Levacor Case
Levacor Case
Levacor Case
into the circulatory system. Patients must wear a battery pack and
electric controller that is strapped close to the body.
The first human to receive a Levacor was a 67-year-old male who
took part in the feasibility trials in March, 2006, in Thessaloniki,
Greece. The patient was able to climb stairs 50 days after the
procedure and is currently living at home. WorldHeart (and
LaunchPoint) is also working with the University of Pittsburgh to
develop an even smaller version of the device for babies, only 22mm
in diameter and 43mm in length.
"[The Levacor] is an elegant and efficient-looking design, one that is
compact and bio-compatible," observes MDDI's co-editor, Erik
Swain. "It's a real contrast to the public perception of the previous
artificial hearts or heart pumps, such as the Jarvik-7."
Improvements Bring Profits
Doctors and patients aren't the only ones who are banking on
sleeker, less-obtrusive implanted heart pumps such as the Levacor.
Analysts are starting to note that demand for more comfortable,
longer-lasting heart-pump devices will start to risemeaning there
could be increased profits for the companies that make them.
In late December research notes, First Albany analyst Jason Mills
and J.P. Morgan Securities analyst Taylor Harris both stated that
the potential for an implantable device by heart-pump market
leader Thoratec (THOR) could grow dramatically, after Medicare
unveiled a proposal to expand the list of hospitals authorized to
implant the pump.
Thoratec's annual sales figures for 2005 were $201 million. The
device in question is the HeartMate XVE, currently the only longterm, implanted heart pump of its kind on the market.
As the American population ages and experiences increasing life
expectancy, the need for longer-term heart pumps will surely
Case Study 1:
The Levacor Heart Pump
Product Management, Innovation & Commercialization
Songbo Qiao
900143
Based on the description in this case, discuss the new products process apparently
underway at World Heart, in comparison to that outlined in this chapter. How is it
similar or different? The launch phase is, of course, still well into the future at the
time the case occurs. What are the problem areas the company might face at the
time of launch? At the time of the case, what are the uncertainties that still exist?
What could the company do now to manage these uncertainties?
Based on the description of this case, the new products process of Word Heart is
similar to the outlined in this chapter. Recent 20 years, the medical consumers is
increasing; a group of people wants to live a longer, wonderful live instead of simple
one. The factor is that people who got heart disease before, after doing the
operation, do not able to live like a normal life. Therefore, those patients are eager
to live a independent and freedom life. According to this situation, World Heart
select a high potential opportunity- develop implantable heart pumps that assist the
patients own heart, rather than mechanical devices that actually replace the heart
and begin customer involvement.
World Heart evaluates new products concepts on technical, marketing, and financial
criteria. Following, one of the most promising mechanical devices is selectedLevacor. However, the trials in Europe are feasibility only a few months, in United
States Levacor is not capable obtaining approval. At that time the most exceptional
feature of Levacor is magnetic levitation. World Heart specifies the full development
process and its deliverables. Together with an engineering firm, Launch Point
Technologies, they developed a small, proprietary magnetic levitation system that
could serve to pump blood from the heart throughout the rest of the body.
Problem: When World Heart launches this...
This represents a great milestone for the field, for Oklahoma and for me personally,
says James Long, M.D., Ph.D., cardiovascular surgeon and director of the INTEGRIS
Advanced Cardiac Care program. He and a team of scientists and engineers from
around the world have been researching the device for approximately 10 years. In fact,
Long is one of the co-inventors of the technology and a leader in its early development.
When Dr. Long came to Oklahoma recently to direct the INTEGRIS Advanced Cardiac
Care program, he set a goal of bringing the most technologically advanced therapies for
heart failure to the region. INTEGRIS Baptist Medical Center in Oklahoma City, with its
worldclass team of heart failure experts, was chosen as the inaugural site for the U.S.
clinical trial of the Levacor VAD. This represents a significant step forward for
Oklahoma, says Long. To be able to offer the best medical opportunities in the world to
Oklahomans and patients in surrounding areas is one more benchmark for INTEGRIS
Health and the state as a whole.
After extensive pre-clinical testing and preliminary evaluation in Europe, the Levacor
VAD was approved by the FDA for clinical evaluation in the United States (under an
Investigational Device Exemption (IDE) for a Bridge to Transplant study). Levacor is a
next generation heart pump that is in reality a continuous flow device, meaning blood is
constantly being drawn from the heart and circulated throughout the body. There is no
pumping action required.
In actuality, the blood is propelled through the body by a rotating disc suspended in a magnetic
field. The rotor is the pumps only moving part and it floats in a magnetic field virtually
eliminating all contact and friction that can lead to wear and tear. The hope is that this design
will make Levacor a long-lasting device, with the greatest durability of any VAD currently
available. The leading first generation device lasted only a year and a half before requiring
another operation for replacement.
Patient safety was also a focus of the Levacor design. The magnetically suspended
rotor and pump configuration derived through sophisticated computer modeling is
intended to avoid trauma to delicate blood cells and minimize the potential for clots or
the need for aggressive anticoagulation with risk of bleeding.
Another potential benefit of the Levacor device is modularity with all of the
components of power delivery being individually replaceable. With the existing
technology, if there is a problem with one component many times the entire pump will
need to be replaced. As designed, this should not be the case with Levacor.
Of course improved durability, safety with blood
handling and exchangeability are only potential
advantages of the Levacor, still considered to be an
investigational device. Even though pre-clinical
testing looks promising, all of the potential benefits
have to be confirmed in clinical evaluation. That is why
INTEGRIS Baptist Medical Center is participating in the
FDA approved, national clinical trial.
Douglas Horstmanshof, M.D., cardiologist and co-director of
the INTEGRIS Advanced Cardiac Care program is the
principal investigator of the clinical trial at INTEGRIS Baptist
along with cardiothoracic surgeons Drs. Craig Elkins, John
Patients who qualify, specifically those declining while waiting on the heart transplant
list, will be given a choice. After a thorough, objective review, they can choose to be
implanted with an FDA-approved device or they can opt to participate in the clinical trial
and be implanted with the investigational Levacor device.
So far, two INTEGRIS patients have undergone Levacor VAD implantations, the first two
in the nation. Results will be analyzed at the conclusion of the study expected to enroll
160 patients nationwide.
Heart failure patients who are not Levacor candidates have a variety of other options.
The INTEGRIS Advanced Cardiac Care program offers a full array of services. Virtually
every type of modern medical therapy is now available to heart failure patients in the
state of Oklahoma.
UPDATE 1-World
Heart says will end its
Levacor heart pump
study
* To cut 42 pct of its workforce
WorldHeart has ended efforts to commercialize its Levacor ventricular assist device (VAD)
and will cut its workforce by 42 percent. The company said it will no longer enroll
participants in the Levacor bridge-to-transplant (BTT) clinical study but will continue to
provide technical support to recipients of the devices and their clinical centers.
Salt Lake City-based WorldHeart, which manufactures VADs for adults, children and infants
with heart failure, cited a delay linked to modifications in the Levacor device for its
regulatory decision. In February, WorldHeart announced that it had suspended enrollment in
the BTT study while it awaited notification from the FDA. It had made changes to the Levacor
VAD, which uses a bearingless, fully magnetically levitated implantable centrifugal pump, to
address design issues.
At the time, it characterized the FDAs review and approval as uncertain."
With the lengthening BTT clinical study delay associated with the previously announced
device refinements, the company does not believe the Levacor VAD can be competitively
commercialized, according to a July 29 statement.
According to filings with the National Institutes of Health, the company planned to enroll
approximately 160 patients to study the safety and efficacy of the device in candidates
needing a cardiac transplant with presumed non-reversible left ventricular failure. The BTT
study was launched in August 2009 and was scheduled to be completed by October 2012.
Six hospitals participated in the study.
WorldHeart said that it will focus its resources on smaller, next-generation PediaFlow and
MiFlow technologies. The company suggested that the small size of these devices will lead
to less invasive VAD surgeries with faster patient recovery times while retaining the blood
handling characteristics of the Levacor VAD.
Both PediaFlow and MiFlow technologies are under development. Alex Martin, president and
CEO of WorldHeart, said that the company expected to begin animal studies on the MiFlow
VAD in 2012 and clinical trials in Europe in 2013. The PediaFlow VAD has been in
development since 2005.