Nutritional Properties of Fermented Milk Products
Nutritional Properties of Fermented Milk Products
Nutritional Properties of Fermented Milk Products
Fermented milk products such as yogurts have been consumed for several thousand years and the
belief that they are beneficial to health is probably equally ancient. But it is only in recent years
that scientific support for these beliefs has begun to build. Fermented milk products, like the milk
fr-om which they are made, are rich in protein, vitamins and minerals. However, in addition to
these purely nutritional properties, there is increasing support for a number of other health
advantages. The evidence for some of these is stronger than for others. For example, while the
support for improvement in tolerance of lactose b y maldigesters of this disaccharide is now very
robust, evidence to support the alleged ability of fermented milk products containing particular
bacterial cultures to reduce cuncer risk is still in its infancy. This paper focuses on the products
recognized by Consumers as yogurts. It includes a comparison of the nutritional value of milk and
yogurt, consideration of consumption trends and their impact on nutrition, and summarizes the
strengths and weaknesses of the evidence associated with a number of suggested health benefits
of hioferniented milks.
INTRODUCTION
Fermented milk products have been consumed
in Europe for perhaps 4000 years and yogurt is
one of the oldest and most popular of these
products worldwide. Many of the products
available today are derived from the results of
spontaneous lactic acid bacteria fermentation of
milk that arose centuries ago through the
influence of climatic conditions and local
traditions in the handling of milk. A number of
types of fermented milk products are listed in
Table 1 but mostly this paper will focus on
those recognized by consumers as yogurts.
Fermented milk products were originally
developed as a means of preserving the nutrients. Also, by fermenting milk with different
microorganisms, it has proved possible to
develop a wide range of products with different
flavours, textures, consistencies and functions.
Details of the different bacterial species used to
make fermented milk products can be found in
a review by Robinson. Yogurt is by far the
most commonly found fermented milk in the
UK. Yogurts are produced by a lactic acid
fermentation process using thermophilic strains
of bacteria. Other products such as viili, popular
in Finland, are also made via a lactic acid
fermentation process but mesophilic bacteria
are used and a mould added to give viili its
characteristic slimy consistency through a process which partially hydrolyses the fat. Other
Paper given at
symposium on The
current status of biofermented milks-foc US
on Europe, London,
29 October 1996.
0 1997 Society of
Dairy Technology
21
!t 21%
Fig. 1. Segmentation of the yogurt market, 1992. Based on Milk Marketing Board Trade
Estimates for 1992.
Lactose
An example of how the nutritional composition
is modified by the presence of the culture
concerns the milk sugar, lactose. During fermentation, 20-30% of milks lactose is hydrolysed to its component sugars, glucose and
galactose, by the culture b a ~ t e r i a .Conse~
quently, the lactose levels in yogurt can be
lower than in milk, although this is not always
the case as skimmed milk powder or non-fat
milk solids are sometimes added during manufacture. A lower lactose content would presumably help tolerance of the product by those
with a reduced ability to digest lactose. But
clearly the explanation is not this simple
because yogurts with a fairly high lactose
content also seem to be better tolerated by such
individuals than the equivalent amount of
lactose as milk (see below).
Lactic acid is produced as a byproduct of the
fermentation process. This may act as a preservative by reducing pH. It has also been
suggested that it influences the physical properties of the casein curd (eg, to induce a finer
suspension) so as to promote digestibility, to
improve utilization of calcium and other minerals and to inhibit the growth of potentially
harmful bacteria (see G ~ r r and
, ~ Alm,6 for
reviews).
Protein
Protein is composed of amino acids. Although
the overall amino acid concentration is similar
in yogurt and the milk from which it is derived,
there is a greater proportion of free amino acids
in yogurt because of the proteolytic activity of
the bacterial culture which partially digests the
protein during fermentation. However, this
characteristic is unlikely to be of major importance as most people already digest protein
efficiently.
Fat
It has been proposed that the digestibility of fat
is improved via the action of the bacteria
present during the fermentation process, but
whether this effect really exists is highly
debatable.5,7 The overall energy (calorie) content of yogurt reflects both the fat content of the
milk from which it was made and whether or
not there has been the addition of ingredients
such as cream or sugar.
22
Vitamins
The vitamin content of yogurt varies with the
type of milk used (particularly the fat content of
the milk, which influences the amount of
vitamin A and other fat soluble vitamins
present), with the strain of bacteria and with
fermentation conditions. In addition, whenever
milk is processed there is likely to be an effect
on the concentration of the more labile water
soluble vitamins, concentrations of which are
influenced by heat and/or light. Yogurt manufacture is no exception. Vitamin C is heat and
light labile, but it is more stable in the acid
conditions of fermented milk than in nmnal
milk.7
Levels of some B vitamins are reduced due to
the requirement of some lactic acid bacteria for
vitamin B12, for e ~ a n i p l e . Losses
~ . ~ of up to
90% of vitamin B12 have been reported with
specific bacterial strains, but losses are not
always this great and can be reduced considerably by use of a supplementary culture
capable of synthesizing significant amounts of
vitamin B 12.
On the other hand, several cultures are able to
synthesize the B vitamin, folk acid, increasing
the level of this vitamin present in the final
p r ~ d u c tIn
. ~ the current climate in which there
are concerns about the folate intake of women
in the early stages of pregnancy, this aspect may
prove to be a nutritional advantage.
Minerals
The fermentation process has little effect on the
mineral content of milk. Yogurt is an excellent
source of a number of minerals, especially
calcium, zinc, phosphorus and magnesium (see
Table 4). Not only are the concentrations of
these minerals high, but the bioavailability is
also generally good (ie, the proportion available
for absorption and utilization within the body).
Table 5 demonstrates this point. It lists the
number of servings of calcium containing foods
which would need to be consumed to match the
amount of calcium available from a single small
pot of yogurt (or from a glass of milk).
Some researchers have speculated that bioavailability of minerals from yogurt might even
be enhanced, compared with milk, because of
the lower (more acid) gastric pH induced by
yogurt, but scientific support for this is inconclusive and, generally, findings do not support
superior bioavailability.9
SUGGESTED
HEALTH PROPERTIES
The belief that yogurt consumption is beneficial
to health is ancient and part of folklore, having
been passed from generation to generation in
many parts of Europe. Recently, the term
probiotic has been coined to describe some of
these benefits.
An oral probiotic was defined at a special
workshop in Frankfurt as living micro-organisms which upon ingestion in certain numbers,
exert health benefits beyond inherent basic
nutrition. Probiotics may be consumed either as
a food component or as a non-food preparation.
Many health benefits have been attributed to
fermented milk products over the years, some
of which are listed in Table 6. For some of these
eg, improved lactose tolerance, a considerable
amount of evidence has been amassed as
discussed below, but others remain little more
than speculation and are far from well-established from a scientific point of view.
The job of attempting to make sense of the
available evidence is confounded by a number
23
International Journal
of
Dairy Technology
IMPROVED
LACTOSE INTOLERANCE
Numerous studies appear to indicate that
yogurt, particularly products containing live
bacteria, is well tolerated compared to milk by
individuals who have lactose intolerance. Such
individuals experience gastrointestinal symptoms due to a reduced ability to digest lactose,
the sugar (a disaccharide) in milk, into its
component sugars-glucose and galactosewhich can then be absorbed readily in the small
intestine. Undigested lactose cannot be absorbed and travels to the large bowel (colon)
where it is digested by the resident microorganisms, causing excess gas production,
intestinal discomfort and diarrhoea. In humans
lactase levels peak in early infancy to enable
digestion of human milk to take place efficiently. In most white Europeans levels remain
high during childhood and into adulthood,
perhaps stimulated by cows' milk consumption.
However, in as many as 70% of the world's
population (mainly non-Europeans), activity of
the enzyme, and hence ability to digest lactose
effectively, declines rapidly after weaning. This
is genetically determined and is considered to
be linked with the absence of a tradition of
dairying in Africa, India and Asia because of
adverse climatic conditions.
Lactose intolerance is not an all or nothing
phenomenon and the condition can exist to
varying degrees, depending on the extent of
loss of enzyme activity. The most likely
explanation for an improved tolerance of lactose when it is consumed as part of yogurt is the
presence of microbial (3-galactosidase derived
from the bacterial culture used in yogurt
production, which like intestinal lactase can
break down lactose to its component sugars.
Being intracellular, this enzyme survives its
passage through the stomach so long as the cell
wall of the bacteria remains intact, and so
potentially reaches the small intestine in its
active form. Kuhn and colleagues'8 suggest that
the enzyme can survive passage into the small
intestine even in non-viable but intact bacteria.
Pasteurization (and freezing) destroy the enzyme, but usually yogurt cultures are added to
the milk after it has been heat treated rather than
before.
However, the hypothesis is confounded by
the finding that lactose maldigesters tolerate
yogurts with varying levels of (3-galactosidase
equally well.I9 This suggests that factors in
addition to lactase activity, including rate of
gastrointestinal transit, may contribute. It has
been suggested that the presence in the gut of
bacterial lactase might stimulate residual in-
OTHERSUGGESTED BENEFITS
A number of other claims of health or probiotic
effects of fermented milks have been made
(Table 6).
Protection against gastrointestinal infections
Gastrointestinal infections, including diarrhoea, can result from a change in the gut
microflora caused by an invading pathogen.
Before the problem manifests itself, however,
the pathogen usually needs to establish itself in
sufficient numbers within the gut.
At the beginning of this century it was
suggested that consumption of fermented milk
products containing viable lactic acid bacteria
might interfere with the colonization and subsequent proliferation of foodborne pathogens,
thus preventing manifestation of
L hulgaricus, S therrnophilus, L acidophilus6
and also Bifdobacteriurn b i f d ~ r nhave
~ , ~ all
~
been implicated in this effect. In addition, it has
been suggested that lactic acid bacteria can
protect against antibiotic induced diarrhoea in
patients taking antibiotics capable of destroying
natural antagonists to disease producing organisms.26 Various mechanisms have been suggested including the ability of these cultures to
lower intestinal pH, which favours growth of
lactic acid bacteria, and their ability to produce
acids such as lactic, acetic, formic and propionic acids, which create an unfavourable
environment for the multiplication of pathogenic bacteria.
However, most of the evidence supporting a
role for cultured or culture containing dairy
products is derived from animal experiments
and in vitro s t ~ d i e s , ~ , ' and
~ > *findings
~
tend to
be i n c o n ~ i s t e n t But
. ~ ~ one
~ ~ promising line of
research concerns treatment of young children
with severe diarrhoea associated with various
conditions including rotavirus in f e c ti~ n.*~.~'
In
several studies, ingestion of fermented products
has reduced the duration of diarrhoea associated with rotavirus infection. There are also
25
Relief of constipation
The administration of fermented milk products
containing lactobacilli to severely constipated
elderly patients has been reported to have
beneficial effects on bowel movement in several s t ~ d i e s . ~ , ~ '
Improved immunity
Studies in experimental animals and in vitro
have suggested that consumption of live, active
bacteria via products such as yogurt enhance
specific and non-specific immune mechanisms,
and as a consequence provide protection
against pathogens and viruses.'5 It has been
suggested that gamma-interferon may be instrumental in this
But to date,
evidence is not sufficiently strong to justify
claims that fermented milks enhance the immune response or reduce the risk of infection in
humans. In particular, it is not clear what the
implications of the experimental findings in
animal models and in vitro are for normal
healthy people.
Cholesterol reduction
Having a high blood cholesterol concentration
is considered to be one of the four major risk
factors for coronary heart disease. Interest is
growing in the possibility that some fermented
milk products may facilitate a reduction in
blood cholesterol level, specifically the low
density lipoprotein (LDL) fraction. This interest initially derived from the observation that
Masai tribesmen in East Africa consume large
quantities of yogurt like foods and have low
blood cholesterol in spite of a diet largely based
on animal products. A number of studies have
since provided support for a hypocholesterolaemic effect, although others have failed to
provide confirmation. The conflicting reports in
the literature may be explained by factors such
as differences in experimental design and in the
species and strains of bacteria used. For
example, Agerbaek and colleagues34 have reported a 10% reduction in LDL-cholesterol
after regular consumption of a fermented
product carrying a specific bacterial culture
(which included Enterococcus faecium) for 6
weeks. There was criticism of a number of
aspects of this short study, however, including
the type of placebo used-it
was not a fermented product. There was also a high initial
level of LDL-cholesterol in the treated group of
middle aged men. Other studies reviewed by
Renner9 and Schaafsma" have also demonstrated reductions in LDL-cholesterol of a
similar magnitude4.2% and 5-6%. Additional studies are underway, in which some of
the shortcomings of earlier studies are being
26
CONCLUSIONS
Regular consumption of cultured and culture
containing milk products have been claimed to
confer a wide range of health benefits. It can be
concluded that a number of investigations
support the view that yogurt (particularly 'live'
yogurt) is a well tolerated alternative to milk for
those with a reduced ability to digest lactose.
This improved tolerance is considered to be
partly due to the presence of the enzyme (3galactosidase in the bacterial culture within the
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
27