A Study of Service Quality On Banks With Servqual Model: Rajesh Nair, Ranjith P V, Sumana Bose and Charu Shri
A Study of Service Quality On Banks With Servqual Model: Rajesh Nair, Ranjith P V, Sumana Bose and Charu Shri
7(1): 35-45
Abstract
The study attempts to find out the Service
quality of Banks in Navi Mumbai. It tries to
look whether there is gap between customer
expectations and perceptions of service offered.
One of the most popular models, SERVQUAL,
used in Service marketing is used in the study.
SERVQUAL is based on the perception gap
between the received service quality and the
expected service quality, and has been widely
adopted for explaining consumer perception
of service quality. An undisguised structured
questionnaire, SERVQUAL by (Parasuraman,
et al 1985), was used for the research. The sample
size used was 101 respondents. The study was
conducted in Navi Mumbai (Maharashtra),
India. It was observed that there were five
important factors for service quality analysis
which are Tangibles, Reliability, Responsiveness,
Assurance and Empathy. The fact is evident that
there is a gap between customer expectations
and service perception and it can be reduced
only by employing effective training methods by
banks. The limitations of the study are that the
sample size is limited and it is restricted to Navi
Mumbai Area in Maharashtra.
KeyWords : Service Quality, Banks,
SERVQUAL
Introduction
In the current socioeconomic context, the
service sector has become increasingly more
vital, revealing the need to know and study
the particularities of its operations and to set
up specific management methodologies that
fit its context and specificity. It is necessary
to understand that service processes are
different from manufacturing processes,
especially due to their intangible nature and
the direct participation of clients.
Aiming to make clients loyal, companies
have made every effort to meet their
needs and exceed their expectations. The
SERVQUAL scale is one of the tools that
can help in this sense.
According to Oliver (2005), SERVQUAL is
the method that assesses client satisfaction
as a result of the difference between
expectation and the performance obtained.
According to Zeithaml, Parasuraman and
Berry (1990), SERVQUAL is universal and
can be applied to any service organization
to assess the quality of services provided.
Today, banks have diversified their
activities and are getting into new products
and services that include opportunities
35
Literature Review
According to Lovelock (2001), services
are economic activities that create value
and provide benefits to the client at specific
times and in specific places as a result of
a desired change in, or on behalf of, the
one that receives the service. According to
Meirelles (2006), a service is essentially
intangible and only assessed when
combined with other functions, that is,
with other tangible productive processes
and products. This intangible nature is
associated with this process, which priori
cannot be touched. Services have some
specific characteristics that differentiate
them from the manufactured goods. Gianesi
and Corra (2004) say the following
special characteristics of service operations
are the main ones: intangibility, client
participation and simultaneous production
and consumption. According to Coelho
(2004, p. 36), in service management it is
important to understand how clients assess
the quality of the service provided, that is,
how quality is perceived by the client.
Many scholars and service marketers have
explored consumers cognitive and affective
responses to the perception of service
attributes in order to benefit by providing
what consumers need in an effective and
efficient manner. Consumer satisfaction (e.g.
Cadott et al, 1987; Churchill & Surprenant,
1982; Fornell,1992; Oliver, 1997) and
PSQ (e.g. Parasuraman et al, 1985, 1988;
Rust & Oliver, 1994; Zeithaml et al,
1996) have been considered the primary
intervening constructs in the area of service
marketing because ultimately they lead to
the development of consumer loyalty or repatronization of a product or service.
SERVQUAL
According to Parasuraman, Zeithaml and
Berry (1985), regardless of the type of
service, consumers basically use the same
criteria to assess quality. Service quality is
a general opinion the client forms regarding
its delivery, which is constituted by a series
of successful or unsuccessful experiences.
Managing gaps in service will help the
company improve its quality. But gaps are
not the only means clients use to judge a
service. They can also use five broad-based
dimensions as judgment criteria: reliability,
tangibility, responsibility, security and
empathy (LOVELOCK, 2001).
These dimensions are briefly commented
below (BATESON and HOFFMAN, 2001;
LOVELOCK, 2001):
37
Objectives
The objectives of this research paper are:
To ascertain any actual or perceived
gaps between customer expectations and
perceptions of the service offered.
To study service quality in the banks
particularly in Navi Mumbai.
To provide a small contribution towards
improving banking service by adapting
and using an instrument that, if well
used, can generate interesting results for
the improvement of banks.
To identify the three most important
parameters (gaps) of Service Quality for
both expectations and perceptions of the
service offered in banking sector.
To find out impact of Gender on the three
most important identified parameters of
Service Quality for both Expectations
and Perceptions
To find out impact of Occupation on
the three most important parameters of
Service Quality for both Expectations
and Perceptions
Methodology
A descriptive research was used to gain an
insight into consumers perceived service
quality offered by banks with respect to five
dimensions of SERVQUAL scale. Primary
data were collected for the research. An
undisguised structured questionnaire,
SERVQUAL by (Parasuraman, et al 1985),
was used for the research. The sample size
used was 101 respondents. The study was
conducted in Navi Mumbai, India. The
respondents were selected on the basis of
E
5.2277
P
5.0495
P-E
-0.1782
5.0099
4.9109
-0.0990
5.3564
5.0198
-0.3366
5.1188
5.0297
-0.0891
E
P
P-E
5.5941 5.0990 -0.4951
39
3. RESPONSIVENESS
5. EMPATHY
NAME
P-E
-0.7327
-0.5248
-0.5545
-0.2578
40
P-E
NAME
P-E
5.2673
5.0396
-0.2277
5.1683
4.9208
-0.2475
4.9703
4.9109
-0.0594
5.297
4.9604
-0.3366
5.5149
5.3465
-0.1684
to
Obtain
- 0.1757
- 0.3457
-0.5175
-0.3720
- 0.2080
- 0.3234
df
Asymp. Sig.
(2 sides)
6.466a
.373
Likelihood Ratio
7.123
.310
Linear-by-Linear
Association
2.9.3
.088
N of Valid Cases
101
Pearson Chi-Square
Continuty Correction
41
Hypothesis 2:
H2O: There is no significant impact of gender
and the expectation of valued customers on
the parameter ie, Willingness to help.
H2A: There is significant impact of gender
and the expectation of valued customers on
the parameter ie, Willingness to help.
Table
4:
EXPECTATION
WILLINGNESS * GENDER
ON
Hypothesis 4:
Chi-Square Test
Value
df
Asymp. Sig.
(2 sides)
5.859a
.320
Likelihood Ratio
6.345
..724
Linear-by-Linear
Association
009
.924
N of Valid Cases
101
Hypothesis 3:
H3O: There is no significant impact of gender
and the expectation of valued customers on
the parameter, ie, Safety of transactions.
H3A: There is significant impact of gender
and the expectation of valued customers on
the parameter, ie, Safety of transactions.
Table 5: EXPECTATION ON SAFTEY
* GENDER
Chi-Square Test
Pearson Chi-Square
Continuty Correction
Chi-Square Test
Value
df
Asymp. Sig.
(2 sides)
9.906a
.129
Likelihood Ratio
12.676
.048
Linear-by-Linear
Association
3.445
.063
N of Valid Cases
101
Pearson Chi-Square
Continuty Correction
42
Value
df
Asymp.
Sig. (2
sides)
4.472a
..613
Likelihood Ratio
4.717
.581
Linear-by-Linear
Association
.540
.463
N of Valid Cases
101
Pearson Chi-Square
Continuty Correction
Hypothesis 5:
H5O: There is no significant impact of gender
and the perception of valued customers on
the parameter, ie Willingness to help.
H5A: There is significant impact of gender
and the perception of valued customers on
the parameter, ie, Willingness to help.
Table 7: PERCEPTION ON
WILLINGNESS * GENDER
Chi-Square Test
Value
Pearson Chi-Square
df
Asymp. Sig.
(2 sides)
.781
3.220a
Continuty Correction
Likelihood Ratio
3.096
.797
Linear-by-Linear
Association
.1855
.173
N of Valid Cases
101
Hypothesis 6:
H6O: There is no significant impact of gender
and the perception of valued customers on
the parameter, ie Safety of transactions.
H6A: There is significant impact of gender
and the perception of valued customers on
the parameter, ie, Safety of transactions.
Hypothesis 7:
H7O: There is no significant impact of
occupation and the expectation of the
valued customer on the parameters, ie,
interest of employees in solving the
problem, willingness to help the customers
and safety of transactions.
H7A: There is significant impact of
occupation and the expectation of the
valued customer on the parameters, ie,
interest of employees in solving the
problem, willingness to help the customers
and safety of transactions.
Table 9: Occupation* Expectation on
Interest, Willingness, Safety
Test Statistics a,b
INTERST WILLINGN SAFTEY
Chi-Square
Chi-Square Test
Asymp. Sig.
Pearson Chi-Square
Value
df
Asymp. Sig.
(2 sides)
8.539a
.201
Continuty Correction
Likelihood Ratio
9.775
.134
Linear-by-Linear
Association
.233
.629
N of Valid Cases
101
df
5.821
2.420
.201
2
.054
.298
.053
Hypothesis 8:
H8O: There is no significant impact of
occupation and the perception of valued
customers on the parameters, i.e, interest
of employees in solving the problem,
willingness to help the customers and safety
of transaction.
H8A: There is significant impact of occupation
and the perception of valued customers on
the parameters, i.e, interest of employees in
solving the problem, willingness to help the
customers and safety of transactions.
43
1.341
4.830
1.878
.512
.089
.391
Conclusion
Service Quality plays an important role in
assessing a bank in todays world of cutthroat competition. In this regard the banks
in Navi Mumbai have to improve in a lot
of areas before they can compete with other
International banks. This is very evident
from the fact that there is a gap between what
is expected and perceived for most or all of
the parameters and so the banks have to take
adequate training methods for employees so
that they will be able to reduce the gaps
Recommendations
Employees have to be trained on the skills
required to give adequate help to customers.
Most of the banks do not have the facilities
to inform the consumers when the services
will be performed. This is one area where
44
References
Badri, M. A.; Abdulla, M.; Al-Madani,
A. Information technology center service
quality. International Journal of Quality &
Reliability Management, vol. 22 n. 8, 2005,
p. 819-848.
Cetina I., Odobescu E.(2007) Strategii
de marketing bancar, Ed. Economica,
Bucuresti.
Chirita, N.(2004) Politici si strategii
ale tranzitiei, Analiza modelelor. Ed.
Economica, Bucuresti
Dr. Arash Shahin SERVQUAL and Model
of Service Quality Gaps:A Framework
45
Copyright of SIES Journal of Management is the property of SIES College of Management Studies and its
content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's
express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use.