPU ran so much
hotter at 50MHz that, after around 15 minutes,
it would overheat and crash barely long
enough to complete one mission and save.
Dial the clock forwards 20 years, and in that
time, overclocking has become a hell a lot
easier,safer and better documented.However,
as 2014 gets into full swing, Im no longer convinced its really
relevant or necessary any more at least as far as gamers
are concerned.
While its certainly necessary for me to have a quad-core CPU
capable of good IPC (instructions per clock) or, in product terms,
any recent Intel Core i5, to get a good gaming experience,
anything more powerful is simply wasted on the vast majority
of games. In a recent experiment, I ran my main PCs CPU at stock
speed, and found that none of the half a dozen games Im
currently playing on Steam was adversely affected. The only
effect, and its one thats beneficial, is that my PC now runs slightly
quieter than before.
James Gorbold has been building, tweaking and overclocking PCs ever since the 1980s. He now helps Scan Computers to develop new systems.
122