5/18/2015

Selecting,sizingtransformersforcommercialbuildings|ConsultingSpecifyingEngineer

Research
Username
Forgotpassword?

Trending

*******

Webcasts

Newsletters

Magazine

Subscribe
ManageAccount

NewProducts

Power

Sponsoredby:

Fire,LifeSafety

Electrical,Lighting

BuildingTypes

CodesandStandards

HVAC

Selecting,sizingtransformersforcommercialbuildings
Whilecommercialbuildingdesignschange,theirelectricalloadsremainfundamentallyunchanged.Properlysizingandselecting
transformersensuresthattheseloadsareaccommodated.
ByRalphBaeza,PE,LEEDAP,TLCEngineeringforArchitecture,Miami

06/09/2011

Share

Transformers,alongwithotherpowerdistributionapparatus,remainafundamentalcomponentinelectricalsystemsdistribution
forcommercialbuildings.Thisarticlepresentsseveralusefuldesignconceptsforselectingandsizingtransformersinthe
designofelectricalsystemsforcommercialbuildings.
Transformerschangevoltagelevelstosupplyelectricalloadswiththevoltagestheyrequire.Theysupplytherequiredincoming
electricalservicetothebuildings.Transformerprimaryandsecondaryvoltagescanbe2,4004,1607,20012,470and13,200
for15kVClass,and120,208,240,277,and480for600VClass.
Transformersarelocatedeitheroutdoorsorinsidebuildingsinanelectricalroomorotherareasaspermittedbycode.The
electricalphasecharacteristicsassociatedwiththetransformersprimarysideis3phase,3wireorDeltaconnected.The
secondaryis3phase,4wireorWyeconnected.
Constructiontypes
Therearedifferentconstructiontypesfortransformersusedincommercial
buildings.Ourunderstandingoftheirgeneralcharacteristicswillallowthe
designerandendusertomaketheproperselectionfortheelectricalsystem
application.Followingaresomeofthetransformertypesavailableintheindustry
alongwithafewoftheircharacteristics:
Ventilateddrytypetransformersare
ventilatedbyair,uselargerspacefor
clearance,andusedifferent
insulatingmaterialstoaugmentthe
dielectricstrengthoftheair.They
containanenclosuresurroundingthe
windingsfortheirmechanical
protectionandthesafetyof
personnel.Thistypeisthemostcommontobeusedinthebuildingindoor
electricalsystemdistribution.SeeTable1fortypicaldrytypetransformerratings,
dimensions,andweights.

Weeklym
acquisitio
update:M

Achieving
buildinge
performan

Transfers

Arcflash

Yourque
answered
Systems:
Reduction
240.87Re

Energyef
webcast:
frequency
(VFDs),va
drives(VS
motors

YorkLXs
packaged

Graduatin
tointellig

Casestud
anintellig
system

Video:Re
SanDiego
Center:C

Sealeddrytypetransformersaresimilartodrytypeinmostoftheircharacteristics.
Thedifferenceistheycontainanenclosedtankwithnitrogenorotherdielectricgas
toprotectthewindings.Theycanbeinstalledoutdoorsorindoors.Theyareuseful
inareaswithacorrosiveordirtyatmosphere.
Castcoiltransformersareconstructedwiththeprimaryandsecondarywindings
encapsulatedinreinforcedresin.Theycanbeinstalledwheremoistureorairborne
contaminantsexist.
Nonventilateddrytypetransformersaresimilartotheventilatedtypebutaretotally
enclosed.Thistypecanbeinstalledinareaswithcorrosiveordirtyatmospheric
conditionswhereitwouldbeimpossibletouseaventilatedtypetransformer.
Oilfilledtransformersareconstructedwiththewindingsencasedinanoiltighttank
filledwithinsulatingmineraloil.Itisgoodpracticetoregularlytestthistypeof
transformerinordertodeterminedielectricbreakdown,whichaffectsitsusefullife.
Applicationtypes
Therearedifferentwaysinwhichtransformersareinstalledandusedaspartofa
commercialbuildingelectricalsystem.Theseapplicationtypesinclude:
Indoordistributiontransformersareusedwithpanelboardsandareseparately
mountedtosupplythespecificelectricalloadrequirementsinasystemspecific
applicationwithinthesystemdistribution.Severaltransformertypesratedhigherthan600Vforoilinsulatedtype,higherthan
35,000Vfordrytype,andothertransformersratedhigherthan600Varerequiredtobelocatedinvaultrooms,whichmustbe
builtwithfireratedenclosuresdependingonthetransformertypeandapplicablelocalauthorityrequirements,whenindoors.
Transformersthatarenotover600Vandarepartoftheindoorbuildingelectricalsystemdistributionhavebothprimaryand
http://www.csemag.com/singlearticle/selectingsizingtransformersforcommercialbuildings/4efa064775c5e26f27bfce4f0a61378e.html

1/4

5/18/2015

Selecting,sizingtransformersforcommercialbuildings|ConsultingSpecifyingEngineer
Transformersthatarenotover600Vandarepartoftheindoorbuildingelectricalsystemdistributionhavebothprimaryand
secondaryvoltagesbelow600Vwiththemostcommonvoltagelevelchangefrom480Vto208Y/120V.

Padmountedtransformersareinstalledoutsideandareconsideredthefirstoptionforsupplyingserviceentrancevoltageto
thebuildingelectricalsystembasedontheprojectsizeandrequirements.Theytypicallyhaveprimaryvoltageshigherthan600
Vandsecondaryvoltageslowerthan600Vwithcompartmentsfortheassociatedprotectivedevicesassembledinanintegral
tamperresistantandweatherproofunit.
Inaddition,thesizeofthecommercialfacilitywilldeterminetheappropriateapproachfordesigningtheelectricaldistribution
systemforthespecificapplication.Inthiselectricalsystemdesign,thetransformercanbeusedaspartofasubstation,primary
unitsubstation,secondaryunitsubstation,ornetworkconfiguration.
Sizing
TheelectricalsizeofthetransformerloadisratedinkVA.Thisratingprovidestheassociatedpoweroutputdeliveredfora
specificperiodbytheloadsconnectedtothetransformeronthesecondarysideoftheequipment.Theloads,whichare
calculatedaspartofthebuildingelectricalsystemdesignphase,areshownintheconstructiondocumentsrespective
equipmentschedulesinVAorkVA.
Ageneralapproachtodeterminingtransformercapacityandselectingtheproperratingforthedesignapplicationistoobtain
thecalculateddesignloadfromtherespectiveelectricalscheduleandadd20%sparecapacityforfutureloadgrowthtobe
shownintheequipmentschedule,unlessotherwisedirectedbythefacilitybasedondesignparameters.Forexample,the
codebaseddemandloadofa208Y/120V,3phase,4wirepanelboardis42kVA,whichdoesdonotincludesparecapacity
forfuturegrowth.Therefore,thetransformersizerequiredforconvertingthesystemvoltagefrom480V,3phase,3wireto208
Y/120V,3phase,4wireis:
TransformersizeinkVA=42kVAx1.25=52.5kVA
Therefore,a75kVAtransformerwouldbeselectedforthisapplicationoutoftheavailablestandardratingsfora480Vprimary
to208Y/120Vsecondary.Themostcommonbuildingindustrystandardratingsare3,6,9,15,30,37.5,45,75,112.5,150,
225,300,500,750,and1,000kVA.
Theabovesimplecalculationmeetstheintenttoachievethenormallifeexpectancyofatransformer,whichisbasedonthe
followingbasicconditions:
ThetransformerisequaltoorlessthanitsratedkVAandratedvoltage.
Theaveragetemperatureofthecoolingairduringa24hourperiodis86F.
Thetemperatureofthecoolingairatnotimeexceeds104F.
Selecting
TransformerselectionstartswiththekVAratingrequiredtosupplytheloadsconnectedintheelectricalsystem.Another
considerationforindoordistributiontransformersisthetypeofload:linearornonlinear.Linearloadsincluderesistiveheating
andinductionmotorsnonlinearloadsareproducedbyelectronicequipmentthatcontributestothedistortionoftheelectrical
powersignalsbygeneratingharmonics.Theharmonicsresultingfromnonsinusoidalcurrentsgenerateadditionallossesand
heatingofthetransformercoils,whichreducethetransformerlifeexpectancy.
IndoortransformersfornonlinearloadscanbeselectedwithaKrating,whichallowsthetransformertowithstandnonlinear
conditionsintheelectricalsystem.Kratedtransformersdonotmitigateoreliminateharmonics.However,theydoprotectthe
transformeritselffromdamagecausedbyharmonics.Forharmonicmitigation,Kratedtransformerscanbecombinedwith
harmonicfiltersorchokes.Forlinearloadapplications,transformersshouldbeselectedwithlowercorelosses.Otherfactors
thatshouldbeconsideredinselectingtransformersarevoltageratingsforbothprimaryandsecondary,voltagetaps,efficiency,
impedancevalue,typeofcoolingandtemperaturerise,voltageinsulationclass,basicimpulselevel,andsoundlevel.
Practicalapplications
Inthepasttwoyears,twolargeprojectsinMiamiDadeCountyhavebeenbuilt:the
FloridaInternationalUniversityfootballstadiumandMiamiInternationalAirportSouth
Terminal.Bothprojectsincludeddrytype480V,3phaseto208Y/120VVstepdown
transformers(inNEMA2enclosures),rangingfrom15kVAto112.5kVAinthe
electricalsystemdistributiondesign.
The18,688seatFIUfootballstadiumwasdesignedwithabout12transformersas
partoftheelectricalsystemdistributioninordertosupplygeneralusereceptacles,
smallmotors,andotherloadsinthestadiumbuildingstructureandtheattachedfield
housebuilding.TheMIASouthTerminalexpansionwasdesignedwithabout50
transformerswithsimilarintentasthestadiumsbutamorediversegroupofloadsfor
the208Y/120V3phase,4wiresystem,whichalsoincludedlightingloads,signage,telecommunication,securitysystems,
andotherloadspartofthisbuildingproject(Figure1).

http://www.csemag.com/singlearticle/selectingsizingtransformersforcommercialbuildings/4efa064775c5e26f27bfce4f0a61378e.html

2/4

5/18/2015

Selecting,sizingtransformersforcommercialbuildings|ConsultingSpecifyingEngineer

Installation
Theinstallationofpowertransformersandtransformervaultsmustcomply
withtherequirementsofNationalElectricalCode(NFPA70)article450and
specificlocalauthorityhavingjurisdictionrequirements.Someprinciplesto
considerfortransformerinstallationincludelocatingtheminisolatedrooms
withproperventilation,clearances,andaccessibility.Otherwise,theycanbe
installedonopenwallsorsteelcolumnsorabovesuspendedceilings.
Inaddition,thereareotherspecificrequirementsbasedonthetransformer
type,suchasweatherproofenclosuresfordrytypetransformersinstalled
outdoorsoratransformervaultroomforoilinsulatedtransformersinstalled
indoors.Inaddition,agooddesignandinstallationrequiretheproper
transformerfeederandovercurrentprotectiondevicesizebasedonNEC
articles240,250,450,andapplicablesectionsofArticle310(Figure2).
Lookingahead
Transformersremainafundamentalcomponentofelectricaldistribution
systems.Equipmentoperationcharacteristicswillcontinuetochange.
However,theiroperatingprincipleswillremainwiththesame.Theindustry
trendistocontinuebuildingtransformerswithlesscorelosses,andthat
complywithEnergyStarefficiencyrequirements.
BaezaisaprincipalandseniorelectricalengineeratTLCEngineeringfor
ArchitectureinMiami.Heisaregisteredprofessionalengineerwithmore
than29yearsofexperienceinelectricalengineering,projectmanagement,
buildingdesign,andconstruction.
RelatedNews:
HOKhiresdirectorofengineeringservices08.05.201210:31
Understandingstandbypowersystemgrounding14.12.201100:00
Avoidhiddendangerswhenapplying30cycleratedtransfer
switches12.12.201100:00
Quickconnecttapboxgeneratorsrestorespowerafter
outage07.10.201111:31
Circuitprotectioninhospitals08.07.201100:00
Hospitalincludessophisticatedelectricalsystem08.07.201100:00
Tallorderforsuperhighrises23.05.201100:00
<Backto:Home

Postacomment
Loginorcreateanaccounttosubmityourcommentforthisarticle.
Nocomments

Events&Awards

MagazineArchives

PurePower

2015ProductoftheYear

40UnderForty:GetRecognized

MEPGiantsProgram

ConsultingSpecifyingEngineer'sProductofthe
Year(POY)contestisthepremierawardfornew
productsintheHVAC,fire,electrical,and...

ConsultingSpecifyingEngineermagazineis
dedicatedtoencouragingandrecognizingthemost
talentedyoungindividuals...

TheMEPGiantsprogramliststhetopmechanical,
electrical,plumbing,andfireprotectionengineering
firmsintheUnitedStates.

More

Articles
CareerSmart
CaseStudiesandWhite
Papers
Codes&Standards
Magazine

Blogs

NewProducts
NewProducts
Innovationsfromthe
Industry
CSEProduct&Media
Showcase

Topics
Automation,Controls
Codes&Standards
ElectricalSystems
Fire&LifeSafety
HVAC/R

More

Training,Tools
AppsforEngineers
CareerSmart
CaseStudyDatabase
Videos

More

EventsandAwards News,Views,Blogs Newsletters

CareerSmart
Collaboratingagainst
counterfeitelectrical
products
CuttheCopper

Codes&Standards
ElectricalSolutions
Fire&LifeSafety
HVAC
NewsWatch:Data

http://www.csemag.com/singlearticle/selectingsizingtransformersforcommercialbuildings/4efa064775c5e26f27bfce4f0a61378e.html

Advertising
CaseStudyDatabase
Listing
ContactUs
Innovationsfromthe
Industry

AboutUs

TermsofUse
AppsforEngin
ControlEngine
AboutCFEMe
AdvisoryBoard

3/4

5/18/2015
IndustryRoundup
MagazineArchives
ProjectsinProgress

Selecting,sizingtransformersforcommercialbuildings|ConsultingSpecifyingEngineer
ProductoftheYear

Lighting
Plumbing,Piping

EngineeringChange
IEEEPowerPerspectives
IndustryNews
InsightsonPower
ResearchAnalystBlogs
RSSFeeds
SocialMedia
Understanding
Specifications,Codes,
andStandards

Centers
NewsWatch:Educational
Facilities
NewsWatch:Hospitals
PurePower

http://www.csemag.com/singlearticle/selectingsizingtransformersforcommercialbuildings/4efa064775c5e26f27bfce4f0a61378e.html

InternetProfiles
Magazine
CSEProduct&Media
Showcase

HowtoContrib
ContactUs
Magazine
ContentStream
MagazineArch
EGSAOnPea
Performance
PlantEngineeri
PrivacyPolicy
PurePower
Subscribe

4/4