Type VS1 and VS6 Vertical Turbine Pumps Wet Pit and Double Casing
Type VS1 and VS6 Vertical Turbine Pumps Wet Pit and Double Casing
Type VS1 and VS6 Vertical Turbine Pumps Wet Pit and Double Casing
Marc Buckler
Flowserve Corporation
Marc Buckler
Topics
Configurations & Construction
Pump Features
Design & Analysis
Sump Design
Configurations
&
Construction
Engineered Flexibility
Open or Enclosed
Lineshaft Construction
OR
Open Product
Lubrication
Enclosed Oil
Lubrication
OR
Above Ground
Suction
Below Ground
Suction
Above Ground
Discharge
Below Ground
Discharge
Impeller Constructions
Enclosed Impeller
Semi-Open Impeller
Impeller Constructions
Semi-Open
Enclosed
Impeller Mounting
Configurations
Provides interference fit between bowl
shaft and impeller
Colleted Impeller
Positively locked to shaft
Stainless steel slotted keys prevent
radial movement
Stainless steel split ring keys prevent
axial movement
Commonly used for extreme
temperature applications
Keyed Impeller
O-Ring Construction
Sealing Configurations
Driver Configurations
Question:
I have an application where the
pumping liquid is municipal water.
What pump configuration do I select?
Answer:
Consider a Wet-Pit VS1
with Product Lubrication
VS1
Standard Features
Product Lubrication
Bell Bearing
Provides maximum shaft support
Permanently grease lubricated for reliability
Suction Bell
Provides efficient flow into eye of first stage
impeller
Sand Collar
Prevents grit from entering into bell bearing
Lock Collet
Bowl Bearings
Column Pipe
Available threaded as shown to minimize well casing
diameter
Discharge Head
Pre-lubrication Connection
Question:
What if my pumping liquid contains
some abrasives?
Answer:
Consider a Wet-Pit VS1
with Enclosed Lineshaft /
Oil Lubrication
VTP
Standard Features
Enclosed Lineshaft
Oil Lubrication
Enclosing Tube
Provides protection from the pumped liquid
Question:
What if my application has limited
NPSH available?
Answer:
Consider a Double Casing VS6
Standard Features
Non-API VS6 Pump
Motor Alignment
Precision rabbet fit aids in the alignment of the
motor to the pump shaft
Pumps with larger motors are supplied with motor
alignment screws
Lifting Lugs
Permits economical two point lifting method of
pump during installation and maintenance
Question:
What if my application has limited
NPSH available and compliance to
API specifications are required?
Answer:
Consider a Double
Casing API VS6 Pump
Standard Features
API VS6 Pump
O-Ring Construction
Provides a positive seal of all flanged joints
Located at rabbet fits on bowl and column joints
Also included at discharge head to suction can fit
Pressure Casing
Consists of suction can and discharge head
Designed to ASME standards
Able to withstand APIs specified corrosion
allowances
Pump Intake
Design
Sump Design
Recommended design
Acceptance Criteria
No organized free surface and/or subsurface
vortices should enter the pump
Pre-swirl limited to 5 from the axial direction
Velocity fluctuations at the impeller less
than 10%
Time averaged velocities within +/- 10% of
the mean velocity (Turbulence)
Model Pump
Baseline Test
Sidewall Vortex
Surface Vortex
Floor Vortex
Remedial Measures
Modifications at entrance to pump bay
Curtain Wall
Grating
Baffles
Fillet
Splitter
Remedial Measures
Final Testing
Summary
Potential problems identified and corrected using physical modeling
The approach of using HI Standards with physical modeling provides the
best chance for success
The approach minimizes performance problems, O&M costs, and outages
Pump Analysis
RotoDynamic Analysis
Includes:
Torsional
Lateral
Structural Analysis
Includes:
Reed Critical Frequency (RCF)
Above Ground
Below Ground
Thermal Analysis
Pump Analysis
Reed Critical Frequency Analysis
Why is it done?
Determine the natural frequency of the combined motor & pump system
Prevent excessive vibration
Pump Analysis
Reed Critical Frequency Analysis
Design Standards
When is it required?
All VFD applications
To meet Hydraulic Institute and API 610 vibration limits
Motors > 260 kW (350 HP)
Design speeds 900 rpm
Design speed 3000 rpm AND > 7.5 m (25 ft)
Customer request
Inputs required
Motor Outline Drawing, Weight
Motor RCF (+/- 10%), CoG
Foundation stiffness / spring rates
Discharge head size
Discharge head type (TF, HF, etc)
Pressure rating (wall thickness, etc)
Required Modifications
Discharge head wall thickness
Ribs/gussets
Customer foundation
Possible lockout speed range
Pump Analysis
Reed Critical Frequency Analysis
Design Standards
The predicted lockout speed will be defined in a +/-20% range; however, the
actual lockout typically only requires a +/-5% speed range to be avoided.
Issues typically occur on high speed pumps with TF style discharge heads
Separation Margin
Minimum of separation factor above and below the running speed range is
standard for the reed critical analysis
+/- 20% separation for speeds 1200 rpm and greater
+25% / -20% separation for speeds 900 rpm and less
Pump Analysis
Reed Critical Frequency Analysis
Predicted
RCF Range
Actual
Blockout
Range
Speed
Pump Analysis
Reed Critical Frequency Analysis
Predicted
RCF Range
Actual
Blockout
Range
Speed
Pump Analysis
Reed Critical Frequency Analysis
Rigid System
Predicted
RCF Range
Actual
Blockout
Range
Speed
Pump Analysis
Reed Critical Frequency Analysis
Design Factors
Base Diameter
Frame Size
Weight
Center of Gravity
Reed Critical Frequency
Pump Analysis
Reed Critical Frequency Analysis
Cases To Avoid
Cast Heads have limited use for VFD applications.
Cast heads always have a system natural frequency below the
operating speed (flexible system)
Better for higher RPM applications (1800-3600rpm)
Not much can be done to stiffen the system
Pump Analysis
Reed Critical Frequency Analysis
Special Case
Pump Analysis
Nozzle Load Calculations
Why is it done?
Limit deflection at the stuffing box
Reduce stresses in the discharge head
Pump Analysis
Nozzle Load Calculations
Inputs Required:
Pump loading
Foundation design
Motor weight
Customer imposed loads
When is it required?
If the imposed reaction forces or
moments exceed the allowable load
When nozzle position differs from
standard (PRM)
Customer request
Required Modifications:
Add ribs to the discharge head
Thicken the discharge head riser
NOTES:
Pump Analysis
Foundation Load Calculations
Why is it done?
Determines load imparted on
foundation.
Allows proper sizing of anchor bolts,
foundation, etc.
Pump Analysis
Foundation Load Calculations
Inputs required
Pump and motor weight
Nozzle loads
Pumpage weight
Optional inputs
Start-up and locked rotor torque
Unrestrained piping
Motor imbalance
Other
Required modifications
N/A For reference only
When is it required?
Customer request
Pump Analysis
Seismic Calculations
Why is it done?
System anchorage is designed to
withstand a seismic event
Inputs required
Foundation loading (optional)
Specific design code (IBC is
standard)
Site seismic data
Required Modifications
Anchor bolt size or quantity
Foundation (size, embedment,
strength)
When is it required?
Customer request
Pump Analysis
Anchor Bolt
Why is it done?
System anchorage is designed to
withstand operating loads
Inputs required
Pump and motor weight
Nozzle loads
Pumpage weight
Required Modifications
Anchor bolt size or quantity
Foundation (size, embedment,
strength)
When is it required?
Customer request
When anchor bolts are supplied by
Flowserve
Pump Analysis
Lifting Lug
Why is it done?
To ensure the pump can be safely lifted using
the provisions provided
Inputs required
Pump weight
Discharge head style
Pump components (column size, etc)
Intended installation method (fully assembled,
components, etc)
Required Modifications
Lug redesign
Discharge head wall thickness
When is it required?
If Flowserve standards are exceeded
Weight and diameter dependent
Customer request
Pump Analysis
Torsional Analysis
Why is it done?
Reduce induced torques and stresses
Prevent fatigue
Inputs required
Motor inertia & stiffness
Required Modifications
Shaft material change
Increase shaft size
Modify speed range
When is it required?
Customer request
When required by API 610
Pump Analysis
Lateral Analysis (Critical Speed)
Why is it done?
Prevent displacement
Minimize vibration
Inputs required
Only pump data
Required Modifications
Modify speed range
Change bearing material or
spacing
When is it required?
Flowserve standard
Optional analysis method
using FEA per customer
request.
Pump Analysis
Reed Critical Frequency vs Critical Speed
Reed Critical Frequency Analysis
Structural Analysis
Determines system frequency
based on combination of pump,
motor and foundation data.
Both above and below ground
frequencies exist
Rotodynamic Analysis
Determines bearing spacing
Inputs from pump only
No impact from motor or
foundation
Pump Analysis
Thermal Analysis
Why is it done?
Predict temperature gradient
Determine pump growth rates and
total elongation
Inputs required
Ambient conditions
Vendor temperature limits (motor,
coupling, etc)
Cooling provisions
Operational conditions (temperature
cycles)
Required Modifications
Custom design per application
When is it required?
Applications > 260 C (500 F)
Customer request