Fault Location Using Wavelets
Fault Location Using Wavelets
Fault Location Using Wavelets
4, October 1998
1475
1 Introduction
Transmission line fault location has long been one of the primary
concerns of the power industry. Methods of locating power system faults introduced so far, can be broadly classified under two
categories: one based on the power frequency components, and
the other utilizing the higher frequency contents of the transient
fault signals. The latter is also referred to as traveling wave or
ultra high speed fault location method, due to its use of traveling
wave theory and shorter sampling windows.
The use of traveling wave theory for fault detection was
initially proposed by Dommel and Michels in [I], where a discriminant was defined based on the transient voltage and current
waveforms in order to detect a transmission line fault. McLaren
et al. have later developed a correlation based technique where
the cross correlation between stored sections of the forward and
backward traveling waves were used to estimate the travel times
of transient signals from the relays to the fault point [2,3,4]. An
overview of traveling wave based fault location methods can be
found in [ 5 , 6 ] .
PE-303-PWRD-0-12-1997 A paper recommended and approved by
the IEEE Transmission and Distribution Committee of the IEEE Power
Engineering Society for publication in the IEEE Transactions on Power
Delivery. Manuscript submitted July 28, 1997; made available for
printing December 12, 1997.
1476
Wavelet transform has been introduced rather recently in mathematics, even though the essential ideas that lead to this development have been around for a longer period C P time.
~
It is a
linear transformation much like the Fourier transform, however with one important difference: it allows time localization of
different frequency components of a given signal. Windowed
Fourier transform also partially achieves this same goal, but with
a limitation of using a fixed width windowing function. As a
result, both frequency and time resolution of the resulting transform will be apriori fixed. In the case of the wavelet transform,
the analyzing functions, which are called wavelets, will adjust
their time-widths to their frequency in such a way that, higher
frequency wavelets will be very narrow and lower frequency
ones will be broader. This property of multi resolution is particularly useful for analyzing fault transients which contain localized high frequency components superposed on power frequency
signals. Thus, wavelet transform is better suited for analysis of
signals containing short lived high frequency disturbances superposed on lower frequency continuous waveforms by virtue of this
zoom-in capability.
Given a function f ( t ) , its continuous wavelet transform
(WT) will be calculated as follows:
i,
lem
Consider a single phase lossless transmission line of length
connected between buses A and B, with a characteristic
impedance 2, and traveling wave velocity of U . If a fault occurs
e,
is used. The phase signals are transformed into their modal components by using this transformation matrix as follows:
Sinode
= TSphase
(4)
where, Smo& and Spha.ve are themodal and phase signals (voltages
or currents) vectors respectively.
Clarke's transformation is real and can be used with any
transposed line. If the studied line is untransposed, then an eigenvector based transformation matrix, which is frequency dependent, will have to be used. This matrix should be computed at
a frequency equal or close to the frequency of the initial fault
transients.
Recorded phase signals are first transformed into their modal
components. The first mode (mode l), is usually referred to as the
ground mode, and its magnitude is significant only during faults
having a path to ground. Hence, this component can not be used
for all types of faults. The second mode (mode 2), also known as
the aerial mode, however is present for any kind of fault. Accordingly, the fault location problem is formulated based essentially
on the aerial mode, making occasional use of the ground mode
signal for purposes of distinguishing between certain peculiar situations, which will be discussed in the next section. Depending
on the existing communication scheme between the two ends of
the line, fault location problem can be solved in two different
ways described below.
1477
e - v,
td
where,
It has long been observed that ungrounded faults such as line-toline or ungrounded three-phase, do not cause significant reflections from the remote end bus during the fault transients. Thus,
by measuring the time delay between the two consecutive peaks
in the wavelet transform coefficients of the recorded fault signal
at scale 1, and taking the product of the wave velocity and half of
this time delay, the distance to the fault can easily be calculated
for these kinds of faults. The fault distance will be given by the
equation:
= 2t - tx
(7)
where:
t is the travel time for the entire line length, and e, is the time
interval between the first two peaks of aerial mode WTCs in
scale 1.
Figure 1 shows the flowchart for the proposed fault location
algorithm based on the wavelet transform coefficients. Next
section contains results of simulations used to test this proposed
algorithm for various fault types and line configurations.
Transducer
output
Transformation
Wavelet
L-r
Transformation
YE
Ungrounded Fault
where,
x is the distance to the fault, v is the wave velocity (for the mode
used), and td is the time difference between two consecutive
peaks of the wavelet transform coefficients.
3.2.2
I
I
r
Grounded Faull
Remote half of the line.
Based on Scale 1 Mode 2
calculate td as in Eq. (7)
then calculate the fault
Grounded Fault
Near half of the line.
Based OD Scale 1 Mode 2
calculate the fault loc.
as in Section 3.2.1
I
4 Simulation results
The ATFEMTP program [ 141 is used to calculate the transient
signals in the power system. Figure 2 shows the system configuration used in the simulations. The frequency dependent model
is used to model the line [ 151. The relays are located at hushar A
and B for the double ended configuration and at busbar A for the
single ended configuration.
For this tower configuration, mode 2 (aerial mode) has a
propagation velocity of 1.8 182 x lo5 miles/sec. A sampling time
of l o p s is used. The system is simulated using double and single
1478
1 = 200 miles
345 KV
1-x
345 Kv
D-c------h
I
(
:t
2t
II
3T2
20
20 5
21
.**
T1
225
23
5(a) and (b) show the WTC for scale 1, of the voltage transients
recorded at bus A and B respectively.
In this example, the first WTC peak at bus A occurs at tA =
20.15 ms, and at bus B at t B = 21 ms, yielding f d = 0.85 ms and
using Eq.(5):
200- 1.81 x io5 x 0.85 x 1 0 - ~
= 22.99 miles.
2
x=
0
7-
B u s B: Scale 1, mode 2
2Tl+T2 5T2
3
I I
22
21 5
time (ms)
. .
T1+2TZ
time (ms)
3T1
T1+4T2
*
I
l
j
Figure 3: Lattice diagram for a single phase to ground fault at 120
miles from A.
4.
ronized recording
1479
c)Scale 1, mode 1
a)Scale 1, mode 2
1.5r
c)Scale 1, mode 1
a)Scale 1, mode 2
21
22
23
time (ms)
d)Scale 2, mode 1
5
Q)
A4
30
21
22
time (ms)
b)Scale 2, mode 2
2,
23
time (ms)
d)Scale 2, mode 1
I
x 3
cu
< 2
z1
0
20
21
time (ms)
22
23
time (ms)
21
22
23
time (ms)
time (ms)
4.2.2
= 2 x 5.5 x
Grounded faults:
= 29.09 miles.
1.9 x
X =
= 172.72 miles.
1480
c)Scale 1, mode 1
d)Scale 1, mode 2
101
[2] S. Wajendra and P.G. McLaren, Traveling-Wave Techniques Applied to the protection of Teed Circuits: Principle of Traveling Wave Techniques, IEEE Transactions
on Power Apparatus and Systems, Vol. PAS-104, no. 12,
pp.3544-3550, Dec. 1985.
1,
time (ms)
b)Scale 2. mode 2
[3] S. Rajendra, and P. G. McLaren, Traveling Wave Techniques Applied to the Protection of Teed Circuits: - Multi Phase I Multi Circuit System, IEEE Transactions on Power Apparatus and Systems, Vol. PAS- 104, no. 12, pp.355 13557, Dec, 1985.
time (ms)
d)Scale 2, mode 1
151
4,
? I
aJ
345 Kv
345 KV
345 Kv
I
c
100 miles
161 G.B. Ancell, and N.C. Pahalawaththa, Effects of Frequency Dependence and Line Parameters on Single Ended Traveling Wave Based Fault Location Schemes, ZEE
Proceedings-C, Vo1.139, No.4, July 1992, pp.332-342.
100 miles
5
This paper presents a new, wavelet transform based fault location method. Using the traveling wave theory of transmission
lines, the transient signals are first decoupled into their modal
components. Modal signals are then transformed from the time
domain into the time-frequency domain by applying the wavelet
transform. The wavelet transform coefficients at the two lowest
scales are then used to determine the fault location for various
types of faults and line configurations. The proposed fault location method is independent of the fault impedance and is shown
to be suitable for mutually coupled tower geometries as well as
series capacitor compensated lines. The method can be used both
with single ended and synchronized two ended recording of fault
transients. The fault location estimation error is related to the
sampling time used in recording the fault transient. Furthermore,
for grounded faults near the middle of the line, mode 1 signals
from the fault and from the far end become comparable increasing the error of the fault location algorithm. Simulation results
are given to demonstrate the performance of the method.
References
H. W. Dommel, and J. M. Michels, High Speed Relaying
using Traveling Wave Transient Analysis, IEEE Publications NO. 78CH1295-5 PWR, paper no. A78 214-9, IEEE
PES Winter Power Meeting, New York, January 1978,
pp.1-7.
Transmission Lines in Electromagnetic Transient Simulations, IEEE Trunsactlons on Power Apparatus and Systems, Vol. PAS-101, no. l,pp.147-155, Jan. 1982.
Fernando N. Magnago obtained the B.S. degree from UNRC,
Argentinain 1990 and his M.S. degree from Texas A&M University, College Station, TX in 1997. He is currently a Ph.D. student
at Texas A&M University.
Ali Abur (SM90) received the B.S. degree from M E W , Turkey
in 1979, the M.S. and Ph.D. degrees from The Ohio State University, Columbus, OH, in 1981 and 1985 respectively. Since
late 1985, he has been with the Dept. of Elect. Eng. at Texas
A&M University, College Station, TX, where he is currently an
Associate Professor.