USFS Mission - Tanzania - May 2009 - Water Resources in Tabora and Rukwa - For FRAME
USFS Mission - Tanzania - May 2009 - Water Resources in Tabora and Rukwa - For FRAME
USFS Mission - Tanzania - May 2009 - Water Resources in Tabora and Rukwa - For FRAME
June 2009
Prepared by
Joe Gurrieri
Beverly Young
Environmental Engineer
USDA Forest Service
Northern Region
PO Box 7669
Missoula, MT 59807
Email: [email protected]
Robert Sassor
Water Resources Manager
USDA Forest Service
International Programs
Kigoma, Tanzania
Email: [email protected]
Contents
Acknowledgements........................................................................................................................iii
Acronyms and Abbreviations.........................................................................................................iv
1. Executive Summary....................................................................................................................1
2. Introduction.................................................................................................................................2
2.1 Geographic Context...............................................................................................................2
2.2 Climate...................................................................................................................................3
3. Background and Context: Water Quality....................................................................................5
3.1 Source Water Protection........................................................................................................6
3.2 Water Quality Standards and Monitoring..............................................................................7
4. Background and Context: Hydrogeology....................................................................................9
4.1 Hydrogeologic Setting...........................................................................................................9
4.1.1 Tabora Region: Urambo, Uyui, and Sikonge Districts...................................................9
4.1.2 Rukwa Region: Mpanda District..................................................................................13
5. Field Visits and Observations....................................................................................................15
5.1 Field Visits..........................................................................................................................15
5.2 Observations.......................................................................................................................16
6. Recommendations......................................................................................................................18
6.1. Borehole Drilling................................................................................................................18
6.2 Pump Installation.................................................................................................................18
6.3 Source Protection and Village Water Point Management....................................................19
6.4 Periodic Sanitary Inspections and Water Quality Testing....................................................19
6.5 Technical Capacity Development........................................................................................19
6.6 Tabora Region, Sikonge District..........................................................................................20
6.7 Rukwa Region, Mpanda District.........................................................................................20
Glossary.........................................................................................................................................21
Bibliography..................................................................................................................................22
Appendix 1: Mission Terms of Reference.....................................................................................25
Appendix 2: Mission Itinerary.......................................................................................................27
Appendix 3: Individuals Consulted...............................................................................................34
Appendix 4: Potable Water Standards...........................................................................................36
Appendix 5: Geophysical Survey Techniques...............................................................................38
Appendix 6: Notes from Locations Visited...................................................................................39
Appendix 7: Handpump Documentation......................................................................................50
1. Afridev Deepwell Handpump...............................................................................................50
2. India Mark II Handpump......................................................................................................50
3. India Mark III Deepwell Handpump....................................................................................50
4. NIRA Handpump..................................................................................................................51
5. Vergnet Hydropump HPV 60 / HPV 100..............................................................................52
Appendix 8: Borehole Drilling Project and Contract Design.....................................................53
Credits
Cover photo 2009 Beverly Young
Page ii
Acknowledgements
This mission was seamlessly organized and carried out due to the unflagging efforts of many
people.
First, our gratitude to colleagues at Africare who organized mission logistics and helped ensure
the mission made a maximum impact:
Shidumu Mawe, whose spirited lessons to villages about sanitation and health were
memorable for all of us;
Calvin Meta, who masterfully handled issues as they arose and served as our cultural and
linguistic liaison; and
Africares Field Officers who organized local logistics and will ensure project continuity:
Edward Masawe in Urambo, Linus Salema in Sikonge and Eliya Mgalihya in Mpanda.
Furthermore, we are grateful to District staff who welcomed us to their villages, facilitated
introductions and will ensure that local USAID-sponsored water resource projects will be
properly maintained:
Lucky Mgeni and Faustino Misango, the Acting District Water Engineers for Urambo and
Uyui Districts respectively;
Sikonge District staff, including Paschal Ngunda, the District Water Engineerk, Jafari
Wibonella, Senior Technician for the Water Department, and Severino Kagyabukamo,
Pump Technician; and
Enock Msengi, District Water Engineer for Mpanda.
Finally, our thanks to Rafael and Uledi, Africares drivers, whose good cheer and careful driving
made our long trips enjoyable and safe.
Page iii
Page iv
1. Executive Summary
The US Forest Service (USFS), in conjunction with the US Agency for International
Development (USAID), is working with Africare to provide twelve boreholes in the Tabora and
Rukwa regions in 2009. The purpose of this USFS mission was to visit the villages selected for
an improved water source in order to: inform water scheme design and placement based on best
practices and international water quality standards; increase the capacity of officials and villagers
to implement water and sanitation best practices and manage sustainable water points; promote
health and sanitation related to water source protection; encourage compliance with Tanzanian
law regarding community investments in water schemes and equal gender representation among
water user groups; and promote project sustainability.
The three-week field visit enabled USFS consultants to review existing geologic, climatic,
hydrologic and borehole data, and to conduct hydrogeological analyses and an inventory and
assessment of existing water points. This report details field observations and recommendations
both general to overall water point development and specific to sites visited.
Recommendations for borehole development call first for geophysical surveys to site locations
for drilling two or three exploratory, small diameter boreholes which will increase the probability
of finding an adequate supply of groundwater. Further success will be strengthened by having a
qualified independent supervising hydrogeologist at the drill site. Drilling contracts should use
the language and specifications recommended by the Lake Tanganyika Water Basin staff.
Drilling logs, even those from nonproductive boreholes, represent critical information to be
shared with Africare, the District Water Engineer and the appropriate Water Basin Office.
Groundwater samples for physical and chemical parameters need to be collected at the time of
borehole completion, with bacteriological samples collected and analyzed after the handpumps
are installed. The suitable handpumps for village level operations and maintenance are Nira-85
for shallow wells and Afridev for deepwells. Long-term viability of the developed sources will
be ensured by an adequate source protection area. A fenced area of 30 meter radius around the
borehole or shallow well, with restricted activities within, was recommended to and supported by
the village water committees. Many abandoned shallow wells were observed and should be
properly filled to remove contaminant pathways to the aquifer.
Additional water sector support could be given to these activities to further expand access to
improved water sources and strengthen institutional capacity:
protect and improve existing shallow wells, especially in the Tabora region, which has the
second least access to improved water in Tanzania (WaterAid 2006);
develop institutional capacity to perform microbiological testing;
develop a database to store borehole information;
begin a groundwater mapping program; and
sponsor a technical training workshop on groundwater development.
Page 1
2. Introduction
Safe water is a basic human necessity which is in scarce supply in many parts of Tanzania. The
Tanzanian Government reports that only half the nations rural population has access to a water
source (United Republic of Tanzania, 2002). And despite excellent efforts by a variety of
institutions, over 30% of rural water schemes are nonoperational due to poor maintenance (Ibid).
The Tabora region is one of Tanzanias regions with the least access to improved water sources,
with an estimated 13% of rural households able to access such sources (WaterAid Tanzania
2004). The percentage of households using improved water sources is higher in the Rukwa
Region (48%) (Ibid), although within the Mpanda District many villages still have an insufficient
water supply.
Through generous funding from USAID, the Ugalla Community Landscape Conservation
Project (UCLCP) of Africare will be installing twelve boreholes in the Tabora and Rukwa
regions in June through September 2009. The purpose of this US Forest Service (USFS) mission
was to visit the villages selected for an improved water source in order to: inform water scheme
design and placement based on best practices and international water quality standards; increase
the capacity of ward and village officials and villagers to implement water and sanitation best
practices and manage sustainable water points; promote health and sanitation related to water
source protection; encourage the compliance with Tanzanian law regarding community
investments in water schemes and equal gender representation among water user groups; and
promote project sustainability. Appendix 1 contains the missions terms of reference.
These tasks were accomplished May 17 through June 3 in close collaboration with Africare,
District Water Engineers and representatives of the community-based organization (CBO)
operating in the Mpanda district of Rukwa region named Misitu na Mazingira Mpimbwe
(MIMAMPI). See Appendix 2 for the mission itinerary and Appendix 3 for key contacts made
during the mission.
Tabora Region
Urambo District
o Nsogolo
o Izengabatogilwe
Uyui District
o Utura
Sikonge District
o Utimule
o Msuva villages
o Usega sub-village of Sikonge
Rukwa Region
Mpanda District
o Usense sub-village of
Uruwira
o Kibaoni
o Ilalangulu
o Kikulwe sub-village of
Ikuba
o Makuyugu sub-village
of Mamba
o Majimoto
Page 2
Izenga.
Ilalanguru
2.2 Climate
Water resources are inextricably linked with climate, so the prospect of global climate change
has serious implications for water resources and regional development in Tanzania. Efforts to
provide adequate water resources for the region will confront several challenges, including
population pressure, problems associated with land use such as sanitation, and possible
ecological consequences of local temperature and rainfall changes.
The Tabora and Rukwa regions have a semi-humid tropical climate and receive an annual rainfall
of 800 to 1100 mm (Fig. 2). Mean annual precipitation at the Tabora airport is 1010 mm, with the
majority (~90%) falling during the six-month rainy season between November and April. The
rainfall is bimodal with the wet season between November and May and a dry season in the
months of January and February. A long dry period occurs between June and October. The
amount of rainfall that infiltrates to groundwater varies from 50 to 300 mm/year (Hydrogeologic
Map of Africa).
Forested areas provide a steady supply of surface and groundwater to surrounding areas.
Although the consequences of deforestation on rainfall are difficult to assess in quantitative
terms, deforestation may decrease the amount of water that infiltrates to recharge aquifers and
US Forest Service Technical Assistance Mission
Water Resources in Tabora and Rukwa Regions, Tanzania (May-June 2009)
Page 3
maintain spring flows. The remaining forests in the region are critical to providing a slow,
steady release of water to streams and springs and maintaining a perennial flow, as well as
maintaining recharge to aquifer systems.
Figure 2: Precipitation in southern Africa. (The red line represents the global
average precipitation of 860 mm.)
Page 4
Page 5
districts with the least access in both reports, with Sikonge district, notably, at the bottom of the
list.
Table 1: Water point access in three Districts of Tabora Region.
District/Ward
Per cent of Population
Per cent of households
served by a functional water with access to improved water
point, WaterAid, 2004
(piped or protected source)
Poverty & Human Development
Report, 2005
Urambo
6
14
Uyumbu Ward
2
Uyui
7
11
Mabama Ward
9
Sikonge
3
7
Sikonge Ward
7
Ipole Ward
2
The provision of improved water points alone is not sufficient to supply sustainable access to
safe water. It has been estimated that between 20% and 70% of installed handpumps in SubSaharan Africa are not functioning (UNICEF 2007). The high rate of failure can be attributed to
technological reasons poor construction, high cost of spare parts, inappropriate technology
but also social and institutional factors. This project is attempting to address all of these through
village involvement and ownership, financial capacity building and an appropriate technical
approach including proper borehole development and the specification for handpumps that can
be maintained at a village level.
Page 6
Page 7
water supplies. See Appendix 4 for specifications related to nitrates, fluoride, arsenic and other
contaminants.
Groundwater quality data in the area is sparse but a few reports were acquired as part of a
groundwater investigation in 1991 (Ministry of Water 1991). Turbidity ranged from 2 to 85
NTU, conductivity ranged from 231 to 880 mS/cm, pH ranged from 7.2 to 8.0, alkalinity ranged
from 110 to 400 mg/L, and hardness ranged from 130 to 460 mg/L. There are some wells
particularly in the Mpanda District that are not used because of elevated salinity. The salinity is
probably sourced from the playa deposits in the Rukwa Graben.
Page 8
Page 9
consequence infiltration and aquifer storage is limited. No major faulting has been recognized.
The frequency of rock outcrops and linements are scarce due to erosion which has obliterated
much of the structural evidence. Although the aquifers have a regional occurrence, they respond
variably to pumping, due either to discontinuities or barrier boundaries within the fracture system
being tapped or to the constraints of the low-permeability regolith. These features are commonly
reflected in a significant borehole failure rate and a wide range of yields, despite the apparent
regional uniformity of the basic controls of climate, morphology and geology (Wright & Burgess
1992). The transmissivity of this aquifer is low, on the order of 1 to 100 m2/day. Yields range up
to 8,000 liters/hr in Urambo district but are generally less than 1,000 liters/hr in Sikonge district.
Figure 3: Simplified hydrogeological map of sub-Saharan Africa showing the number of rural
people living on each hydrogeologic setting. Tanzania is dominated by basement rock aquifers.
Shallow groundwater is encountered in sands and gravels of the weathered surface materials and
in sandy layers that underlie ferricrete deposits. Many of the wetlands and hand dug wells in this
area are supported by shallow perched groundwater systems. Deeper aquifers are encountered
within the weathered or fractured bedrock. A hydrogeologic conceptual model for basement rock
aquifers in areas with some relief are shown in Figure 4.
Page 10
Figure 4: Diagrammatic basement complex hydrogeology in an area with some relief. The weathered regolith zone
is thinner on the ridges and thicker in the valleys. Reasonable quantities of water can be obtained from thick saprolite
in valleys, the basal breccia, and from major fault and fracture zones in bedrock.
Sources: A: Acworth, 1987; B: Clark, 1985; and International Association of Hydrogeologists, Briefing Note,
Groundwater and Rural Water Supply in Africa.
Wright & Burgess (1992) list a number of constraints to development of basement aquifers
which include: 1) the frequent high failure rate of boreholes, commonly in the range 10-40%; 2)
shallow groundwater and permeable fractures in the bedrock aquifer component which makes for
susceptibility to surface pollutants and drought; 3) the low storativity of basement aquifers which
Page 11
may cause wells to go dry during sustained drought periods; and 4) aquifer recharge is sensitive
to certain land-use changes.
Basement rock aquifers occur within the weathered residual overburden (the regolith or
saprolite1) and the fractured bedrock. To contain significant aquifers, the weathered profile must
attain a significant areal extent and thickness and have sufficient hydraulic conductivity and
storage to yield groundwater to wells or boreholes. From Fig. 5 it may be seen that these
conditions are only met in the lower weathering zones 'c' and 'd'. The clay rich zone 'b', while
containing significant storage when saturated, normally acts as an aquiclude and groundwater in
zones 'c' and 'd' may be confined by this zone 'b' material. However zone b can also locally be
Figure 5: Vertical profile through crystalline basement rocks showing variation of weathering, permeability and
porosity. Permeability varies with lithology. Zones a and b are derived by in situ weathering of the bedrock and
permeability commonly increases at lower levels due to a lesser development of secondary clay minerals.
Permeability in zones c and d are generally increased as result of weathering (as compared with fresh bedrock)
unless infilled by clay minerals. Permeability of fresh fractured bedrock is dependent on location and degree of
fracturing.
semi-confining or not confining at all leading to contamination migrating from the surface due to
poor land-use practices. The most productive borehole sites are usually those which pass through
1
Page 12
10 m to 15 m of zone 'c' weathering and then intercept fractures in zone 'd.' The fractures produce
a high permeability while the disaggregated zone 'c' material provides a high storage. Wells or
boreholes that penetrate to this depth can usually provide sufficient water to sustain a handpump
(MacDonald and Davies, 2000).
According to Acworth (1987), the low relief basement rock areas of Tanzania have an extensive
saprolite zone that extends into the area previously occupied by the zone d fractured material.
The reduction in relief has tended to reduce the rate of groundwater flow. This, in turn, causes
reduced chemical solution and the formation of interstitial clay platelets which result in lower
values of hydraulic conductivity with consequent lower yielding wells and a greater chance of
drilling dry wells.
Comparatively little structural information is available for basement rock aquifers. Electrical
resistivity soundings are useful to calculate the depth of weathering, although the exact location
of the borehole sites is sometimes not critical. In general, sites for dug wells or boreholes should
be chosen towards the middle or toe of the slope where the depth of weathering and saturated
material is maximized. Dug wells, possibly enhanced by collectors or boreholes fitted with hand
pumps, are appropriate to exploit the groundwater resource. The low ability of the aquifer to
transmit groundwater through its entire thickness causes vertical drainage from the overlying
material to become important when development takes place.
Page 13
Page 14
Village
Nsogolo
Izengabatogwile
District
Urambo
Urambo
Ward
Uyumbu
Uyumbu
PopuLation
4,000
2,326
Households
675
281*
Utura
Utimule
Msuva
Uyui
Sikonge
Sikonge
Mabama
Ipole
Ipole
5,000
2,778
2,839
Usega (subvillage)
Sikonge
Sikonge
1,200
Usense
Mpanda
Uruwira
833
Kibaoni
Ilalanguru
Kikulwe (subvillage)
Mpanda
Mpanda
Mpanda
Kibaoni
Kibaoni
Usevya
834+
3,000
1,080
428
Makuyugu(subvillage
)
Mpanda
Mamba
3,253
510
Majimoto
Mpanda
Mamba
13,623
1,753
Distance or
time for
collecting
water
Charge for
Water, per 20
liter bucket,
TZS
5 km in dry
season
~ 30-40
minutes
roundtrip
200
150,000
110,000
50,000
70,000
4 mile round
trip
180
Water Fund
Reserve,
TZS
4 hours/day
3 hours/day
3 hours/day
(2.3 miles
away)
3-4
hours/day
80,000
(able people
will
contribute
5000
TSH/year)
800,000
1,066,890
760,000
500,000
710,000
20
50 (nonhandicapped)
100
3000/HH/yr
20
1000/HH/yr
(with plan to
raise to
3000/HH/yr)
20
* notes show that there are 43 households in subvillage to be served by the improved water point
+ this population was given as those able to work, not entire village population
Evaluations of existing water sources were made for background information and then a
proposed borehole site was located with Global Positioning System (GPS) for further
geophysical investigation in the next phase of the project. Table 3 lists the GPS locations for the
proposed sites. Due to the topography of the villages and poor surface water quality, groundwater
is considered the best choice for development in these areas. A few sites had year-round, waterUS Forest Service Technical Assistance Mission
Water Resources in Tabora and Rukwa Regions, Tanzania (May-June 2009)
Page 15
table springs (Utimule and Msuva) which might be future candidates for a powered-pumping
system if the village and local officials have the maintenance and financial capacity for operating
a more technically challenging and expensive pumping system.
Table 3: GPS Coordinates for Proposed Borehole Sites
Village
Region
District
Ward
Nsogolo
Izengabatogwile
Utura
Utimule
Msuva
Usega
Usense
Kibaoni
Ilalanguru
Kikulwe
Makuyugu
Majimoto
Tabora
Tabora
Tabora
Tabora
Tabora
Tabora
Rukwa
Rukwa
Rukwa
Rukwa
Rukwa
Rukwa
Urambo
Urambo
Uyui
Sikonge
Sikonge
Sikonge
Mpanda
Mpanda
Mpanda
Mpanda
Mpanda
Mpanda
Uyumbu
Uyumbu
Mabama
Ipole
Ipole
Sikonge
Uruwira
Kibaoni
Kibaoni
Usevya
Mamba
Mamba
S 0707.127 E 03108.346
S 0704.351 E 03113.740
5.2 Observations
All villages had limited, if any, reasonable access to improved water points. Traditional
hand-dug wells are the current sources for most villagers, especially in the Tabora region,
and most of these had seasonal scarcity. Both water quantity and water quality were
significant issues for these villages. Women and children are spending up to 4 hours per
day collecting water.
Africare and MIMAMPI staff has done considerable work with village executive and
water committees to sensitize the community and develop their capacity to manage a new
water point. In most, if not all cases, the villages have land management plans and will
be able to control activities in the borehole protection area.
The shallow hand dug wells will continue to be an important source of water for many
villagers. Most of these water sources are in poor condition and are compromised by
poor sanitation and source water protection practices.
Africare, MIMAMPI and District Water Engineers have begun the discussion with
villagers of establishing Water Funds. However, it appeared in some situations that
villagers do not have a good understanding of how much it costs to maintain a pump.
Most villages had inadequate reserves for parts, tools and technician costs. The Sikonge
district has a standard of 2 million TZS for a reserve water account balance. The Urambo
District Water Engineer encouraged a balance of 4 million TZS. MIMAMPI has a
standard for villages contributing 800,000 TZS towards the water project, which is based
on the National Water Policy which requires villages to contribute 5% of the cost of a
water project. Work is needed to ensure that project villages increase the balances of their
Water Funds.
Numerous abandoned wells, both traditional and improved, were observed; these act as
potential contaminant pathways to the aquifer. The USFS staff emphasized during field
visits the importance of properly closing these wells, for both health and safety reasons.
Page 16
Page 17
6. Recommendations
6.1. Borehole Drilling
i.
ii.
iii.
iv.
v.
vi.
vii.
Select the appropriate pump, working with the DWE, to ensure compatibility with
borehole or shallow well depth, yet focusing on those considered appropriate for villagelevel operated maintenance (VLOM). The Afridev pump is probably the best for deep
boreholes and Nira-85 for shallow wells. For the specific needs of those individuals with
disabilities in the Usega sub-village, consider installing a foot-operated pump such as the
Vergnet Hydropump.
Page 18
ii.
iii.
iv.
v.
vi.
ii.
iii.
Develop institutional capacity to perform microbiological testing for total coliform and
E. coli and basic chemical parameters within the Mpanda district and Tabora town. There
are several portable field sampling kits which can be powered by AC power supply, 12V
DC battery or a vehicle cigarette lighter.
Institute twice yearly (if possible) microbiological testing and annual nitrate testing when
laboratory facilities become available. Consider acquiring conductivity meters for
Rukwa region due to issues of salinity in the groundwater.
Develop an operations and maintenance program that includes periodic sanitary
inspections of developed water points. MacDonald outlines a basic inspection form in
the book Developing Groundwater: A Guide for Rural Water Supply.
iv.
Page 19
ii.
iii.
iv.
Consider casing-off the salt bearing playa deposits for boreholes drilled in the Rukwa rift
valley (Mpanda division). This will reduce the likelihood of developing a well with high
salinity, as well as reduce the likelihood of bacterial contamination from shallow sources.
The Mkukuba River flowing off the Ufipi Escarpment has a large, perennial flow. It is
now used to generate power for the local Mission. Efforts should be made to investigate
the water supply potential of this river.
Makuyugu sub-village needs to create its own water committee. Currently the Mamba
village water committee is serving this role.
Page 20
Glossary
Annular: shaped like a ring.
Aquiclude: impermeable beds of geologic material that hinder or prevent groundwater
movement.
Aquifer: A rock formation that is sufficiently porous and permeable to be useful for water
supply.
Borehole: A cylindrical hole (usually greater than 20 m deep and less than 0.5 m in diameter)
constructed to allow groundwater to be abstracted from an aquifer.
Graben: a depressed block of land bordered by parallel faults. Graben is German for ditch.
Groundwater: The name given to water stored in an aquifer in pore spaces or fractures in rocks
or sediments.
Hydrology: The study of groundwater.
Permeability: Generally, the term is used loosely to mean the ease with which a rock or soil can
transmit groundwater. However, the term also has a precise definition: the ease with which a rock
can transmit any fluid under an unequal pressure.
Regolith: layer of loose rock resting on the bedrock that constitutes the surface of most land.
Saprolite: a deposit of clay and disintegrating rock that is found in its original place.
Water point: The point at which water is intended to emerge from a public, improved water supply,
such as a tap or handpump.
Water table: The upper surface of a groundwater body in an unconfined aquifer. It can be
measured by the static water level in a well or borehole in an unconfined aquifer.
Transmissivity: A measure of how much water can be transmitted to a pumping well.
Page 21
Bibliography
Acworth, R. I., 1987. The development of crystalline basement aquifers in a tropical
Environment. Quarterly Journal of Engineering Geology, Vol. 20, pp. 265-272.
Bartram J, Corrales L, Davison A, Deere D, Drury D, Gordon B, Howard G, Rinehold A, Stevens
M., 2009. Water safety plan manual: step-by-step risk management for drinking-water
suppliers. Geneva: World Health Organization.
Calow, R., Macdonald, A., Nicol, A., Robins, N., Kebede, S., 2002. The struggle for water,
drought, water security and rural livelihoods. British Geological Survey Commissioned Report,
CR/02/226N, 74pp.
Carl Bro International a/s, 2001. Siting of 35 boreholes in Umutara Province (Bugaragara,
Rukara and Gabiro Districts). Final Report, Volume I and II.
Clark L., 1885. Groundwater abstraction from Basement Complex areas of Africa. Q. J. eng
Geol. London, 1985, Vol. 18, pp. 25-34.
Directorate of Water Development, 2002. Proposal for mapping of groundwater resources.
Entebbe, Uganda.
Foundation Connect International, 2004. Borehole and hand pump implementation, operation
and maintenance: A manual for field staff of NGOs. In collaboration with WES Consultants
(Uganda).
Geology of Tanzania, 2005. Tanzania: Opportunities for Mineral Resource Development.
Harvey,P., May 2007 Handpump data from Rural Water Supply Network. UNICEF Zambia
http://www.rwsn.ch/prarticle.2005-10-25.9856177177/prarticle.2005-1026.9228452953/prarticle.2009-03-09.1365462467 (accessed on June 11, 2009).
Hydrogeologic Map of Africa,
http://www.sigafrique.net/datawebmaster/doc/Carte_Hydro_Afrique.pdf (Accessed on June 10,
2009)
International Association of Hydrogeologists. Briefing Note, Groundwater and Rural Water
Supply in Africa.
Kaliba, A. R. M., 2002. Participatory Evaluation of Community-Based Water and Sanitation
Programs: The Case of Central Tanzania. Kansas: Kansas State University
Kassenga, G.R., and R.R. Mato, 2008. Arsenic contamination levels in drinking water sources
in mining areas in Lake Victoria Basin, Tanzania, and its removal using stabilized ferralsols.
International Journal of Biological and Chemical Sciences Vol. 2 (4) 2008: pp. 389-400
US Forest Service Technical Assistance Mission
Water Resources in Tabora and Rukwa Regions, Tanzania (May-June 2009)
Page 22
MacDonald, A. M. and Davies, J., 2000. A brief review of groundwater for rural water supply in
sub-Saharan Africa. Technical Report WC/00/33, Overseas Geology Series.
MacDonald, A., Davies, J., Calow, R., and Chilton, J., 2005. Developing Groundwater: A
Guide for Rural Water Supply. ITDG Publishing.
Mjengera, H.J. and Mkongo, G.B. Occurrence of Fluoride in Water Sources and Water
Defluoridation in Tanzania. Ministry of Water, Dar es Salaam, Tanzania
http://www.maji.go.tz/modules/documents/index.php?
action=downloadfile&filename=OCCURRENCE OF
Mjengera, H.J, 2007. Water Quality and Health Aspects. Ministry of Water Dar es Salaam,
Tanzania.
North Carolina Wildlife. Factsheet on Wildlife and Tobacco Pesticides.
http://www.ncwildlife.org/pg07_wildlifespeciescon/pg7f2b7.htm (Accessed on June 10, 2009)
Research on Poverty Alleviation, 2005. Poverty and Human Development Report.
http://www.repoa.or.tz/documents_storage/PHDR_2005_Chap2.pdf (Accessed June 8, 2009)
Tindimugaya, C. 2004, People-centered approaches to water and environmental sanitation,
groundwater mapping and its implications for rural water supply coverage in Uganda. 30th
WEDC International Conference, Vientiane, Lao PDR.
United Nations. Millennium Development Goals.
http://www.un.org/millenniumgoals/environ.shtml (Accessed on June 16, 2009).
United Republic of Tanzania, Office of the Vice President, 2005. National Strategy for Growth
and Reduction of Poverty.
(http://www.povertymonitoring.go.tz/documents/mkukuta_main_eng.pdf; Accessed June 6,
2009)
United Republic of Tanzania Ministry of Water, 2006. Water Sector Development Program,
Program Implementation Manual. Volume 5: Environmental and Social Management
Framework. http://www.maji.go.tz (Accessed June 6, 2009)
van Dongen, P., and M., Woodhouse, 1994, Finding Groundwater: A project managers guide to
techniques and how to use them, International Bank for Reconstruction and Development/The
World Bank,Washington, DC, USA.
WaterAid Tanzania, 2004. WaterAid Tanzania Policy Programme Budget Analysis Workshop.
Dar es Salaam, Tanzania.
WaterAid Tanzania, 2006. Water Point Mapping Report. Unpublished internal report. \
Page 23
Page 24
IR3: Conservation enterprises generate increased and equitable benefits from sustainable use of
natural resources
In Financial Year 2008 /2009, USAID provided a grant of $ 321,000 ($221,000 for UCLCP and 100,000 for
MIMAMPI) to Africare for the implementation water project within selected UCLCP and MIMAMPI
villages. The target is to establish 12 water sources (7 UCLCP and 5 MIMAMPI). The sources are expected
to be deep well, gravity flow or rainwater catchments depending on the findings from hydrological study.
MIMAMPI (Misitu na Mazingira Mpimbwe) is a community-based organization formed in Mpimbwe
division, Mpanda district with the goal of managing forest and other natural resources in Mpimbwe.
US Forest Service through its Program Management Specialist Ms. Catherine Hughes visited the
proposed sites to be established water sources in Mpimbwe division.
2.0 Things to Accomplish
2.1 Conduct hydrological survey in sampled 12 villages
The overall objective of this survey will be to establish durable, affordable and environmental friendly
water sources in sampled 12 villages (5 MIMAMPI and 7 UCLCP). The survey will focus on the
following tasks:
(a) Determine available water sources in sampled villages
The team in collaboration with local community will determine available water sources (gravity flow,
deep well, rainwater catchments etc) in area selected by the local community. Incase the selected area will
US Forest Service Technical Assistance Mission
Water Resources in Tabora and Rukwa Regions, Tanzania (May-June 2009)
Page 25
not have good quality of water source (quality and quantity of water), the team can have chance of
choosing another location in the same village.
(b) Prioritize potential water sources
Having knowing the available potential water sources in a particular location, the team will make a
priority of water sources basing on Environmental Appraisal Reports that will be done prior the
Hydrology team to intervene in. The Environmental Appraisal Reports will suggest areas that are suitable
for deep wells construction using criteria {areas away from sewage disposal, artisanal mines drainage,
e.g. mercury etc}
(c) Water sources management
In order to ensure the proposed water sources are sustainable, the team should recommend the best water
sources management approach.
3.0 Expected Outputs.
The following outputs need to be accomplished in order to achieve the set survey objectives.
(a) A list of potential water sources in a surveyed village
(b) Preference of water sources in each location/ village
(c) Specific location (GPS) to establish water source (for the case of deep well)
(d) Cost of establishing preferred water source
(e) The best water sources management approach in each location/ village
All outputs should be documented in a report submitted in electronic format (MS Word) no later than a
week after the end of the survey in Tabora.
4.0 Area.
The area to be surveyed includes 5 villages (Kibaoni, Ilalanguru, Ikuba, Mamba and Majimoto) proposed
by MIMAMPI and 7 UCLCP villages in Mpanda (1), Urambo (2), Sikonge (3) and Uyui (1).
5.0 Methodology
The survey is expected to be planned and conducted in collaboration with UCLCP field staff.
The proposed methodology should be participatory and The US Forest Service Officials should be as a
facilitator.
The USFS Officials will be required to work with respective local community and project staff to
guarantee effective data collection. During this collaboration, the project staff are expected to receive
hands on experience and knowledge on hydrological survey.
Page 26
Activity
Individuals Met
Arrival in Tabora
Meeting with Africare
1230
1400
1530
1600
1630
Tuesday, May 19, 2009: Nsogolo and Izengabatogilwe Villages (Urambo District)
0810
0930
1000
1345
1420
1500
1600
Page 27
1000
1100
1430
0900
0915
Travel to Utimule
1000
1100
1200
1400
Page 28
1515
1015
1115
1400
1530
Saturday, May 23, 2009: Usega sub-Village of Sikonge Village (Sikonge District)
0930
0945
1130
1300
1325
1345
1540
Page 29
1600
1730
1900
Arrive in Mpanda
Report writing
Dinner with Africare staff
Monday, May 25, 2009: Usense sub-Village of Uruwira Village (Mpanda District)
0840
0920
1120
1245
1430
1500
Depart Majimoto
1245
1400
Page 30
1500
Depart Majimoto
1030
1300
1530
Thursday, May 28, 2009: Kikulwe sub-Village of Ikuba Village (Mpanda District)
0900
Depart Majimoto
1000
1045
1400
1445
Depart Majimoto
Page 31
0930
0950
1145
1200
1235
1300
1320
1350
1435
1520
1015
Page 32
1150
1300
1530
Report Write-up
Report Write-up
Check-in at Dar es Salaam International
Airport; return flight to the US
*Titles and contact information for individuals in these lists are contained in Appendix 3.
US Forest Service Technical Assistance Mission
Water Resources in Tabora and Rukwa Regions, Tanzania (May-June 2009)
Page 33
www.africare.org
Huruna Juma
Kalunkumya
Africare
Water Technician (Mpanda
Region) (Short-term)
Shidumu Mawe
Africare
Project Coordinator, Tabora and
Rukwa Regions
Edward Masawe
Africare
Field Conservation Officer
(Urambo)
E-mail address:
[email protected]
Phone numbers:
+255-26-260-4907 (Fax,
Business)
+255-26-260-4906 (Business)
Work address:
Swetu Street
Tabora, Tanzania
Calvin Meta
Africare
Monitoring & Evaluation Officer
Eliya Mgalihya
Linus Salema
Linus Salema
Africare
Africare
Field Conservation Officer (Mpanda) Field Conservation Officer
(Sikonge)
Africare
E-mail address: [email protected] E-mail addresses:
Field Conservation Officer
[email protected]
(Sikonge)
Phone numbers:
[email protected]
+255-26-260-4906 (Business)
Phone number:
Phone numbers:
+255-787-933-218 (Cell)
Work address:
+255-784-775-595 (Business)
Swetu Street, Tabora, Tanzania
John Stephen
Africare Tanzania
Senior Programs Manager
E-mail address:
[email protected]
Phone numbers:
+255-22-266-7242; +255-22-2667086 (Business)
Work address:
Galu Street Plot No. 116,
Ada Estate, P. O. Box 63187
Dar es Salaam, Tanzania
Page 34
Lucky Mgeni
Enock Msengi
Paschal Ngunda
E-mail address:
[email protected]
E-mail address:
[email protected]
Faustino Misango
Jafari Wibonella
Senior Technician, Water Department,
Sikonge District
E-mail address:
[email protected]
Work address:
PO Box 70, Sikonge, Tanzania
Other
Benard
Chikarabhani
Tanganyika Basin Office
Hydrologist
Dick Mlimuka
E-mail address:
[email protected]
E-mail addresses:
[email protected]
[email protected]
Michael Sungula
Ben Taylor
Ndyamukama
Muganyizi
WaterAid
WaterAid Tanzania
Phone numbers:
+255-22-270-1609 (Business)
Phone numbers:
+255-766-709-890 (Business)
Page 35
Table 5: The chemical and physical limits for quality of drinking water supplies
No. Name of Constituent
Symbol
Units
Limits
Toxic
1
Lead
Pb
mg/l
0.01
2
Arsenic
As
mg/l
0.05
3
Selenium
Se
mg/l
0.05
4
Chromium
Cr
mg/l
0.05
5
Cyanide
Cn
mg/l
0.20
6
Cadmium
Cd
mg/l
0.05
7
Barium
Ba
mg/l
1.00
8
Mercury
Hg
mg/l
0.001
9
Silver
Ag
mg/l
Not mentioned
Affecting Human Health
1
Fluoride
F
mg/l
1.5 - 4.0
2
Nitrate
NO3
mg/l
10 - 75
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
Organoleptic
Color
Turbidity
Taste
Odor
Salinity and Hardness
pH
Total Filterable Residue
Total Hardness
Calcium
Magnesium
Magnesium + Sodium
sulphate
Sulphate
Chloride
mg/l
mg/l
-
15 - 50
5 - 25
Not objectionable
Not objectionable
CaCO3
Ca
Mg
Mg-Na2
mg/l
mg/l
mg/l
mg/l
mg/l
6.5 9.2
500 - 2000
500 - 600
75 - 300
50 - 100
500 - 1000
SO4
Cl
mg/l
mg/l
200 - 600
200 - 800
Less-toxic Metals
2
This table was extracted from the Tanzania Standard TZS 789:2008.
Page 36
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
Iron
Manganese
Copper
Zinc
Fe
Mn
Cu
Zn
Organic Pollution of
Natural Origin
BODs( 5 days)
O2
PV (Oxygen abs. KMnO4) O2
Ammonium
NH3
Total Nitrogen Exclusive
Nitrate
mg/l
mg/l
mg/l
mg/l
1.0
0.5
3.0
15.0
mg/l
mg/l
mg/l
mg/l
6.0
20
2.0
1.0
mg/l
2.0
mg/l
0.5
mg/l
0.002
21
22
23
Surfactants ABS
(Alkyl Benxyl
Sulphonates)
Organic matter as carbon
in chloroform extract)
Phenolic substances as
phenol
Limit
0.1 Bq/l
0.1 Bq/l
Page 37
Hydrogeological
Environment
Unconsolidated sediments
Consolidated sediments
Sediments fresh/salt water
Volcanics
Basement depth to bedrock
Basement faults/fractures
++ very suitable + suitable
Resistivity
Resistivity
Sounding
Profiling
++
+
+
+
++
+
+
O
++
+
+
++
O not very suitable
Seismic
Refraction
+
+
O
O
++
++
Electromagnetics
O
O
+
+
+
++
Very Low
Frequency
+
O
O
O
+
++
Page 38
Page 39
government office which is dry; 3) a functioning surface well near a home; 4) a functioning
concrete ring well not far from the school; and 6) a location proposed by WaterAid for a borehole
which is now also a surface well.
1) Proposed Borehole Site (S 0515.768 E 03216.809)
This site is located within a forest which is centrally-located between the eastern and
western portions of the community; it is also not far from the school and local
government offices, making it a politically attractive location for a well.
2) Dry Well (S 0515.743 E 03216.869)
This well was dug near the local government office in 1967 and went dry in the 1980s.
USFS recommendation: the hole should be filled to avoid the contamination of
ground water through the disposal of trash, etc. The village agreed to do so.
3) Functioning Surface Well (S 0515.828 E 03216.610)
This is an uncovered surface well located near a home. The surface of the water is
approximately 7-8 meters below the ground, and plastic bottles and other debris float in
the well. This well dries in the dry season and people reported having to walk up to 5 km
to collect water during those months.
4) Functioning Shallow Well (S 0515.181 E 03217.384)
Community members indicated that the quality of the water from this well is superior to
other wells in Izenga. The well is lined with concrete rings; while those rings show
cracks, the cracks do not appear to encompass the circumference of the well and therefore
it is hoped that outside contamination will not leak in.
The well is partially covered, but the pump was vandalized and is no longer attached to
the well. It is located within walking distance to the school.
USFS recommendation: This well should be rehabilitated, including covering the
well and installing a new pump. A government representative suggested that the
Urambo District Council will make this investment in the community.
5) Proposed WaterAid Borehole Location (S 0515.050 E 03217.296)
This site was identified as a possible borehole by WaterAid and currently hosts a shallow
surface well which is approximately 1.5 meters deep. Villagers are able to collect limited
amounts of water from this well in September and October. This well currently serves
approximately 20 households. It may be a good location for a well, but is likely too far
from the rest of Izenga to make it a feasible choice for a borehole.
The two feasible sites for the borehole are: the one in the woods and the ring well. While the
location in the woods would be more centrally located, the ring well site may be more likely to
supply a sufficient quantity of water. The Acting District Water Engineer prefers digging a new
borehole fifty meters from the existing ring well.
Page 40
Page 41
Page 42
This well is perennial and the water quality is considered to be high. The location may,
however, be situated too closely to latrines, and it may be difficult to control the activities
(including the use of fertilizers) on adjacent land.
3) Third Proposed Borehole Site (S 0549.778 E 03244.616)
This is the site recommended by the USFS and approved by a consensus of villagers in
attendance. The site is situated between the primary and secondary schools in a grove of
eucalyptus trees, and is approximately 40 m from the nearest owned land, which has been
designated as agricultural land. The nearest home would be more than 100 m away.
A functioning well on this site may be able to serve 60-70% of Msuva residents. A nearby
gravel pit may serve as a groundwater recharge basin to enhance the sustainability of the
water source.
USFS recommendations: the gravel quarry must be protected from drainage and
water-contaminating activities; consider screening the shallow ferricrete layer in
addition to the lower aquifer, but only if the nearby gravel quarry can be
significantly protected from contaminating the water table.
Usega Sub-Village of Sikonge Village (Sikonge Ward, Sikonge District, Tabora Region)
While a variety of locations were visited in Usega, only one was considered a feasible location
for a borehole. In addition, two other wells were visited and recommendations were made to
improve their integrity.
1) Functioning Shallow Well (S 0537.969 E 03244.896)
This well was constructed in 2003 and consists of concrete rings to a depth of 5 meters;
water is accessed using a NIRA AF 85 hand pump. A pipe directs overflow water into a
pond in which tilapia fish are grown. There are many threats to the integrity of the water
in this well, including: proximity to fish ponds, only one of which is lined with concrete
bricks; nearby agriculture, including goats; the degeneration of the well apron; and an
access hatch which was crudely cut into the lid of the well which allows a variety of
contaminants to enter, including backsplash from the hand pump.
The static water level is represented by the level of water in nearby fishponds, which
have an approximate SWL of 2-3 feet. People drink water from this pump, but consider it
to have elevated hardness.
2) Surface Well (S 0538.062 E 03244.974)
This surface well is poorly situated, located near maize fields (on which fertilizers are
typically used) and in an area that floods in the rainy season.
USFS Recommendation: reroute the drainage around this well or move the well
uphill.
Page 43
Usense sub-Village of Uruwira Village (Uruwira Ward, Mpanda District, Rukwa Region)
Usense is an isolated sub-village located between the Msaginia Forest Reserve, the Mpanda
Forest Reserve, the Mulele Game Controlled Area and the Mulele Hills Forest Reserve. The
nearest school is reported to be five miles from the sub-village; Usense is in the process of
gaining village status.
Villagers present at the meeting agreed that each individual will contribute 5,000 TSH per year to
the water fund, in addition to a fee of 100 TSH per twenty liters of water collected. The villages
water fund is currently only 80,000 TSH.
Eight boreholes were drilled in the region in the 1980s, all of which hit hard rock at between 7080 meters. The nearest of these boreholes to Usense is approximately 4 km away.
The villages water committee consists of nine people, four women and six men. Africare
suggested adding another female member to that committee.
Two technicians from this village will be trained: one man and one woman.
1) Surface Well (S 0630.058 E 03121.538)
This perennial well is 6 meters deep, roughly 4 meters in circumference and has a static
water level of ~70-100 cm. The well has been a primary water supply for the community
since 1973; today it serves an estimated 50% of Usenses 883 inhabitants. The well was
originally a spring, called Kabajungu bubbling spring. This source is a two-mile walk for
some community members.
2) Proposed Borehole Site (S 0629.607 E 03121.713)
This site is located near where Usenses school will be constructed later this year. The
village agreed to protect the well from contaminants, including a buffer zone of 30 meters
from the school and latrines.
Page 44
Page 45
should a borehole be drilled here, Africares Water Technician will ensure that it is shifted
an additional 7 meters from the footpath.
3) Current Borehole (S 0707.375 E 03108.368)
This borehole was installed in 1989 and is located less than 1 kilometer from the
proposed sites for the new borehole. The well is 70 meters deep and villagers like the
taste of the water it produces; people are reported to travel from far away for this water. A
seepage pit next to the borehole is a direct conduit for contamination into the
groundwater. Fetching water from this site takes three hours round-trip for some
community members.
4) Mirumba Village Spring (S 0705.765 E 03104.530)
This spring serves as the primary source of water for the 1,340 inhabitants (263
households) of the Mirumba village; additionally, the village has two hand-dug wells
which also never dry. Villagers believe the spring is protected by a female spirit named
Wamwelu. Villagers drink the water and some do so without boiling it first. The site is an
example of how spring source protection should be done.
Forests in a nearby catchment have been conserved at the behest of the Regional
Commissioner, in part to protect the water in this spring. Villagers pay 2,000 TSH per
household per year to access this water.
USFS Recommendations: water fund monies should be used to improve the sanitation of
the current borehole and limit sources of contamination, including cleaning the area
around the pump and creating a buffer zone with trees and flowers; fill-in the seepage pit
with large boulders, prevent soil from collecting on top of the pit and protect the pit from
becoming a drainage for other surface water in the community.
Kikulwe sub-Village of Ikuba Village (Usevya Ward, Mpanda District, Rukwa Region)
The Kikulwe sub-village of Ikuba is comprised of approximately 1,080 people (180 households)
of the Sukumu tribe. This sub-village is located in a very remote region; current water sources
include two seasonal rivers and, during the dry season, hand-dug wells in those riverbeds, which
are over three hours away from most Kikulwe households.
The borehole will be managed by the Kikulwe water committee, which has currently raised
760,000 TSH for its water fund.
1) Proposed Borehole Site (S 0704.290 E 03113.712)
This central location of the sub-village is very far from the nearest home. Neither
pesticides nor fertilizers are used on the land. It seems an ideal location in terms of
borehole protection. This site is approximately 2.5 miles from the nearest river source.
USFS Recommendation: a fence should be built around this borehole to prevent
cattle from grazing on land within a 30 meter buffer zone.
Page 46
Page 47
Water Engineer reported that this water received unacceptable results in a water quality
test (conducted above the point where the water is collected and piped to the turbine in a
300 meter pipeline). The flow of water in the river leading to this turbine fluctuates very
little throughout the year.
USFS Recommendation: Consider water treatment systems so water from the
hydroelectric plant may be used as a water point for the area.
Page 48
Page 49
Page 50
domain pump defined by Indian Standards and RWSN specifications. This pump requires special
skills for installation and has good potential for community based maintenance (VLOM).
Designed for water depth of 20 - 45 m
Approximate discharge: 0.9 cubic meters per hour
o Pump performance (basis 50 full strokes /minute):
50mm cylinder setting at 45m: Capacity 0.222 litres/stroke, Output 800
litres/hour
63.5mm cylinder setting at 30m: Capacity 0.375 litres/stroke, Output 1125
litres/hour
Stainless Steel pump rods/riser for water of pH>6.5 or iron content>1 ppm
Many components are the same as the India Mark II Pump
Cylinder assembly is different than Mark II -- allows for the plunger and valve
assemblies to be repaired more easily without lifting the riser main
Mark III is also different in that its riser pipe 65 mm
Bureau of Indian Standard Specifications IS-13056: 1991
Minimum diameter well: 100 mm
Most, if not all, India Mark III pumps are manufactured in India
The India Mark III/VLOM 50 is a redesign of the India Mark III (newly designed cylinder)
Lifts water from a depth of 20 - 45 m
Discharge: 0.6 cubic meters per hour
Benefits over previous India Mark designs include: 50 mm riser makes lowers the cost,
cylinder assembly changes mean that no tools are required for valve maintenance
Minimum diameter well: 100 mm
The India Mark III/VLOM 65 is a deep well pump in the India Mark III family
Recommended for water depth of 20 - 45 m
Minimum well diameter: 125mm
Approximate discharge: 0.9 cubic meters per hour
GI riser pipe: 65mm
4. NIRA Handpump
The Nira AF-85 Pump is a direct action pump for low lift wells. It uses a buoyant pump rod that
helps to reduce the forces on the handle. It is designed for heavy-duty use, serving communities
of 300 persons. The maximum recommended lift is 15 m. The Nira AF-85 is fully corrosion
resistant. It is easy to install and has excellent potential for community-based maintenance
(VLOM). The Nira AF-85 pump is not in the public domain. For specifications and information,
it is necessary to contact the manufacturer.
Manufactured in Finland, Ghana and Tanzania.
Approximate maximum capacity: 3.6 cubic metres per hour
Suction height approximately 12m (without bottom valve -- 4m)
Brochure for NIRA pumps in Africa can be found at: http://www.nira.info/service.cntum?
pageId=118193
US Forest Service Technical Assistance Mission
Water Resources in Tabora and Rukwa Regions, Tanzania (May-June 2009)
Page 51
Page 52
Page 53