TRG & Dev 819
TRG & Dev 819
Assignment No. 01
Q. No. 01
Objectives:
There are many different theories of how people learn. What follows is a variety
of them, and it is useful to consider their application to how your students learn
and also how you teach in educational programs. It is interesting to think about
your own particular way of learning and to recognize that everyone does not learn
the way you do.
Reinforcement theory
Carl Rogers and others have developed the theory of facilitative learning. The
basic premise of this theory is that learning will occur by the educator acting as a
facilitator, that is by establishing an atmosphere in which learners feel
comfortable to consider new ideas and are not threatened by external factors
(Laird 1985.)
Learners:
Experiential learning
Kolb proposed a four-stage learning process with a model that is often referred to
in describing experiential learning (McGill & Beaty 1995). The process can begin
at any of the stages and is continuous, ie there is no limit to the number of cycles
you can make in a learning situation. This theory asserts that without reflection
we would simply continue to repeat our mistakes. The experiential learning cycle:
Kolb's research found that people learn in four ways with the likelihood of
developing one mode of learning more than another. As shown in the
'experiential learning cycle' model above, learning is:
Q. No. 01
Exploration
In the first phase, students work on their own or in small groups to explore
scientific phenomena, manipulate materials, and attempt to solve problems. The
teacher acts as facilitator, posing questions and providing assistance as needed.
Students have the opportunity to develop their own hypotheses and to test them
through a hands-on experiment or observation.
Concept development
In the second phase of the learning cycle, the teacher leads the students through
the introduction and development of the scientific concepts central to the lesson.
The students may begin by sharing their observations and ideas from the
exploration phase. The teacher may then use written or audio-visual materials to
develop the concept and introduce relevant vocabulary.
Concept application
The teacher now poses a new problem or situation for the students to solve based
on their initial exploration and on the concepts they refined in the second phase.
As in the first phase, the students work individually or in small groups while the
teacher acts as facilitator. The learning cycle may then begin again, as these
hands-on activities become the starting point for the exploration and
development of a related concept.
A. Engagement:
Engagement is a time when the teacher is on center stage. The teacher poses the
problem, pre-assesses the students, helps students make connections, and
informs students about where they are heading.
B. Exploration:
Evaluation of Exploration: In this portion of the learning cycle the evaluation
should primarily focus on process, i.e., on the students' data collection, rather
than the product of the students' data collection. Teachers ask themselves
questions such as the following:
C. Explanation:
In this phase of the process, students use the data they have collected to solve the
problem and report what they did and try to figure out the answer to the problem
that was presented. The teacher also introduces new vocabulary, phrases or
sentences to label what the students have already figured out.
D. Elaboration:
The teacher gives students new information that extends what they have been
learning in the earlier parts of the learning cycle. At this stage the teacher also
poses problems that students solve by applying what they have learned. The
problems include both examples and non-examples.
By recognizing and understanding our own learning styles, we can use techniques
better suited to us. This improves the speed and quality of your learning.
Your learning styles have more influence than you may realize. Your preferred
styles guide the way you learn. They also change the way you internally represent
experiences, the way you recall information, and even the words you choose. We
explore more of these features in this chapter.
Research shows us that each learning style uses different parts of the brain. By
involving more of the brain during learning, we remember more of what we learn.
Researchers using brain-imaging technologies have been able to find out the key
areas of the brain responsible for each learning style. For example:
• Visual. The occipital lobes at the back of the brain manage the visual
sense. Both the occipital and parietal lobes manage spatial orientation.
• Aural. The temporal lobes handle aural content. The right temporal lobe
is especially important for music.
• Verbal. The temporal and frontal lobes, especially two specialized areas
called Broca’s and Wernicke’s areas (in the left hemisphere of these two
lobes).
• Physical. The cerebellum and the motor cortex (at the back of the frontal
lobe) handle much of our physical movement.
• Logical. The parietal lobes, especially the left side, drive our logical
thinking.
• Social. The frontal and temporal lobes handle much of our social
activities. The limbic system (not shown apart from the hippocampus) also
influences both the social and solitary styles. The limbic system has a lot to
do with emotions, moods and aggression.
• Solitary. The frontal and parietal lobes, and the limbic system, are also
active with this style.
Q. No. 02:
6
(a) State the general concepts and dimensions for training needs
assessment?
Too often people consider only one solution (a want) and discuss it as a need,
when in truth what they really need will not be addressed. Effective questioning
can reveal the need behind the want. However it is important to remember that
the “want” is often the best solution. Two things to remember:
Needs are gaps – the space between what currently exists and what should
exist.
• Are often done through the human resource office although sometimes
contracted out to training organizations
• Focus on internal needs of an organization
• Focus on internal needs and are therefore not necessarily associated with
market analysis
• Are initiated in response to a change or perceived problem
• Are the most common type of needs assessment
7
Multi-Individual assessments
• Use results of market analysis to further refine training needs and wants of
specific target audiences
• Are a program development tool to guide development and design of
products and services
• Audiences are targeted based on needs perceived by organizations
providing products, services, and training
So the members of your team haven't got the skills they need if they're to perform
at their best, and people are coming at you from all directions with courses they
want to go on. How do you identify the training that people really need, make
best use of a worryingly small training budget, and negotiate for more money
where you need it? This is where a well-conducted Training Needs Assessment
can be a useful tool.
When you're designing any training and development program, you really need to
know the fundamentals (who, what, why, how, where and when) before you
arrange the training:
Understood in this way, you can see that Training Needs Assessment is much
more than simple data gathering. Rather, it is a process that starts with gathering
data and ends with a training plan.
Q. No. 02
(b) What are the major tools and techniques used for
training needs assessment?
8
Audience,
Format,
Length,
Technical specifications,
Cost, and
Purpose or optimum use
Observation
Patterns observed with particular user groups or when retrieving certain types of
information can also point out training needs. If persons in the marketing group
consistently ask about retrieving certain types of information, there may be a
need for training in this application. The more you observe user interaction with
an information product/service, the better you will be able to target training to
needs of the user.
Surveys
Needs Assessments can also take the form of written surveys or web-based
surveys. Data about training needs collected from a structured, standardized
survey instrument can serve as justification for building a training program. The
survey data serves as a baseline from which to benchmark progress in the future,
and may provide baseline data for measuring ROI (return on investment).
Very Need to
9
The advantage of conducting focus groups and/or interviews is that you will get
qualitative feedback from users. These insights into how users would like to be
able to use information products/services as well as real or perceived barriers to
use can help you further shape the training program to bring the maximum
benefit to persons being trained.
In preparation for leading a focus group, create a list of questions that you
would like to have the participants discuss. Market researchers in your
organization (or vendors or outside facilitators) can give you pointers about
phrasing the questions to obtain the feedback you need, about capturing data,
and reporting outcomes.
Written individual responses (15 min): Leader reads the written needs
assessment question that has been posted. Participants are asked to write each
idea on a 3 x 5 card in brief phrases or statements, working silently and
independently.
Group discussion of feedback (15 min.): The leader points to the first idea,
reads it out loud, and asks the group if there are any questions, statements of
clarification, or statements of agreement or disagreement anyone would like to
make. The object of this is to clarify, not persuade. Duplicates can be eliminated.
If new ideas occur to someone, they can be added to the list. The leader makes
sure this entire process is done quickly so all items can be discussed.
Vote tally (5 min.): Leader collects all the cards. The transcriber uses a tally
sheet to record and tabulate results. Recorder shares results with group.
Group discussion (10 min.): Discussion to clarify any questions. Members may
change votes.
10
Plenary session feedback (1 hr and 20 mm): All the small groups convene in
one setting. Final votes from each group are reported to the entire audience.
The Process
Understanding the Situation
• Defining objectives, people impacted, and tasks
• Developing agendas, sample questions
Collecting information
Using information from only a few sources may restrict the range of alternatives
considered as well as mislead. For this reason we generally use a variety of
methods, often including:
• Identification of sources of data
• Review of existing data
• Data collection techniques, such as interviews, questionnaires, small and large
group meetings, committees, focus groups, and observations
Q. No. 03
11
• direct observation
• questionnaires
• consultation with persons in key positions, and/or with specific knowledge
• review of relevant literature
• interviews
• focus groups
• tests
• records & report studies
• work samples
Program objective
12
Definition
At first glance, the list of 20 high level objectives may seem daunting. However,
in the same way an organization focuses its compliance activities on areas that
affect financial reporting, it also concentrates most of its effort on the areas that
have the greatest impact on ensuring integrity and passing an audit. Of the high-
level objectives, organizations working to comply spend much of their effort on
the following:
Here are examples of COBIT detailed control objectives involving user account
management and configuration management that are critical in meeting SOX
requirements:
Configuration Recording
CONTROL OBJECTIVE
Procedures should be in place to ensure that only authorized and identifiable
configuration items are recorded in inventory upon acquisition. These procedures
should also provide for the authorized disposal and consequential sale of
configuration items. Moreover, procedures should be in place to keep track of
changes to the configuration (e.g., new item, status change from development to
prototype). Logging and control should be an integrated part of the configuration
recording system including reviews of changed records.
Training objectives are one of the most important parts of training program.
While some people think of training objective as a waste of valuable time. The
counterargument here is that resources are always limited and the training
objectives actually lead the design of training. It provides the clear guidelines and
develops the training program in less time because objectives focus specifically
on needs. It helps in adhering to a plan.
Training objective tell the trainee that what is expected out of him at the end
of the training program. Training objectives are of great significance from a
number of stakeholder perspectives,
1. Trainer
2. Trainee
3. Designer
4. Evaluator
Trai
nee – The training objective is beneficial to the trainee because it helps in
reducing the anxiety of the trainee up to some extent. Not knowing anything
or going to a place which is unknown creates anxiety that can negatively affect
learning. Therefore, it is important to keep the participants aware of the
happenings, rather than keeping it surprise.
Thirdly, if the goal is set to be challenging and motivating, then the likelihood
of achieving those goals is much higher than the situation in which no goal is
set. Therefore, training objectives helps in increasing the probability that
the participants will be successful in training.
Q. No. 03
(b) How to plan program implementation? Discuss.
Program implementation consists of three main objectives.
• Planning program implementation
• Preparing and organizing program activities
• Executing the program
population, the objectives to be achieved, the pre requisites for entering the
program, the description and evaluating the results.
Program implementation planning should take into consideration
company management development policy, which could be collected from
company documents or by interviewing top management. The policy should
indicate the most important procedures, for example, whether training
should:
(3) Budget
An approved training budget is another major output of the
planning phase. It is based on the resources requirements identified during the
preparation of the master plan. In most cases, a management training program is
organized as a separate economic activity with its own budget. A training unit
with in an enterprise may also charge for its training services. It is therefore good
16
practice to accompany the master plan with a training budget. Such a budget
contains training costs and participant cost.
Training costs
• Cost of trainers: salary, travel and allowances
• Cost of training support staff or services: course secretariat audio visual
and technician, translation, interpretation, printing etc,
• Tuition fees to be paid to other institutions.
• Rental of training facilities and equipment.
Participants costs
• Main travel and daily local transport.
• Excess baggage allowance (for training materials)
• Transport for study/tours
• Subsistence allowance (for accommodation, meals, and incidental
expenses)
• Board and lodging, if no subsistence allowance is paid
• Allowances for books
• Social events, receptions
ORGANIZING
Management
Program Director
the nominated program director is responsible for all preparatory
activities, program execution, and for expenditure within the budget. He or she
directs the secretariat and staff involved in preparation and organization, selects
briefs and monitors the trainers, prepares the program schedule.
Secretariat duties
the secretariat supports the program director and professional staff in all
administrative matters. Participants needs should be the first concern of the
secretariat.
b) Trainers
trainers should be selected on the basis of their professional reputation.
Some audiences find it difficult to accept lessons from a management trainer who
is junior to them, if that person is not a reputed genius. If we cannot afford to pay
a management consultant’s high training fee, look for a successful manager who
would appreciate sharing experience with others managers, perhaps free of
charge.
17
Briefing of trainers
A trainer needs to know for example:
• The number of participants, their position, their experience in the subject
matter.
• The general objective of the training event.
• The subject to be taught, breadth and depth of coverage, skills to be
developed, level to be attained.
• The teaching provided by the other trainers.
• Date, time, place ,arrangements for travel, accommodation, training
facilities.
• Contract conditions if any.
c) promotion
printing of program
program description or publicity pamphlets should contain the
following essential information.
• The title, dates and place of the training event;
• The general objective;
• To whom it is addressed;
• The content, hand-outs, methods;
• Names, qualifications and jobs of speakers;
• Fees and /or allowances
Press/radio/ Tv briefing
Depending on the location of the target audience, daily press, radio and
television networks may be more efficient than mailing program for spreading
information about the training event.
The secretariat is organized; trainers are briefed and ready; the promotion
campaign has resulted in the enrolment of participants; the training support staff
has prepared the required facilities and printed the necessary materials;
accommodation, catering, transport and social services are ready to receive the
participants. These are the required inputs for program execution which produce
the three final outputs illustrated in figure below.
ORGANIZING
To avoid last minute improvisation and accidents which disturb the smooth
running of training activities. it is recommended to use checklists to monitor each
of the three main activities mentioned above.
Q. No. 04
(a) How self development is defined? Give appropriate examples in
support of answer.
Self development has two main characteristics – development of the self and
development by the self.
At first we will describe a process, and by doing this we will in fact be using
two important principles of self development, which are that:
• It involves the developer working things out for him or herself;
• The developer can be helped to do this by some one else providing an
appropriate process.
Therefore, in order to start this first process, take a piece of paper and write down
six or seven key development events in our life (e.g things that have happened,
experiences we have had, that in our opinion have led us to develop in some way).
These events- which can be from our working life, our private life, or a misture of
both- may have been very short or long. As long as we can identify them as
definite, separate happenings then that is fine.
Development BY
the self development OF the self
19
Above figure although simple, is very important because it shows that for
someone to experience development of the self. We must be allowed, encouraged
and helped to undertake processes of development by the self. This means that if
the trainer does too much- prevents the learners from having to do some of the
work by themselves- then they will not benefit from development of themselves.
Few trainers, of course deliberately set out to prevent self development. But it is
very easy to get drawn into being too helpful, for example by:
• Giving the answer rather than letting the learners find out for themselves.
• Stepping in when the learners have difficulties, solving a problem for
them, rather that proving them with just enough guidance and structure to
solve it them selves or
• “doing the dirty work” for the learner for example by going to see the
learner boss on their behalf rather that coaching, persuading and
encouraging them to take the risk and present their own case.
It was a realization of this danger, in fact, that led to the growth of management
self development in the 1980s.
Elements of self
1. Gender: what does it mean to be a woman/man
Mode 1. Adhering
In this mode my basic sense of self is one of self protection. I am looking
for safety and security in this world, so that I may be defended from its
uncertainties and dangers.
Mode 2. Adapting
Mode 3. Relating
i seek to find out what is acceptable; I try to tune into the norms,
conventions, OK ways of doing things. I want to demonstrate that I belong, by
behaving in the appropriate way, by showing that I understand and agree with
established explanations, theories, ideas; that I share the predominant values,
that I have a repertoire of useful praiseworthy skills.
Mode 4. Experiencing
To begin the process of knowing, being and valuing my inner self, I seek
and participate in a variety of situations and experiences. More importantly,
reflect on these and make my own meaning from them. I am prepared to cope wit
h the ambiguity of not having a source of right answers to call on. I am open to
experience, prepared to learn from it.
Mode 5. Experimenting
I am now committed to deepening my expertise in a given field. To do so I
am prepared to explore that field systematically, rationally, carrying out
experiments in the sense of scientific (i-e “knowing”) method. I thus take active
steps to seek further insights, to find out more, to increase my understanding.
Mode 6. Connecting
In mode 06 I sense my self as part of a much larger whole. To be myself, I
need to achieve wholeness, balance, unity. I feel connected to other people, other
departments, other groups, other societies. I see my ideas as connected to other
fields of learning. I see connections between past, present and future. I see how
what were “opposites”- male and female; good and bad; teacher and learner;
mass and energy; matter and spirit – are, in fact, essentially linked. They are
parts of same whole.
Mode 7. Dedicating
So now in Mode 7 I have recognized my purpose in life, and the task I want
to achieve. Hopefully this task is not just for myself, but in some way make a
definite, identifiable, conscious contribution to the development of my field,
specialization, art, craft, organization, area of expertise, hobby, community,
affinity group of whatever I choose to commit myself to.
Although the modes appear in sequence, it is important to recognize that
once a new one appear, earlier ones are still available. Thus as I develop I have a
larger repertoire or collection of modes available to me. Part of managing myself
is being aware of choice of modes open tome, and making that choice in
consciousness of the advantages and disadvantages of each, bearing in mind the
needs, opportunities and constraints presented by the situation in which I find
myself.
Q. No. 4
(b) Define the process of experiential and action learning ?
Experiential Learning Cycles are models for understanding how the process of
learning works. They are distinct from other models of learning, such as
behavioral models or social learning models, in two notable ways:
• Experiential Learning Cycles treat the learner's subjective experience as of
critical importance in the learning process.
• Experiential Learning Cycles propose an iterative series of processes which
underlies learning. Depending on the model, there is anywhere between
21
Kolb (1984) provides one of the most useful (but contestable) descriptive models
available of the adult learning process, inspired by the work of Kurt Lewin.
This suggests that there are four stages in learning which follow from each other:
Concrete Experience is followed by Reflection on that experience on a
personal basis. This may then be followed by the derivation of general rules
describing the experience, or the application of known theories to it (Abstract
Conceptualization), and hence to the construction of ways of modifying the
next occurrence of the experience (Active Experimentation), leading in turn
to the next Concrete Experience. All this may happen in a flash, or over days,
weeks or months, depending on the topic, and there may be a "wheels within
wheels" process at the same time.
Intuition is receiving input and ideas without knowing exactly how and where
you got them from. You simply know it is not from yourself. Like creativity,
intuitive inspiration often happens when someone virtually «fuses» in an activity,
when one is highly focused on the respective activity in a state of joy and
fulfillment. Intuition can be trained and in its highest level leads into a conscious
contact with non-incarnated beings, a process usually called channeling.
Most of us are used to making intuitive decisions in our daily life: As soon
as subjective judgment is involved, rational reasoning is very difficult to apply.
Typical examples where intuition can play an important role in making decisions
are: Choosing your life partner, selecting the right car to buy, evaluation of a job,
decision about an education, selecting a meal when eating out, selecting the next
book to read, decide how to dress for today, and so on.
Intuitive decision making is far more than using common sense because it
involves additional sensors to perceive and get aware of the information from
22
Action Learning
Action Learning is a process for bringing together a group of people with varied
levels of skills and experience to analyze an actual work problem and develop an
action plan. The group continues to meet as actions are implemented, learning
from the implementation and making mid-course corrections. Action Learning is
a form of learning by doing.
To address problems and issues that are complex and not easily resolved.
To find solutions to underlying root causes of problems.
To determine a new strategic direction or to maximize new opportunities.
“Discipline-Specific”
• Each team elects a “project manager” after openly discussing each other’s
strengths
• Each team analyzes the issues involved in completing the project within
the given time frame: scope, collaborative partners, resources available,
etc.
• Team generates their own objectives & goals for project via reflective
inquiry & dialogue
• teams present their work to the larger group, sharing what they learned
regarding making a difference, what went well, what they would change
and why
An action learning set is a group of usually 4 - 7 people who get together (on a
regular basis) to discuss issues of personal or mutual importance. They are
designed to deal with the specific needs of the set members and require agreed
action by the end of each meeting. Sets may, or may not, be facilitated, or may
start with a facilitator and later become self-facilitating. Whichever the case, it is
important for some ground rules to be negotiated at the outset.
• Participants will be organized into small groups on day 1, and will begin to
build up relationships with other participants in their group. Action learning
will form part of these sessions on days 2 and 3;
• Each participant will bring a real issue or problem to the set, but due to time
constraints only one or two issues will be covered each day
• The facilitator will help the group to set up explicit ground rules for the set;
• The whole set will look at each issue in turn;
• The person who has described the issue will decide on at least three action
points to address after the module.
Participants will work together on their chosen topics, listening and supporting
their colleagues, and helping them to decide on courses of action. Participants
will help individuals to understand the problem better and to challenge their
underlying assumptions, rather than to offer advice. Each participant will be
invited in turn to share their problem. Their peers will look at the problem from
their own perspective, and through pertinent questions, discussion and sharing of
experience, participants will be helped to move on in their understanding of an
issue or problem, and to come to see possible ways forward. Participants will be
encouraged to show empathy rather than be judgemental, to listen and provide
support for each other.
The facilitator will help to develop the ground rules for the operation of the set.
This will include allocation of time, confidentiality, attendance etc
Q. no. 05
Relevance the degree to which the topic of the simulation is relevant to the
needs of the participants and their organizations;
25
The second set of success criteria relate to the trainer’s ability to keep the
components of the first set in balance with each other.
(A) challenge
The simulation should challenge the participants to apply themselves,
make them want to seek new and innovative solutions, create a desire to use skills
that they have not sued before or to use them differently. For example, in a
simulation for owners of small enterprises where the theme is personnel
management and where the general tendency among them has been to treat
personnel in an autocratic way, a simulation where they can apply human insight
will challenge them to take a different view of dealing with people.
(B) Relevance
A game of Monopoly can be fun, especially when in good company.
However, it may not reflect the needs of a manager who is constantly facing a
mixture of operational, strategic and interpersonal problems. A relevant
simulation is one where the theme reflects the needs and interests of the
participants. The degree of relevance is important in motivating participants to
become actively involved.
(C) Realism
The realism of a simulation may sometimes be difficult to distinguish from
its relevance. Whereas the relevance of the simulation reflects the relationship
between its content and the participants needs and concerns, its realism is
addressed to the organization being simulated and the extent to which
participants are able to recognize their work situation reflected in the simulation.
The trainer may find the following points useful for attaining realism in
simulations:
• The task should be a recognizable action of managerial work;
• The environment should produce effects that are readily understandable
and recognizable by the managers;
• Participants should be able to see clearly the cause effect relationships of
their actions;
• The reward system of the simulation should be compatible with those
used in real life.
Advantages of Simulation
26
One of the primary advantages of simulators is that they are able to provide users
with practical feedback when designing real world systems. This allows the
designer to determine the correctness and efficiency of a design before the system
is actually constructed. Consequently, the user may explore the merits of
alternative designs without actually physically building the systems. By
investigating the effects of specific design decisions during the design phase
rather than the construction phase, the overall cost of building the system
diminishes significantly. As an example, consider the design and fabrication of
integrated circuits. During the design phase, the designer is presented with a
myriad of decisions regarding such things as the placement of components and
the routing of the connecting wires.
Disadvantages of Simulation
Q . No. 05
(b) What are the main objectives of simulations? Also
describe different aspects of simulations with
examples?
There are three main objectives in suing simulations:
• To change attitudes,
• To develop skills
• To identify needs and problems