Chapter 17
Chapter 17
Chapter 17
CHAPTER 17
Problem 17.24 (KEEP-OR-DROP FOR SERVICE FIRM, COMPLEMENTARY
EFFECTS, TRADITIONAL ANALYSIS)
Diketahui :
Sales
Less : Variable Expenses
Contribution Margin
Less : Direct Fixed Expense
Segment Margin
Less : Common Fixed Expenses
(Allocated)
Operating Income (Loss)
Property Insurance
Automobile Insurance
$4.200.000
$12.000.000
3.830.000
9.600.000
$ 370.000
$ 2.400.000
400.000
500.000
$ (30.000)
$ 1.900.000
100.000
200.000
$(130.000)
$1.700.000
Required :
1. If Devern Assurance Company drops property insurance, by how much will income
increase or decrease? Provide supporting computations
Answer :
Sales
Keep
Drop
$16.200.000
$10.560.000
13.430.000
8.448.000
Contribution Margin
$ 370.000
$ 2.112.000
900.000
500.000
$ 1.870.000
$ 1.612.000
Assume that dropping all advertising for the property insurance line and increasing the
corporate advertising budget by $450.000 will increase sales of property insurance by
10% and automobile insurance by 8%. Prepare a segmented income statement that
reflects the effects of increased advertising. Should advertising be increased?
Answer :
Sales
Property Insurance
Automobile Insurance
TOTAL
$4.620.000
$12.960.000
$17.580.000
4.213.000
10.368.000
14.581.000
Contribution Margin
Less : Direct Fixed
Expensec
Segment Margin
Less : Common Fixed
Expensesd
Operating Income
$ 407.000
$ 2.592.000
$ 2.999.000
500.000
500.000
$ 407.000
$ 2.092.000
$ 2.499.000
750.000
$ 1.749.000
Required :
1. What is the profit normally earned on one production run of Refined Oil and Top Quality
Oil?
Answer :
Revenues
Refined Oil
TOTAL
$127.500
$124.500
$252.000
72.000
29.250
101.250
Contribution Margin
$ 55.000
$ 95.250
$ 150.750
92.500
Operating Income
$ 58.250
Revenues
Refined Oil
TOTAL
$186.000
$240.000
$426.000
144.000
51.600
195.600
Contribution Margin
$ 42.000
$188.400
$230.400
185.000
Operating Income
$ 45.400
If Fiorello accept the spesial order, Fiorello must manufacture two additional
standar production runs as order :
Top Quality Oil = 2 x 15.000 = 30.000 gallons (MangiareBuonos order)
Refined Oil = 2 x 30.000 = 60.000 gallons
a
$23.400
Direct Labor
9.000
Catalyst
3.600
Overhead
8.000
The pain relieve are bottle in 5 gallon plastic containers and shipped
The cost of each container = $12,10
The revenue received tablet oer case = $13,50, with 8 cases produced by every gallon
of PR1
The cost process into tablet : PR1 = $11,00; Packaging Cost = $5,16 per case and
shipping cost =$1,68 per case
Required :
1. Should Pharmaco sell PR1 at split-off, or should PR1 be processed and sold at tablet?
Answer :
For 2000
gallons
Revenuesa
Containers
Shipping
Process Further
Sell at split-off
$216.000
$68.000
Differential Amount to
Processs Further
$148.000
(840)
840
(26.880)
(200)
(26.680)
Processing
(22.000)
(22.000)
Packaging
(82.560)
(82.560)
TOTAL
$ 84.560
$66.960
$ 17.600
2.
If Pharmaco normally sells 26.000 gallons of PR1 per year, what will be the difference in
profits if PR1 is processed further?
Answer :
Difference in profits if PR1 is processed further :
Additional Income per gallon = $17.000 / 2.000
= $8,80
Additional Income = $8,80 x 26.000
= $228.800
Problem 17.31 (MAKE OR BUY, TRADITIONAL ANALYSIS)
Diketahui :
Morrill Company produces two different types of gauge : density and thickness
Density Gauge
Thickness Gauge
$150.000
$80.000
$230.000
80.000
46.000
126.000
$ 70.000
$34.000
$104.000
20.000
38.000
58.000
$ 50.000
$(4.000)
$ 46.000
Sales
Contribution Margin
Less : Direct Fixed
Expenses*
Segment Margin
Less : Common Fixed
Expenses
Operating Income
TOTAL
30.000
$ 16.000
* Includes depreciations
Density Gauge uses a subassembly that is produced from an external supllier : $25 per
unit. 2.000 subassemblies are purchased each quarter
Unit-level variable manufacturing costs are as follows :
Direct Materials
$2
Direct Labor
Variable Overhead
Purchase
$50.000
14.000
Lease Expenses
27.000
Supervisor Salary
10.000
$51.000
50.000
Buy
Purchase Cost
Variable Manufacturing Costs
14.000
34.000
$48.000
The direct fixed expenses are the same accross all alternative
Best alternative : Drop the thickness gauge and the subassembly
2. Suppose that dropping the thickness gauge will decrease sales if the density gauge by
10%. What effect does this have on the decision?
Answer :
Complementary effect analysis :
MAKE
BUY
Lost sales for density gaugea
$15.000
12.600
(3.000)
34.000
50.000
$58.600
$50.000
Purchase Costd
TOTAL RELEVANT COST
The correct decision = to keep the thickness gauge and buy the components
3. Assume that dropping the thickness gauge decreases sales if the density gauge by 10%
and that 2.000 subassemblies are required per quarter. As before, assume there are no
ending inventories of subassemblies and that all units produced are sold. Assume also
that the per-unit sales price and variable costs are the same as in Requirement 1. Include
the leasing alternative in your consideration. Now, what is the correct decision?
Answer :
Buy
$19.600
Lease Expenses
27.000
Supervisor Salary
10.000
70.000
$56.600
$70.000
Purchase Costa
TOTAL RELEVANT COST
a
Drop Thickness
Gauge and Make
$15.000
17.640
(1.000)
34.000
Purchase Cost
TOTAL RELEVANT COSTS
a
0
$65.640
So, the answer is the corret decision = to lease and make the component