BUS322Tutorial5 Solution
BUS322Tutorial5 Solution
1 Amber McClain
Amber McClain, the currency speculator we met earlier in the chapter,sells eight June futures contracts for
500,000 pesos at the closing price quoted in Exhibit 8.1.
a. What is the value of her position at maturity if the ending spot rate is $0.12000/Ps?
b. What is the value of her position at maturity if the ending spot rate is $0.09800/Ps?
c. What is the value of her position at maturity if the ending spot rate is $0.11000/Ps?
Assumptions
Number of pesos per futures contract
Number of contracts
Buy or sell the peso futures?
Ending spot rate ($/peso)
June futures settle price from Exh8.1 ($/peso)
Spot - Futures
Value of total position at maturity (US$)
Value = - Notional x (Spot - Futures) x 8
a.
Values
500,000
8.00
Sell
b.
Values
500,000
8.00
Sell
c.
Values
500,000
8.00
Sell
$0.12000
$0.10773
$0.01227
$0.09800
$0.10773
($0.00973)
$0.11000
$0.10773
$0.00227
($49,080.00)
$38,920.00
($9,080.00)
Interpretation
Amber buys at the spot price and sells at the futures price.
If the futures price is greater than the ending spot price, she makes a profit.
a)
Values
12,500,000
180
$0.008000
$0.000080
b)
Values
12,500,000
180
$0.008000
$0.000080
c)
Values
12,500,000
180
$0.008000
$0.000080
d)
Values
12,500,000
180
$0.008000
$0.000080
e)
Values
12,500,000
180
$0.008000
$0.000080
f)
Values
12,500,000
180
$0.008000
$0.000080
g)
Values
12,500,000
180
$0.008000
$0.000080
110.00
$0.009091
115.00
$0.008696
120.00
$0.008333
125.00
$0.008000
130.00
$0.007692
135.00
$0.007407
140.00
$0.007143
$0.000000
($0.000080)
($0.000080)
$0.000000
($0.000080)
($0.000080)
$0.000000
($0.000080)
($0.000080)
$0.000000
($0.000080)
($0.000080)
$0.000308
($0.000080)
$0.000228
$0.000593
($0.000080)
$0.000513
$0.000857
($0.000080)
$0.000777
($1,000.00)
($1,000.00)
($1,000.00)
($1,000.00)
$2,846.15
$6,407.41
$9,714.29
Assumptions
Notional principal ()
Maturity (days)
Strike price (US$/)
Premium (US$/)
Ending spot rate (/US$)
in US$/
Open
1.4246
1.4164
High
1.4268
1.4188
Low
1.4214
1.4146
Settle
1.4228
1.4162
Change
0.0032
0.0030
If Jaime buys 5 June pound futures, and the spot rate at maturity is $1.3980/, what is the value of her position?
If Jamie sells 12 March pound futures, and the spot rate at maturity is $1.4560/, what is the value of her position?
If Jamie buys 3 March pound futures, and the spot rate at maturity is $1.4560/, what is the value of her position?
If Jamie sells 12 June pound futures, and the spot rate at maturity is $1.3980/, what is the value of her position?
a)
Values
62,500
June
5
buys
b)
Values
62,500
March
12
sells
c)
Values
62,500
March
3
buys
d)
Values
62,500
June
12
sells
$1.3980
$1.4162
($0.0182)
$1.4560
$1.4228
$0.0332
$1.4560
$1.4228
$0.0332
$1.3980
$1.4162
($0.0182)
($24,900.00)
$6,225.00
$13,650.00
Assumptions
Pounds () per futures contract
Maturity month
Number of contracts
Did she buy or sell the futures?
Ending spot rate ($/)
Pound futures contract, settle price ($
Spot - Futures
Interpretation
Buys a future: Jamie buys at the futures price and sells at the ending spot price. She therefore profits when the futures price is
less than the ending spot price.
Sells a future: Jamie buys at the ending spot price and sells at the futures price. She therefore profits when the futures price is
greater than the ending spot price.
Strike Price
$0.6500/S$
$0.6500/S$
Premium
$0.00003/S$
$0.00046/S$
Call on S$
$0.6500
$0.00046
Assumptions
Current spot rate (US$/Singapore dollar)
Days to maturity
Expected spot rate in 90 days (US$/Singapore dollar)
Put on S$
$0.6500
$0.00003
Values
$0.6000
90
$0.7000
Note this does not include any interest cost on the premium.
Strike price
Plus premium
Breakeven
Per S$
$0.65000
$0.00046
$0.65046
c. What is Sallie's gross profit and net profit (including premium) if the ending spot rate is $0.70/S$?
Spot rate
Less strike price
Less premium
Profit
Gross profit
(US$/S$)
$0.70000
($0.65000)
$0.05000
Net profit
(US$/S$)
$0.70000
($0.65000)
($0.00046)
$0.04954
d. What is Sallie's gross profit and net profit (including premium) if the ending spot rate is $0.80/S$?
Spot rate
Less strike price
Less premium
Profit
Gross profit
(US$/S$)
$0.80000
($0.65000)
$0.15000
Net profit
(US$/S$)
$0.80000
($0.65000)
($0.00046)
$0.14954
Assumptions
Initial investment (funds available)
Current spot rate (US$/)
30-day forward rate (US$/)
Expected spot rate in 30 days (US$/)
a.
Values
$10,000,000
$1.3358
$1.3350
$1.3600
b.
Values
$10,000,000
$1.3358
$1.3350
$1.2800
$10,000,000.00
$1.3350
7,490,636.70
$1.3600
$10,187,265.92
$187,265.92
$10,000,000.00
$1.2800
7,812,500.00
Stefan had sold these euros forward at the start of the 30 day period.
30 day forward rate (US$/)
US$ proceeds (euros sold forward into US$)
Profit in US$
$1.3350
$10,429,687.50
$429,687.50
Assumptions
Initial investment (funds available)
Current spot rate (US$/Swiss franc)
Six-month forward rate (US$/Swiss franc)
Expected spot rate in six months (US$/Swiss franc)
Strategy for Part a:
1. Use the $100,000 today to buy SF at spot rate
2. Hold the SF indefinitely.
3. At the end of six months, convert SF at expected rate
4. Yielding expected dollar revenues of
5. Realize profit (revenues less $100,000 initial invest)
Strategy for Part b:
1. Buy SF forward six months (no cash outlay required)
2. Fulfill the six months forward in six months
cost in US$
3. Convert the SF into US$ at expected spot rate
4. Realize profit
a.
Values
$100,000
$0.5820
$0.5640
$0.6250
b.
Values
$100,000
$0.5820
$0.5640
$0.6250
SFr. 171,821.31
$0.6250
$107,388.32
$7,388.32
SFr. 177,304.96
($100,000.00)
$110,815.60
$10,815.60
Values
8,000,000
8
6.250%
56
360
77,777.78
56
360
77,777.78
60
360
83,333.33
Andina should borrow in Great Britain because it has the lowest interest cost.
Values
30,000,000
2.00
5.000%
3.500%
1.500%
4.500%
First 6-months
Certain
Certain
750,000
Certain
Certain
Certain
Certain
Second 6-months
$
Third 6-months
1,500,000
Certain
Certain
750,000
Certain
Uncertain
1,350,000
Certain
Certain
Fourth 6-months
$
1,500,000
Certain
Certain
750,000
Certain
Uncertain
Certain
Certain
750,000
Certain
Uncertain
???
Uncertain
Uncertain
Only alternative #1 has a certain access and cost of capital for the full 2 year period.
Alternative #2 has certain access to capital for both years, but the interest costs in the final 3 of 4 periods is uncertain.
Alternatvie #3, possessing a lower interest cost in year 1, has no guaranteed access to capital in the second year.
Depending on the company's business needs and tolerance for interest rate risk, it could choose between #1 and #2.
???
Uncertain
Uncertain
Strike Price
125/$
125/$
Premium
$0.00003/S$
$0.00046/S$
Values
120.00
$0.00833
90
140.00
$0.00714
Call on yen
125.00
$0.00800
$0.00046
Put on yen
125.00
$0.00800
$0.00003
$0.00800
-$0.00003
$0.00797
in yen/$
125.00
125.47
c. What is Cachita's gross profit and net profit if the end spot rate is 140 yen/$?
Strike price
Less spot rate
Less premium
Profit
Gross profit
(US$/yen)
$0.00800
-$0.00714
$0.00086
Net profit
(US$/yen)
$0.00800
-$0.00714
-$0.00003
$0.00083
Assumptions
Notional principal (euros)
Maturity (days)
Strike price (US$/euro)
Premium (US$/euro)
Ending spot rate (US$/euro)
Gross profit on option
Less premium
Net profit (US$/euro)
Net profit, total
a.
Values
100,000.00
90
$1.2500
$0.0380
$1.1000
b.
Values
100,000.00
90
$1.2500
$0.0380
$1.1500
c.
Values
100,000.00
90
$1.2500
$0.0380
$1.2000
d.
Values
100,000.00
90
$1.2500
$0.0380
$1.2500
e.
Values
100,000.00
90
$1.2500
$0.0380
$1.3000
f.
Values
100,000.00
90
$1.2500
$0.0380
$1.3500
g.
Values
100,000.00
90
$1.2500
$0.0380
$1.4000
$0.0000
($0.0380)
($0.0380)
$0.0000
($0.0380)
($0.0380)
$0.0000
($0.0380)
($0.0380)
$0.0000
($0.0380)
($0.0380)
$0.0500
($0.0380)
$0.0120
$0.1000
($0.0380)
$0.0620
$0.1500
($0.0380)
$0.1120
($3,800.00)
($3,800.00)
($3,800.00)
($3,800.00)
$1,200.00
$6,200.00
$11,200.00
Arthur Doyle is a currency trader for Baker Street, a private investment house in London. Baker Streets clients are a collection of
wealthy private investors who, with a minimum stake of 250,000 each, wish to speculate on the movement of currencies. The investors
expect annual returns in excess of 25%. Although officed in London, all accounts and expectations are based in U.S. dollars.
Arthur is convinced that the British pound will slide significantly -- possibly to $1.3200/ -- in the coming 30 to 60 days. The current
spot rate is $1.4260/. Arthur wishes to buy a put on pounds which will yield the 25% return expected by his investors. Which of the
following put options would you recommend he purchase? Prove your choice is the preferable combination of strike price, maturity, and
up-front premium expense.
Strike Price
$1.36/
$1.34/
$1.32/
$1.36/
$1.34/
$1.32/
Maturity
30 days
30 days
30 days
60 days
60 days
60 days
Assumptions
Current spot rate (US$/)
Expected endings spot rate in 30 to 60 days (US$/)
Potential investment principal per person ()
Premium
$0.00081/
$0.00021/
$0.00004/
$0.00333/
$0.00150/
$0.00060/
Values
$1.4260
$1.3200
250,000.00
Put #1
$1.36
30
$0.0008
Put #2
$1.34
30
$0.0002
Put #3
$1.32
30
$0.0000
Put #4
$1.36
60
$0.0033
Put #5
$1.34
60
$0.0015
Put #6
$1.32
60
$0.0006
Strike price
Less expected spot rate
Less premium
Profit
Put #4
Net profit
$1.36000
(1.32000)
(0.00333)
$0.03667
Put #5
Net profit
$1.34000
(1.32000)
(0.00150)
$0.01850
Put #6
Net profit
$1.32000
(1.32000)
(0.00060)
($0.00060)
75,075,075.08
166,666,666.67
416,666,666.67
$2,753,003.00
$356,500.00
772%
$3,083,333.33
$356,500.00
865%
-$250,000.00
$356,500.00
-70%
Values
$0.6750
90
Call option
$0.7000
$0.00049
Put option
$0.7000
$0.0003
$0.7000
0.00049
$0.7005
c) What is Calandra's gross profit and net profit (including premium) if the ending spot rate is $0.7600/C$?
Spot rate
Less strike price
Less premium
Profit
Gross profit
(US$/C$)
$0.7600
(0.7000)
$0.0600
Net profit
(US$/C$)
$0.7600
(0.7000)
(0.00049)
$0.05951
d) What is Calandra's gross profit and net profit (including premium) if the ending spot rate is $0.8250/C$?
Spot rate
Less strike price
Less premium
Profit
Gross profit
(US$/C$)
$0.8250
(0.7000)
$0.1250
Net profit
(US$/C$)
$0.8250
(0.7000)
(0.00049)
$0.12451
Assumptions
Principal borrowing need
Maturity needed, in years
Current euro-LIBOR
Banque de Paris' spread & expectation
Banque de Paris' initiation fee
Banque de Sorbonne's spread & expectation
Banque de Sorbonne's initiation fee
Values
20,000,000
4.00
4.000%
2.000%
1.800%
2.500%
0.000%
Expected Chg
in LIBOR
0.500%
0.250%
Raid Gauloises must evaluate both loan proposals under both potential interest rate scenarios.
Banque de Paris Loan Proposal
Expected interest rates & payments:
Expected euro-LIBOR
Bank spread
Interest rate
Funds raised, net of fees
Expected interest costs
Repayment of principal
Total cash flows
All-in-cost of funds if:
euro-LIBOR rises 0.500% per year
euro-LIBOR rises 0.250% per year
Banque de Sorbonne Loan Proposal
Expected interest rates & payments:
Expected euro-LIBOR
Bank spread
Interest rate
Funds raised, net of fees
Expected interest costs
Repayment of principal
Total cash flows
All-in-cost of funds if:
euro-LIBOR rises 0.500% per year
euro-LIBOR rises 0.250% per year
Year 0
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
4.000%
2.000%
6.000%
4.500%
2.000%
6.500%
5.000%
2.000%
7.000%
5.500%
2.000%
7.500%
6.000%
2.000%
8.000%
- 1,300,000
- 1,400,000
- 1,500,000
- 1,300,000
- 1,400,000
- 1,500,000
- 1,600,000
- 20,000,000
- 21,600,000
19,640,000
19,640,000
7.7438%
7.1365%
Year 0
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
4.000%
2.500%
6.500%
4.250%
2.500%
6.750%
4.500%
2.500%
7.000%
4.750%
2.500%
7.250%
5.000%
2.500%
7.500%
- 1,350,000
- 1,400,000
- 1,450,000
- 1,350,000
- 1,400,000
- 1,450,000
- 1,500,000
- 20,000,000
- 21,500,000
20,000,000
20,000,000
7.0370%
7.1036%
The Banque de Sorbonne loan proposal is actually lower all-in-cost under either interest rate scenario.
Values
5,000,000
4.00
4.000%
2.500%
70%
100,000
Year 0
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
3.500%
2.500%
6.000%
3.000%
2.500%
5.500%
2.500%
2.500%
5.000%
2.000%
2.500%
4.500%
- 100,000
- 300,000
- 25,000
- 275,000
- 50,000
- 250,000
- 75,000
4,900,000
- 325,000
- 325,000
- 325,000
- 225,000
- 100,000
- 5,000,000
- 5,325,000
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
4.500%
2.500%
7.000%
5.000%
2.500%
7.500%
5.500%
2.500%
8.000%
6.000%
2.500%
8.500%
- 100,000
- 350,000
17,500
- 375,000
35,000
- 400,000
52,500
4,900,000
- 332,500
- 340,000
- 347,500
- 425,000
70,000
- 5,000,000
- 5,355,000
-0.500%
4.000%
2.500%
6.500%
5,000,000
7.092%
Year 0
Year 1
0.500%
4.000%
2.500%
6.500%
5,000,000
7.458%
This rather unusual forward rate agreement is somewhat one-sided in the favor of the insurance company. When Schifano is correct,
Schifano pays the full difference in rates to the insurance company. But when interest rates move against Schifano, the insurance company
pays Schifano only 70% of the difference in rates. And all of that is after Schifano paid 100,000 up-front for the agreement regardless of
outcome. Not a very good deal.
A final note of significance is that since Schifano receives only 70% of the difference in rates, its total cost of funds is not effectively
"capped"; they could in fact rise with no limit over the period as interest rates rose.
Chrysler LLC, the now privately held company sold-off by DaimlerChrysler, must pay floating rate interest
three months from now. It wants to lock in these interest payments by buying an interest rate futures contract.
Interest rate futures for three months from now settled at 93.07, for a yield of 6.93% per annum.
a. If the floating-rate interest three months from now is 6.00%, what did Chrysler gain or lose?
b. If the floating-rate interest three months from now is 8.00% , what did Chrysler gain or lose?
Assumptions
Interest rate futures, closing price
Effective yield on interest rate futures
Values
93.07
6.930%
Three Months From Now
Floating Rate is
Floating Rate is
6.000%
8.000%
6.000%
-6.930%
-0.930%
Loss
8.000%
-6.930%
1.070%
Gain
Heather finds that she can swap her current floating rate payments for fixed payments of 7.00% per annum. (CB Solutions's
weighted average cost of capital is 12%, which Heather calculates to be 6% per six month period, compounded semiannually).
a. If LIBOR rises at the rate of 50 basis points per six month period, starting tomorrow, how much does Heather save or cost her
company by making this swap?
b. If LIBOR falls at the rate of 25 basis points per six month period, starting tomorrow, how much does Heather save or cost her
company by making this swap?
Assumptions
Notional principal
LIBOR, per annum
Spread paid over LIBOR, per annum
Swap rate, to pay fixed, per annum
Values
5,000,000
4.000%
2.000%
7.000%
First
6-months
Second
6-months
Third
6-months
Fourth
6-months
0.500%
4.500%
5.000%
5.500%
6.000%
-2.250%
-1.000%
-3.250%
-2.500%
-1.000%
-3.500%
-2.750%
-1.000%
-3.750%
-3.000%
-1.000%
-4.000%
Swap Agreement:
Pay fixed (for 6-months)
Receive floating (LIBOR for 6 months)
-3.500%
2.250%
-3.500%
2.500%
-3.500%
2.750%
-3.500%
3.000%
-4.500%
-4.500%
-4.500%
-4.500%
Swap savings?
Net interest after swap
Loan agreement interest
Swap savings (swap cost)
$
$
(225,000)
(162,500)
(62,500)
$
$
(225,000)
(175,000)
(50,000)
$
$
(225,000)
(187,500)
(37,500)
$
$
(225,000)
(200,000)
(25,000)
-0.250%
3.750%
3.500%
3.250%
3.000%
-1.875%
-1.000%
-2.875%
-1.750%
-1.000%
-2.750%
-1.625%
-1.000%
-2.625%
-1.500%
-1.000%
-2.500%
Swap Agreement:
Pay fixed (for 6-months)
Receive floating (LIBOR for 6 months)
-3.500%
1.875%
-3.500%
1.750%
-3.500%
1.625%
-3.500%
1.500%
-4.500%
-4.500%
-4.500%
-4.500%
Swap savings?
Net interest after swap
Loan agreement interest
Swap savings (swap cost)
$
$
(225,000)
(143,750)
(81,250)
$
$
(225,000)
(137,500)
(87,500)
$
$
In both cases CB Solutions is suffering higher total interest costs as a result of the swap.
(225,000)
(131,250)
(93,750)
$
$
(225,000)
(125,000)
(100,000)
Assumptions
Credit rating
Prefers to borrow
Fixed-rate cost of borrowing
Floating-rate cost of borrowing:
LIBOR (value is unimportant)
Spread
Total floating-rate
Comparative Advantage in Borrowing
Lluvia's absolute advantage:
in fixed rate borrowing
in floating-rate borrowing
Comparative advantage in fixed rate
One Possibility
Lluvia borrows fixed
Paraguas borrows floating
Lluvia pays Paraguas floating (LIBOR)
Paraguas pays Lluvia fixed
Net interest after swap
Savings (own borrowing versus net swap):
If Lluvia borrowed floating
If Lluvia borrows fixed & swaps with Paraguas
Xavier
AAA
Floating
8.000%
Zulu
BBB
Fixed
12.000%
5.000%
1.000%
6.000%
5.000%
2.000%
7.000%
Values
4.000%
1.000%
3.000%
Xavier
-8.000%
---5.000%
8.500%
-4.500%
Zulu
---7.000%
5.000%
-8.500%
-10.500%
6.000%
4.500%
1.500%
12.000%
10.500%
1.500%
The 3.0% comparative advantage enjoyed by Lluvia represents the opportunity set for improvement for
both parties. This could be a 1.5% savings for each (as in the example shown) or any other combination
which distributes the 3.0% between the two parties.
Values
10,000,000
1.5000
1.5560
5.20%
2.20%
Year 0
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
5.56%
5.56%
5.56%
###
###
###
SFr. 301,500
SFr. 301,500
SFr. 15,301,500
SFr. 15,000,000
Settlement:
Cash inflow
Cash outflow
Net cash settlement of unwinding
3-year ask
5.59%
2.01%
10,000,000
3- year bid
5.56%
1.93%
1.5000
Swap Rates
Original: US dollar
Original: Swiss franc
2.01%
2.01%
2.01%
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
$
5.20%
$
$
556,000
0.9506
528,517
$
$
10,066,750
2.20%
SFr. 301,500
0.9785
SFr. 295,010
SFr. 14,944,827
1.5560
$
9,604,645
$
$
10,556,000
0.9036
9,538,232
10,066,750
(9,604,645)
462,105
SFr. 15,301,500
0.9574
SFr. 14,649,818
Assumptions
Notional principal
Spot exchange rate, Yen/euro
Values
5,000,000
104.00
Swap Rates
Euros --
Japanese yen
Year 0
3- year bid
3.24%
0.56%
3-year ask
3.28%
0.59%
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
3.24%
3.24%
3.24%
5,000,000
###
###
###
523,068,000
104.00
3,068,000
3,068,000
520,000,000
3.60%
0.59%
0.59%
0.59%
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
162,000
0.9653
156,371
5,162,000
0.9317
4,809,484
SFr. 3,068,000
0.9921
SFr. 3,043,651
SFr. 523,068,000
0.9842
SFr. 514,798,280
4,965,855
0.80%
517,841,931
114.00
4,542,473
4,965,855
(4,542,473)
423,382
Assumptions
Notional principal
Spot exchange rate, $/
Values
50,000,000
1.16
Year 0
Swap Rates
US dollar
Euros
Year 1
7- year bid
5.86%
4.01%
7-year ask
5.89%
4.05%
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
Year 6
Year 7
5.86%
50,000,000
$ 2,930,000 $ 2,930,000 $ 2,930,000 $ 2,930,000 $ 2,930,000 $ 2,930,000 $ 52,930,000
1.16
1,745,690
1,745,690
1,745,690
1,745,690
1,745,690
1,745,690
44,849,138
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
Year 6
Year 7
43,103,448
4.05%
b. Unwindingthe Swap
Year 0
If the swap is unwound three years later, there are four years of cash flows remaining:
Remaining dollar cash inflows
PV factor at now current fixed $ interest
PV of remaining dollar cash inflows
Cumulative PV of $ cash infllows
4.40%
$
52,625,033
5.35%
1,745,690
0.9492
1,657,038
41,132,542
1.02
$ 41,955,193
52,625,033
(41,955,193)
$ 10,669,840
1,745,690
0.9010
1,572,889
1,745,690
0.8553
1,493,012
44,849,138
0.8118
36,409,603