It Might Appear That B Will See A Disappearing As He Reaches The Angle of 45

Download as docx, pdf, or txt
Download as docx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 5

It might appear that B will see A disappearing as he reaches the angle of

45 but actually what happens is that the light from A before he crosses
the 45 will take a very long time reaching B because B is traveling further
and further away (he is almost going with the speed of light) so light itself
will take a long time to catch him up and it will catch him but only at
infinity
So B will perceive that A is traveling slower and slower reaching the point
C (or 45) but never crossing it
the reason we went through all of that is because general relativity
predicts the same phenomenon for black holes
if someone is traveling in a rocket towards a black hole he will feel himself
accelerating towards it, but someone else observing from the outside will
see the rocket getting slower and never reaching the Schwarzschild radius
Schwarzschild
radius

Observer

There is a mathematical description which is the solution for Einstein field


equation (1) and its called Schwarzschild metric
2

d + sin d
r
r2
c 2 2= 1 s c 2 t 2
r 2 )
r
rs
1
r

( )

( )

is the proper time (time measured by a clock moving along the


same world line with the test particle),

c is the speed of light,

t is the time coordinate (measured by a stationary clock located


infinitely far from the massive body),

is the radial coordinate (measured as the circumference, divided by


2, of a sphere centered around the massive body),

is the colatitude (angle from North, in units of radians),

is the longitude (also in radians), and

is the Schwarzschild radius of the massive body, a scale factor which


is related to its mass M by rs = 2GM/c2, where G is the gravitational
constant.

We can see that two things happens: First when r s=r the term (1-

rs
r

=0 which means that the proper time is infinite and thats why the
observer will see the time traveling ever slower and the rocket never
crosses the Schwarzschild Radius, so an instant of time appears to him an
infinity of time
Second when r itself is zero (means when we heat the black hole) we will
get that

2 2=

And that represents singularity which means the event horizon (a hyper
surface in space-time that can only be crossed in one direction) and that is the ultimate
bent of space time

VI -Information paradox
According to the no Hair theorem stationary black holes are only
characterized by three parameters electric charge mass and angular
momentum.
Hence there is no need to describe the matter that went to form the black
hole in all detail. It seems like thermodynamics does not bring new
information however one can see it as useful paradigm for the black
holes ,the mass plays the role of energy charged and rotating
thermodynamics systems are known so the charge and angular
momentum can be admitted , but to have a complete list of parameters
one needs entropy .
The fact that the horizon area tends to increase leaded Bekeinstein to the
conclusion that the area represents the entropy of the black hole.
If a system fall into a black hole the entropy outside the black hole must
decreases which is in contradiction with the second law of
thermodynamics so Bekeinstein suggests that one must not discuss
entropy inside a black hole but define a more general form of the second
law the sum of black holes entropies together with the entropy outside the
black hole cannot decrease.

When black holes are formed by a collapse the no hair theorem shows
that information is lost the body is described by a large number of
parameters the type of matter the multiple however when the black hole
is formed all information is lost only the mass and charge are conserved.
In general relativity an outside observer would find difficulty determining
what the body was like but he could determine what was the body made
of and the distribution of the mass Hawking demonstrated that quantum
theory changes all of that because the body would send a discreet number
of photons before crossing the event so not all the information will be
carry out and since a black hole radiate (thermal radiation) and loses mass
because of the heat causes by the entropy causing it to disappear
completely taking the information outside .
One concludes that the information is lost. In quantum field theory a state
can be represented by a ket bracket vector and a mixed state can be
represented by a density matrix named wish can represents both the
pure and mixed state because a mixed represents the probabilistic mixture
of pure state .
-if 2 is equal to 1 the state is pure. -If 2 is less than one the state is
mixed.
Another criterion is if the Von Newman entropy is equal to zero for a pure
state and positive for a mixed one. When hawking did consider radiation
he found that it is possible to convert a pure state into a mixed state. In
March 2015 AnshulSaini DejanStojkovic constructed a mathematical
formalism demonstrating that the density matrix respects the unitarily
principle.
For that they used the functional Schrdinger which is adequate for this
problem because it gives the time evolution if the system rather than
radiation from a pre-existing black hole. First they did consider a massive
shell which is collapsing under its own gravitational pull. This process can
be described by a time dependent metric (they used Schwarzschild
metric) this metric excites the quanta field.
As general relativity predict an outside observer would take infinite time to
see the collapse reaching its own Schwarzschild radius.
The formalism of the two collaborators gives an explicit form of the wave
function of the emitted radiation, which holds all the information about the
diagonal Hawking matrix and the correlations terms.
The fact that time evolution created progressively more off-diagonal terms
and that the cross product terms become of the same order of the
magnitude as the hawking terms leaded to a modification in density
matrix .
The two physicists calculated the time evolution of the density matrix as a
function of frequency and time and then the squared density matrix. When

taking only the diagonal terms in the density matrix then the squared
density matrix goes from pure state to mixed one so the information is no
longer conserved.
However when taking the off- diagonal terms in consideration the squared
density matrix respects the unitarily principle for all frequencies and time
evolution. So we now have a consistent mathematic proof of the
conservation of the information inside the black hole.

You might also like