Indira Gandhi

National Open University

School of Computer and
Information Sciences

MCS-014
SYSTEMS ANALYSIS
AND DESIGN

Block

IMPLEMENTATION AND SECURITY OF

SYSTEMS & MIS
UNIT 11
Implementation and Maintenance of Systems

UNIT 12
Audit and Security of Computer Systems

16

UNIT 13
Management Information Systems

31

Programme / Course Design Committee

Prof. Sanjeev K. Aggarwal, IIT, Kanpur
Prof. M. Balakrishnan, IIT , Delhi
Prof. Harish Karnick, IIT, Kanpur
Prof. C. Pandurangan, IIT, Madras
Dr. Om Vikas, Sr. Director, MIT
Prof P. S. Grover, Sr. Consultant
SOCIS, IGNOU

Faculty of School of Computer and

Information Sciences
Shri Shashi Bhushan
Shri Akshay Kumar
Prof Manohar Lal
Shri V.V. Subrahmanyam
Shri P. Venkata Suresh

Block Preparation Team

Shri M.P.Goel (Content Editor)
Principal Systems Analyst (Retd)
National Informatics Centre
New Delhi
Mr.Akshay Kumar Purohit
Deputy Director (IT)
Bureau of Indian Standards
New Delhi

Shri P. Venkata Suresh

SOCIS, IGNOU
Prof. M.R.Dua
New Delhi

Language
Editors

Prof. Sunaina Kumar

SOH, IGNOU

Course Coordinator : P. Venkata Suresh

Block Production Team

Shri H.K Som, SOCIS

Acknowledgements
To all the faculty of SOCIS, IGNOU for their comments on the course material;
to Shri Vikas Kumar for help in finalizing the CRC.

April, 2004
Indira Gandhi National Open University, 2004
ISBN-81-266-1199-5
All rights reserved. No part of this work may be reproduced in any form, by mimeograph or any other means,
without permission in writing from the Indira Gandhi National Open University.
Further information on the Indira Gandhi National Open University courses may be obtained from the
Universitys office at Maidan Garhi, New Delhi-110 068.
Printed and published on behalf on the Indira Gandhi National Open University, New Delhi by The Director,
SOCIS.

BLOCK INTRODUCTION
This block is on implementation and security of systems and management information systems.
Automation of manual processes in any organization is the order of the day. Apart from just
developing the software which may be information systems , the security of the transactions is
very important. In the absence of security, there is no value to the software. Though the software
is developed in modules, ultimate integration of modules and their implementation is doubtful in
most of the cases and effort is need to succeed in implementation. Implementation not only
includes running the software successfully at the client site , but also includes the training of users
etc. which are essential for the application of the system successfully. There are several
information systems which help the management of an organization to take decisions, which give
the entire performance of their organization concisely.
This block consists of 3 units and is organized as follows:
Unit - 11 focuses on the implementation aspects of information systems. The aspects that are
covered include conducting system tests, installing databases, preparing user manuals and
converting from existing system to new system, if applicable.
Unit - 12 deals with audit and security of computer systems. The meaning of audit is explained
and various threats that are faced by computer systems are discussed along with solutions to these
problems.
Unit - 13 explains the role of management information systems in an organization. Also, different
categories of information systems that are used in organizations are covered in this unit.

UNIT 11 IMPLEMENTATION AND

MAINTENANCE OF SYSTEMS

Implementation and
Maintenance of
Systems

Structure
11.0
11.1
11.2

Introduction
Objectives
Implementation of Systems
11.2.1
11.2.2
11.2.3
11.2.4
11.2.5
11.2.6

11.3

Maintenance of Systems
11.3.1
11.3.2

11.4
11.5
11.6

11.0

Conducting System Tests

Preparing Conversion Plan
Installing Database
Training the End Users
Preparing User Manual
Converting to the New System
Different Maintenance Activities
Issues Involved in Maintenance

Summary
Solutions/Answers
Further Readings

INTRODUCTION

Implementation and Maintenance of System brings the SDLC life cycle to an end.
After the design phase is over, actual writing of computer program as per the design
specification and testing the system as a single entity called system testing which
actually differs from the unit and module testing carried out during program
development stage is carried out. A detailed conversion plan is the design to change
over from the existing system to the new system. A properly designed conversion plan
ensures a smooth transition to the new system. Database is designed, created and
installed by using the existing data from the old system or by creating data manually.
Appropriate training of the end user is important as the success of any system depends
on the involvement of end user who is actually going to use the system. A
comprehensive user manual is prepared outlining the procedural things to use the
system. Actual conversion to the new system can be either in phased manner or in just
one instance depending on the situation. Maintenance of the system after
implementation is a major activity considering the total life of a software product.
Maintenance is important to make the system current and relevant in a changing
organizational environment.

11.1

OBJECTIVES

After going through this unit, you should be able to:

conduct System tests;

prepare Conversion plans;
install Databases;
train the End Users;
prepare User Manual;
move to the New System; and
perform Various Maintenance Activities.

11.2

IMPLEMENTATION OF SYSTEMS

Implementation of system involves developing working computer software from the

design specification through coding by a team of programmers. Many times, the user

Implementation and
Security of Systems &
MIS

requirements are either not built-into the design specification or compromised to make
the design simple and manageable. Implementation of the system is done by coding,
testing and creating the necessary hardware and network environment, and imparts
training to the end users. Of course, apart from Coding and Testing, the running
implementation activities differ from project to project. This phase of the software
development requires intensive user involvement.

11.2.1

Conducting System Tests

No system can be perfect. Testing is of vital importance as all information systems are
designed by a team of Software Engineers and end users have little or no knowledge
of system development. Testing is done to bridge the gap between the perceived out
comes desired by the user to that of systems analysts and programming team. The
design specifications are requirements of the user and are translated to working
software by the programmer. Hence, it is the ability of the programmer to code
exactly as per the design specification that is to be judged by testing the software
module.
The objective of any testing mechanism is to discover and fix bugs before the product
is delivered to the customer. A good testing scheme has a high probability of
discovering an undiscovered error. The objective of any good testing scheme is to find
and fix bugs with minimum time and resources. Besides, bugs and errors systems are
tested for response time, volume of transactions that can be handled, stress under
which it can function, security and usability. For an Online Transaction Processing
System, testing of the system for response time could be quite vital.
System testing assumes that all parts of the system are correct and error-free. Even
though the system has been tested for individual components and modules, there is no
guarantee that the system after integration will work as per the desired specification.
System test involves a holistic approach for testing the working of the application in
totality.
The following are various types of System Testing:
Recovery Testing: Test the ability of the system to recover from errors. Errors or any
other processing faults must not cause overall system to fail. The recovery time of the
system after failure must be within a specific period and tolerance limit. System
failures are forced during this phase of testing by introducing exceptions to see how
the system responds to the case.
Security Testing: System used for processing sensitive information are prone to high
security risks. Individual often tries to access unauthorized data for various reasons.
Threats could be external or internal. Hacking of passwords is a common problem.
Individual can use software to generate random passwords to gain access of the
system. Security testing takes care of these aspects of the system security.
Stress Testing: Stress test is designed to test the system as to how the system behaves
in abnormal situation. The aim of the stress test is to find the limit of quantity or
frequency of input after which the system fails. Stress test cases are designed which
require maximum memory and other resources; in excess of what a normal situation
demands.
Performance Testing: Performance testing is specifically important to embedded
and real time systems. It checks the run time performance of the system. It is often
coupled with stress testing.
Response Testing: Testing of response time is of special importance in OLTP (online transaction processing systems like railway reservation system, points of sale,
6

etc.). Testing is done to measure the response time. The same is compared with
desired maximum response time.

Implementation and
Maintenance of
Systems

Usability and Documentation Testing: Testing is done to review the usability and
user friendliness of the software. Most often, systems are provided with on-line help
screen to help the end user. This also includes whether proper care had been taken to
document the development stage of the project. User friendliness of the system is
often compromised, which may lead to problem during implementation and
maintenance of the system.
The following are the various activities involved during system testing:
Preparation of Test Plan: The first step in system testing is to prepare a document
called a Test Plan. Test plan is a document which outlines the aspect of the system to
be tested. A workable Test Plan is prepared in accordance with the design
specification such as

Expected output from the system;

Criteria for evaluating the output;
Nature and Volume of test data; and
Procedure for using the test data.

Specifications of User Acceptance Test: User is involved to prepare test cases.

These can be derived from the test plan. Other parameters are test schedule, test
duration and the person delegated to carry out the user acceptance test.
Preparation of Test data for Testing: Test data are often generated during testing of
program. The test data must be true representative of the live data to be actually used
by the end users after installation. Care should be taken to select the nature and
volume of data.
Although enough care is taken to test the system as per the documented specification,
it is almost always a confusion regarding how the user will use the end product. In
case there is one customer (a specific application designed for a specific use), a series
of acceptance tests are carried out to validate all the user requirements. But this is not
possible if the software is to be used by many customers (general purpose software
like word processor, etc.). An alternate approach is application of Alpha and Beta
testing techniques.
Alpha Testing: Alpha testing is carried out by the customer at the developers site.
The customer uses the software and records the errors/bugs and usage problem. Alpha
testing is carried out in a controlled environment.
Beta Testing: Beta testing is carried out at one or more customer sites by the end
users. It is live testing of the software product and not controlled by the developer.
The customer tests the software using her/his own data records and reports the bugs or
problems in regular intervals to the developer.
Many organizations deploy specially trained personnel for system testing. The
problems of bugs uncovered in alpha and beta testing are fixed before the product is
shipped and installed in customers premises. Testing of complex software can be
time consuming and frustrating also. The aim of system testing is to uncover every
possible error that may come up at the user end. The role of Data Processing Auditor
(EDP auditors)/Information System Auditor is quite involved during all stages of
system development especially during testing. Auditors can provide useful
independent inputs to minimize complications during maintenance.
7

Implementation and
Security of Systems &
MIS

Check Your Progress 1

1. The first step in system testing is to prepare a document called
2. .. is designed to test the system as to how the system
behaves in abnormal situations.
3. In . live data is used in the customers real working environment.

11.2.2

Preparing Conversion Plan

A conversion plan is a document which spells out detailed requirements for a

successful conversion from existing system to proposed system. The complexity of
conversion is directly proportional to the complexity of the system in question. An
important role of Systems Analyst is to see that the newly designed system is
implemented to the set specification. Conversion is just one aspect of implementation,
other being software maintenance and system review.
A proper conversion plan ensures that conversion from old system to new system is
smooth without affecting the normal business operation. The conversion process can
be tedious and disrupt normal functioning of system and also involves financial and
human resources. A well designed conversion plan facilitates a smooth switch over to
the new system while keeping the cost and human involvement to the minimum.
A typical conversion plan is a document that consists of the following information:

Guidelines regarding Conversion processes involved and the roles of end user.
Planning conversion of files, creation of computer compatible files.
Types of conversion to be undertaken depending on the existing types of system.
It could be from an existing manual system to a newly designed system or from an
existing old computerized system to a newly designed enhanced system.
Types of conversion may be parallel, phased or direct.
Evaluation of hardware, software and related services.

11.2.3

Installing Database

Installation of database is nothing but creating computer readable files from the
existing systems/documents. Each installation involves data. The new system is going
to use data created either manually or data that has been obtained from the old system.
If the current system is using computer readable data, it must be made error free and
compatible for use in the new system. The data must be converted to the new format
supported by the current technology on which the system is being developed.
Usually, there will be upward compatibility between various versions of software. The
data conversion process can be tedious depending on the format supported by the new
system. Special software are designed to facilitate the installation of Database.

11.2.4

Training the End User

Training the user is one of the vital activities. The project team must make sure that
the end users are trained to operate the new system. Many systems fail to get
implemented or deliver the desired result because the end users are not trained.
Managers and the users must be trained on fundamentals of information technology in
addition to knowing the operation of the new system. Training and support form the
two crucial issues involving success of any information system. While training is
imparted in a fixed schedule, support is an ongoing process. In support activity, the
user is provided continual operational and technical support to carry out the work.
8

Support materials are developed to facilitate this task. The goal of any training and
support activity is to achieve highest possible productivity with lowest cost. Training
may involve the following activities:

Implementation and
Maintenance of
Systems

Entering the data into the system. Generating the required reports.
Basic training of computers not specific to the application program like copying a
file, starting and shutting down system, etc.
Briefing about Hardware and Software concepts.
Reporting non compliance and bugs in the program? Process of taking backup of
daily work.

There is no exhaustive list of training requirement of the end user and can vary
depending on the nature of application. The training must be scheduled in logical
sequence depending on the pre-requisite for the next module of the training. A
dependency chart could be useful for this purpose.
Training can be imparted in different ways:

Computer-aided training
Classroom tutorial
Interactive training manual
Resident technical expert
One to one training
External sources
Information center / help desk

Many organizations have a well-developed automated support mechanism for end

user support. To make a system success, following issues should be taken care of:

Develop a satisfactory support base for providing support to the user;

Obtain user participation and commitments;
Institutionalize the system of training; and
Insist on mandatory use of the information system.

Regular training should become part of the organizations policy as information

system changes as per the requirement of the organization and new features are added.

11.2.5

Preparing User Manual

All information systems are unique and different from one another. Documentation
starts from the day one of system development lifecycle, but preparation of end user
documentation is of specific importance as the end user does not understand the
intricacies of system development and hence operational problems are bound to occur.
Documentation of any information system is generally of two types. System
Documentation and User Documentation. System documentation contains detailed
information about systems design specification, its internal structure and related
technical details. The system documents are primarily for the programmer for
maintenance purpose. The user documentation on the other hand is for the end user.
The document should be structured and self-contained.
A user manual generally contains written as well as pictorial representation of the
information system about its working and application. A well-designed user manual
can reduce the overall cost of training and support. On-line help system with
hyperlinks and context sensitive help systems are slowly replacing bulky and noninteractive documents.
The following are the components of a User Manual:

Title and Version of software release

Implementation and
Security of Systems &
MIS

Table of contents
Salient features of the product
Installation Guide and System requirements
Getting started
Frequently asked questions
Sample scenario
Glossary of terms used in the manual
Known bugs in the applications

With changing technology, user documentation is often bundled to the information

system. It is separate document. On-line documentations are being extensively utilized
in user environments due to their convenience. Context sensitive helps are making the
users life easy by reducing the time to browse the bulky documents.

11.2.6

Converting to the New System

Actual conversion process involves equipments, personnel, data and financial

resources. The process of conversion from the existing system (manual or
computerized) to the newly developed system can be performed in several ways
depending on the criticality of the system and other related issues.

10

Direct Conversion: This is abrupt approach. The old system is shutdown and the
new system starts. This kind of conversion although economical, the users are at
the mercy of the new system, hence direct installation can be very risky. Some
times due to procedural reasons where two systems cant be run parallel, this kind
of conversion is the only option. When the new system fails, there is no way to
start the old system as a backup as it has been shutdown. This kind of conversion
plan is often the least preferred for critical business applications.

Pilot Conversion: This is the middle path approach. Instead of converting all at
once throughout the organization, this kind of pilot installation involves
conversion/installation of system at a single pre-decided location. The location
may be a branch office of the organization. Proper selection of the pilot site is
important as it should be able to perform a true conversion process to test all
functionalities of the new system. The advantage of the pilot conversion is that the
potential risk in case of failure of the system is limited to a single location. Once
the user is ascertained that the implementation of the system has been successful
in a particular location, it is proposed to replicate the system in other locations.
Although this kind of pilot conversion plan is beneficial for the user, it places a
substantial burden on the implementation team as it has to maintain two systems
in parallel.

Parallel Conversion: is least risk prone. Under this kind of conversion, the old
system is allowed to run alongside the new system until the management and the
end user are satisfied with the result of the new system. It is compared with the
new system to test whether the functionalities covered by the old system are
thoroughly covered in the new system by comparing the outputs. Errors and bugs
identified with the new system are not detrimental for normal functioning of the
organization as the new system is replaced and normal functions are resumed by
the old system. Parallel conversion is costly as two systems are run in parallel, but
results of only one system are used for business operations.

Phased Conversion: is an incremental approach to switch over to the new

system. Different sub-systems of the new system is used in conjunction until the
whole new system is converted. This kind of approach for conversion limits the
potential risk of failure of the new system. In a phased installation as a sub-system
is made functional, actual results are visible before the whole new system is made
functional.

Each conversion strategy not only involves data and software, but also other resources
like personnel, hardware, etc. Hardware and software selection is an important issue to
be considered before actually carrying the conversion.

Implementation and
Maintenance of
Systems

Check Your Progress 2

1. is an incremental approach to switch over to the new system.
2. . is nothing but creating computer readable files from the existing
systems/documents.
3. A .. is a document, which spells out detailed requirements for a successful
conversion.

11.3

MAINTENANCE OF SYSTEMS

Once the information system is successfully installed and started showing result, the
next issue is to maintain the system. System maintenance involves more than 80% of
the total life of a software product; this shows the importance of maintenance. System
maintenance is the task of monitoring, evaluating and modifying the information
system to make necessary desirable changes during the total life cycle of the software.
Organizational requirements as perceived during the analysis phase changes, the
system has to accommodate all such changes to make the system current and useful
for the organization. Maintenance of system also takes care of the failure and
shortcomings that arise during the operation of the information system by the end
user. During the implementation phase, one person from the system maintenance
group is nominated to collect information from the user for maintenances.
Maintenance activity involves collecting requests for changes, transforming these
requests to changes, designing the changes to be incorporated and implementing the
changes in the system.
Any maintenance activity comprises the following four key stages:

Help Desk: The problem is received from the user through a formal change
request. A preliminary analysis of the change request will be done, and if the
problem is sensible, it is accepted.

Analysis: Managerial and technical analyses of the problems are undertaken to

investigate the cost factors and other alternative solutions. Feasibility Analysis is
done to assess the impact of the modification, to investigate alternative solutions,
to assess short and long term costs, and to compute the benefit of making the
change.

Implementation: The chosen change/solution is implemented and tested by the

maintenance team. All infected components are to be identified and brought in to
the scope of the change. Unit test, integration test, user-oriented functional
acceptance tests and regression test strategies are provided.

Release: The changes are released to the customer, with a release note and
appropriate documentation giving details of the changes.

11.3.1

Different Maintenance Activities

Once the system is fully implemented and starts operating, the maintenance phase
begins. When the user starts operating the system, initial difficulty diminishes as the
user learns to operate the system. The maintenance may include modification of
system due to changes in business environment, government regulations, new
business ventures and enhancement of functionalities.

11

Implementation and
Security of Systems &
MIS

The majority of Software Maintenance activity is concerned with evolution derived

from user requested changes. A program that is used in a real world environment
necessarily must change or become progressively less useful in that environment. As
an evolving program changes, its structure tends to become more complex. Extra
resources must be devoted to preserving the semantics and simplifying the structure.
The following are the different types of maintenance activities:

Corrective Maintenance: This type of maintenance is to rectify design, coding

and implementation problems detected after the implementation of the System.
This kind of problem generally surfaces immediately after the system is
implemented. This type of problem needs immediate attention as it hampers the
day to day work of the end user. Proper planning and interaction with the end user
during system development process can minimize Corrective Maintenance. In
spite of the all these kinds of maintenance, these constitute more than 60 percent
of total maintenance effort. Corrective maintenance is very much undesirable. It
does not do any value addition to the software. Care should be taken to see that
normal business operations are not disturbed because of it.

Adaptive Maintenance: Changes are needed as a consequence of upgraded

versions or changes in operation system, hardware, or DBMS. Adaptive
maintenance is required because business operates on a social environment and
need of the organization changes as organization ventures in to new areas, or as
government regulation policy changes, etc. Maintenance of the software to adapt
to this kind of changes is called adaptive maintenance. Unlike corrective
maintenance, this kind of activity adds value to the information system and affects
a small part of the organization. This activity is not as urgent as corrective
maintenance as these changes are gradual and allow sufficient time to the system
group to make changes to the software.

Perfective Maintenance: This kind of maintenance activity involves adding new

functionalities and features to the software to make it more versatile and user
oriented. Some times, changes are made to improve performance of the software.
In some sense, this maintenance can be thought of as a new development activity.
This adds value to the information system and is required to stay ahead of the
competition.
75%

Adaptive Maintenance,
Perfective Maintenance
and Preventive
Maintenance

Corrective
Maintenance

25%

Figure 11.1: Comparative figures of maintenance effort.

12

Preventive Maintenance: Changes are made to software to make it easily

maintainable and to prevent any kind of system failure in future. This reduces the
need of corrective maintenance. As corrective maintenance could lead to hamper
normal functioning, preventive maintenance is done periodically to ensure that the
probability of system failure is minimized. Preventive maintenance could increase
the volume of transactions that can be handled by the system. Preventive
maintenance is done when the system is least used or not used at all. This does not
add value to the system, but certainly lowers the cost of corrective maintenance.

Figure 11.1 depicts the maintenance efforts that are to be put during each maintenance
activity.

11.3.2

Issues Involved in Maintenance

The responsibility of the software development team and clients does not end once the
product is released for implementation and installed. If software is not properly
maintained, a well-documented and cleanly designed system can decay into a poorly
documented and ill-maintained system. Additional venerability may get introduced
during the activity of maintenance. In a network environment, a bug has ramification
beyond just poor performance or functionalities. A bug can open up avenue for a
hostile intruder.

Implementation and
Maintenance of
Systems

It is very important that the Software should be easily maintainable. Factors like
availability of source code, availability of system manuals, etc., are very important
for maintainability. One of the most important issues is the cost factor for
maintenance of software. There are a number of factors that influence the cost of
maintenance. Maintenance activity may some times introduce new bugs while
rectifying it.
The following are various factors which affect the ease of maintenance:

Volume of Defects: The inherent errors / bugs that are found in the system after
installation. Cost of maintenance increases with the increase in volume of defects.

Number of Customers: More number of customers means more requests for

changes in the system after installation.

Availability of System Documentation: The quality and availability of system

documentation is vital to carry out the maintenance. Poorly written system
documentation increases the cost of maintenance. Most often, the programmers
for development are different than the team of programmers for maintenance and
the later often finds it difficult to understand a program written by the former.
Structured programming and program documentations are very useful in
maintaining the system

The following are various issues in Software Maintenance:

1. Organizational Issues

2.

The maintenance activity must align with organizational objectives.

Most of the Software Maintenance activity is resource consuming and it has
no clear quantifiable benefit for the organization.
Outsourcing the job of Software Maintenance

Process Issues

Software Maintenance requires a number of additional activities not

performed at development stage. Impact analysis and Regression tests on the
software changes are crucial issues

3. Technical Issues
How to construct software that it is easy to comprehend is a major issue and the
technology to do this is still not available. Still, the following are some guidelines
for the same:

Translate the problem into software terms to decide if it is viable or not.

Determine the origin of the change request and suggest solutions.
All solutions are investigated to determine that they are applied to all software
components affected.
Make a decision on the best implementation route or to make no change.
13

Implementation and
Security of Systems &
MIS

Ripple effect propagation is a phenomenon by which changes made to a software

component along the software life cycle have a tendency to be felt in other
components

Legacy System
A legacy system is typically a very old and large system which has been modified
heavily since it started operation. Legacy systems are based on old technology with
very little or no documentation. Dealing with a legacy system can be very hard.
Solutions for the problems mentioned above relating to a Legacy System:

Explore possibility of subcontracting the maintenance

Replace software with a package
Re-implement from scratch
Discard software and discontinue
Freeze maintenance and phase in new system
Reverse engineer the legacy system and develop a new software suite.

Check Your Progress 3

1. At , the problem is received from the user through a formal change
request, a preliminary analysis is done, and if the request is sensible, it is
accepted.
2. .. is performed to rectify problems in design, coding etc. detected after
the implementation of the System.
3. A ., is typically a very old and large system which has been modified
heavily since it started operation.

11.4

SUMMARY

Implementation of system involves coding, testing installation and user training.

System design specifications are converted to computer programs and database
structures are created. The programs are tested using a code walk through and by
creating different test scenarios. System testing is testing of the software in its totality
after individual modules had been tested. Different conversion plans are discussed like
software and hardware installation etc. Installation of a system is usually moving from
old system to a new system. Different methodology is adopted for conversion/
installation like direct conversion, parallel conversion, phased conversion, single
location conversion. User documentation is a written document of visual and textual
information about the application and how to use it. Well-designed user
documentation can reduce training cost of the organization. Training of user is vital
for success of any system. Training should be conducted after any significant changes
are made to the system
Software maintenance is the activity of modifying the software once it is delivered to
the customer depending of the requirement of the customer or to add additional
functionalities to the software. Software maintenance activity in general does not
provide any quantifiable benefit to the organization. Different maintenance activities
are adaptive maintenance, corrective maintenance, perfective maintenance and
preventive maintenance. Out of all maintenance activity, corrective maintenance
constitutes more than 60 percent of the total maintenance activity. Different issues
related to software maintenance are technical, organizational and procedural.

14

11.5

SOLUTIONS/ANSWERS

Implementation and
Maintenance of
Systems

Check Your Progress 1

1. Test Plan
2. Stress Test
3. Beta Testing
Check Your Progress 2
1. Phased Conversion
2. Installation Database
3. Conversion Plan
Check Your Progress 3
1. Help Desk
2. Corrective Maintenance
3. Legacy System

11.6

FURTHER READINGS

Joey George, J. Hoffer and Joseph Valacich; Modern Systems Analysis and Design,
Third Edition, 2001, Pearson Education.
Alan Dennis, Barbara Haley Wixom; Systems Analysis and Design, 2002, John Wiley
& Sons.
Reference Websites
http://www.rspa.com
http://www.dur.ac.uk/csm/jsm

15

Implementation and
Security of Systems &
MIS

UNIT 12

AUDIT AND SECURITY OF COMPUTER

SYSTEMS

Structure
12.0
12.1
12.2

Introduction
Objectives
Definition of Audit
12.2.1
12.2.2
12.2.3
12.2.4

12.3

Audit of Transactions on Computer

12.3.1
12.3.2
12.3.3
12.3.4

12.4

12.0

Analysis of Threats and Risks

Recovering from Disasters
Planning the contingencies
Viruses

Concurrent Audit Techniques

12.6.1
12.6.2
12.6.3
12.6.4
12.6.5

12.7
12.8
12.9

Audit Software
Test Data
Audit Expert Systems
Audit Trail

Computer System and Security issues

12.5.1
12.5.2
12.5.3
12.5.4

12.6

Transaction Audit
Audit of Computer Security
Audit of Application
Benefits of Audit

Computer Assisted Audit Techniques

12.4.1
12.4.2
12.4.3
12.4.4

12.5

Objectives of Audit
Responsibility and Authority of the System Auditor
Confidentiality
Audit Planning

Need for Concurrent Audit Techniques

An Integrated Test Facility Techniques
The Snapshot Technique
SCARF
Continuous and Intermittent Simulation Technique

Summary
Solutions/Answers
Further Readings

INTRODUCTION

Every business process can experience events that can hamper and in some cases may
stop normal operations of business. Even best designed system cant control the
prevention of natural disaster. In todays ever-changing world of information
assurance and network security, it can become extremely difficult to keep up on the
latest vulnerabilities, viruses, patches, trends, technology, hacker behaviors and
activity. Its easy for the information systems security professional to get caught up in
attending the logical aspects of security such as reviewing log files, making
configuration changes, troubleshooting, and other technical duties.

12.1

OBJECTIVES

After going through this unit, you should be able to:

16

control, Assess and Monitor your organizations information and business

systems;
know Factors that are looked into , during Audit;
learn about CAATs (Computer Assisted Audit Techniques);
apply Information System Architecture;
recover the Information Systems from disasters;

plan the contingencies in the event of disasters; and

protect Information Systems from Virus.

12.2

Audit and Security of

Computer Systems

DEFINITION OF AUDIT

This is an assessment of an information system performed by an information systems

professional or IS auditor to provide recommendations and advice to improve system
performance and security. Audit should be done regularly and the result should be
used to refine the system.
Is auditors are those people who make it sure that the system does what it is supposed
to do. Although the audit can be carried out by the internal team of IT professionals, it
is advisable that the audit is carried out by external auditors as they are neither
stakeholders nor friendly with the stakeholders. Above all there is nothing like an
unbiased opinion.
Information System auditor is a person who engages in Information system audits
with the following knowledge and abilities:
1. Basic knowledge of information systems.
2. Knowledge of system audits.
3. Ability to perform system audits.

12.2.1

Objectives of Audit

The following are the objectives of Audit:

To improve the quality of information systems, prevent failure and minimize the
effects of failure, and speed up the process of recovery in the event of a failure.
This will help Information System to be more reliable.
To make an information system more secure from natural as well as manmade
disasters, unauthorized access, and other destructive actions.
To improve the cost performance of an information system by optimum utilization
of its resources, which leads to increase in efficiency.

During the course of audit, the Information Systems Auditor will obtain sufficient,
reliable, relevant and useful evidence to achieve the audit objectives effectively. The
audit findings and conclusions are to be supported by appropriate analysis and
interpretation of this evidence.
To achieve the above objective, the following documents should be made available to
the auditors A diagram of the Information System (Application)
1. Network diagram
2. A hierarchical diagram of the project team

12.2.2

Responsibility and Authority of the System Auditor

The system auditor shall make the basis for each of his or her assessment clear. The
system auditor may demand data and materials from the division being audited. The
system auditor may also demand the head of an organization to issue a report on the
implementation of improvement to an audited division as suggested by him.
The system auditor shall firmly maintain professional ethics as an impartial evaluator.
The system auditor shall be aware of the ethical demands on himself or herself and
meet the internal and external trust by performing an accurate and sincere system
audit.
17

Implementation and
Security of Systems &
MIS

12.2.3

Confidentiality

The system auditor with strict adherence to professional ethics must maintain
confidentiality of the information provided to him to carryout his or her activity and
should not, without sufficient reason, divulge any information that is classified as
confidential information by the audited organization.

12.2.4

Audit Planning

The Information Systems Auditor has to plan the information systems audit work to
address the audit objectives and must comply with applicable professional auditing
standards.

Check Your Progress 1

1. What are the objectives of Audit?

2. ... are those people who make it sure that the system does
what it is supposed to do.
3.

CAAT stands for

12.3

AUDIT OF TRANSACTIONS ON COMPUTER

Audit can be broadly of two types namely auditing manual processes and audit
through computer. Audit through computer is important to find out the accuracy and
integrity of information system output. This types of audit are done by information
system expert and use test data to check the adequacy and accuracy of control
mechanism built-in to the system.
A typical audit looks at the following factors:
Audit of response time: In this audit the actual response time of the system verses
the desired response time is compared to the performance of the system
Audit of broken links: This is applicable to web site and other intranet applications.
The most irritating things on a web site is not finding a link document. There are
automated software to find broken/unavailable links on web site.
Database Audit: Database audits involve checking the database integrity and
availability. The information that is sent to the database should be checked with the
information actually stored on the database.
Network audit: Network audit involves checking the venerability of network. It
checks whether the network configuration is giving optimal performance or not.

12.3.1

Transaction Audit

Transaction audit is a process to find

18

Who did changes?

What changes are made?
Whether the changes are authorized or not as per the security policy of the
Organization?

The details of the above transactions are written to either a media or printed. This
allows Database Administrators to track changes and helps the organization to satisfy
regulatory requirements such as tracking specific users actions, general security
screening, validating user permissions etc.

12.3.2

Audit and Security of

Computer Systems

Audit of Computer Security

Issues of security of computer involve both physical and logical security. Physical
security involves restricting physical access to the computing resources from
unauthorized person. Logical security involves restricting the use of computing
resources by unauthorized person by providing logical control mechanism (e.g.
password protection). The audit of computer security involves review of physical and
logical security measures. Review of parameters, plans, practices, and policies that are
developed and implemented by the organization over the computer resources, and
how security measures are followed for Computers, Networks and Data
communication. They are also included in the Audit.

12.3.3

Audit of Application

Here, both manual and programmed internal controls related to information systems
are assessed. Primarily, there are four areas of audit coverage for an application being
reviewed.
The four areas are given below:
Control environment: This includes reviewing the systems security, its operating
platform, system documentation and the interaction it has with other systems.
Data Input Controls: This involves reviewing the controls which ensure that data
that enters into the system is accurate, complete and valid as per the standard.
Examples include verifying system tables, limit checks, range checks and redundant
data checks.
Processing Controls: These controls ensure that the data is properly processed and
that automatic calculations performed by the system are accurate. This is tested by
assessing controls built into the programs and by processing test data through the
system and comparing the results of processing with expected results. Also, there will
be checks on currency of stored data, default values and reporting exceptions.
Output Controls: In this, review of the system generated reports to ensure that they
are accurate and the reports produced are reliable, timely and relevant is done. Also, it
is checked whether cost savings can be achieved by reducing the number of reports
produced. Data control personnel perform visual review of computer output and
reconciliation of totals.

12.3.4

Benefits of Audit

Information system audit is increasingly becoming the focal point of the independent
audit, compliance audit, and operational audits. An information system audit can help
the organizations in many ways:

Improve system and process controls.

Prevent and detect errors as well as fraud.
Reduce risk and enhance system security.
Plan for contingencies and disaster recovery.
Manage information & developing systems.
Prepare for the independent audit.
Evaluating the effectiveness and efficiency related to the use of resources.
Standardization.
Improve business efficiency.

19

Implementation and
Security of Systems &
MIS

Cost control.
Competitive advantage.

12.4

COMPUTER ASSISTED AUDIT TECHNIQUES

The auditors use various types of automated audit software to carryout IS audit. The
use of Computer Assisted Audit Tools (CAATs) should be controlled by the IS
Auditor to provide reasonable assurance that the audit objectives and the detailed
specifications of the CAATs have been met. There are two major types of CAATs
namely audit software and test data.

12.4.1

Audit Software

This is a computer program used to process data of significance for audit from
entitys accounting system. The auditor should substantiate their validity for audit
purposes before making use of these tools. These include:

a) Package programs: Generalized computer programs to perform data processing

functions like reading computer files, selecting info, performing calculations, etc.

b) Special purpose programs: Computer programs designed to perform audit tasks

in specific business circumstances.

c) Utility tools: Used by the auditors to perform common data processing functions
like sorting, creating and printing files. These tools are not designed for audit
purposes specifically.
Various commercial Audit Software are available to carry out System Audit. Some of
them are:
1. Visual Audit Pro
2. IDEA
3. E-Z Audit
Visual Audit Pro: It audits automatically over a network. It audits activities like, use
log on/off, collects information about software and its version, collects information
about hardware inventory like serial number, model, memory and associated
peripheral devices, user information, registry information etc.
E-Z Audit: With this software one can know information on capacity of RAM, name
of network card with its connect speed, MAC address and TCP/IP information. You
can also find out how many local, removeable and network drives are there on the
system, what printers are connected, both networked and local, etc.. On software
front, it gives information on name and version of OS running on the system with
service packs, installed programs and their names, EXE files and DLL versions.
IDEA (Interactive Data Extraction and Analysis): IDEA can be used to import
information from database to be audited for further analysis to auditor. It helps to
corroborate audit evidence effectively. For example it can check for duplicate
payment on a single invoice. It is useful to analyze system log for fraud detection.
Consider the audit of a Payroll Package. The potential fraud that can occur in a payroll
system is very high. Therefore, audit software is used as detection tool for fraud. The
Audit software looks for salary unusually high, extracting information without a
department number, extract information on bank account number. It also can extract
information on fictitious employee, compare it with personnel database. It can also
compare payment details of two different months.
20

12.4.2

Test Data

Audit and Security of

Computer Systems

Test data is used to test the correctness of the software. When test data is processed
with the entitys normal processing systems, the auditors should ensure that the test
transactions are subsequently eliminated from the system. When using the test data,
the IS auditors should be aware that the test data should only point out the erroneous
processing and should not change the data that is produced by the system during real
life.

12.4.3

Audit Expert Systems

Some IS auditors make use of Expert Systems to assist in auditing. When using these
audit expert systems, the IS Auditor should be thoroughly knowledgeable of the
operations of the system to confirm that the decision paths followed are appropriate to
the given audit environment or situation.

12.4.4

Audit Trail

Audit trail is a log of changes made in the data, settings and related changes. A
security subsystem should maintain detailed logs of who did what and when and also
if there are any attempted security violations. The availability of the log is extremely
valuable. Log provides information for the system auditor to be able to determine who
initiated the transaction, the time of the day, date of entry, the type of entry, fields of
information that were affected and the terminal used.
System log should be analyzed to provide detailed information on all normal and
abnormal transactions during each processing period. System access and attempted
access violations can be automatically logged by the computer and can be reported for
check & review. Listing of terminal addresses and locations can be used to look for
incorrectly logged, missing or additional terminals.
Applying the principles of Information System Security and Audit raised in this writeup will ensure that an organizations information assets and systems are adequately
controlled, monitored and assessed.

Check Your Progress 2

1. Audit through computer is important to find out the .... and
..of information system output.
2. Information system audit is increasingly becoming the focal point of the
..., ... and .
3. .can be used to import information from database to be
audited for further analysis to auditor.

12.5

COMPUTER SYSTEM AND SECURITY ISSUES

Security is an important issue for modern IT Systems. Even though technology

provides immense possibilities to safeguard organizations computing infrastructure,
there has been security lapses and security breaches which have cost the organization
heavily. System administrator and security administrator have spent sleepless nights to
safeguard organizations data and computing infrastructure. One can think of
organization like airlines, railway and banks which are heavily dependent on
computing infrastructure and unavailability of system for few hours can create havoc.
Organizations cant afford to underestimate the security issues that can affect their
business operations.
Degree of security = 1 - (No. of security failures / No. of attempt to breach security)

21

Implementation and
Security of Systems &
MIS

There may be security threats due to natural reasons such as Earth Quakes, Cyclones
etc. Sometimes, the threats are made by people. These may be due to riots, unrest,
sabotage etc. Whenever , there is an attack, immediate reactive measures are to be
taken. Also, one should study various controls to find out the people or reasons behind
the attack. This can be done with the help of transaction logs etc. These attacks
basically become possible due to several drawbacks in the information system such as
lack of proper implementation of security protocols etc. Such things are exploited by
people who plan attacks. The entire situation surrounding attacks is depicted in Fig.
12.1.
Natural,
Man made and
External/Internal

Threats
Create

Business process
Information system
Exploit

Vulnerability

Attacks

Reduce

Prompt

Recovery, Strategy,
System modification
and Legal action

Reactive
Measures

Controls
Self assessment,
Process review,
System Audit,
Network
Monitoring and
Secured services

Figure 12.1: Information Security Architecture.

12.5.1

Analysis of Threats and Risks

The security of any system should be commensurate with the risk involved. Threat and
risk assessment involves identification of applicable threats to IS infrastructure,
recognition of vulnerability and probable loss calculation. In this context, it is
necessary to identify the source of threat.
Historically, an organizations computer systems were centrally located and the
management of issues related to it were responsibility of the computer center staff and
as such security related issues were also the responsibility of computer center staff
whose focus were to make available the application on the centrally located computer
as required. In comparison, todays computing infrastructure are far more diverse and
complex to manage. Business information is dispersed.
The source of threats can be either external or internal. Historically virus has been the
major potential external security threat but as organizations are diversifying their
activity over multiple locations and with evolution of new technology it is difficult to
perceive when an unauthorized intruder may try to hack upon organizations vital
information and cause damage. Internal security threats are more common although
the integrity of employee is checked before being inducted into the organization.
Employee of an organization can pose serious threats to information security as they
are closely associated with the system and know the vulnerabilities that can be
targeted.
Risk Analysis
The common questions asked in evaluating the risks are given below.

22

Are the risks such as fire, earthquakes and the scope of their effects on the
information system been made clear?

Has the loss, the organization would suffer from a halt or the like of the
information system been analyzed?
Is the time permissible for recovery of operation and the order of priority of
recovery been determined?

Audit and Security of

Computer Systems

Security policy underlines an organizations holistic approach to security issues.

Organizations must possess a security policy in writing, which should address the
following issues:
Authentication: To see that the person is bonafide user of the resources
Authorization: Privileges of the user or who can do what?
Information integrity :Is it possible that the end user can modify the information?
Detection: Once the problem is identified, how it is handled and managed.
Risk Assessment and Management
A thorough and proactive risk assessment is the first step in establishing a sound
security system. This is the ongoing process of evaluating threats and vulnerabilities,
and establishing an appropriate risk management program to mitigate potential
monetary losses and harm to an institution's reputation. Threats have the potential to
harm an institution, while vulnerabilities are weaknesses that can be exploited.
There are different approaches followed by organizations to analyze risks. However,
ultimately all the methods boil down to two types of approaches: quantitative and
qualitative.
Quantitative Risk Analysis
This approach although difficult to implement gives an idea about the amount of risk
involved with the event. This basically employs two fundamental elements i.e. The
probability of occurrence of the loss making event and probability of occurrence of
the event.
Estimated Loss = Potential loss due to the event * probability
It is therefore possible to rank the events in order of estimated loss. But the problem
associated with the quantitative approach is estimating the probability of occurrence
of the event, also in some cases the events are interrelated making the probability
calculation even more difficult. Notwithstanding above difficulty, many organizations
have adopted and implemented this approach successfully.
Qualitative Risk Analysis
The extent of the information security program should commensurate with the degree
of risk associated with the institutions systems, networks, and information assets. For
example, compared to an information-only Web site, institutions offering transactional
Internet banking activities are exposed to greater risks. Further, real-time funds
transfers generally pose greater risks than delayed or batch-processed transactions
because the items are processed immediately. The extent to which an institution
contracts with third-party vendors will also affect the way the risk assessment has to
be done.
Performing the Risk Assessment and Determining Vulnerabilities
Performing a sound risk assessment is critical to establishing an effective information
security program. The risk assessment provides a framework for establishing policy
guidelines and identifying the risk assessment tools and practices that may be
appropriate for an institution. Banks still should have a written information security
policy, sound security policy guidelines, and well-designed system architecture, as
23

Implementation and
Security of Systems &
MIS

well as provide for physical security, employee education, and testing, as part of an
effective program.
When institutions contract with third-party providers for information system services,
they should have a concrete opinion about third party providers quality of work and
loyalty to the clients. At the minimum, the security-related clauses of a written
contract should define the responsibilities of both parties with respect to data
confidentiality, system security, and notification procedures in the event of data or
system compromise. The institution needs to conduct a comprehensive analysis of the
providers security program, including how the provider uses available risk
assessment tools and practices. Institutions also should obtain copies of independent
penetration tests run against the providers system.
When assessing information security products, management should be aware that
many products offer a combination of risk assessment features, and can cover single
or multiple operating systems. Several organizations provide independent assessments
and certifications of the adequacy of computer security products (e.g., firewalls).
While the underlying product may be certified, banks should realize that the manner
in which the products are configured and ultimately used is an integral part of the
products effectiveness. If relying on the certification, banks should understand the
certification process used by the organization certifying the security product. Other
examples of items to consider in the risk assessment process include:

Identifying mission-critical information systems, and determining the effectiveness

of current information security programs. For example, vulnerability might involve
critical systems that are not reasonably isolated from the Internet and external
access via modem. Up-to-date inventory listings of hardware, software, as well as
network topologies, is important in this process.
Assessing the importance and business sensitivity of information for the
likelihood of outside attacks/hacking and internal misuse of information. For
example organization could be harmed if human resource data (e.g., confidential
personnel information) were made public. The assessment process should identify
systems that review the appropriateness of access controls and other security
policy settings.
Assessing the risks posed by service provider or business partner through
electronic connections with internal IT infrastructure. The outsider may have poor
access controls that could potentially lead to an indirect compromise of the
organizations security system.
Determining legal implications of security breaks and contingent liability
concerns associated with any of the above factor. For example, if hackers
successfully access a banks system and withdraw money fraudulently, the bank
will be liable for damage incurred to the account holder.

Potential threats

24

Denial of service (DoS), which can be described as any action that prevent a
system from normal operation. It may be the unauthorized destruction,
modification, or delay of service. DoS is common where the number of requests
outnumber the maximum number of connections possible. Under such
circumstances, legitimate users have to wait for large amount of time for response
to their request.
Internet Protocol (IP) spoofing, which allows an intruder via the Internet/intranet
to effectively impersonate a local system's IP address in an attempt to gain access
to the system. The system in this case may misinterpret the incoming connection
as originating from a trusted host.
A Trojan horse program generally performs unintended destructive functions that
may include destroying data, collecting invalid or falsifying data. Trojan horses
can be attached to e-mails.

Viruses are computer programs that may be embedded in other program and have
the capability to self-replicate. Once active, they may result in either
nondestructive or destructive invalid outcomes in the host computer. The virus
program may also move into multiple platforms, data files, or devices on a system
and spread through multiple systems in a network or through emails to other
systems.

12.5.2

Audit and Security of

Computer Systems

Recovering from Disasters

Natural and man-made disasters are inevitable. Earthquake, floods, fire and terrorist
attack can severely damage organizations computing infrastructure. The disaster
recovery plan is a document containing procedures for emergency response, extended
backup operations, and recovery should a computer installation experience a partial or
total loss of computing resources or physical facilities (or of access to such facilities).
The primary objective of this plan, used in conjunction with the contingency plans, is
to provide reasonable assurance that a computing installation can recover from
disasters, continue to process critical applications in a degraded mode, and return to a
normal mode of operation within a reasonable time. A key part of disaster recovery
planning is to provide for processing at an alternative site during the time that the
original facility is unavailable.
Contingency and emergency plans establish recovery procedures that address specific
threats. These plans help prevent minor incidents from escalating into disasters. For
example, a contingency plan might provide a set of procedures that define the
condition and response required to return a computing capability to nominal operation.
An emergency plan might be a specific procedure for shutting down equipment in the
event of a fire or for evacuating a facility in the event of an earthquake.
During a disaster, normal operating procedures may be significantly altered. Both
personnel and systems will be expected to function under conditions that are not
expected under normal day-to-day operations. Security remains a requirement but
techniques to apply it are altered to fit the contingency situation.
In-House Backup
This level is the minimum acceptable and is mandatory for all installations and
applications systems. Define in detail all in-house back up procedures, the techniques
used, files copied, frequency, etc.
Alternate Storage Area
This level of protection is necessary for mission critical components. It consists of offsite storage of at least one copy of all AIS files and databases, programs, and
procedures necessary to operate the high priority application systems, either at the
installation or at an alternate site of operation (including copies of contingency plans
and related materials).
The alternate storage area should be located in an area reasonably accessible to the
installation, but not subject to the same degree of major threat as the site. It is
recommended that, as a rule of thumb, the alternate storage area be no closer than one
mile from the site. However, the distance may vary from location to location.
The Disaster Recovery Toolkit
The Disaster Recovery Toolkit is a highly valuable collection of items and documents
to assist in ensuring business continuity in the face of serious incident or disaster.
Many organizations use these documents as a checklist and add element specific to
their need.
25

Implementation and
Security of Systems &
MIS

Although they vary from organization to organization, they generally comprise the
following:

A contingency audit questionnaire

A dependency analysis document - questions and guidance
A Business Impact Analysis questionnaire.
An audit questionnaire for disaster recovery or business continuity plan
A checklist, action list and framework for disaster recovery

The toolkit is designed to help review the full spectrum of business continuity and
disaster recovery issues.

12.5.3

Planning the Contingencies

Every business entity can and do experience events which can prevent it from normal
function. The factors can range from natural events like flood, fire, earthquake etc. or
a man made events like unauthorized access, serious computer malfunction or various
information security accidents.
The very first step for contingency planning is to identify the contingency events
covered and the appropriate actions for each. Contingency events usually refer to
varying degrees of loss across six major asset categories: Data, Software,
Communications, Hardware, Personnel, and Facility. The cause of the loss is dealt
with in the Risk assessment, the primary concern in the contingency plan is the degree
of loss, impact on the mission and techniques for coping.
Contingency management tools address basic issues such as asset identification,
location, value, alternatives, replacement, and intangible costs; and most importantly,
how long can the organization function without the asset? Since no asset is impervious
to loss, the prudent leader will ensure that mechanisms are in place for a secure &
rapid recovery. Our intent is to help managers break the cycle from normality to panic
with crisis management.
Contingency Events
Loss of Data: To Identify key data and the type or degree of loss/damage that would
be required for necessary recovery action. It can be done as follows:

Identify appropriate recovery plan and procedure procedures. (Example inhouse backups, etc.)
The location of the required recovery files.
To identify procedures for recovery of the files indicated above and include them
in the contingency plan.

Loss of Software: To identify key software and the degree of criticality for necessary
recovery action. It can be done as follows:

Identify the type of software (commercial / in-house developed.)

Identify the location where backup copies are maintained.
In case of an emergency procurement process, the authorized person for it and any
alternate source from where operational copies can be obtained.

Loss of Communications: To identify voice as well as data communications loss for

necessary contingency plan and recovery action. It can be done as follows:

26

Identify alternate communication facility available such as radios links or mobile

phones for interim measures.
Whether there is any service agreement in place with any party to deal with
contingency issues.
To estimate recovery time

Loss of Hardware: Inventory of required hardware must be maintained. For each

hardware component, the loss which would require implementation of the contingency
plan has to be found. It can be done as follows:

Audit and Security of

Computer Systems

Identify the hardware component and what functionalities it supports.

Identify any alternate piece of equipment that may be used as a substitute to the
equipment and its degree of compatibility with the existing software.
Whether the equipment is repairable?, and if so, is there maintenance agreement
in place to accomplish the repairs. What is the response time to repair the
equipment?
The estimated cost and time for procurement of replacement hardware in case it is
not repairable.
Whether there are any emergency procurement procedures for key items?

Loss of Personnel: Loss of Personnel can result from employee leaving the
organization, illness, death, family emergency and a number of other events. The
following steps can be taken to minimize this type of loss:

To identify key personnel in the organization and what their involvement/impact

on major systems/programs/components.
To identify substitutes for each personnel to handle such situation.
Whether there are written procedures for every important function accomplished
by the key personnel. Whether the substitutes use the same procedures
periodically and do the assigned tasks.
If alternates are not available within the organization replacements must be
obtained from outside sources. It must be ensured that there are sufficient
procedures in place and establish a training/orientation program to assign them the
desired work to them.

Loss of the Facility: The loss of facility in general is due to some catastrophic
natural action such as fire, flood, storm, earthquake, etc. However, a facility may
become non-functional temporarily due to failure of power, or any other events that
could render the facility non-functional.

If the facility is to be out of operation beyond the maximum tolerable time,

identify the procedures that are necessary for moving to the alternative facility.
To identify all necessary hardware, software, data, and personnel required for
normal functioning at the alternative location.
To notify the alternative location to all concerned.

Any recovery procedure generally consists of following broad steps.

Preparing contingency plan involves people from all activities. The people should
understand their role in the event of disaster and should be ready to react to the
situation. Following are the major step involved in contingency planning :
Develop the Plan: The contingency plan is a detailed milestone to move the
organization from a disrupted status to the status of normal operation. The role and
responsibility of each employee and service provider are defined clearly in the event
of disaster.
Testing the Plan: Once the plan is ready, it should be subjected to rigorous testing
and evaluation. The plan should be initially tested in a simulated environment.
Persons who would actually be involved in the event of a real disaster should test the
plan.
Maintaining the Plan: Once the plan is created and tested it must be kept updated so
that it remain relevant and applicable to changed business environment. The changes

27

Implementation and
Security of Systems &
MIS

in the business process must be reflected in the plan and all changes in it should be
communicated to all concerned.

12.5.4

Viruses

Viruses are one of the major security threats to computer system. The first computer
viruses were written in mid-eighties. The first virus written was a boot sector virus.
Today, there are several tens of thousands of viruses.
Computer virus is nothing but a program that is loaded into your computer without
your knowledge. This is only basic information . But, what makes people fear from
Virus is the disastrous impact on remaining programs in your machine due to this
program. The difference between a computer virus and other programs is that viruses
are designed to self-replicate usually without the knowledge of the user. Computer
viruses are called viruses because they share some of the traits of biological virus. A
computer virus passes from computer to computer like a biological virus passes from
person to person. A computer virus must piggyback on top of some other program or
document in order to get executed. Once it is running, it is then able to infect other
programs or documents. Obviously, the analogy between computer and biological
viruses seems superficial, but, there are enough similarities as the name suggest.
Virus carries out instruction for replication. The effect of virus can vary from
annoying messages, to the disastrous consequences (for example, the CIH virus,
which attempts to overwrite the Flash BIOS, can cause irreparable damage to certain
machines). Superficially, it looks as if virus which can format hard disk is more
damaging but damage can be avoided by taking backups. Think of a virus which
corrupts data by changing the numbers randomly on a spreadsheet application or
changes + to . This is certainly disastrous.
Viruses can be hidden in programs available on floppy disks or CDs, hidden in email
attachments or in material downloaded from the web. If the virus has no obvious
payload, a user without anti-virus software may not even be aware that a computer is
infected.
A computer that has an active copy of a virus on its machine is considered infected.
The way in which a virus becomes active depends on how the virus has been
designed, e.g. macro viruses can become active if the user simply opens, closes or
saves an infected document.
Prevention
The best way for users to protect themselves against viruses is to apply the following
anti-virus measures:

28

Make backups of all software (including operating systems). So,if a virus attack
has been made, you can retrieve safe copies of your files and software.
Inform all users that the risk of infection grows exponentially when people
exchange floppy disks, download web material or open email attachments without
caution.
Have anti-virus (AV) software installed and updated regularly to detect, report
and disinfect viruses.
Visit sites which give information on the Internet about latest virus, its behavior
and assess their potential threat.
In case of doubt about a suspicious item that anti-virus software does not
recognize, contact your anti-virus team immediately for guidance.

12.6

CONCURRENT AUDIT TECHNIQUES

Audit and Security of

Computer Systems

Most of the Audit techniques collect data after transaction is completed. So, the
outcome of the Audit is usually useful only for the future. The outcomes may be used
as precautionary measures for the future.
In the case of Concurrent Audit Techniques, Data is collected while the transaction is
in progress. This is very much useful for high risk transactions as they will be put on
hold in case the Audit desires so. If any other Audit technique is used, then , such high
risk transactions are processed after which it will be found that these transactions are
invalid.

12.6.1

Need for Concurrent Audit Techniques

The following are few reasons for the need of Concurrent Audit techniques:

Missing Audit trails.

Need for continuously monitoring largely integrated and automated systems .

The following are various Concurrent Audit Techniques:

12.6.2

An Integrated Test Facility Technique (ITF)

In this technique , the Auditing software is embedded into the client software.
Basically, what happens is that the test data of Auditor is integrated and the same is
processed with Clients real life input data. ITF ensures that files of the client are
unchanged and any changes, if necessary , will be made only to the dummy files of the
clients files. At the end, these dummy files are studied to know the discrepancies.

12.6.3

The Snapshot Technique

In this technique, Audit software is embedded in the software that is to be audited. It is

embedded at those places where critical processing takes place. Then, it takes a
snapshot of the process before and after the critical processing.

12.6.4

SCARF

It stands for System Control Audit Review File. It is one of the complex Audit
techniques. This technique will embed Audit software in the host application. This will
enable audit software to monitor the Systems transactions uninterruptedly. The
information that is collected during Audit process will be stored in a special audit file
known as SCARF master file.
Usually, SCARF is used to collect the following information : Application System
errors, Policy and procedural variances, System exceptions, Statistical samples,
Snapshots and extended records, Data profiling, Data for performance measurement.

12.6.5

Continuous and Intermittent Simulation technique (CIS)

This technique will use the Data Base management systems to trap exceptions.
Whenever , there is a need for service, DBMS will inform the same to CIS. CIS will
then carry out the suitable service.

Check Your Progress 3

1.

. and .. assessment involves

identification of applicable threats to IS infrastructure, recognition of vulnerability
and probable loss calculation.
2. A .. program generally performs unintended destructive
functions that may include destroying data, collecting or falsifying data

29

Implementation and
Security of Systems &
MIS

3. In the case of .., Data is collected while the transaction is in

progress.

12.7

SUMMARY

Auditing IT system is a crucial activity to provide feedback to the system. The process
of audit the report can be a food-for-thought for improving the information system. It
is surprising that only very few companies take this activity seriously. Audits not only
bring out the potentially weak areas in a system but also provide inputs for future
improvement. It also helps in improving business efficiency.
Audit in generic sense refers to investigation of risks to computer as well as to
processes and management of these risks through controls, proper procedures. Any
one, who is doing this kind of assessment and submits a report in a sense is
functioning as Auditor.

12.8

SOLUTIONS/ANSWERS

Check Your Progress 1

1. Improvement of Reliability, Security and Efficiency of Information Systems
2. Information System Auditors
3. Computer Assisted Audit Techniques
Check Your Progress 2
1. Accuracy, Integrity
2. Independent audit, compliance audit, and operational audits
3. IDEA
Check Your Progress 3
1. Threat, Risk
2. Trojan Horse
3. Concurrent Audit Techniques

12.9

FURTHER READINGS

James A. OBrien; Mc Graw Hill Edition; Introduction to Information Systems, An

End user/Enterprise Perspective;1995
Ian Somerville; Pearson Education; Software Engineering; Sixth Edition
James F.Peters and Witold Pedryez; John Wiley & Sons; Software Engineering-An
Engineering Approach;2000
Reference Websites
http://www.contingency-planning-disaster-recovery-guide.co.uk
http://www.disasterrecoveryworld.com

30

Management Information
Systems

UNIT 13 MANAGEMENT INFORMATION

SYSTEMS
Structure
13.1
13.2
13.3
13.4

Introduction
Objectives
Role of MIS in an Organization
Different kinds of Information Systems
13.4.1
13.4.2
13.4.3
13.4.4

13.5
13.6
13.7

13.1

Transaction Processing Systems

Management Information Systems
Decision Support Systems
Expert Systems

Summary
Solutions/Answers
Further Readings

INTRODUCTION

There are many kinds of Information Systems in the real world which use hardware,
software and the people to transform data to meaningful information for business
needs and decision-making. Every business process relies on information for day-today activities and decision-making. Management Information System have been
playing a key role in helping the managers at various levels of business functions for
decision-making. In early days of business information system, data processing is
used to generate various day to day reports. In todays world, as business is operating
in a more varied and complex environment, managers have realized the need for
specialized computer-based information systems for special activities and business
needs. Keeping this in view, various types of Business Information Systems have
evolved over time such as Transaction Processing Systems, Management
Information Systems, Decision Support Systems and Expert Systems.

13.2

OBJECTIVES

After going through this unit, you should be able to:

gain insight into various Business Information Systems;

learn the way Information Systems support business transactions;
understand the support given by Information Systems to organizations to perform
business operations , decision-making and for problem solving; and
Know various types of Information Systems and distinguish between them

13.3

ROLE OF MIS IN AN ORGANIZATION

Management Information System helps the organization to produce information that

organizations need to improve decision-making, problem solving, control operations
and creating new products or services. Many organizations have implemented
computer-based Management Information System to retain competitive edge over
their competitors. The role of Management Information System (MIS) has expanded
significantly over the years. Until the early 1960s, the role of MIS was simply
processing transaction data, record keeping and other data processing activity. The
early 1970s, evolved MIS for reporting to managers in a specified format for
managerial decision-making. The early 1980s have been the time for decision support
system which helps individual managers in decision-making. The early 1990s have
been the age of expert system that provides knowledge based expert advice to
managers for decision-making. All these have increased importance of MIS for the
success of an organization.

31

Implementation and
Security of Systems &
MIS

Management Information Systems can help a business in that they contain important
information about a particular client or event that takes place in the organization or
the environment surrounding it. MIS is not as important for smaller organizations as
it is for the larger corporations. The smaller locally run businesses are run usually by
owners who rarely need instant access of information that larger companies require.
Large corporates with varied product lines definitely cant do without a computer
based MIS in order to survive and keep pace with competitors.
Any MIS performs various roles in an organization:

Supports day-to-day business operations;

Supports managerial decision-making;
Supports strategic decision-making and competitive advantage;
Optimising operational cost;
Provide timely and accurate information; and
Provide expert advice to the managers on selected domains.

For example, an organization may use MIS to keep track of inventory, evaluate sales
trend of different products, keep information about client and employees, etc.
Management Information Systems are used for

Operational control: Information for control of day-to-day business operations.

Information required by operational managers to control their daily work. This
includes information on current stock of items, employee attendance, employee
performance sheet, etc. Such information is very much structured and
computational in nature and is produced in fixed format. Example : In an
inventory control system, report on minimum inventory levels for reordering of
inventory, sales performance figures by product line, sales person or sales region
can be obtained with the help of MIS.

Management control: Information for short term planning (few weeks and
months). Information is rather un-structured or semi-structured such as cash flow
statement, sales trend analysis, monthly and annual financial statements . This
type of information is used by mid-level manager for planning and control of
organizational sub-units. Example : Sales trend figure in different regions of the
country for product. Managers can carryout what if analysis like effect of price on
sales figure, effect of cut on advertisement on sales.

Strategic planning: Information for long-term planning, developing policies and

long-term goals for the organization. Such information is ad-hoc and unstructured
such as human resource forecast, market trend analysis, etc. This type of
information is mostly useful for top management.

13.4

DIFFERENT KINDS OF INFORMATION SYSTEMS

Depending on the end use, the information systems may be classified broadly to
operation information systems and management information systems. Operation
information system generally helps to support business operation, whereas
management information system helps in managerial decision-making. Transaction
processing systems may be classified into Operation information system. Decision
support systems, MIS and expert systems may be classified into different forms of
MIS for specific purposes. The information requirements of managers are directly
related to the position of manager in hierarchy ladder as shown in Figure 13.1.
Keeping this in view, various types of information systems have evolved over time.

32

Top

Ad-hoc, unstructured, non-periodic:

DSS, MIS, expert system

Middle

Semi-structured: MIS

Operational

Structured, periodic and in fixed

Management Information
Systems

Level of Management

Type of Information Requirement

Figure 13.1: Levels of Management and their Information requirements.

The types of information systems to be discussed subsequently have specific focus

areas to support an organizations information requirements. Table 13.1 depicts
various functions of Information Systems.
Table 13.1: Functions of Information Systems.
Systems

Transaction
Processing
Systems
Process Data
resulting from
business
operation

Management
Information
Systems
Process data
from business
operation as
well as external
data

Types of
Support

Provides
support for
day-to-day
operation of
business
process

Provides data
for managerial
decisionmaking

Format of
Reporting

Periodic and
routine type in
fixed format

Provides
advice like
human expert

Used by

Operational
management

Reports are
Provides
semi-structured report like
and ad-hoc type sensitivity
analysis and
what-if
analysis
Strategic
For decision
decisionsupport
making for
tailored made
managers
to individual
managers

Examples

Sales
transaction
processing
system, on-line
railway
reservation
system

Marketing
management
information
system

Expert
System for
medical
diagnostic
(e.g.,
MYCIN)

Information
Source

13.4.1

Decision
Support
System
Use analytical
models and
specialized
database in
addition to
internal data.
Provides
interactive
decision
support to
managers for
decisionmaking

Geographic
Information
System (e.g.
IBMs GeoManager,
which
integrates
interacticve
computer
graphics with
geographic
database.

Expert
Systems
Use
knowledge of
experts from a
specific field

Provide
expert advice
on a specific
domain of
activity

Managers for
expert advice
on a specific
field.

Transaction Processing System

Businesses offer service and products to the customers. In simple terms, transaction
processing system is an information system that supports business in the delivery of
33

Implementation and
Security of Systems &
MIS

various business transactions. A transaction processing system records and processes

data resulting from business transaction. Transactions are events that occur as a result
of business operations like transfer of money from one account to another account,
purchase of items, etc. Transactions are basically a series of related operations that
must all succeed or fail as a group. A single transaction of withdrawing money from
a bank account actually involves two operations are a debit to an account and credit
to another account. Transactions processing system allows the two operations to
group into a single transaction. When both the operations are successfully completed,
then the transaction is said to be complete. TPS can be classified into the category of
Operation information system. Example can be Sales Transaction Processing System.
These systems are transaction intensive and results of such transaction processing are
used to update various databases like customer databases, inventory databases and
accounts receivable databases. Transaction Processing Systems are also used to
make day to day decisions that control operational processes.
Transaction processing systems (TPS) could be on-line or off-line. In case of On-line
Transaction Processing systems, data is processed by the system immediately after
the transaction occurs. Point of Sale (POS) is a common example of the On-line
Transaction Processing System (OLTP).
The following are major characteristics of Transaction Processing Systems :

Support business operations;

Focus on data resulting from business transactions; and
Captures and processes data of business transactions.

For example, consider a Sales Transaction Processing System. Sales Transaction

Processing Systems handle routine business operations like sales and maintain
records related to those activities. TPS transforms large number of inputs to outputs,
using simple processing logic and operations. Compared to other types of information
systems, TPS handles far more volume of inputs and outputs but generally involves
simple processing logic.
Transaction Processing Systems perform the following operations (Refer to Figure
13.2):

Data is captured from documents or business operation and input into the system
to record a transaction.
Then, data is processed. That is, calculations or other logical operations are
performed for output.
The relevant files or databases are then updated with the results. Output of a TPS
includes documents and reports.
Business operation

Transaction
document

Transaction
processing
System

Figure 13.2: Business Operation and Transaction Processing System.

To save time, storage space, and reduce errors of data entry, it is desirable to capture
the information electronically at its point of origin, i.e. from the point of sales
terminal (POS). This is referred to as source data automation. Rarely, nonconventional methods are used to facilitate data entry. For example, in a library, the
barcode printed on the library members card can be used to capture required
information such as name of the member, address, validity date of the membership
etc. Figure 13.3 depicts a Transaction Processing System at a Library.

Barcode
Scanner

34

Management Information
Systems
Library Database

Figure 13.3 : Transaction Processing System at a Library.

The TPS should have the ability to process work flows of a business and each state of
the business transaction can be represented by a step in the work flow. TPS captures
and processes data of every business transaction and updates the relevant files and
databases. It produces a variety of information for internal and external use.
Components of a Transaction Processing System
Consider a typical Transaction Processing System as depicted in Figure 13.4.

Input
Terminal/
Data entry

Process
Transaction
Processing

Batch

On-line

Inquiry

Reports
Billing
Invoices

Database

Figure 13.4: A typical transaction processing system.

Data entry: Data can be captured directly from machines which consists of data
when it is entered during business transaction or the data can be directly keyed in.
Sometimes, Data is also converted to a machine-readable form by scanning.
Transaction processing: Input data is processed basically in two ways, namely
Batch Processing or Online Processing. Table 13.2 compares the both.

Batch processing: In this technique, accumulated data over a period of time

is processed periodically depending on the requirement. This type of
processing is economical. It is suited for situations when it is not required to
process the transaction data as occurs and report generated are required only
at a scheduled interval.

On-Line Transaction processing (OLTP): In this technique, the data is

processed by the system immediately after the transaction is over. This type
of processing is well suited for small transactions and where turn around time
is important. The database is always up-to-date since these are updated as
when the transaction data is generated. Responses to the user inquiry are
immediate. Since the database is accessed and updated after every
transaction, care must be taken to protect the integrity of the database.
Controls are some times built-in to the software for this kind of applications.
Information systems related to Banking are examples of OLTP. The
drawback of OLTP is high costs associated with the necessary security and
fault tolerance features.
Table 13.2: Batch and Online Transaction Processing
Batch Processing

Online Transaction
Processing

35

Implementation and
Security of Systems &
MIS

Process

Transaction data is
accumulated in regular
intervals for processing at
a scheduled interval

Transaction data is
processed as and when
generated by the business
process

Updation of database

When the batch is

processed

When the transaction is

processed

Response time

Several hours/day

Immediate

Associated cost

Economical with efficient

utilization of resources

High

Example

Processing pay cheques

received for clearance in a
banking system

Point of sales terminal,

Online Railway
reservation system

Database: It is the most important component of TPS. TPS updates the

organizational database that reflects day-to-day business transactions carried out
by the organization. For example, stock from the inventory database is reduced
when an item is sold from POS stock. Stock from inventory database is increased
when an item is received. Debtors and creditors database is updated depending
on amount received or paid in an accounts receivable database. The data
generated and processed by TPS are subsequently used for other Information
Systems such as Decision Support Systems etc.

Inquiry processing: The transaction processing system supports query by the

end-users. This inquiry processing is done by separate sub-system of the TPS.
The user can make specific query by using the sending query to the inquiry
processing system sitting on a LAN and receive response immediately.

Document and report generation: The final stage of the transaction processing
system is document generation. The collection of documents generated by the
TPS is called transaction document. Invoice generated by a POS terminal is an
example. Transaction logs are specific types of documents generated for Audit
and other control purposes. All transactions recorded on the databases are printed.

Examples of transaction processing systems are sales transaction processing system

(Refer to Figure 13.5), marketing transaction processing System, financial accounting
system. One of the special types of transaction processing system is process control
system (PCS). These are the systems that control processes of a manufacturing unit in
a plant. Many process have been mechanized by PCS minimizing human
involvement.
Data Inputs
Purchase order,
Shipped order,
Customer order,
Vendors order

Processing

Database Update
Vendor Database
Customer database

Reports
Inventory status,
Reminders,
Paycheques,
Invoices

Figure 13.5: Sales transaction processing system.

Check Your Progress 1

1. use knowledge of experts from a specific field.
2. .. use analytical models and specialized database in addition
to internal data.
36

Management Information
Systems

3. .. process data from business operations as well as external

data.

13.4.2

Management Information Systems

Management Information System (MIS) is a special kind of information system that

helps managers to take decisions. MIS is tailored to provide specific information to
individual managers for long term and strategic decision-making. MIS is used by the
middle and top-management for their information requirements for decision-making.
The use of MIS helps to produce the information that organizations need to improve
decision-making, problem solving, controlling operations, and creating new products
or services. Keeping this in view, a number of organizations invest in development of
a computerized MIS . The focus of MIS is to provide strategic information required
by top-management. Major volume of information for top management comes from
events not directly related to day-to-day business operations. Therefore, the
information from normal reporting systems is found inadequate for managers.
Therefore, special information system is developed for top management to support
their activity, which is not met by other information systems.
The following are the characteristics of Management Information Systems (MIS):

Provides reports to management usually in semi-structured format ( in detailed,

summary, and exception);
Usually uses shared database from many sources;
Often based on management or statistical models;
Information presented in both textual and graphical forms, but more often in
graphical format;
Provides information on trend analysis, exception reporting and what-if-analysis.
It allows the user to ask questions such as , what if we increase price by 10%, the
effect on sales of the product? If inflation increases by 5 per cent what will be the
effect on the sales forecast?

Table 13.3 depicts a Sales Performance Report. Figure 13.6 depicts a Bar chart.only
Figure 13.7 depicts a Pi chart.
Table 13.3: Sales Performance Report.
Sales
Region

2000

2000

2001

2001

2002

2002

Estimated

Actual

Estimated

Actual

Estimated

Actual

East

54353

98877

435

76

76667

76776

West

5453

34534

43

59

867

64465

North

9876

5354

435

567

76667

76776

South

89987

98877

675

345

878

876

37

2000

2001

Profit

Turnover

Profit

Turnover

Profit

4000
3500
3000
2500
2000
1500
1000
500
0

Turnover

Implementation and
Security of Systems &
MIS

2002

Figure 13.6: Turnover and Profit Ratio (Bar chart).

Turnover
Profit

Figure 13.7: Turnover and Profit Ratio (Pi chart).

Components of MIS
The bulk of information requirement of Managers at middle and top levels comes
from external non-computer sources like meeting documents, newspaper, telephonic
talk, letters, memos, etc. Corporate databases are important for day to day operations
of the organization.
MIS Software
module

Top Executive

DBMS

Communication
software

External
Database
Corporate
Operational
Database
Corporate
Management
Database

Figure 13.8: Components of an MIS

At the same time, data from external non computer sources provides managers with
objective information that helps them to make strategic, long and near term
decisions. Various components of MIS are showed in Figure 13.8 and explained
below.

38

Management Information
Systems

External Database: External databases are databases that are not owned by the
organization and the organization pays royalty to access these databases. Examples of
these databases are: databases of Market research groups, Statistical and
Demographic organizations etc. Since organization operates in a social environment
it is influenced by various external factors. Impact of theses external factors on the
long-term goal and success of organization is very important. Top management needs
to analyse data from these sources for long term planning.
Corporate database: Corporate database stores data generated by various business
processes through transaction processing Systems. These can be employee database,
customer database, inventory database, etc.
Management database: These databases store select data from corporate databases.
It generally stores summarized information for the requirements of managers.
MIS Software: This is used to extract and process information from various databases.
It acts as a user interface to the managers.
DBMS: Database Management System stores, retrieves and manages data on various
databases.
Communication Software: This is used to communicate with customers, suppliers
and other stakeholders of the organization. Examples are Messaging Software or
Organizations Bulletin board.

13.4.3

Decision Support Systems

In contrast to other information systems which provide general information about

organizations performance in fixed format to managers, Decision Support Systems
provide information to managers which will be helpful for them to make decisions. A
manager at a higher level needs adhoc information for strategic planning and control.
Decision Support Systems (DSS) can be defined as a specific class of information
systems that support business and organizational decision-making activities, as
needed to managers. A properly designed DSS is an interactive software-based
system intended to help decision makers compile useful information from raw data,
documents, personal knowledge, and/or business models to identify and solve
problems and make decisions.
The following are the major characteristics of Decision Support Systems (DSS):

Help decision makers to take decisions rather than replace them;

Use underlying data and models;
Have little or no reasoning capability;
Are tailored to directly support decision-making styles of individual managers;
Support interactive inquires and responses;
Are used to aid semi-structured or unstructured decisions;
Produce information on ad-hoc, flexible and adaptable format;
Information is produced by analysis of operational and external data; and
Analyses and supports comparison of specific alternative decisions.

Components of a DSS
Figure 13.9 depicts various components of a Decision Support System. They are
explained below:
Data Management System
This is a system where various activities associated with retrieval, storage, and
organization of the relevant data for the particular decision context are managed. It
also provides security functions, data integrity procedures, backup and recovery,

39

Implementation and
Security of Systems &
MIS

concurrency control, and general data administration. It can be a relational, objected

oriented or any other suitable database.
Model Management System
Similar to Data Management Systems, Model Management Systems perform
retrieval, storage, and organization activities associated with various quantitative
models that provide the analytical capabilities for Decision Support Systems. This
software module is responsible for analytical and limited reasoning capability of a
DSS. This may contain various statistical and operation research models.
Knowledge Engine
This module is responsible for activities related to problem recognition and
generation of interim or final solutions. The knowledge engine is the brain of the
Decision Support System. Decisions require reasoning, and less structured decisions
require more reasoning.
User Interface
This software module provides functionalities for input/output, error capturing and
reporting. A common user interface for various Decision Support Systems is not
possible as their designs vary in accordance with the environment of the organization
when they are deployed.
Types of User interface: Keyboard, Joystick, Mouse, Scanner, Voice, Pen mouse,
Touch screen, etc.
Like all information systems, issues related to the user such as training , skill ,
motivation levels are critical.

Model Management System

Data base
Data Management System
User

Interactive
Session

User Interface

Knowledge Engine

Model base

Figure 13.9: Components of Decision Support System.

Types of DSS
Various Decision Support Systems are Communication driven DSS, Data driven
DSS, Model driven DSS and Knowledge driven DSS. Table 13.4 draws a comparison
between MIS and DSS.

Table 13.4 : Management Information Systems and Decision Support Systems

40

Management Information
Systems

Structure of Information

Management
Information Systems
(MIS)
Periodic and often in fixed
format

Decision Support
Systems (DSS)
Interactive inquiry and
Response to support

Source of information

Operational data/external
database

Analytical models/external
database and operational
database

Target

Support group decisionmaking by managers

Tailored to decisionmaking style of individual

managers

Check Your Progress 2

1. MIS provides reports to management usually in format.
2. Decision Support Systems help decision makers to take decisions rather than
. them .
3. . is the software module that provides functionalities for input/output,
error capturing and reporting.

13.4.4

Expert Systems

An Expert System is a computer program that simulates the judgment and behaviour
of a human expert or an organization that has expert knowledge and experience in a
particular field. Typically, such a system contains a knowledge base containing
accumulated experience and a set of rules for applying the knowledge base to each
particular situation that is described to the program. Sophisticated expert systems can
be enhanced with additions to the knowledge base or to the set of rules. The expert
system is a knowledge-based information system to act as a consultant to the user.
Expert systems are being used in many specialized field like medicine, engineering
and business. An Expert System in the field of medicine can help diagnose illness.
Unlike Decision Support System, an expert System interacts with the user to get input
and provides expert advice on a problem in a specific domain.
Among the best-known expert systems have been those that play chess and those
which assist in medical diagnosis such as Mycin.
The following are the major characteristics of expert systems (ES):

Captures knowledge and expertise of a problem solver or decision maker and

simulates thinking for those with less knowledge;
Replaces a human advisor/expert for specific domain of knowledge;
Its domain of knowledge is narrow;
Has reasoning and explanation capability;
Types of problem treated is repetitive; and
The direction of interaction is from machine to the user.

Expert systems are distinct from traditional Information Systems because of two main
reasons:
Representation of Knowledge: Information is expressed in declarative form in
contrast to procedural expressions used in other types of Information Systems. Here,
knowledge is stored in a structured non-procedural way.

41

Implementation and
Security of Systems &
MIS

Perform Inexact Reasoning: Reasoning A process by which new information is

derived from a combination or combinations of existing, or previously derived,
information. In this aspect, an expert system comes closer to human mind, which is
hardly seen by traditional software. The ability to perform in exact reasoning leads to
easier decision-making because irrelevant alternatives are reasoned out before the
execution of the software.
Components of Expert System
An Expert System consists of a knowledge base and a software module (called
inference engine) to perform inferences from the knowledge base. These inferences are
communicated to the user. Figure 13.10 shows the components of an expert system.
Knowledge Base: It contains facts on a specific subject domain and rules to express
the reasoning capability of a subject expert. Knowledge Base is logically divided into
a fact base and a rule base. Knowledge means rules, heuristics (non-algorithmic),
boundaries, constraints, previous outcomes and other knowledge programmed in by
designers. A knowledge base typically incorporates definitions of factual knowledge
and rules along with control information. Knowledge base format is specific to the
implementation of the expert system software. Figure 13.11 shows the components of
knowledge base.
Knowledge base contains much of the problem solving knowledge. Rules are of the
form IF <condition> THEN <action>. Rules can be chained together (e.g., If A then
B If B then C since A
B
C so If A then C). (If it is raining, then roads
are wet. If roads are wet, then roads are slick.)
Inference Engine: Inference engine is software that provides the reasoning capability
to the expert system. It processes rules and facts to provide advice on a specific
problem. Rule based expert systems make use of two types of inferences for
reasoning by forward chaining and backward chaining. Some expert systems use
forward chaining by applying rules and facts to reach the conclusion where as others
use backward chaining methods where it is verified whether the stated conclusion can
be reached by applying the rules to the facts. The types of data processed by the
inference engine are symbolic rather than numeric or character data types processed
by other types of information systems. It usually takes the help of heuristic to solve a
problem which other wise leads to combinatorial explosion.
In addition to above, expert systems may contain a knowledge acquisition module
which in reality does not form the component of an expert system but is certainly
important for development of knowledge base of an expert system. Specially
designed languages such as LISP and PROLOG are used for programming expert
systems.

Inference Engine
User
Expert
System

Knowledge
Base

Figure 13.10: Components of an Expert System.

Facts
Definitions,
observations and
hypothesis

42

Rules
If A then X
If A then Y
else
Z
Knowledge Base

Management Information
Systems

Figure 13.11: Components of Knowledge Base.

An expert system starts with an interactive query session, which is directed from the
expert system to the user. In this interactive query session, expert system asks a series
of queries to the user and expects reply from the user similar to a doctor asking a
series of queries to the patients before reaching any conclusion on the diagnosis of the
disease. The user is expected to give reply to all the queries based on which the expert
system recommends a solution like human expert. The advantage of computer based
expert system is that it is unlike a human expert who is prone to environmental
condition, these systems are consistent, fast and accurate in providing expert advice. It
can also be programmed to give advice on behalf of several experts. This is the reason
why expert systems are used as knowledge based strategic information resources for
the managers in an organization. Various information systems are developed with an
expert system component built in to it. These are called expert assisted information
systems.
Knowledge Acquisition by Expert Systems
Expert systems must liase with people(experts) in order to gain knowledge and the
people must be specialized in the appropriate area such as Medicine, Geology and
Chemistry to name a few. Knowledge Engineer acts as an intermediary between the
specialist (human expert) and the expert system. This process of picking the brain of
an expert is a specialized form of data capture and makes use of interview techniques.
The Knowledge Engineer is also responsible for the self-consistency of the data
loaded to the expert system. Thus, a number of specific tests have to be performed to
ensure that the conclusions reached are sensible and accurate. Figure 13.12 depicts
communication between expert system, knowledge base and human expert.

Figure 13.12: Communication between Expert System, Knowledge Engineer and Human
Expert.

There are various applications for expert systems in business, engineering and
medicine. Expert systems ask the user, a series of queries and based on the feedback
from the user, deliver expert advice on the specific subject. Expert systems are used
in the field of Medical diagnosis, Sales forecasting etc. Expert Systems are being
used by managers for credit management, employees performance evaluation,
portfolio analysis and production monitoring. Although expert systems are used in
many fields, it can never replace a human expert. Expert system can provide expert
advice based on the available information and knowledge. Expert systems lack
learning capability like human being and have very limited focus area. It fails in the
areas where advice requires a broad knowledge base.
Table 13.5 draws a comparison between Decision Support Systems and Expert
Systems.

Check Your Progress 3

1. is a computer program that simulates the judgment and behaviour of a
human expert.
43

Implementation and
Security of Systems &
MIS

2. .. is logically divided into a fact base and a rule base.

3. acts as an intermediary between the specialist(human expert) and
expert system.
Table 13.5: Decision Support Systems and Expert Systems.

Objective
Reasoning capability
Database

Decision Support System

(DSS)
To assist human decision
No or limited
Adhoc, factual information

Domain

Broad

Types of Data

Numerical, character
based
Human to machine
Human takes the decision
with support from DSS

Direction of Query
Decision Maker

13.5

Expert System (ES)

To mimic human decision
Yes
Procedural and factual
knowledge
Narrow, very specific
domain
Mostly symbolic
Machine to human
Computer makes the
decision

SUMMARY

Information needs vary among different managers depending on their hierarchy in

the corporate ladder. Information systems are being used since their evolution for
planning and operation of the organization. Specialized information systems have
evolved for different executives at different levels.
During the initial years of evolution of MIS, Computers are mostly used for data
processing activities. Transaction Processing Systems have evolved to process data
generated from various business transactions. When the data is processed as and
when it is generated, it is called Online Transaction Processing System. Some times,
the data is processed in batch depending on the business requirement, called batch
processing system.
Management Information System (MIS) helps decision-making process of managers.
Interpretation of data and interface with external data base is required due to broad
nature of top management functions.
Decision Support System (DSS) helps to automate routine decision-making
functions by managers. Structured decision is easy to program. Various statistical
and analytical models are used to provide decision support to the managers.
Expert System has been designed to give expert advice to managers in specific
domain. A series of queries are put by the expert system and based on the response
of the user, it comes out with advice. Expert systems are accurate and consistent in
providing expert advice. Expert systems are found in many applications in the field
of portfolio analysis, medicine, building regulations etc.

13.6

SOLUTIONS/ANSWERS

Check Your Progress 1

1. Expert Systems
2. Decision Support Systems
3. Management Information Systems
Check Your Progress 2
44

Management Information
Systems

1. Semi-structured
2. replace
3. User interface
Check Your Progress 3
1. Expert System
2. Knowledge Base
3. Knowledge Engineer

13.7

FURTHER READINGS

Joey George, J Hoffer and Joseph Valacich; Pearson Education Modern System
Analysis and Design;2001
K.C.Laudon and J.P.Laudon; Pearson Education Management Information
Systems;Seventh Edition;2002
Reference Websites
http://www.usus.cs.york.ac.uk
http://power.cba.uni.edu/isworld/dss.html

45