Infant and Young Child Feeding
Infant and Young Child Feeding
Infant and Young Child Feeding
Infant and
Young Child
Feeding
May 2011
Nutrition Section, Programmes, UNICEF New York
This is a working document. Any comments or corrigenda to this version and requests to reproduce may be sent
to: the IYCF Unit, Nutrition Section, UNICEF New York, at: [email protected]
ii
Acknowledgements
This programming guide was prepared by Nune Mangasaryan, Senior Nutrition Advisor (Infant and
Young Child Nutrition), Christiane Rudert, Nutrition Specialist (Infant Feeding) Mandana Arabi,
Nutrition Specialist (Complementary Feeding) and David Clark, Nutrition Specialist (Legal), from the
Infant and Young Child Feeding Unit, Nutrition Section, Programmes, UNICEF New York, with the
support of Werner Schultink, Chief of Nutrition Section.
The inputs provided by the following people are acknowledged: Paula Claycomb, Communication for
Development, France Begin, Regional Nutrition Advisor APSCC, Maaike Arts, Nutrition Specialist in
Mozambique, Anirban Chatterjee, former Nutrition Specialist HIV Care and Support UNICEF New
York. Editing support was provided by Linda Sanei and Crystal Karakochuk, NETI Programme
Nutrition Specialist.
As a working document, the Programme Guidance will periodically undergo revisions to improve its
programmatic utility. Comments and suggestions are welcome from UNICEF staff and partners.
For questions arising from this document or general questions on IYCF programming, contact the
IYCN Unit: [email protected]. For specific questions regarding breastfeeding programming and HIV and
infant feeding please contact Christiane Rudert ([email protected]). For questions regarding
complementary feeding programming, please contact Mandana Arabi ([email protected]). For
questions regarding the Code and other legal aspects of IYCF programming, please contact David
Clark ([email protected]).For questions on communication to promote behaviour and social change,
please contact Paula Claycomb ([email protected]). For general comments or questions on IYCF
programming or any other topics not mentioned above, please contact Nune Mangasaryan,
[email protected].
iii
Preamble
This Programme Guidance contains detailed programming information on IYCF, including
breastfeeding, complementary feeding and infant feeding in general and in especially difficult
circumstances including in the context of HIV and in emergencies. It also briefly addresses maternal
nutrition. The key action areas for these components are detailed at the different levels, including
national policy/strategy level, health services, and community. The document provides strategic
programme recommendations for priority IYCF actions and their operationalization that will support
achievement of MDGs 1 and 4, among others, as well as UNICEF Medium Term Strategic Plan
(MTSP) Focus Area 1 on Young Child Survival, Growth and Development. The document emphasizes
that breastfeeding and complementary feeding both play a significant role in the reduction
undernutrition (both stunting and wasting) which is a key strategic area of UNICEFs equity focus. The
document briefly summarizes UNICEFs role in IYCF programming, but the document is not focused
on UNICEF actions alone it may be used by a broad range of partners involved in IYCF
programming.
The Programme Guidance serves as a single reference on IYCF programming updating existing
1
2
guidance where necessary (e.g. HIV and infant feeding and the Code ) and adding new or more
detailed guidance where little existed previously (e.g. complementary feeding, community-based
programming and communication). It draws upon and builds on existing tools such as the 2007
WHO/UNICEF Planning Guide for National Implementation of the Global Strategy for IYCF, with
additional detailed and practical guidance on the how the design and implementation of the
recommended key IYCF action areas at scale in a comprehensive manner. For each component, the
document describes the best practices, based on lessons learned, case studies, reviews and evidence
of impact. It suggests options to implement proven effective interventions, such as institutionalizing the
BFHI, building skills of community health workers to counsel and support mothers on IYCF and
describing improved approaches to communication for behaviour and social change. The guidance
highlights that communication alone is not sufficient for improving breastfeeding and complementary
feeding practices, and needs to be complemented by counselling and support by skilled workers at
community and health system levels.
The new guidance on complementary feeding programming includes the process and tools for
assessment of various parameters to understand the local complementary feeding situation, a decision
tree on selecting appropriate programmatic options depending on the local situation and the use of
different types of products within complementary feeding programmes.
Annex 1: Resources, tools & useful websites contains a listing with active web links of major reference
materials, tools and resources on IYCF to facilitate the planning and implementation process.
The Programming Guide aims to be comprehensive. However, users may elect to use only those
chapters, resources and tools that provide the direction they are seeking on a specific topic. The
potential for modular use of the guidance is the reason why there is a certain amount of repetition in
the document.
This document may be used to help design and implement comprehensive IYCF programmes, but
also to assess the extent to which existing programmes are congruent with the recommended key
action areas. The associated IYCF Assessment Matrix (Resources Annex 1-1) is to be used to provide
a detailed overview of the scope and scale of all of the action areas in each country. This overview will
serve as a baseline, and after a certain number of years the matrix can be updated to assess the
progress in each country with the various programme components.
Finally, UNICEF has also recently developed a number of new tools for IYCF: a complete generic
training package and planning/adaptation guide for community based IYCF counselling; a set of
training slides and resource module on communication on exclusive breastfeeding (currently being
conveyed through webinars but can be used in the field too) and an e-learning course for programme
managers and technical staff on IYCF, currently under development in collaboration with Cornell
University. A slide set on the programme guidance can be used to promote and advocate for
increased attention to IYCF or to orient stakeholders on the key IYCF action areas.
1
2
iv
Table of Contents
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS.............................................................................................................................. III
PREAMBLE .............................................................................................................................................. IV
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS ........................................................................................................................... VII
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: KEY POINTS ................................................................................... 1
1. BACKGROUND ...................................................................................................................... 2
1.1 INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................................................ 2
1.2 IYCF AND ITS ROLE IN CHILD SURVIVAL, GROWTH AND DEVELOPMENT ...................................................... 3
1.3 SUMMARY OF GLOBAL SITUATION ...................................................................................................... 10
1.4 THE POLICY BASES FOR IYCF ............................................................................................................. 14
1.5 SUMMARY OF THE EVIDENCE ON EFFECTIVE OF INTERVENTIONS .............................................................. 15
2. NATIONAL LEVEL STRATEGIC PLANNING FOR IYCF .................................................. 17
2.1. ADVOCACY, PARTNERSHIPS AND COORDINATION .................................................................................. 18
2.1.1 Advocacy and partnerships ................................................................................................ 18
2.1.2 Coordination....................................................................................................................... 19
2.2. SITUATION ASSESSMENT ................................................................................................................... 21
2.2.1 Completing assessment matrix .......................................................................................... 21
2.2.2. Obtaining baseline of practices using the updated IYCF indicators ................................... 22
2.2.3 Reviewing the area graphs for the country........................................................................ 24
2.2.4 Collecting additional quantitative & qualitative data ....................................................... 25
2.3 DEVELOPING NATIONAL IYCF POLICY ................................................................................................... 27
2.3.1 National IYCF Policy............................................................................................................ 27
2.3.2 Policies for strengthening IYCF within health systems ....................................................... 28
2.3.3 Policies to strengthen IYCF within community-based services........................................... 29
2.4 DEVELOPING A COMPREHENSIVE IYCF STRATEGY & PRIORITIZING INTERVENTIONS ...................................... 30
2.4.1 Goals, objectives and targets of the national IYCF strategy ............................................... 31
2.4.2 Costing of the strategy ....................................................................................................... 32
2.4.3 Key components and interventions of IYCF strategy.......................................................... 32
Strategy component: Legislation .......................................................................................................................... 33
Strategy component: Interventions in the health system .................................................................................. 35
Strategy component: Community based IYCF interventions ........................................................................... 37
Strategy component: Communication for behaviour and social change ........................................................ 38
Strategy component: Additional complementary feeding interventions/components ................................... 39
Strategy component: IYCF in exceptionally difficult circumstances ................................................................ 43
vi
List of Abbreviations
ACSD
AED
AFASS
AIDS
ANC
APSCC
ART
ARVs
ASF
BCC
BFC
BFHI
BMS
CAR
C4D
CBO
CCM
CEE/CIS
CF
CHW
CMAM
Code
CSB
CSGD
CW
DALY
DHS
EBF
EFNEP
EID
ENA
ENN
EPI
FAO
FBFs
HFP
HIV
HMIS
HSS
HW
GAIN
GMP
GSIYCF
IATT
IBFAN
ICDC
IEC
IFA
IFE
vii
ILO
IMCI
IYCF
IYCN
KAP
LAM
LBW
LNS
LQAS
LSHTM
MAM
MBB
MICS
MDGs
M&E
MMR
MNs
MTCT
MTSP
MUAC
OR
ORS
OVC
NETI
PAHO
PLWH
PMTCT
PRSP
RED
QA
RUF
RUIF
SAM
SBA
SF
SIDS
SMART
SOWC
SQUEAC
SWAp
TBA
TIPS
UNFPA
UNICEF
U5MR
WFP
WHA
WHO
viii
1. BACKGROUND
1.1
Introduction
Optimal Infant and Young Child Feeding (IYCF) is presented in the WHO/UNICEF Global Strategy
for Infant and Young Child Feeding (2003) (Resources Annex 1-1) as follows:
As a global public health recommendation, infants should be exclusively breastfed
for the first six months of life to achieve optimal growth, development and health.
Thereafter, to meet their evolving nutritional needs, infants should receive safe and
nutritionally adequate complementary foods while breastfeeding continues for
up to two years of age or beyond. Exclusive breastfeeding from birth is possible
except for a few rare medical conditions as specified by WHO and UNICEF [2], and
virtually every mother can breastfeed.
In addition, a growing body of recent evidence underscores the important global recommendation that
1
breastfeeding be initiated within the first hour of birth.
IYCF actions are often implemented as part of the priority child survival and development programs of
UNICEF and WHO, as well as the plans of many nations. The scientific rationale for this decision is
clear, with several decades of scientific documentation on this topic including the several Lancet
Series on Child Survival 2003 [3], Nutrition 2008 [4], Newborn Health 2005 [5], Childhood
Development 2007 [6] reconfirming the essential role of infant and young child feeding as major factor
in child survival, growth and development.
Important new information is now available on what works to improve infant and young child feeding.
Results from efficacy and effectiveness trials have demonstrated the effects of community-based
approaches to improve breastfeeding and complementary feeding practices. New food technologies to
improve the diet of children 6-23 months of age have been developed and tested.
Policy and strategy documents produced by WHO and UNICEF over the last 25 years provide a sound
basis for action. This has resulted in the prioritization of IYCF in programmes in many countries,
leading to improvements in breastfeeding practices in those countries today compared to the late
1980s and early 1990s, as well as achievements in reducing stunting in countries that moved towards
more comprehensive approaches to IYCF. Despite the achievements, there is still significant room for
improvement in programming to improve infant and young child feeding practices. This includes both
increasing and sustaining good breastfeeding practices as well as interventions to improve
complementary feeding.
Why, then, the concern now? With competing priorities, disease-specific interventions, and an
interest in technologies, campaigns and products, the health and nutrition impact provided by good
infant and young child feeding is often underestimated. Interventions to improve infant and young child
feeding need increased attention and commitment if sustainable achievements in child survival, growth
and development are to be attained. Successful IYCF interventions rely on behaviour and social
change implemented at scale, which can only be reached through political commitment, adequate
resource allocation, capacity development and effective communication. Current investments in
nutrition in general and IYCF in particular, are very small given the magnitude of the problem and the
potential impact.
This document summarizes the current understanding of optimal infant and young child feeding and
presents the scientific rationale (see Resources Annex 1-1) and policy and strategy bases. The
recommendations for national strategies and actions are based on evidence of efficacy and
effectiveness, country experiences and lessons learned. The conclusion is clear: success in increasing
optimal infant and young child feeding practices is based on commitment for implementing
comprehensive, evidence based, at scale programming tailored to the local context.
The recommendation on early initiation was not mentioned in the GSIYCF, but is supported by evidence, is one of the Ten
Steps to Successful Breastfeeding and is one of the core indicators for infant and young child feeding (2008 edition)
1.2
13%
BF
7%
with
Complementary feeding
6%
Zinc
5%
Hib vaccine
4%
Clean delivery
4%
3%
Antenatal steroids
3%
Vitamin A
2%
Tetanus toxoid
2%
2%
2%
Measles vaccine
1%
1%
<1%
10
1
2
14
The 2008 Lancet Nutrition Series [4] also reinforced the significance of optimal IYCF on child survival.
Optimal IYCF, especially exclusive breastfeeding, was estimated to prevent potentially 1.4 million
deaths every year among children under five (out of the approximately 10 million annual deaths).
According to the Nutrition Series, over one third of under-five mortality is caused by undernutrition, in
which poor breastfeeding practices and inadequate complementary feeding play a major role. (See
Resources Annex 1-1 for a references and resources supporting the evidence for IYCFs impact on
reducing under-five mortality).
Growing evidence points to the impact of early initiation of breastfeeding on neonatal mortality. A
2006 study in rural Ghana [7] showed that early initiation within the first hours of birth could prevent
22% of neonatal deaths, and initiation within the first day, 16% of deaths, while a study in Nepal [8]
found that approximately 19.1% and 7.7% of all neo-natal deaths could be avoided with universal
initiation of breastfeeding within the first hour and first day of life respectively.
Breastfeeding, especially six months of exclusive breastfeeding, has a significant effect in the
reduction of mortality from the two biggest contributors to infant deaths: diarrhoea and pneumonia
(Figure 2), as well as on all-cause mortality [4].
Figure 2: Relative risk of not breastfeeding for infections and mortality compared to exclusive
breastfeeding from 0-5 months
15.13
16
14.4
14
12
Predominant
breastfeeding
10.53
10
Partial
breastfeeding
8
6
4.62
4
2.28
2
Exclusive
breastfeeding
2.49
1.75
Diarrhoea
mortality
Pneumonia
mortality
3.04
3.65
2.85
1 1.26
2.48 2.07
1.79
1.48
1
1
Diarrhoea
incidence
Pneumonia
incidence
Not
breastfeeding
0
All cause
mortality
In addition, evidence for the specific survival benefits of continued breastfeeding from 6 to 23
months points to continued protection against illness such as diarrhea and respiratory infection, with
similar levels observed for both [9].
1
Box 1 summarizes all the main evidence-based benefits for survival and health of the infant . The longterm benefits are summarized in a later section of the document.
A review of the benefits of breastfeeding is contained Quantifying the benefits of breastfeeding Leon-Cava et al 2002 (see
Resources Annex 1-1), although more recent studies are not included.
Z-scores (WHO)
0.25
-0.25
-0.5
-0.75
-1
-1.25
-1.5
-1.75
-2
Age (months)
Source: Victora et al, Pediatrics 2010: showing mean anthropometric Z-scores for weight for age, weight for length and height
for age for 54 low and middle income countries, 1994-2007, using WHO standards [9].
The declining trajectory of the curve is particularly steep for the stunting indicator (as indicated by low
height for age). At the same time, vulnerability to wasting (manifestation of acute malnutrition indicated
1
by low weight for height) also occurs during the same period . Acute malnutrition in children is usually
most prevalent among the age group 6-23 months, with 16% of cases occurring in infants less than 6
months old [55], which is consistent with the new analysis of growth patterns among children shown in
Figure 3. Also significant in its declining trajectory is the curve for underweight (as indicated by low
weight for age), which reflects both stunting and wasting, either separately or in combination.
Low birth weight and low height (length) at birth are some of the factors determining growth of the
child later on. Intra-uterine growth of a child is determined by the mothers health and nutritional status
before and during pregnancy. A womans poor nutrition status during pregnancy (especially low BMI
and anaemia [4]) are among the contributing factors to intrauterine growth restriction (IUGR), along
with pre-term delivery, as well as other maternal health complications [4]. Hence tackling the causes of
IUGR will go certain way to reducing young child undernutrition.
After birth, a childs ability to achieve the standards in growth is determined by the adequacy of
dietary intake (which depends on infant and young child feeding and care practices and food
security), as well as exposure to disease [56]. Undernutrition and infection are intertwined in a
synergistic vicious cycle. Therefore, support to quality child feeding practices (breastfeeding and
complementary feeding) and improvement of household food security, together with disease
prevention and control programmes, are the most effective interventions that can significantly reduce
stunting and acute malnutrition during the first two years of life.
During this period, vulnerability to oedematous malnutrition is also high, as measured by the presence of bilateral pitting
oedema. It is also called kwashiorkor, which means the deposed child.
This window of opportunity to prevent undernutrition is the same period when the recommended
infant and young child feeding practices are applied: exclusive breastfeeding for the first 6 months,
continued breastfeeding to 2 years or beyond together with adequate, safe, and appropriate
complementary feeding from 6 to 23 months. Therefore, sub-optimal breastfeeding and
complementary feeding practices put children in developing countries at high risk for undernutrition
and its associated outcomes which are far-reaching and difficult to reverse later in life. Many studies
have also shown that the greatest impact for interventions can be seen among children less than two
years of age [57]. Taking full advantage of this window of opportunity, optimal breastfeeding and
complementary feeding practices together can allow children to reach their full growth potential and
prevent irreversible stunting, as well as acute undernutrition.
Breastfeeding impacts growth in several ways, such as through reduction of morbidity due to
infections, stronger immunological response to disease due to transfer of maternal antibodies and
provision of the optimum balance of nutrients, growth factors, enzymes, hormones and other bioactive
factors. For example, reviews of evidence on the effects on child health and growth of exclusive
breastfeeding for six months have presented lower morbidity from gastrointestinal and allergic
diseases, which in turn can prevent growth faltering due to such illnesses [58].
Breastmilk alone is enough to meet all the nutritional needs of infants for the first six months of life.
After six months of age, to meet all of a childs nutritional requirements breastmilk needs to be
complemented by other foods, although it continues to be an important source of nutrients as well as
impacting disease morbidity and mortality [3]. At this age children have high nutritional needs for rapid
growth, and appropriate complementary feeding provides key nutrients (e.g. iron and other
micronutrients, essential fatty acids, protein, energy, etc.). Inadequate complementary feeding lacking
in quality and quantity can restrict growth and jeopardize child survival and development.
IYCF and child development
The period from birth to about 36 months is a critical period in early childhood development for
stimulating positive cognitive development, particularly in settings where ill health and undernutrition
are common [59]. Furthermore, a recent Lancet series on Child Development [60] recognized tackling
stunting and iron deficiency as two of the four most effective early childhood development
interventions, along with addressing iodine deficiency and cognitive stimulation (Figure 4). Thus, by
reducing stunting and iron deficiency, optimal infant and young child feeding can have a significant
effect on child development.
In addition, breastfeeding and responsive feeding provide constant positive interactions between
mother and child which can contribute to emotional and psychological development of infants. There is
also strong evidence of higher performance in intelligence tests among those subjects who had been
1
breastfed as infants [61].
Women who have breastfed are less likely to develop ovarian and premenopausal breast cancers [72], [73],
[74]. The increased risk of not breastfeeding is 39% for maternal breast cancer and 26% for ovarian cancer.
The more months a woman has spent breastfeeding, the greater the beneficial effect.
Breastfeeding reduces osteoporosis [75], [76].
Breastfeeding mothers enjoy a quicker recovery after childbirth, with quicker expelling of the placenta and
reduced risk of postpartum bleeding [77].
Breastfeeding helps decrease insulin requirements in diabetic mothers, and breastfeeding mothers have a
14% lower risk of maternal type 2 diabetes [78].
Mothers who breastfeed are more likely to return to their pre-pregnancy weight than mothers who formula
feed [79].
Exclusive breastfeeding for the first 6 months postpartum, in the absence of menses, is 98 per cent effective
in preventing pregnancy The delayed return of the menstrual cycle for 20 to 30 weeks may also reduce the
risk of anaemia [77].
Breastfeeding mothers are reported to be more confident, calm and less anxious than bottle-feeding mothers
[80]. Breastfeeding contributes to feelings of attachment between a mother and her child.
Economic benefits
Sub-optimum infant feeding is a determinant of stunting. At the same time, stunting is not only a
significant contributor to child mortality and development, but also to future productivity and
economic development. Prevention of stunting can prevent future productivity losses [81]. It has
1
been shown that body size at two years of age is clearly associated with future enhanced human
capital [82]. The importance of improving the quality of diets of children for future economic
development and productivity of a nation has been recognized to be as high as broader economic
policy approaches such as trade liberalization [83]. For example, improved complementary feeding
interventions can go as far as having a significant effect on adult wages one programme for example
had a 46% increase in average wages as adults (although only significant for men, probably due to
lack of womens engagement in paid jobs in the context of that study) [84].
The economic benefits of breastfeeding are also important to highlight. A lack of breastfeeding or poor
breastfeeding practices lead to high health care costs for the household and the health services due to
increased child morbidity, as well as the health care costs to deal with consequences of not
breastfeeding, including long term consequences related to obesity and chronic diseases. The much
higher mortality associated with not breastfeeding also represents a drain on countrys economies.
When infant illness due to lack of breastfeeding requires mothers to miss work, households, employers
and the economy are all affected. A lack of breastfeeding also impacts human capital development. In
addition, artificial feeding leads to additional expenditure and workload for households.
The following graphics are used to summarize the benefits of optimal infant feeding and the risks of
artificial feeding during training sessions on infant feeding counselling.
Figure 5: Benefits of breastfeeding an example from a training slide
Prevention of
stunting and acute
malnutrition
Prevention of
overweight/obesity
Improved
cognitive
development
1.3
Improved
productivity and
economic status
Over the past two decades significant progress has been achieved in IYCF policies, practices and
programmes. The following summary highlights these achievements as well as the areas in which little
progress has been made.
Global progress on breastfeeding
Key breastfeeding indicators which are important to monitor include early initiation of breastfeeding
(within the first hour), exclusive breastfeeding among children less than six months and continued
breastfeeding after six months (at 12-15 months and 20-23 months).
The global rate of early initiation of breastfeeding remains below 40 per cent (Figure 8).
Figure 8: Percentage of infants benefited from early initiation of breastfeeding
100
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
59
48
47
47
46
36
27
31
39
Between around 1996 and 2008, the rates of exclusive breastfeeding during the first six months of life
in 86 developing countries with available trend data have increased only slightly, from 33 to 38 per
10
cent (Figure 9). However, this trend data also shows that breastfeeding is increasing in two-thirds of
these nations.
Figure 9: Infants less than six months exclusively breastfed (%)
%
50
46
45
40
39
37
30
38
38
34
32
30
29
around
1995
42
41
33
around
2008
27
27
24
20
15
11
10
While global data indicate very slow progress in improving the overall exclusive breastfeeding
situation, countries that have shown strong commitment and invested heavily in IYCF show significant
progress (Figure 10). Since around 1996, exclusive breastfeeding rates increased more than 20
percentage points on average in these 20 countries, with several countries exhibiting remarkable
increases of almost 60 percentage points. These countries have demonstrated unequivocally that it is
possible to change infant feeding practices. This is an important advocacy point, particularly to counter
the common perception that feeding practices are cultural and cannot be modified.
Figure 10: 20 countries with increases in exclusive breastfeeding > 20 percentage points
100
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
baseline
76
61
32
23
34
37
38
39
40
47
48
48
11
16
6
52
10
11
11
most
recent
data
33
16
10
70
54
31
26
12
33
43
63
66
19
7
12
17
Source: UNICEF database 2011. The baseline is considered to be between 1993-2000, except for East Timor, where the
baseline is 2003 and Peru, where it is 1992.
Factors for success include the large-scale implementation of comprehensive programmes to promote,
support and protect breastfeeding with strong government leadership and broad partnerships. Such
programmes involve action at national level, including national policies, strategies and plans to
implement the main operational targets of the WHO/UNICEF Global Strategy for Infant and Young
11
Some encouraging facts are the percentages of children still breastfeeding at 12-15 months in
developing countries (73 per cent) and at 20-23 months (56 per cent). This rises to 90 per cent and 68
3
per cent respectively in least developed countries , where infants and young children face the greatest
threats to survival.
On the other hand, it is important to highlight the missed opportunities along the continuum of care
(Figure 11), where it can be observed that provided health care did not necessarily support relevant
feeding practices: while the coverage of ante-natal care in developing countries is 79 per cent and the
coverage of deliveries assisted by a skilled attendant is 64 per cent, a dramatic difference is seen in
terms of early initiation of breastfeeding, where coverage is only 44 per cent. Similarly, while the
coverage with three doses of DPT immunization, which is usually attained around 3-5 months, is 81
per cent, exclusive breastfeeding among children less than six months is only 36 per cent.
Figure 11: Missed opportunities along the continuum of care
100
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
81
79
64
44
36
Ante natal care with Skilled attendant at Early initiation of BF DPT 3 coverage %
skilled professional
delivery %
%
%
Pregnancy
Birth
Exclusive BF %
85
for
As of April 2011, 84 countries have enacted legislation implementing all or many of the provisions of the Code and subsequent
relevant World Health Assembly resolutions, 19 countries have incorporated at least some of the provisions of the Code into
their national legal systems, and 14 countries have draft laws awaiting adoption.
2
In 2010, over 21,000 maternity facilities worldwide had been designated baby-friendly (M.Labbok/WABA) however this data is
incomplete and not updated for all countries.
3
UNICEF database 2010.
12
global assessment and trend analysis of the 10 guiding principles of complementary feeding [86] have
only recently been finalized by WHO, UNICEF and counterparts, and need to be operationalized by
countries. However, available data on the global situation of complementary feeding [87] provide some
insight to the extent of the problem. According to the State of the Worlds Children 2010, only 58 per
cent of breastfed children between the ages of six and nine months in developing countries had
received any complementary foods in the past 24 hours.
Following the release of the new indicators, several countries have started reporting on a full set of
indicators on complementary feeding, including the new indicator: dietary diversity and the composite
indicator minimum acceptable diet (see Chapter 2.2 more explanation on the indicators). Recent
country surveys show that complementary feeding practices are far from acceptable (Figure 12). While
timely introduction of complementary foods (at 6-8 months) is a common practice in many countries,
the quality of the diet is poor. In India, country with the highest number of stunted children, only 54.5
1
per cent of children between the ages of six and eight months had received any complementary foods
in the previous day, and only 7 per cent of breastfed children between ages of 6-23 months met the
minimum acceptable diet criteria. In Nigeria, a country with the third highest burden of stunting, only
21 per cent of breastfed children receive the minimum acceptable complementary feeding diet.
Similarly, Ethiopias 2005 Demographic and Health Survey (DHS) data show that only 2.9 per cent of
children 6-23 months of age have a minimum acceptable diet. These outcomes strongly support the
need for improvement on complementary feeding practices.
Figure 12: Status of complementary feeding in selected countries with data on minimum
acceptable diet (breastfed children 6-23 m), & introduction of complementary foods (6-8m old,
BF & non BF children)
100.0
90.0
81.4
80.0
70.0
69.3
46.0
50.0
40.0
61.6 60.5
54.5
60.0
36.1
30.0
43.4
37.8
33.6
29.9
21.7 22.9
29.5
21.6
20.6
20.0
10.0
6.0
3.6
2.9
7.1
6.7
9.3
3.1
0.0
Source: DHS, most recent survey for each country, from 2002-2008
In addition to the data on feeding practices, analysis of trends in stunting can further inform us about
the quality of feeding practices in infants and young children. In the developing world, stunting rates
have declined slowly, from 40 per cent to 29 per cent between 1990 and 2008, but in some regions
and countries there has not been significant progress. Figure 13 shows that despite progress in some
regions (e.g. CEE/CIS, East Asia and Pacific), the statistics are alarming. Sub-Saharan Africa has
made almost no progress in the 10 year period between 1996 and 2008, and the progress has been
slow in some other regions. Vital opportunities to save millions of lives are being lost, and many more
children are not growing and thriving the way they should.
In 2009, 195 million children under five years of age in developing countries were estimated to be
stunted. Most of these children live in just 24 high-burden countries. On the other hand, 129 million
children are underweight and an estimated 26 million are severely wasted [88].
1
The new indicator for introduction of complementary foods includes the age group of 6-8 months and breastfed and nonbreastfed children, as compared to the old indicator which included 6-9 months and only breastfed children,
13
Figure 13: Percentage of stunted children under the age of 5 yrs, by region
100
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
circa
1990
54
42
47
39
3734
40
29
35
2423
15
22
14
circa
2008
20
12
1.4
Global IYCF targets, as well as policies and strategies have informed the emphasis that is accorded to
IYCF in UNICEFs and other development partner strategies and programs. These include:
1990 Innocenti Declaration on the Protection, Promotion and Support of Breastfeeding [89].
1990 Convention on the Rights of the Child [90] (Article 24) which states that governments
must combat disease and malnutrition, through, inter alia, the provision of adequate nutritious
foods and ensure that all sectors of society are informed, have access to education and are
supported in the use of basic knowledge of child health and nutrition, including the advantages of
breastfeeding :
CRC Article 24 (e):
To ensure that all segments of society, in particular parents and children,
are informed, have access to education and are supported in the use of
basic knowledge of child health and nutrition, the advantages of breastfeeding,
hygiene and environmental sanitation and the prevention of accidents;
2000 Millennium Declaration [91] establishing health and development goals and targets
(Millennium Development Goals) for 2015.
2002 World Fit for Children [92] which clearly states to reduce child under-nutrition among
children less than five years of age by at least one third, with special attention to children under
two years of age and to protect, promote and support exclusive breastfeeding for six months and
continued breastfeeding with safe, appropriate and adequate complementary feeding up to two
years of age and beyond.
WHO/UNICEF Global Strategy for Infant and Young Child Feeding (2003), adopted by
UNICEFs Executive Board and the World Health Assembly [1].
2005 Innocenti Declaration on Infant and Young Child Feeding [93] which celebrates the 15
Anniversary of the 1990 Declaration [94], commits urgent actions, and sets concrete targets.
th
14
1.5
Scientific evidence has been gathered on the effectiveness of a number of interventions to improve
breastfeeding and complementary feeding practices. These include:
Interventions to improve breastfeeding practices and to promote breastfeeding:
Maternity care practices: Institutional changes in maternity care practices have been shown to
effectively increase breastfeeding initiation and duration rates [95,96,97].
Lay and peer support: Lay counselors shown to be most effective in increasing the initiation and
duration of exclusive breastfeeding [99].
Media and social marketing: Media campaigns have been shown to improve attitudes towards
breastfeeding and increase initiation rates [101]. Social marketing has been established as an
effective behavioural change model for a wide variety of public health issues, including
breastfeeding [102].
Support for breastfeeding in the workplace: Evidence from industrialized countries has shown
how workplace support programmes increase the duration of breastfeeding [103].
Nutrition education improves caregiver practices through the following strategies [105,106]:
Provision of information about local foods, industrially-processed complementary foods, and inhome fortification of foods to caregivers.
Promotion of appropriate feeding behaviours (see Guiding Principles for Complementary
Feeding of the Breastfed Child (PAHO/WHO 2003) (Resources Annex 1-2).
Use of multiple channels to educate and counsel caregivers (from communication through mass
media to individual counselling).
15
Special support to food insecure populations improves diets of young children [114]
through:
Social schemes, economic models to ensure access to complementary foods.
Distribution of micronutrients and other micronutrient-rich products.
1
Distribution of fortified complementary foods to families in need .
Social protection schemes which link provision of counselling and education with in-kind
supplements or vouchers for specific products. These schemes have been implemented in a
number of Latin American countries, mostly with positive outcomes in terms of reducing rates of
stunting [115], [116].
Aid can be targeted to children with poor nutritional status, to the poorest families in a community, or to all families within the
poorest communities
16
National level strategic planning includes the process of situation analysis, development of policies,
systems, strategies and plans and their monitoring, review and evaluation, with relevant oversight and
coordination. Figure 14 depicts the strategic planning process in a graphic manner:
Figure 14: Core processes in development, planning and implementation of a comprehensive
approach to improving IYCF
IMPLEMENATION and
MONITORING;
REVIEW and EVALUATION
PLANNING,
mobilization of
resources
Additional
Opportunities for
INTEGRATION
IYCF strategic
planning and
implementation
IYCF STRATEGY
ADVOCACY,
COORDINATION,
PARTNERSHIP
SITUATION
ANALYSIS
POLICY
Countries have different starting points and are at different stages in the evolution of their IYCF
programmes. For example, much of the required information for the situation analysis may already
exist, a policy may be in place or a strategy has been developed, and these existing documents may
merely need to be reviewed and updated and gaps filled. On the other hand, a country should not wait
until the updated policy is endorsed or all the research is completed before initiating development of
action plans.
Thus these processes are not necessarily followed in a rigid and sequential step-wise manner
in all contexts; this will depend on the results of the situation assessment, whether comprehensive
policies, strategies and plans exist, the maturity of programmes, the experiences and results of
implementation, etc.
17
Planning the advocacy component: Planning for advocacy needs to consider which objectives
are targeted, who the audience will be and which approaches and methods will be most
appropriate to apply. The advocacy should address major bottlenecks or required shifts in existing
policies and programme components as well as the introduction of new components.
Choosing advocacy targets or spokespersons: a review of key stakeholders who have a role to
play in the IYCF programme and who might be influenced by advocacy - e.g. health, social welfare
and agriculture systems to develop and implement respective components of the IYCF strategy,
the Attorney Generals office to review and change laws and regulations on the marketing of
breastmilk substitutes and maternity protection, legislators of labour policies and practices and
employers to ensure mother-baby friendly workplaces, training department and medical/nursing
school officials to incorporate or update the IYCF curriculum, local hospital administrators to
implement the Ten Steps, local government officials for resource allocation, etc. Other
stakeholders may also be chosen to become spokespersons and deliver advocacy messages.
For example, the recent Lancet series on maternal and child undernutrition (January 2008), Lancet series on child
development (January 2007)
18
complementary feeding, the latter having generally received much less attention. The evidence,
including the most recent Lancet series on child survival, nutrition, and others (see chapter 1), are
a rich source of advocacy materials. The science on the potential impact of IYCF interventions
needs to be complemented by evidence on what works to achieve this impact i.e. intervention
research such as the studies referenced in section 1.5, as well as lessons learned from
programme reviews and evaluations.
Dissemination of key IYCF policy and technical documents (e.g. amongst others, the national
IYCF policy, Global Strategy for Infant and Young Child Feeding (2003), Guiding Principles
for Complementary Feeding of the Breastfed Child (2003), Guidelines on HIV and Infant
Feeding (2010), Operational Guidance on Infant Feeding in Emergencies (2007), as well as
the principle scientific references which provide the evidence base for IYCF impact and
interventions) among the appropriate government representatives, international organizations,
NGOs, and other potential in-country partners (i.e. private industry, civic groups etc.) working in
the health and nutrition sector and other related sectors (e.g. agriculture, social protection).
Strategic partnerships should be pursued between not only within different sectors of national
governments, but also with UN agencies, national and international non-government organizations
(NGOs), donors and private sector partners taking into account their different mandates and agendas.
Their common aim would be to increase synergy to protect, promote and support IYCF as an essential
contributor to young child survival, growth, and development goals. The advocacy plan should include
reaching all relevant partners to gain the commitment for IYCF and ensure it receives greater
attention.
2.1.2 Coordination
It is important that IYCF is effectively managed and coordinated and is featured prominently on the
agenda of the Government and partners at all levels. A country may decide to have a dedicated
national coordination forum for IYCF, or include IYCF in the broader nutrition coordination mechanism.
Whether IYCF is coordinated through a dedicated body, a sub-group of health or nutrition coordination
mechanism or as a major area of work within a single health or nutrition coordinating body, the
national coordination structure plays a triple role to: 1) strategize and plan, 2) oversee implementation,
and 3) monitor and evaluate. It has the authority and responsibility to ensure achievement of stated
IYCF goals, by setting targets for the key IYCF outcomes based on international standards but tailored
to the local situation. The national coordinating structure also maximizes synergies between partners
to avoid duplication of services, ensure harmonized messages, curricula and materials, gains buy-in
and commitments from all key stakeholders to the objectives of the IYCF action plan, ensures
maximum coverage among partners and programmes, and supports and encourages cooperation and
collaboration.
Specifically, the national coordination structure will:
Ensure that the national IYCF policy, programme/strategy and plan of actions are developed,
19
agreed upon and disseminated to all relevant stakeholders and that there is wide adoption and
application of the strategy.
Oversee legislation to protect optimal infant feeding, such as the on the marketing of breastmilk
substitutes and maternity protection
Oversee standards for health worker education and training, such as infant feeding curricula for in
service and pre-service training
Ensure that actions to improve breastfeeding practices in maternity facilities, including the BFHI,
are fully institutionalized within the national health system, including in private hospitals, and will
advocate for the implementation and monitoring of the Ten Steps to Successful Breastfeeding to
become a mandatory part of the standard operating and supervision procedures for hospitals and
integral to the accreditation of facilities, including private ones.
Provide oversight and coordination of community-based IYCF activities, to ensure high coverage,
a harmonized approach and effective monitoring
Ensure the integration of relevant IYCF actions such as IYCF counselling and support and training
into related health (e.g. maternal and newborn care, PMTCT, CCM, C-IMCI, CMAM) or social
programmes (e.g. Early Child Development, cash transfer or other social protection schemes, food
security programmes, etc.)
Ensure effective routine monitoring of IYCF activities at all levels, analysis of programmatic data
on breastfeeding and complementary feeding and appropriate evaluation activities.
Within the national body, there will be a need for smaller sub-groups to work on specific issues, for
example for a communication sub-group and a complementary feeding sub-group. Both of these areas
will require the participation of technical specialists in the respective fields and may involve
participation from several other sectors.
The national body will develop a multi-year plan of action and will meet regularly to assess progress
against each goal, as well as to assess progress on agreed objectives. To perform its functions, the
national body should be an integral part of the government system, with funding provided and mandate
approved by the national government. The national body should be independent and free from
commercial influence of commercial enterprises or industry NGOs and foundations, as there is a
potential conflict of interest.
It is also important to assure effective coordination at sub-national level, especially in large countries.
Appropriate existing nutrition/health coordination fora at sub-national level need to be identified to
reflect IYCF prominently on their agendas, or a dedicated IYCF coordination forum could be
established.
To adopt a comprehensive approach to IYCF, the group may need to be broadened from the
traditional partners supporting breastfeeding programmes. The Government can work through the
health and social protection systems promoting use of high-quality complementary foods, advocating
appropriate feeding practices, and providing aid to families in need, while international organizations
and NGOs can help fill in the gaps left by government services. At the same time, private industry will
be particularly important in bringing high-quality inexpensive fortified complementary foods and food
supplement products to the market.
20
Introduction
Different stages of IYCF programming may be found in different countries, with some already having a
comprehensive policy basis and programme and others with minimal progress. A policy and strategy
basis for breastfeeding and actions at various levels is already underway in many cases, but very few
countries have conducted a comprehensive situation assessment of complementary feeding or have
relevant policies and strategies. In some cases formative research is needed. Further, there may be
detailed information available on health service activities, but limited information on community-based
activities or barriers to IYCF, and on the communication environment at different levels. Therefore, it is
important to complete a situation assessment tailored to the local context and fill in the country-specific
information gaps.
The situation assessment should include primary IYCF data (feeding practice indicators) and the
implementation status of IYCF programmes with relevant outcomes, as well as document successful
interventions and failures, to ensure that all lessons learned are taken into consideration for the
development of new strategies and action plans. It should include participatory assessments with
communities if possible (see Section 2.3 Community-based IYCF actions) and formative research on
knowledge, attitudes and practices.
The situation assessment should also take account of gender issues. Addressing gender inequalities
should make nutrition programmes more effective overall and thus improve the nutrition prospects for
both girls and boys. (See also Operational Guidance (Resources Annex 1-1) on gender analysis and
programming with specific details on infant and young child feeding issues). Globally, there are no
gender differences in stunting and underweight rates and no differences in breastfeeding rates [117].
However, in some areas there are gender differences in stunting rates [118,119]. Various barriers to
optimal infant and young child feeding may also have gender dimensions that need to be analyzed and
addressed. For example, the low social status of women is considered to be one of the primary
determinants of undernutrition across the life cycle [120]. In addition, an analysis of survey data from
17 developing countries confirms a positive association between maternal education and nutritional
status in children 323 months old, although a large part of these associations is the result of
educations strong link to household economics [121]. These aspects need to be included in the
situation assessment for a comprehensive picture.
Completing the Assessment Matrix (Resources Annex 1-1) will provide a comprehensive overview
of the scope and scale of IYCF programming and implementation status in the country. The most
useful outcome of this exercise is to identify gaps in information, policies and programmes to inform
further development of the IYCF strategy and national plan. It will also assist in summarizing major
activities that have already taken place in the country and planning their scale-up, as well as enable
leveraging of resources for those districts that have been poorly supported. The matrix can also be
used for periodic updates of progress.
The assessment matrix was developed by UNICEF/HQ in 2008-2009 to obtain a comprehensive picture of the scope and scale
of IYCF programmes. Some 65 countries have completed it as of May 2011.
21
It should be noted that the full set of these indicators should be taken into account for programmatic
purpose. Looking at one without the others can provide an incomplete and at times misleading picture.
For example, in a country one may see a very high rate of timely introduction and adequate frequency
of feeding, but diversity of foods is quite limited (children are receiving monotonous, mainly staple with
low content of vitamins, minerals, and other important nutrients).
Breastfeeding
1. Early initiation of breastfeeding: Proportion of children born in the last 24 months who were
put to the breast within one hour of birth.
This indicator was not a core indicator in the previous set IYCF core indicators (1991) [122]. Its
importance is emphasized by including it in the set of core indicators, especially given the recent
evidence regarding its impact on neo-natal mortality. This indicator is based on historic recall for all
children (living and deceased) born in the previous 24 months.
Part I of the IYCF Indicators series gives the definitions of the indicators, while Part II Provides tools for collection and
calculation of the indicators, primarily for use by large-scale surveys. It covers topics specific to data collection such as: a) An
example questionnaire; b) Example interviewer instructions; c) Suggestions for adapting the questionnaire to the survey context;
d) Instructions for calculating indicator values
2
The core IYCF indicators, with the exception of early initiation of breastfeeding, are based on feeding recall of the previous day
for children in the specified age group.
22
2. Exclusive breastfeeding: Proportion of infants aged 0-5 months who are fed exclusively
with breastmilk.
It is reiterated that the exclusive breastfeeding (EBF) indicator is a current status indicator derived
from 24-hour recall of how the child was fed. The data collected represents a cross-section of children
in the age-range 0-5 months. It does not represent the proportion of infants who are exclusively
breastfed throughout the period from birth to just under 6 months, nor does it represent the proportion
of infants aged exactly 6 months who were exclusively breastfed during the previous day. The criteria
for the indicator allow for the child to receive ORS, which was not the case in previous definitions.
In developing the revised set of indicators, it was agreed globally that the current status indicator
represents the best option for capturing EBF. Recall based on any other period or other questions is
not valid and cannot be included as a data point in survey reports. However, some national surveys
still ask about EBF in a non-standard way, which invalidates the results. Non-standard questions about
exclusive breastfeeding in surveys include for example:
3. Continued breastfeeding: proportion of infants aged 12-15 months who are fed breastmilk.
The importance of this indicator is emphasized by its inclusion in the list of core indicators, and is
linked to evidence on the impact of continued breastfeeding at least to one year, for example in the
Lancet Child Survival series. Previously, continued breastfeeding was commonly reflected using the
optional indicator continued breastfeeding at 2 years.
Complementary feeding
In the previous version of the IYCF Indicators (WHO 1991) [123], there was only one indicator
reflecting complementary feeding timely complementary feeding (proportion of children aged 6-9
months who received breastmilk and complementary foods). This indicator provided information about
whether complementary foods were consumed during the past 24 hours in the 6-9 months age group,
and covered only breastfed children. The wide age range and lack of information on non-breastfed
children made the applications of this indicator quite limited. In addition, lack of information on other
important aspects of feeding such as the quality of the diet as dietary diversity created a major
programmatic obstacle.
In the 2008 new set of IYCF Indicators, the indicator has been revised to reflect the age range of 6-8
months and to include both breastfed and non-breastfed children, to be better reflective of the overall
situation of introduction of complementary foods in a population:
4. Introduction of complementary foods: proportion of infants aged 6-8 months who receive
solid, semi-solid or soft foods.
In addition, three new globally agreed indicators for complementary feeding are now available. These
indicators better reflect the quality and quantity of food given to children aged 6-23 months, and
include the following indicators:
5. Minimum dietary diversity: Proportion of children 6-23 months of age who receive foods
from 4 or more food groups*.
*The 7 food groups include the following:
1. Grains, roots and tubers
2. Legumes and nuts
3. Dairy products (milk, yoghurt, cheese)
4. Flesh foods (meat, fish, poultry, and liver/organ meats)
5. Eggs
6. Vitamin A rich fruits and vegetables
7. Other fruits and vegetables
23
The 7 food groups have been identified based on research showing the critical importance of each in
the complementary feeding diet, and they may be different from the food groups historically used in
countries or in surveys. For example, eggs count as a separate food group rather than being
categorized together with the other animal-source foods.
The information for the diversity indicator is collected using a 17-item question (see Measurement
Guide, p. 9) [123], which is then combined into the 7 main food groups.
The new set of adopted indicators contains a new composite indicator on measuring the quality and
quantity of complementary feeding, called the minimum acceptable diet. This indicator is a
composite based on the indicators on minimum meal frequency and minimum dietary diversity
(below).
6. Minimum meal frequency : Proportion of breastfed and non-breastfed children 6-23
months of age who receive solid, semi-solid, or soft foods (but also including milk feeds for
non-breastfed children) the minimum number of times or more: 2 for 6-8 mo., 3 for 9-23 mo., 4
for 6-23 mo. (if not BF).
Previously, household surveys such as the DHS and MICS measured complementary feeding
frequency, but limited to breastfed children aged 6-23 months. The new indicator allows measuring it
for all children, and assessing the frequency based on recommended levels at different age groups.
7. The new minimum acceptable diet: Proportion of children 6-23 months of age who had
both minimum meal frequency and dietary diversity (in both BF and non-BF children).
This is a composite indicator which reflects both quality of diet and frequency of complementary
feeding. While information on feeding frequency and diversity was already being collected through
certain household surveys such as the DHS, these indicators have not been reported universally as a
standard set of indicators. The DHS collected food group information that reflected different food
grouping that are not fully compatible with the 7 food groups listed above and would need to be reanalyzed. In addition, feeding frequency data both from DHS and MICS was also only collected from
breastfed children. Therefore any re-analysis of DHS data to obtain the minimum acceptable diet can
only reflect the indicator for breastfed children (as for the data shown in Figure 12 above). Other
surveys such as MICS do not currently have the full set of indicators due to difficulty in ensuring the
quality of dietary data. Therefore, it is very important to explore opportunities such as national
nutrition surveys or even specific surveys with focus on IYCF for inclusion of the full set of
indicators.
8. Consumption of iron-rich or iron-fortified foods: Proportion of children 6-23 months of
age who receive an iron-rich food or iron-fortified food that is especially designed for infants
and young children or that is fortified in the home.
This indicator can provide information on use of multiple micronutrient powders or lipid-based nutrient
supplements, commercially fortified complementary foods or similar iron-fortified products. However,
guidance on how to operationalize the data collection is difficult to standardize and significant incountry adaptation is needed to ensure that local names for foods and products are used and that they
contain an adequate or appropriate amount of iron.
The document Introduction to Interpreting Infant and Young Child Feeding Area Graphs issued by UNICEF provides details
on interpreting the area graphs. Area graphs for many countries are also available and updated periodically at: ChildInfo
website
24
provide additional insights for monitoring progress. The example below shows how the country has
progressed from almost no exclusive breastfeeding to a much better status (54% EBF).
Figure 16: Area graphs for Ghana, 1988 and 2003
Quantitative data on IYCF practices: Primary data includes at least an information on core
indicators of IYCF t(he rates of initiation of breastfeeding, exclusive breastfeeding among children
less than six months, and continued breastfeeding among children aged 12-15 months, data on
complementary feeding (timely introduction, frequency, and diversity). Primary data collection
should be undertaken by using standard survey methodology (e.g. MICS or DHS) or tools such as
ProPAN (see Resources Annex 1-3), to feed into the situation analysis. In the case of subnational programmes, focus should at a minimum be on districts where the programme is being
planned
Qualitative data on behaviours and practices, barriers, social norms etc. It is also necessary
to gather information on traditional practices related to IYCF as well as other data that will input
into the design of the communication strategy and feed into the local adaptation of counselling
tools (see Resources Annex 1-9 for more information on communication development strategy
and tools). This data can be collected through various approaches including formative research
and KAP studies to have full information about socio-cultural norms, factors influencing particular
behaviours, as well as knowledge level, attitudes, practices, and beliefs.
Secondary data relevant to IYCF may include household expenditure surveys, living standards
measurement surveys (LSMS), market assessments, food and crop assessments, food security
surveys, vulnerability assessments.
National IYCF policies and targets: this part of the assessment focuses on the key actions and
1
targets identified in the Innocenti Declarations and Global Strategy for IYCF .
The WHO-Linkages 2003 manual entitled Infant and Young Child Feeding: A Tool for assessing national practices, policies
and programmes is a useful tool for conducting an assessment of national level documents
25
26
Once all data has been collected or compiled, it should be analysed and the implications determined in
terms of type or design of interventions that may be required.
In this document, the terms policy, strategy, programme and intervention have been used with distinct and specific
definitions. See the various boxes for definitions of these terms as they have been used in this document. See also Glossary for
definitions of policies and strategies, and norms.
27
policy, strategy and planning documents and monitoring and evaluation frameworks should have IYCF
sufficiently on the agenda.
Development of standard
minimum packages of services
Financing/budgets
Health management
information systems
28
The community worker needs to have official recognition by Government authorities as well as by
the community; the workers authority to provide services and products, to refer patients and to
give advice needs to be endorsed and supported by Government policies.
The community programme needs to be well-linked to the health system and consistent with its
policies.
The policy should indicate the need to develop capacity for and implement IYCF counselling and
support services at community level, as well as IYCF promotion (BCC).
The counselling, training, communication, tools provided for the community workers need to be
consistent with those provided to health workers.
The community worker needs to receive appropriate incentives or remuneration on a regular basis.
A system for regular monitoring and supportive supervision needs to be established and
implementation assured (see section on Capacity development for community IYCF counselling
for more details).
29
Introduction
Developing a comprehensive IYCF strategy is a key in achieving the objectives and goals for IYCF in a
country. The development of a national strategy on IYCF will help unify, focus, and guide all in1
country interventions and programmes related to breastfeeding and complementary feeding by the
government, NGOs and other partners
Box 5: Definitions of terms used in this guidance: IYCF
in the health, nutrition, social
strategy and interventions
protection and other sectors. It should
be fully integrated within established
An IYCF strategy involves high-level national strategic thinking
Government systems and implethat defines why the issue of IYCF is being addressed, what the
overarching goal and specific objectives are, what key principles
mentation platforms and Government
will be observed, what should be done to achieve the objectives
and donor budgets.
In many countries the development of
annual plans is decentralized to lower
levels of Government structures, for
example regions, provinces and
states. Therefore, it is essential that
the national IYCF strategy is
disseminated to these lower levels and
there is a process of national-level
review of the local plans.
A comprehensive IYCF strategy needs
to include context-specific package of
interventions and actions (see Box 5)
at different levels that need to be
implemented together. It comprises
action at three main levels including:
In this document, the terms policy, strategy, programme and intervention have been used with distinct and specific
definitions. See the various boxes for definitions of these terms as they have been used in this document.
30
interventions focusing on child nutrition and homestead gardening and small animal husbandry (see
Chapter 2.4.3. More large-scale experience and evidence needs to be gathered/generated before
programming recommendations and detailed guidance can be provided.
The national IYCF strategy in a country should address all key components and interventions that
are relevant to the country and sub-national situation (See Chapter 2.4,4 on prioritizing
interventions) and include both breastfeeding and complementary feeding. Overall, optimal
breastfeeding practices have been more clearly defined and are supported in many countries through
integration of breastfeeding strategies into national health policy and action plans. At the same time, in
many cases the package of breastfeeding interventions has not been sufficiently comprehensive for
example, focusing only on the BFHI and Code with no interventions at PHC or community level and no
communication strategy, or only covering communication but with no action at health system or
community level. On the other hand, integration of strategies to improve complementary feeding has
not generally occurred, even though it is also crucial to the survival, growth and development of
children.
The national IYCF strategy will include the most appropriate components based on assessment of the
situation, the policy framework and the prioritization exercise for the interventions. The purpose of the
national strategy is to define how and by whom the interventions and the activities under each main
component will be delivered. In cases of an existing IYCF strategy, a review of the existing
components should be undertaken to assess their appropriateness and determine which necessary
components are missing or which are inadequate in terms of scope, implementation approach and
scale.
1
Background and rationale, including summary of the most recent situation analysis
Goals, objectives and targets.
Summary of policy statements on recommended infant and young child feeding practices,
legislative aspects and main components of national programme strategy.
Principle areas of intervention & opportunities for integration.
Implementation: summary of actions; actors in different sectors; vision for achieving scale.
Monitoring, review and evaluation.
Resource implications.
31
Model projects to assess feasibility, efficacy and effectiveness of new interventions or innovative ways
of implementing interventions may be conducted before replicating different models to a large scale,
but the focus of the national strategy should be on implementation of proven interventions at scale as
there is sufficient evidence of the impact of the main, proven interventions without a lengthy process of
modelling.
32
China
India
The International Code of Marketing of Breastmilk Substitutes was adopted by the World Health
Assembly in 1981 to address this problem. The Code recommends that Governments enact legislation
that will prohibit the advertising and all other forms of promotion of breastmilk substitutes, feeding
bottles and teats. The World Health Assembly regularly revisits the issue of IYCF and has adopted
subsequent resolutions intended to address ambiguities in the Code and deal with new and innovative
ways in which companies market products to circumvent the Code. In this document, all references to
the Code include the subsequent WHA Resolutions.
The most recent document was adopted in May 2010, when the sixty-third World Health Assembly
again called on Member States to implement the International Code of Marketing of Breastmilk
Substitutes and all Subsequent World Health Assembly Resolutions (The Code). In doing so, the WHA
made the following observations:
Euromonitor. Global Packaged Food: Market Opportunities for Baby Food to 2013. 2009. Euromonitor is an industry
intelligence agency.
33
Recognizing that the promotion of breast-milk substitutes and some commercial foods for infants
and young children undermines progress in optimal infant and young child feeding;
Expressing deep concern over persistent reports of violations of the International Code of
Marketing of Breast-milk Substitutes by some infant food manufacturers and distributors with
regard to promotion targeting mothers and health-care workers;
Expressing further concern over reports of the ineffectiveness of measures, particularly voluntary
measures, to ensure compliance with the International Code of Marketing of Breast-milk
Substitutes in some countries;
then called on governments:
(2) to strengthen and expedite the sustainable implementation of the global strategy for infant and
young child feeding including emphasis on giving effect to the aim and principles of the
International Code of Marketing of Breast-milk Substitutes ..;
(3) to develop and/or strengthen legislative, regulatory and/or other effective measures to control
the marketing of breastmilk substitutes in order to give effect to the International Code of
Marketing of Breastmilk Substitutes and relevant resolution adopted by the World Health
Assembly
34
Protection Recommendation, 2000 No. 191. Maternity leave, day-care facilities and paid breastfeeding
breaks should be available for all women employed outside the home.
Albania, Austria, Belarus, Belize, Bulgaria, Cuba, Cyprus, Hungary, Italy, Latvia, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Mali, Republic of
Moldova, the Netherlands, Romania and Slovakia
35
is significantly jeopardised. In many instances a strong advocacy is needed to convince this group of
professionals on the importance of IYCF and the actions needed.
A key component of the strategy therefore is the capacity development of health staff. Whether for inservice training or pre-service education, the need to build up teams of experienced trainers is
critical. There are excellent examples of countries that have been able to implement breastfeeding
counselling training nationwide by systematically building the capacity of district managers and senior
clinicians to plan for and conduct in-service training. The same success needs to be replicated for
more integrated infant and young child nutrition training at scale which would include both
breastfeeding and complementary feeding. It is also critical to ensure that the training of health
providers is not the first and last step in the process of capacity building. Training sessions on their
own do not produce capacity and sustained implementation of services and achievement of results.
The appropriate systems and structures to implement the IYCF counselling services need to be
developed, and supervision and performance monitoring mechanisms need to be in place to ensure
sustained implementation. This is especially important in contexts where human resources are
constrained or health systems are weak. For development or updating of pre-service and inservice curricula to ensure they adequately address IYCF the WHO Model Chapter on IYCF can be
used as the standard.
Improving infant feeding practices in maternity facilities through applying the Ten Steps to
Successful Breastfeeding in all facilities should be an important part of the national strategy. The IYCF
strategy needs to set out the vision for fully integrating the principles of the Ten Steps to Successful
Breastfeeding within the standard operating procedures for maternity services, including required
capacities and training of staff and monitoring systems. All IYCF interventions in the health system
must be properly institutionalized within the national health system in order to ensure continuity and
sustainability. Implementation of parallel, vertical project-type IYCF activities should be avoided.
It is also important to implement IYCF actions in the health system beyond maternity services:
especially at the primary health care level. Even in countries where institutional delivery coverage is
high, continued IYCF counselling and support is needed after discharge which is not feasible to
organize by the maternities. This support is best delivered at multiple maternal and child health
contacts with the primary health care system to maximize the opportunities to deliver age-appropriate
advice by capable staff. The task of conducting IYCF counselling should be integrated into the
standard tasks and job descriptions of MCH staff, as well as in the performance monitoring systems
and within the child and maternal health cards. The IYCF support and counselling by the primary
health care services should be complemented by community-based activities where no health provider
exists.
HIV and infant feeding recommendations, based on the latest (2010) guidelines, need to be fully
integrated within all the IYCF guidelines, materials, training sessions and counselling contacts in the
health services. (Specific HIV and infant feeding issues in the health services are addressed in the
separate HIV and infant feeding chapter in this guidance document.)
The monitoring of IYCF services in the health system also needs to be carefully designed to
ensure it captures relevant information on priority indicators, including counselling sessions held with
each caregiver and reported feeding practices. Tools can include simple tally sheets summarized onto
graphs or charts at the health facility and aggregated for reporting at each subsequent level of the
health system. Other tools for monitoring are the child and maternal health cards, which can be
modified to reflect counselling contacts and reported feeding practices; these cards can also record
problems with feeding. Health professionals, particularly those at the primary health care services
level, also have a role in supervising community cadres, and they need to have the appropriate
capacity perform this task.
The health system may also have a role in distributing supplements for complementary feeding
(e.g. lipid nutrient supplements or multiple micronutrient supplements, or vouchers for fortified
complementary foods for children aged 6-23 months among vulnerable, food insecure groups, linked
to IYCF counselling and MCH services (see Chapter 3.2.6). The systems for targeting, delivery and
monitoring of these products, as well as the supply forecasting, requisition and management in the
health services, need to be clearly defined. The linkage to the IYCF counselling services also needs to
be clearly articulated and monitored. The distribution of products to these groups can effectively serve
36
as an incentive to attend health facilities more frequently and thus provide an opportunity to deliver
IYCF counselling services [132].
Maternal nutrition, especially during pregnancy and lactation, is crucial to good maternal health,
healthy pregnancy outcomes, and infant health and nutrition. The health services should deliver a
package of interventions during pregnancy and lactation aiming to ensure that women consume an
adequate balanced diet, including supplements and fortified foods where available, and achieve and
maintaining a desirable weight. The interventions include regular assessment of nutrition status,
counselling on diet and care, micronutrient supplementation, provision or referral for supplementary
feeding in case of undernutrition and related health interventions.
37
encouraging mothers to give the child an egg three times a week than to just tell them feed more
animal source foods, or provide children with a more diverse diet).
IYCF is often addressed over a few hours as part
of an integrated preventive training module for
community workers, but this type of training
cannot build counselling, communication and
problem-solving skills and is superficial to build a
good understanding of the technical aspects of
good IYCF practices and the risks of poor
practices.
Reviews have shown that many community-based
programmes have failed to achieve scale.
Therefore, a national strategy needs to have a
vision for scale. Inclusion of the community IYCF
actions in all districts needs to be pursued in a
phased manner and progressively integrated
within the national and district health plans and
budgets. District health authority leadership,
ownership and management and partner support
are important issues to emphasize in this process.
Six key steps are suggested for the design and development of a communication strategy and
implementation plan:
1. Establishment of a national coordination mechanism for communication aspects of the national
IYCF strategy.
2. Undertaking and analysing a communication situation assessment and formative research.
3. Development of a communication strategy and operational plan.
38
ingredients.
10. Measures to improve the availability and use of local foods through increasing
agricultural production of high quality local foods (e.g. homestead production, animal
husbandry, linking with agricultural extension).
11. Provision of nutrition supplements and foods for complementary feeding (MNPs, LNS,
fortified complementary foods) in food-insecure populations and social & commercial
marketing of nutrition supplements and foods for complementary feeding in general
population, including stimulating quality local production.
12. Social protection schemes with nutrition component.
9. Improving the quality of complementary foods through locally available ingredients
Locally available and acceptable foods should be used for complementary feeding whenever possible.
Identification of such foods should be prioritized so that key findings can be incorporated into nutrition
education and counselling. Traditional household techniques that improve nutritional content of
commonly consumed plant-based foods, as well as availability and consumption of animal source
foods should be assessed and exploited. In addition, analyses of typical diets need to take into
consideration the presence of anti-nutrients and inhibitors of absorption when assessing adequacy of
nutrient intake. Analysis of diets will allow the identification of the main nutrient gaps and the so-called
problem nutrients most prevalent in a particular setting. In many developing countries, iron, iodine,
zinc, vitamin A and vitamin D are problem nutrients, among others. Iron, iodine, zinc and vitamin D
requirements are very difficult to be met with plant-based diets, and therefore are problematic in many
contexts where animal-source foods and fortified foods are scarce. In addition to micronutrients, diets
in developing countries are often deficient in essential fatty acids. There is increasing evidence that
essential fatty acids affect growth in infants and young children [135].
Tools which can be used to identify and optimize use of locally available foods and design
complementary feeding programmes include ProPAN, a tool which addresses essential elements
necessary to design and evaluate interventions to improve IYCF through:
identification of specific nutritional and dietary problems,
understanding of the context in which these problems occur,
presenting a method for identifying, ranking and selecting practices to promote that are
practical, feasible and accepted by the community and potentially effective if adopted.
Linear Programming (Resources Annex 1-3) is a tool to analyze the nutritional value of locally
available foods and recommend the best combinations to meet the infant/child needs. It can also be
used to develop least-cost complementary feeding diets. This process requires information on the
types of foods locally available, their costs, and an estimation of the maximum amount of each food
type infants and young children should consume.
Improving bio-availability of nutrients in local foods is another important method for improving the
quality of the local diet. Traditional processing methods, such as fermentation, germination, and
roasting, are simple and inexpensive and have been practiced for generations in many countries.
Traditional processing may produce foods with many positive attributes, such as favourable texture,
good organoleptic quality, reduced bulk, enhanced shelf life, partial or complete elimination of antinutritional factors, reduced cooking time, and improved nutritional value. These methods have often
been used separately or in combination with one another for preparation of infant complementary
foods, and the nutritional profile of these foods has been reported [136]. It is therefore recommended
to review the available and accepted techniques at the local level and encourage their utilization for
enhancing absorption of nutrients from traditional diets.
39
40
Micronutrient deficiencies are often part of an overall inadequate diet with low diversity. It should
therefore be noted that if in a population both growth and micronutrient deficiencies are problematic,
additional interventions will be needed to improve growth [143,144]. To improve overall
complementary feeding of infants and young children, provision of micronutrient supplements could
also provide an additional incentive to caregivers to follow up the recommendations and return for
visits. Using the supplements in this manner, together with improved quality of counselling and access
to foods and supportive supervision, can have a significant impact on growth (e.g. reduce stunting) as
well [145].
Use of lipid based nutrient supplements and other types of food assistance in food insecure
environments or socio-economic deprivation (non-emergency situations).
Under certain conditions, provision of lipid-based nutrient supplements and other types of food
assistance may be needed to ensure appropriate complementary feeding for selected food-insecure
sub-populations. These populations may experience significant nutrient gaps in both macro and
micronutrients.The supplement distribution may have different inclusion criteria, e.g., households with
children who have poor nutritional status, the poorest families in a community or to all families in the
poorest communities in a target area, or blanket distribution in an area during the hunger season.
Large-scale approaches may include the provision of complementary food supplements such as lipid
based nutrient supplements (LNS) containing both micronutrients and macronutrients to selected
target groups (see Resources Annex 1-2, Description of available complementary foods and
supplements for details of various products). These groups may include the most socio-economically
deprived families, communities or larger geographical areas with high levels of food insecurity. The
selection of the product should be context-specific, based on the degree of food insecurity and the
quality of locally available foods, and evidence of high potential for impact. There may be a need for
longer-term provision of the product in some cases, or shorter-term provision during a lean season or
a post-emergency recovery period, for example.
Current evidence shows that in order to show an impact on growth, the supplements in the context of
IYCF counselling has to be provided for at least six months, with the greatest impact shown after six
months of provision in a highly controlled, small study setting [111]. However, the decision to include
these supplements within the national IYCF program calls for further national-level consultation to
assess needs, evidence of impact and potential for benefits in the children 6-23 months. It should be
noted that the evidence is gradually building in this area; therefore there is a need to use the most
recent information for making programmatic decision.
Although in some contexts there is a need for provision of supplements to address nutritional gaps in
the diet, the focus should not be solely on the products. It is not recommended to develop a
programme related to a product per se, rather, there needs to be a comprehensive IYCF programme,
into which this additional provision of products can be integrated as necessary.
It should be noted that appropriate complementary feeding provides a solid basis for prevention of
growth faltering, as well as for stopping the progression of growth faltering towards moderate and
severe undernutrition.
The overall IYCF programming framework provides a baseline for ensuring best practices for
prevention of undernutrition in all situations, including the non-emergency context as well as
"acceptable situations" in accordance with relevant guidelines [146]. In such circumstances where no
specific blanket supplementary food rations are provided, IYCF counselling and support ensures that
caregivers of children who do not have adequate growth or are faltering, can address problems and
improve feeding practices. Therefore, the complementary feeding decision tree could be applied to
interventions for prevention of any type of undernutrition.
There may be different scenarios of transition between complementary feeding and blanket
supplementary feeding interventions. For example, an emergency blanket feeding programme for all
children 6-59 months may transition to a more focused programme providing complementary feeding
supplements to children 6-18 months during the recovery phase, or a complementary feeding
intervention for children 6-18 months in a chronically food insecure area or a seasonal intervention
during the annual lean season may transition to a broader blanket supplementary feeding
programme if the situation deteriorates. Interventions implemented as part of an emergency response
41
programme may serve as a catalyst for longer-term programming to improve complementary feeding,
especially in situations where there was no prior complementary feeding programming.
42
Following this policy decision, the health services should counsel and support all mothers known to be
HIV-infected on the countrys selected recommendation, as opposed to the previous approach of
counselling each mother on choice of options: to breastfeed or artificially feed her infant.
This decision should be based on international recommendations and consideration of the socioeconomic and cultural contexts of the populations served by maternal and child health services, the
availability and quality of health services, the local epidemiology including HIV prevalence among
pregnant women and main causes of infant and child mortality and maternal and child under-nutrition.
Countries with high infant mortality rates are also likely to have a high risk of death due to lack of
breastfeeding and therefore should carefully consider this balance of risks versus HIV transmission
through safer breastfeeding with ARVs.
Interventions and actions to address infant feeding in the context of HIV include:
i.
ii.
iii.
Implementation of actions related to HIV and infant feeding in the health system, including
ensuring implementation of IYCF counselling as part of the PMTCT services and capacity
development of health providers on the new WHO guidelines.
iv.
Implementation of IYCF counselling in communities using counselling tools which include the
2010 HIV and infant feeding guidelines, and provision of support for follow up of HIV-infected
43
mothers and exposed and exposed infants and ensuring adherence to ARV regimes and
infant feeding recommendations.
v.
Communication on HIV and infant feeding as part of the overall communication strategy, with
carefully-tailored messages on the safety and importance of breastfeeding in the context of
ensuring HIV-free survival, the importance of adherence to the ARV regimens, and messages
on the importance of exclusive breastfeeding even in the absence of ARVs.
vi.
Monitoring and evaluation considerations for HIV and infant feeding, including routine
monitoring of feeding practices, review of the impact of HIV and PMTCT programmes on
breastfeeding rates and other aspects of infant feeding and operations research.
Breastfeeding is safe, free and a crucial life-saving intervention for vulnerable children whose risks
of death increase markedly in emergencies.
Emergency situations exacerbate risks for non-breastfed children and those who are on mixed
feeding.
Both exclusive breastfeeding up to 6 months and continued breastfeeding after 6 months are
crucial in reducing the risk of diarrhoea and other illnesses in older children, which is heightened in
emergencies.
Donations of BMS undermine breastfeeding and cause illness and death.
IYCF is central to reducing the high risk of undernutrition during emergencies.
Safe, adequate, and appropriate complementary feeding, which significantly contributes to
prevention of undernutrition and mortality in children after 6 months, is often jeopardized during
emergencies and needs particular attention.
The Operational Guidance on Infant and Young Child Feeding in Emergencies (see Resources
Annex 1-11) contains 6 practical steps for IYCF actions in emergencies which should be planned as
a part of national IYCF strategy and emergency preparedness:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
The major priority actions in emergencies are highlighted in the Chapter 3.5.2 of this programme
guidance and include the following areas:
i.
ii.
iii.
iv.
v.
vi.
The three items in bold have been added or addressed in more detail in this document as compared with the Operational
Guidance. The Operational Guidance is due to be updated in 2011.
44
45
rather than generic messages about the benefits of optimal feeding practices. Channels and
techniques for communication and counselling should be selected based on their potential
effectiveness in reaching the target groups.
46
Figure 19: Example of a decision tree for population-based programmatic options for
improving nutrient quality of complementary foods and feeding practices in non-emergency
situations
This is a decision tree for population based public health approaches, not based on individual level screening. For all
contexts, counselling and education of mothers about optimal feeding and care practices and use of locally available foods
are essential, as well as strategies to improve availability and affordability of quality local foods (* see notes below for more
details). The decision tree would help with choosing additional components for the program, both in contexts where
adequate local foods are available but supplementation may be needed to fill in nutritional gaps of local diets in certain
groups or areas, or where there is generalized food insecurity. The examples of strategies and supplements are not
exhaustive.
2.
Complementary feeding
practices
3.
Availability
&
affordability
of foods
Macronutrient
requirements for 623m olds are met in
typical diet but
micronutrient gaps
present
Macronutrient &
micronutrient
requirements of 623m olds are not met
in typical diet
a)
b)
c)
Interventions:
BOX 1:
BOX 2:
Multimicronutrient
supplements
(powders)
along with:
a) IYCF counseling and
communication
b) Increasing availability
and
c) affordability of quality
food
Virtually no suitable
staple diet available
staple diet
BOX 4:
Fortified
complementary
foods
along with:
a) IYCF counseling and
communication
b) Increasing availability
and
c) affordability of quality
food
along with:
a) IYCF counseling
and communication
b) Increasing
availability and
c) affordability of
quality food
BOX 3:
Lipid based nutrient
supplements to enrich
Strategies for increasing availability of quality foods: improving production, commercial and social marketing of
high-quality local foods, homestead production, animal husbandry, links with agriculture extension.
c)
Strategies for increasing affordability of high quality foods: vouchers/coupons, conditional cash transfers or
other social safety nets, or through free distribution.
47
48
Following all three steps of the situation analysis, and based on results of categorization, various
options for interventions (Boxes 1-4) are suggested in the decision tree.
Interventions
It is important to emphasize that even though there will be different options in the decision tree
(Boxes 1-4) for necessity of additional foods to supplement local diets, there are two major
interventions (a, b, c) that need to be prioritized in all cases. Therefore all three interventions
appear in all boxes along with context-specific additional solutions.
49
the diet. Assistance for home gardening, raising poultry, and animal husbandry can increase
availability of high-quality ingredients for complementary feeding among the rural poor.
Linear programming is one tool that can be used for development of least-cost complementary foods.
Linear programming requires the input of accurate nutrient content estimates of foods and adjustment
for factors such as bioavailability, and absorption rate of nutrients.
Linkage to agriculture can prove to be effective in improving the access of these households to better
food options. Traditional techniques at the household level such as dehulling, peeling, soaking,
germination, fermentation and drying can improve nutritional content of local foods, though these
techniques by themselves may still not result in sufficient amounts of bioavailable iron.
When local foods are not adequate to meet the micro and macronutrient requirements of children, the
role of industry in producing high quality complementary foods should be assessed. Availability of
industrially-processed fortified complementary foods marketed to young children should be evaluated.
A list of these foods and their nutrient content assessed for adequacy as foods for children 6-23
months can be made. Accessibility of these foods among different sub-populations (including urban,
rural, and extremely poor populations) should be assessed.
c) Strategies for increasing affordability of quality foods
Inability to afford adequate quality foods suitable for children 6-23 months is a major limiting factor in
the diets of children in many communities, particularly the lowest income quintiles and the most
disadvantaged and deprived groups. These groups are found in both rural and urban settings. The
urban poor may have specific vulnerabilities since they generally have a greater dependence on cash
income for purchases, greater participation of women in the work force, and a greater number of
women heading households as compared to the rural poor. This often poses greater time constraints
for caregivers and increases tendency to use processed foods. However many of these foods are of
low quality. As discussed above, strategies to improve access of these households to better food
options need to be addressed, such as vouchers, coupons, and linking with social protection
programmes.
Improving complementary feeding where households are food secure (Boxes 1 & 2 in Decision
Tree)
Even when households are not facing challenges of food insecurity, there are many challenges
in providing optimal complementary feeding to children, therefore, one should not assume that even if
the food is available, appropriate complementary feeding would happen automatically.
In food-secure settings where local foods appropriate for complementary feeding with
sufficient macro and micronutrients are available and affordable but not necessarily given to
children, the focus should be on improving complementary feeding practices. The main strategy
should be to improve practices by optimizing approaches to use locally available and acceptable
foods. Identification of such foods should be prioritized so that key findings can be incorporated into
nutrition education and counseling. The three main interventions described above a) counseling &
communication, b) improving availability of local foods and c) improving affordability should
be applied but no additional intervention is needed, as shown in Box 1 in the Decision Tree.
In food-secure settings where local foods appropriate for complementary feeding with
sufficient macronutrients are available and affordable but lack micronutrients, the focus should
be on improving complementary feeding with additional micronutrient supplementation. The
role of in-home supplementation of complementary foods among different populations (i.e. rural vs.
urban) with multiple micronutrient powders should be explored. Selection of best additional options
needs to be based on assessment of local situation and gaps, as explained later here. Use of
supplements, such as vitamin-mineral powders or tablets, can improve the nutritional quality of local
CF at a low cost. Widespread use of supplements will require social marketing and/or distribution to
families in need. These products may be especially useful in rural areas where access to industriallyprocessed fortified complementary foods is limited. The three main interventions described above a)
counseling/communication, b) improving availability of local foods and c) improving
affordability should be applied together with multiple micronutrient supplementation, as shown
in Box 2 in the Decision Tree.
50
Complementary feeding in the face of household food insecurity (Boxes 3 & 4 in Decision Tree)
The availability, accessibility and affordability of high quality foods for children are key factors in
determining the capacity of caregivers to provide optimal complementary feeding to children.
Therefore, in food-insecure situation, the typical diet is usually not able to meet the nutritional needs of
children. The inability to meet the dietary requirements may be transient, e.g. during normal or
abnormal seasonal hunger patterns, during the recovery phase following an emergency or as a result
of sudden food price increases. In such situations provision of supplements may be considered as a
short-term temporary measure.
In food insecure settings where local foods appropriate for complementary feeding with
sufficient macro and micronutrients are unavailable and unaffordable, but a limited, low quality
staple diet is available, the focus could be on improving complementary feeding with additional
provision of quality foods such as lipid-based nutrient supplements (LNS) and similar
products. Widespread use of supplements will require social marketing and/or distribution to families
in need. These products may be especially useful in rural areas where access to industriallyprocessed fortified complementary food is limited, or under special circumstances such as during
hunger season, in refugee settings or in HIV context. The three main interventions described above
counselling/communication, improving availability of local foods and improving affordability
should be applied along with the supplements, as shown in Box 3 in the Decision Tree.
In food insecure settings where local foods appropriate for complementary feeding with
sufficient macro and micronutrients are unavailable and unaffordable, and staple diet is scarce
and of low nutritional quality, the focus could be on improving complementary feeding with
additional provision of industrially-processed fortified complementary foods. Such foods have
been developed for improved complementary feeding in many countries [158]. In addition, fortified
blended or ready to use foods have been typically used in food assistance programmes in
emergencies and situations of acute food insecurity. The three main interventions described above
a) counselling/communication, b) improving availability of local foods and c) improving
affordability should be applied together with provision of industrially processed fortified
complementary foods as shown in Box 4 in the Decision Tree.
In addition to developing IYCF strategy and designing relevant interventions, other programmes
targeting women and young children should be used as entry points to incorporate key elements of
IYCF, and the use of existing contacts should be maximized to implement IYCF actions. This will help
in achieving high coverage of interventions, multiplying resources and avoiding duplication, thus
saving time and resources and enabling more people to be reached. At the same time, IYCF should
not be implemented only through integration leaving out components which have to be implemented
separately, as has been observed in some cases.
Examples of interventions and entry points for integration within the health system include:
Maternal and neo-natal health programmes: the contacts of ante-natal care, maternity care,
postnatal/newborn care and family planning all provide opportunities to counsel and support
women on IYCF. All relevant trainings should include infant feeding counselling as one of the
mandatory training modules. Staff with training on lactation management/breastfeeding
51
counselling should be one of the core requirements for quality maternity services, along with
compliance with the Ten Steps.
Child health programmes in the health system: the contact points of routine immunization,
IMCI or other facility-based child illness treatment programmes, growth monitoring and promotion
(GMP) and child health days are all entry points for IYCF. A structure needs to be institutionalized
that both requires and enables health workers to conduct IYCF assessment and counselling
activities as a standard, routine part of their daily work (see page 47 for a detailed table of the
health system contacts relevant to IYCF and suggested services at each contact).
Community case management (CCM) of common childhood illnesses: CCM is being pursued to
address malaria, diarrhoea and pneumonia in many countries. Optimal breastfeeding practices are
essential to the reduction of diarrhoea and pneumonia, and CCM programmes have much to gain
from appropriate attention to IYCF activities. IYCF counselling training could be implemented as
an integral element of CCM programmes.
PMTCT and paediatric AIDS treatment: PMTCT is intimately related to infant feeding, and
PMTCT programmes represent an important entry point for IYCF. Several countries have made
significant progress in scaling up IYCF (e.g. Zambia, Kenya) through PMTCT programmes, and
have shown significant results in terms of increased exclusive breastfeeding rates. The infant
feeding component has often proven to be a challenging area within PMTCT programmes,
sometimes not very well addressed, but there are important lessons learnt that can be used to
overcome some of the constraints and design and plan the IYCF component within PMTCT more
effectively.
52
A potential entry point is the Community Led Total Sanitation (CLTS) initiative implemented by
the WASH programme, which uses participatory approaches to generate understanding on
pathways to contamination of food and water and mobilizes communities to improve handwashing
practices and use of latrines. It uses motivators of shame and disgust as well as pride in adopting
new practices. This could potentially be a powerful incentive to move away from the practice of
giving water and food to babies less than six months old, highlight vulnerability of small babies to
contamination, and promote safe preparation of complementary foods.
Social protection programmes can provide an entry point to reach mothers and caregivers in
vulnerable households, increase the availability of affordable and high quality foods and influence
their feeding and care practices. Various interventions, including provision of micro-credit, food
supplementation, food vouchers, subsidies, conditional cash transfers etc. can be assessed within
the context of each country and integrated with IYCF services for specific target groups. Effective
mechanisms are needed to link IYCF counselling to the receipt of these social benefits.
Programmes for improved access to local food can also provide an entry point to reach
mothers and caregivers in vulnerable households and influence their feeding and care practices.
Delivery gaps for high impact nutrition interventions for children under-two may be best filled by
cross-sectoral approaches that integrate IYCF, nutrition and public health with agriculture
programmes, including animal husbandry, home gardening, agricultural extension etc.
53
Ensuring strong links across all levels, as well as adopting harmonized curricula, materials and
messages are crucial. Figure 20 represents graphically the different levels, stakeholders and
components of a comprehensive IYCF strategy, with key actions at each level and the importance of
strong links and harmonization across all levels.
54
Figure 20: IYCF stakeholders, components and actions with strong links across all levels
Levels
Stakeholders
INDIVIDUAL/
HOUSEHOLD
COMMUNITY
HEALTH FACILITY
SUB-NATIONAL
(STATE, DISTRICT)
NATIONAL
Health workers
(public and private faith-based)
Local Govt.,
district MOH team, NGOs,
hospital admin.
Policy makers,
planners, programme
managers,
development
partners,
mass media,
academia,
private
sector
donors
55
The microplanning model of the EPI programme is an example of the useful tool for developing
local IYCF plans and should be adapted and tailored to IYCF. As with EPI, multiple contacts are
required to deliver tailored IYCF counselling topics through the life-cycle to a pre-determined
group of pregnant women and caregivers of children under 2, along with various training activities
and regular supervision. Therefore, the EPI and similar types of tools can be used to reflect, by
the lowest applicable administrative level (e.g. the district health authority), activities such as
training of health providers and community workers, creation of mother support groups,
communication, supervision and monitoring, the supplies required etc. The health facility and
community levels could also develop their own micro-plans, using the model for immunization
services. Planning of supplies will be applicable if supplements for complementary feeding are
provided. The EPI budget tools can also be adapted to local-level budgeting for IYCF. (See
Resources Annex 1-1 for a sample of micro-planning format for the Reaching Every District
(RED) strategy for immunization).
56
academic institutions. NGOs play a key role in supporting district community-based actions as
part of this national plan.
The mapping of all potential partners may precede the setting up of programmes for IYCF or take
place when trying to move from small-scale or initial implementation to a Government-managed,
more widespread approach. In both cases it is important to take into account that involvement of
partners in implementing a comprehensive IYCF strategy should not be a top-down, one-size-fitsall approach though the basic policies and strategies are fixed. The way the approach is
implemented and managed must be fitted to the context and the managing body (e.g. MOH or
NGOs).
A review of existing capacities for IYCF both within the health system, NGO and other partners
should be undertaken in order to position and design a comprehensive approach to IYCF in the
country while providing appropriate support, including health systems strengthening. Capacity
mapping allows the identification of gaps and system weaknesses that will need to be addressed
to ensure success by both national and international partners. Capacity gap analysis includes
assessing institutional and human resources capacities, identifying capacity deficits and leads to
the development of a strategy to address them.
57
plan should be developed with clear and measureable targets and indicators (see examples of
process indicators in Table 1).
At each service delivery level (community worker/health post, health facility, hospital), the lowest
administrative level (e.g. district health authority), the provincial/regional/state level and the
national level, simple tools can be used to facilitate and monitor implementation against annual
targets for the numbers of caregivers and children reached, similar to the approach for monitoring
progress for immunization or ante-natal care.
Graphic representation can be used at different levels, for example adapted from the
monitoring chart for health facility monitoring of immunization (see Annex 2 for a possible layout
for tracking IYCF counselling adapted from the immunization chart, and see also Step 7/pages
30-31 of the Reaching Every District (RED) microplanning guide, Resources Annex 1-1) or using
a simple bar graph to record cumulative numbers of children and caregivers reached with
counselling. While planning for IYCF counselling integrated in MCH services, it will be important
to have the same target numbers of women for IYCF counselling as for ante-natal care and the
same target numbers of children under one year old as for immunization. This will help to ensure
that the provision of IYCF counselling is well integrated and ingrained in the day to day
monitoring of activities of a health facility. This should be the minimum target of contacts for
IYCF, and there may of course be more counselling and monitoring opportunities at other
contacts, e.g. regular growth monitoring sessions, MUAC screening or contacts for treatment of
illnesses, all of which should be tallied and reflected on the monitoring chart.
The use of simple tally sheets can also be adapted for IYCF counselling activities at the health
facility and community levels, on which each counselling session, regardless of which contact it is
delivered through, can be recorded and the tallies aggregated on a monthly reporting form or
electronic system. Innovative tools such as RapidSMS using cellphone technology might also be
applied to monitoring of IYCF services. The attendance at group communication sessions can
also be tallied.
Antenatal care cards and child health cards should be adapted to include IYCF counselling
contacts, which will help to ensure counselling becomes one of the activities not only routinely
conducted and recorded, but also monitored, and also helps to verify information during surveys.
The minimum number of counselling sessions to be monitored should be linked to attendance at
ANC, EPI and vitamin A supplementation, but there could also room to undertake and monitor
additional contacts and counselling sessions, for example if the child came for IMCI, CMAM, ART
or other services and received IYCF counselling.
In addition, the execution of training plans need to be closely monitored to ensure the planned
number of training sessions took place, follow up visits were undertaken and target supportive
supervision was implemented.
Tools for the monitoring of IYCF activities and performance should be incorporated in the
standard monitoring frameworks for health facilities and services. Countries may create their
own, tailored tools, or may adapt existing tools. For example, supervision tools contained in the
UNICEF generic community IYCF counselling package (see Chapter 3.3) could be adapted to
become an integral part of monitoring checklists and guides for different levels of the health
1
system .
While tools are available, there are routinely large gaps in routine monitoring and supervision that
need to be addressed at the planning stage. Therefore, effective monitoring needs adequate
planning, baseline data, indicators of performance, and results as well as practical
implementation mechanisms that include field visits, stakeholder meetings, documentation of
project activities, regular reporting, formal reviews, effective feedback and follow up.
It is also important to integrate key IYCF programme indicators within the existing Health
Management and Information System (HMIS) and ensure quality data collection and analysis at
all levels.
1
Note that the WHO/UNICEF IYCF counselling course for health providers does not contain supervision tools
58
59
An example of a recent in-depth IYCF programme review is the Infant and Young Child Feeding
Programme Review: Consolidated Report of Six-Country Review of Breastfeeding Programmes
commissioned by UNICEF in 2008 and conducted in Bangladesh, Benin, the Philippines, Sri
Lanka, Uganda and Uzbekistan [160]. The report contains a series of questions which were used
to guide this review. The document Infant and Young Child Feeding: A tool for assessing
national practices, policies and programmes (Resources Annex 1-1) also contains some
checklists for assessing the status of programmes, which can be adapted to the country situation.
At minimum a best practice must: 1) demonstrate evidence of success; 2) affect something important and, 3) have the
potential to be replicated or adopted to other settings. Given the shifting definition of what is best, there is an increasing
preference to talk about good practices or promising practices or lessons learned as well as success stories
60
Cross-sectoral:
Policy
National multi-sectoral infant and young child feeding committee is present
National IYCF committee includes members from the M. Agriculture, Finance, social services, education,
and other relevant sectors
PRSPs include nutrition
Food security policy includes nutrition interventions for families 0-24 months children
% government budget for nutrition out of the total health budget and total government budget
Social protection programs include child nutrition component/conditions
Agriculture extension programs include nutrition education component
Agriculture extension programs include homestead food production component
Agriculture extension programs include support of animal source production
Implementation
# and % of children under 2 reached with social protection scheme (incl. cash transfers) with child nutrition
component
% of districts/lowest local administrative area with homestead gardening programmes focused on
production of a variety of vegetables and fruits
% of districts/lowest local administrative area with small animal/fowl husbandry programmes
% of districts/lowest local administrative area with agriculture/food security programmes focused on
production of high quality foods with a child nutrition focus or education component
% of schools with child nutrition in curriculum
% of planned Code monitoring activities implemented
61
Community level:
Routine monitoring:
# and % of community workers (CWs) trained on IYCF counselling and support
% of planned supportive supervision visits for IYCF trained CWs undertaken
# and % of local administration areas (sub-district) with trained CWs conducting planned activities
# and % of local administration areas (sub-district) with mother support groups meeting/conducting
activities
at least once per month
1
HH surveys/rapid surveys/SQUEAC
% of local administration areas (sub-district) with active community worker providing IYCF counselling
% of local administration areas (sub-district) with mother support groups meeting/conducting activities
at least once per month
% of CWs who reported receiving at least one supervisory visit in the last xx months
% of caregivers of children <2 who reported receiving at least one individual IYCF counselling session
in the last xx months
% of caregivers of children <2 who reported receiving at least one group education session on IYCF
in the last xx months
% of caregivers of children <2 who were able to correctly state at least 3 essential breastfeeding
practices
% of caregivers of children <2 who were able to correctly state at least 3 essential CF practices
% of caregivers of children 6-23m who report receiving [the type of supplement provided in the country]
(as applicable)
% of caregivers of children 6-23m who report giving iron-fortified foods or supplements in the past 24
hours
Outcome Indicators
Impact Indicators
SQUEAC = Semi- Quantitative Evaluation of Access and Coverage. The methodology may be used to obtain data on
sustained coverage of the IYCF counselling services http://www.brixtonhealth.com/squeaclq.html
62
Checking the status of Code legislation. The Code is a minimum standard, and only those
countries in category 1 which incorporate all provisions of the international Code and
subsequent WHA Resolutions are actually complying with this minimum standard. If a country
has not reached this minimum standard, then the available legislation in the country, if any,
should be assessed for gaps and revised to include the requirements necessary to comply
with the standard of a full provision law.
ii.
Encouraging the Ministry of Health to adopt an interim policy applying the Code to all
health facilities with immediate effect. The adoption of legislation to implement the Code
may involve a lengthy process, whereas the Ministry of Health may be able to adopt a policy
or circular relatively quickly to apply the provisions of the Code and subsequent WHA
Resolutions to the health care system. Although this approach does
not afford full protection from unethical and inappropriate marketing
by manufacturers of breastmilk substitutes, feeding bottles and teats,
it will prevent them at least from promoting their products in health
care facilities.
vi. Ensuring that the HIV pandemic and emergencies are not being
used to reintroduce commercial donations of BMS to the health
care system. Where the government decides to make free or subsidized BMS available to
63
3.1.2
There are several actions that can be taken to raise awareness and support implementation of
appropriate maternity protection legislation and dispel the misconception that mothers in
employment cannot breastfeed:
i.
ii.
Develop culturally appropriate advocacy messages and materials about how maternity
protection benefits all of society: women and men, employees, employers, governments, and
most of all babies. Emphasize that all mothers work, and that breastfeeding mothers need
support and time to nurse their babies.
iii. Develop Baby-Friendly Workplace Initiative advocacy materials for industries and factories,
focusing on the benefits to the employer of offering 14 weeks maternity leave, crches and
nursing breaks (improved morale, reduced absenteeism, improved productivity and image
booster for the company).
See: UNICEF: "Infant feeding and mother to child transmission of HIV: operational guidance note" CF/PD/PRO/2002003 (ref. 132)
64
3.2.4
3.2.5
3.2.6
3.2.7
Introduction
Health professionals are often influential figures in a society, and the messages, counselling and
advice they provide play a crucial role in ensuring optimal infant and young child feeding
practices. They include not only doctors and nurses in general practice, but also paediatricians,
obstetricians/gynaecologists, neonatologists and general doctors. The experiences of mothers
and infants in the health care services exert a strong influence on breastfeeding initiation and
later infant feeding behaviour. On the other hand, the functions of health providers may also
reflect a lack of knowledge about correct feeding advice and practices or a bias towards suboptimal infant feeding, for example they may encourage the use of formula or sanction giving
water along with breastmilk. In many settings where proactive feeding advice and support is
absent in the health system (and often in the community as well), the opportunity for influencing
mothers towards optimal practices is lost and mothers are left to be influenced by wrong advice,
for example by health providers who have incorrect knowledge and biased views or by formula
companies inappropriately marketing breastmilk substitutes.
The influence of health providers extends beyond the facilities where they work and the
caregivers they come into contact with. The senior health providers and managers working in
larger facilities and hospitals, district and provincial health offices, the national Ministry of Health
and in training institutes are often the people who train others, conduct supervision and who
advise on policies and protocols. It is crucial that they are fully capacitated on the most effective
ways of IYCF programming. In cases where their capacity and understanding of IYCF is limited,
their commitment and performance for IYCF is significantly jeopardised. In many instances a
strong advocacy is needed to convince this group of professionals on the importance of IYCF and
the actions needed.
65
It is critical to avoid having parallel and often contradictory systems of training, a scenario
common in many countries. The most appropriate support is to ensure that the various preservice curricula for doctors, health officers, nutritionists, midwives, nurses, nurses assistants,
etc. contain appropriate IYCF content and that pre-service and in-service training curricula are
harmonized.
Involving academics and teaching staff from the outset when new curricula and courses are
introduced and in training of trainers has proven to be an effective approach. In addition,
investing in quality IYCF content in the basic training packages and ensuring regular updates can
also contribute to development of a well-trained cadre of IYCF advocates in academia, an
important resource for an IYCF programme. High level and influential academics may in turn
become key champions for IYCF in a country.
Pre-service and in-service curricula therefore need to devote sufficient attention to building
professional support and counselling skills on IYCF, including through practical residency and
other on-the-job programmes where skills can be practised. In many countries IYCF features as a
module within a broader nutrition training programme. This is a good start that helps in the
general promotion of appropriate infant feeding, but needs further IYCF-focused capacity building
to adequately counsel mothers, negotiate with them, solve problems and provide practical
support.
The
five-day
Integrated
IYCF
Counselling
Course
(WHO/UNICEF 2006) which contains modules on breastfeeding,
complementary feeding, and HIV and infant feeding, is a good
model that provides sufficient depth but at the same time is feasible
to implement at scale. It can be adapted to the local context and
can be used for in-service curricula. It does not, however, have
counselling cards or other job aids. The counselling cards
developed by UNICEF for community cadres may also be utilized
for primary health care staff. In addition, the HIV aspect of the
IYCF training courses needs to be updated based on the 2010
WHO guidelines on HIV and infant feeding Guidelines on HIV and
Infant Feeding - Principles and recommendations and a
summary of the evidence (WHO 2010)
Specialized training on lactation management of selected health staff can use the 40-hour
1
Breastfeeding Counselling Training Course (WHO/UNICEF 1993) . In addition, there
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
66
within the teaching institutions will also avoid creating parallel systems with different approaches
and contents and will lead to lead to continuity and sustainability.
It is important to define precise quality criteria for training, including ensuring that there are
adequate clinical and field practice sessions, and continuously monitor it. There are numerous
experiences of using a number of training packages on IYCF for example, the IYCF integrated
course or a local adaptation, breastfeeding counselling, the BFHI 20-hour course, or training
packages which contain elements of IYCF such as IMCI, CMAM, ENA, a PMTCT course, an
HIV and nutrition course, and a pre-service nutrition technician course. The ultimate decision on
the content should be based on consideration of objectives and relevance to functions of the
trainee.
It is critical to ensure the IYCF content of all the different courses in the health system is
harmonized. All health workers are then trained on the same material, which can be useful in a
context with a high degree of staff rotation and turnover. Materials for health provider training also
need to be harmonized with the materials for training of community cadres. Harmonization is
essential to ensure that all those who provide IYCF counselling disseminate the same messages
and apply best practices to counsel caregivers.
It is also critical to ensure that the training of health providers is not the first and last step in the
process of capacity building. Training sessions on their own do not produce capacity and
sustained implementation of services and achievement of results. The appropriate systems and
structures to implement the IYCF counselling services need to be developed, and supervision
and performance monitoring mechanisms need to be in place to ensure sustained
implementation. This is especially important in contexts where human resources are constrained
or health systems are weak.
When IYCF counselling training is provided, follow up after training, mentoring and supportive
supervision need to be undertaken to ensure that theoretical skills are put into practice effectively.
At least one follow up visit should be conducted within 4-6 weeks of the IYCF training. The
Integrated IYCF Counselling Course has guidelines on follow up after training which can be used
to guide this aspect of the capacity development process. The IMCI approach to follow up and
ongoing mentoring and refresher training can be applied to IYCF capacity building.
Monitoring of performance
Following the initial follow up visit after training, regular, sustained monitoring of performance of
the health providers on IYCF needs to be conducted, and should be an integral part of the IYCF
activity and local and national plans. The scope will be dependent on existing systems of
performance monitoring, achievement of targets, service provision etc. in the countrys health
system. The monitoring system needs to take realistic account of the way the health services are
structured and organized and who within the structures is best placed to conduct the supervision.
It should be integrated within the existing internal system of supervision, or performance
monitoring in the hierarchy of the health services.
Therefore the routine performance monitoring system for IYCF services is most likely to be
tailored around ensuring that:
Health providers trained on IYCF are implementing the specified IYCF counselling
services.
IYCF counselling is actually taking place routinely within the designated MCH service
Targets for the numbers of pregnant and lactating women are being achieved.
Data on IYCF counselling is being collected (e.g. monitoring of percentage facilities
reporting on IYCF).
Tools for the monitoring of IYCF activities and performance should be incorporated in the
standard monitoring frameworks for health facilities and services. Countries may create their
own, tailored tools, or may adapt existing tools. For example, supervision tools contained in the
UNICEF generic community IYCF counselling package (see Chapter 3.3) could be adapted to
67
become an integral part of monitoring checklists and guides for different levels of the health
1
system .
Note that this type of routine performance monitoring does not address in depth the quality of the
counselling service. In many health care settings in developing countries it may not be feasible or
realistic to assess and supervise the quality of IYCF counselling or mentor health providers.
Routine supervisory visits may not be standard practice, nor may their scope be suitable for
assessing quality of counselling and mentoring staff on their performance and skills in
counselling. Therefore periodic health facility surveys similar to the health facility surveys of IMCI,
with random sampling, may be utilized to conduct this aspect of monitoring and evaluation of
IYCF counselling services.
However, if there is a system of regular, more in depth supervision of health providers already in
place in a country, assessment of the IYCF counselling and mentoring could be integrated within
this system, especially in cases of particular concern or need. The supervisors need to have
capacities for supervision and mentoring on IYCF, which may need to be developed. It should be
emphasized that that this type of supervision is not regulatory or punitive, but rather an interactive
process of support and mentoring, problem solving and feedback. Health provider concerns and
problems can also be addressed during supervisory visits.
Note that the WHO/UNICEF IYCF counselling course for health providers does not contain supervision tools
68
Programme or
Contact
Pregnancy
Ante-natal care
(including
PMTCT)
Delivery
Neo-natal
period
0-12
months
Maternity care
(health facility
or home)
Postnatal/
newborn care
incl.
community-
based newborn
care
Lactation
**
management
Possible new
contact
EPI
69
Life Cycle
Stage
Programme or
Contact
0-23
months
Growth
monitoring and
promotion
PMTCT
Paediatric ARV
treatment
IMCI/sick child
consultation
Family planning
Community-
based health
and/or nutrition
programmes
(including
CHWs, lay
counsellors,
mother support
groups)
Child Health
Days
Integrated
management of
severe acute
malnutrition
(inpatient,
outpatient and
community-
based)
70
Section 3: Breastfeeding Promotion and Support in a BabyFriendly Hospital, a 20-hour course for maternity staff
71
principles in health care settings beyond hospitals was raised by a number of groups as well. The
process of updating the BFHI materials began in 2004 and the modules have all been updated
and revised based on a decade of accumulated knowledge and experience and the new
developments. A final updated version for BFHI materials was issued in 2009. However, the
section on HIV needs to be updated in light of the recommendation of the 2010 WHO Guidelines
on HIV and infant feeding [126].
The updated version places greater emphasis on sustainability and options for expansion and
integration of the BFHI into the health care system. In addition, significant changes have been
made to the training materials. For example, they contain guidance for implementing BFHI in
settings of high HIV prevalence, updated technical information and additional clinical practice
sessions. The hospital self-appraisal and monitoring tools include revised global criteria, a
strengthened self-appraisal tool and a range of monitoring tools for consideration, while the
external assessment and reassessment tools have revised data gathering tools, slides for training
assessors and an updated computer tool for calculating and presenting results, and new modules
focused on the Code, HIV, and mother-friendly labour and birth. Countries implementing the
BFHI are encouraged to use the updated modules as part of their national pre-service and inservice training curricula and training programmes for maternity staff.
Global status of the BFHI
By 2010, more than 21,000 hospitals have been designated in
154 countries around the world. This represents just over 25 per
cent of the total of over 77,000 hospitals/maternity facilities
reported to exist in these countries. This figure reflects the status
of ever-designated, as many facilities were never re-certified or
updated data has not been possible to obtain.
The UNICEF Assessment Matrix on IYCF programming
contains a section to reflect the current status of hospitals
implementing the 10 Steps and/or certified within the past 4-5
years as baby friendly. This tool will allow further data collection
on the BFHI in developing countries.
72
feeds, giving water and BMS, etc.). This approach can be implemented rapidly and at scale while
working on broader institutional improvements.
In order to achieve a much wider scale of implementation of actions to improve breastfeeding
practices in maternity facilities, it is proposed that up to seven of the Ten Steps may be prioritized
for rapid and at-scale implementation (Steps 1, 3, 4, 6, 7, 8 and 9 indicated in bold in Box 14).
These seven steps specifically relate to
Box 16: Selected priority steps for rapid
national policies and requirements for
implementation
hospital functions, are feasible to implement
without special staff training and can be
immediately introduced into all hospitals for
1. Have a written breastfeeding policy that is
quick, visible and positive results on
routinely communicated to all health care staff.
breastfeeding practices. An instruction issued
3. Inform all pregnant women about the benefits
by the Ministry of Health or other relevant
and management of breastfeeding.
authorities to all maternity facilities to
4. Help mothers initiate breastfeeding within a
half- hour of birth.
implement these seven steps could be a
6. Give newborn infants no food or drink other
feasible and effective action to making all
than breast milk unless medically indicated.
facilities baby-friendly.
7.
73
Communication on IYCF) should be made available to the health workers, as well as job aids and
1
communication materials .
It is essential that the staff who conduct these sessions at health facilities be trained on
interpersonal communication skills and participatory approaches to group facilitation, in
addition to the key technical information. Interactive communication using effective techniques
and appropriate skills is essential to help bring about sustainable behaviour change, in contrast to
the traditional form of delivering health education messages, which is often in a one-way, didactic
manner. The training on effective communication techniques could cover topics such as barriers
and motivators to behaviour and social change, stages of behaviour change, negotiation in
behaviour change, participatory communication techniques, use of role play and interactive
drama, problem solving and action-oriented group work (refer to resources on communication
skills training in Annex 1-9).
Certain compact supplements such as multiple micronutrient powders, lipid based nutrient
supplements and similar products can be distributed in regular and carefully supervised
manner through the routine health services, such as during monthly growth monitoring or
well-child care visits. Bulkier products may not be possible to distribute through the health
services, as their logistics and warehousing may not be amenable to integration within the
pharmacy/medical supplies systems. The supplements may be given out monthly, or every
two months, or as the child gets older, the frequency of contacts may be reduced further.
Multiple micronutrient powders (e.g. Sprinkles) can also be distributed to parents twice yearly
during child health days or similar national or sub-national events [163].
The health services may also refer eligible families to the social welfare system, social
protection programmes or to other organizations to collect other products such as fortified
complementary foods, including blended flours, or to collect vouchers.
Within health system interventions, counselling and communication on optimal use of locally
available foods should always be the starting point and should always complement any
distribution of a product (see Chapter 2.4,4 on identifying and prioritizing interventions for
complementary feeding).
Examples of training packages on behaviour change communication include Behaviour Change Communication for
Improved Infant Feeding Training of Trainers (AED/Linkages 2004).
74
Regular weighing to monitor weight gain and also mid-upper arm circumference
(MUAC) screening for undernutrition.
Appropriate measures for meeting nutrient requirements during pregnancy and lactation
include for example provision or referral for food supplements in poor socio-economic
circumstances or for women who are not gaining sufficient weight, or in situations of food
insecurity and emergencies. Therapeutic and supplementary feeding for undernourished
women as per the national protocols for management of acute malnutrition should be
2
provided if available . Cash transfers as part of social protection schemes could also be
considered, linked to attendance at ante-natal care and well child clinics.
Provision of daily iron/folic acid supplements through ante-natal care, as per the WHO
recommendations [164] and national protocols. A minimum of 90 days supplementation is
recommended.
During emergencies only, as per the Joint Statement on use of multiple micronutrients for
pregnant and lactating women [165], this group of women may be provided with multi3
micronutrient supplements, which contain 15 essential vitamins and minerals .
The focus is on weight and micronutrient status during pregnancy and lactation, as increases in height cannot be
achieved once an adolescent girl reaches her adult height. Improvements in maternal height therefore require a life cycle
approach by increasing birth weight, enhancing growth in children less than two years of age and improving adolescent
nutrition and growth.
2
For women, MUAC <210 mm is considered the cutoff for severe malnutrition. Using body mass index (BMI), severe
acute undernutrition is classified as BMI <16 and mild and moderate undernutrition is classified by BMI between 16 and
18.5. BMI cannot be used to classify undernutrition in pregnant women and lactating women during the first six months of
the babys life.
3
Multi-micronutrients for women are available in capsule, tablet or powder form. The powder has been shown to improve
compliance due to fewer side effects. If conventional Iron and Folic Acid (IFA) supplementation has very low compliance
in a country, these alternatives may be considered. Currently, guidance on multi-micronutrients during pregnancy and
lactation is provided only by the joint statement on micronutrient supplementation in emergencies [ref. 164].
75
breastfeeding women on consuming an adequate quantity and quality of food to meet their
energy requirements and micronutrient needs during lactation (i.e., iron, iodine and vitamin A).
This needs to be done along with reinforcing the message that only in exceptional cases (such as
1
severe undernutrition ) are women unable to breastfeed. Actions include:
Regularly weighing and MUAC screening for undernutrition, and provision of appropriate food
supplements or therapeutic food if found moderately or severely malnourished [166]
respectively.
Provision of a high-dose vitamin A supplement within the first six weeks after the delivery in
high deficiency areas.
Introduction
The systems and policy aspects of community based IYCF are addressed in Chapter 2.3.3. To
summarize, key IYCF actions at the community level may include facilitating establishment of
community structures and participation, counselling and support by trained community workers,
distribution of supplements according to government policy, and behaviour change
communication (BCC). For optimal impact, it is suggested that community-based IYCF activities
should include - at minimum - IYCF promotion and counselling, either through a trained,
dedicated lay IYCF counsellor or through an existing community cadre trained on IYCF
counselling (e.g. community health workers, extension workers and lay counsellors) and relevant
form of mother support group.
It is crucial to first conduct an assessment to understand the existing community based
programmes, systems and structures, identify suitable entry points and understand local feeding
practices and barriers (see also section on situation assessment below); to mobilize and engage
communities and support systems to commit to the programme and participate in its design and
planning, and then to conduct capacity building activities, which include ongoing mentoring and
regular supportive supervision. Training sessions are relatively easy to plan and implement, but
strong programme design and systems for functioning are crucial for producing results on a
sustained basis. Too many community-based programmes have focused only on training of
community cadres but not paid adequate attention to the systems for ongoing implementation of
the activities and ensuring supervision. This often resulted in poor sustainability of programmes,
low motivation, poor quality and wasted resources with minimal outcomes.
The energy and protein content of breastmilk are barely affected by the nutritional status of the breastfeeding mother,
unless the undernutrition is severe [4]. Mildly and moderately malnourished mothers can therefore breastfeed
successfully, although their own body reserves of all nutrients will be depleted. The concentration of some nutrients in
breastmilk, including Vitamin A, iodine and Vitamins of group B, as well as essential fatty acids, is dependent on maternal
status and intake, and so infant depletion is increased by maternal deficiency.
76
The Planning and Adaptation Guide from the UNICEF generic community IYCF counselling
package (Resources Annex 1-8) which includes within it 5 proposed essential steps in designing
a new community-based intervention:
i.
ii.
iii.
iv.
v.
77
Separate formative research/KAP studies for the community and communication components of
the overall IYCF programme are not necessary: it is a single process, and the resulting
counselling tools used by community cadres and the communication messages and materials
should be harmonized.
Existing community health and nutrition programmes should be mapped to determine the
coverage of programmes and scope of activities, the type of community cadres and the
incentives and support they receive. The Assessment Matrix (Resources Annex 1-1) can be
used to facilitate this mapping. Existing community-based IYCF projects should be reviewed if
they exist, to determine which models achieve the desired results and would be feasible for
scaling up.
Policies and systems
Policies and systems need to be in place to support and facilitate the community-based
programme, whether it is an integrated community-based health and nutrition programme or a
stand-alone IYCF community programme. To ensure sustained functioning of the programme, it
is important to address these issues before embarking on training of community cadres.
Challenges to sustainability
Some of the challenges to sustainability of community IYCF interventions (both community IYCF
counselling and mother support groups) are the lack of support and supervision, drop-out of
community workers or support group members and lack of motivation to continue activities, as
well as financial constraints from Government and partners to train enough community workers or
groups and supervise them regularly. Turn-over is often the result of family responsibilities and a
lack of recognition and acceptance of the volunteers by health care providers. These challenges
have been addressed by focusing on one or two activities, matching tasks to available time, and
providing incentives. Some programmes have addressed financial constraints by initiating
income-generating activities. Lack of collaboration with other health services also threatens
sustainability. As a general rule, networking and collaboration with government agencies and
NGOs are essential links that can facilitate two-way referrals, shared training, and technical
assistance opportunities. A solid and consistent support structure, with committed individuals,
needs to be in place to support the community workers and groups.
Note that it is not proposed to involve TBAs in IYCF through any kind of work related to attending births the latest
WHO guidance on this must be upheld. However, as trusted women in the community they may have a role in promoting
good IYCF practices, participating in mother support groups and encouraging attendance or referrals to health facilities.
Involving TBAs in IYCF may also represent a potential approach to giving them a new role in their communities.
78
Consultations with communities and local authorities and partners to determine the influential
community members and decision makers.
Identifying groups and individuals to include in the IYCF activities (Table 5).
Orientation and advocacy sessions with the identified groups to gain their support of and
engaging them in planning and implementation and motivating the different groups for action.
As part of the participatory planning process with communities, it may be decided to designate
the community as a Baby-Friendly Community (BFC), as implemented in certain countries (e.g.
The Gambia), in order to:
Expand BFHI practices into delivery settings where there are no health facilities.
Strengthen the vital tenth step in ensuring best practices and support for every mother.
The BFHI modules provide model national criteria for BFC guidelines, which minimally would
need be adapted based on the local community situation and on dialogue with the communities.
Criteria for a baby-friendly community could include the following:
Box 17: Criteria for a Baby Friendly Community (based on BFHI modules):
i. Community political and social leadership, both male and female, are committed to making a change
in support of optimal infant and young child feeding.
ii. All health facilities that include maternity services, or local health care provision, are designated Babyfriendly and actively support both early and exclusive breastfeeding (0-6 months).
iii.If home deliveries are the norm, all who assist in deliveries are informed concerning the importance of
delayed cord cutting, immediate skin-to-skin continued for at least 60 minutes, and no prelacteal feeds.
iv.All who assist in facility-based or home deliveries are informed concerning mother-friendly labour and
birthing practices such as encouraging mothers to have companions to provide support, minimizing
invasive procedures unless medically necessary, encouraging women to move about and assume
positions of their choice during labour, etc.
v. Community access to referral site(s) with skilled support for early, exclusive and continued
breastfeeding is available.
vi.Support is available in community for age-appropriate, frequent, and responsive complementary
feeding with continued breastfeeding. This will generally mean that there is availability of
micronutrients or animal based foods and adequate counselling to assist mothers in making
appropriate choices.
vii.
Mother-to-mother support system, or similar, is in place.
viii.
No practices, distributors, shops or services violate the International Code (as applicable) in the
community.
ix.Local government or civil society has convened, created and supports implementation of at least one
political or social normative change and/or additional activity that actively supports mothers and
families to succeed with immediate and exclusive breastfeeding practices (e.g. time-sharing of tasks,
granting authority to transport breastfeeding mothers for referral if needed, identification of
breastfeeding advocates/protectors among community leaders, breastfeeding supportive workplaces,
etc.).
x. Simplified job-aids for assisting and for assessing home deliveries by skilled birth attendants have
been developed and are in use.
See the BFHI modules, Section 1.1 and 1.5, for more details on baby friendly communities.
79
Table 3: Potential Providers of Lay Community IYCF Promotion and Support Services
Providers/
Cadres
Peer/lay
counsellors
Multi-purpose
community
health workers
Community
development
and
extension
workers
Traditional health
practitioners
(TBAs, traditional
healers, herbalist
etc.
Local child
nutrition
advocates
Common Characteristics
Advantages
Disadvantages
Often high
turnover rates
among
volunteers
Part-time work
limits number of
contacts
If purely
voluntary,
incentive may be
low
Broaden support
network, reach
secondary targets
May have special
skills in community
promotion and
education
Require special
training curricula,
materials, and
trainers
(Grandmothers,
religious &
traditional leaders
local media,
teachers, womens
groups, members of
village health
committees,
community or faith
based organizations
Source: Adapted from WellStart Trilogy (1996) and Learning from Large Scale Community Based Breastfeeding
Promotion (2008) [166]. Note that many of these community based providers are also secondary participants in the
communication strategy.
80
Using existing cadres: Community-based IYCF actions should build upon existing structures as
much as possible, rather than creating parallel ones. Many developing countries already have
some form of community-based health and/or nutrition programmes and structures, such as
community-based management of acute malnutrition (CMAM), community IMCI (C-IMCI) and
community case management (CCM) of common childhood illnesses, with different types of
community-based workers and varying types of incentives, from volunteers to paid cadres of the
Government system.
Community health and nutrition programmes are not viewed as a panacea for weak health
systems [169], but as a complementary approach to reach vulnerable groups. Their success
depends on the ability to motivate involvement of CHWs, offer opportunities for personal growth
and accomplishment, retain CHWs after they have been trained, sustain their performance, and
provide supervision, support, and recognition from the health system and community
Creating a new community cadre: In some settings and situations, there may be a need to
create a new community cadre. These may be necessary in case if:
In these cases establishment of IYCF counselling through new community cadres may serve as
an entry point for other elements of community-based health and nutrition care to become
comprehensive community-based mother and child care.
IYCF counsellors also may be part of different outreach activities in target communities.
Community involvement is important during the process of planning and determining the most
appropriate model of IYCF counselling.
Deciding on an appropriate CW or lay counsellor profile for the tasks of IYCF promotion,
counselling and support, including gender, minimum educational level, residence, etc.
Determining how many community workers will be deployed and trained over a specified time
period.
Establishing how, when and where IYCF counselling will be conducted in the community and
the time commitment of the community workers i.e. identifying multiple contact points most
appropriate for IYCF promotion and counselling activities e.g. home visits, at a health post
or the home of the community worker, at the nearest health facility, early childhood care
centres, community-based screening of severe acute malnutrition, growth monitoring and
promotion sessions, immunization sessions, health days, and other community events.
Establishing incentives for the community workers in-kind, cash, transport, materials etc.
Creating a system of mother support groups as appropriate, including establishing targets for
the number of groups to be created over a specified time period.
Establishing how the mother support groups will function, the time commitment of its
members (e.g. how many meetings, group sessions, outreach visits etc.) and how the groups
will be replicated.
81
Defining the types and duration of training to be conducted for the different actors (e.g. IYCF
counsellors and mother support groups) and the materials to be used
Updating the knowledge and skills of health professionals on IYCF to ensure good quality
training and supervision of community cadres.
Planning training sessions for the identified community health workers/lay counsellors,
mother support groups and other available groups or cadres functioning at community level
(e.g. SBAs TBAs (see footnote on p.86), activists, promoters, health committees and other
volunteers) on IYCF.
Designing an effective system for sustained supportive supervision, mentoring and retraining
for the identified cadres and groups, and ensure that supervision is included in annual plans.
Ensuring a strong link with the health system, for example for referral, mentoring, supervision
and data collection.
82
In some programmes, community workers are trained over a six-month period and cover a
wide range of topics. One option, therefore, is to integrate community IYCF counselling within
the overall pre-service training package for community cadres.
In other programmes, the community workers may receive a week-long training on the key
preventive health and nutrition topics, in which IYCF may be covered in a session of a few
hours. The latter may imply that the community worker receives some basic information to
promote good IYCF practices, but the time allotted to the IYCF component of the training may
not be sufficient to build the specific counselling and problem solving skills necessary to
provide practical support to mothers. This will then mean that the community worker has to
refer the mother and infant to the nearest health facility if there is a feeding problem if at all
the training has provided them with the skills to assess feeding practices properly. In such
contexts advocacy is needed to add a training programme that builds the IYCF counselling,
problem solving, group facilitation and communication skills of these community workers.
Where there are no pre-existing community workers, the IYCF counselling training can be
provided as a stand-alone package to new community workers. In this case the IYCF
programme may serve as an entry-point for other community based health and nutrition
activities.
The new UNICEF Community IYCF Counselling Package (see Resources Annex 1-8) adapted to
the local context, is recommended for both initial and in-service training of community cadres.
Three-day and five-day sample schedules, as well as seven-day training in a modular approach
are options outlined in the package. An option for a three-day sessions with sessions tailored to
the context of SAM is also outlined. The package covers breastfeeding, complementary feeding,
HIV and infant feeding (based on the 2010 WHO guidelines), infant feeding in the context of
emergencies and SAM and maternal nutrition. It uses interactive adult learning techniques
particularly suited to people of low literacy and includes a set of 28 counselling cards. The
training methodology has been developed and tested over many years and represents
good practice in terms of effective skills building and learning new knowledge. The
package also contains a planning and adaptation guide, with detailed checklists on the adaptation
process. It also outlines the steps to adapt the graphics, using photographs, PhotoShop and
InDesign software to reproduce the same high-quality graphics for different settings.
Integration of IYCF into CMAM: Facilitator's Guide (IASC/IFE/ENN 2009) is a short training manual (1.5 days) to train
health care personnel and community health workers as trainers/facilitators in integrating recommended infant and young
child feeding (IYCF) practices within CMAM.
83
2. Facilitator guide
3. Training aids
4. Participant materials
The planning of the IYCF training using the training component of the Community IYCF
Counselling Package is covered in detail in the introduction to the Facilitator Guide of the
package.
84
counselling by health facility and community-based workers, community group sessions and
information sharing through traditional channels and local media. Repeated contacts and
messages help to reinforce both knowledge and practice.
It may be helpful for community workers to set specific targets for activities, either as individuals
or as a group: e.g. for the expected pregnant and lactating women there would be in the
community who need to be followed up, or for the number of group sessions to be conducted, the
number of support groups to be created, or for the number of IYCF contacts to be made each
month at growth monitoring sessions, community meetings etc. These targets can be discussed
and set during the training and reinforced and followed up during mentoring and supervision.
Setting targets gives a concrete structure and focus to the activities and helps in monitoring
performance.
Linkages
Community-based IYCF support and counselling needs to be embedded in a larger context of
communication activities that disseminate consistent and relevant information to mothers, other
caregivers, as well as their support network, repeatedly and frequently. At the same time, the
community-based programme needs to be closely linked to health system actions and impart the
same messages on optimal practices and behaviours. The health system will often be involved in
training and supervising the community cadres, but NGOs may also be the main facilitators. In
both cases harmonization and consistency are essential. There should be a strong system of bidirectional referral: health workers should link mothers with lay counsellors or CWs and mother
support groups for ongoing support and counselling on infant feeding; and the community cadres
and groups should ensure that pregnant and lactating women attend consultations in health
facilities.
A growing number of countries are initiating and expanding community based programmes for
the management of severe and/or moderate acute malnutrition (generally referred to as CMAM).
Many of these programmes, however, focus on screening and home treatment of malnourished
children with little attention to counselling on feeding of the child to prevent future episodes of
SAM and promote good growth. The creation of new CMAM programmes presents a good
opportunity for IYCF counselling and support actions to be included from the outset. In
established CMAM programmes, IYCF content may be integrated in refresher training for existing
community cadres and added to training for new community workers as part of the scale up
process using the two-day integration module developed for the Nutrition Cluster [170] or the
UNICEF community IYCF package.
Similarly, more and more countries are implementing community case management (CCM)
programmes for malaria, diarrhoea and pneumonia. The IYCF counselling training can be
promoted as an integral module in a new CCM programme or can be provided later on to trained
workers or during refresher training. Advocacy for integration should highlight the fact that optimal
IYCF practices have a major impact on diarrhoea and pneumonia mortality and a community
based IYCF counselling programme could significantly enhance the potential for results of the
CCM programme in terms of reducing mortality from these diseases.
Another main programmatic success factor that has emerged from multiple reviews [171] is the
involvement of local NGOs, who often provided excellent facilitators as well as culture-relevant
training. They are usually accountable to the community, which facilitates sustainability to a great
extent.
85
support to other women in an atmosphere of trust and respect. Similarly, mothers who have
successfully fed their children from 6-23 months may model optimal complementary feeding
practices in the group. Mother-to-mother support is available in the mothers own community and
provides an essential complement to the health care system. The groups should aim to create a
supportive and safe space for mothers. Mother support group members may gather together at
regular meetings, they may provide individual support to mothers, they may facilitate larger
community events, may provide group education at health facilities or during outreach visits or
any other activities as needed.
A mother-to-mother support group is initiated and facilitated by a mother who facilitates the
group. She may have received training, but her primary qualification is that she is a mother with
1
breastfeeding experience . At the meetings organized by the mother support group, new, as well
as experienced mothers, share information and are encouraged to voice their doubts and
concerns. A mothers support group may also be facilitated by a health care provider, a
community health worker or someone who is considered an expert in a certain field. The
facilitator may not be a mother or belong to the same peer group. Mothers support groups can
take place in the context of clubs formed for the purpose of credit, arts/crafts, gardens, sewing,
etc. In some mothers support groups, new, as well as experienced mothers, share information
and are encouraged to voice their doubts and concerns; in others, information is given via talks or
lectures.
An example of mother support is Positive Deviance strategies which can be used in a simple way in all mother to
mother support groups. Positive Deviance is a strength-based or asset-based approach based on the belief that in
every community there are certain individuals (Positive Deviants) whose special, or uncommon, practices and
behaviours enable them to find better ways to prevent malnutrition than their neighbours who share the same resources
and face the same risks. Through a dynamic process called the Positive Deviance Inquiry (PDI), program staff invites
community members to discover the unique practices that contribute to a better nutritional outcome in the child. The
program staff and community members then design an intervention to enable families with malnourished children to learn
and practice these and other beneficial behaviours. CORE has developed a manual on positive deviance for reducing
malnutrition (see Resources), which may be adapted (and simplified) for use in countries. NB Positive Deviance
approaches have only been applied in small-scale NGO supported projects thus far.
86
Training
Those involved in leading support groups should be oriented on the essentials of good
breastfeeding and complementary feeding practices as well as on counselling and
communication skills and group facilitation dynamics. Community workers may be mother support
1
87
group leaders. The Community IYCF Counselling Package training includes sessions on how to
convene and facilitate mother support groups. Once groups are convened, the CW, supported by
health providers or NGO staff if required, can organize a series of group meetings to convey the
essentials of breastfeeding, complementary feeding and maternal nutrition and how to promote
and communicate and to support mothers. Abbreviated sessions and materials from the UNICEF
generic IYCF counselling package can be used for these sessions e.g. some of the counselling
cards. These materials need to be selected and prepared for use by the CWs and a plan on how
to use them to conduct the orientation of the groups needs to be provided. The initial sessions
need to be monitored and supported by the CWs supervisors.
Some programmes, such as the one in Sierra Leone (see case study in Box 16 above), have
undertaken a full training programme on IYCF and BCC through a three-day training workshop
for the mother support group members. This was done in absence of a community IYCF
counselling training and cadre of IYCF counsellors, but approach is unlikely to be possible or
realistic at scale in many countries.
Feedback to community workers on their activities, the data they collect and their performance is
essential to further building skills, solving problems and to overall programme improvements.
Monitoring and Evaluation (M&E)
A small set of clearly articulated indicators helps keep community IYCF promotion and support
88
focused on the essentials and provides data for assessing progress and informing programme
strategies. Monitoring whether defined targets for activities were met during a certain period is
1
helpful to assess performance of the CWs and mother support groups . Examples of targets
could include:
% of targeted pregnant and lactating women in the community who were counselled at least
once.
% of target mothers attending a mother support group meeting (per time period).
% of target contact points (e.g. GMP or MUAC screening session, outreach visit by clinic, well
child/immunization session at clinic, health post, community meeting, etc.) at which IYCF
counselling provided (per time period).
Key basic principles for the use of information for action include the requirements to: only collect
data that will be used; maximize the use of data at the level they are collected; and to collect the
minimum, feasible amount of data required to inform and improve decisions leading to action.
Well-designed surveys and costs studies will enable programme managers to determine with
greater confidence what works and at what cost. This information is valuable for future
program planning and implementation as well as evidence-based advocacy.
These are addressed in more detail in Appendix 14: Package of supervisory tools in the Planning and Adaptation Guide
of the Community IYCF Counselling Package.
89
3.4 Communication
Overview of section for Communication on IYCF:
3.4.1 Establishment of a national coordination mechanism for communication aspects of the
national IYCF strategy
3.4.2 Assessing and analysing the communication situation, including formative research
3.4.3 Development of a communication strategy and operational plan
3.4.4 Design of messages and materials and selection of channels
3.4.5 Implementation of the communication plan
3.4.6 Monitoring interim communication outcomes and evaluating impact on behaviours
Introduction
This section of the Programme Guidance provides general guidance on approaches to designing
1
and implementing an evidence and results-based communication strategy on IYCF and contains
six action areas of a Triple-A type process. Communication should be viewed broadly: not as only
a community-based action, or only a massmedia campaign, but as a comprehensive national
strategy and set of actions with a broad stakeholder base and participation, and the use of
multiple communication channels.
Box 19: Communication for Improved
Communication for IYCF, an essential contributor
IYCF Practices:
to large-scale behavioural and social change,
Policy dialogue and advocacy to build
should be an intrinsic element of any national Child
support for IYCF & the communication
Survival/Health and Nutrition programme.
strategy.
UNICEF uses the term Communication for Development (C4D) but in this Guidance document the generic term
communication is used.
90
The boxes below summarize some of the key dos and donts of communication on
breastfeeding based on lessons learned (and can be applied to communication on
complementary feeding as well.)
Dos:
1. Use evidence from KAP studies
and barrier analysis to design
strategies (including
messages).
2. Emphasize the risks of artificial
or mixed feeding as well as
benefits of breastfeeding.
3. Use multiple channels with
emphasis on inter-personal
communication and
community-based approaches.
4. Ensure continuous
communication at multiple
levels.
Donts:
1. Use generic messages (e.g. breast is
best or breastfeed exclusively for 6
months or breastfed baby = healthy
baby) with no discussion of WHY and no
context.
2. Focus only on the benefits of BF with no
mention of risks of sub-optimal feeding
practices.
3. Rely heavily on information, education,
communication (e.g., posters, slogans,
mass media).
4. Expect a campaign approach to be
sufficient on its own (e.g., World
Breastfeeding Week).
91
Box 20:
In Ghana one problem that was encountered
was breastfeeding on the run. At each feed
mothers gave a little bit of milk from both
breasts, so children were not suckling enough
to get the rich hind milk. Because of this,
mothers were tempted to give other foods
since they thought their babies were
hungryand they were! The standard
message to give the breast at least 10 times
a day was thus inappropriate for Ghana since
mothers were already giving the breast as
much as 20 times a day.
Linkages Ghana
The situation assessment may be conducted as a single process to inform the development of the community and
communication components of the IYCF programme, as well as the counselling tools for health providers.
92
vi.
vii.
viii.
ix.
The formative research will likely reveal a number of myths and beliefs about infant feeding,
some of which are included in Box 21. Many of these will need to be countered in the
communication messages.
Box 21: Common Beliefs about Infant Feeding That Are Not True
On breastmilk:
Colostrum is dirty.
Colostrum is yellow because it has been in the breast for too long and has gone bad.
A baby should not be suckled until the white milk comes in.
Most women cannot produce enough milk, and therefore need to feed the baby other foods/milk
Feeding other foods, milk and water together with breastmilk in the first six months is necessary and
is not a problem.
Milk that accumulates when the mother is separated from her baby should not be given to the baby
Giving water, other liquids and milks in addition to breastmilk is fine in industrialized or middle
income countries or in wealthier families with safe water sources and good sanitation and hygiene
facilities and will not cause diarrhea.
On formula:
Babies in industrialized or middle income countries can safely be fed water or formula together with
breastmilk as the risks of contamination and diarrhea are minimal.
On the mothers practices
Mothers cannot eat or drink certain foods or liquids during breastfeeding and can only breastfeed if
they have a perfect diet.
A mother who is malnourished cannot produce enough milk and cannot breastfeed.
A mother who is breastfeeding cannot have sex as the milk will go bad; therefore she should stop.
breastfeeding soon so that sexual relations can resume.
Determining whose behaviours related to IYCF are the focus should be done to the extent
possible before the formative research begins. Some groups, such as fathers and mothers-in-law,
should be included in the formative research; others such as employers may also emerge as
important. The findings may indicate that different strategies or approaches may be needed for
different groups.
93
Behavioural analysis: Using the formative research findings, behavioural analysis will
enable the incentives and barriers to breastfeeding will be identified. This guides the
1
development of the communication strategy, SMART programme objectives and activities.
This implies full review and discussion of the data to understand the types of behaviours, the
reasons and motivators for them, the facilitating factors and barriers and the social, cultural,
gender, economic and political context in which they take place. For example, is it pride in a
child who is growing well and not getting diarrhea that may motivate a caregiver to not give
water or other liquids and foods before 6 months? Or is it a better understanding of risks of
mixed feeding and artificial feeding? Or how the prevailing social norm in the community
influences them?
Channel analysis examines the range of available communication channels and how they
are accessed and used by intended participant groups. The analysis phase determines which
channels are likely to be most effective in reaching and influencing the different participant
groups, and which ones less so.
94
It is also important to design the monitoring system for the implementation of the communication
actions from the outset - not later on once implementation has already started - identifying how
information will be collected, by whom, how often, with which resources and how it will be
compiled and used.
See Resources Annex 1-9 for some relevant resources and tools for communication planning and
1
some examples of country communication strategies .
Outcome objectives for the communication strategy focus on what can be achieved entirely
through communication, addressing behavioural, social change and advocacy objectives.
Outcome objectives for an IYCF programme rely on a broader range of strategies that
includes communication.
A communication objective for behaviour and social change is SMART and indicates who-will-dowhat.
i. Behavioural objectives should be defined for primary participant groups (e.g. mothers,
fathers, grandmothers); for example
To increase the proportion of mothers with infants less than six months who do not give
water along with breastmilk.
At least 60 per cent of women with infants less than 2 years report at least one contact
with a mother support group.
ii. Social change objectives for secondary participants (e.g. health providers, community
workers, religious leaders, etc.), for example:
Trained health providers/CHWs will develop plans for conducting communication
sessions on IYCF and implement at least 70% of planned sessions.
Trained health providers/CHWs use at least 3 of 4 main communication skills see box
22 below).
At least 20% of religious leaders are sensitized and promote priority IYCF practices
during their regular and special prayers and ceremonies.
iii. Advocacy objectives for tertiary participant groups (e.g. policy and decision makers,
Government authorities). For example:
50% of local government authorities (all directors and programme managers) and
development partners are sensitized about the National IYCF Strategy and initiate
allocation of resources for implementing relevant sections of the action plan.
Reporters and gatekeepers from 50% of national media outlets (print, broadcast, radio
and web) producing increased coverage on IYCF practices and impact on child mortality,
nutrition, health and development.
See the section on Monitoring and evaluation of the effect of communication on behaviour in this
chapter for more information on monitoring of the achievement of the communication objectives
and review and evaluation of the outcomes.
1
Including: Communication for development in IYCF: Improving exclusive breast feeding practices; Using
Communication for Development in ACSD Programmes (under development, 2010) and Behaviour Change
Communication in Emergencies: A Toolkit (UNICEF 2006), which contains practical tools for developing a communication
strategy which can be applied to non-emergency situations as well. Facts for Life (UNICEF 2010) also includes basic
information on breastfeeding and may be useful.
95
3.Involves and inspires members in friendly debate and dialogue to express opinions,
discuss problems/issues, make decisions and agree on collective actions:
Manages group discussion, problem solving and conflict resolution.
Asks open-ended questions to check for understanding
Uses local examples, anecdotes, humour (as appropriate), and engages members to share own
stories to illustrate/explain subject or issue and to reflect on their feeling and actions (touches their
hearts and not just their minds)
Invites feedback, ideas, comments and suggestions
Assists in examining consequences of each option discussed
If not from community, trains and involves local mobilizers/animators to facilitate
4.Explains subject matter and answers questions clearly, credibly and with confidence
Encourages both girls and boys, women and men, marginalized and disabled to participate and
avail of opportunity to benefit
Summarizes points of discussion and actions
96
Levels
INDIVIDUAL/
Primary
participants
HOUSEHOLD
Secondary participants
COMMUNITY
HEALTH FACILITY
SUB-NATIONAL
(STATE, DISTRICT)
NATIONAL
Coordinating & Harmonizing Across Levels to Effect Behaviour and Social Change
97
1.
However, it is emphasized that this list of correct behaviours should not be seen as the exact
messages to be reflected in communication materials. They need to be adapted for use with the
different participant groups
Often, planners get caught up in what is medically correct, and recommend an ideal behaviour
without examining whether it is feasible. Recommending a long list of behaviours or complex
behaviours reduces the credibility of the advice and makes it seem impossible to do. One result of
analysis is to make sure messages promote feasible behaviours and are linked with other activities
that help to improve feasibility of the recommended behaviours and practices. The analysis needs to
address the requirements to practice each desired behaviour (time, resources, skills, products), the
extent to which people are already engaging in it, its acceptability to the various participant groups,
the short and long term benefits, and the immediate and long term consequences of NOT engaging in
the desired practices. To adopt and maintain the new practice, women need to be surrounded by a
1
These ideal behaviours are derived from WHO recommendations on optimal practices. They may also be found in Facts for
Life (Resources Annex 1-9).
98
supportive community that also believes in the value of the new practice. An enabling environment
needs to be created that may include a reduction in workload, support from family members, correct
and practical advice from health workers and counselling support to clarify misconceptions about
breastfeeding. Therefore additional activities need to be conducted to make the messages on
behaviours feasible to implement based on the local context, such as conducive health facility and
workplace policies and practices, support services, helplines etc.
Box 25: Examples of feasibility considerations and contextualization of breastfeeding messages
The advice to women who must return to work or will be separated from their infant during EBF months
is often to express breastmilk and feed it to the baby from a cup. But is this even feasible? Behaviour
analysis can put a microscope on the behaviours to express and store breastmilk. What are milk
expression techniques? How long does it take to express enough milk for a feeding? Does a working
mother have adequate time and place to express? How should she store the milk? How long will the
milk last without refrigeration? What are recommended feeding techniques (cup or bottle) and are they
available? What does the community think about expressing breastmilk is it acceptable, or does the
prevailing social norm not favour expressing? Focus group discussions with women who have
expressed milk and behaviour observations of expressing, storage and feeding are important in making
messages for working women.
In Ghana one problem that was encountered was breastfeeding on the run. At each feed mothers gave
a little bit of milk from both breasts, so children were not suckling enough to get the rich hind milk.
Because of this, mothers were tempted to give other foods since they thought their babies were
hungryand they were! The standard message to give the breast at least 10 times a day was thus
inappropriate for Ghana since mothers were already giving the breast as much as 20 times a day.
1
Trials of Improved Practices (TIPS) is one approach that can be used to test the feasibility and
acceptability of feeding recommendations among the participant groups, including health workers.
TIPS is a formative research technique used by program planners to pretest the actual practices that
a program will promote. (See Resources Annex 1-3 for more tools for formative research.)
The procedure for TIPs consists of a series of visits in which the interviewer and the participant analyze current practices,
discuss what could be improved, and together reach an agreement on one or a few solutions to try over a trial period; and then
assess the trial experience together at the end of the trial period. The process leads to identification of ways to gauge the
acceptability of new practices and learn how to promote and support them through program interventions.
99
It is likely that the tendency to select these types of generic messages may be due to the ease of
rapidly producing posters, radio spots etc. However, this approach may result in little more than
providing visibility for the producer of the poster or spot, decorating the walls of clinics or allowing the
programme manager to report that an action to promote breastfeeding has been undertaken.
Ensuring that the messages resonate with the target communities, are doable and feasible and
actually motivate behavior change involves the process of formative research, pre-testing and
ongoing monitoring and review that are described in this chapter.
It is vital to encourage debate and discussion so that communities can propose their own solutions,
messages and communication approaches that address the barriers to optimal feeding. Using
participatory communication methods such as group meetings with primary caregivers, peer
educators and one to-one counselling is helpful in determining meaningful infant and child health
related messages that they will understand. In addition, it is important to focus on a few messages
only: those that are vital to influencing current practices in the country.
The priority messages that are selected should be:
Exclusive breastfeeding is a straight-forward health issue. The real issue with formula feeding and mixed
feeding is the proven higher morbidity and mortality. Therefore, the risks of formula feeding or mixed
feeding need to be properly and correctly explained and communicated to all mothers, to ensure that the
mother and her family have all the necessary information to make informed decisions.
If messages are designed only around the "benefits of breastfeeding," in some societies, particularly
where breastfeeding is not the norm, they may lead to the implication that formula is normal and
adequate and breastfeeding (the best way to feed your baby) is something ideal or "extra". People
are usually satisfied with normal behaviours, while ideal behaviours are perceived to be unattainable.
Thus, instead of focusing only on the "benefits of breastfeeding," messages should also address the
risks of not breastfeeding, or the risks of mixed feeding (such as the risks of adding water, etc.
depending on the local context).
Because breastfeeding is the biological norm, instead of only having messages stating breastfed babies
are healthier, messages highlighting that artificially-fed babies are ill more often and more seriously
should also be included.
On mixed feeding, rather than highlighting that mothers should exclusively breastfeed your baby,
messages could also emphasize that adding water, tea, milk or food to breastfeeding makes your baby
sick and thin.
Instead of mentioning that breastfeeding prevents cancer, diabetes and obesity, messages should
highlight that non-breastfed infants have a higher risk of chronic conditions later in life compared to
breastfed infants.
100
In addition to messages around the benefits of breastfeeding and optimal breastfeeding practices,
countries could also develop messages around the risks of artificial feeding or sub-optimal
breastfeeding practices. All messages need to be pre-tested.
Some advertisements regarding the use of BMS and messages harmful to breastfeeding may have to
be countered with messages that reinforce the benefits of breastfeeding and highlight the risks of
artificial feeding.
(See Resources Annex 1-9 for some examples of key messages and communication on exclusive
breastfeeding and complementary feeding, including those in the flagship Facts for Life publication.)
101
Importance of using multiple channels: Evidence shows that successful efforts use multiple
channels to reach priority audiences with age- and context-specific messages on particular
behaviours. They need to reach the primary audience frequently enough to stimulate lasting
behavioural change. The messages should be regularly delivered and reinforced through the multiple
channels, and should be consistent with the messages conveyed by health providers and community
cadres.
Pre-testing
Pre-testing is an important step which helps to ensure that the strategy will ensure achievement of
expected results for improving IYCF.
Messages and the methods and channels to deliver the messages (see the section below on channel
analysis) should be pre-tested with the representation of all the intended participant groups. The use
of the identified channels should also be pre-tested this may be done through implementation of the
strategy in demonstration areas - to see which channels are most effective and appropriate in
reaching the different participant groups.
102
integrated within the overall national IYCF strategy and plan and the local microplans. Some
elements will need to be included in the action plans of different sectors, for example, the
communication research, monitoring and evaluation component and the media aspects. Opportunities
for synergy amongst the service delivery system and the community level should be maximized. For
example, if in-service training for health workers, lay counsellors or community health workers on
IYCF counselling is planned, sessions on communication approaches and skills can be added.
Synergies with other related programmes such as IMCI, PMTCT or CMAM, should also be explored
to add communication skills training and define entry points for communication in IYCF.
Inputs/Outputs
Behavioural monitoring
Impact
Supply
Train
Changes in
Results of communication activities
Reach
Inform
health,
nutrition,
survival
Partners, Stakeholders,
Health providers,
Community, Families,
Parents
103
Monitoring
Building a monitoring system to track performance of the communication intervention is essential for
communication managers. The monitoring system will be able track input indicators to measure the
quantity, quality and timeliness of resources provided, for example, funding, human resources,
communication materials or technical support. It will also track output indicators to measure quantity,
quality and timeliness of products or services provided through use of the inputs. They will measure
immediate results, for example the number of people exposed to a message or participating in
community action. Routine monitoring may also measure some of the intermediate outcomes of the
communication activities, for example, behavioural outcomes in the primary participants, secondary
participants use of newly acquired communication skills and tertiary participants allocation of
resources etc.
If routine monitoring is not set up to collect this type of data on intermediate outcomes, a mid-term
review may be needed as the major period evaluations may be too infrequent to ensure course
correction if intermediate outcomes are not being achieved. For example, without M&E addressing
intermediate outcomes, significant resources may be invested in training community health workers
on communication skills but it will not be possible to determine if the skills are being applied. In case
the skills are not being applied, these resources are not in fact being used optimally.
It is important not to confuse how the programme is doing with what is being done. The what can
be a simple tally of activities, such as number of training sessions for health workers, number of visits
made by representatives of mother support groups, number of meetings held with policy-makers. The
measure that matters is the actual change that results from those training sessions, visits and
meetings. For this reason, a communication strategy can widen the focus of M&E beyond traditional
indicators of outcome and impact, such as reach of media and information, increased knowledge and
awareness, improved and new skills, changes in individual behaviour and practices, increased
delivery and demand for products and services, to also include additional indicators that acknowledge
individual and community empowerment, human rights and social, systems and policy change in the
long-term, for example:
Social norms and social processes (e.g. social support for involvement of fathers in child care;
participatory approach to the definition of most needed community services in support of IYCF;
exposure in the media to positive images and stories on good IYCF practices).
Power within different levels of society (e.g. number of women who recognize the importance
of optimal IYCF and feel entitled to ask questions and demand services and support that would
improve practices and behaviours; number of households where the fathers of children are
supportive of and help enable optimal feeding).
Policies, systems and strategies (e.g., workplace policies that provide support and resources
for women who breastfeed, hospital policies supportive of successful breastfeeding, national
legislation on marketing of BMS that is enforced effectively, strategies to provide appropriate
complementary foods to the most vulnerable children, district plans etc.).
Social behaviours (e.g., proportion of fathers and grandmothers who do not insist on giving
formula or water to infants <6m, number of district directors of health allocate adequate human,
material and financial resources to implement district-level IYCF communication activities).
It is also important to obtain information on the coverage of communication activities for IYCF. Since
the use of multiple channels for communication is promoted, monitoring of coverage will need to be a
composite of the channels used in a country. Coverage monitoring could therefore assess:
The coverage (# & % of health facilities) that conduct group sessions on IYCF and estimated
numbers of people reached in these sessions.
104
The # and % of districts with community based BCC activities and estimated numbers of people
reached.
The number of the people reached through mass media messages.
The same principle could be applied to other channels used in the local context, e.g. religious
institutions, etc.
Evaluation
Evaluation provides information on whether the strategy is generating appropriate behaviour and
social change results. Impact evaluations should be designed around the outcome indicators on IYCF
knowledge, attitudes and practices of the various participant groups collected in the formative
research. Trends in the standard programme impact indicators such as exclusive and continued
breastfeeding and minimum acceptable diet in children aged 6-23 months should be analysed.
Table 4 gives examples of indicators that can be used for the different levels in the chain of results for
communication on IYCF (see also the table of general IYCF indicators national, health system and
community levels in Chapter 2.7)
105
% of mothers who can correctly name at least 6 of the 12 optimal breastfeeding practices (as per Box 19)
% of lactating women who do not give water or other fluids/foods to infants
% of elder women who tell new mothers that babies dont need water
% of lactating women who breastfeed on demand including during the night
% of mothers who can correctly state the age of introduction of complementary foods
106
The Global Strategy for Infant and Young Child Feeding (WHO/UNICEF 2003) highlights the
difficult circumstances in which infants and young children and their families require special attention
regarding feeding. These include exposure to HIV, emergencies, severe malnutrition, low birth weight
and other social circumstances such as orphans and children in foster care, and children born to
adolescent mothers, mothers suffering from physical or mental disabilities, drug- or alcoholdependence, or mothers who are imprisoned or part of disadvantaged or otherwise marginalized
populations.
This guidance will focus on HIV and emergencies, as these are areas of IYCF that require specific
approaches to programming globally. However, national programs should ensure that the other
difficult circumstances, specific to county situation, are also adequately addressed and provisions
1
made for appropriate feeding of the vulnerable children facing these circumstances .
Guidance for feeding of severely malnourished infants is available in the Infant Feeding in Emergencies Module 2 V.1.1
(IFE Core Group 2003); guidance on feeding low birth weight babies and babies who are orphaned or who cannot breastfeed
are provided in the various training modules on breastfeeding and IYCF (See Resources Annex 1-11 for more resources and
tools on IYCF in Emergencies).
107
sustainable and safe) conditions were in place to replacement feed. Where AFASS criteria were not
met, the recommendation was to continue breastfeeding.
Since then, evidence that antiretroviral (ARV) interventions to either the HIV-infected mother or HIVexposed infant can significantly reduce the risk of postnatal transmission of HIV through
breastfeeding has been reported [177]. The evidence shows that administering anti-retroviral
treatment (ART) to all HIV+ mothers with CD-4 counts <350 throughout the breastfeeding period
[178] or providing extended anti-retroviral prophylaxis to infants born to HIV-positive women with CD4 counts >350, along with prophylaxis for the mother, can significantly reduce post-natal transmission
[179]. With provision of ARVs, breastfeeding is made dramatically safer and the balance of risks
between breastfeeding and replacement feeding is fundamentally changed. The mothers own health
is also protected. This new evidence fundamentally transforms the landscape in which decisions on
infant feeding practices are made by individual mothers, national health authorities and international
development partners.
This evidence is the basis for the 2009/2010 WHO recommendations on PMTCT and on infant
feeding in the context of HIV. The recommendations highlight that the risk of mother to child
transmission of HIV can be reduced to less than 5% in breastfeeding populations (from a background
risk of around 35%) and to less than 2% in non-breastfeeding populations (from a background risk of
25%). In addition, the most recent studies show that the risk of transmission in a breastfed infant can
be reduced to less than 1% in the first 6 months when ARVs are provided.
Latest UN Guidance
In November 2009, WHO released the revised Principles and
Recommendations on HIV and Infant Feeding (2009) as a Rapid
Advice document. This preceded the more detailed joint publication,
Guidelines on HIV and Infant Feeding 2010 [180], which includes the
principles and recommendations as well as a summary of the evidence.
These HIV and infant feeding recommendations are consistent with new
WHO recommendations on PMTCT [181] (Resources Annex 1-10).
In summary, the latest UN guidance is based on the following principle:
National infant feeding recommendations: National or sub-national health
authorities should select and make a decision on which one of two
feeding options should be supported by the health system as the
strategy that will most likely give infants the greatest chance of HIV-free
survival:
Following this policy decision, the health services should counsel and support all mothers known to
be HIV-infected on the selected option. This decision should be based on international
recommendations and consideration of the socio-economic and cultural contexts of the populations
served by Maternal and Child Health services, the availability and quality of health services, the local
epidemiology including HIV prevalence among pregnant women and main causes of infant and child
mortality and maternal and child under-nutrition. Countries with high infant mortality rates are also
likely to have a high risk of death due to lack of breastfeeding and therefore should carefully consider
this balance of risks versus HIV transmission through safer breastfeeding with ARVs.
The revised WHO PMTCT recommendations [180] refer to two key approaches:
1. Treatment: lifelong antiretroviral therapy (ART) for HIV + women in need to treatment for her own
health as per the criteria, while the infant receives prophylaxis for the first six weeks of life only.
108
2. Two ARV prophylaxis options are recommended for women who are not on lifelong ART for their
own health and breastfeed (countries select either option A or option B as their national protocol):
Option A: The woman receives ARV prophylaxis during pregnancy, delivery and 7 days postpartum, and the infant receives daily ARV prophylaxis from birth until one week after all exposure
to breastfeeding has ended or
Option B: The woman receives a three-drug ARV prophylaxis regimen during pregnancy, and
continuing through the end of the breastfeeding period, while the infant receives prophylaxis for
the first six weeks of life only.
ARV prophylaxis for the mother can start as early as 14 weeks of gestation, or as soon as possible
when women present later in pregnancy, or during labour and delivery.
Infant feeding practices in countries where the policy is breastfeeding + ARVs:
Mothers known to be HIV-infected (and whose infants are HIV uninfected or of unknown HIV status)
should exclusively breastfeed their infants for the first six months of life, introduce appropriate
complementary foods thereafter, and continue breastfeeding for the first 12 months of life.
Breastfeeding should then only stop once a nutritionally adequate and safe diet without breast-milk
can be provided, and ARV prophylaxis should continue to be provided as long as the child is
breastfed.
Conditions needed for safe replacement feeding:
Mothers known to be HIV-infected should only
give commercial infant formula milk as a
replacement feed to their HIV uninfected infants or
infants who are of unknown HIV status, when
specific conditions are met (see Box 27).
Infants known to be HIV-infected:
If infants and young children are known to be
already HIV-infected, mothers are strongly
encouraged to exclusively breastfeed for the first
six months of life, introducing appropriate
complementary foods thereafter, and continue
breastfeeding as per the recommendations for the
general population (up to two years of age or
beyond).
c)
d)
e)
f)
109
messages. In addition, it should be noted that in some settings AFASS criteria have tended to be
used as points and advice for counselling, not as criteria for whether a woman should choose
replacement feeding or not. This may be especially true in programmes which provide free BMS.
These programmes do not use the AFASS criteria as conditions to provide replacement milks or not,
and they do not assure full compliance with all of the AFASS criteria, such as acceptability, safety,
feasibility etc.).
Shift in focus of counselling: In conjunction with the known benefits of breastfeeding to reduce
mortality from other causes, in many settings an approach that strongly recommends the option of
breastfeeding plus ARVs as the standard of care can be justified: information about options should be
made available but services would principally support the one approach. Similarly, a country which
chooses replacement feeding as its recommendation should still provide information and counselling
on breastfeeding plus ARVs and support women who opt out of replacement feeding. However,
individual rights should not be forfeited in the course of public health approaches. Recommending a
single option within a national health framework does not remove the need for skilled counselling and
support to be available to pregnant women and mothers. The nature and content of counselling and
support that are required will shift away from the current practices of counselling on the balance of
risks and the different options available, and then helping a mother to make an informed choice.
Rather, the counselling will focus on conveying the policy the national health authorities have decided
to adopt and how to feed the baby according to these guidelines. The counsellors should be able to
provide additional information on the alternative options if the mother asks (Key Principle 5 of the
WHO guidelines). This may be particularly relevant in countries with high coverage of PMTCT
services where mothers have already been exposed to counselling and information directed towards
counselling on choice.
Duration of breastfeeding: The 2010 Guidelines propose (Recommendation 2) that, in light of the
effectiveness of ARV interventions, continued breastfeeding by HIV-infected mothers until the infant is
12 months of age capitalizes on the maximum benefit of breastfeeding to improve the infants chance
of survival while reducing the risk of HIV transmission. This is in contrast to the 2006 recommendation
to stop breastfeeding after 6 months if AFASS conditions are met. In the presence of ARV
interventions, being able to breastfeed to 12 months avoids many of the complexities associated with
stopping breastfeeding and providing a safe and adequate diet without breastmilk to infants 6-12
months of age. It is not currently possible to recommend, without any qualification, that all HIVinfected mothers breastfeed beyond 12 months to 24 months, unless there were no other options.
Mixed feeding: Earlier evidence on HIV transmission through breastfeeding [182], highlights that
exclusive breastfeeding for up to six months is associated with a three to four fold decreased risk of
transmission of HIV compared to non-exclusive breastfeeding (mixed feeding). It is believed that
mixed feeding in the first six months carries a greater risk of transmission because the other liquids
and foods given to the baby alongside the breastmilk can damage the already delicate and
permeable intestinal wall of the infant, allowing the virus to be transmitted more easily. Mixed feeding
also poses the same risks of contamination and diarrhoea as artificial feeding, diminishing the
chances of survival. Unfortunately mixed feeding is still the norm for many infants less than six
months old in many countries with high HIV prevalence. Thus HIV transmission through breastfeeding
can be reduced if HIV-positive women breastfeed exclusively for six months rather than practice
mixed feeding. With the new recommendations, it is postulated that an HIV-infected woman who
takes ARVs and mix-feeds may still have a higher rate of transmission than a mother who exclusively
breastfeeds and takes ARVs: the transmission risk is shifted downwards for all breastfeeding modes
but the pattern of increased risk remains for the mixed-fed infants. Thus continued emphasis needs to
be placed on discouraging mixed feeding in the first six months.
Recommendations for situations when there are no ARVs: Every effort should be made to
accelerate access to ARVs for both maternal health and also prevention of HIV transmission to
infants. While ARV interventions are being scaled up, national authorities should not be deterred from
recommending that HIV-infected mothers breastfeed as the most appropriate infant feeding practice
in their setting, even when ARVs are not available. An implementation and communication challenge
110
will be to prevent the misconception that HIV-infected mothers should only breastfeed if they have
ARVs. An additional Principle (Key Principle 4, absent from the 2009 Rapid Advice) has been added
to the 2010 WHO guidelines which states:
Even when ARVs are not available, breastfeeding may still provide infants born to HIV-infected
mothers with a greater chance of HIV-free survival. Mothers should be counselled to exclusively
breastfeed in the first six months of life and continue breastfeeding thereafter unless
environmental and social circumstances are safe for, and supportive of replacement feeding.
111
Actions required to strengthen the Code implementation and enforcement in settings with high HIV
prevalence (in addition to the actions in the section on the Code above):
Ensure that the HIV pandemic is not being used to reintroduce donations of BMS to the
health care system. Many Health Ministries adopted policies banning the distribution of free and
low-cost supplies of BMS through health facilities by the commercial sector. These policies should
continue to be respected. Where the government decides to make free or subsidised BMS available
to HIV positive mothers, procurement should be encouraged in a transparent manner through
tendering on the international or local market, avoiding a privileged relationship which will promote
the image and products of one particular company. As specified in the Code once procured, the
BMS should be supplied for as long as the child needs them.
There are many reasons why a government should not enter into a special "partnership" with any
one company, but rather should procure supplies of BMS through public tender:
This avoids dependency on "donated" or "low-cost" supplies which companies claim are given
for humanitarian purposes. Supplies should not be subject to the goodwill of a donor or used as
a marketing tool.
A tendering process will guarantee and lead to a long-term and sustainable supply of BMS,
since it leads to a legally binding contract for the supply of the BMS. Manufacturers have been
hesitant to reveal the actual cost of production of BMS, but it is felt that it is extremely low
compared with the market price.
Any partnership with a particular company will imply the Government's satisfaction with the
112
If free or subsidised quantities of BMS are made available, they should be consistently in stock
at a local, decentralised level to avoid the need for frequent trips to a distant distribution point,
to reduce the chances of mixed feeding if the mother does not receive sufficient BMS and to
reduce the chances of undernutrition.
The receipt of free or subsidised BMS may become associated with HIV positive status of the
mother and care is therefore needed to protect the anonymity of those receiving them to
prevent potential stigmatisation. Stigma may also increase the chances of mixed feeding,
whereby the mother may feed the infant with BMS at home and breastfeed in public.
In addition to ensuring Code compliance and providing appropriate counselling and practical
support on safe preparation and use of BMS, PMTCT programmes providing BMS may also
provide water purification means, soap, stoves and fuel together with the BMS to ensure
conditions for safe artificial feeding are met and reduce the chances of contamination.
Important Note:
UNICEF offices may provide support in ensuring Code-compliant procurement and distribution of
BMS, but should not procure or supply BMS directly for PMTCT programmes [183]. UNICEF made
the decision to cease procurement of BMS for PMTCT programmes in 2002, based on the following
considerations:
UNICEFs formula support was to the PMTCT pilot sites only in the early stages of these
programmes.
UNICEF resources have been used to purchase and provide infant formula, whereas use of these
resources for hiring more infant feeding counsellors and improving the counselling on making
breastfeeding safer will be more cost-effective.
Anecdotal information from PMTCT sites suggested that many mothers who opted for free
formula also breastfed because of social pressure to do so or convenience. The resulting mixed
feeding not only put the child at an increased risk of infectious diseases and probably at
increased risk of HIV, it was also a waste of the financial resources used to purchase the formula.
Free formula was given for a short period, in most countries only 6 months. However a child
needs replacement feeding (milk feed) till it is at least 2 years. Through donations a dependency
on formula as the replacement food has been created, which may be far too expensive to
maintain.
113
counselling, poor support and supervision, and very weak monitoring and evaluation of infant feeding
practices. Finally, there are very few examples of linkages between health facility PMTCT services
and community-based infant feeding interventions.
While some countries have significantly scaled up PMTCT interventions over the past couple of
years, it is realised that it will take some time before all health workers involved with supporting
HIV+ mothers are properly trained on HIV and infant feeding counselling and conduct the
counselling and support effectively. With the new guidance on HIV and infant feeding, health
workers will need to be (once again) reoriented on the new recommendations which their respective
national health authorities have set. There will need to be a shift in mindset away from individual
counselling on risks and benefits of different options and asking the mother to choose an option,
towards conveying the national recommendation to the mothers, providing counselling to the
mother on how to implement it, but also counselling those mothers who choose to opt out of the
national recommendation on alternative options.
Revised global training and counselling tools for health providers still need to be developed at the
time of writing this guidance. The health system initiatives supportive of optimal infant and young
child feeding in general, including BFHI and IYCF counselling and support through multiple health
system contacts should use updated guidelines, training materials, counselling tools, job aids and
communication messages and materials which address the 2009 guidance on infant feeding in the
context of HIV. These efforts will contribute to an environment in which optimal breastfeeding and
complementary feeding are the norm and HIV-positive mothers get appropriate counselling and
special support on infant and young child feeding.
Key actions related to HIV and infant feeding in the health care system include the following:
Integrate infant feeding counselling
in the counselling and testing
contacts in maternal care services:
At present, far too few pregnant women
are aware of their HIV status. HIV
testing and counselling, now provided
as part of the routine package of
screening tests during pregnancy and
delivery
(provider-initiated
testing),
represents the main gateway to HIV
prevention, care, and treatment for
most women of reproductive age.
These services need to be widely
available to enable pregnant women
and their partners to know their status
and to access relevant treatment and
care services, including ARVs. The
testing service needs to be well-linked
with counselling services on infant
feeding to ensure that all HIV-positive
women receive adequate counselling
and support to enable them to feed their
infants safely and effectively.
Feeding implications of early infant diagnosis (EID) of HIV: Early infant diagnosis in PMTCT
programmes in developing countries is a growing priority as technologies become more widely
available. On the one hand, knowing a childs status as early as 6 weeks enables early treatment
decisions to be made if the child is HIV-positive. In terms of infant feeding, the mother of the HIV+
child should be counselled to breastfeed the child if possible, even if she was feeding BMS before,
to ensure that the infant can benefit from all the protective qualities of breastmilk. On the other
114
hand, the health provider faces a heightened counselling challenge for the mother of a child
confirmed HIV- negative through EID. The decision to continue exposing the negative child to HIV
through breastfeeding may be made more difficult by having this definitive knowledge, but the
counselling principles around the low risk of transmission with ARVs plus breastfeeding and
conditions to feed BMS safely in fact remain the same.
Support to training of counsellors in PMTCT sites and MCH health workers outside PMTCT
sites on HIV and infant feeding counselling: Knowledge of health workers on HIV and infant
feeding is usually poor, as is their knowledge of infant feeding in general. It seems that the rapidlychanging information on the risks of MTCT through breastfeeding and the constantly shifting
guidance has confused many health workers and raised doubts about how best to support mothers.
In addition, some of the information they receive, for instance through the media, may be incorrect
and harmful. A similar lack of knowledge and mistaken beliefs also exist among the general
population and pregnant women in particular. It is thus important that training on breastfeeding
counselling and on HIV and infant feeding is not restricted to the counsellors in the PMTCT sites.
Ideally all health workers who are in contact with pregnant women and mothers with infants and
young children should be trained. All workers who counsel on infant and young child feeding
choices should be well trained and able to communicate the national infant feeding policy in the
context of HIV, and can provide support for exclusive breastfeeding, replacement feeding, and
complementary feeding.
Introduce a new contact at 11 months: With the new recommendations on HIV and infant
feeding, a visit at 11 months is needed to assess the food security and other aspects of the
mothers situation to decide whether breastfeeding can be stopped after 12 months or whether it
needs to continue. Up to two additional contacts may be needed to follow up the mother and infant
and ensure feeding is adequate. These new contacts may also be used to provide complementary
food supplements until the child reaches two years, if the country has a policy and programmes to
do so.
Follow up support to and monitoring of feeding practices, health and nutritional status of
mother and child: A key step of the counselling process for HIV-positive mothers is to follow up
and provide continuous support to the mother in carrying out her infant feeding decision, to identify
and solve possible problems, to monitor the health of the mother and the health and growth of the
baby. This step is essential to ensure that the mother is feeding the child appropriately and that the
baby is healthy and growing well. Since infant and young child feeding practices change several
times during the first 24 months of a childs life, support to the mother should continue to be
intensive during this period. Follow-up support should also include nutritional support to HIVpositive mothers, in particular those mothers who decide to breastfeed.
115
IYCF counselling and communication skills training for community cadres using modules
containing material on HIV and infant feeding that is based on the 2010 WHO
recommendations, as well as breastfeeding and complementary feeding, such as the UNICEF
Community IYCF Counselling Package (see Chapter 3.3). There should be one consolidated
package containing both IYCF counselling and HIV and infant feeding counselling in HIV
settings. The training should include practical sessions to enhance counselling skills, as well as
address referral for testing of the pregnant women and of the infant and support for taking
ARVs as applicable. It is expected that the national recommendation on HIV and infant feeding
will be conveyed and explained to the mother at the PMTCT contact in the health facility, and
the role of the community worker (CW) is to support the mother to implement it. The CW should
have sufficient understanding of the policy to be able to promote and reinforce the health facility
messages and provide further clarification or reassurance.
Capacity building and support for mother support groups: Groups created through the
PMTCT programme in countries should be adequately capacitated to address infant feeding in
the context of HIV, and mother to mother groups created through the BFHI or nutrition
programme. These groups should be encouraged to involve and follow up the women until the
infant is at least two years old (and longer if the mothers wish), and not just for the duration of
the pregnancy until the early infant diagnosis test, as is the case in some programmes.
Simplified training tools to build interactive communication skills and to be able to provide
support to mothers based on those for lay counsellors/CWs should be used; these should be
adapted to the local context.
Data collection: lay counsellors, CWs and mother support groups can be a rich source of
information on actual infant feeding practices, challenges and possible solutions, and the
monitoring tools for community based IYCF programmes in high HIV burden countries should
include a section on infant feeding in the context of HIV.
116
it is often due to these groups that women, despite having received the counselling on infant
feeding at the PMTCT service, do not practice the recommended behaviour optimally.
The approach to communication on HIV and infant feeding needs to follow the steps described in
the chapter on communication.
Proportion of children exclusively breastfed at the DPT3 contact in the EPI schedule.
In addition, the drop-off of children and their caregivers is high: many HIV-exposed infants are lost
to follow up and it is therefore not possible to establish their status in terms of HIV, survival and
nutrition for example by age 12 or 24 months. However, for a more accurate assessment of feeding
practices and a more in-depth understanding of processes and outcomes of HIV and infant feeding
activities more information needs to be collected at household level.
Monitoring of the application of the new recommendations: monitoring of how many PMTCT
sites have staff trained on IYCF in the context of HIV (based on 2010 guidelines and their national
adaptation) and how many sites routinely conduct IYCF counselling; tracking the total number of
health providers and community workers trained on and applying the latest guidance on HIV and
infant feeding; formative research on knowledge and practices among health workers, community
cadres, including assessment of the actual counselling of HIV-positive mothers through health
facility survey type approaches such as observing a sample of counselling sessions; exit interviews
with mothers/caregivers at PMTCT sites.
Assessment of Code implementation in the context of HIV programmes for mothers and infants
needs to be undertaken.
Evaluation of the impact of interventions on mother and child health and survival is important to
analyze through the use of household survey data such as DHS, MICS, and nutrition surveys in
conjunction with sero-studies of HIV prevalence. In the absence of this type of gold-standard
household surveys, lot quality assurance system (LQAS) can be used to obtain a rough indication
of the ranges of coverage of exclusive breastfeeding, for example, in a specific population. Various
tools for modelling potential impact can also be used.
117
This chapter provides a brief summary of the key aspects of infant feeding in emergencies, as key
policy and guidance tools such as the Infant and Young Child Feeding in Emergencies:
Operational Guidance (IFE Core Group 2007) and various training materials already exist,
including a module for counsellors on integration of IYCF into CMAM programmes. In addition to the
e-learning module on infant feeding in emergencies developed by the Emergency Nutrition Network
and the Harmonized Training Package module on IYCF in emergencies, UNICEF also has an elearning on IYCF in emergencies as part of its Nutrition in Emergencies e-learning series (see
Resources Annex 1-11)
IYCF in emergencies is also reflected in the current Sphere standards for humanitarian response
[184]. The two new IYCF standards in Sphere 2011 are:
Infant and young child feeding standard 1: Policy guidance and coordination
Infant and young child feeding standard 2: Basic and skilled support
118
impact for survival of infants less than six months during an emergency . The fundamental means of
preventing both mortality and undernutrition among infants and young children during emergencies is
to ensure their optimal feeding and care, focusing in particular on creating conditions that will facilitate
breastfeeding.
In many emergency-prone countries, however, exclusive breastfeeding coverage remains very low
and the scope and scale of IYCF programmes remains limited.
During an emergency, continued breastfeeding up to two years or beyond, together with quality
complementary feeding, is also very important for the continued protection from infection that the
breastfeeding confers, as well as its nutritional value. The valuable protection from infection and its
consequences that breastmilk confers is all the more important in environments without a safe water
supply and sanitation, where the safe preparation and use of BMS is often impossible.
In emergencies, the use of any BMS can further increase the risks of illness, malnutrition and
death and disrupt the protection provided by breastfeeding. Breastfeeding during emergencies must
not be undermined by inappropriate donations and use of BMS. Experience has shown that without
proper assessment of needs, an excessive quantity of milk products for feeding infants and young
children are often provided in emergency situations by well-intentioned but poorly informed donors or
requested by poorly-informed Governments. If unsolicited supplies of donated BMS and/or powdered
milks are widely available, mothers who might otherwise breastfeed might needlessly start giving
artificial feeds. This exposes many infants and young children to increased risk of disease and death,
especially from diarrhoea when clean water is scarce. The use of feeding bottles only adds further to
the risk of infection as they are difficult to clean properly.
Thus, to summarize, IYCF programming in emergencies is important for the following reasons:
Breastfeeding is safe, free and a crucial life-saving intervention for vulnerable children whose
risks of death increase markedly in emergencies.
Emergencies exacerbate risks of not breastfeeding or mixed feeding.
Continued breastfeeding is crucial in reducing the risk of diarrhoea and other illnesses in older
children, which is heightened in emergencies.
Donations of BMS undermine breastfeeding and cause illness and death.
IYCF is central to reducing the high risk of undernutrition during emergencies.
Safe, adequate, and appropriate complementary feeding, which significantly contributes to
prevention of undernutrition and mortality in children after 6 months, is often jeopardized during
emergencies and needs particular attention.
Challenges
Some common challenges faced by countries in terms of IYCF in emergencies include the following:
IYCF is often not well reflected in emergency preparedness and response plans and activities.
Many countries do not have comprehensive IYCF programmes, which could serve as the basis for
effective and well-organized emergency response activities. The lack of IYCF programmes also
means that the IYCF practices at the onset of the emergency are also likely to be poor, and that
local IYCF guidelines and training materials and other resources will be absent.
Countries often lack a critical mass of various cadres of trained IYCF counsellors in health system
and community who can be mobilized in emergencies.
Only a small number of international agencies with presence in the field during emergencies have
expertise in IYCF in emergencies: advocacy and capacity development have been lacking.
See: Why Promote Breastfeeding in Emergencies? section in Behaviour Change Communication in Emergencies: A Toolkit
- Chapter 5 (UNICEF ROSA 2006)
119
Local and international capacity for communication for behaviour change on IYCF in emergencies
is often inadequate.
Clear guidance and materials are lacking on complementary feeding in emergencies (no single
panacea package is available; attention and adaptation to local context is crucial).
In many cases, governments fail to take action to implement and enforce the Code: donations of
BMS and powdered milk still flood in all emergencies.
The response to donations of breast-milk substitutes during emergencies is often inadequate or
inappropriate:
o Donations are not discouraged or blocked.
o There is a lack of clarity on how to handle donations.
o Logistics problems in storing or incorporating confiscated donations into pre-mixed
blended foods/flours are often encountered.
Systems to rapidly procure, target and distribute appropriate BMS to eligible non-breastfed children
are often weak.
Many of these steps are included in the priority actions the three items in bold have been added or
1
addressed in more detail than in the Operational Guidance :
i.
ii.
iii.
iv.
v.
vi.
Including IYCF interventions, with guidelines and training materials for IYCF in emergencies, in
emergency preparedness and response plans.
The Operational Guidance is due to be updated in 2011.
120
Ensuring adequate local institutions and partners to design, plan and implement IYCF
counselling, support and communication activities in emergencies, including training of
humanitarian personnel and Government staff, as widely as possible.
Developing adequate cohorts of skilled IYCF counselors (health providers and community
workers) across the country should also be part of emergency preparedness as a key priority.
Educating Government and NGO staff on the importance of protecting and supporting
breastfeeding and approaches to preventing and dealing with donated BMS.
Countries need to implement and enforce the Code, including the adoption of a policy on not
requesting, preventing and dealing with donations of BMS and powdered milk, in emergency
situations. It is important to sensitize Governments on the issue of donations as part of
emergency preparedness, so that swift and decisive action can be taken at the onset of an
emergency to ensure donations of BMS are not requested by the Government and that any
donations are prevented and stopped effectively from the outset.
During the emergency, there may be a need to conduct rapid training on IYCF counseling and
specific issues (e.g. use of RUIF, how to establish and manage IYCF counseling sites [185] and
services, how to integrate IYCF in SFP and CMAM). It is important to have trainers and materials
in place as part of preparedness.
121
friendly spaces or through stand-alone specialized IYCF structures. The decision on which type of
service should be implemented needs to be made based on the following considerations:
o
When there are major threats or problems with breastfeeding large numbers of orphaned or
unaccompanied infants and many displaced people, destruction of existing health facilities or
disruption of services then stand-alone temporary services such as baby tents or baby1
friendly spaces are likely to be needed.
When the emergency is slow-onset such as a drought, there is no major destruction of
existing services and there are sufficient workers at sites with nutrition services, there is no
significant displacement of the populations and no major concentration of people into camps,
then IYCF services can be integrated within other nutrition services such as management of
SAM and supplementary feeding.
Communication strategies (See Resources Annex 1-11) to promote optimal infant feeding raise
awareness of the risks of artificial feeding and broadcast information to mothers and caretakers
on the services available (e.g. the safe havens, counselling and support, etc.).
Effective IYCF coordination as part of the Nutrition Cluster is crucial. IYCF should feature
prominently on the agenda of nutrition cluster meetings, effective IYCF interventions should be
promoted, guidance and tools should be issued to all cluster partners, and if required an IYCF
sub-group can be created.
iii. Preventing and dealing with donations of BMS and powdered milks
Key actions on this important issue, which unfortunately arises in every emergency that occurs,
include the following
Ensuring that such donations are not requested or accepted. This may involve advocacy to
Governments to avoid requesting donations of BMS in the lists of emergency supplies, preventing
donations from being made, issuing a joint statement calling for donations to be avoided,
preventing consignments from entering the country through involving customs, or removing the
donations from distribution channels.
While the focus should be on preventing donations, if unsolicited donations of supplies do come
in, a sole coordinating agency should be designated to handle the donated supplies, including
their collection, planning their safe use and distribution. Appropriate use for those children who
require BMS as described above should be ensured, and surpluses to such requirements should
be used for target groups who could benefit from milk products, such as children 6-23 months or
An example of a stand-alone IYCF service is the baby tent programme in Haiti following the earthquake, for which
guidelines were developed (see [131] and Resources Annex.
2
Including key documents such as Joint Model Statement on IFE (IFE Core Group 2008) and Media Guide on IYCF in
Emergencies (IFE Core Group 2007)
3
As per IYCF indicators Part II (measurement), MICS or DHS questionnaires
122
pregnant and lactating women by mixing with milled fortified staple foods or blended foods.
Powdered milk should never be distributed as a separate commodity. Close coordination is
needed with WFP and its implementing partners and other food aid partners who may be
preparing pre-mixes into which the powdered milk can be added.
Mapping or monitoring of the scope and scale of donations may be included in household surveys
1
or as a separate exercise .
There are some situations in emergencies when breastfeeding is not possible .This needs to be
determined on the basis of professional assessment and advice by staff trained on lactation
3
management, as well as on the accepted medical reasons for not breastfeeding .
Any provision of BMS for feeding infants and young children should be based on careful professional
assessment of needs, stipulating criteria for children with no possibility to be breastfed. They should
be used only under strict control and monitoring. In the case of BMS for children under 6 months and
unsafe water/hygiene conditions, a safer option may be ready-to-use infant formula (RUIF). These
products should be distributed separately from food aid and separately from breastfeeding
counselling consultations to avoid spillover. They should be stored, prepared and given under
hygienic conditions as per international guidance and under the close supervision of trained health
workers.
Procurement of RUIF or other BMS in an emergency for orphaned and other eligible infants should be
made by the Government or a designated agency under the coordination of the Nutrition Cluster.
4
UNICEF will only procure BMS after approval by HQ Nutrition Section .
Box 31
In May 2010 the World Health Assembly expressed its concern that national emergency
preparedness plans and international emergency responses do not always cover protection,
promotion and support of optimal infant and young child feeding, and issued Resolution 63.23
which urged Member States:
to ensure that national and international preparedness plans and emergency responses follow
the evidence-based Operational Guidance for Emergency Relief Staff and Programme Managers
on infant and young child feeding in emergencies, which includes the need to minimize the
risks of artificial feeding, by ensuring that any required breast-milk substitutes are purchased,
distributed and used according to strict criteria;
Key actions related to identification and appropriate feeding of infants with no possibility to be
breastfed include the following:
See Resources and tools Annex 1-11 for a report on a monitoring exercise carried out in Haiti, including the tool. The ENN
website contains a number of articles on monitoring of donations in recent emergencies.
2
See Section 6.2.2 of Infant and Young Child Feeding in Emergencies: Operational Guidance (IFE Core Group 2007) [69].
3
See Acceptable medical reasons for use of breastmilk substitutes (WHO/UNICEF 2008) [1].
4
The IFE Core Group recently issued an addendum to the Operational Guidance that clarifies issues related to procurement of
BMS (available on ENN website).
5
Example criteria from the IFE Ops Guidance for temporary or longer term use of infant formula include: absent or dead
mother, very ill mother, relactating mother until lactation is re-established, mother who was exclusively artificially feeding her
123
Locally-appropriate solutions to feed these infants need to be rapidly identified at the outset of the
emergency. In some contexts this may involve wet-nursing or milk banks, while in others an
appropriate BMS may be the best solution, particularly RUIF.
Limited amounts of BMS may be appropriate in the hands of hospitals, camp health facilities,
NGOs and orphanages, for eligible children. The nutrition coordination mechanism in the country
(usually the Nutrition Cluster) should, as a key part of emergency preparedness, determine
whether the Government can procure any needed BMS in an efficient and rapid manner
according to defined criteria, or, in cases where the Government does not have this possibility,
identify an appropriate provider. UNICEF may be a provider of last resort, upon approval by
1
UNICEF HQ . The supplies should be in accordance with applicable standards recommended by
the Codex Alimentarius Commission and labelled in accordance with the Code.
Ensuring that only those children who need BMS receive them and avoid spillover effects.
Ensuring that those who make decisions concerning acceptable supplies are informed about the
dangers of distribution of these commodities.
Ensuring availability and use of age appropriate complementary foods and supplements
Children from the age of six months require appropriate, adequate and safe complementary feeding
in addition to breastmilk. Under emergency conditions it may often be difficult to meet these
requirements without additional support. Dietary diversity often decreases significantly, and risk of
micronutrient deficiencies becomes very high [186]. Therefore, provision of fortified foods or
micronutrient supplements in supervised programmes for young children represents a more
appropriate form of food aid than sending milk products or unfortified cereal-based food aid. Suitable
foods for feeding children aged 6-23 months include lipid nutrient supplements (see Resources
Annex 1-2 for description of complementary foods). Actions include:
187
Ensuring the integration of IYCF counselling with programmes for management of SAM
In contexts where CMAM programmes are implemented, IYCF should be fully integrated within these
infant prior to the emergency and cannot relactate, HIV positive mother who has chosen not to breastfeed and where AFASS
criteria are met, infant rejected by mother, rape victim not wishing to breastfeed
1
See the addendum to the Operational Guidance that clarifies issues related to procurement of BMS (available on ENN
website).
124
programmes:
Before discharge of children admitted with SAM, reviewing of feeding practices of the
malnourished child and counselling on exclusive breastfeeding or continued breastfeeding plus
counselling on timely, safe, appropriate and adequate complementary feeding (after 6 months of
age) , including demonstration of food preparation and sharing of recipes with mothers for optimal
use of locally available foods for children 6-23 months.
125
126
programs in a given country. Software was updated recently to take into account new scientific
evidence, and is continuously being updated to include the latest literature available. At the
following link you can see the models Profiles has: For example, it has new mortality models
based on the WHO growth standards which use the mild severity category o f underweight,
stunting and wasting. It also has a new stunting-productivity model using the latest available
literature. http://www.aedprofiles.org/about-profiles
A Policy Analysis Tool for Calculating the Health, Child Spacing, and Economic Benefits of
Breastfeeding: This Excel spreadsheet tool consists of seven worksheets: introduction,
assumptions, breastmilk production, health, survival, fertility, and summary. The spreadsheets
estimate the effects of breastfeeding on a variety of functional outcomes with public policy
significance. J. Ross, V. Aguayo, H. Stiefel. AED (2006).
http://www.linkagesproject.org/technical/breastfeeding.php
Experience LINKAGES: Cost & Effectiveness. Describes the process LINKAGES' Madagascar
program undertook to link the costs of its interventions with the resultant changes in infant feeding
behaviours. AED/Linkages (2005).
http://www.linkagesproject.org/media/publications/Experience_LINKAGES_Cost&Effectiveness.pdf
Marginal Budgeting for Bottlenecks (MBB): A tool for performance-based planning of Health and
Nutrition Services for Achieving Millennium Development Goals.MBB is a result-based planning and
budgeting tool that utilizes knowledge about the impact of interventions on child and maternal
mortality in a country, identifies implementation constraints and estimates the marginal costs of
overcoming these constraints.It was jointly developed by UNICEF, the World Bank and WHO. It is
being used to assist in setting targets for proven high-impact interventions and the estimation of their
expected impact, cost per life saved and additional funding requirements, as well as a projection of
the required fiscal space to finance these extra costs. Information is available from UNICEF Health
Section, contact: [email protected].
Operational Guidance on Gender Analysis and Programming for Young Child Survival and
Development. UNICEF, Version 1, April 2010. This guidance aims to orient UNICEF programme
staff on how to apply gender analysis and programming to young child survival and development
overall, as well as to sectoral areas of intervention. While some areas are more advanced than others
in terms of understanding and mainstreaming gender into programming, this document provides a
starting point for pragmatically introducing a gender perspective into UNICEFs work in young child
survival and development. Contains a specific section on IYCF and maternal nutrition.
http://www.intranet.unicef.org/iconhome.nsf/1033ed9773ce3c1e8525756900783ac9/277b5da2ba871
7a885257769005a0a72?OpenDocument
127
Guiding Principles for Feeding Non-breastfed Children 6-24 Months of Age. WHO (2005).
http://www.who.int/nutrition/publications/infantfeeding/guidingprin_nonbreastfed_child.pdf
Complementary feeding: family foods for breastfed children. WHO (1998).
http://www.who.int/nutrition/publications/infantfeeding/WHO_NHD_00.1/en/index.html
Description of available complementary foods and supplements (UNICEF 2009)
http://intranet.unicef.org/PD/YCSD.nsf/0/F996EEFE3EBD0EDC852572030074B023/$FILE/Complem
entary%20foods%20and%20supplements%20Sept.%202010.pdf
Resources Annex 1-3: Tools for formative research & other situation assessment
tools
Tools for situation assessment/prioritization
ProPAN Manual: Progress for the Promotion of Child Feeding. PAHO (2003). (currently
being updated) http://www.paho.org/common/Display.asp?Lang=E&RecID=6048
Linear Programming. WHO/LSHTM. A mathematical tool for analyzing and optimizing
childrens diets during the complementary feeding period (currently being revised to become
more user-friendly for programming in the field). http://www.nutrisurvey.de/lp/lp.htm.
A description of Linear Programming by SCN can be found at
http://www.nutrisurvey.de/lp/lp_scn.pdf
Trials of Improved Practices (TIPs). The Manoff Group. TIPs is a formative research
technique used for nutrition programming since the late 1970s to pretest the actual practices
that a program will promote.
http://www.manoffgroup.com/approach_developing.html
Comprehensive Food Security and Vulnerability Analysis (CFSVA) Guidelines, WFP. January
2009. Provide extensive guidance on how to conduct an in-depth study of the food security and
vulnerability situation during a normal year (non crisis time).
http://www.wfp.org/content/comprehensive-food-security-and-vulnerability-analysis-cfsva-guidelinesfirst-edition
FAO/WFP Crop and Food Security Assessment Missions (CFSAM) Guidelines, January 2009.
Provides guidance on assessing crop and food security by looking at the supply and demand for
staple foods, and households access to food and on estimating uncovered staple food import
requirements. http://www.wfp.org/content/faowfp-joint-guidelines-crop-and-food-security-assessmentmissions-cfsams
United Nations Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) Food Insecurity and Vulnerability
Information and Mapping System (FIVIMS) http://www.fivims.net/index.jspx?lang=en
FIVIMS is an Inter-agency initiative to promote information and mapping systems on food insecurity
and vulnerability.
128
129
130
Code monitoring kit: This 40-page kit contains a full set of guidelines and forms for Code
monitoring. ContactIBFAN to order a copy of the kit: [email protected]
For a full list of Code and other breastfeeding resources, see the IBFAN website:
http://www.ibfan.org/code-publications.html
Infant and Young Child Feeding: Model Chapter for textbooks for medical students and allied
health professionals. WHO (2009)
http://www.who.int/nutrition/publications/infantfeeding/9789241597494/en/index.html
rd
131
Self-study and e-learning modules on lactation management and related issues. International
Board of Lactation Counsellor Education website.
http://www.iblce.edu.au/CERP%20Programs%20.php
Integrated Management of Childhood Illness. WHO (2008).11-day course (adaptations made in
countries for 6-day course; 1 day on infant feeding, including 2 practice sessions). For doctors,
nurses and other health workers at first level facilities.
http://www.who.int/child_adolescent_health/documents/IMCI_chartbooklet/en/index.html
Adolescent Nutrition: A Review of the Situation in Selected South-East Asian Countries
(chapter 8 contains strategies for adolescent nutrition).WHO (2006).
http://www.searo.who.int/EN/Section13/Section38_11624.htm
Essential Nutrition Actions: A Four Day Training Course for Planners and Managers of
Health & Nutrition Programs: Training guide for program managers and pre-service instructors
to train service providers in an action-oriented approach to improve the nutrition of infants,
young children and women. AED (2004; 2008 update available)
http://www.linkagesproject.org/media/publications/Training%20Modules/ENA_module_Ethiopia.p
df
Essential Nutrition Actions: Using essential actions in nutrition to improve the nutrition of children
and women. Training course for Health Workers. Three-day training for facility-based health workers
with 1-day training on IYCF. AED (2008). http://www.linkagesproject.org/
Training Methodologies and Principles of Adult Learning: Application for Training in Infant
and Young Child Nutrition and Related Topics. AED/USAID/Linkages (2005).
http://www.linkagesproject.org/media/publications/Training%20Modules/TOT-Adult-Learning.pdf
Facts for Feeding: Birth, Initiation of Breastfeeding and the First Seven Days after Birth.
Identifies actions health care providers can take during the first week postpartum to help the mother
and baby establish and maintain good breastfeeding practices. AED/Linkages (2003).
http://www.linkagesproject.org/media/publications/facts%20for%20feeding/FFF7daysEnglish_update0
703.pdf
Facts for Feeding: Feeding Infants and Young Children During and After Illness. This document
describes optimal feeding behaviours during and after illness, challenges of feeding during these
times, special considerations for common illnesses, and guidelines for counselling caregivers.
AED/Linkages (2006). http://www.linkagesproject.org/media/publications/Facts-for-FeedingIllness_11-21-06.pdf
Facts for Feeding: Feeding Low Birth weight Babies. This recent publication in the Facts for
Feeding series provides guidance on breastmilk feeding options to ensure that low birthweight
babies receive the attention needed to survive, grow, and develop. AED/Linkages (2006).
http://www.linkagesproject.org/media/publications/FFF_LBW_3-30-06.pdf
http://www.linkagesproject.org/media/publications/FFF_LBW_3-30-06.pdf
A Toolbox for Building Health Communication Capacity. AED/Linkages (1995).
http://www.globalhealthcommunication.org/tools/29
Behaviour Change Communication for Improved Infant Feeding. Manual for Training of
Trainers for Negotiating Sustainable Behaviour Change. Linkages (2004).
http://www.linkagesproject.org/media/publications/Training%20Modules/BCC_and_IF.pdf
Ethiopia - Counselling Cards for Fathers. These counselling cards were developed for use with
fathers, to encourage their support of breastfeeding and maternal nutrition. They tell fathers what they
can do during pregnancy and breastfeeding to support the health of their wives. AED/Linkages.
http://www.linkagesproject.org/media/publications/Tools/Ethiopia-counseling-cards-fathers.pdf
132
Care for Development (UNICEF/WHO, March 2009): The Care for Child Development package
consists of simple recommendations health workers can make to families to improve the growth,
health and development of children; training programmes and materials, guidance for the integration
of Care for Child Development into ongoing programmes and activities at health and nutrition facilities
and in the community; guidance for adaptation for local conditions; advocacy materials; and a
monitoring and evaluation framework.
http://intranet.unicef.org/pd/ecd.nsf/96054cb61a0f902885256fd9004dda04/2641aa458a57dd4385257
5b400598923?OpenDocument
133
134
Learning to listen to mothers. Vella, Jane, and Uccellani, Valerie, Academy for Educational
Development, Washington, D.C. Focuses on GMP programmes. (Available at:
www.globalhealthcommunication.org)
Development of Messages and Materials to Promote Improved Infant and Young Child Feeding: A
Case Study in Northern Ghana. AED/Linkages. (2003).
http://www.linkagesproject.org/media/static_pdfs/ccards/ghana_bcc_casestudy.pdf
Development Communication Sourcebook: Broadening the Boundaries of
Communication. World Bank (2008).
http://wwwwds.worldbank.org/external/default/WDSContentServer/WDSP/IB/2008/07/09/000020
953_20080709145627/Rendered/PDF/446360Dev0Comm1ns0handbook01PUBLIC1.pdf
World Breastfeeding Week. Website contains advocacy and communication resources for
each of the annual World Breastfeeding Week events. http://worldbreastfeedingweek.org/
135
IFE Module 1, v 2.0, 2009: IFE Orientation package. ENN/IFE Core Group, 2009. This is a
package of resources to help in orientation on infant and young child feeding in emergencies
(IFE). These resources are targeted at emergency relief staff, programme managers, and
technical staff involved in planning and responding to emergencies , at national and international
level. This IFE Orientation Package (IFE Module 1, v 2.0, 2009) is an update of Mod ule 1 on IFE
(essential orientation), a print content first produced in 2001. It comprises e-learning lessons,
training resources and technical notes. Module 17 of the Harmonized Training Package of the
Global Nutrition Cluster will also be uploaded here once it is updated.
http://www.ennonline.net/ife/orientation
Introduction to Nutrition in Emergencies: Basic Concepts. E-learning lessons. Module 5 is on
IYCF in emergencies (produced by IFE Core Group). On UNICEF intranet or contact Erin Boyd
([email protected])
Model Statement and Media Guide on Infant Feeding in Emergencies. ENN/IFE Core Group
(2008). Model Statement on IFE: http://www.ennonline.net/resources/237 and Media Guide on IYCF
in Emergencies: http://www.ennonline.net/resources/126
Guiding Principles for Feeding Infants and Young Children during Emergencies. WHO (2004).
http://www.who.int/nutrition/publications/guiding_principles_feedchildren_emergencies.pdf
Complementary Feeding of Infants and Young Children in Emergencies. Evaluating the Specific
Requirements of Realizing a Dedicated Complementary Feeding in Emergencies Training Resource;
a Preliminary Scoping Review of Current Resources. IFE Core Group/IASC Nutrition Cluster. October
2009. http://www.ennonline.net/pool/files/ife/cfe-review-enn-&-ife-core-group-oct-2009.pdf
Behaviour Change Communication in Emergencies: A Toolkit. UNICEF (2006). This toolkit
includes a chapter on breastfeeding and some useful tools.
http://www.influenzaresources.org/files/BCC_in_Emerg_chap1to8_2006.pdf
Joint Statement on Preventing and Controlling Micronutrient Deficiencies in Populations
Affected by an Emergency: multiple vitamin and mineral supplements for pregnant and lactating
women and for children aged 6 to 59 months. WHO/WFP/UNICEF (2007).
http://www.who.int/nutrition/publications/micronutrients/WHO_WFP_UNICEFstatement.pdf
Integration of IYCF Support into CMAM: Facilitators Guide. IASC/IFE/ENN (2009). Facilitators
guide and handouts for participants on 1 day orientation on IYCF counselling in the context of
community-based programmes for management of severe acute malnutrition.
http://www.ennonline.net/pool/files/ife/iycf-cmam-facilitators-us-final.pdf
Management of Severe Acute Malnutrition in Children: Programme Guidance. UNICEF
(February 2008).UNICEF Intranet Website:
http://intranet.unicef.org/PD/YCSD.nsf/acf15d033c45653b85256fa5005984d2/a5877444f0698b07852
571a7003df704?OpenDocument#Management%20of%20Severe%20Acute%20Undern
Management of Acute Malnutrition in Infants (MAMI) Project: Summary Report. IASC Nutrition
Cluster/ACF/UCL/ENN. October 2009.
http://www.ennonline.net/pool/files/ife/mami-project-summary-report-final-041209.pdf
Guidelines for Selective Feeding: the Management of Malnutrition in Emergencies.
UNHCR/WFP (2009). http://www.ennonline.net/pool/files/ife/wfp-unhcr-sfp-guidelines.pdf
136
137
http://oneresponse.info/globalclusters/nutrition
The cluster website with news, tools, training packages, events etc.
International Baby Food Action Network (IBFAN):
www.ibfan.org
The IBFAN website with news, fact sheets, resources, Code watch etc. Website includes links to
regional IBFAN sites and the International Code Documentation Centre.
International Lactation Consultant Association (ILCA):
http://www.ilca.org
The ILCA is the professional association for International Board Certified Lactation Consultants
(IBCLCs) and other health care professionals who care for breastfeeding families.
La Leche League International (LLLI):
http://www.lalecheleague.org
The LLLI aims to help mothers worldwide to breastfeed through mother-to-mother support,
encouragement, information, and education, and to promote a better understanding of breastfeeding
as an important element in the healthy development of the baby and mother.
Linkages Project:
www.linkagesproject.org
USAID-funded project (19962006) to provide technical information, assistance, and training to
organizations on breastfeeding, related complementary feeding and maternal dietary practices.
Website contains many useful training, communication, formative research and monitoring tools on
IYCF.
Pan American Health Organization (PAHO):
www.paho.org
WHOs regional office for the Americas with documents on IYCF for the region (including Spanish and
Portuguese versions), as well as the ProPAN Manual.
UNICEF Intranet:
http://intranet.unicef.org/
This is the Intranet site accessible with a password by UNICEF staff, which has many IYCF
documents and documents on other aspects of UNICEFs nutrition programming. It also contains
Section 5 of the BFHI, including the computer tool. The IYCF documents can be found by going to:
Programmes > Young Child Survival and Development >High Impact Health and Nutrition
Interventions > Nutrition >Infant and Young Child Feeding.
UNICEF Public Website:
http://www.unicef.org/nutrition/index_breastfeeding.html
UNICEFs public website with pages on IYCF and links to documents and stories from the field.
UN Standing Committee on Nutrition (SCN):
www.unscn.org/
Information on the SCN work, meetings, publications, updates, news, networks, etc., as well as
working groups, including the breastfeeding and complementary feeding working group.
Wellstart International:
www.wellstart.org
US-based organization focusing on health professionals education on breastfeeding, includes
Lactation Management Self-Study Modules, Level 1. This educational tool is downloadable without
charge.
138
139
Year
Catchment population
Target post-natal
Target 0-5 m.
Target 6-23m.
12
11
10
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
Coverage
100%
75%
50%
25%
0%
Jan
Cum
total
Feb
Cum
total
Mar
Cum
total
Apr
Cum
total
May
Cum
total
Jun
Cum
total
Jul
Cum
total
Aug
Cum
total
Sep
Cum
total
Oct
Cum
total
Nov
Cum
total
Dec
Post natal
counselling
Counselling
for < 6 months
children
Counselling
for 6-23
months
children
Adapted from the monitoring chart in the guide: Microplanning for immunization service delivery using the Reaching Every District (RED) approach. WHO. 2009
140
PPG1: Mother
PPG3: Father
This format was developed by Dr. Renato Linsangan, formerly with UNICEF Pakistan. It has been used by several UNICEF Country Offices and can be adapted to fit
local needs. It has been partially filled in to give a sample of the information that might be included; the example in this case relates to exclusive breastfeeding.
141
1. Behavioural
Analysis
What is the
recommended/ desired
behaviour?
142
1. Behavioural
Analysis
TPG1:
2.Communication
Strategy
What can
communication do to
overcome the key
barrier to the
recommended
behaviour?
Primary Participant
Groups: Behaviour
Change Communication
PPG1: Connect to EBF support group;
improve knowledge on EBF and that water
not necessary
PPG2: Promote another way senior women
can be involved in infant care and feeding;
improve knowledge on EBF
PPG3: Promote ways father can support wife
during EBF (nutrition, less work); improve
knowledge on EBF
Secondary Participant
Groups: Social
Mobilization
SPG1: Improve knowledge and communication skills;
community mobilization techniques
SPG2: improve knowledge and communication skills;
improve community mobilization techniques
SPG3: Improve knowledge and communication
skills; build capacity to plan and run group activities
143
2.Communication
Strategy
What benefits
(immediate and long
term) of the
recommended
behaviour can C4D
promote?
Primary Participant
Groups: Behaviour
Change Communication
PPG1: Baby will not be as sick as often; no
financial cost
Secondary Participant
Groups: Social
Mobilization
SPG1: Doing more and effective communication on
EBF, discouraging BMS will improve health of
children in catchment area.
TPG2:
TPG2:
PPG3:
TPG3:
TPG3:
TPG1:
PPG1:
SPG1:
TPG1:
PPG2:
SPG2
TPG2
SPG3:
TPG3:
PPG1
SPG1
TPG1:
PPG2:
SPG2:
TPG2:
PPG1:
SPG1:
TPG1:
144
2.Communication
Strategy
Primary Participant
Groups: Behaviour
Change Communication
Secondary Participant
Groups: Social
Mobilization
PPG2:
SPG2:
TPG2
SPG3:
TPG3:
message?
SPG4:
What are the
supportive
messages?
PPG1
SPG1
TPG1:
PPG2:
SPG2:
TPG2:
SPG3:
TPG3:
SPG4:
What are the C4D
interventions?
(e.g., interpersonal
communication
through peer
education,
community
dialogues; street
theatre; radio/TV,
advocacy)
PPG1:
PPG2:
145
2.Communication
Strategy
management)
Primary Participant
Groups: Behaviour
Change Communication
Secondary Participant
Groups: Social
Mobilization
esp. in EBF promotion and community mobilization
146
Annex 3: Glossary
Acute malnutrition: WFH <-2 Z scores or < 80% of the reference median and/or bilateral oedema
Advocacy: A continuous and adaptive process of gathering, organising and formulating information
into argument, to be communicated to decision-makers through various interpersonal and media
channels. This is done with a view to influencing their decision towards raising resources or political
and social leadership acceptance and commitment for a programme such as IYCF, thereby preparing
a society for its acceptance. Advocacy should include developing mechanisms to ensure that the
perspectives, concerns and voices of children, women and men from marginalized groups, are
reflected in upstream policy dialogue and decision making (based on McKee et al, Involving People
Evolving Behaviour, 2000).
Artificial feeding: Infant is fed only breastmilk substitute.
Balance of risks: To weigh therisk of mother-to-child transmission of HIV through breastfeeding and
excess morbidity and mortality associated with positive HIV status, against the risk of excess
morbidity and mortality by not breastfeeding, whether an infant is HIV positive or not. Current WHO
guidelines recommend that HIV positive mothers should avoid breastfeeding only if replacement
feeding is acceptable, feasible, affordable, safe and sustainable, or to breastfeed exclusively but stop
as early as possible. The risk of virus transmission through breastfeeding depends on a variety of
factors, including the disease status of the mother, whether she exclusively breastfeeds and for how
long. Experts now estimate that on average, for each month of breastfeeding, less than 1% of infants
are infected. With exclusive breastfeeding, the risk drops to less than half this level. The extremely
high risks of infant mortality associated with not being breastfed need to be taken into account when
informing HIV-infected mothers about options for feeding their infants.
Behaviour Change Communication (BCC): A research-based consultative process of addressing
knowledge, attitudes and practices that are intrinsically linked to programme goals, including IYCF. It
identifies analyses and segments audiences and participants and provides them with relevant
information and motivation, using an audience-appropriate mix of interpersonal, group and massmedia channels, including participatory methods and social marketing. Behaviour change strategies
tend to focus on the individual as a locus of change.In general, BCC is considered more data driven,
based on empirical evidence and able to demonstrate measurable results, sometimes in relatively
shorter time frames.
Bottle-feeding: Infant is fed from a bottle (with expressed breastmilk, water, formula, etc.).
Breastmilk substitutes: Any food being marketed or otherwise represented as a partial or total
replacement for breastmilk, whether or not it is suitable for that purpose.
Communication for Development (C4D): A systematic, planned and evidence-based process to
promote positive and measurable individual behaviour and social change that is an integral part of
development programmes, policy advocacy and humanitarian work.
It uses research and
consultative processes to promote human rights, mobilize leadership and societies, influence
attitudes and support the behaviours of those who have an impact on the well-being of children,
women, their families and communities. It uses a combination of advocacy, social mobilization,
behaviour change communication and social change communication. Using one without the others
will not yield the desired long-term results.C4D is a UNICEF term; previously known as Programme
Communication.
Community health worker (CHW): CHWs are known by many different names in different countries.
The umbrella term CHW embraces a variety of community health aides selected, trained and
working in the communities from which they come. CHWs are trained to carry out one or more
functions related to health care. A widely accepted definition was proposed by WHO: Community
health workers should be members of the communities where they work, should be selected by the
communities, should be answerable to the communities for their activities, should be supported by the
health system but not necessarily a part of its organization, and have shorter training than
professional workers.
147
148
barriers to behaviour change. Source: Strategic Communications in the HIV/AIDS Epidemic by Neill
McKee, Jane T. Bertrand, Antje Becker-Benton, 2004
Formula: Artificial milk for babies made out of a variety of products, including sugar, animal milks,
soybean, and vegetable oils. They are usually in powder form, to mix with water.
Commercial infant formula: A breastmilk substitute formulated industrially in accordance with
applicable Codex Alimentarius standards to satisfy the nutritional requirements of infants during the
first months of life up to the introduction of complementary foods.
Fortified foods: These are foods that have certain nutrients added to improve their nutritional quality.
Growth Monitoring and Promotion (GMP): Growth monitoring and promotion programs include
regularly weighing of children to detect early growth falterers, using the growth chart as an
educational tool to trigger improved caring practices among health workers and caretakers. GMP is a
preventive and promotive strategy aimed at action before malnutrition occurs; it is a behaviour
change strategy carried out through communication to achieve adequate growth through home and
community action.
HIV testing and counselling: Testing for HIV status, preceded and followed by counselling. Testing
should be voluntary and confidential, with fully informed consent. The expression means the same as
the terms: counselling and voluntary testing, voluntary counselling and testing, and voluntary and
confidential counselling and testing. Counselling is a process, not a one-off event: for the HIV-positive
client it should include life planning, and, if the client is pregnant or has recently given birth, it should
include infant-feeding considerations.
Information, Education and Communication (IEC): An outdated approach to behaviour change
that focused on the development of posters, flyers, leaflets, brochures, booklets, messages for health
education sessions, radio broadcast TV spots and other materials, as a means of promoting desired,
positive behaviours in the community. Todays managers recognize that effective IYCF programme
design incorporates the design, pre-testing and production of materials as only one element of a
comprehensive C4D strategy.
Integrated Management of Acute Malnutrition (IMAM): Integrated management of acute
malnutrition encompasses both the community-based approach (see definition of CMAM above) and
in-patient management of severe cases of malnutrition with complications or less than 6 months in a
health facility or therapeutic feeding centre with skilled health care providers, both in the emergency
and development contexts.
Integrated Management of Childhood Illness (IMCI): A WHO/UNICEF principal strategy developed
in the mid-1990s that integrates all available measures for disease prevention and management of
the major health problems during childhood (fever, respiratory illness, diarrhoea and malnutrition), for
their early detection and effective treatment, and for promoting healthy habits within the family and
community. Based on this evaluation, IMCI gives clear instructions on disease classification and
problems, establishing the treatment that should be administered for each one. IMCI implementation
involves the participation of the community, the health-service sector and the family. This is carried
out in three ways: 1) improving the performance of health workers for in the prevention and treatment
of childhood diseases; 2) improving the organization and operation of health services so they provide
quality care; 3) improving family and community care practices.
Infant feeding counselling: Counselling on breastfeeding, on complementary feeding, and, for HIVpositive women, on HIV and infant feeding.
Infant: A child from birth to 12 months of age.
Knowledge, Attitude and Practice (KAP) studies: These surveys are a tried and tested way to
measure changes in peoples knowledge, attitudes and practices on specific issues. The Knowledge
possessed by an individual or community refers to their understanding of that topic. Attitude refers to
their feelings toward the subject, such as complementary feeding, as well as any preconceived ideas
they may have towards it. Practice refers to the ways in which they demonstrate their knowledge and
attitudes through their actions. Understanding these three dimensions will allow a project to track
149
changes in them over time, and may enable the project to tailor activities to the needs of that
community. KAP studies should be conducted both pre- and post-intervention to measure impact.
Lactation Amenorrhoea Method (LAM): Using the period of amenorrhoea after childbirth as a
family planning method. It is most effective during the early months and if the infant is exclusively
breastfed on demand including at night and as long as the menstruation has not returned, but there is
still a chance (of a few per cent) that the woman can become pregnant, and this increases after six
months, when other family planning methods should be used.
Lay counsellor: Lay counsellors are members of the community who are trained to provide a specific
service or to perform certain limited activities. Lay community counsellors overcome the issues of
entry into community, those related to ethnocentrism, and the shortage of resources, by training
members from within the affected community. Lay counsellors have been effectively used in
promoting exclusive breastfeeding and in supporting HIV and AIDS programs, among others.
Lipid-based Nutrient Supplements (LNS): Are ready-to-use foods that have been used for treating
children with severe acute malnutrition and for preventing malnutrition and linear growth failure.
Because of their high energy and nutrient content, LNS could be used for supplementation during and
soon after illness to mitigate the impact of illness-associated anorexia on the nutritional status of
children.
Low birth weight (LBW): An infant weighing less than 2.5 kg at birth.
Mixed feeding: Infant receives both breastmilk and any other food or liquid including water, nonhuman milk and formula before 6 months of age. Mixed feeding significantly increases the risk of
mother to child transmission of HIV.
Moderate Malnutrition (MM): MM includes all children with moderate wasting (also known as
moderate acute malnutrition - MAM) defined as a weight-for-height between -3 and -2 z-scores of the
WHO child growth standards and all those with moderate stunting defined by a height-for-age
between -3 and -2 z-score of the WHO child growth standards. Most of these children will also be
moderately underweight (weight-for-age between -3 and -2 z-scores).Children with moderate
malnutrition have an increased risk of mortality and MM is associated with a high number of nutritionrelated deaths. If some of these moderately malnourished children do not receive adequate support,
they may progress towards severe acute malnutrition (severe wasting and/or oedema) or severe
stunting (height-for-age less than -3 z-scores), both life-threatening conditions. Therefore, the
management of MM should be a public health priority.
Mother-support group: A community-based group of women providing support for optimal
breastfeeding and complementary feeding.
Mother-to-Child Transmission (MTCT): Transmission of HIV to a child from an HIV-infected woman
during pregnancy, delivery or breastfeeding.
Mid Upper Arm Circumference (MUAC): MUAC is a quick and simple way to determine whether or
not a child is malnourished using a coloured plastic strip. MUAC is suitable to use on children from
the age of 12 months up to the age of 59 months. However, it can also be used for children over six
months with length above 65 cm.
Multi-micronutrient supplements: Preparations of several vitamins and minerals, in the form of
powders to add to food, syrups, capsules or tablets.
Norms: norms tend to reflect the values of the group and specify those actions that are proper and
those that are inappropriate, as well as rewards for adherence and the punishment for conformity.
Related to nutrition, there are many traditional beliefs and accepted norms that need to be recognized
and respected in developing socially acceptable and effective policies.
Operational research (OR): OR identifies service-delivery problems and tests new
programmatic solutions to these problems. An important objective of OR is to provide program
managers and policy decision makers with the information they need to improve and expand
existing services.OR employs many methodologies in a process that includes five basic steps: (1)
150
problem identification and diagnosis; (2) strategy selection; (3) strategy experimentation and
evaluation; (4) information dissemination; and (5) information utilization.
Overweight: Body Mass Index (BMI) is a simple index of weight-for-height that is commonly used to
classify underweight, overweight and obesity in adults. It is defined as the weight in kilograms divided
2
by the square of the height in metres (kg/m ). Measuring overweight and obesity in children aged 5 to
14 years is challenging because there is not a standard definition of childhood obesity applied
worldwide. The new WHO Child Growth Standards, launched in April 2006 include BMI charts for
infants and young children up to age 5. However, WHO is currently developing an international
growth reference for school-age children and adolescents.
Partial breastfeeding: Infant receives other liquids or solids in addition to breastmilk before 6 months
of age
Peer support or mother-to-mother support: Peer or mother-to-mother support takes place one-onone or in groups, informally or formally, in a variety of settings including, but not limited to, chance
encounters (market place, bus stop, church meetings, community hall, maternity clinics, etc.),
telephone counselling, hospital and home visits, interactive presentations at service club meetings,
schools, universities, etc. One form of peer or mother-to-mother support is the support group. A
mother-to-mother support group is initiated and operated by a mother who facilitates the meeting.
She may have received training, but her primary qualification is that she is a mother with
breastfeeding experience. Mother-to-mother support is not about giving medical advice but about
sharing information, and raising doubts or concerns.
Policy: A policy is a high-level overall statement of general goals and acceptable procedures
especially of a governmental body to guide and determine present and future decisions. An IYCF
policy, therefore, would spell out Governments goals and procedures in ensuring optimal infant and
young child nutrition at various levels including in the health system and at the community level. A
policy spells out what should be implemented.
Prevention of Mother to Child Transmission (PMTCT): In the absence of any preventive
intervention, infants born to and breastfed by HIV-infected women have a 2540% chance of
acquiring HIV infection. This can happen during pregnancy, during labour and delivery, or after
delivery via breastfeeding. The risk of mother-to-child transmission (MTCT) can be reduced through
the complementary approaches of antiretroviral therapy for the mother and infant, implementation of
safe delivery practices, and use of safer infant feeding practices.
Predominant breastfeeding: Infant receives certain liquids (water and water-based drinks, fruit
juice), ritual fluids and ORS, vitamins, minerals, medicines) in addition to breastmilk
Prophylaxis: Women may receive antiretroviral (ARV) drugs during pregnancy as part of potent
combination regimens used to treat their HIV infection or as prophylaxis to prevent HIV infection in
infants.
ARV
treatment
for
women
benefits
their
health
but
also
substantially reduces the risk of MTCT. All efforts should be made to ensure that
all women who require ARV treatment have access to it.
Provider-initiated or opt-out testing: Testing for HIV that is routinely offered, for example in antenatal or delivery care services for women or for inpatients. Clients are offered the test and can
specifically decline to be tested. Once they accept the test, they are offered pre and post-test
counselling.
Ready to use foods (RUF): Are energy-dense, mineral and vitamin-enriched foods that deliver
precise quantities of macro and micronutrients and are therefore ideally suited to the treatment of the
various types of under-nutrition. These foods come in the form of oil-based pastes with the texture of
peanut butter. They have a very low moisture content and because of this they do not spoil and can
be stored in simple packaging in tropical climates. As they can be eaten straight from the pack and do
not require cooking or dilution with water, the labour and fuel demands on poor households are
minimised. RUF can also be designed for other purposes such as the treatment of adults living with
HIV or prevention of severe or chronic malnutrition in children under two. They can be made from a
variety of cereals and legumes including peanuts, chickpeas, sesame seeds, maize and soybeans
151
and can therefore be designed to take advantage of ingredients that are the most cost-effective in a
given area. The technique for making RUF is very simple and requires basic production processes
and technology that is generally available in developing countries.
Ready to use infant formula (RUIF): Are products that represent an option to feed infants,
especially those less than six months old, with no possibility to be breastfed, in a manner that may be
safer than feeding powdered infant formula. They are safer because they do not need to be mixed
with water, but still pose risks of contamination if fed in bottles rather than cups or if diluted with
water. These products are particularly relevant in emergencies.
Relactation: Re-establishing breastfeeding after a mother has stopped, whether in the recent or
distant past.
Replacement feeding: The process of feeding a child who is not receiving any breastmilk with a diet
that provides all the nutrients the child needs until the child is fully fed on family foods. During the first
six months this should be with a suitable breastmilk substitute. After six months it should be with a
suitable breastmilk substitute, as well as complementary foods made from appropriately prepared and
nutrient-enriched family foods.
Responsive feeding: Feeding infants directly and assisting older children when they feed
themselves, being sensitive to their hunger and satiety cues.
Rooming-in: A baby staying in the same room as his mother.
Severe Acute Malnutrition (SAM): Malnutrition defined by a very low weight for height (WHZ below
three z scores of the median WHO growth standards), MUAC less than 115 mm, by visible severe
wasting, or by the presence of nutritional oedema.
Social marketing: The application of marketing techniques to achieve specific behavioural goals for
a social good.Social marketing campaigns may bemultifaceted approaches fora variety of audiences,
including mothers, their families and health care providers and their community. They are particularly
effective if part of a comprehensive communication strategy around IYCF.
Social mobilization:A process that engages and motivates a wide range of partners and allies at
national and local levels to raise awareness of and demand for a particular development objective
through face-to-face dialogue. Members of institutions, community networks, civic and religious
groups and others work in a coordinated way to reach specific groups of people for dialogue with
planned messages. In other words, social mobilization seeks to facilitate change through a range of
players engaged in interrelated and complementary efforts.
Social protection programme: Social protection involves policies and programs that protect people
against risk and vulnerability, mitigate the impacts of shocks, and support people who suffer from
chronic incapacities to secure basic livelihoods. It can also build assets, reducing both short-term and
intergenerational transmission of poverty. It includes social insurance (such as health, life, and asset
insurance, which may involve contributions from employers and/or beneficiaries); social assistance
(mainly cash, food, vouchers, or subsidies); and services (such as maternal and child health and
nutrition programs). Interventions that provide training and credit for income-generating activities also
have a social protection component.
Spillover: A term used to designate the feeding behaviour of new mothers who either know that they
are HIV-negative or are unaware of their HIV status they do not breastfeed, or they breastfeed for a
short time only, or they mix-feed, because of unfounded fears about HIV or of misinformation or of the
ready availability of breastmilk substitutes.
Strategy: A strategy sets out how the goals will be achieved and the selected interventions will be
implemented.
Supplementary feeding (SF): Provision of an additional food ration for moderately malnourished
children or adults - targeted SF; or to the most nutritionally vulnerable groups - blanket SF.
Stunting: Stunting, or chronic undernutrition, is a form of undernutrition. It is defined by a height-forage (HAZ) z-score below two SDs of the median WHO standards. Stunting is a result of prolonged or
152
repeated episodes of undernutrition starting before birth. This type of undernutrition is best addressed
through preventive maternal health and nutrition programmes aimed at pregnant women, and
improved infant and young child feeding of children under age 2, especially complementary feeding.
Supplements: Drinks or artificial feeds given in addition to breastmilk after the age of six months
Ten Steps to Successful Breastfeeding: Ten activities for support for breastfeeding in maternity
services, distilled from successful clinical experiences in protecting, promoting and supporting
breastfeeding in maternity services in a wide range of settings, both developing and industrialized
country
Trials of Improved Practices (TIPS): TIPs is a formative research tool to help programme planners
select and pre-test the actual practices that the programme will promote. Mothers and other family
members try out and sometimes modify a menu of possible improved practices prepared on the basis
of previous community research. In the case of infant feeding, recommendations are tested in homes
by discussing and negotiating specific practice changes, and following up to record the mothers and
childrens experiences with and reactions to the new practices. This method is also referred to as
household trials.
Undernourished: A classification that indicates undernutrition such as stunting, underweight, or
wasting.
Undernutrition: A consequence of a deficiency in nutrient intake and/or absorption in the body. The
different forms of undernutrition that can appear isolated or in combination are acute malnutrition
(bilateral pitting edema and/or wasting), chronic malnutrition (stunting), underweight (combined form
of wasting and stunting), and micronutrient deficiencies.
Underweight: A composite form of undernutrition including elements of stunting and wasting and is
defined by a weight-for-age z-score (WAZ) below 2 standard deviations of the median (WHO
standards). This indicator is commonly used in growth monitoring and promotion (GMP) and child
health and nutrition programmes aimed at the prevention and treatment of undernutrition.
Young child: A person from the age of more than 12 months up to the age of 36 months.
153
References
1.
WHO/UNICEF. Global Strategy for Infant and Young Child Feeding. 2003.
154
20. American Academy of Pediatrics, Work Group on Breastfeeding. Breastfeeding and the Use
of Human Milk, Pediatrics, 2005; 115(2): 496506.
21. Edmond, K et al. Delayed breastfeeding initiation increases risk of neonatal mortality.
Pediatrics 2006: 117(3):e380-6.
22. Mullany L. et al. Breastfeeding patterns, time to Initiation and mortality risk among newborns
in southern Nepal. The Journal of Nutrition 2008: 138; 599-603.
23. Singh K, Srivastava P. The effect of colostrum on infant mortality: Urban rural differentials.
Health and Population 1992;15(3&4):94100.
24. Lamberti LM, Fischer Walker CL, Noiman A, Victora C, Black RE. Breastfeeding and the risk
for diarrhea morbidity and mortality. BMC Public Health; Volume 11, Supplement 3; published
13 April 2011).
25. Arifeen, S. et al., Exclusive breastfeeding reduces acute respiratory infection and diarrhea
deaths among infants in Dhaka slums, Pediatrics, 2001; 108(4): E67.
26. Heinig MJ, Dewey KG. Health advantages of breastfeeding for infants: a critical review. Nutr
Res Rev 1996; 9: 89110.
27. Cushing, A. H. et al., Breastfeeding reduces risk of respiratory illness in infants, Am. J.
Epidemiol., 1998; 147(9): 863870.
28. Silfverdal et al, Protective effects of breastfeeding: an ecological study of haemophilus
influenzae (HI) meningitis and breastfeeding in a Swedish population. Int J Epidem 1999;
28:152-6.
29. Cochi SL, Fleming DW, Hightower AW, et al. Primary invasive Haemophilus influenzae type b
disease: a population-based assessment of risk factors. J Pediatr. 1986;108:997-896
30. Lucas, A. and T.J. Cole, Breast milk and neonatal necrotising enterocolitis, The Lancet,
1990; 336:15191523.
31. Pisacane A, et al Breastfeeding and Urinary Tract Infection J Pediatr 1992 120: 87-89.
32. Furman L. et al. The effect of maternal milk on neonatal morbidity of very low-birth-weight
infants, Arch. Pediatr. Adolesc. Med., 2003; 157:6671.
33. Oddy W.H., et al BMJ 1999;319:815-819 (25 September).
34. Heinig MJ. Host defense benefits of breastfeeding for the infant: effect of breastfeeding
duration and exclusivity. Pediatr Clin North Am, 2001; 48: 105123.
35. Uhari M, Matysaari K, Niemela M. A meta-analytic review of the risk factors for acute otitis
media. Clin Infect Dis 1996; 22: 10791083.
36. Moreland J, Coombs J. Promoting and supporting breast-feeding. Am Fam Physician
2000;61(7):2093-100, 103-4.
37. Heinig MJ, Dewey KG. Health advantages of breastfeeding for infants: a critical review. Nutr
Res Rev 1996; 9: 89110.
155
38. Akobeng AK et al. Effect of breastfeeding on risk of coeliac disease: a systematic review and
meta-analysis of observational studies. Archives of Diseases in Childhood, 2006, 91:39-43.
39. M.S. Eiger. MD, S. Wendkos Olds. The Complete Book of Breastfeeding 1999.
40. Neiva et al, J Pediatr (Rio J) 2003;79(1):07-12.
41. Loesche WJ, Nutrition and dental decay in infants. Am J Clin Nutr 41; 423-435, 1985.
42. WHO. Effect of breastfeeding on infant and child mortality due to infectious diseases in less
developed countries: a pooled analysis. Collaborative Study Team on the role of
breastfeeding on the prevention of infant mortality. The Lancet, 2000, 355:451455.
43. Villalpando S, Lopez-Alarcon M. Growth Faltering is Prevented by Breastfeeding in
Underprivileged Infants in Mexico City. J Nutr. Mar 1997; 127(3):436-43.
44. Froozani MD, Permehzadeh K, Motlagh AR, Golestan B. Effect of breastfeeding education
on the feeding pattern and health of infants in their first 4 months in the Islamic Republic of
Iran. Bull World Health Organ. 1999; 77(5):381-5.
45. Arifeen SE, Black RE, Caulfield LE, Antelman G, Baqui AH. Determinants of infant growth in
the slums of Dhaka: size and maturity at birth, breastfeeding and morbidity. Eur J Clin Nutr.
2001 Mar; 55(3):167-78.
46. Kramer MS, Guo T, Platt RW, Shapiro S, Collet JP, Chalmers B, Hodnett E, Sevkovskaya Z,
Dzikovich I, Vanilovich I; PROBIT Study Group. Breastfeeding and infant growth: biology or
bias? Pediatrics. 2002 Aug; 110(2 Pt 1):343-7.
47. WHO. HIV and Infant Feeding Technical Consultation held on behalf of the Inter-agency Task
Team (IATT) on prevention of HIV infections in pregnant women, mothers and their infants in
Geneva on October 25-27, 2006 (2007).
48. Ip S, Chung M, Raman G, et al. Breastfeeding and maternal and infant health outcomes in
developed countries. Rockville, MD: US Department of Health and Human Services, Agency
for Healthcare Research and Quality; 2007.
49. Chen A, Rogan WJ. Breastfeeding and the risk of postneonatal death in the United States.
Pediatrics. 2004 May;113(5):e435-9.
50. Jonville-Ber, A. et al., Sudden unexpected death in infants under 3 months of age and
vaccination status A case-control study. Br. J. Clin. Pharmaco., March 2001; 51(3): 271
276.
51. McVea, K.L., P. D. Turner and D.K. Peppler, The role of breastfeeding in sudden infant death
syndrome. J. Hum. Lact., Feb. 2000; 16(1): 1320.
52. Schellscheidt, J., A. Ott and G. Jorch. Epidemiological features of sudden infant death after a
German intervention campaign in 1992. Eur. J. Pediatr., Aug. 1997; 156(8): 655660.
53. Shu X-O, et al. Breastfeeding and the risk of childhood acute leukemia. J Natl Cancer Inst
1999; 91: 1765-72.
54. An Exploratory Study of Environmental and Medical Factors Potentially Related to Childhood
Cancer. Medical & Pediatric Oncology, 1991; 19(2):115-21.
156
157
72. Heinig MJ, Dewey KG. Health advantages of breastfeeding for mothers: a critical review. Nutr
Res Rev 1997; 10: 3556.
73. Labbok MH. Effects of breastfeeding on the mother. Pediatr Clin North America 2001; 48:
143158.
74. Collaborative Group on Hormonal Factors in Breast Cancer (2002). Breast cancer and
breastfeeding: collaborative reanalysis of individual data from 47 epidemiological studies in
30 countries, including 50,302 women with breast cancer and 96,973 women without the
disease. The Lancet 360: 187-95
75. Kalwart HJ and Specker BL Bone mineral loss during lactation and recovery after weaning.
Obstet. Gynecol. 1995; 86:26-32
76. Blaauw, R. et al. Risk factors for development of osteoporosis in a South African population.
SAMJ 1994; 84:328-32
77. Ip S, Chung M, Raman G, et al. Breastfeeding and maternal and infant health outcomes in
developed countries. In: Evidence Report/Technology Assessment Number 153: Agency for
Healthcare Research and Quality; April 2007.
78. Davies, H.A. Insulin Requirements of Diabetic Women who Breastfeed. British Medical
Journal, 1989.
79. Dewey KG, Heinig MJ, Nommwen LA. Maternal weight-loss patterns during prolonged
lactation. Am J Clin Nutr 1993;58:162-166.
80. M. Sears, R.N. and Wm. Sears, M.D. The Breastfeeding Book, Copyright 2000, Little Brown
and Co.
81. Helena Ribe, Banco Mundial, Nutricion, Guatemala. 2005.
82. Victora, C., Barros, F., Horta, B., Martorell R. Short-term benefits of catch-up growth for
small-for-gestational-age infants. Int J Epidemiol 2001: 30: 132530.
83. World Bank. Repositioning Nutrition in Development (2005).
84. Hoddinott J et al. Effect of a nutrition intervention during early childhood on economic
productivity in Guatemalan adults. The Lancet 2008: 371: 411-416.
85. Indicators for Assessing Infant and Young Child Feeding Practices: Part 1: Definitions. WHO,
UNICEF, USAID, AED, UCDAVIS, IFPRI (2008).
86. WHO. Guiding principles for complementary feeding of the breastfed child. 2003.
87. WHO, UNICEF and Partners. Indicators for assessing infant and young child feeding
practices. Part 3: country profiles. World Health Organization. 2010.
88. UNICEF. Tracking Progress on Child and Maternal Undernutrition. A Survival and
Development Priority. November 2009
89. Innocenti Declaration on the Protection, Promotion and Support for Breastfeeding. 1990
90. Convention on the Rights of the Child. 1989. (see article 24).
158
159
107. Ferguson E.L., Darmon N., Fahmida U., Fitriyanti S., Harper T.B. & Premachandra I.M.
Design of optimal food-based complementary feeding recommendations and identification of
key problem nutrients using goal programming. Journal of Nutrition 2006: 136: 23992404.
108. Moursi M., Mbemba F. & Treche S. Does the consumption of amylase-containing gruels
impact on the energy intake and growth of Congolese infants? Public Health Nutrition 2003:
6: 249258.
109. Santos I., Victora C.G., Martines J., Goncalves H., Gigante D.P., Valle N.J. et al. Nutrition
counselling increases weight gain among Brazilian children. Journal of Nutrition 2001: 131:
28662873.
110. Zlotkin S., Antwi K.Y., Schauer C. & Yeung G. Use of microencapsulated iron (II) fumarate
sprinkles to prevent recurrence of anemia in infants and young children at high risk. Bulletin
of the World Health Organization 2003: 81: 108115.
111. Adu-Afarwuah S, Lartey A, Brown KH, Zlotkin S, Briend A, Dewey KG. Randomized
comparison of 3 types of micronutrient supplements for home fortification of complementary
foods in Ghana: effects on growth and motor development. Am J Clin Nutr 2007: 86(2):41220.
112. Dhingra P., Menon V.P., Sazawal S., Dhingra U., Marwah D., Sarkar A. et al. Effect of
fortification of milk with zinc and iron along with vitamins C, E,A and selenium on growth, iron
status and development in preschool children a community-based double-masked
randomized trial. Report from the 2nd World Congress of Pediatric Gastroenterology,
Hepatology and Nutrition 3-7 July 2004: Paris, France.
113. Avula R., Frongillo EA, Arabi M., Sharma S. and Schultink W. Enhancements to Nutrition
Program in Indian Integrated Child Development Services Increase Child Growth and Energy
Intake. (accepted for publication by Journal of Nutrition in January 2010)
114. Rivera J.A., Sotres-Alvarez D., Habicht J.P., Shamah T. & Villalpando S. Impact of the
Mexican program for education, health, and nutrition (Progresa) on rates of growth and
anemia in infants and young children: a randomized effectiveness study. Journal of the
American Medical Association 2004: 291: 25632570.
115. Rivera JA, Martorell R, Ruel MT, Habicht JP, Haas JD. Nutritional supplementation during
the preschool years influences body size and composition of Guatemalan adolescents. J
Nutr. 1995 Apr;125 (4 Suppl):1068S-1077S.
116. Behrman, J., and J. Hoddinott. 2000. An Evaluation of the Impact of PROGRESA on PreSchool Child Height. July. International Food Policy Research Institute, Washington, D.C.
117. UNICEF. Progress for Children. A World Fit for Children Statistical Review. Number 9.
September 2010
118. Dancer D, Rammohan A, Smith MD. Infant mortality and child nutrition in Bangladesh.
Health Econ. 2008 Sep; 17(9):1015-35.
119. Wamani et al. Boys are more stunted than girls in Sub-Saharan Africa: a meta-analysis of 16
Demographic and Health Surveys. BMC Paediatrics 2007: 7:17.
160
120. Smith, L. C., U. Ramakrishnan, et al. (2003). The Importance of Women's Status for Child
Nutrition in Developing Countries. Household decisions, gender, and development: A
synthesis of recent research. A. R. Quisumbing, Washington, D.C.
121. Cleland, John G., and Jeroen K. van Ginneken. Maternal Education and Child Survival in
Developing Countries: The search for pathways of influence. Social Science and Medicine,
vol. 27, no. 12, 1988, pp. 13571368.
122. WHO. Indicators for Assessing breastfeeding practices. Report of an informal meeting, 1112 June 1991. Geneva, Switzerland. 1991.
123. WHO/UNICEF/USAID/AED/FANTA/UC Davis/IFPRI. Indicators for assessing infant and
young child feeding practices. Part II. Measurement. 2010.
124. Pelto, G. Levitt, E and Thairu L. Improving feeding practices: current patterns, common
constraints, and the design of interventions. Food and Nutrition Bulletin 2003: 24(1):45-82.
125. Moore, A., Akhter, S. and Aboud, F. Responsive complementary feeding in rural
Bangladesh. Social Science and Medicine 2006: 62(8): 1917-1930.
126. UNAIDS/UNFPA/UNICEF/WHO Guidelines on HIV and infant feeding 2010. Principles and
recommendations for infant feeding in the context of HIV and a summary of evidence. 2010.
127. Horton, S., et al. Scaling up Nutrition: What will it cost? The World Bank (2010).
128. United States Government Accountability Office. Report to Congressional Addressees:
Some strategies used to market infant formula may discourage breastfeeding. State contracts
should better protect against misuse of the WIC name. (Feb. 2006 GAO-06-282)
129. Foss, K, and Southwell, B. Infant feeding and the media: the relationship between Parents
Magazine content and breastfeeding 1972-2000. International Breastfeeding Journal 2006:
1:10.
130. C3 Maternity Protection Convention, 1919. http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/cgi-lex/convde.pl?C003; C103
Maternity Protection Convention (Revised), 1952. http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/cgi-lex/convde.pl?C103;
C183 Maternity Protection Convention, 2000 http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/cgi-lex/convde.pl?C183
131. R95 Maternity Protection Recommendation,1952. http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/cgilex/convde.pl?R095; R191 Maternity Protection Recommendation, 2000.
http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/cgi-lex/convde.pl?R191
132. Avula R., Frongillo EA, Arabi M., Sharma S. and Schultink W. Enhancements to Nutrition
Program in Indian Integrated Child Development Services Increase Child Growth and Energy
Intake. (accepted for publication by Journal of Nutrition in January 2010).
133. WHO/UNICEF/AED/USAID: Learning from large-scale community-based programmes to
improve breastfeeding practices. Report of ten-country case study. 2008.
134. WHO/UNICEF. Strengthening action to improve feeding of infants and young children 6-23
months of age in nutrition and child health programmes (2008).
135. Kim F. Michaelsen, Kathryn G. Dewey2, Ana B. Perez-Exposito, Mulia Nurhasan, Lotte
Lauritzen, Nanna Roos. Food sources and intake of n-6 and n-3 fatty acids in low-income
countries with emphasis on infants, young children (624 months), and pregnant and
161
lactating women. Maternal & Child Nutrition. Special Issue: Fatty Acid Nutrition in Early Life,
Volume 7, Issue Supplement 2, pages 124140, April 2011.
136. Mensah, P. and A. Tomkins, Household-level technologies to improve the availability and
preparation of adequate and safe complementary foods, Food and Nutrition Bulletin, vol. 24,
no. 1, 2003, pp. 104-125.
137. Randolph, T. et al. Role of livestock in human nutrition and health for poverty reduction in
developing countries. Journal of Animal Science2007:85 (11): 2788-2801.
138. Ianotti, L. et al. Improving diet quality and micronutrient nutrition, homestead food
production in Bangladesh. IFPRI 2009.
139. Maundu, P. 2003. IPGRI report: African Leafy Vegetable Promotion Forum, (March 26-28,
2003).
140. Hertzler, A. A. & Frary, R. B. Effect of instruction and family attributes on iron intake of
expanded food and nutrition education homemakers. Topics in Clinical Nutrition. 4(1): 27-35,
1989.
141. Bowering, J. Role of EFNEP aides in improving diets of pregnant women. J Nutr Educ. 8(3):
111-117, 1976.
142. Cadwallader, A. A. & Olson, C. M. use of a breastfeeding intervention by nutrition
paraprofessionals. J Nutr Educ. 18(3): 117-122, 1986.
143. Ramakrishnan U., Nguyen P., and Martorell R. Effects of micronutrients on growth of
children under 5 y of age: meta-analyses of single and multiple nutrient interventions. Am J
Clin Nutr 2009;89:191203.
144. Zlotkin SH, Schauer C, Christofides A, Sharieff W, Tondeur MC, Hyder SM. Micronutrient
sprinkles to control childhood anaemia. PLoS Med. Jan 2005;2(1):e1.
145. Rasmi Avula, Edward A. Frongillo, Mandana Arabi, Sheel Sharma and Werner Schultink.
Enhancements to Nutrition Program in Indian Integrated Child Development Services
Increase Child Growth and Energy Intake. J Nutr. 2011 Apr 1;141(4):680-4. Epub 2011 Feb
23.
146. Guidelines for Selective Feeding: the Management of Malnutrition in Emergencies.
UNHCR/WFP (2009).
147. Codex Alimentarius: Standard for processed cereal-based foods for infants and young
children (CODEX STAN 74-1981, Rev.1-2006); Guidelines on formulated supplementary
foods for older infants and young children (CAC/GL 8-1991).
148. GAIN. Nutritional guidelines for complementary foods and supplements supported by GAINs
Infant and Young Child Nutrition (IYCN) program (not yet released, under review).
149. Bassett. Can Conditional Cash Transfer Programs Play a Greater Role in Reducing Child
Undernutrition? SP discussion paper 0834, 2008, the World Bank.
150. Lechtig, Aaron, et al., Decreasing Stunting, Anemia, and Vitamin A Deficiency in Peru:
Results of the Good Start in Life Program, Food and Nutrition Bulletin 2009 Mar;30(1):37-48.
162
151. Habicht JP, Martorell R, Rivera JA Nutritional impact of supplementation in the INCAP
longitudinal study: analytic strategies and inferences. J Nutr. 1995 Apr;125(4 Suppl):1042S1050S
152. Behrman, J. and Hoddinott J.An Evaluation of the Impact of PROGRESA on Pre-School
Child Height.International Food Policy Research Institute. 2000.
153. Palombi, L., et al. Treatment acceleration and the experience of the DREAM program in
prevention of mother-to-child transmission of HIV. AIDS 2007: 21(S4): 565571.
154. Jackson, J., et al. Intrapartum and neo-natal single-dose nevirapine compared with
zidovudine for prevention of mother to child transmission of HIV-1 in Kampala, Uganda: 18month follow- up of the HIVNET 012 randomized trial. The Lancet 2003: 362(9387):859-868.
155. David Gordon, Shailen Nandy, Christina Pantazis, Simon Pemberton and Peter Townsend.
The Distribution of Child Poverty in the Developing World. Report to UNICEF. 2003.
156. WHO/PAHO. Guiding Principles for Feeding of the Breastfed Child. 2003.
157. WHO. Guiding Principles for Feeding of the Non-Breastfed Child. 2005
158. Lutter, Chessa, K. Macrolevel approaches to improve the availability of complementary
foods. Food and Nutrition Bulletin, vol. 24, no. 1, 2003.
159. DAdamo, M and Kols, A. A Tool for Sharing Internal Best Practices. USAID INFO Project
(2005).
160. UNICEF/AED. Infant and Young Child Feeding Programme Review: Consolidated Report of
Six-Country Review of Breastfeeding Programmes. 2010.
161. Fairbank l. et al. A systematic review to evaluate the effectiveness of interventions to
promote the initiation of breastfeeding (Cochrane Review) Health Technology Assessment
2000: 4 (25) 1-171.
162. DiGirolamo AM, Grummer-Strawn LM, Fein S. Maternity care practices: implications for
breastfeeding. Birth 2001; 28 (2):94100.
163. Ip, H., Hyder, S.,Haseen, F., Rahman, M., and Zlotkin, S. Improved adherence and anemia
cure rates with flexible administration of micronutrient Sprinkles: a new public health
approach to anemia control. European Journal of Clinical Nutrition 2009: 63(2) 65-73.
164. Stoltzfus R., Dreyfuss M.L. Guidelines for the Use of Iron Supplements to Prevent and Treat
Anaemia. WHO/UNICEF/INACG.1998.
165. WHO/UNICEF/WFP. Preventing and controlling micronutrient deficiencies in populations
affected by an emergency. Multiple vitamin and mineral supplements for pregnant and
lactating women, and for children aged 6 to 59 months. 2007.
166. UNHCR/WFP Guidelines for Selective Feeding: the Management of Malnutrition in
Emergencies. (2009).
167. Learning from Large-Scale Community-based Programmes to Improve Breastfeeding
Practices: Report of ten-country case study. WHO/UNICEF/AED/USAID (2008).
163
168. WHO. Community-based Strategies for Breastfeeding Promotion and Support in Developing
Countries. 2003.
169.Bhattacharyya K, Winch P, LeBan K, Tien M. Community health worker incentives and
disincentives: How they affect motivation, retention, and sustainability. BASICS Project for
USAID. (October 2001).
170. IASC/ENN. Integration of IYCF into CMAM. 2009. Facilitators Guide and handouts for
participants. 1 - 2 day orientation on IYCF counselling in the context of community based
programmes for management of severe acute malnutrition.
171. Kraisid Tontisirin and Stuart Gillespie. Linking Community-based Programs and Service
Delivery for Improving Maternal and Child Nutrition. Asian Development Review, vol. 17, nos.
1,2, pp. 33-65.
172. Lutter, C. K., Macro-level approaches to improve the availability of complementary foods.
Food and Nutrition Bulletin 2003: 24(1):83-103.
173. Stone-Jimnez, Maryanne, and Irma (Mimi) de Maza. Mother-to-Mother Support Groups:
The Periurban Model. In The Proceedings of an International Conference on Communication
Strategies to Support Infant and Young Child Nutrition. Edited by Peggy Koniz- Booher.
Cornell International Nutrition Monograph Series Numbers 24 and 25, 1993, p. 103-115.
174. Wiessinger, Diane. Watch Your Language in Journal of Human Lactation, Vol. 12, No. 1,
1996.
175.WHO/UNICEF/UNAIDS/UNFPA: HIV transmission through breastfeeding: A review of
available evidence (2007).
176. WHO: HIV and infant feeding: update based on the technical consultation held on behalf of
the Inter-agency Team (IATT) on Prevention of HIV Infections in Pregnant Women, Mothers
and their Infants, Geneva, 25-27 October 2006. 2007.
177. WHO. Summary of Evidence for the Revised WHO Principles and Recommendations on
HIV and Infant Feeding (2010).
178. Palombi, L., et al. Treatment acceleration and the experience of the DREAM program in
prevention of mother-to-child transmission of HIV. AIDS 2007: 21(S4): 565571.
179. Jackson, J., et al. Intrapartum and neo-natal single-dose nevirapine compared with
zidovudine for prevention of mother to child transmission of HIV-1 in Kampala, Uganda: 18month follow- up of the HIVNET 012 randomized trial. The Lancet 2003: 362(9387):859-868.
180. UNAIDS/UNFPA/UNICEF/WHO Guidelines on HIV and infant feeding 2010. Principles and
recommendations for infant feeding in the context of HIV and a summary of evidence, 2010.
181. WHO. Revised WHO recommendations on the use of antiretroviral drugs for treating
pregnant women and preventing HIV infection in infants (2009).
182. WHO. HIV and Infant Feeding Technical Consultation held on behalf of the Inter-agency
Task Team (IATT) on prevention of HIV infections in pregnant women, mothers and their
infants in Geneva on October 25-27, 2006 (2007).
183. UNICEF. Infant feeding and mother to child transmission of HIV. Operational guidance note.
2002.
164
184. The Sphere Project. Humanitarian Charter and Minimum Standards in Humanitarian
Response, 2011.
185. Rpublique d'Hati, Ministre de la Sant Publique et de la Population. Points de conseil en
nutrition pour bb. Directives Nationales (revised July 2010). An English, generic version is
being produced by UNICEF HQ.
186. Block, Steven et al. Macro shocks and micro outcomes: child nutrition during Indonesias
crisis. Economics and Human Biology 2004: 2:2144.
187. WHO/UNICEF/WFP. Preventing and controlling micronutrient deficiencies in populations
affected by an emergency: Multiple vitamin and mineral supplements for pregnant and
lactating women, and for children aged 6 to 59 months. 2007.
165