Performa 09 Conference on Performance Studies

University of Aveiro, May 2009

Portuguese piano music:

Notable moments from the 18th century until today
Nancy Lee Harper, University of Aveiro
[email protected]

Objectives:
The objective of this paper is to present important milestones in Portuguese
piano works from the 18th century until our times, taking into account Portugals
political, social, and cultural history, while focusing on solo piano, four-hand and twopiano works, instrumental chamber music without voice, piano concerti, and didactic
piano works. What follows is a brief look at a topic that is currently undergoing more
exhaustive research.

Context:
Introduction
Portugal has been associated with piano music since the creation of the
pianoforte. The first piano sonatas in music history Sonate da Cimbalo di piano, e
forte detto volgarmente di martelletti were composed by Lodovico Giustini di Pistoia
(1685-1743) in 1732 and dedicated to Dom Antnio of Bragana, the younger brother
of King Joo V of Portugal. The Portuguese court was amongst the first places where
the early piano was frequently heard. Too, Portugal was instrumental in the creation of
early pianos1. Foreign instrument builders, who were supported by the Portuguese
King, were required to have Portuguese apprentices. Eventually, the entire Portuguese
piano-building industry died out. Nevertheless, piano works by native composers living
at home or abroad, or by foreign composers living in Portugal or its territories, gave rise
to a considerable pianistic legacy. This legacy is distinguished by such composers as
Jos Antnio Carlos Seixas (1704-1742), Domingos Bomtempo (1775-1842), Jos
Viana da Mota (1868-1948), Fernando Lopes-Graa (1906-1994), and others, as well
as a growing and impressive number of contemporary composers.
Several problems exist in the identification of Portuguese piano music: cultural
interchanges, political instabilities, social unrest, economic fluctuations, and other
factors. The devastating Lisbon earthquake of 1 November 1755 with its tsunamis and
fires destroyed a large number of valuable music manuscripts and books, which has
made a continuous identification impossible. As well, the removal of the Portuguese
court to Brazil, which was precipitated by the Napoleonic invasion in 1807 and
culminated with Brazils independence in 1822, accounts for some works falling into
obscurity. The lack of continuity by a state or foreign publisher has not facilitated quick
identification or access to a large amount of piano works. Many works have too
frequently fallen into an early demise, remaining extant only if fortunate. To date, a
1

An excellent original piano by Manuel Antunes (1767) is preserved today at the University of South Dakotas Shrine to Music
Museum in Vermillion.

large body of 18th-19th century manuscripts awaits publication. Finally, entire archives
of some composers are located in the hands of family members, who reluctantly permit
access to the works, if at all. Yet beyond these myriad problems lie many jewels of
Portuguese culture awaiting a re-discovery. Fortunately, the proportion of recorded
works to modern publications is relatively high and shows the interest that performers,
be they Portuguese or foreign, have in this music.
18th Century
By mid-17th-century the Portuguese Royal Music Library was considered to be
the best in the world. At the height of its glory, the 18th-century Portuguese court, under
predominantly Italian musical influence, saw many new developments in the existing
keyboard literature. Notable are the keyboard works of Carlos Seixas, the principal
organist in Coimbra since a young age and called to serve in the Lisbon court of John
V alongside of his Italian colleague, Domenico Scarlatti (1685-1757). Of Seixas more
than 700 keyboard sonatas/toccatas not 20% remain, disappearing during the Lisbon
earthquake.
Principal 18th century solo piano (harpsichord, clavichord, and fortepiano)
genres include single and multi-movement Baroque and Rococo Sonatas, Toccatas,
Variations, Dances (Contradances, Minuets, Marches, other dances) and descriptive
multi-movement suites that commemorated Battle victories, Royal matters, and other
events. Chamber and salon music abound, with parts often being doubled or
substituted on other instruments for which the works were originally written even in solo
keyboard work. The solo piano concerto in Portugal is scarce. Two concertos for
harpsichord (playable on fortepiano) are probably by Carlos Seixas, as well as a
Concerto (Quintet) by Jos Palomino (1755-1810). Four-hand or two-piano works are
almost non-existent, although there is a Sonata for two organs by Antnio Joaquim
Nunes, (fl. 1790-1826). Didactic works abound, as found in numerous figured bass
treatises and it could also be said that most of the solo works from the 18th century had
a didactic function.
19th Century
Portugals dominance begins to notably wane in the 19th century. Its musical
production becomes dispersed. In spite of the removal of the Portuguese court to Brazil
and the influence of Brazilian music on Portuguese composers, the importance of the
piano gradually developed. Around 1809, there were reported to be approximately 20
fortepianos in Lisbon, followed by a precipitous increase in 1821 to more than 500
(Brito, Cranmer: 50) about the return of the Portuguese court. Home tutoring became a
cottage industry. A young woman was considered to be cultured if she spoke
French and played the piano. However, by the end of the 19th century, a certain Dr.
Waetesold warned young woman not to take up the study of the piano (this disgraceful
instrument) before the age of fifteen or sixteen for fear of developing a nervous
disease.
In the 19th century Portuguese women composers began to emerge: Amlia
Augusta Azevedo (1846-1913), Josefina Amann (1848-1887), Julia R. C. Boulogne (fl.
18-), Julieta Pinho (ca. 1900), and Queen Maria Pia de Saboa (1847-1911). 19thcentury solo piano genres included the Classical and Romantic multi-movement
Sonatas, Variations, Dances (Gallops, Polkas, Quadrilles, Minuets, Waltzes and other
Salon Dances), Fantasies (including Opera fantasies), Character pieces, and
Arrangements (fado, folksongs, Modinhas,etc.). From the sheer quantity, although not
outstanding quality, the sonatas and variations of Bomtempo have made a significant
contribution to the 19th-century Portuguese repertoire. Liszts visit to Lisbon in 1845
caused a sensation. Lisztmania inspired new works from Portuguese composers. His
French Boisselot piano was acquired by the Portuguese state and now resides in the
Music Museum in Lisbon. Four-hand works began to appear, including those by
Marcos Portugal, Joaquim Casimiro Jnior, and a March by Queen Maria, with even

perhaps the first Portuguese work for 1 piano, 6 hands, by Jos Viana da Mota
(Fantasy on Meyerbeers Opera O Roberto Diabo, op. 42, 1881). The piano concerto
began to proliferate (Domingos Bomtempo, Artur and Alfredo Napoleo, Viana da
Mota). Didactic works were found in the form of treatises or Etudes (Bomtempos
Mtodo and Studies), or the solo works themselves, a unique one being Viana da
Motas youthful work Resignao, Melodie composed for the Left Hand, op. 39 (1880).
20th-21st Centuries
In the 20th century Portuguese piano music not only begins to flourish but to
gain international ground. The evolution of the piano is now stable, not having changed
much since the 1860s and making it perhaps the oldest unchanged invention today.
Questions of identity in Portuguese music begin to surge. According to Fernando
Lopes-Graa (1906-1994), "there was no Portuguese music because there was no
classical music tradition, no interest in popular music (almost unknown and neglected
by the authorities), no interest in the development of a national musical life as it was
understood in Germany, France, England..." (Monteiro: 6) Politically, Portugal arrived at
Democracy on 25 April 1975 after passing through various stages from Monarchy to
the right-wing New State. Musically, harmonic languages encompassed all that Europe
experienced, but usually later. Viana da Mota, after his return to Portugal in 1917,
assumed directorship of the National Conservatory and undertook a curriculum reform
that remains today intact for piano students.
In the 20th-century, solo piano works include: Character pieces (sometimes as
Miniatures or in collections); Preludes; large-scale Sonatas; Sonatinas; multimovement Suites; experimental works with improvisatory or aleatoric elements for
piano, prepared piano, harpsichord, and electronic music. This abundant and
interesting corpus ranges from the Impressionistic Miniatures of Francisco Lacerda
(1869-1934) and the Preludes of Lus Freitas Branco (1890-1955) the father of
Modernism in Portugal to the large-scale poly-tonal, sometimes primitivistic, works of
Fernando Lopes-Graa (6 sonatas, 2 sonatinas, multiple collections inspired from
folksongs and dances, Preludes, Nocturnes, Variations, etc.). The few promising works
of Antnio Fragoso (1897-1918) are complemented by the large number of character
suites by scar da Silva (1870-1958), a student of Clara Schumann and Carl
Reinecke, together with the uvre of Viana da Mota and Luz Costa (1879-1960)
preserve the Romantic spirit and the Portuguese heritage.
On this wave into the second half of the 20th century, solo piano works
embrace: the 2nd Renaissance of Portuguese composers (Emmanuel Nunes, b.
1941); Experiments in aleatoric music by Filipe Pires (b. 1934); Expressionism and
dodecaphony of Cndido Lima (b. 1939) and Victor Macedo Pinto (1917-1964); Neoclassicism by Filipe Pires and J. Croner Vasconcelos (1910-1974); Neo-Baroque forms
by Armando Jos Fernandes (1906-1983); varied styles by Antnio Victorino dAlmeida
(b. 1940), Srgio Azevedo (b. 1968); Prepared piano and theatrality by Jorge Peixinho
(1940-1995), and Constana Capdeville (1937-1992); Post-modernism in works by
Clotilde Rosa (b. 1930, particularly interesting is her Fortepiano Sonata); exploration of
Silence by Toms Henriques (b. 1963); Improvisatory-like works by Amlcar Vasques
Dias (b. 1945); Jazz-or fado infiltrations by Antnio Pinho Vargas (b. 1951) and Sara
Carvalho (b. 1970); Acusmatic music by Isabel Pires (b. 1970); Electronic music with
piano by Joo Pedro Oliveira (b. 1959), Eduardo Patriarca (b. 1970) and Cndido
Lima.
In the 20th and 21st centuries the category of 4 hand/2 piano music begins to
find a respectable offering from such composers as Fernando Lopes-Graa, Cludio
Carneyro (1895-1963), Fernando Corra Oliveira (1921-2004), Christopher Bochmann
(b. 1950), Joo Pedro Oliveira, Pedro Faria Gomes (b.1979), Srgio Azevedo, Sara
Claro (b. 1986), Bruno Ribeiro (b. 1982), Hugo Ribeiro (b. 1983), etc.
As well, the proliferation of instrumental chamber music takes on many forms.
Especially notable are the the violin/piano sonatas of scar da Silva (Sonata de

Saudades), Lus de Freitas Branco, Cludio Carneyro, Frederico de Freitas, and

Lopes-Graa; the trios and quartets of Armando Jos Fernandes, Carneyro, and
Lopes-Graa. Notable is Patriarcas exotic La nuit de temps (2006) with its Tibetan
bowls, Thailandese bells, and other percussion. Other important chamber music
contributions have been made by Antnio Victorino dAlmeida, Christopher Bochmann,
Srgio Azevedo, Eurico Carrapatoso (b. 1962), Sara Claro, Cndido Lima, Pedro Faria
Gomes, Toms Henriques, David Miguel (b. 1979), Ivan Moody (1964), Joo Pedro
Oliveira, Isabel Soveral (b. 1961), Eduardo Patriarca, Edward Ganalves Pinto (b.
1989), Joo Rafael (b. 1960), Pedro Rocha (b. 1961), Clotilde Rosa, and Evgueni
Zoudilkine (b.1965).
A wealth of piano concertos is found by: Ruy Coelho (1889-1986), Francine
Benoit (1894-1990), Luiz Costa, Lus de Freitas Branco, Cludio Carneyro, Ivo Cruz,
(1901-1985), lvaro Cassuto (b. 1938), Maria de Lourdes Martins (b. 1926), Joly Braga
Santos (1924-1988), Armando Jos Fernandes, Clotilde Rosa, Fernando Lopes-Graa,
Antnio Victorino dAlmeida, Antnio Chagas Rosa (b. 1960, A ascenso de caro /
Icaros Ascent, 1994-5), Rui Soares da Costa (b. 1958), Srgio Azevedo, Joo Victor
Costa (b. 1939), Joaquim dos Santos (1936-2008), Lus Tinoco (b. 1969), Eduardo
Patriarca, as well as foreigners in Portugal: Pedro Blanco (d. 1918, Concerto, op. 15),
Ernesto Halffter (1905-1989, Rapsdia portuguesa), Christopher Bochmann
(Monograph Expanded, 1997), Ivan Moody (Linnunlaulu, for piano and chamber
orchestra, 2003).
Most unusual Portuguese piano concerti are: the concertos for 2 pianos by
Victorino dAlmeida (Concerto de Pfaro e Fungg op.14 for 2 Pianos, 1956, rev.
1960); and Srgio Azevedo (2003), the Chamber Concertino (piano, oboe, viola, bass)
the Harpsichord concerto (1999) by the latter composer; Lopes-Graas Concertino for
Piano, Strings, Brass, and Percussion (1952/1954); the Clavichord Concerto by Jorge
Peixinho (MemoiresMiroirs, Concerto para Clavicrdio, 1980); the Flute and Piano
Concerto with String Orchestra by Fernando Lapa (b. 1950; 2002); the anti-piano
concerto of Sara Claro (Concertante, 2007); keyboard or piano and electronics by
Amlcar Vasques Dias (Branda, Concerto para teclas, chocalhos e rebanho virtual
piano, sampler, sintetizador e controlador digital de sopros, 1998) and Joo Pedro
Oliveira (Tessares, 1991, rev. 2006).
Didactic piano works appear more frequently: Eurico Thomaz de Limas Para os
pequeninos pianistas tocarem/For Little Pianists to Play (1932) and Gradual para Piano
(pub. 2006); Lopes-Graas Album de Jovem Pianista/Young Pianists lbum (1953)
and Msica de piano para as crianas/Piano Music for Children (1937); Carneyros Trio
Infantil com Piano (1966) and Pacincias de Ana Maria (1938); Frederico de Freitas O
Livro de Maria Frederica; and Corra Oliveiras many works, plus unique reading
system. Srgio Azevedos Caleidoscpio of 150 didactic pieces is the largest collection
by a Portuguese composer. Also notable are didactic works by Christopher Bochmann,
Ivan Moody, Clotilde Rosa, Amlcar Vasques Dias, and Joo Pedro Oliveira (for piano
and tape), as well as collections coordinated by Colien Honnegger (Album de Colien),
A. Lopes & V. Dotsenko (Manual de Piano) and Olga Silva.
Although the first decade of the 21st century has not yet been completed, there
are no clear indicators as to how Portuguese piano music will be known by the end of
the century. What is evident are the changing ways of handling material and form.
These may depend on circumstances (be they for didactic purposes, for soloists, for
ensembles, commissions, etc.) and aesthetic propensities. To date, we have seen a
wide gamut of styles and genres including electronic music, acusmatic music, music for
harpsichord or fortepiano, large-scale sonatas, short pieces, experimental works,
didactic piano with tape, and even the anti-piano concerto. The tendency seems to be
away from usage of Portuguese folk material (although composers such as
Carrapatoso and Amlcar Vasques Dias draw inspiration from their patrimony) and
towards more international or European trends, reinforcing the Portuguese inclination
for discoveries.

Methodology
The methodologies used in this research include a systematic investigation into
national and international libraries, as well as bibliographic sources found in
dictionaries, encyclopedias, histories of music and general histories, biographies,
bibliographies, discographies, publishers catalogues, music magazines, online
references, and other sources. In addition, correspondence with living Portuguese
composers in Portugal and abroad has yielded direct and important information.

Conclusions
Because of Portugals chequered political, dramatic historical, and often colorful
socio-cultural past, it is important to note that there has been no one continuous staterun music publishing house in any century. Because of the many now defunct
publishing houses, it now more than ever important to identify lost, out-of-print, and
current piano works into a single source. Although Portugal was at the forefront of
musical development in the court of John V in the 18th century, it quickly fell behind
because of unfortunate events, such as the 1755 Lisbon earthquake, the Napoleonic
wars of the 19th century, the end of the monarch in the early 20th century and the
resulting instabilities until democracy was declared on 25 April 1974. The dominance of
other cultures and the slow-to-develop national identity has caused Portuguese music
to lag behind its European counterparts. However, this problem had at least three
positive sides 1) because Portugal was some thirty years behind mainstream Europe,
the Romantic spirit was well preserved far into the 20th century; 2) a Portuguese
national identity associated with its rich folk and fado culture has emerged in the 20th
century, which remains to be seen if continued in the 21st century; 3) solo piano works,
instrumental chamber music, and the piano concerto are compositional predilections in
Portuguese music, while didactic works and 2-piano/4 hand works are less important.
Have there been any new inventions regarding the piano in Portugal? No, not
like the Harmonic piano of Joshua Harrison, the Player Piano of Conlon Nancarrow, or
Faziolis 4th pedal. Nor do we see the tendency of teaching piano in groups as in AngloSaxonic countries, which may account for the lack of multiple-piano repertoire. There is
currently no Portuguese piano method in wide usage.
Portuguese composers of the 20th-21st-centuries have quickly caught up to their
European colleagues. Their exploration of the piano in an aesthetic and sonorous way
is often most creatively and in unusual combinations. Portuguese piano music
deserves to be known outside of Portugal and to become standard in every pianists
repertoire.

Bibliography
1. ALBUQUERQUE, Maria Joo Dures (2006) A edio musical em Portugal (17501834). Lisbon: Imprensa Nacional, Casa da Moeda, Fundao Calouste Gulbenkian.
2. ALVARENGA, Joo Pedro d (Out. 2006) Carlos Seixas: um esboo biogrfico e
uma leitura sinttica da sua obra in Aguas furtadas Revista de Literatura Muisca e
Artes Visuais, 10, p. 164-178, consulted on www.ensino.uevora.pt/jpa on 10 April 2009.
3. BILSON, Malcolm (2006) Knowing the Score (DVD). Ithaca, NY: Cornell University.
4. BRITO, Manuel Carlos de & CRANMER, David (1990) Crnicas da Vida Musical
Portuguesa na Primeira Metade do Sculo XIX. Lisboa: Imprensa Nacional Casa da
Moeda.
5. MONTEIRO, Francisco (2003) The Portuguese Darmstadt Generation The Piano
Music of the Portuguese Avant-Garde, unpublished PhD Dissertation, U. Sheffield,
consulted at www.geocities.com/francmonteir on 2 April 2009.

6. Various archives (Archives of Biblioteca Nacional de Portugal, Biblioteca Nacional

do Brasil, Bibliotque Nationale de France, Library of Congress, British Library,
Portuguese Music Centre, Atrio/Atrium, Shrine to Music): www.bn.pt; www.bn.br;
www.bn.fr;
www.loc.gov;
www.bl.uk:
www.mic.pt;
http://sites.google.com/site/patrimoniomusical, www.usd.edu/smm; as well as
correspondence with some living composers.