APPLIED ENGINEERING FOR
SMALL HYDROPOWER
PROJECTS
PRACTICAL TIPS
FOR HYDROPOWER PRACTITIONERS
Sven Homscheid
21 s t August 2015
Georgetown, Guyana
Hydropower Consultant
1
OUTLINE
Field measurements for topographic survey of mini and
smaller hydro projects
Different turbine types, their technical qualities and
field of usage
Environmental and Social considerations of hydropower
projects
Hydropower civil design options: differences,
advantages and disadvantages
Optimizing hydropower projects: the difference
between grid integrated and island supply
FIELD MEASUREMENTS
FOR TOPOGRAPHIC
SURVEY OF MINI AND
SMALLER HYDRO
PROJECTS
3
FIELD MEASUREMENTS FOR TOPOGRAPHIC SURVEY
Why is good topographic data so extremely important?
H is one of three main parameters in the power output
equation
P=Q*H***g
Where:
P
Q
H
g
-
Power output
Discharge
Head (difference of water levels)
Plant efficiency
Density of water
Acceleration constant
FIELD MEASUREMENTS FOR TOPOGRAPHIC SURVEY
Q = flow in m3/s
Depending on
Geographic location
(rain forest or desert)
Elevation above sea level
(the higher, the wetter)
Time of the year
(rainy season or dry season)
FIELD MEASUREMENTS FOR TOPOGRAPHIC SURVEY
Hn = net head in m
Gross Head depending on
Topography
Net Head depending on
Friction losses
Mountain or valley
Dam, run-off river or
diversion
Pipe diameter/canal dimensions
Pipe/canal roughness
Length of pipe/canal
Other hydraulic losses
-
Trash rack
Bends
Valves
FIELD MEASUREMENTS FOR TOPOGRAPHIC SURVEY
Gross Head is estimated by different means according to required
accuracy
Different approaches
a) Desktop approaches
b) Field measurements
Some examples:
FIELD MEASUREMENTS FOR TOPOGRAPHIC SURVEY
Desktop Approaches:
Read out from Google Earth
Accuracy of elevation: about 3 to 15 m depending on vegetation and
relief
FIELD MEASUREMENTS FOR TOPOGRAPHIC SURVEY
Desktop Approaches:
Read out from Google Earth
Accuracy of elevation: about 3 to 15 m depending on vegetation and
relief
FIELD MEASUREMENTS FOR TOPOGRAPHIC SURVEY
Desktop Approaches:
Read out from contour lines in topographic maps
Accuracy of elevation: about one contour line interval (50 ft = 15 m)
10
FIELD MEASUREMENTS FOR TOPOGRAPHIC SURVEY
Desktop Approaches:
Read out from contour lines in topographic maps
Accuracy of elevation: about one contour line interval (50 ft = 15 m)
11
FIELD MEASUREMENTS FOR TOPOGRAPHIC SURVEY
Desktop Approaches:
Global Digital Elevation Models used in GIS, e.g. ASTER
Several products available, some free of charge, others for fees
For example: ASTER GDEM >> https://asterweb.jpl.nasa.gov/data.asp
12
FIELD MEASUREMENTS FOR TOPOGRAPHIC SURVEY
13
FIELD MEASUREMENTS FOR TOPOGRAPHIC SURVEY
14
FIELD MEASUREMENTS FOR TOPOGRAPHIC SURVEY
15
FIELD MEASUREMENTS FOR TOPOGRAPHIC SURVEY
16
FIELD MEASUREMENTS FOR TOPOGRAPHIC SURVEY
Desktop Approaches:
Global Digital Elevation Models used in GIS, e.g. ASTER
Several products available, some free of charge, others for fee
For example: ASTER GDEM >> https://asterweb.jpl.nasa.gov/data.asp
Spatial Resolution: 30 x 30 m
Vertical Accuracy: RMS Error = 8.68 m, depending on relief structure
17
FIELD MEASUREMENTS FOR TOPOGRAPHIC SURVEY
Conclusion to Desktop Approaches:
(-)
(+)
(+)
(+)
(-)
(+)
(+)
Vertical accuracy is quite poor
Data is quickly available for almost all corners of the world
Some data is available for free; more precise data costs money
Usefulness of the desktop approach for
initial analysis of sites and site identification
initial analysis of high head projects where the relative error is
small compared to the overall head
Method is not suitable for
analysis of low head sites where every half meter head counts
detailed analysis of any projects
The desktop approach gives a quick overview on the site
Allows identification of geomorthologic basics such as mountain
folding, faults etc.
18
FIELD MEASUREMENTS FOR TOPOGRAPHIC SURVEY
Field Measurement Approaches:
Hand held GPS
(+)
(+)
(-)
(+)
(-)
Easy to handle
Quick results
Poor accuracy for elevations (<5 m at best)
Spatial accuracy: up to 1 m
Not applicable in deep forest
19
FIELD MEASUREMENTS FOR TOPOGRAPHIC SURVEY
Field Measurement Approaches:
Water level bubble, line and measuring tape
20
FIELD MEASUREMENTS FOR TOPOGRAPHIC SURVEY
Field Measurement Approaches:
Water level bubble, line and measuring tape
(+) Very cheap tools available in hardware store
(+) Relatively quick for small sites, time consuming for larger sites
(-) Accuracy depends on users skills; generally around 1 2 m per
100m longitudinal distance
(-) Accuracy of bubble reading needs thorough practice
(+) Best when supplemented with aerial photos, e.g. Google Earth
(+) Applicable nearly everywhere
21
FIELD MEASUREMENTS FOR TOPOGRAPHIC SURVEY
Field Measurement Approaches:
Hose water level and measuring tape
22
FIELD MEASUREMENTS FOR TOPOGRAPHIC SURVEY
Field Measurement Approaches:
Hose water level and measuring tape
23
FIELD MEASUREMENTS FOR TOPOGRAPHIC SURVEY
Field Measurement Approaches:
Hose water level and measuring tape
24
FIELD MEASUREMENTS FOR TOPOGRAPHIC SURVEY
Field Measurement Approaches:
Hose water level and measuring tape
(+) Cheap tools
(+) Relatively quick for small and shallow sites, time consuming for larger
and steep sites; can only measure as far as the hose is long
(-) Accuracy depends on users skills; generally around 0.3 1 m per
100m
(+) Best when supplemented with aerial photos, e.g. Google Earth
(+) Applicable nearly everywhere
25
FIELD MEASUREMENTS FOR TOPOGRAPHIC SURVEY
Field Measurement Approaches:
Levelling machine and measuring tape
26
FIELD MEASUREMENTS FOR TOPOGRAPHIC SURVEY
Field Measurement Approaches:
Levelling machine and measuring tape
(+) Simple technology, needs only brief introduction
(+) Relatively cheap equipment (Levelling machine: 200 USD; Tripod: 100
USD; Scale bar: 80 USD)
(+) Accurate results of up to 0.001 m
(-) Relatively time consuming
(+) Can measure far distances in shallow areas
(-) Needs at least a team of two persons
27
FIELD MEASUREMENTS FOR TOPOGRAPHIC SURVEY
Field Measurement Approaches:
Tachymeter
28
FIELD MEASUREMENTS FOR TOPOGRAPHIC SURVEY
Field Measurement Approaches:
Tachymeter (with or without GPS)
(+)
(+)
(+)
(-)
(-)
(-)
(-)
High accuracy of 0.005 m horizontal and 0.001 m vertical possible
Measures all spatial coordinates (x, y, z)
Modern machines can be remote controlled one man station
Expensive equipment (used: USD 10,000 upwards)
Needs thorough training for operator
Needs specialized software for evaluation and visualization of data
Needs local fixed point network
With GPS:
(+) Coordinates available in WGS84
(-) Poor satellite reception in the forest
(-) Very costly equipment
29
FIELD MEASUREMENTS FOR TOPOGRAPHIC SURVEY
Field Measurement Approaches:
Survey Drone (= Unmanned Aerial Vehicle)
Multirotor G4 Surveying Robot
e-bee of Sensefly
30
FIELD MEASUREMENTS FOR TOPOGRAPHIC SURVEY
Field Measurement Approaches:
Survey Drone (= Unmanned Aerial Vehicle)
How it works:
Remote controlled drone carries multiple sensors
GPS/DGPS
Photo camera resolution > 16 Mpix
Ground proximity
Temperature
Altitude
Wind velocity and direction
Flying altitude: about 200 m
Photos and other data are stored on the devices memory when flying
over the investigation area, or are transmitted real-time to a laptop on
the ground
The data is superposed and from each two neighboring photos a
digital elevation model is produced by ortho-photogrammetry
31
FIELD MEASUREMENTS FOR TOPOGRAPHIC SURVEY
Field Measurement Approaches:
Survey Drone (= Unmanned Aerial Vehicle)
How it works: (continued)
The data is evaluated with specialized software
Terrestrially measured reference points are
required to improve the precision
High density point clouds are generated from the
measured data
One pixel is up to 1.5 cm on the ground
Accuracy: up to 0.001 m, normally 0.03 to 0.05 m
Was successfully applied in Ethiopias Grand
Renaissance hydropower project
32
FIELD MEASUREMENTS FOR TOPOGRAPHIC SURVEY
Field Measurement Approaches:
Survey Drone (= Unmanned Aerial Vehicle)
(+) Fast field work over large areas
(+) Produces ortho-photos, contour maps, digital elevation models and
other information depending on the deployed sensors
(+) Various models are available and have been tested in practice
(-) Requires high-tech software for data evaluation
(+) Accuracy: 0.01 m horizontal; 0.05 m vertical (if reference points avail)
(-) Very expensive equipment (> USD 25,000) and software (>
USD3,500)
(-) Needs highly specialized skills
(-) Not everywhere applicable without aviation license
(+) Future technology with lots of potential
33
DIFFERENT TURBINE
TYPES, THEIR
TECHNICAL QUALITIES
AND FIELD OF USAGE
34
DIFFERENT TURBINE T YPES
Selection of the right turbine type using diagrams:
35
DIFFERENT TURBINE T YPES
Selection of the right turbine type:
36
PELTON TURBINE
Pelton turbine: Impulse turbine
37
PELTON TURBINE
Pelton turbines key data:
Impulse turbine for high heads
38
PELTON TURBINE
Pelton turbines key data:
Impulse turbine for high heads
39
PELTON TURBINE
Pelton turbines key data:
Impulse turbine for high heads
Low and medium discharges
Between 1 and 6 jets possible
Quick ability to control power output
Typically used for storage projects and in peak power plants
Unit sizes of up to 400 MW each and more
Sensitive to abrasion through suspended sediments desanding is
very important: up to d = 0.2 to 0.1 mm depending on head
Baffles divert the jet completely or partially and thus allow fine
regulation of the power output
Turbine efficiencies of up to some 92 % with flat efficiency curves
Kick-in point at discharges of some 10 % of design discharge
Easy to maintain technique
40
PELTON TURBINE
New Trafalgar, Dominica
41
PELTON TURBINE
Needle valve and baffle
42
PELTON TURBINE
Pelton blades: cups
43
PELTON TURBINE
Break jet
44
TURGO TURBINE
Turgo turbine: Impulse turbine
45
TURGO TURBINE
Difference between Turgo and Pelton turbines
The Turgo turbine can process about twice the amount of water than Pelton turbines
46
TURGO TURBINE
Turgo turbines key data:
Impulse turbine for medium and high heads > about 30 to 250 m
Low and medium discharges
Similar to Pelton but jet hits at 30 to 40 angle
Quick ability to control power output
Typically used for small hydropower projects with storage or run-ofriver
Much less sensitive to abrasion through suspended sediments than
Pelton turbines desanding is less costly
Baffles divert the jet completely or partially and thus allow fine
regulation of the power output
Turbine efficiencies of up to some 90 % with flat efficiency curves
Kick-in point at discharges of some 10 % of design discharge
Extremely robust and easy to maintain
47
CROSS-FLOW TURBINE
Cross-flow turbine: Impulse turbine when free running, reaction when inundated
48
CROSS-FLOW TURBINE
Cross-flow turbine: Impulse turbine when free running, reaction when inundated
49
CROSS FLOW TURBINE
Cross flow turbines key data:
Impulse or reaction turbine depending on operation mode
Low and medium heads > about 1 to 200 m
Low discharges: 0.025 to 13 m3/s
50
CROSS FLOW TURBINE
Cross flow turbines key data:
Impulse or reaction turbine depending on operation mode
Low and medium heads > about 1 to 200 m
Low discharges
51
CROSS FLOW TURBINE
Cross flow turbines key data:
Impulse or reaction turbine depending on operation mode
Low and medium heads > about 1 to 200 m
Low discharges: 0.025 to 13 m3/s
Capacity up to 1,500 kW
Typically used for small hydropower projects with storage or run-ofriver
Principle similar to hydro wheels
Low sensitivity to abrasion through suspended sediments
Turbine efficiencies of up to some 87 %
Efficiency curves flat through usage of three cells
Kick-in point at discharges of some 5 % of design discharge
With or without draft tube
Robust and easy to maintain
52
FRANCIS TURBINE
Francis turbine: Reaction turbine
53
FRANCIS TURBINE
Francis turbines key data:
Reaction turbine
Medium and high heads from about 14 to 2,000 m
Medium and high discharges: 0.2 to 1,000 m3/s
Capacity up to 750 kW
54
FRANCIS TURBINE
Francis turbines key data:
Reaction turbine
Medium and high heads > about 14 to 2,000 m
Medium and high discharges: 0.2 to 1,000 m3/s
Capacity up to 750 kW
55
FRANCIS TURBINE
Francis turbines key data:
Reaction turbine
Medium and high heads > about 14 to 2,000 m
Medium and high discharges: 0.2 to 1,000 m3/s
Capacity up to 750 kW per unit
Typically used for small, medium and large hydropower projects
with storage or run-of-river, and as pump-turbines
Low sensitivity to abrasion through suspended sediments
Turbine efficiencies of up to some 94 %
Efficiency curves rather pointy
Kick-in point at discharges of some 30 % of design discharge
With or without draft tube
With or without spiral case
Moderate to maintain
56
FRANCIS TURBINE
Cumberland, St. Vincent
57
FRANCIS TURBINE
Francis shaft (a) and spiral (b) turbine arrangements
58
FRANCIS TURBINE
Top left: vertical shaft
arrangement;
Top right: horizontal shaft
alignment;
Bottom left: double
flooded turbine;
Center: elements of a
Francis turbine
59
KAPLAN TURBINE
Kaplan type turbine: Reaction turbine
60
KAPLAN TURBINE
Kaplan turbines key data:
Reaction turbine
Low and medium heads < about 80 m
Medium and high discharges: 1.5 to 1,000 m3/s
Capacity up to 350 kW per unit
61
KAPLAN TURBINE
Kaplan turbines key data:
Reaction turbine
Low and medium heads < about 80 m
Medium and high discharges: 1.5 to 1,000 m3/s
Capacity up to 350 kW per unit
62
KAPLAN TURBINE
Kaplan turbines key data:
Reaction turbine
Low and medium heads < about 80 m
Medium and high discharges: 1.5 to 1,000 m3/s
Capacity up to 350 kW per unit
Typically used for small and medium hydropower projects with
small storage or run-of-river
Low sensitivity to abrasion through suspended sediments
Turbine efficiencies of up to some 95 %
Efficiency curves flat through double regulated blades/guide vanes
Kick-in point at discharges of some 20 % of design discharge
With or without draft tube
With or without spiral case
High maintenance
63
KAPLAN / PROPELLER TURBINE
Kaplan turbine: guide vanes
and blades can be regulated;
Propeller turbine: only guide
vanes can regulate flow
64
KAPLAN / PROPELLER TURBINE
Related turbine types: Bulb turbine
65
KAPLAN / PROPELLER TURBINE
Related turbine types: HydroMatrixTM
66
KAPLAN / PROPELLER TURBINE
Related turbine types: HydroMatrixTM
Some 7 % less efficient than Bulb turbines
67
KAPLAN / PROPELLER TURBINE
Related turbine types: Straflo Turbine
68
KAPLAN / PROPELLER TURBINE
Related turbine types: S-Bulb turbines
69
KAPLAN / PROPELLER TURBINE
Related turbine types: Cone-gearbox (a) and Gearbox (b) turbines
70
DIAGONAL (OR DERIAZ) TURBINE
Diagonal (Deriaz) turbines: Mix between Kaplan and Francis Turbine
Reaction turbine
Shape similar to Francis Turbines
Double regulated: guide vanes and blades are adjustable
Medium heads 20 to about 140 m
Medium and high discharges: 1.8 to 500 m3/s
Capacity up to 100 MW per unit
71
DIAGONAL (DERIAZ) TURBINE
Diagonal (Deriaz) turbines: Mix between Kaplan and Francis Turbine
72
DIAGONAL (OR DERIAZ) TURBINE
Diagonal Turbine
73
DIAGONAL (OR DERIAZ) TURBINE
Diagonal Turbine
74
DIAGONAL (OR DERIAZ) TURBINE
Diagonal Turbine efficiencies, Geppert GmbH (Austria)
75
DIAGONAL (OR DERIAZ) TURBINE
Diagonal (Deriaz) turbines: Mix between Kaplan and Francis Turbine
Reaction turbine
Shape similar to Francis Turbines
Double regulated: guide vanes and blades are adjustable
Medium heads 20 to about 140 m
Medium and high discharges: 1.8 to 500 m3/s
Capacity up to 100 MW per unit
Typically used for small and medium hydropower projects with storage
or run-of-river and high flow variability
Moderate sensitivity to abrasion through suspended sediments
Turbine efficiencies of up to some 95 %
Efficiency curves flat through double regulated blades/guide vanes
High maintenance
76
DIAGONAL (OR DERIAZ) TURBINE
Diagonal Turbine
77
DIAGONAL (OR DERIAZ) TURBINE
Diagonal Turbine
78
HYDRO WHEELS
(a) Breast wheel with cells
(b) Breast wheel with blades
(c) Overshot wheel
(d) Undershot wheel
79
HYDRO WHEELS
Breast shot hydro wheel
80
HYDRO WHEELS
Overshot hydro wheel
81
HYDRO WHEELS
Breast shot hydro wheel type
Zuppinger
Q = 1.2 m3/s
H = 1.3 m
P = 10 11 kW
82
HYDRO WHEELS
Hydro Wheels key data:
Low heads < about 7 m
Low discharges up to 5 m3/s
Capacity up to 100 kW per unit
Typically used for small run-of-river hydropower projects, rarely with
small storage pond
Very low sensitivity to abrasion through suspended sediments
through slow rotation speed
Efficiencies of 50 % to some 82 %
Efficiency curves generally flat with good partial load efficiency due
to slow rotational speed
Requires gear box
Kick-in point at discharges of some 10 % of design discharge
Eco friendly
83
HYDRODYNAMIC SCREW
Hydro-dynamic screw: Reaction turbine (Archimedical Principle)
> 87%
Eco-friendly
84
HYDRODYNAMIC SCREW
Hydro-dynamic screw also available with integrated fish pass
https://www.youtube.com/watch?
feature=player_embedded&v=geh2c0kbfqs
85
HYDRODYNAMIC SCREW
Hydro-dynamic screw also available with integrated fish pass
https://www.youtube.com/watch?
feature=player_embedded&v=geh2c0kbfqs
86
HYDRODYNAMIC SCREW
Hydrodynamic Screw key data:
Low heads of 1.5 to about 10 m
Low discharges up to 5.5 m3/s
Capacity up to 300 kW per unit
87
HYDRODYNAMIC SCREW
Hydrodynamic Screw key data:
Low heads < about 7 m
Low discharges up to 5 m3/s
Capacity up to 100 kW per unit
Typically used for small run-of-river hydropower projects, rarely with
small storage pond
Very low sensitivity to abrasion through suspended sediments
through slow rotation speed
Efficiencies of 50 % to some 82 %
Efficiency curves generally flat with good partial load efficiency due
to slow rotational speed
Kick-in point at discharges of some 10 % of design discharge
Breast wheel with cells, breast wheel with blades, overshot wheel or
undershot wheel
Eco friendly
88
HYDRODYNAMIC SCREW
Hydrodynamic Screw key data:
Low heads of 1.5 to about 10 m
Low discharges up to 5.5 m3/s
Capacity up to 300 kW per unit
Typically used for small run-of-river hydropower projects
Very low sensitivity to abrasion through suspended sediments
through slow rotation speed
Efficiencies of up to some 87 %
Efficiency curves generally flat with good partial load efficiency due
to slow rotational speed
Eco friendly, optional with integrated fish lift
89
PUMPS AS TURBINES
What is Pumps as Turbines?
Centrifugal pumps are similar to Francis turbines with fixed
guide vanes
Pumps operated in reverse mode generate electricity
Disadvantage: efficiency decreases quickly when operation
point moves out of optimum
90
PUMPS AS TURBINES
91
STEFF TURBINE
Steff Turbine
92
DIVE TURBINE
93
DIVE TURBINE
Dive Turbine key data:
Principle of a Kaplan Turbine
Low heads of 2 to about 25 m
Low to medium discharges of 0.6 to 40 m3/s
Capacity of 30 kW to 2 MW per unit
Permanent magnet generator with frequency converter
Variable speed drive
Typically used for small run-of-river hydropower projects
Submersible design no need for powerhouse
Medium sensitivity to abrasion through suspended sediments
Efficiencies of up to some 87 %
94
DIVE TURBINE
Dive Turbine key data:
Principle of a Kaplan Turbine
Low heads of 2 to about 25 m
Low to medium discharges of 0.6 to 40 m3/s
Capacity of 30 kW to 2 MW per unit
Typically used for small run-of-river hydropower projects
Submersible design no need for powerhouse
Medium sensitivity to abrasion through suspended sediments
Efficiencies of up to some 87 %
Efficiency curves generally flat with good partial load efficiency due
to slow rotational speed
Eco friendly, optional with integrated fish lift
95
MICRO TURBINE COMPACT SYSTEMS
For very small projects compact turbine packages exist.
Example: Fuchun Industry from Shenzhen, China
Turgo and propeller type turbines
Turgo:
H between 12 m and 45 m;
Q between 0.003 and 0.120 m3/s;
P between 0.3 and 300 kW
One or two nozzles
One or three phase permanent magnet generator
Propeller:
H between 4 m and 11 m;
Q between 0.045 and 0.165 m3/s;
P between 3.0 and 10.0 kW
See web-page: http://www.fuchunind.com
96
MICRO TURBINE COMPACT SYSTEMS
97
MICRO TURBINE COMPACT SYSTEMS
98
MICRO TURBINE COMPACT SYSTEMS
Example: IREM Ecowatt Hydro, Torino, Italy
Pelton and cross flow type turbines
Pelton:
H between 10 m and 350 m;
Q between 0.001 (?) and 0.080 m3/s;
P between 0.5 and 100 kW
Between one and six nozzles
One or three phase permanent magnet generator
Cross flow:
H between 5 m and 60 m;
Q between 0.008 and 1.000 m3/s;
P between 1.0 and 100.0 kW
See web-page: http://www.irem.it/ENG/lines/hydro.html
99
MICRO TURBINE COMPACT SYSTEMS
100
MICRO TURBINE COMPACT SYSTEMS
101
MICRO TURBINE COMPACT SYSTEMS
When ordering packaged systems:
Is the control system included or not?
How much civil works are required?
Warranty period?
Supply of spare parts and delivery time?
Labeling of the control system: English, Chinese, Italian,...?
Easy to operate?
Shipping costs?
Online or telephone support available?
102
ENVIRONMENTAL AND
SOCIAL
CONSIDERATIONS
103
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
Importance:
Requirement (legal in most countries and/or for
financiers)
For macroeconomic cost-benefit analysis
For microeconomic viability of the project
Anticipated irreversible adverse impacts on the
environment may result in the discontinuation of
projects!
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
Main issues:
Loss of natural resources, habitats, biodiversity,
ecosystem services
Alteration of the natural environment and its
consequences
Pollution and environmental degradation during
construction phase
Noise pollution from power house (and other noisy
equipment)
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
Special issues for (large) dams:
Sediments and nutrients are trapped in dams if there
are no low-level outlets
Reduced oxygen levels in water due to decomposing
vegetation in dams
Release of methane and carbon dioxide from rotting
organic matters into the atmosphere
Mercury contamination in dams
High rates of water evaporation in tropical climate may
lead to significantly reduced water levels downstream
Reduced water levels downstream might cause loss of
floodplains and mangrove forests
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
Special issues for (large) dams: (continued)
Seasonal variations of water levels in the river as well
as water temperature are lost through the regulation of
the dams outflow
Change of air flow patterns have an influence on air
quality and subsequently on local flora
Colonization by aquatic plants
Dams provide ideal breeding grounds for disease
vectors
Change of fish habitat from river to lake
Lakes might pose barriers to wildlife migration
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
Questions to be answered by an EIA:
Are mitigation measures for all issues possible?
How much do they cost?
SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
Importance:
Requirement in some countries and for some
financiers
For macroeconomic cost-benefit analysis
For microeconomic viability of the project
Information, communication and consultation with
affected people is essential for a successful project!
People who are angry because they feel their concerns
are ignored may find ways to stop the project.
SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
Main issues and mitigation measures to consider:
Communication, information and consultation
Establish good communications channels with affected
people from the start of the project (and keep complaints
management in place after construction is completed)
Hold open information and consultation meetings for the
affected people at the beginning of the project and in
regular intervals thereafter; involve the affected people in
the project planning
Manage expectations carefully: ensure the local
population benefits from the project but does not create
expectations the project cannot fulfill
SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
Main issues and mitigation measures to consider:
(Continued)
Resettlement:
Negotiate fair deals with communities that have to be
resettled
Transparent decision-making processes and consultations
with the communities are essential
Pay attention to the following:
Land rights (customary and statutory land rights might be
overlapping, people might not have official land titles)
Water rights
Gender equality
Indigenous peoples rights
SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
Main issues and mitigation measures to consider:
(Continued)
Compensation:
For loss of houses and land, livelihoods, cultural/ religious
goods and places, community services
Also consider communities downstream whose livelihoods
might be endangered through changes in the ecosystems
Might include training and initial resources for uptake of
new livelihoods
SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
Main issues and mitigation measures to consider:
(Continued)
Health issues
Loss of cultural heritage sites
Noise pollution
Social disruptions
Large, especially cross-border projects add political
component and issues with water rights and water
usage on a national level
SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
Positive social impacts might include:
Development impulses through access to electricity
Education benefits through access to electricity
Health benefits through access to clean water
SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
The positive and negative impacts must be put
in relation to one another!
SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
Assessment of the Ability and Willingness to Pay for
Electricity:
For electrification of unserved areas, including
communities affected by the hydropower plant
Importance:
Serves to project electricity demand
Informs electricity tariff setting
Projection of electricity sales and income important for the
economic analysis of a project
Projected demand, increase in demand and purpose of
electricity use should inform the grid design
SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
Data to be collected:
Demographic data (population and growth rate, migration
patterns, seasonal variations)
Economic data (livelihoods, economic growth, possibilities
to increase cash income)
Electricity-specific data (types of users: residential/
commercial/ industrial and their relative share; projected
initial and overall connection rate; projected amount of
electricity demanded; projected increase in the electricity
demand over time; types of electrical equipment to be used)
Training needs among the population
INTERRELATION OF EIA AND SIA
Social and environmental impacts are closely
related, especially in developing countries, as people
often depend on the environment for their livelihoods
People who are adversely affected by the project and
feel they do not benefit enough from the project
might find environmental impacts as reasons to stop
the project!
Access to electricity and clean water for communities
affected by the project should be ensured
ENVIRONMENTAL & SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
Conclusions:
The importance of ESIAs must not be underestimated
ESIAs should not be viewed as additional bureaucratic
hurdles to overcome, but as an instrument to inform the
debate about the costs and benefits of a proposed
project and its viability
Impact mitigation costs must be considered in the
economic viability analysis of a project
Local population must participate in the benefits of the
project and not just bear the costs
ENVIRONMENTAL & SOCIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
Conclusions (continued)
Expectations, concerns and grievances of affected
population must be considered and managed carefully;
otherwise conflicts will arise, which is very costly: angry
people might find ways to stop projects
High adverse environmental or social impacts may be a
reason to discontinue a project
But: environmental and social costs should not be
compared to status quo (zero development) but instead
to costs of realistic alternatives
HYDROPOWER CIVIL
DESIGN OPTIONS:
DIFFERENCES,
ADVANTAGES AND
DISADVANTAGES
121
HYDROPOWER PROJECT DESIGN
Characteristic ciphers of hydropower projects
Development factor
Is the ratio of mean river discharge and plant design discharge;
Plant Factor
Is the ratio of the average power load of a plant to its rated capacity; (kW)
Capacity factor
The net capacity factor of a power plant is the ratio of its actual output over a
period of time, to its potential output if it was possible for it to operate at full
nameplate capacity continuously over the same period of time.(kWh)
Availability factor
The availability factor of a power plant is the amount of time that it is able to
produce electricity over a certain time period.
122
HYDROPOWER PROJECT DESIGN
Characteristic ciphers of hydropower projects
Load factor
Load factor for a power plant is the ratio between average load and peak load.
Operational efficiency
Is the ratio of the total electricity produced by the plant during a period of time
compared to the total potential electricity that could have been produced if the
plant operated at 100 percent in the period.
123
HYDROPOWER PROJECT DESIGN
Yield diagram of a hydropower project
124
HYDROPOWER PROJECT DESIGN
Power and energy calculations
Purpose: to estimate annual electricity generation and annual
benefits.
Input parameters:
Available flow
Residual flow
Hydraulic characteristics of the waterway
Tailwater level
Turbine operational characteristics (cut-in and cut-out points)
Turbine efficiency function
Generator efficiency function
Transformer efficiency function
(Excel Spreadsheet)
125
HYDROPOWER PROJECT DESIGN
Plant optimization and design criteria
Hydropower projects can be optimized for different criteria:
Maximum power output;
Minimum electricity generation cost;
Maximum power availability and reliability;
Maximum flexibility;
Provision of grid system services;
Pumped storage;
Other parameters that deem fit.
Depending on optimization objective the structural design will change.
More details in a later session.
126
HYDROPOWER PROJECT DESIGN
Plant optimization and design criteria
Each individual element of a hydropower plant is optimized using
value engineering criteria:
Value engineering (VE) is systematic method to improve the "value"
of goods or products and services by using an examination of
function.
Value, as defined, is the ratio of function to cost. Value can therefore
be increased by either improving the function or reducing the cost.
It is a primary tenet of value engineering that basic functions be
preserved and not be reduced as a consequence of pursuing value
improvements.
(Source: Wikipedia)
127
HYDROPOWER PROJECT DESIGN
Plant design criteria
For design criteria of hydraulic structures refer to:
Hydraulic Design Criteria, Volume 2 of the US Army Corps of
Engineers, 1987
Powerhouse design criteria are mainly governed by the data
provided by the equipment manufacturer.
The electricity grid operator provides design criteria for electrical
equipment.
Other design criteria may apply depending on the project.
128
PRINCIPLES OF GOOD PROJECT LAYOUT DESIGN
When visiting a site for the first time, or watching a topo map,
an initial project layout should be visualized
Logically: Upstream = water in; Downstream = water out
Dam and reservoir or Run-Off River?
Pressure head
High head (h > 50 m)
Medium head (15 m < h < 50 m)
Low head (h < 15 m)
Water availability
General geology
Solid rock
Soil and rock
Soil and sand
Look for good geology for the various structures!
129
PRINCIPLES OF GOOD PROJECT LAYOUT DESIGN
Try to avoid areas of high population density for project design
avoid need for resettlement and lengthy disputes
Try to maximize the hydropower potential of each site with the
layout design. If the potential is more than the power needed
for supply, a stage wise construction can be envisaged.
Integrate environmental considerations (fish ladders,
minimum flow donation, and so on) in your design to avoid
additional cost when these items are required later in the
process
Consider sediment handling to be a serious aspect
Do not omit the bottom outlet at dams and reservoirs
Design with realistic redundancy: black start hydropower plant
instead of diesel generators
Do not save on safety aspects
130
WATERWAY HYDRAULICS
PHYSICAL HYDROPOWER BACKGROUND
Important design aspect: Reducing Hydraulic Losses
Remember:
Hn = net head in m
Gross Head depending on
! Topography
Net Head depending on
! Friction losses
Mountain or valley
Dam, run-off river or
diversion
Pipe diameter/canal dimensions
Pipe/canal roughness
Length of pipe/canal
! Other hydraulic losses
-
Trash rack
Bends
Valves
Net Head???
131
68
WATERWAY HYDRAULICS
Hydraulic losses occur due to water moving over surfaces or
along or against structural elements in the waterway.
132
WATERWAY HYDRAULICS
Losses are caused mainly by the waters viscosity.
Inner friction converts loss energy into
heat,
turbulence, and
sound energy
133
WATERWAY HYDRAULICS
Hydraulic losses typically originate from:
Water intake
Trash rack
Friction losses in open channels
Desilting chamber due to deceleration of water velocity
Pipeline intake, forebay
Friction losses in pipelines
Valves and other fittings
Bends in pipes and channels
Changes in cross section size
Bifurcations and merging y-pieces and similar
Losses in the turbine itself; these are usually included in the
turbine efficiency
Draft tube
Tailrace channel turbulence
134
WATERWAY HYDRAULICS
Calculation of the hydraulic losses hydromechanics
principles
Main sources of hydraulic losses: friction losses in open
channels and pipelines, bend losses and valve losses
Poorly designed structures: also desilting basin losses and
changes in cross section area are significant
good understanding of the hydraulic principles is important
to establish good hydropower designs
135
WATERWAY HYDRAULICS
Generally, hydraulic losses are quantified as loss head hv in [m]
Where
hv,i = loss head resulting from origin i
= loss coefficient, in other literature also named K
v = water velocity
g = earth acceleration constant
Considering individual loss causing components:
Important: use water velocity v where the losses occur!
136
WATERWAY HYDRAULICS
Where to get loss coefficients from?
Established from physical experiments for a multitude of
fittings, intake shapes and surfaces
Good practical guide is Internal Flow Systems by D.S.Miller
(Volume 5 in the BHRA Fluid Engineering Series)
The loss head depends on the discharge through the waterway
and is proportional to the square of the discharge.
Remember:
Q = v * A v = Q/A and v2 = Q2/A2
137
WATERWAY HYDRAULICS
Basic variables for hydraulic calculations
Reynolds Number: Re
= dimensionless cipher to describe similar flow processes in different fluid
flow situations
Kinematic viscosity is temperature dependent See next table
138
WATERWAY HYDRAULICS
139
WATERWAY HYDRAULICS
Basic variables for hydraulic calculations
Froude Number
Is the ratio between inertia and gravity force:
Where
= kinematic viscosity
g = gravity constant
h = water depth
The Froude Number is mainly used in open channel flow calculations.
140
WATERWAY HYDRAULICS
Pipe losses
141
WATERWAY HYDRAULICS
Pipe losses
The formula for friction losses is
Where
hv,r = friction loss
= loss coefficient
L
= length of pipe
dhy = hydraulic diameter (=4 x hydraulic
radius; hydraulic radius rhy = A/Lu)
di = diameter of pipeline
142
WATERWAY HYDRAULICS
The loss coefficient
The loss coefficient is calculated by means of a recursive formula by COLEBROOKWHITE:
Where
= constant factors
C1/C2
according to the following table
Re
= Reynolds number
143
WATERWAY HYDRAULICS
The loss coefficient
For completely filled circular pipelines the loss coefficient is calculated by
Where
k = hydraulic roughness in mm
dhy = hydraulic diameter in mm (!)
For simplicity, can be obtained from the MOODY-Diagram:
144
WATERWAY HYDRAULICS
The MOODY-Diagram
145
WATERWAY HYDRAULICS
Bend losses
Bend losses are calculated by
Values for bend can be obtained from literature, such as Internal Flow Systems by
Miller.
(Note: instead of bend in the following figures the symbol Kb was used but has the same
meaning.)
146
WATERWAY HYDRAULICS
Bend losses
K*b is the basic
coefficient
modified by other
factors considering, e.g.
Reynolds number,
outlet pipe length
etc.
For estimates at design
level it is sufficient to
use K*b straight for in
the above formula.
147
WATERWAY HYDRAULICS
Valve losses
Valve losses are calculated by
Values for valve can be obtained from literature, such as Internal Flow Systems by
Miller.
Here, s and smax are the
opening width; As is the
cross section area.
148
WATERWAY HYDRAULICS
Valve losses
149
WATERWAY HYDRAULICS
Intake losses
Intake losses are calculated with the same formula as above.
Some intake coefficients are given below:
150
WATERWAY HYDRAULICS
Hydraulic Transients - Water Hammer Effect
Water has a mass m = * V
Where
m = mass
= density
V = volume
Closing or opening a valve causes change of velocity
Change of velocity causes an impulse with impulse force
The impulse force shows as pressure change (up or down)
The resulting transient process is known as Water Hammer
The magnitude of pressure rise depends on the time it takes to close a
valve
Generally speaking, it depends on the deceleration rate v/t
151
WATERWAY HYDRAULICS
Hydraulic Transients - Water Hammer Effect
The magnitude of pressure variation in the pipe depends on:
Density of the water or liquid;
Length of the pipeline;
Diameter of the pipeline, which defines the water velocity;
Modulus of elasticity of the pipe wall or tunnel wall;
Difference between initial and final velocity;
Time to reduce the speed from its initial to its final value.
Generally: softer pipe walls lower sound propagation speed in water
slower propagation of the pressure waves.
Higher water velocities greater pressure modifications
152
WATERWAY HYDRAULICS
Hydraulic Transients - Water Hammer Effect
To calculate the pressure rise, various methodologies are applied:
Finite element and finite difference methods;
Characteristics method using simple differential equations
Theory of elastic water column
For rough estimates the formula according to Joukowsky is commonly
used:
153
WATERWAY HYDRAULICS
Where
max ha
a
v
g
TR
ts
= Maximum pressure head from water hammer
= Shock wave propagation speed
= Difference between final and initial velocity
= gravity constant
= reflection time of the wave in the pipe
= time to close the valve
154
WATERWAY HYDRAULICS
Where
berdruck = positive pressure
Unterdruck = negative pressure
Absperramatur = valve
The reflexion time is
calculated by
Where
TL = Running time of the shock wave in one direction
l
= Length of pipeline
a = Propagation speed of sound in the medium, depending on pipe
material and bedding conditions
155
WATERWAY HYDRAULICS
Shock wave propagation speed is depending on the bedding situation and the pipe
material.
The following figure gives an indication for different pipe materials installed
without bedding:
156
WATERWAY HYDRAULICS
To reduce the water hammer effect, different measures can be taken:
Reduce the speed of closing the valve;
Change pipe and bedding material;
Increase the pipe diameter to reduce the flow velocity;
Installation of pressure release valves or bypasses (high risk of
failure!)
Reduce the pipe length;
Installation of an air pressure cushion;
Installation of a surge shaft to reduce the pipe length;
157
DRAWING CONCLUSIONS FROM THE RESULTS,
QUESTION AND ANSWER SESSION
Questions? Comments?
186
THANK YOU FOR YOUR
ATTENTION!
CONTACT
E-mail:
[email protected]Web: http://www.sven-homscheid.com
187
REFERENCES
Magazine Hydro Review Worldwide, edition July - August 2015
https://www.sensefly.com/drones/ebee-rtk.html
www.wikipedia.com
Wasserkraftanlagen; Giesecke; Mosonyi; 2003; ISBN
3-540-44391-6
Hydraulik fuer Bauingenieure; Heinemann/Paul; ISBN
3-519-05082-x
http://www.hydroconnect.at
http://www.wasserradfabrik.de/wasserkraftraeder.html
http://goecke.de/Produkte/
188
