ADDIS ABABA UNIVERSITY

SCHOOL OF GRADUATE STUDIES

THE FRAMING OF
GENDER VIOLENCE BY THE ETHIOPIAN
PRINT MEDIA

BY

BRUKTAWIT EJIGU

July, 2008

Addis Ababa
THE FRAMING OF GENDER VIOLENCE BY THE ETHIOPIAN
PRINT MEDIA

BY

BRUKTAWIT EJIGU

A THESIS SUBMITTED TO THE SCHOOL OF GRADUATE

STUDIES OF ADDIS ABABA UNIVERSITY

IN PARTIAL FULFILMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE

DEGREE OF MASTER OF ARTS IN JOURNALISM AND
COMMUNICATIONS

THESIS ADVISORS

EXTERNAL, Dr. KRISTIN ORGERET, and

INTERNAL, Dr. WOLDEAB TESHOME

July, 2008

Addis Ababa
Acknowledgements
I would like to express my heartfelt appreciation to my advisors, Dr. Kristin Orgeret and
Dr. Woldeab Teshome, for their constructive comments and feedbacks on the project. I
am also indebted to my families and friends for their love and support throughout the
completion of the thesis. I would also like to extend my gratitude to the coders who have
devotedly coded the newspapers.
Table of contents
Contents Page
Acknowledgement-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------i
List of Figures---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------iii
List of Tables----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------IV
Abstract-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------V
Acronyms---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------iv

Chapter one
1. Introduction---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------1
1.1 Statement of the problem-------------------------------------------------------------- 3
1.2 Objectives-------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5
1.3 Significance of the study--------------------------------------------------------------- 5
1.4 Scope of the study ---------------------------------------------------------------------- 6

Chapter Two
2. Review of literature------------------------------------------------------------------------------7
2.1 Gender violence------------------------------------------------------------------------- 7
2.2 Media and gender violence ---------------------------------------------------------- 10
2.3 Framing theory-------------------------------------------------------------------------13
2.3.1 Location of framing-------------------------------------------------------------- 17
2.3.2 Types of farming------------------------------------------------------------------18
2.3.3 Factors affecting framing-------------------------------------------------------- 20
Chapter Three
3 The research design ----------------------------------------------------------------------------22
3.1 The research method------------------------------------------------------------------ 22
3.2 The sample------------------------------------------------------------------------------22
3.3 Sampling techniques-------------------------------------------------------------------23
3.4 Data collection and analysis----------------------------------------------------------26
3.5 Limitations of the study---------------------------------------------------------------28
Chapter Four
4. Presentation of findings and data analysis------------------------------------------------29
4.1 The extent of the newspapers coverage of gender violence----------------------29
4.2 The nature of the newspapers coverage of gender violence--------------------- 31
4.3 Sources used in the articles-----------------------------------------------------------35
4.4 Frames used in stories of gender violence -----------------------------------------37
4.5 Media function ----------------------------------------------------------------------- -41
4.6 Results and discussion--------------------------------------------------------------- -43
4.6.1 Extent of coverage----------------------------------------------------------------43
4.6.2 Themes of articles---------------------------------------------------------------- 45
4.6.3 Coverage of types of gender violence----------------------------------------- 46
4.6.4 Sources used in the articles------------------------------------------------------47
4.6.5 Frames employed in stories of gender violence------------------------------ 48
4.6.5.1 Human interest and empathy frames----------------------------------- 49
 4.6.5.2 Diagnostic and prognostic frames-------------------------------------- 50
4.6.5.3 Attribution of responsibility and solution frames-------------------- 51
4.6.5.4 Morality and educative/advocacy frames------------------------------51
4.6.5.5 Conflict and economic frames------------------------------------------ 52
4.6.6 Media functions-------------------------------------------------------------------52

Chapter Five
5. Summary, conclusions, and recommendations-------------------------------------------54
5.1 Summary and conclusion-------------------------------------------------------------54
5.2 Recommendation for further research-----------------------------------------------56

Bibliography
Appendix
List of figures

Figures Page
4.1 Percentage of stories on gender violence published by the newspapers ---------------29
4.2 Percentage of article type distribution in the newspapers-------------------------------- 30
4.3 Percentage of themes covered by the newspapers-----------------------------------------32
4.4 Percentage of types of gender violence mentioned in the newspapers----------------- 33
4.5 Percentage of sources quoted in the newspapers-------------------------------------------35
4.6 Percentage of distribution of location in the newspapers -------------------------------- 37
4.7 Percentage of frames used by the newspapers--------------------------------------------- 38
4.8 Percentage of roles played by the newspapers--------------------------------------------- 42

List of tables
Tables Page
4.1 Percentage of distribution of article type across the newspapers------------------------31
4.2 Percentage of theme distribution across the newspapers----------------------------------32
4.3 Percentage of types of gender distribution across the newspapers---------------------- 34
4.4 Percentage of source distribution across the newspapers---------------------------------36
4.5 Percentage of location allocation of gender violence stories across the newspapers- 38
4.6 Percentage of frame distribution across the newspapers covering gender violence---39
4.7 Distribution of functions performed by each newspaper----------------------------------42

Appendices
A. Coding sheet
B. Lists of key informants
C. Coding guide
D. Interview guide
E. Number of frames used in the newspapers
F. Monthly Statistical Data About Press Products
Which Circulate Beyond The Confinement of
One Region
 Abstract

Gender violence is a day-to-day tragedy around the world. Many females, both children
and adults, have suffered a great deal from different acts of violence because of their sex.
Rape, beating, female genital mutilation (FGM), abduction, and early marriage are
among the dominant types of gender violence that affect women physically,
psychologically, socially and economically.

The media may play significant roles by covering and framing gender violence. How the
media portray gender violence has pronounced implications on both public perception
and social policy. Therefore, to better understand these portrayals, this study examines
the Ethiopian print media coverage of gender violence over one year period. The study
content analyzes a nationally representative sample of newspaper coverage of gender
violence during the period of September 2006 to September 2007. Three Amharic
newspapers, Addis Admas, Police na Ermijaw, and Medical which deal with the social,
crime and health aspects of gender violence, were used for analysis. In addition,
journalists and editors who work for the sample newspapers were interviewed to
supplement the information gathered through content analysis.

The results of the study show that in terms of coverage, the analyzed newspapers mostly
framed gender violence using human interest and empathy frames. However, they
ignored economic and conflict frames. Private owned Addis Admas and government
owned Police na Ermijaw have given gender violence a better extent of coverage
compared to Medical. Furthermore, rape and beating were found to be the most
frequently reported forms of violence in the newspapers. Most of the articles were
informative rather than educative. They focused on reporting committed violence and
court trials held regarding gender violence. Little was done, however, in educating the
public on the health consequences and possible treatments of the violence.

Acronyms

EMWA- Ethiopian Media Women’s Association

EWLA- Ethiopian Women Lawyers’ Association
FGM- Female Genital Mutilation
NGO- Non Governmental Organization
IPV- Intimate Partner Violence
STD- Sexually Transmitted Disease
UDHR-Universal Declaration of Human Rights
UNFPA- United Nation For Population Agency
UNIFEM- United Nations Development Fund for Women
USA- United States of America
WHO- World’s Health Organization

Chapter One

1. Introduction

Gender violence is a universal concern. It is a problem of both the developed and the
developing world. Steeves (1997: 96) notes that “gender violence is a global reality that
kills and injures millions of girls everywhere. Those not directly attacked remain affected
by an ever-present fear of violence.” UNIFEM (United Nations Development Fund for
 Women) in its 20003 report states that one out of three women is likely to be sexually
assaulted during her lifetime (Marshall 2004).

Putting a clear definition of gender violence can be a bit difficult as it can involve several
acts. In Article 1 of the Declaration on the Elimination of All Forms of Violence against
Women, gender violence is defined as “any act of gender-based violence that results in,
or is likely to result in, physical, sexual or psychological harm or suffering to women,
including threats of such acts, coercion or arbitrary deprivation of liberty, whether
occurring in public or private life” (Marshall 2004).

According to United Nations Fund for Population Agency (UNFPA, 2007), there are
different phases and types of violence against women starting from before birth to old
age.

Gender violence throughout the life cycle

Phase Type of Violence

Sex selective abortion; battering during pregnancy (emotional and

physical effects on the woman; effects on birth outcome); coerced
Pre-Birth pregnancy; mass rape in war

Infancy Female infanticide; emotional and physical abuse; differential access

to food and medical care

Girlhood Child marriage; genital mutilation; sexual abuse by strangers and

family members; differential access to food and medical care; child
prostitution

Adolescence Dating and courtship violence; economically coerced sex; sexual

abuse in the workplace; rape; sexual harassment; forced prostitution;
trafficking in women

Reproductive Age Abuse of women by intimate male partners; marital rape; dowry
abuse and murders; partner homicide; psychological abuse; sexual
abuse in the workplace; sexual harassment; rape; abuse of women
with disabilities
Old age Abuse of widows; elder abuse affects mostly women

Source: Heise, L. 1994. Violence Against Women: The Hidden Health Burden. World
Bank Discussion Paper. Washington. D.C. The World Bank

Gender violence causes serious health, social and economic problems. It has severe
health consequences for the affected, both physical and psychological. It also brings
devastating social and economic impacts. In addition, violence against women is a
serious violation of human rights. World Health Organization (WHO (2007) lists some
effects of gender violence on women’s health:

• the increase of sexual risk-taking among adolescents,

• the transmission of sexually transmitted disease (STD), including HIV/AIDS,
• unplanned pregnancies,
• Precipitating various gynecological problems including chronic pelvic pain and painful
intercourse.

The complications of gender violence get worse in developing countries like Ethiopia
where poor economic background often result in inadequate health care. Despite the fact
that it is an alarming and deep-rooted problem in the country, gender violence is an
under-reported issue in Ethiopia. It has received little attention and coverage by the
media. Commenting on the situation globally, Marshall (2004:1) says “violence against
women isn't news. Or at least that is the logical implication one might draw from the
lacking and skewered coverage given to the subject by the media.” When it is reported,
the issue is treated like an ordinary phenomenon which is normal to occur. Supporting
this idea, Frieda Werden of the Women's International News Gathering Service cited in
Marshall (2004: 2) points out:

Men’s violence against women is treated like a "dog bites man"

story, and women's violence against men as a "man bites dog"
 story. Thus the amount of coverage in mainstream media is
inversely proportional to the actual prevalence of these kinds of
violence, and gives a false impression.

Furthermore, how the media frame stories of gender violence has been criticized for their
little attempt to reinforce change in policies regarding the issue. According to Entman
(cited in Powers and Andsager, 1999: 553), frames occur when journalists “emphasize
certain words and source of information; the writings of the reporters then form thematic
clusters.” How the media frame stories of gender violence was scrutinized for failing to
show the true danger of the problem. Other studies on media’s coverage of gender
violence have found out similar results that how the media cover the issue reinforces
patriarchal conceptions of rape and other forms of gender violence. Patriarchal ideology
is “grounded in patriarchal notions of male and female sexuality, that is, the notions that
males are innately aggressive and females are innately submissive and receptive.”
(Steeves, 1997:11)

1.1 Statement of the problem

Media have the power to influence public opinion as well as social policy about
significant social matters. Gender violence is one of the issues that require media’s
attention and coverage to reinforce change in attitude and policy. Carlyle et al (2008)
note that how the media cover issues that have health and legal implications can affect
both public policy response and individual behavior. In addition to the attention the issue
receives from the media, how it is framed has implications for both public perception and
policy making. Goffman (cited in Paterson 2006:295) describes frames as “internal
cognitive structures consisting of systems of classification and rules of interpretation that
allow us to locate, perceive, identify and label, the diverse phenomena we may encounter
through out the course of our lives.”

How gender violence is represented in the media can certainly affect the public’s
perception of the issue. For example, the Ethiopian media have played a significant role
in minimizing stigma and discrimination against HIV-infected people. Carlyle et al
(2008: 171) argue that “ the extent of coverage of intimate partner violence (IPV) as well
as its framing can affect attributions of both blame for IPV incidents and responsibility
for addressing IPV; these attributions, in turn, can impact support for funding, safe
houses, legal sanctions for perpetrators, protections for victims, and so forth.”

Researches conducted on the framing of an issue or event are important in examining the
roles of the media in defining a problem, stating the cause, providing moral evaluation
and suggesting treatment. Even though several mass media studies were carried out on
gender and the media as a whole, there are very few researches that focused on media and
gender violence in particular.

Steeves (1997:98) studied the print media’s coverage of the so-called St. Kizito story,
where nineteen girls were murdered and over seventy were raped in Kenya. She found
out that the framing used in the media supported patriarchal views of rape. She has noted
that rape myths were reflected during the framing; “…the common myth that rape is
motivated by lust is reflected in stories blaming the crime on mixed-sex schools, or on
inadequate religious training.” She also found out that although they were not detailed in
providing alternative suggestions for the problem, there were few stories which show real
concern about the wellbeing of the St. Kizito survivors.

Similarly, Carlyle et al (2008:180) examined newspaper coverage of intimate partner

violence in the U.S.A. Their findings show that newspaper framing of IPV tended to be
greatly dominated by episodic framing, “which focuses on the individual and tends to
ignore the larger social context within the IPV occurs”. When discussing the implications
of such framing, the writers state that “by portraying IPV as an individual or a
relationship issue without discussing the underlying causes of IPV, victims may be more
likely to feel blamed for their own victimization.”

As to the researcher’s knowledge, despite the significance of media framing in tackling

gender violence, little research has been done on media and gender violence in general
and the Ethiopian media and gender violence in particular. Therefore, there seems to be a
need to conduct a research which aims at finding out how the local media portray and
represent an important social issue like gender violence. As a result, this study is believed
to fill in the gap by studying how three local newspapers frame gender violence.

1.2. Objectives of the study

The main objective of this research is to gauge how the Ethiopian newspapers frame
gender violence. The specific objectives are:

1. To assess the extent of the newspapers coverage of gender violence in terms of

number of articles and topics.
2. To identify themes of the stories and sources who are quoted in the stories.
3. To analyze what frames are used in reporting gender violence
4. To examine at who wrote the stories (female or male journalists); and if the sex of
the reporter has any impact on the stories.
5. To study into the functions the newspapers performed regarding gender violence.

1.3 Significance of the study

The results of this study will be significant in examining how the national media frame
issues regarding violence against women. Hence, the study was conducted in a belief that
it might give an idea on how the national media addresses relevant social issues like
gender violence.

The research will also benefit the three analyzed newspapers as it will point out both their
strong sides and limitations in the coverage and portrayal of gender violence. It will offer
some insight on what is covered and how to improve such coverage.

Findings of the study will also be helpful for sectors outside the media that work on
gender issues like Ethiopian Media Women’s Association (EMWA) and Ethiopian
Women Lawyers Association (EWLA) by providing them with data about the framing of
gender violence in the Ethiopian media.
Finally, as the study focuses on the national media, it will also serve as a reference for
other researchers who conduct their study on similar areas.

1.4 Scope of the study

The scope of the study is limited to Ethiopian print media. The study only assesses how
three local newspapers covered gender violence during the period of September 2006 to
September 2007. Hence, it should be noted that the study does not examine coverage of
gender violence in other media like television, radio, internet, magazines or pamphlets.
Furthermore, as the study only included newspapers published during the period of
September 2006 to September 2007, its horizon was limited to almost 13 months
examination. In addition, the study merely looks at how the media present issue; and does
not include reception analysis.

Chapter Two
2. Review of literature

The aim of this chapter is to provide a literature review which may function as a relevant
frame work for the current research project. The chapter is organized into three sections:
1) a brief discussion of selected literature on gender violence; 2) media’s role in relation
to gender violence; and 3) media framing theory. In each of these sections, the relation
between the current research and the review literature is discussed.

2.1 Gender violence

Gender violence is a deep-rooted problem in every society. It is a result of women’s
subordinate role in a society. Many cultures have norms, beliefs and social institutions
that legitimize and perpetuate violence against women. Heise et al. (1999) Cherinet and
Mulugeta (2002) state women’s low status in a society as a cause for violence against
them. They assert that in all Ethiopian cultures, women and girls are subjected to
“physical, sexual and psychological abuse, in the family and the community. Violence
involving beating, rape, female genital mutilation (FGM), abduction, early marriage,
nutritional taboos and unregulated fertility are well established traditions that negatively
affect the health and well-being of the woman, and are violations of human rights but not
considered so, by the societies concerned.” (Ibid: 28)

However, cross-cultural studies by Peggy Reeves Sandy and David Levinson (quoted in
Steeves 1997:13) show that gender violence is lesser in some societies:

Gender violence including rape, occurs to some extent in nearly

every society, there appears to be less gender violence in societies
where women participate in the public sphere, men are involved in
family life, and the surrounding culture condemns interpersonal
violence. Rape incidents are greater in societies where men
express contempt for women’s public- sphere participation, where
men have little or no role in child rearing, and where interpersonal
violence is encouraged as an expression of masculinity.

According to Heise, et al (1999), there are two common forms of violence against
women: ‘abuse by intimate male partners’ and ‘coerced sex’, whether it takes place in
childhood, adolescence, or adulthood. Intimate partner abuse is also known as domestic
violence, wife-beating, and battering. It is almost always accompanied by psychological
abuse and in one-quarter to one-half of cases by forced sex as well. The majority of
women who are abused by their partners are abused many times.
WHO’s (2008) multi–country study on women’s health and domestic violence against
women reveals that Ethiopia is among the countries in the world where women report to
encounter greatest amount of physical and sexual violence by intimate partners. 54%
ever-partnered women in Ethiopia reported to experience physical or sexual violence, or
both during the past year. On the contrary, physical and sexual non- partner violence
among Ethiopian women is reported to be interestingly lesser. Only 5% of the women
reported to encounter with non-partner violence. However, it should be taken to
consideration that the figures merely indicate the reported violence.

In Ethiopia rape is a major problem and most of the times the only reported sexual
violence against women. Almost all court trials regarding gender violence involve rape.
Gill (2007) defines rape as a criminal act aimed at humiliating, debasing, overwhelming,
and controlling a woman. “It involves invasion of parts of a woman’s body normally
reserved for pleasure, intimacy and, for some women, for child bearing.” It has an
everlasting effect on victims’ physical and psychological conditions. There are, however,
some misconceptions about rape. The most common misconception is holding women
responsible for initiating the attacker to commit the crime. (Gill, 2007; Steeves, 1997)
Gill (2007:137) lists some of the blames women meet if they are raped: ‘[women] were
dressed provocatively, they were out alone at night, and they ‘led the man on’, etc’.

Gender violence affects women’s health, social and economic lives. It is a crime which
should be handled by the criminal justice system. Crime is referred to as an action “that
violates social norms about appropriate behavior.” (Stalans and Lurigio cited in Carlyle et
al, 2008: 170)

Many scholars agree that despite its high prevalence and its devastating effects on
women’s health, social and economic systems, gender violence is largely a neglected
issue. (Cherinet and Mulugeta, 2002; and Heise, et al., 1999)

In concluding its multi-country study WHO (2008) asserts that violence against women is
widespread and deeply ingrained, and has serious impacts on women’s health and well-
being. Its continued existence is morally indefensible; its cost to individuals, to health
systems, and to society in general is enormous. Yet no other major problem of public
health has – until relatively recently – been so widely ignored and so little understood.

In the USA, Center for Disease Control and Prevention in its 2003 report notes that
intimate partner violence results in costs of more than $5.8 billion each year, with the
present value of expected life time earnings lost by intimate partner violence victim at
$892.7 million which is an average of more than $713,000 per fatality. (Carlyle et al.,
2008)

Gender violence is a problem which requires an international concern. Steeves (1997:11)

shows how feminists internationally argued ‘freedom from gender violence is an
international human right, one that must be explicitly addressed in human rights
conferences'. Ethiopia has ratified the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR)
of 1949 which prohibits the negative discrimination based on their sex. However, it took
a while for the international organization to declare gender violence as a violation of
Human Rights. Finally, in June 1993 United Nations Human Rights Conference in
Vienna, at the workshop on Gender and Human Rights, gender abuse and violence was
recognized as a violation of Human Rights in the Declaration of Vienna and program of
Action. (ibid)

At the national level, violence against women is a criminal offence. Carlyle et al. (2008:
170) note that “criminal laws reflect social values and are sometimes created to reinforce
them.”

Eliminating gender violence requires much more than putting down declarations and
strategies on papers. First and foremost, women should be aware of their rights. Here, the
media play a crucial role in bridging the information gap. Carlyle et al., (2008: 170 )
argue that media’s coverage of intimate partner violence can help the social climate
change so that people would begin to question the fundamental norms of male-female
relationships, which can contribute to gender violence situations.
2.2. Media and Gender violence
Gender and the media has been a dominant issue in several media studies. Different
researches have been conducted to see the extent of coverage of women and matters
related to them, how they are portrayed, their role in the profession of journalism, etc.
(Byerly and Ross, 2006; Gill, 2007; Steeves, 1997)

The media are the main sources of information for the public to understand and interpret
different issues.( Shen, 2004: 123) Shen further asserts that “the media are the arena in
which politicians, activists, and journalists all seek to articulate and amplify their views
as well as define things their way.” Similarly, Steeves (1997: 3) notes media “along with
other ideological institutions (such as schools, churches, and families), help sustain
societal values, and also are capable of challenging them.” As such, the media are
significant agents in informing citizens about salient social issues like gender violence.

Concerning the representation of women by the media, Steeves (1997:7) writes:

Feminist scholars around the world have documented ways in

which the products and process of global media reflect patriarchal
values- by ignoring and excluding women, by stereotyping women
in narrow traditional roles, and by degrading women via
representations of them as sex symbols or objects of abuse. News
including crime news, has been examined by many researchers
who have discovered that very little news is by or about women,
uses female sources, or examines issues of particular salience to
women, such as child care, women’s health, women’s economic
status, abortion, or gender violence.

Authors like Byerly and Ross (2006:40) share Steeves’ idea on the representation of
women by the media. According to a study by the Global Media Monitoring Project in
1995 which simultaneously monitored news media on one day across 71 countries, 19%
of the individuals featured in news stories were women and ‘the most popular roles that
they occupied were as victims, mothers, and wives’. (Ibid) In other words, the media are
found to be under- representing and misrepresenting women and their roles in a society.
Violence against women is a terrorizing reality which affects many lives of women all
over the world. However, the extent of the coverage of the issue by the media is
astonishingly very little. (Marshall, 2004) As to Carter (1998), gender violence has
transformed through the years from an extraordinary to ordinary news. As a result it is
not first page news unless famous people or murder are involved. Meyer’s cited in Carter
(1998:223), from her interviews with crime reporters in Atlanta, Georgia , finds out that
“because news organizations cannot report on each and every crime taking place every
day, journalists have developed a ‘hierarchy of crime’ in which murder is considered to
be the most serious offence, and therefore the most important to cover.” She also learns
that women’s battery, rape or even murder is considered common by journalists and
‘journalistically unimportant’, unless the victims are white and middle class. Gill
(2007:144) also states that ‘the available evidence shows that most rapes are not reported
as news at all; only the most typical cases, often with bizarre or horrific violence,
received prominent coverage…’

Furthermore, Thorson (in Carlyle et al, 2008: 169) asserts that “crime and violence are
most appropriately presented as public health issues and that presenting violence as
purely criminal issue may misrepresent health risks.” Thus, reporting gender violence
merely as a criminal act may lead the public to ignore the violence’s dangerous
consequence on health.

The extent of the coverage of gender violence as well as its framing can affect the
response that the issue should receive from both the public and the authorities. (Carlyle et
al., 2008) As Waldron quoted in Marshall (2004:1) points out ‘media implicitly tell us
how to rank the importance of the public issues according to the amount of press
coverage devoted to an issue.’ Similarly, Chong and Druckman (2007:113) argue that
“whichever issue receives the greatest volume of coverage will be the most accessible
and have the largest effect.” In other words, lack of appropriate media coverage of an
issue leads to the implication that the topic is not important. And obviously, if a story is
not reported, public awareness is significantly lessened.
When it gets the media’s attention, violence against women may not be framed in a
balanced manner. Gill (2007:135) points out that the media give a distorted version of
incidents of violence against women. Reports on rape and sexual assault focuses on
disproportionately on attacks by strangers, on unusual assaults and on those perpetrated
against young women. She also argues that the reports ‘trivialize women’s experience of
the attack’ and present rape in ‘a manner that is designed to be arousing’. The victims are
‘frequently described in highly sexualized terms-‘sexy 21-year- old’, ‘blonde beauty’,
‘blue- eyed schoolgirls’ etc., with descriptions that bear little relationship to the woman’s
experience of the attack – such as ‘fondled her breasts’. Similarly, Benedict (quoted in
Gill 2007:139) notes that “Men are never described as hysterical, bubbly, pretty, pert,
prudish, vivacious, or flirtatious, yet these are all the words used to describe the female
victims of cases I have examined…Male crime victims are rarely described in terms of
their sexual attractiveness, while female crime victims almost always are…”

Another misleading reporting is the portrayal of rapists by the news media as

‘identifiably sick and depraved strangers’. In reality, however, many of the rapists are
friends, relatives, neighbors or someone else known to the victim. (Gill, 2007) Byerly and
Ross (2006) ask why the media frame ‘rapist-as sex- fiend flies’ while the available
statistics shows that the vast majority of the rapists are friends or acquaintances of the
victims. Regarding media reporting of rape in Britain, Gill (2007: 147) writes that it is
‘powerfully framed by some outdated and pernicious discourses that are at best unhelpful
and at worst dangerous.’ Similarly, Byerly and Ross (2006:43) argue that the portrayal
of sexual assaults as ‘unusual occurrences’ committed by ‘unnatural men’ misleads
people to think that such crimes are both rare and the result of ‘individual pathology that
requires a law-and-order response, rather than constituting a serious social problem that
requires a social reform solution.’

The media take a vital responsibility to inform and educate people about relevant issues
in the society. Stanko cited in Carter (1998) argues that the media plays a significant role
in teaching women and girls about potential dangers of sexual violence, primarily from
male strangers, and how to try their best to keep themselves ‘safe’ from such men.
Carlyle et al. (2008) also note that coverage and portrayals of violence against women in
media are very important because they contribute to measures taken in preventing and
intervening.

No matter how serious a problem is, how reporters frame the story influences readers’
interpretation of the issue. (Price and Tewksbury cited in McManus and Dorfman,
2002:8) According to these writers, “lack of information with which to process the
incoming message leaves people particularly vulnerable to the frames embedded in the
new message.” It is therefore important to note that the way the media frame gender
violence influence the public’s understanding and interpretation of the issue.

2.3. Framing theory

The framing and presentation of an issue or event in the media can affect how recipients
of the news understand and interpret the stories. (Price, Tewksbury, and Powers cited in
Scheufele, 1999) As stated earlier, gender violence is a deep-rooted problem all over the
world. However, how it is framed by the media can affect the public’s formation of
opinion and the response received from the government regarding the issue.

In the past decade, the term ‘framing’ has become very popular in media research and
communication articles. (Weaver, 2007) Several definitions have been forwarded about
media frames. Authors like Tankard et al define media frames as “the central organizing
idea for news content that supplies a context and suggests what the issue is through the
use of selection, emphasis, exclusion, and elaboration.” (Cited in Weaver 2007:142)
Similarly, Gitlin (quoted in Steeves, 1997:25) describes media frames as “persistent
patterns of cognition, interpretation, and presentation, of selection, emphasis, and
exclusion, by which symbol handlers routinely organize discourse, whether verbal or
visual.” The process of framing involved in both definitions is similar, that is, they both
consider selecting, emphasizing, interpreting and excluding as the main components of
framing.
Entman (1993, 2007) has provided more than one definition for media framing. His
famous definition of framing is ‘to select some aspects of a perceived reality and make
them more salient in a communicating text, in such a way as to promote a particular
problem definition, causal interpretation, moral evaluation, and/or treatment
recommendation for the item described.” (Entman, 1993 cited in Weaver, 2007:142)
Using the same theme, Entman (2007) defines framing as “the process of culling a few
elements of perceived reality and assembling a narrative that highlights connections
among them to promote a particular interpretation.” In other words, framing is intended
to make the audience think or feel in a certain way about the issue under discussion.

According to Entman’s definitions, well developed frames usually have four functions:
problem definition, causal analysis, moral judgment, and remedy promotion. First, frames
define problems that are salient to the public. Then, they determine and highlight causes
of the problem. Next, they encourage moral evaluations by providing the causal analysis.
Finally, they promote remedies so the concerned bodies can come up with favored
policies. (Entman, 2007)

Frames can affect the way people understand and interpret issue or events. (Shen, 2004)
In his study “Examining the effects of message frames in political advertisements”,
(Shen, 2004) finds out that political ads framed as either character- or issue-oriented had
a profound effect on voters cognitions in political evaluations. Similarly, McManus and
Dorfman (2002:6) assert that:

…news frames are influential in making certain elements of issues

and events available for mental processing while ignoring others.
We know the level of context in stories greatly influences
comprehension. Terse episodic reporting, for example, throws
readers and viewers back on their own pre-conceptions about why
events take place. It encourages simplistic explanations such as
blaming individuals and exempting the conditions shaping them.
Some kinds of reporting appear to promote an apolitical or social
reaction while others elicit only apathy
As to Carlyle et al. (2008: 172), the effectiveness of frames is found in their “ability to
make certain elements and perspectives more salient, thereby increasing the chances that
certain schemas of interpretation will be evoked.” Frames can be found in “the properties
of news narratives, thus encouraging certain interpretations and understandings of
issues.”

As stated earlier, how gender violence is framed has its own implications on how the
issue is perceived by the public. In their study of media coverage of intimate partner
violence, (Maxwell et al., 2000 in Carlyle et al. 2008: 173) found that “most articles were
framed in a way that left the victim responsible for ending the violence in the
relationship.” Furthermore, they found out that the reports mostly neglect social factors
perpetuating violence. In addition, the authors assert that most of the coverage focuses on
individual incidents. This may result in, according to Carlyle et al. (2008: 173) “societal
attitudes that are victim blaming and unsupportive of intervention from social structures
despite the need for victims of crime to be protected”.

Providing contextual features in the coverage of violence against women is helpful for
the audience to have better understanding of the story. The contextual features include:
the relationship between the perpetrator and victim, alcohol use, etc. (Carlyle et al., 2008)
The authors, in their study of media coverage of intimate partner violence, found that the
relationship between the perpetrator and the victim was the spouse in 62.0%, separated
14%, dating 13.3% cohabiting 3.9%, and engaged 2.7%.

As frames need to be seen as ways for both presenting and comprehending news,
Scheufel (1999) identifies two concepts of framing: media frames and individual frames.
Media frames are “devices embedded in political discourse”. On the other hand,
individual frames are “internal structures of the mind”. (Kinder and Sanders cited in
Scheufele, 1999: 106) For Chong and Durckman (2007: 101), individual frames are
“what an audience member believes to be the most salient aspect of an issue.” For
Entman cited in Scheufel (1999: 106) individual frames are “information –processing
schemata” of individuals and media frames are “attributes of the news itself”.
The combination of individual and media frames is what makes framing successful. The
effect of framing is feasible when “a communication increases the weight of a new or
existing belief in the formation of one’s overall attitude” (Chong and Druckman, 2007:
107). The authors further assert that when there is an existing belief, the framing effect
results from “a reweighting of the set of prior beliefs associated with the object; on the
other hand, if the [media] promote a new belief about the object, the framing effect
produced by the recipient’s accepting the new consideration and giving it priority in his
or her allover attitude.” Entman (in Shen, 2004: 106) also shares the idea that “a framing
effect is more likely to occur when the media frames comport with the existing beliefs of
the audience, rendering related concepts more salient and more cognitively accessible
than others.” Thus, both individual and media frames must be taken into consideration in
terms of clarifying the concept of framing. (Scheufel, 1999) For example, people’s
existing knowledge and attitude towards gender violence is important in making the
framing of the issue by the media have some impact on them.

The term framing has been used interchangeably with concepts like agenda setting and
priming. (Popkin cited in Scheufele, 1999) Entman (2007) suggests agenda setting to be
considered as an alternative name for “successfully performing the first function of
framing: defining problems worthy of public and government attention. Among other
things, agenda problems can spotlight societal conditions, world events, or character traits
of a candidate.” Scholars like McCombs et al., 1997 in Zhou and Moy (2007) refer
framing as second-level agenda setting. On the other hand, Scheufel (1999: 101) argues
that framing is concerned with “the salience of issue attributes”; whereas agenda setting
is concerned with “the salience of issues”. Zhou and Moy (2007) also point out that
although framing and agenda setting are two theories of media effects, they have been
portrayed as one.

2.3.1 Locations of framing

Journalists use various tools to frame an issue or event. Pan and Kosicki (in Scheufel,
1999:111) present four types of structural dimensions that journalist can frame news
through:

a) syntactic structures, or patterns in the arrangements of words

or phrases; b)script structures, refereeing to the general
newsworthiness of an event as well as the intention to communicate
news and events to the audience that transcends their limited sensory
experiences; c) thematic structures, reflecting the tendency of
journalists to impose a causal theme on their news stories, either in
the form of explicit causal statements by linking observations to the
direct quote of a source; and d) rhetorical structures, referring to
the stylistic choices made by journalists in relation to their intended
effects.

According to Entman (in D’Angelo 2002), there are at least four locations of frames in
the communication process: the communicator, the text, the receiver, and the culture.
Issues or events can be framed through words, images, phrases, and presentation styles
that a journalist uses. (Gamson and Modigliani in Chong and Druckman, 2007) As to
Chong and Druckman (2007), the frames used by speakers reveal ideas that they think are
relevant at the time. As to Pan and Kosicki (in D’Angelo 2002), textual items (words and
images) can be used to frame an issue or event.

2.3.2 Types of framing

The existence of one or another frame in the news and its consequences for the public
opinion has been a focus in many studies. (Semekto and Valkenburg, 2000) Steeves
(1997) in her study of press’s coverage of the St. Kizito story has found nine frames
(ignoring or marginalizing rape, quoting government-sources, emphasizing school-critic
explanations, excusing assailants and bolstering existing ethnic prejudice; and reinforcing
patriarchal rape myths, identifying surviving victims but not assailants, suggesting
survivor-assailant equality via labels, showing concern for survivors; and feminist
resistance) .

Framing can be classified under two contrasting dimensions: episodic and thematic
coverage. (Shah et al., 2004) Episodic framings are used to “construct social issues
around specific instances and individuals” This type of framing, according to Carlyle et
al. (2008), tends to rely on individual explanations. Sotirovic (in Carlyle et al. 2008: 172)
describes individual explanations as “those that focus on the personality, disposition, or
motivational states of the people involved”. It promotes “attributions of responsibility
both for the creation of problems or situations (causal responsibility) and for the
resolution of these problems or situations (treatment responsibility) to the people featured
in press reports.” (Iyengar cited in Shah et al., 2004: 104) This type of frame is dominant
in coverage of violence reports. (McManus and Dorfman, 2002; and Carlyle et al., 2008)
For example, in their study of media coverage of intimate partner violence, Carlyle et al.
(2008) found episodic coverage being the dominant one. Most of the articles (88.3%)
were framed using episodic framing.

On the other hand, thematic framing emphasizes society’s role in addition to the
individual. (Iyengar, 1991 cited in Carlyle et al., 2008) The frame relies on social
explanation. (Carlyle et al., 2008) These social explanations focus on “circumstances and
situational forces”. (Sotirovic, 2003 in Carlyle et al., 2008: 172)

Semetko & Valkenburg (2000) discuss five dominant news frames that have been
identified in earlier studies: conflict frame, human interest frame, economic frame,
morality frame, and attribution of responsibility frame. In addition other frames like
diagnostic and prognostic are commonly used frames. These frames are used in the
current research.
Conflict frame
This frame focuses on conflict between individuals, groups, or institutions so as to attract
audience attention. (Semetko & Valkenburg(2000) Neuman et al. (in Semetko &
Valkenburg (2000) found that among the few central frames of reporting various issues
that the media draw, conflict was the most common frame in U.S.

Human interest Frame

This frame puts a human face or an emotional perspective on the report of an issue or
event. It personalizes the news, “dramatize or emotionalize” the stories as a means to
capture and retain audience interest. The frame is also referred as “human impact” frame,
and is considered the second common frame in the news next to conflict frame. (Neuman
et al., in Semetko and Valkenburg, 2000) As to Bennett in (Semetko and Valkenburg,
2000), because of the increasing competition in the market for news, journalists and
editors are exert greater effort to produce stories that captures the public’s interest.

Economic Frame
This frame presents issues or events focusing on their economical consequences on an
individual, group, institution, or country. (Semetko and Valkenburg, 2000) When an
issue or event has wide impact, it adds value to the news, and its economical
consequences are often vital. (Garber cited in Semetko and Valkenburg, 2000)

Morality Frame
This frame emphasizes moral or religious contexts of an issue or event. (Semetko and
Valkenburg, 2000) In order to keep the professional norm of objectivity, journalists often
make use of the moral frame indirectly by using quotation and inference, for example,
having others ask the question. (Neuman et al., in Semetko and Valkenburg, 2000) For
example, a journalist can have religious leaders raise moral questions about gender
violence. Neuman et al., in (Semetko and Valkenburg, 2000) further assert the moral
frame is to be more dominant in the minds of the audiences than in the content of news.
How ever, the frame is among the common frames of news.
Attribution of Responsibility Frame
As Semetko and Valkenburg (2000: 96) put it, this frame “presents an issue or problem in
such a way as to attribute responsibility for its cause or solution to either the government
or to an individual or group.” Iyengar (1987) argued that when television news covers an
issue or event, or individual (episodically) rather than presenting the larger historical
social context (thematically), it promotes individuals’ explanations for social problems.
(Cited in Semetko and Valkenburg, 2000)

Diagnostic Frame
This frame emphasizes identifying a problem and attributing blame and causality.
(Gerhards and Rucht, 1992 in Scheufel, 1999)

Prognostic Frame
This frame can also be described as a solution frame which specifies what needs to be
done. (Gerhards and Rucht 1992 in Scheufel, 1999)

3.3. Factors affecting framing

Framing can be affected by various factors. According to Scheufel (1999), journalists’
framing of an issue may be influenced by several social-structural or organizational
reasons and by individual or ideological factors. Based on previous research, the author
further identifies five variables that may potentially affect journalists’ framing of an issue
or an event: social norms and values, organizational pressures and constraints, pressure of
interest groups, journalistic routines, and journalists’ ideological or political orientations.

Likewise, McLeod, Kosicki, and McLeod in Shen (2004: 125) point out framing social
and political issues and events can be affected by “journalists’ individual values,
ideological constraints, and market forces.” In case of journalists, their “common reliance
on politicians, interest groups and other experts for quotes and analysis means that the
news media may serve as conduits for individuals and interest groups eager to promote
their perspectives.” (Nelson et al., cited in Shen, 2004: 125). Consequently, journalists
adopt frames suggested by interest groups or political actors as sound bites and
incorporate them in their report of an issue or event. Further more, type and political
orientation of the medium can also influence news framing. (Gans 1979 in Scheufel,
1999)

Despite the fact that framing theory has been used in many different researches (Carlyle
et al., 2008 and Shen, 2004), it has been criticized by some. As to Scheufele (1999:103),
most of the limitations of theory framing are attributed to its “lack of clear conceptual
definition and generally applicable operation.”

As mentioned earlier, framing plays a prominent role in presenting and comprehending

salient issues like gender violence to the public. However, little has been done on the area
of media framing of gender violence. The current research will study media framing of
gender violence in Ethiopian newspapers so as to show the kinds and processes of news
frames in coverage of violence against women.

Chapter Three
3. The Research Design

3.1 The Research Method

In conducting this study, the researcher employed a quantitative approach (content
analysis) as a main research method adding a qualitative method (in-depth interview) to
it. The quantitative approach is selected as a major research method because it is a
frequently used and an appropriate approach for studying media framing.

A quantitative approach was used to collect data from the newspapers about themes,
sources, and frames used in stories of gender violence. Content analysis was employed to
gauge how gender violence is framed in three selected local newspapers. As Berger
(1998:23) points out, content analysis is an approach that aims at measuring the extent of
an issue “in a representative sampling of some mass-mediated popular art form.”

The qualitative method, on the other hand, was utilized to supplement the information
gathered through the content analysis. It was assumed that adding in-depth interviews
will help to get better and deeper understanding of how stories of violence against women
are framed by the Ethiopian media. Berger (1998:55) notes that by using depth interview,
“you often obtain unexpected information that other forms of research might not
discover.”

3.2 The Sample

Two types of subjects were involved in the study. The first subjects were the selected
newspapers that report on the health, social and criminal aspects of gender violence. The
other subjects of the study were journalists and editors of the selected newspapers.

As indicated above, the study focused entirely on newspaper coverage, and did not
consider television or radio stories. Although television and radio are significant media in
many major events, the fact that they are monopolized by the state in Ethiopia would
limit the study merely to government owned media. The research would have, therefore,
failed to look into how the private-owned media frame gender violence. In addition, in
terms of topics the researcher reasoned that there would be no major difference since
what the broadcast media covered can be found in the press as well.
In reality, newspapers reach only a certain level of the population as the illiteracy rate is
high in the country. However, they are regarded to be crucial in reaching the ruling
powers and the decision makers. As Steeves (1997:97) points out the print media can
have an influence on the educated and political leaders “who wield disproportionate
power to effect change”.

According to the Ministry of Information (2008), there are about 64 private and
government owned newspapers in Ethiopia covering social, political, health, criminal and
economic issues. From the total, the researcher selected three newspapers namely: Addis
Admas (private), Police na Ermjaw (government), and Medical (private). Two of the
newspapers (Addis Admas and Medical) are weekly newspapers; whereas Police na
Ermjaw is a fortnightly paper.

To strengthen the information gathered from the newspapers through content analysis,
four journalists and editors who took part in publishing the stories of gender violence
were interviewed. Both female and male journalists participated in the interview to see if
their sex had any impact on their reporting.

3.3 Sampling Technique

The three newspapers were selected mainly because of their themes. They deal with
social, crime and health issues purposefully. As mentioned in Chapter two, gender
violence is a concern of all these three themes. In addition, circulation was considered as
another criterion during the selection of the two private owned newspapers, Addis Admas
and Medical. However, the numbers of circulation do not necessarily reflect the exact
numbers of readers in Ethiopia as each newspaper can be read by several readers. In the
case of the government owned newspaper, Police na Ermijaw, it is the only paper that
deal with crime. In addition, it was in the belief that the selected newspapers would
ensure ownership diversity as both government and private owned newspapers were
included. As mentioned above, two of the sample newspapers are private owned whereas
one is government owned. This would be logical since the majority of the newspapers in
the country, 77% are private owned and the rest 33% are owned by the government.
(Mekasha, 2005) Furthermore, as all three newspapers use the local Amharic language,
they can be understood by any literate reader which in turn might raise their readership.

Addis Admass was established in 2000. It is a private owned newspaper which focuses on
social and entertainment issues. It is a weekly newspaper with a circulation of 31,000.
(Ministry of Information, 2008) This newspaper was selected because it was assumed
that it covers the social aspect of gender violence.

Police na Ermijaw was established in 1961. It is a government owned newspaper

published by the police bureau. The newspaper is a fortnightly one which mainly reports
crime and Police activities. There is no clear information on its circulation.

Medical is a private owned newspaper which primarily deals with health issues. It is a
weekly paper with a circulation of 14,200. (Ministry of Information, 2008) It was
established in 2003.

Time frame
The study intended to find out how gender violence was framed by the Ethiopian press
within the period of September 2006 to September 2007. This time frame was chosen to
look into recently used frames in the newspapers on the coverage of the issue.
Nevertheless, selecting a specific time frame for getting a higher number of articles
would be irrational as gender violence is not a one time phenomenon. Although only an
individual experience, the so-called ‘Kamilat’ story of a girl who suffered an acid burn
from her alleged boyfriend falls in this time frame.

Within the selected time frame, four editions per month from the two weekly newspapers
(Addis Admas and Medical); and two editions per month from the fortnightly newspaper
(Police na Ermjaw) were analyzed. As a result, 104 editions of the weekly newspapers
and 26 editions of the fortnightly one within the period of thirteen months were taken for
analysis. (September’s editions in both 2006 and 2007 were included) As the fortnightly
newspaper chiefly deals with crime, it was assumed that it would contain more stories of
gender violence. Thus, it was assumed that the number of articles to be found in the
sample newspapers would not be affected by the lesser number of editions.

Therefore, from all three newspapers, a total of 130 editions were used for the analysis.

Story selection
From the sample newspapers, all factual articles (news, interviews, and features) were
coded according to whether the story mentions violence against women (rape, beating,
genital mutilation, abduction, early marriage, verbal assault, and the like) as part of the
study. For this study, stories talking about violence against men were excluded.

Interview
As stated earlier, the interview was used to support the data gathered through content
analysis. To conduct the interview, an interview guide was prepared. (See Appendix D)
The guide contained different questions on journalists/editors’ roles on the coverage of
gender violence during the period of September 2006 to September 2007. The questions
were similar to those stated in the coding sheet. (See Appendix A) However, a different
category –‘background’ was added to learn about the journalists/editors’ point of view on
gender violence in general.

Four journalists and editors from the sample newspapers were selected purposefully.
Journalists who had written most of the analyzed articles were included in the interview.
In identifying journalists who wrote most of the stories, the researcher counted the
number of stories a reporter wrote by looking at the by-lines. Then, those who wrote most
of the analyzed stories were contacted. Editors of the newspapers were also included for
the interview. Hence, a total of four journalists (2 females and 2 males) were interviewed.
(See Appendix B)
3.4 Data Collection and Analysis
In conducting this research, the researcher employed content analysis and in-depth
interviews to collect and analyze the necessary data. Content analysis was used because it
is a commonly used approach in the study of media framing. As it is defined by Zito
(cited in Berger, 1998:23), content analysis is “a methodology by which the researcher
seeks to determine the manifest content of written, spoken, or published communications
by systematic, objective, and quantitative analysis […]” Furthermore, content analysis
was joined with in-depth interviews to come up with a better result. It was believed that
the data gathered through the qualitative method could provide personal histories,
perspectives and experiences regarding gender violence.

In analyzing the contents of the newspapers, coding sheets were adopted from prior
researches in order to look into the types, locations, themes, sources, frames, and media
functions of articles about violence against women. The sheet was classified into five
parts. The first part consists of article description which in turn embraces article type and
location of article. Article type refers to whether the article was news, feature or
interview. Location indicates where in the newspaper the story is placed; front, inside or
last page. The second category is theme. It refers to the main idea of the story. It includes
violence, court trials, neglect, discussions/demonstrations, and health consequences. The
third category is sources which are identified as the name of individual, group or
organization which are quoted directly or indirectly in the story. The next part deals with
the different kinds of frames used in the media. They are diagnostic, prognostic,
attribution of responsibility, solution, empathy, morality, human interest, economic,
conflict, and educative/advocacy frame. Finally, the last category is about media function
which discusses the role of the newspapers in reporting the issue. (See Appendix A)

Frames used in the analyzed articles were measured adopting a series of questions to
which the coders had to answer ‘yes’ (1) or ‘no’ (0), which were developed by Semeketo
and Valkenburg (2000). Some minor changes were made on the questions to measure
whether frames of attribution, human interest, moral, conflict and economic were
available in the stories. Some other questions were also developed based on the review
literature to gauge the existence of frames of diagnostic, prognostic, solution, empathy,
and educative. The existence of frame was determined by dividing the number of ‘yes’ to
the total number of questions under that frame. The coefficient of frame existence varies
from 0.0 to 1.0. It was assumed that a specific frame existed if the coefficient was more
than half (0.5).

Other ‘yes’ or ‘no’ questions were also developed to examine the functions the
newspapers carried out in reporting gender violence. The questions were prepared to look
at four general media functions: defining the problem, stating causes, providing moral
evaluation and suggesting treatments.

Coding process
The coding process was carried out by two students, a female and a male, who were
trained on how to code articles. The training was given by the researcher. The coders
were provided with the coding sheet along with coding guides. (See Appendix C) Then,
they filled out the coding sheet by replying ‘yes’ or ‘no’ to the lists of questions that were
developed from the literature and current facts of gender violence in Ethiopia.

Inter- coder reliability was assessed through Holist’s formula where:

Reliability=2*M/ (N1+N2)
M represents the number of coding decisions with which the two coders agree while N1
and N2 are the total number of coding decisions by the first and the second coder
respectively. The inter-coder reliability across all categories ranges from 92% to 100%
for the 15% of the stories the two coders coded.

The validity can be assured from the categorizations of relevant issues on the coding
sheet as well. In addition, the objective of assessing the extent to which gender violence
is covered in the Ethiopian media and how it is framed would be indicators of the validity
as the most important points in each category were reasonably developed and included.

3.5 Limitations of the study

The major limitation that the study suffers from is time constraint during the collection of
data. As the coders were students who have their own responsibilities, it took a while
before they finished the coding process.

In addition, identifying some of the journalists in the newspapers was difficult because
names of the reporters in some articles were left unmentioned. In case of Addis Admas,
features appeared by sponsorship were sometimes contributed by individuals outside the
profession of journalism. Hence, these individuals were intentionally excluded from the
interview. Regarding, Police na Ermijaw, the researcher learned that most of the news
stories were contributed by police officers who worked on cases of gender violence.
Thus, these individuals were also not contacted.

Chapter Four
 4. Presentation of Findings and Data analysis

This chapter presents the findings of the study, their analysis and discussion. The
collected data focused on how the Ethiopian newspapers framed gender violence with in
the time period from September 2006_2007. The data were collected from three local
newspapers (Addis Admas, Police na Ermijaw, and Medical) using coding sheets. In
addition, in-depth interviews were conducted with editors and journalists of the sample
newspapers. In the following, the results are presented in graphs and tables along with
their analysis and discussion.

4.1 The extent of the newspapers coverage of gender violence

Out of 130 editions of the three sample newspapers, 67 articles that dealt with issues of
gender violence were found. The articles were concerned with different themes and
consisted of different types of gender violence. As figure 4.1 shows, Addis Admas, a
private owned newspaper which deals with social issues, has provided 47 percent of the
total analyzed articles. Police na Ermijaw, a government owned paper which primarily is
concerned with crime, has reported 37 percent of the articles. The private owned
newspaper which reports health issues, Medical, has published 16 percent of the stories.

Figure 4.1 Percentage of stories on gender violence

published by the newspapers

47
50
37
40
Percent

30
20 16

10
0
Addis Admas Police na Ermijaw Medical
Name of new spapers

From the interview conducted with the editors and journalists of the three newspapers, it
was found out that the number of stories published on gender violence was influenced by
factors like sponsorship, sex of the editor/journalist, priority and the like. The editor of
Addis Admas attributed the appearance of significantly higher number of articles on their
newspaper to sponsors that funded coverage of stories on gender violence in their
newspaper. Interestingly, he noted that “different [non governmental organizations]
NGOs that work on gender issues sponsored the stories written on violence against
women.” Furthermore, a journalist in Addis Admas stated that her sex had an impact on
the selection of the topic. She said “I deliberately look for news on gender violence. I
think my sex has something to do with my preference to stories on the issue.” Similarly,
the editor of Police na Ermijaw pointed out that she made sure that articles on gender
violence appeared in every fortnightly edition. She admitted that her sex had influenced
her decision. “I am a mother. This is a very sensitive issue for me.”, she said.

On the other hand, the editor of Medical told that ‘priority’ was one of the factors that
resulted in the lesser number of stories on gender violence in their newspaper. He stated
that “Although violence against women is a very important issue, we give priority to
other health matters.” In addition, lack of sponsorship was also mentioned as another
factor for the small number of such articles in Medical.

Figure 4.2 shows distribution of type of articles published in the three newspapers. As
can be seen from the figure, news accounted for 48 percent of the analyzed articles,
followed by feature which held 46 percent. On the other hand, only 6 percent of the
stories were interviews.

Figure 4.2 Percentage of article type distribution in the

newspapers

Interview
6%
News News
48% Feature
Feature
Interview
The distribution of46%
article types across the newspapers is indicated in Table 4.1. News
was the major type of articles in Police na Ermijaw, and made up for 68 percent of the
total content. Most of the stories in Medical, 73 percent, and 48 percent in Addis Admas
were feature stories. Interviews were only found in Addis Admas, where they constituted
13 percent of the newspapers total content.

Table 4.1 Percentage of distribution of article type across the newspapers

Article type Addis Admas Police na Ermijaw Medical

News 39 68 27
Feature 48 32 73
Interview 13 - -
Total 100 100 100

In explaining their newspaper’s content, Informant 2 said that a great deal of articles in
Police na Ermijaw were news because the stories either report violence or court trials that
occurred recently. On the contrary, Informant 1 asserted that most of the stories in Addis
Adams were feature stories as the articles were published with the support of sponsors
that focused on the general nature of gender violence. Similarly, Informant 3 gave the
same reason as informant 2; discussing general characters of the problem contributed to
the higher percentage of features in Medical.

4.2 The nature of the newspapers coverage of gender violence

Six main themes were found in the analyzed articles. Figure 4.3 shows the percentage of
themes covered by the newspapers. As the figure shows, violence and court trials
accounted for 46 percent and 24 percent of the analyzed articles respectively. The theme
in 15 percent of the stories is demonstrations/discussions. Health consequences/
treatments and neglect were themes in 10 percent and 4 percent of the analyzed articles
respectively. The sixth theme, legal issues, was found in the category ‘others’. It only
made up for 1 percent of the articles.

Figure 4.3 Percentage of themes covered by the

newspapers

50
40
30
In terms of distribution of themes across the newspapers, there was some diversity. Some
themes were excluded in one or two of the newspapers. As can be seen from table 4.1, the
topics neglect, and health consequences/treatments were not available in the government
owned newspaper, Police na Ermijaw. Similarly, the theme, ‘legal issue’, was not
reported in neither Police na Ermijaw nor Medical. The private owned newspaper, Addis
Admas did not report on court trials.

Table 4.2 Percentage of theme distribution across the newspapers

Themes Addis Admas Police na Ermijaw Medical

(n=31) (n=25) (n=11)
Violence 56 36 37
Court trials - 52 27
Neglect 3 - 18
Discussions/Demonstration 19 12 9
Health 19 - 9
consequences/treatments
Legal issues analysis 3 - -
Total 100 100 100

Distribution of themes across the newspapers also showed some distinctions. Violence
accounted for 56 percent and 37 percent of the themes covered in Addis Admas and
Medical newspapers respectively. 52 percent of the analyzed articles in Police na
Ermijaw newspaper dealt with court trials as their major theme. The least covered themes
in Addis Admas were neglect and legal issues, each accounted for 3 percent of the articles
in each newspaper. Discussions/demonstrations were themes in 12 percent of the articles
in Police na Ermijaw, and 9 percent in Medical. Although Medical is a newspaper which
mainly reports on health issues, the theme ‘health consequences/treatments’ was the least
covered theme in this newspaper, which accounted only 9 percent of the analyzed
articles.

The informants from the private owned newspapers (Addis Adams and Medical) noted
that violence was a major theme in their newspaper for two reasons. First, violence is a
day to day event which is reported to police officers. Hence, it would be easier to collect
the necessary information from police officers. Secondly, violence attracts more
readership as it is more dramatic than most other themes. In case of, Police na Ermijaw,
the informant stated that court trials were themes in most of the stories because most of
the stories were collected from police stations. The informant said that “As the main
objective of our newspaper is to protect the society from crime, our reason for
emphasizing on court trials is to teach the society a lesson by showing what would
happen when such crimes are committed.”

Figure 4.4 Percentage of types of gender violence

mentioned in the newspapers
38
40
35
30 21
25
20 11
15 9 10 7
10 4
5
0
pe

e
g

rn
M

lt
ag
in

au
tio
FG

bu
Ra

at

ri
c

ss
Be

du

ar

id
A
M

Ac
Ab

al
rly

rb
Ea

Ve

In the analyzed articles, seven types of gender violence were included. Out of these, ‘acid
burn’ is found under the category ‘others’. Figure 4.5 shows the percentage of types of
gender violence that were mentioned in the analyzed articles. Rape and beating made up
for 38 percent and 21 percent of the total types of gender violence mentioned in the
articles respectively. The least mentioned type of gender violence in the analyzed articles
was verbal assault, which accounted only for 4 percent.

Table 4.3 Percentage of types of gender distribution across the newspapers

Types of gender violence Addis Admas Police na Medical

(n=49) Ermijaw (n=33)
Rape 36 40 31
Beating 14 30 23
FGM 12 9 15
Abduction 8 9 15
Early marriage 12 9 8
Verbal assault 6 3 -
Acid burn 12 - 8
Total 100 100 100

Some of the newspapers mentioned more than one or no type of gender violence in the
analyzed articles. As can be seen from table 4.2, stories on verbal assault were totally
absent in Police na Ermijaw. Similarly, despite the fact that acid burn is a criminal
activity, it was not reported in Police na Ermijaw which deals with criminal issues. Table
4.2 further shows that 40 percent of the analyzed articles in Police na Ermijaw, 36
percent of the articles in Addis Admas and 31 percent of the articles in Medical reported
on rape cases. Beating was the second mostly mentioned type of gender violence in all
three newspapers. It accounted for 30 percent of the articles in Police na Ermijaw, 23
percent in Medical and 14 percent in Addis Admas.

All informants agreed that rape was the most common topic in relation to stories on
violence in their newspapers because it was a frequently reported crime in police stations.
They also pointed out that though the other types of gender violence were equally
criminal acts, some types of violence were tied up with some of the society’s cultures and
traditions. According to Informant 2, “In some cultures, some people are reluctant in
reporting some types of gender violence like early marriage and abduction as criminal
activities because they are regarded as part of their traditions.”
4.3 Sources used in the articles
In terms of sources used in the articles, diversified sources were identified and quoted.
Figure 4.6 indicates that most of the articles quoted victim’s families and friends, 16
percent, followed by police officers, 15 percent. Victims contributed to 12 percent of the
sources. Women’s associations, NGO officials and community members accounted for
11 percent, 7 percent and 6 percent of sources used in the stories respectively. The
articles used 10 percent unspecified sources.

Figure 4.5 Percentage of sources quoted in the newspapers

18 15 16
16
14 12 11
12 10
10 Series1
7 6
8 5 5 Series2
6 4 3 4
4 2
2
0
o f ls

p e rg.
ilie offi s

No n a rs
te ea rs

d
P e ic s

fr i rs

ity oia rts

&r D rs
ds

em ns
im P p e s

r
l
O ficia

ie
tim
ia

fa ice to

io e
In e s no
s& e

ts lo
en
m a ss xpe

m tio

a t rch

cif
c

eb
f ic

's oil tr a

o
NG t o f

E
un c
en

r
nm

rn
m

es
co n's
er

ch
ov

e
om

ar
m
G

se
W
ct

Re
Vi

The source distribution across the newspapers indicated a significant difference. As

indicated in Table 4.3, Addis Admas used victim’s families and friends as its major
sources, 19 percent. In Police na Ermijaw, the majority of the stories, 34 percent, quoted
police officers. In the case of Medical, the highest number of sources used in the articles
was accounted by the victims, 23 percent. Police officers were the least quoted sources in
the two private owned newspapers, Addis Admas and Medical, 2 percent and 6 percent
respectively. Perpetrators (10 percent) were used as sources only in Police na Ermijaw.
Similarly, donors and international organizations (6 percent and 8 percent respectively)
were only quoted in Addis Admas.
Table 4.4 Percentage of source distribution across the newspapers

Sources Addis Admas Police na Medical

(n=51) Ermijaw (n=40) (n=17)
Government officials 4 8 -
Non-government 8 3 12
Victims 15 5 23
Perpetrators - 10 -
Police officers 2 34 6
Victim’s families and 19 12 18
friends
Experts 6 3 6
Women’s associations 12 12 6
Community members 6 8 -
Donors 6 - -
Research and 4 - 6
researchers
International 8 - -
organizations
Unspecified source 10 5 23
Total 100 100 100

Regarding the sources they used in their newspapers, the informants noted that who
should be used often depend on the theme of the stories they were reporting on. If the
article was about violence and court trials, victims’ families and friends and police
officers were the main sources in their stories. Informant 2 stated that police officers were
their major sources as they were the contributors of their articles. The Informant added
that “in most cases because victims are traumatized, their families and friends are the
ones to explain what happened and to express their rage.” As to Informant 4, if the
victims were in a better psychological condition and were willing to talk, they were
preferable sources because they could add personal experience to the stories; and were
likely to get more reaction from the audience. According to the interviewees, if talking to
victims was impossible, the next best thing would be quoting their families and friends.

On the other hand, when the articles were on discussions/demonstrations and neglect, the
informants asserted that their sources were quite often government and non-government
officials who worked on gender issues and women’s associations.
4.4 Frames used in stories of gender violence
In framing gender violence, the location of the articles in the analyzed newspapers can be
considered as a significant factor because it might indicate the importance of the issue in
the newspapers. As Figure 4.6 shows, 58 percent of the articles were located at the inside
pages of the newspapers. The rest 42 percent of the analyzed articles were placed in the
front page. Although the last page was included as a category, no such article was found
at this location. In the two newspapers, Addis Admas and Police na Ermijaw, the last
page was reserved only for sports news. In case of Medical, the last page contained
merely ‘the letter’ section.

Figure 4.6 percentage of distribution of location in the newspapers

58

60 42
50
40
30
20
10
0
Front page inside

Table 4.5 shows the distribution of location of stories across the three newspapers. The
majority of the articles in the two private owned newspapers, Medical (82 percent) and
Addis Admas (68 percent), were located in the inside page. The government owned
newspaper, Police na Ermijaw has published 68 percent of the articles at the front page.

Table 4.5 Percentage of location allocation of gender violence stories across the
newspapers

Location Addis Admas Police na Medical Total

(n=31) Ermijaw (n=25) (n=11) (n=67)
 Front page 32 64 18 42
Inside page 68 36 82 58

From the interviewees, it was found out that the location of the articles covering gender
violence was often determined by the types of the articles. If the stories were hard news,
they quite often were placed at the front page. Informant 1 said that they usually put the
news about gender violence on front page. However, if the articles were feature, they
were located at the inside pages where the sections were most of the time sponsored by
organizations. According to Informant 2, they deliberately placed stories of gender
violence at the front page so as to catch the readers’ attention towards the topic. The
informant also added when there were “several stories on the issue for one edition, we
sometimes put the stories in the inside page even if they are news.” On the other hand,
Informant 3 stated that they decided the location of the stories depending on the focus of
the story on health consequences/treatments. If the story presented health perspective, the
story might appear at the front page, and vise versa.

Figure 4.7 Percentage of frames used by the newspapers

25 20
20 17
Percent

15 12
9 10 9
10 8 7
6
5 2
0
st

e
n
y
tic

t
ic
ic

ity

lic
t io
ilit

th

iv
re
st

om
os

al

at
nf
pa
sib
no

lu

te
or
gn

co

uc
on
So

in
Em
og

on

Ed
a

Ec
an
Pr
Di

sp

m
Re

Hu

The findings show that the frames used in the analyzed articles range from the least
applied frame, 2 percent, the economic frame to the dominant one - 20 percent, human
interest. (See Figure 4.7) Empathy frame was the second most frequently used frame in
the articles, which covered gender violence and accounted for 17 percent. Prognostic and
solution frames were employed in 12 percent and 10 percent of the analyzed articles
respectively.

Regarding distribution of frames across the news papers, Table 4.6 shows that most of the
articles in Medical, 26 percent, and 19 percent in Addis Adams contained human interest
frame. The dominant frame in Police na Ermijaw was the empathy frame, 22 percent,
with the human interest frame as a close number two with 21 percent of the stories. The
economic frame in relation to gender violence was the least applied frame in Addis
Admas and Medical, which accounted for 3 percent and 1 percent of the articles
respectively. The economic frame was totally absent in Police na Ermijaw in the
coverage of gender violence.

Table 4.6 Percentage of frame distribution across the newspapers covering gender
violence

Themes Addis Adams Police na Ermijaw Medical

Diagnostic 8 8 7
Prognostic 10 20 7
Responsibility 11 9 3
Solution 11 7 9
Empathy 14 22 15
Morality 11 6 9
Human interest 19 21 26
Economic 3 - 1
Conflict 5 3 16
Educative 8 4 7
Total 100 100 100

The distribution of diagnostic frame across the newspapers shows a great deal of
similarity. The frame counts for 8 percent of the analyzed articles on gender violence in
both Addis Admas and Police na Ermijaw; and 7 percent in Medical. On the other hand,
the distribution of prognostic frame indicates some differences between the newspapers.
While it accounted for 20 percent of the articles on gender violence in Police na Ermijaw,
it was used in 10 percent of such articles in Addis Admas and in 7 percent of the gender
violence stories in Medical.

All informants agreed that they were not conscious of the frames they used in reporting
gender violence. When asked about why involving human face in most of their stories
was important, Informant 1 and Informant 3 pointed out that having human faces added
more color to the story. It could also attract readers’ attention more easily as people
would like to read stories that have a personal touch. Similarly, Informant 2 stressed that
they used human examples because they believed people could learn from others’
experience and take precautions. As the Informant put it “Parents can learn from the
children examples that were affected by gender violence and can protect their children
from suffering similar crimes.”

Concerning the use of empathy frame in the coverage of gender violence, the informants
highlighted that the problem by nature contributed to the existence of the frame.
Informant 2 stated that most of the characters in gender violence stories were children.
She also added that they most often addressed those affected by the violence as ‘victims’
because they saw them that way. In addition, Informant 4 noted that the story by itself
made her use words or expressions that might generate feelings of outrages, empathy,
caring, sympathy or compassion. The other informants also supported the idea that the
nature of the issue contributed to the empathetic way of reporting.

When asked why frames like diagnostic, prognostic, and solution frames, which show
why the violence has happened, what consequences they can have and what measures
should be taken, were moderately used in their stories, Informant 3 stated that the
presence of these frames could be influenced by the information they got regarding the
stories and the sources used in the story. Similarly, Informant 4 explained that finding
sources who could tell her the extent of the violence was important in stating the causes
and effects of the problem. However, sometimes the information she could get on the
violence simply stated what happened. Unfortunately, time and resource constraints held
her back from investigating the story further.
For the question why they used attribution of responsibility frame to a limited extent,
Informant 4 reasoned that it was to avoid repetition that they did not attribute the
responsibility to anyone in every article. She also said “publishing the stories by itself
was attributing responsibility to those who could alleviate the problem like the
government, different NGOs and the society.” On the other hand, Informant 2 noted that
although it was not mentioned in their newspaper, she personally attributed the
responsibility to judges who could alleviate the problem by executing the maximum
punishment on the perpetrators.

Regarding the employment of morality frame, the informants stated that they quite often
presented the stories in a neutral manner so the reader could pass its own judgment.
However, depending on the severity of the violence, they some times condemned or
asked the audience to condemn the act. Similarly, concerning the little use of educative
frame, Informant 3 highlighted that time and resource constraints limited their attempt in
providing educative articles. He noted that preparing stories on how to get medical care
and how to cope after the violence required a longer period of time and different experts’
point of views. Hence, they focused on reporting the violence with little educative
information. The other informants also stated similar reasons.

Finally, all informants agreed that lack of information on the economic consequences of
the problem either on individual or on the national level affected the existence of the
economic frame. Furthermore, the informants asserted that as most of the sources used in
the stories were against the violence, they made the issue one-sided. Hence, the conflict
frame became significantly less dominant in the articles covering gender violence.

4.5 Media function

The function the newspapers performed is indicated in Figure 4.7. Out of the four media
roles played by the newspapers seen together, 47 percent was held by defining the
problem. 26 percent of the articles also stated the cause of the violence. Articles that
provided moral evaluation accounted for 16 percent of the analyzed articles. The lowest
percentage is indicated by the fourth function of the media, suggesting treatment _11
percent.

Figure 4.8 Percentage of roles played by the

newspapers

50
40
30
47
20
26
10 16 11
0
Define probem State cause Provide moral evn. Suggest treatment

Table 4.7 Distribution of functions performed by each newspaper

Roles of the media Addis Admas Police na Medical (n=22)

(n=54) Ermijaw(n=40)
Define the problem 37 62 41
State the cause 24 28 27
Provide moral evaluation 20 5 27
Suggest treatment 19 5 5
Total 100 100 100

Police na Ermijaw defined the problem in most of its articles on gender violence, 62
percent. Medical and Addis Admas defined the problem in 41 percent and 37 percent of
their articles respectively. Regarding stating the cause of the violence, 28 percent of the
articles in Police na Ermijaw, 27 percent in Medical, and 24 percent in Addis Admas
performed that task. Suggesting solutions for the problem was the least frequent function
carried out by the newspapers. Only 5 percent of the stories in Police na Ermijaw and 5
percent in Medical suggested solutions for the violence.

4.6 Results and Discussion

The study aims at finding out how the Ethiopian newspapers framed gender violence. A
total of 67 newspaper articles were analyzed. Out of these, 31 were from Addis Admas,
25 were from Police na Ermijaw, and 11 were from Medical. Types, locations, themes,
sources and frames of articles were examined. In addition, journalists and editors who
worked for the sample newspapers were interviewed. The results of the study are
interpreted and discussed in the following section.

4.6.1 Extent of Coverage

The findings indicate that Addis Admas has published the majority of the total amount of
articles on gender violence, 47 percent. Higher coverage of gender violence by the highly
circulated newspaper in the country would enable the issue reach wider readership. As
stated in Chapter two, the extent of media coverage of the issue would impact the
response the problem receives from the public and the policy makers.

From the interview with the editor and the journalist of the newspaper, it was observed
that two factors contributed to the comparatively higher number of articles in Addis
Admas. The first factor mentioned was the presence of different organizations, mostly
NGOs, to sponsor the appearance of articles on gender issue. Thus, getting sponsorship
enabled the newspaper to cover the issue with better human and material resources.

The second factor was the sex of the journalist who reported the issue in the analyzed
articles. The journalist who quite often reported on the issue affirmed that her sex has
influenced her to look for and report on gender violence. She did, however, underline that
this did not affect the way she reported the issue. She only admitted her purposive
selection of the topic; and would not let her sensitivity interfere with how the story was
presented. Steeves (1997) argues that the reporter’s sex has its own impact on the
reporting of gender-sensitivity stories.

Out of the total articles published by Addis Admas, a significantly high number of them,
68 percent were placed inside the newspaper; where as 32 percent made it to the front
page. The location of the articles might have a direct correlation with the types of the
stories; whether they were news, feature or interview. As indicated in the presentation
section of this thesis, a considerable amount of stories in Addis Admas (48 percent) were
presented in feature formats which commonly is found in the inside pages. The placement
of the articles can be attributed to the importance of the issue. It is assumed that when a
story is located at front page, it catches greater attention.

Police na Ermijaw is found second in line by contributing 37 percent of the total amount
of the analyzed articles. However, it should be taken into account that the newspaper is a
fortnightly paper which publishes half of the weekly newspapers, Addis Admas and
Medical. As a result, considering its number of editions, it would be possible to highlight
that the newspaper has published a considerable amount of articles on the issue compared
to the others. Moreover, unlike the private owned newspapers, greater amount of articles
in this newspaper were front page news. According to the Informant, as the newspaper is
purposively concerned with crime issues, most gender violence stories that were reported
to police officers were sent to her (the editor). Hence, they were able to contain the issue
in most of their editions; 21 articles were found in the total of 26 editions. More than one
or no article about gender violence was found in each edition. In addition, during the
interview the editor expressed her profound commitment in making the newspaper
inclusive of the issue. She related her action with her gender. As a result sex of the
journalist was found to have a profound impact on the coverage of gender violence.

Medical published 16 percent of the analyzed articles. Only 11 articles dealing with
gender violence were found in the analyzed sample from the newspaper. Despite the
issue’s devastating health consequences, physical as well as psychological, the health
newspaper has contributed surprisingly little in providing information that readers could
benefit from. Powers and Andsager (1999) point out that newspaper has played a
significant role in increasing awareness of different health issues in the USA. When
explaining why the number of articles was so small in the newspaper, the editor
underlined that other health issues were given priorities compared to gender violence as
there were several health issues to be discussed. Furthermore, lack of sponsorship was
mentioned as a reason for not having a fixed section regarding the issue.
4.6.2 Themes of articles
Gender violence can be presented from different perspectives as the issue has multiple
causes and effects. When an issue or event has several sides, the media tend to focus on
certain elements of that issue or problem. (Powers and Andsager, 1999) Like wise, this
research found out that the analyzed articles on gender violence overly emphasized some
aspects of the theme while focusing on other themes to a limited extent.

Violence and court trials were the highly concentrated themes across the newspapers. In
the private newspapers, violence was found to be the major theme in most of their
articles, 56 percent in Addis Admas and 37 percent in Medical. That violence was the
majority theme in the private owned newspapers might be due to marketing reasons as
the nature of the theme can easily attract reader’s attention. According to Husselbee and
Elliot (2002), journalists sensationalize news coverage to attract readership. On the other
hand, about the positive impact of reporting on violence, Byerly and Ross (2006) note
that it encourages more women to report such crimes to the police.

Court trial was the dominant theme in Police na Ermijaw. However, in every court trail
case the violence was briefly stated as well. Obviously this theme is important in
emphasizing the consequences of committing the violence. It, therefore, would probably
send a message to the public what would happen if they got involved in such crime.

Surprisingly, the theme _ health consequences/treatment was hardly covered by Medical,

a paper which mainly deals with health matters. Only 9 percent of the analyzed articles in
the newspaper reported this theme. In fact Addis Adams was the only newspaper that
focused on this theme.

The other themes like discussions/demonstrations and neglect were covered only to a
limited extent. Seminars, meetings and demonstrations regarding gender violence were
themes only in 15 percent of the analyzed articles. Similarly, stories on neglect; how the
issue and those affected by the problem are neglected, were very few. Besides, neglect
was only the theme of the articles in the private owned newspapers.

4.6.3 Coverage of types of gender violence

As stated in chapter two, gender violence involves several acts. Those believed to be
more common such as rape, beating, FGM (Female Genital Mutilation), abduction, early
marriage, and verbal assault were coded for types of gender violence. In addition, acid
burn was found as one type of gender violence covered by the newspapers. One or more
than one form of gender violence was mentioned in a story.

Among the coded types of gender violence, rape has received a greater extent of coverage
by all three newspapers. The findings of the study show consistency with the literature
that rape is a frequently reported type of gender violence. (See Chapter two) The number
of rape mentioned in the newspapers was relatively high, probably because it was also the
form of gender that was most frequently reported to the police in Ethiopia.

The second most frequently mentioned type of gender violence in the analyzed material
was beating. In numbers both the private and government newspapers reported on beating
next to rape. This form of violence can occur alone or with other types of gender
violence. For example, a woman might be beaten while she was raped.

FGM, abduction, and early marriage are types of gender violence that are also referred to
as harmful traditional practices. These forms of violence were covered only to a limited
extent in the newspapers. As indicated in the presentation section, FGM, abduction, and
early marriage accounted for 11 percent, 9 percent and 10 percent of the analyzed articles
respectively. What make these forms of violence different and more complicated than
others is that they are integral parts of some cultures and traditions. In addition, those
parties that can protect the victims from the violence such as parents often take a central
part in committing the violence. This might be attributed to the limited number of these
types of gender violence in the newspapers. However, newspapers can play significant
roles in challenging these harmful traditional practices by giving them more coverage.
Moreover, the extent of coverage given to these forms of violence might encourage those
victimized by the violence to report such cases to the police.

Another type of gender violence which was coded under the ‘other’ category was acid
burn. This type of violence was found in 7 percent of the analyzed newspaper articles on
gender violence. It was reported only in the private newspapers. Police na Ermijaw
totally ignored this form of violence. The type was largely mentioned during the coverage
of the so called Kamilat case, where a girl who suffered acid burn caused by her alleged
boyfriend. The story outraged many and led to public opposition through demonstration.

The least reported type of gender of violence in the analyzed articles was verbal assault,
which made up for 4 percent. While it was mentioned in Addis Admas and Police na
Ermijaw, it was excluded in Medical in spite of its psychological impacts. In most cases,
verbal assault is rarely reported to the police unless it gets too extreme. This may result
from the belief that one needs physical injury to take an act as a crime. The newspapers,
however, can influence such thinking by emphasizing the impacts of the violence in their
coverage.

4.6.4 Sources used in the articles

Sources used in stories can influence how an issue or event is framed. (Andsager and
Powers, 1999) Unlike several media studies, the results of the present study show the use
of few number of government officials in the stories. Lacy and Coulson (2000:14) point
out that “general studies on news source use conclude that reporters limit their choice of
sources and choose governmental officials over any other.” However, the reporters of the
analyzed articles used only 5 percent of governmental officials as sources in the analyzed
articles.

Victims’ families and friends were most often quoted followed by police officers.
However, differences among the private and government newspapers occurred in the use
of the two sources (victims’ families and police officers). While Addis Admas and
Medical used victim’s families and friends more frequently in their stories; Police na
Ermijaw quite often quoted police officers as major sources. Similarly, whereas victims
were the second most frequently used sources in Addis Admas and Medical, they were the
least quoted sources in Police na Ermijaw. The use of victims’ words in stories by the
private owned newspapers might be correlated with sensationalizing the issue to sell
papers.

Source use variation among the newspapers is similar with Lacy and Coulson’s findings
on newspaper source use on the environmental beat. They found out that there were
variations in source distribution between government officials and business men.

Individuals from different women’s associations were other significantly quoted sources
in the newspapers’ articles on gender violence. Nowadays, several women’s associations
are working with the media to fight against gender violence. This closeness might be
attributed to the moderately significant number of sources from the associations. Lacy
and Coulson (2000:15) argue that sources that have access to journalists “provide a
socially constructed interpretation of newsworthy events or issues that makes journalists’
job easier by providing an acceptable structure for succeeding stories.”

On the other hand, doctors, social workers and psychologists who might have shared their
expertise on the issue were interviewed to a limited extent. This suggested that the stories
did little in showing gender violence from experts’ perspectives.

4.6.5 Frames employed in stories of gender violence

The extent of coverage and location of articles are integral parts of media framing of an
issue or event. In this case, Addis Admas and Police na Ermijaw framed gender issue in
more significant manner compared to the third sample newspaper, Medical.

As the findings of the study indicate, a number of frames were used in the stories
reporting on gender violence. The dominant frame in the analyzed articles was found to
be human interest followed by empathy frame. Frames like diagnostic, prognostic,
responsibility, solution, morality and educative were used in the stories to some extent.
On the contrary, economic and conflict frames were the least frequently utilized frames in
the newspapers. In fact, economic frame was totally ignored in Police na Ermijaw. (See
Table 4.6)

The frames are discussed in the following section. For the sake of convenience, the
frames are grouped into 5 parts: (1) human interest and empathy (2) diagnostic and
prognostic (3) responsibility and solution (4) morality and educative/advocacy, and (5)
economic and conflict.

4.6.5.1 Human interest and empathy frame

Human interest is the most frequently used frame in the newspapers compared to the
other frames. It was the dominant frame in the private owned newspapers, Addis Admas
and Medical. However, it was the second mostly used frame in Police na Ermijaw very
close to the newspapers’ dominant frame, empathy. The use of this frame suggested that
the newspapers tried to focus on individual experiences to report the stories of gender
violence.

The result also indicated that the newspapers’ coverage of the issue skewed toward more
of episodic, which emphasizes individuals issue while ignoring social factors that
contribute to the occurrence of the violence. (Carlyle et al, 2008) The existence of
episodic frame can be strengthened through the newspapers’ fewer use of diagnostic
frame which can provide social factors that help perpetuate the violence. (See Table 4.6)
According to Carlyle et al (2008:181), such coverage has its own limitation. They argue
that “by portraying [the violence] as an individual or a relationship issue without
discussing the underlying causes of [the violence], victims may be more likely to feel
blamed for their own victimization.”

On the other side, using human interest frame might easily attract readers’ attention to the
issue. Semetko and Valkenburg (2000) note that one way of capturing and retaining
audience interest is by framing news in human interest terms. Obviously having wider
audience influences the response the issue can receive from the public. The public
perception in turn might affect the laws and policies made regarding gender violence.

Next to human interest, empathy is a frequently used frame in the newspapers. In the case
of Police na Ermijaw, however, it was the most frequently utilized frame. The
newspapers quite often addressed those affected by the violence as ‘victims’. Further
more, children were most often mentioned among those who encountered the violence.
The extent of empathy frame might be attributed to the sources used by the newspapers.
As it is stated earlier, the majority of the sources quoted in the articles were victims’
families and friends who would be outraged by the violence. In addition, the quoting of
victims in the articles might also make the story more empathic.

4.6.5.2 Diagnostic and Prognostic frames

Diagnostic and prognostic frames explain causes and effects of an issue or event
respectively. These frames were utilized by the newspapers in the coverage of gender
violence only to some extent. Diagnostic frame was used in 8 percent of the analyzed
articles. The frame’s distribution among the newspapers showed significant similarity.
From the items coded as causes of gender violence, social norms/beliefs and harmful
traditional practices were comparatively the frequently stated factors. Alcohol was
mentioned as the cause of the violence only in 4 percent of the articles. Similarly, Carlyle
et al (2008) found out that the perpetrator was under the influence of alcohol only in 6
percent of the stories. The findings of the study imply that journalists did little in
providing causes of the violence that might help the readers processing the information.
The prognostic frame was employed slightly more frequently than diagnostic frame. 12
percent of the articles in the newspapers used this frame. Among the newspapers, Police
na Ermijaw employed the prognostic frame more often (20 percent) than the private
newspapers, Addis Admas and Medical. Mortality occurred due to the violence in 31
percent of the articles; whereas school dropout/loss of job due to the violence was rarely
mentioned in the articles. In addition, intimate partners were involved in the violence in
33 percent of the stories. Framing gender violence using prognostic frame can be
important in indicating the seriousness of the problem.
4.6.5.3 Attribution of responsibility and solution frames
Attribution of responsibility and solution frames were used in the newspapers to some
extent; they were found in 9 percent and 10 percent of the newspapers respectively. The
two frames are highly correlated since both frames focus on the solution of the problem.
Regarding distribution of the frames across the newspapers, 11 percent of articles in
Addis Admas used attribution responsibility. Similarly, 9 percent of the stories in Police
na Ermijaw contained this frame. On the contrary, only 3 percent of the stories in
Medical were framed using attribution of responsibility frame. Government and the
general community were relatively stated often as agents who could alleviate the
problem.

Stories using the solution frame were 11 percent of the total stories from Addis Admas, 7
percent of the analyzed stories from Police na Ermijaw, and 9 percent of the analyzed
stories in Medical. Similar to the attribution of responsibility frame, government actions
and societal responsibility were suggested as solutions of the problem. The findings
suggested that the newspapers tended to suggest solutions for gender violence to a limited
extent.

4.6.5.4 Morality and educative/advocacy frames

The morality frame was utilized in 9 percent of the newspapers. It was used in 11 percent
of the analyzed articles in Addis Admas, 6 percent in Police na Ermijaw, and 9 percent in
Medical. Neuman et al (cited in Semetko and Valkenburg, 2000) highlight that the
morality frame is not categorized under the most frequently used frames in reporting. The
findings of the study also support this. This specific frame is believed to exist in the
minds of the audience rather than in the content of the stories. (Neuman et al cited in
Semetko and Valkenburg, 2000)

Out of the articles where the morality frame was found, some of them condemned or
asked the audience to condemn the violence. Like wise, only few articles presented
gender violence as violation of human rights. This suggested that most journalists failed
to include the problem in wider context.
As educating the public is one of the main responsibilities of the media, employing an
educative frame is indisputably crucial. Side by side, the media can also advocate policy
changes regarding an issue. However, the analyzed newspapers made use of
educative/advocacy frame to a small extent. Only 7 percent of the articles on gender
violence in the selected newspapers contained this frame. All the newspapers did little in
providing the audience with educative information, and in advocating policy changes.
The highly circulated newspaper, Addis Admas utilized the frame only in 8 percent of the
analyzed articles. Similarly, the health newspaper, Medical used this frame in 7 percent
of the analyzed articles. The newspaper which could have published more articles on how
to get medical care and how to cope up once the violence occurred seemed to contribute
little in educating the public. The educative frame was hardly found in the analyzed
articles from Police na Ermijaw (4 percent).

4.6.5.5 Conflict and economic frames

These frames were the least frequently used in the newspapers. While 6 percent of the
analyzed articles employed a conflict frame, only 2 percent of the analyzed articles on
gender violence used the economic frame. Contrary to Semetko and Valkenburg (2000)
findings where conflict frame was the most common frame in U.S. news, the results of
this study show a very limited usage of this frame in the analyzed articles.

Economic is the very least employed frame in the newspapers. It was totally avoided by
the government owned newspaper, Police na Ermijaw. Although gender violence can
cause serious economic loss (See chapter two), the newspapers seemed to ignore showing
such consequences.

4.6.6 Media Functions

In framing an issue or an event, the media play four important roles: defining the
problem, stating the cause, providing moral evaluation, and suggesting solutions.
Andesager and Powers (1999:533) argue that the media can “reinforce conventional
definitions of health problems, and hence the legitimacy of various solutions.”
Concerning roles played by the newspapers, the findings show diversity among the four
functions. All newspapers performed a great deal in defining the problem. 47 percent of
the articles’ main role was to define the problem. Although defining the problem
accounted for the higher percentage of the four functions in the three newspapers, it was
much greater in Police na Ermijaw, 62 percent of the analyzed articles in this newspaper.

The other function, stating the cause of the problem, was carried out by the newspapers to
some extent, in 26 percent of the analyzed articles. It was the second most frequently
performed function by the newspapers. The result suggested that the newspapers tended
to ignore providing the readers with causes of the violence in all articles. Lack of a stated
cause in some articles might impact how the audience perceived the problem as it could
make the story incomplete.

In terms of providing moral evaluation and suggesting treatments, the newspapers played
a limited role. The newspapers provided moral evaluation on the violence in 16 percent
of their articles covering gender violence. Like wise, 11 percent of the articles suggested
a solution to the problem. This implied that the newspapers mostly focused on presenting
facts as they were instead of interpreting them. However, by stressing these functions, the
newspapers could have influenced both the public perception and policy making
processes regarding gender violence.
 Chapter Five
5. Summary, conclusions and recommendations
This chapter presents a brief summary of the research process and conclusion of findings.
In addition, recommendations for future studies are also forwarded. These
recommendations are believed to expand our understanding of how the Ethiopian media
frame gender violence.

5.1 Summary and conclusion

Gender violence is a day to day tragedy in every part of the world. What makes the
problem even more heart breaking is the prevalence of a great number of children among
the affected. The violence can have multiple devastating effects on the health, social, and
economic lives of the victims. One way of fighting against gender violence is through the
media. This study was conducted in a belief that the extent of coverage given to the issue
along with its framing has implications on public perception and social policy. Hence, the
research attempted to examine how the Ethiopian print media framed gender violence
during the period of September 2006_September 2007.

In conducting the study, three Amharic newspapers were selected purposively. Addis
Admas, Police na Ermijaw, and Medical deal with the social, crime, and health aspects of
gender violence respectively. Thirteen months editions were taken for analysis.

The study made framing theory its central conceptual frame work. In order to gauge local
media framing of gender violence, both quantitative and qualitative methods were
employed. Content analysis was used to collect data on the number of articles, themes of
stories, types of gender violence mentioned in the articles, sources used in the stories, and
frames employed by the newspapers. In addition, in-depth interview was conducted with
journalists and editors of the newspapers to support the information gathered through
content analysis. The conclusions of the findings are presented below.

The findings of the study indicated that both the private owned, Addis Admas and the
government owned, Police na Ermijaw gave significantly more coverage to gender
violence compared to Medical. Most of the articles were informative rather than
educative. They focused on reporting committed violence and court trials held regarding
gender violence. On the other hand, little was done in educating the public on the health
consequences and treatments of the violence.

Rape was found to be the most commonly reported type of violence in the media. Beating
was also another form of gender violence which received a relatively high extent of
coverage from the newspapers. It was assumed that the frequency of types of violence
mentioned in the media might be correlated with the epidemiological reports. The more
the violence was reported to the police the more frequently it was to appear in the
newspapers.

Concerning sources used in the articles, the private owned newspapers, Addis Admas and
Medical, quoted victims’ families and friends in most of their stories. In the case of the
government owned paper, Police na Ermijaw, however, the most frequently used sources
were police officers. Those affected by the violence were identified and quoted in some
of the articles. The interviewed journalists and editors reasoned that the complex
psychological condition of the victims had made it difficult to talk to them. Moreover,
shortage of quoted experts (doctors, social workers, psychologists, and the like) regarding
the problem was observed in all the newspapers.

Several frames were found in the analyzed articles. The most dominant frames employed
by the newspapers were human interest and empathy. The private newspapers used
human faces, examples, and testimonies in the majority of their articles. Although Police
na Ermijaw utilized human interest frame quite frequently, the empathy frame appeared
to be the most dominant one in the articles of this newspapers.

In terms of providing information on causes and effects of gender violence, the

newspapers performed only to a limited extent. The diagnostic frame was used in all
three newspapers but to a limited degree. Likewise, although exceeding the frequency of
the diagnostic frame, the prognostic frame was also quite rarely employed in the articles.
Similarly, the newspapers attributed responsibility to others in alleviating the problem in
some of their stories. Government and society were relatively often mentioned to tackle
gender violence. The findings were similar in terms of the newspapers’ use of the
solution frame. Only some of the articles suggested treatments for the problem. Similar to
the findings in the attribution of responsibility frame, government actions and societal
responsibility were proposed as solutions for gender violence.

The newspapers rarely framed the stories using economic and conflict frames. Only 2
percent of the analyzed articles stated economic consequences of the violence both on the
victims and the country. Similarly, the newspapers showed disagreement of individuals
and groups in very few of their stories, 6 percent.

Moreover, the findings of the study show that the sex of the editor/journalist in the
analyzed media has its own implication on the coverage of stories on gender violence. It
was found out those female editors/journalists in the sample newspapers deliberately
preferred to work on stories of gender violence because of their gender.

By framing an issue or event, media define the problem, state causes, provide moral
evaluation, and suggest solution. The results of the study revealed that the analyzed
articles played profound roles in defining the problem. In the case of stating and
interpreting causes of gender violence, the newspapers’ function was some what limited.
Furthermore, the analyzed media contributed little in providing moral evaluation, and
suggesting potential solutions to the problem.

According to the interviewed journalists and editors, time and resource constraints
affected their coverage and framing of gender violence.

5.2 Recommendations for further research

The findings of the study showed how the national Ethiopian media framed gender
violence over a period of 1 year. However, the study was limited in terms of examining
the issue from different perspectives. Therefore, there is still a need to conduct further
research within the area. For example, further research should include reception analysis
to examine the effects of the newspaper coverage presented here on public attributions of
responsibility, both for the prevalence of gender violence and for finding a solution, as
well as on attitudes towards victims.

Furthermore, as this study only looked at how the issue was framed in textual forms,
further studies could examine how gender violence was framed in pictures as well.
Moreover, as the study merely focused on factual articles (news, features and interviews),
other researchers could expand the study to look at letters, editorials, and short stories.
Finally, other possibilities include the examination of how the broadcast media
(television and radio) portray the issue.
 Bibliography

Andsager, J., and Powers, A. (1999). ‘Social or Economic concerns: How News and
Women’s Magazines Framed Breast Cancer in the 1990s’. Journalism & Mass
communication Quarterly, 76(3)

Berger, A. (1998). Media Research Techniques. SAGE publications, London.

Byerly, C., and Ross, K. (2006). Women & Media. Blackwell Publishing, U.S.A

Carlyle, K., et al (2008). ‘Newspaper Coverage of Intimate Partner Violence: Skewing

Representations of Risk.’ Journal of communication, 58(1): 168-186. Available at
<http//www. blackwell-synergy. Com/doi/pdf> [Accessed on February 15, 2008]

Carter, C. (1998). News, Gender and Power. In Carter, C., Branston, G., and Allan, S.,
(eds). New York, Routledge

Cherinet, H., and Mulugeta, E. (2002). ‘Country Gender Profile Ethiopia.’ Swedish
International Development Cooperation Agency (Sida) Available at
http://www.hivaidsclearinghouse.unesco.org [Accessed on January 26, 2008]

Chong, D., and Druckman, J. (2007). ‘A Theory of Framing and Opinion Formation in
Competitive Elite Environments.’ Journal of communication, 57(1): 99-118. Available at
<http//www. blackwell-synergy. Com/doi/pdf> [Accessed on February 4, 2008]

D’Angelo, P. (2002). ‘News framing as a multiparadigmatic research program: a

response to Entman.’ Journal of communication, 52(4):870-888 Available at <http//www.
blackwell-synergy. Com/doi/pdf> [Accessed on February 2, 2008]

Entaman, R.(1993). Framing: Toward clarification of a fractured paradigm. Journal of

communication, 43(4), 51-58

Entman, R. (2007). ‘Framing bias: Media in the distribution of power.’ Journal of

communication, 57(1) Available at <http//www. blackwell-synergy. Com/doi/pdf>
[Accessed on February 6, 2008]

Garber, D. (1993) Mass media and American politics. Washington, DC: CQ Press

Gill, R. (2007). Gender and the Media. Cambridge, Polity Press

Goffman, E. (1974) Frame Analysis: An Essay on the organization of Experience. Harper

& Row, New York

Heise, L.,et al (1999). ‘Ending Violence Against Women.’ Population Reports, 27(4)
Available at < http://www.genderhealth.org> [Accessed on January 10, 2008.]
Husselbee, L., and Elliot, L (2002). ‘Looking beyond hate: How National and Regional
Newspapers Framed Hate Crimes in Jasper, Texas, and Laramie Wyoming.’ Journalism
& Mass Communication Quarterly, 74(4)

Iyengar, S. (1987). Television news and citizens’ explanations of national affairs.

American Political Science Review, 81, 815-831

Kinder, D. R., & Sanders, L.M. (1990). Mimicking political debate with survey
questions: The case of white opinion

Lacy, S., and Coulson, D. (2000). ‘Comparative case study: Newspaper Source use on the
Environmental beat.’ Newspaper Research Journal, 21(1)

Marshall, L. (2004).Media Culpability in the Continuum of Violence against Women:

Available at http://www.countercurrents.org/gender-marshall300904.htm: [Accessed on
October14, 2007]

Maxwell, K. A., Huxford, J., Borum, C., & Hornik, R. (2000). Covering domestic
violence: How the O.J. Simpson case shaped reporting of domestic violence in the news
media. Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly, 77, 258-272.

Mc Manus, J., and Dorfman, L. (2002). ‘Youth Violence Stories focus on Events, Not
Causes.’ Newspaper Research Journal, 23(4).

Mekasha, M. (2005).The Ethiopian media landscape. Unpublished, Addis Ababa,

Ethiopian Mass Media Training Institutes.

Ministry of Information (2008). Monthly Statistical Data About Press Products Which
Circulate Beyond The Confinement of One Region: From 10th March 2008 to 8th April,
2008. Available at <http://www.moinfo.gov.et/circulation.php> [Accessed on March 18,
2008]

Neuman, W. R., Just, M. R., and Crigler, A.N. (1992) common knowledge. Chicago:
University of Chicago Press

Paterson, B. (2006). ‘Newspaper representations of mental illness and the impact of the
reporting of ‘events’ on social policy: the ‘framing’ of Isabel Schwarz and Jonathan
Zito.’ Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing, 13(3), 294-300. Available at
<http//www. blackwell-synergy. Com/doi/pdf> [Accessed on February 8, 2008]

Powers, A., and Andesager, J. (1999). “How Newspapers Framed Breast Implants in the
1990s’. Journalism & Communication Quarterly, 76 (3)

Price, V., Tewksbury, D. & Powers, E (1997). Switching trains of thought: The impact of
news frames on readers’ cognitive responses. Communication research, 24, 481-506.
Scheufele, A.D. (1999). ‘Framing as a theory of media effect.’ Journal of communication,
49(1): 103-122. Available at <http//www. blackwell-synergy. Com/doi/pdf> [Accessed
on February 4, 2008]
Semetko, H., and Valkenburg, P. (2000). ‘Framing European Politics: A content analysis
of press and television news.’ Journal of communication, 50(2): 93-109 Available at
<http//www. blackwell-synergy. Com/doi/pdf> [Accessed on February 2, 2008]

Shah,D., et al (2004). ‘The Interplay of News Frames on Cognitive Complexity’ Journal

of Communication, 30(1): 102-120 Available at <http//www. blackwell-synergy.
Com/doi/pdf> [Accessed on February 4, 2008]

Shen, F. (2004). ‘Chronic Accessibility and Individual Cognitions: Examining the effects
of Message Frames in political Advertisements.’ Journal of Communication, 30(1): 123-
137. Available at <http//www. blackwell-synergy. Com/doi/pdf> [Accessed on January
28, 2008]

Stalans, L. J., & Lurigio, A. J. (1995). Public preference for the court’s handling of
domestic violence situations. Crime and Delinquency, 41, 399-413

Steeves,H. (1997). Gender violence and The Press: The St. Kizito story. Ohio University,
Ohio

Sotirovic, M. (2003). How individuals explain social problems: The influences of media
use. Journal of Communication, 53, 122-137.

United Nation Fund for Population (2007).Ending Widespread Violence Against Women.
Available at < http://www.unfpa.org/gender/violence.htm> [Accessed on October 12,
2007]

Weaver, H.D. (2007). ‘Thoughts on agenda setting, framing, and priming. Journal of
communication, 57 (1): 142-147.’ Available at <http//www. blackwell-synergy.
Com/doi/pdf> [Accessed on February 4, 2008]

World Health Organization (2007). Violence against Women: Available at

<http://www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs239/en/index.html.> [Accessed on October
12, 2007]

World of Health Organization (2008). Multi- country study on Women’s Health and
Domestic Violence against Women. Available at
http://www.who.int/gender/violence/who_multicountry_study/summary_report/en/index.
html [Accessed on March 28, 2008]

Zhou, Y., and Moy, P. (2007). ‘Parsing Framing Processors: The Interplay Between
Online Public Opinion and Media Coverage.’ Journal of communication, 57(1) 79-98.
Available at <http//www. blackwell-synergy. Com/doi/pdf> [Accessed on February 2,
2008]
 Appendix A
Coding Sheet

Name of coder ___________________________

Name of newspaper ______________________________
Date of publication ________________________
Headline of the article ____________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________

1. Article description
1.1 Article type
- News ________
- Feature _______
- Interview______
1.2 Location
- Front page ________
- Inside page________
- Last page_________

2. Theme of the article

2.1 Themes

- Violence_____________
- Court trials _____________
- Neglect _____________
- Discussions/Demonstrations ___________
- Health consequences/ treatments _____________
- If other please specify ___________________________________________

2.2 Types of gender violence mentioned mostly

- Rape________
- Beating _________
- FGM( Female Genital Mutilation)___________
- Abduction__________
- Early Marriage___________
- Verbal Assault___________
- If other please specify _________________________________________
3. Sources
- Government officials ________
- Non-government officials ________
- Victims ________
- Perpetrators _________
- Police officers________
- Victim’s families and friends _______
- Experts ( social workers, psychologists, doctors, etc) _______
- Women’s associations ________
- Community members ________
- Donors______
- Researches and researchers _____
- International organizations ______
- No specified source _____
- If other please specify _________________________________________

4. Frames
4.1 Diagnostic frames
-Does the story provide social norms/beliefs as causes of the violence? Yes/ No
-Does the article provide alcohol as the cause of the violence? Yes/ No
-Does the story state harmful traditional practices as causes of the problem? Yes/ No
-Does the story state government actions, policy, judicial system or inefficiency as
causes of the violence? Yes/ No
-If other please specify __________________________________________________

4.2 Prognostic Frames

-Does the story mention mortality among the victims? Yes/ No
-Does the story state the violence was committed by intimate partners? Yes/ No
-Does the story state the violence was committed by non-intimate partners? Yes/ No
-Does the story mention school dropout/ loss of job due to the violence? Yes/ No
-Does the article state effects of the violence like, suicides or other self-destructive
actions? Yes/ No
If other please specify _________________________________________________

4.3 Attribution of responsibility frame

- Does the article suggest that cultural attitudes have the ability to alleviate the
problem? Yes/ No
-Does the story suggest that the victims themselves have the ability to alleviate the
problem? Yes/ No
-Does the story suggest that some level of government has the ability to alleviate the
violence? Yes/ No
-Does the story suggest that NGOs have the ability to alleviate the problem? Yes/ No
-Does the story suggest that the international communities have the ability to alleviate
the problem? Yes/ No
-Does the story suggest that good medical care has the ability to alleviate the
problem?
Yes/ No
-Does the story suggest that the general community has the ability to alleviate the
violence? Yes/ No
-If other please specify __________________________________________________

4.4 Solution frames

-Does the story suggest government or other agents intervention as solutions for
gender violence? Yes/ No
-Does the story suggest attitudinal change towards gender violence as a solution for
the problem? Yes/ No
-Does the story suggest serious punishment of the perpetrators as solution? Yes/ No
-Does the story states gender violence as unsolvable or out of human control?
Yes/ No
-If other please specify__________________________________________________

4.5 Empathy frame

-Does the article refer those who encountered gender violence as victims? Yes/ No
-Does the article mention children and elders among those who encountered gender
violence? Yes/ No
-Does the story use adjectives or personal vignettes that generate feelings of outrages,
empathy, caring, sympathy or compassion? Yes/ No

4.6 Morality frame

-Does the article condemns/asks the audience to condemn the violence? Yes/No
-Does the story make reference to morality, God, and other religious tents? Yes/ No
-Does the article offer social prescriptions about how to behave towards the problem?
Yes/ No
-Does the article present the violence as a violation of human rights? Yes/ No
-If other please specify __________________________________________________

4.7 Human interest frame

-Does the story provide a human example or ‘human face’ on the issue? Yes/ No
-Does the story go in to the private or personal lives of the characters? Yes/ No
-Does the story emphasize how individuals and groups are affected by the violence,
socially, culturally, politically and economically? Yes/ No
-Does the story provide testimonies of people who encountered gender violence?
Yes/ No
-If other please specify __________________________________________________

4.8 Economic frame

-Does the story mention financial implications of those who encountered gender
violence? Yes/ No
-Does the article indicate economic consequences of gender violence on the country?
Yes/ No
-If other please specify __________________________________________________

4.9 Conflict Frame

-Does the story reflect disagreement between individuals or groups? Yes/ No

-Does the story refer to two sides or more than two sides? Yes/ No
-Does an individual or group reproach another? Yes/ No
-If other please specify __________________________________________________

4.10 Educative/advocacy frames

-Does the story give information on how to get medical care? Yes/ No
-Does the article explain how to cope up with situations after the violence? Yes/ No
-Does the article suggest policy changes in the country regarding gender violence?
Yes/ No
-Does the story state the need for societal change in attitude? Yes/ No
-If other please specify _________________________________________________

5. Media Functions
5.1- Is the issue of gender violence in the media? Yes/ No
-Does the story include all sides of the story (more than two sources)? Yes/ No
-Does the article present the issue socially or medically? Yes/ No
-Does the article present the issue as a crime? Yes/ No

5.2- Do other groups contribute to the story to appear in the media like, sponsors,
NGOs, women associations, health institutions, etc.? Yes/ No

5.3-Does the article define the problem? Yes/ No

-Does the article state causes and interpret the issue? Yes/ No
-Does the article provide moral evaluation of the problem? Yes/ No
-Does the article suggest treatments? Yes/ No
-Does the article provide logical reasoning of why the problem happened? Yes/ No
-If other please specify________________________________________________
 Appendix B
Lists of key Informants
Informant Position Newspaper
1. Solomon G/Egzabheir (Male) Deputy editor-in-chief Addis Admas
2. Yemewodesh Bekele (Female) Editor-in chef Police na Ermijaw
3. Dr. Abush Ayalew (Male) Editor-in-chief Medical
4. Abebayehu Gebeyaw (Female) Journalist Addis Admas
 Appendix C

Coding Guide

1. Article description (Inter-coder reliability 100%)

1.1 Article Type - shows the nature of the article (news, feature or interview).
1.2 Location - indicates where the article is placed (front page, inside page or last page).

2.1 Theme (Inter –coder reliability 92%)

-Theme refers to the main idea of the story.

-Violence _an article which simply reports the occurrence of gender violence
- Court trials - refers to a story on the legal process of violence against women (court
appearances, arguments or verdicts)
- Neglect - refers to ignoring or giving less attention and care to the issue (gender
violence) and people affected by it.
- Discussions/Demonstrations – meetings, seminars and demonstrations on the issue of
gender violence.
- Health consequences/ treatments – refers to providing information on the effect of
gender violence on women’s health and medical treatments.

2.2 Types of gender violence mentioned mostly

-Rape- refers to having a forced sex.
-Beating – causing a physical damage on a woman by hitting/beating
-FGM (Female Genital Mutilation) - an act of mutilating a female’s genital.
-Abduction- forcing a girl to agree to marry by taking her away from her home and her
families.
-Early Marriage- marriage before the age of 18.
-Verbal Assault – insulting or degrading a woman because of her sex.

3. Sources – refers to as name(s) of a person, group or organization that are quoted

directly or indirectly in the story as victims, officials, NGOs, etc.

4. Types of Framing
-Conflict frame – when the story provides two or more opposing views or statements.
- Human interest frame- when the story involves people and their testimonies about
gender violence.
-Attribution of responsibility frame – when the story suggests individuals or an
organization should take actions on the issue.
-Diagnostic frame – when the story lists ranges of causes of gender violence
-Prognostic frame – when the story provides the effects of gender violence on the
individual ass well as the country.
-Solution frame – when the story states solutions for the problem.
-Morality frame - when the story tells the readers to do or not to do something; or when
the story involves religious or human right perspectives.
-Empathy frame – when the story describes people who experienced gender violence with
expressions that create sympathy, for example words like ‘ruined ’, ‘unfortunate’ and the
like.
-Educative/advocacy frame – when the story relates the issue of gender violence with
policy changes or human rights.
-Economic frame – when the story mentions the impact of gender violence on an
individuals as well as the country’s economy.
 Appendix D
Interview Guide

Interview with editors and journalists

1. Background
- What is your attitude towards gender violence in general?
- How do you report about the issue, do you get too emotional or what?
- Do you think your reports had any influence on the readers?
- How did you get responses of the audience?
- Do you think your sex affect you r way of reporting gender violence?

2. Themes
- What were the central ideas or issues in your stories?
-Why were such themes important?
-Do you prefer to report the violence as it is or to add some of your opinions?

4. Types of gender violence

- Which form of gender violence is the most common type in your report?
- Is there a specific type of gender violence which gets you emotional?
- If yes, what is your reason?

5. Sources
- Who were the dominant sources in your reports about gender violence?
- Were victims used as sources in your stories?
- Did you face any pressure from interest groups to write the story in certain
ways?

6. Frames
- How do you construct your reports on gender violence? Why?
-Did you purposefully shape or organize the stories in certain ways?
- Were you aware of how your stories were framed?
- What were your principles in reporting the stories?
-Do you think your principles had any impact on your reporting?
-What factors affect how you frame the stories, like sources, cultural attitudes?

Diagnostic frame
- What do you think are the causes of gender violence?
- Why do most of the stories lack interpretation of causes?

Prognostic frame
- What do you think are the effects of gender violence?
- On which effect, long- term or short term, do you focus more?

Attribution of responsibility
- Who do you think is responsible for solving or addressing the problem?
- Why did most articles fail to attribute responsibility to anyone?
 Solution frame

- What do you think are the solutions for gender violence?

Empathy frame
- How do you think of victims of gender violence?
- What kind of expressions do you use for the victims?
- What are the justifications for using such expressions?

Morality frame
- Do you ask the audience to condemn the problem?
- Do you refer to God or any religious tent when you write the stories?
- Do you consider cultural or social values when you write the stories?

Human interest frame

- Do you think using human face in the stories is important? Why?

Economic frame
- What do you think are the economic or financial implications of the issue?
- Why do most articles fail to show this impact?

Conflict frame
- How do you entertain conflicted ideas and opinions from different
individuals/groups?

Educative frame
- Do you think it is important to give information on how to deal with gender
violence?
- Do you think you need to educate the audience about human right issues?
- Do you suggest societal change in your stories?
-
Media functions
- What roles do you think your media played in reporting gender violence?
 Appendix E

Frames used in each newspaper

Diagnostic frames

Norms/beliefs
Type of newspaper Total
Yes No
Addis Admass 11 20 31
Police na Ermijaw 6 19 25
Medical 2 9 11

Total 19 48 67

Alcohol
Type of newspaper Total
Yes No
Addis Admass 1 30 31
Police na Ermijaw 2 23 25
Medical 0 11 11

Total 3 64 67

Harmful traditional practices

Type of newspaper Total
Yes No
Addis Admass 8 23 31
Police na Ermijaw 5 20 25
Medical 4 7 11

Total 17 50 67

Government actions, policy,

Type of newspaper judicial system of inefficiency Total
Yes No
Addis Admass 9 22 31
Police na Ermijaw 2 23 25
Medical 2 9 11

Total 13 54 67

Prognostic frame

Mortality
Type of newspaper Total
Yes No
Addis Admass 8 23 31
Police na Ermijaw 11 14 25
Medical 2 9 11

Total 21 46 67

Intimate partners
Type of newspaper Total
Yes No
Addis Admass 11 20 31
Police na Ermijaw 9 16 25
Medical 2 9 11

Total 22 45 67

Non-intimate partners
Type of newspaper Total
Yes No
Addis Admass 13 18 31
Police na Ermijaw 12 13 25
Medical 4 7 11

Total 29 38 67

School dropout/loss of job

Type of newspaper Total
Yes No
Addis Admass 2 29 31
Police na Ermijaw 1 24 25
Medical 0 11 11

Total 3 64 67

Suicides/self-destructive actions
Type of newspaper Total
Yes No
Addis Admass 2 29 31
Police na Ermijaw 4 21 25
Medical 0 11 11

Total 6 61 67

Attribution of responsibility

Cultural attitudes
Type of newspaper Total
Yes No
Addis Admass 5 26 31
Police na Ermijaw 4 21 25
Medical 0 11 11

Total 9 58 67

Victims
Type of newspaper Total
Yes No
Addis Admass 1 30 31
Police na Ermijaw 1 24 25
Medical 0 11 11

Total 2 65 67

Government
Type of newspaper Total
Yes No
Addis Admass 14 17 31
Police na Ermijaw 3 22 25
Medical 3 8 11

Total 20 47 67

NGOs
Type of newspaper Total
Yes No
Addis Admass 5 26 31
Police na Ermijaw 2 23 25
Medical 0 11 11

Total 7 60 67

International communities
Type of newspaper Total
Yes No
Addis Admass 2 29 31
Police na Ermijaw 0 25 25
Medical 0 11 11

Total 2 65 67

Good medical care

Type of newspaper Total
Yes No
Addis Admass 4 27 31
Police na Ermijaw 0 25 25
Medical 0 11 11

Total 4 63 67

General community
Type of newspaper Total
Yes No
Addis Admass 10 21 31
Police na Ermijaw 6 19 25
Medical 0 11 11

Total 16 51 67

Solution frame

Government or other agents

Type of newspaper Total
Yes No
Addis Admass 12 19 31
Police na Ermijaw 4 21 25
Medical 3 8 11

Total 19 48 67

Educating men
Type of newspaper Total
Yes No
Addis Admass 3 28 31
Police na Ermijaw 2 23 25
Medical 0 11 11

Total 5 62 67

Societal responsibility
Type of newspaper Total
Yes No
Addis Admass 14 17 31
Police na Ermijaw 4 21 25
Medical 2 9 11

Total 20 47 67

Serious punishment
Type of newspaper Total
Yes No
Addis Admass 9 22 31
Police na Ermijaw 4 21 25
Medical 6 5 11

Total 19 48 67

Unsolvable
Type of newspaper Total
Yes No
Addis Admass 1 30 31
Police na Ermijaw 0 25 25
Medical 0 11 11

Total 1 66 67

Empathy frame
As victims
Type of newspaper Total
Yes No
Addis Admass 15 16 31
Police na Ermijaw 18 7 25
Medical 1 10 11

Total 34 33 67

Children and elders

Type of newspaper Total
Yes No
Addis Admass 17 14 31
Police na Ermijaw 12 13 25
Medical 7 4 11

Total 36 31 67

Empathetic words
Type of newspaper Total
Yes No
Addis Admass 19 12 31
Pmlice na Ermijaw 13 12 25
Medical 9 2 11

Total 41 26 67

Morality frame
Condemn the issue
Type of newspaper Tot`l
Yes Ng
Addis Admass 16 15 31
Police na Epmijaw 3 22 25
Medical 7 4 11

Total 26 41 67

Morality/God/religion
Type of newspaper Total
 Yes No
Addis Admass 2 29 31
Police na Ermijaw 3 22 25
Medical 1 10 11

Total 6 61 67

Social prescriptions
Type of newspaper Total
Yes No
Addis Admass 10 21 31
Police na Ermijaw 4 21 25
Medical 2 9 11

Total 16 51 67

Violation of Human right

Type of newspaper Total
Yes No
Addis Admass 12 19 31
Police na Ermijaw 1 24 25
Medical 1 10 11

Total 14 53 67

Human interest frame

Human face
Type of newspaper Total
Yes No
Addis Admass 24 7 31
Police na Ermijaw 19 6 25
Medical 10 1 11

Total 53 14 67

Private lives of characters

Type of newspaper Total
Yes No
Addis Admass 19 12 31
Police na Ermijaw 13 12 25
Medical 9 2 11

Total 41 26 67

Effect of the problem on

Type of newspaper individuals/groups Total
Yes No
Addis Admass 18 13 31
Police na Ermijaw 5 20 25
Medical 8 3 11

67
Total 31 46

Testimonies of victims
Type of newspaper Total
Yes No
Addis Admass 12 19 31
Police na Ermijaw 2 23 25
Medical 4 7 11

Total 18 49 67

Economic frame
Financial implications on
Type of newspaper individuals Total
Yes No
Addis Admass 6 25 31
Police na Ermijaw 0 25 25
Medical 1 10 11

Total 7 60 67

On the country
Type of newspaper Total
Yes No
Addis Admass 4 27 31
Police na Ermijaw 0 25 25
Medical 0 11 11

Total 4 63 67

Conflict frame

Individual/ group disagreement

Type of newspaper Total
Yes No
Addis Admass 7 24 31
Police na Ermijaw 2 23 25
Medical 7 4 11

Total 16 51 67

Two sides or more than two

Type of newspaper sides Total
 Yes No
Addis Admass 8 23 31
Police na Ermijaw 2 23 25
Medical 7 4 11

Total 17 50 67

Reproaching
Type of newspaper Total
Yes No
Addis Admass 4 27 31
Police na Ermijaw 1 24 25
Medical 4 7 11

Total 9 58 67

Educative/advocacy frame

How to get medical care

Type of newspaper Total
Yes No
Addis Admass 3 28 31
Police na Ermijaw 0 25 25
Medical 1 10 11

Total 4 63 67

How to cope up
Type of newspaper Total
Yes No
Addis Admass 2 29 31
Police na Ermijaw 0 25 25
Medical 1 10 11

Total 3 64 67

Policy change s
Type of newspaper Total
Yes No
Addis Admass 9 22 31
Police na Ermijaw 3 22 25
Medical 3 8 11

Total 15 52 67

Societal change in attitude

Type of newspaper Total
Yes No
Addis Admass 14 17 31
Police na Ermijaw 5 20 25
Medical 3 8 11

Total 22 45 67

Appendix F

Monthly Statistical Data about Press Products Which Circulate Beyond the
Confinement of One Region: From 10th March 2008 to 8th April, 2008

6. List of the Press

6.1 News Papers
Name of the Average
No Language Schedule Content
Press Circulation
Political, Economic &
1 Addis Zemen Amharic Daily Social Issues (Current 18443
Affairs)
 The Ethiopian
2 English ' ' '' '' 9930
Herald
3 Barrissa Oromifa Weekly ' '' '' 2000
4 Al-alem Arabic ' ' '' '' 1000
Abiotawy
5 Democracy Amharic Fortnightly ' '' '' 63230
(APDM)
Abiotawy
6 Democracy ' ' ' '' '' 10670
(SPDM)
7 Woyien Tigrigna ' ' '' '' 19934
8 Oromiya Oromifa '' ' '' '' 77709
9 Reporter Amharic Biweekly ' '' '' 11000
10 Addis Admas ' Weekly ' '' '' 31000
11 Sendek ' ' ' '' '' 3500
12 Embilta ' ' ' '' '' 2800
13 Addis Nagar ' ' ' '' '' 20000
14 Ethio Channal ' ' ' '' '' 7000
15 Soresa ' Fortnightly ' '' '' 2000
16 Haramba ' Weekly ' '' '' 8000
17 Goggle ' ' ' '' '' 4000
18 Awraamba ' ' ' '' '' 9000
19 Hedasse ' ' ' '' '' 30000
20 Awda Media ' ' ' '' '' 1000
21 The Reporter English ' ' '' '' 2700
22 Seven Days Update ' ' ' '' '' 300
The Sub-Saharn
23 ' ' ' '' '' 1500
Informer
24 Metro Politan ' ' ' '' '' 700
25 Press Digest ' ' ' '' '' 282
26 Guardian ' Fortnightly ' '' '' 2000
27 The Daily Monitor ' Daily ' '' '' 1880
28 Capital ' Weekly Economic & Business 5000
29 Fortune ' ' ' 7000
30 Wastena Amharic Monthly Social Issues 9000
31 Lambadina English ' ' '' 5000
32 Lambadina Amharic ' ' '' 25000
33 Abugida ' ' Youth 3600
34 Mendake ' Weekly Construction 1000
35 Medical ' ' Medical 14200
36 Laqa ' ' ' '' 1000
37 Kalkidan Amharic Biweekly Love &Sex 3600
38 Negadras ' ' Trade &Advertisement 5000
ABBI Weekly
39 Amh/Eng ' ' '' 3000
Ethiopia
40 Negd Ena Lemat Amharic ' ' '' 3200
41 What is up Addis English ' ' '' 16000

No Name of the Press Language Schedule Content Average

 Circulation
42 Mesenazerya Amharic Weekly Trade &Advertisement 3600
43 Thasma Amharic Biweekly Miracle story 3100
44 World Sport Amharic Weekly Sport 18500
45 Sport Alemakef ' ' ' '' 4000
46 Red Devil ' ' ' '' 3000
47 Lege Sport ' ' ' '' 4500
48 Ethio Sport ' ' ' '' 22500
49 Inter Sport ' ' ' '' 15500
50 Hatic ' ' ' '' 5000
51 Zegernerse ' ' ' '' 11000
52 Mamch Ena Arse ' ' ' '' 5000
53 Lesane Georgis ' Fortnightly ' '' 3000
54 Sematsidek ' ' Religion 10000
Zena Mahdere
55 ' Monthly ' '' 3000
Sebhat
56 Amanuale ' ' ' '' 2500
57 Fikrna Salam Amh/Eng ' ' '' 3000
58 Misirach ' ' ' '' 5000
59 Jumea ' Weekly ' '' 1000
60 Alkduse ' ' ' '' 5000
61 Fiziker ' Monthly ' '' 1000
62 Selefia ' ' ' '' 3000
Children Recreation &
63 Raselase ' ' 1000
Education
64 Police na Ermjaw ' Fortnightly Crime
576378

Source: Ethiopian Ministry of Information, 2008