Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • 63 views

    Marvan, Al Bukhari and Deviant Engineer Ali Mirza of Jhelum

    Uploaded by

    AHLUSSUNNAHVSALIMIRZA
    Engineer Ali Mirza claims to have found a sahih hadith that suggests one of the charges against Marwan ibn al-Hakam is true, in an attempt to attack the credibility of Imam Bukhari and his hadith collection. However, if the hadith contradicted the ijma on Marwan, it would be nullified. It is also possible it was simply an accidental killing of an ally in battle. To maintain the credibility of hadith literature and ijma, one cannot make definitive claims against figures like Marwan based on isolated reports. Engineer Ali Mirza's real goal appears to be launching a disguised attack on Imam Bukhari and other scholars through criticism of Marwan.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Marvan, Al Bukhari and Deviant Engineer Ali Mirza of Jhelum

    Uploaded by

    AHLUSSUNNAHVSALIMIRZA
    63 views2 pages
    Engineer Ali Mirza claims to have found a sahih hadith that suggests one of the charges against Marwan ibn al-Hakam is true, in an attempt to attack the credibility of Imam Bukhari and his hadith collection. However, if the hadith contradicted the ijma on Marwan, it would be nullified. It is also possible it was simply an accidental killing of an ally in battle. To maintain the credibility of hadith literature and ijma, one cannot make definitive claims against figures like Marwan based on isolated reports. Engineer Ali Mirza's real goal appears to be launching a disguised attack on Imam Bukhari and other scholars through criticism of Marwan.

    Original Description:

    MARVAN,ALBUKHARI AND DEVIENT ENGINEER ALI MIRZA

    Original Title

    MARVAN,AL BUKHARI AND DEVIANT ENGINEER ALI MIRZA OF JHELUM

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    Engineer Ali Mirza claims to have found a sahih hadith that suggests one of the charges against Marwan ibn al-Hakam is true, in an attempt to attack the credibility of Imam Bukhari and his hadith collection. However, if the hadith contradicted the ijma on Marwan, it would be nullified. It is also possible it was simply an accidental killing of an ally in battle. To maintain the credibility of hadith literature and ijma, one cannot make definitive claims against figures like Marwan based on isolated reports. Engineer Ali Mirza's real goal appears to be launching a disguised attack on Imam Bukhari and other scholars through criticism of Marwan.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as docx, pdf, or txt
    63 views2 pages

    Marvan, Al Bukhari and Deviant Engineer Ali Mirza of Jhelum

    Uploaded by

    AHLUSSUNNAHVSALIMIRZA
    Engineer Ali Mirza claims to have found a sahih hadith that suggests one of the charges against Marwan ibn al-Hakam is true, in an attempt to attack the credibility of Imam Bukhari and his hadith collection. However, if the hadith contradicted the ijma on Marwan, it would be nullified. It is also possible it was simply an accidental killing of an ally in battle. To maintain the credibility of hadith literature and ijma, one cannot make definitive claims against figures like Marwan based on isolated reports. Engineer Ali Mirza's real goal appears to be launching a disguised attack on Imam Bukhari and other scholars through criticism of Marwan.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as docx, pdf, or txt
    of 2

    1

    [BORROWED WITH THANKS]

    BISMILLAHIR RAH:MANIR Rahi:m

    MARVAN ,BUKHARI and EXTREMIST VIEW


    4OF ALI MIRZA:=
    3

    5Marvan Bin H:ACM is a controversial figure in Islamic History.Many myths are


    6deliberately produced to distort the historicity of this unfortunate figure.
    7Attempts are made to attack on S:ah:i:h: Al Bukhari based upon the misguided view
    8of Marvan.
    9The aim of this article is neither to defend Marva:n nor to attack him ,BUT to shew
    10that the extremist view of Engineer Ali Mirza against this character is a secret
    11weapon to attact S:AH:I:H: AL BUKHARI: .
    12According to a number of Extremist Marvan was a Cafir or a Fasiq. Some Shiite
    13minded proclaimers of Sunnism cross the limits by claiming one who believe that
    14Marvan was a Muslim or S:alih: is out of folds of Sunnism.
    15But real Sunnism takes a moderate VIEW ABOUT Marva:n.
    16He was a Muslim and a SIQH Ravi [Tradition Narrator], whether he was a ASunni or
    17not is not the issue at the moment.
    18Many Rafid:I and Rafid:I minded persons , attact on Noble Bukhari THAT it has
    19accepted a tradition even from Marvan. Some even go further to attack Imam Malic
    20RH.
    21It is proposed by some [ Apocryphal Rafid;si] that Marvan was the killer of Saiyidna
    22Talh:ah RD in the war \battle of J-ml, even if they were on same sides.
    23Some also attribute to him the act of killing of Saiyiduna Zubair RD.
    24Engineer Ali Mirza claims that he had found a S:AH:IH: AL ASNA:D tradition
    25[RAVA:YAH] which informs that at least one of the charge against Marva:n is true.
    26Engineer Ali Mirza [an apocryphal Rafid:i] actually tries to accack on the credibility
    27of IMAM BUKHARI, BUKHARI SHARIF, IMAM MALIC and MUVATTA SHARIF.
    28A RESPONSE TO ALI MIRZA:=
    1
    2
    3

    2
    4
    29IF A TRADITION WITH S:AH:H:I:H: Sanad is found which narrates that Marvan had
    30atleast one of the two stated above S:AH:BI: even then the MATN[TEXT] of the
    31tradition is Not MAH:FU:Z: [conserved] or the narrator and the eye witness of the
    32event was mistaken.
    33Since if this were the cases then neither of the two Great Imams would have
    34accepted his traditions, not even s ingle one.
    35Not even in support, not even as subsidiary tradition or assistant tradition etc.
    36There is an Ijma: on Bukhari even ACCEPTED BY THE ENGINEER.
    37So it is clear that if a S:AH:IH: UL ASNA:D TRADITION CONTRADICTETH AN IJMA: it is
    38nullified.
    39An other possible answer is that it might be an act of QATL AL KH-T:A: . That is in the
    40event of the was it was just an accident that he killed one of the Great S:AH:ABI who
    41was on his side. Such an act is logically and rationally possible and not impossible.
    42WE MUST HAVE TO TAKE THESE POSITIONS OTHER WISE CRADIBILITY OF ALL SUCH
    43HOLY BOOKS OF HOLY TRADITIONS ALONG WITH THEIR AUTHORS SHALL BE LOST.
    44AL AYA:Z:. BILLAHI TAA:LA:
    45Even the credibility of IJMA: shall be lost. AL AYA:Z:. BILLAHI TAA:LA.
    46This doeth prove that in disguise of Marvan THE Engineer Engineered a scheme to
    47attact Imam Bukhari Rh ,Imam Malic and their respective noble works. AL AYAZ:.
    48BILLAHI TAA:ALA: .
    49
    50

    2
    5
    6

    You might also like