0% found this document useful (0 votes)
74 views6 pages

Warning: Full of Spoilers For Volume 1 or Anime Episodes 1,4,5,6,7,12

This document summarizes differences between the Tokyopop English translation and original Japanese version of the manga Kino no Tabi Volume 1. It lists changes in terminology, chronological order of events, character names, and passages added or modified in the English translation. The summary aims to objectively present the differences without commentary.

Uploaded by

Ella Servantes
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
74 views6 pages

Warning: Full of Spoilers For Volume 1 or Anime Episodes 1,4,5,6,7,12

This document summarizes differences between the Tokyopop English translation and original Japanese version of the manga Kino no Tabi Volume 1. It lists changes in terminology, chronological order of events, character names, and passages added or modified in the English translation. The summary aims to objectively present the differences without commentary.

Uploaded by

Ella Servantes
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 6

WARNING:FULLOFSPOILERSFORVOLUME1ORANIMEEPISODES1,4,5,6,7,12

ThefollowingarealistofdifferencesbetweenTokyopopsversionandtheJapaneseversion
ofKinonoTabiVolume1ascompiledbyaJapanesefaninthispage:

http://budusheye.okitsune.com/dawun.html

Disclaimer:SinceIwanttolistthedifferencesasobjectivelyaspossible,theexampleswillbe
givensansthecommentariesandopinionsoftheoriginalwriterandmyown,asmuchas
possible.

Note:TokyopopsversionislabeledTPwhiletheoriginalversionislabeledJP.Excerpts
takenfrombookareitalicizedandhighlightedgray.

Changesinterminology:

*Persuader>Gun/Rifle
*Motorrad>Motorcycle
*Hovee>Hovercraft

Chapter1:GrownupCountry(JP:Chapter5:LandofAdults)

Kuni(theplacesKinoandHermesgoto)
JP:Country
TP:VillageorTown

Kinosoriginalname
JP:xxxxx
TP:LittleFlower

ReferencetodaysbeforeyoungKino's12thbirthday/operation
JP:"threedaysleft"
TP:"threemoredays"

WhenthefirstKinotookthejunkmotorradtorepairit,
TP:HeobtainedpermissionfromKino'sfather
JP:Therewasnomentionofwhogaveittohim.

TheknifeusedtokillthefirstKino
JP:Kitchenknife
TP:Carvingknife

SentencesnotintheJapaneseversion:

o WithahorriblesuckingsoundthatIstillhearsomenightsinmysleep,theknife
slidoutofKino'scorpse.

o So,webeganourtravelsknowingnothing,leastofallwhereweweregoing.

(Changedfromoriginal,Afterthat,wedecidedtogotoanearbycountrybutgot
lostinsidetheforest.AndthereImet,bypurechance,anoldpersonwhothought

mevariousthings.Ifitwerenotforthatperson,Iwouldntbealivetoday.Iamtruly
grateful.Butthatisanotherstory.)

Chapter2:TheLandofSharedPain(JP:Chapter1:LandofVisiblePain)

ChronologicalOrder
JP:Asentenceindicatesthat'TheLandofMajorityRule'happenedbefore'Landof
VisiblePain'.
TP:Sentencewasreplacedbythispassageinstead:

"Youmean,they'reallintheresidentialarea?"
"Probably"
"Thenlet'sgothere!"
Kinoshookherhead."No.Nottoday.Wewouldn'tgetbackuntilafterdark.Wemay
beinawalledcityanemptywalledcitybutIdon'twanttodriveinthedark."
"Ah!So,youthinktheremightbesomeoneorsomethingthatcomesoutatnight,
afterall."
"Idonot!"

WoodsmansBackstory
JP:Woodsmanhasnobackstoryinvolume1(itwillberevealedinvolume2)
TP:Kinonamedthegunafterthefirstpersonshefirsttookdownwithit,a
highwayman.

Mansname
JP:ThemanKinometinthischapterwasnotnamed.
TP:Hewasgivenaname,Kyoshi.

Chapter3:TheLandofMajorityRule(JP:Chapter2:TheLandofDecisionbyMajority)

ChronologicalOrder
TP:Asentencewasadded,

"Youthink...youthinkthesamethinghappenedhere?"

...hintingthatthischaptercameafter'LandofVisiblePain'.

JP:Asmentionedbefore,theorderintheoriginalisimpliedtobe'LandofMajority
Rule'>'LandofVisiblePain'

Kinosfood
JP:portablerations
TP:ProteinEnergyBar

PassagenotintheJapaneseversion:

"Sleepingalready?"
"Nothingelsetodo.Keepwatchforme.Goodnight,Hermes."
KinohadalmostdroppedoffwhenHermesmurmured,"Ihatekeepingwatch."

"Sorry,"shemuttered.
"Ireallyhateit."
"Hermes..."
"It'sboring."
HewassilentjustlongenoughtoallowKinotodrifttowardsleeponcemore.
"Boring...boring...bo"
"HERMES!"
Silence.

Mansname
JP:Themantheymetherewasnotnamed.
TP:Hewasgivenaname,Kanaye.

PassageisinJap,butchanged:

"We'releavingnow,Yourmajesty.Noneofyouroffersistheleastbittempting.ButI
dothankyoufortheconversation."Shebowedherheadonce.
"Whatdidyoucallme?"
Kinoshookherhead."Notimportant.Goodbye,Kanaye."
(Intheoriginal,Kinodoesn'tcallhim'Yourmajesty'.Hermesdoes.)

Hermesblunder
JP:Inthefinalpart,Hermesmakeshisusualslipuponanexpressionwhichwould
meansomethinglike,'whatsortofwindblewtomakeyouchangeyourmind?'
TP:Itwastranslatedas:

"Haveyouturnedoveranewpetal?"
Sheglanceddownatthebike."Youmeananewleaf?"
"Oh...right...leaf."

Chapter4:ThreeMenontheRails(JP:Chapter3:ThreeMenontheRails)

SentencesnotintheJapaneseversion:

o "Youhaveacompass,Kino."

o Andtheforestperfumetreeandearthit'slikeincenseinashrine.Youfall
intoastateof...prayer."
"Hello,"saidHermes."Placestogo.Peopletomeet."

Chapter5:TheLandofPeace(JP:Chapter3:APeacefulLand)

Minornamechanges
JP:TatataandVeldelval
TP:TatanaandVeldeval

SentencenotinJapaneseversion:
"Veldevalwonthelastengagement.So,they'reconsideredthedefensiveforce."

Names
JP:Theyoungsoldierhasnoname
TP:Hewasgivenaname,Yasuo

SentencesnotintheJapaneseversion(Note:Theexplanationsareratherlongso
mostwillnotbeincluded.ThemainpointhereisthatKinowasmademore
sympathetic,whennormallysheisemotionallydetachedtothecountriesand
peopleshemeets.Moreover,itwasimpliedthatshewasheavilytraumatizedwith
theoriginalKinosdeath.)

Rightfullyproud,Kinothought,ifitistrue.
Kinonodded,unabletospeakafraidofwhatmightcomeoutofhermouth.
Thesmellofblooddriftedup,andforamomentshesawalongknifeblade
gleaminginthesunasitprotrudedfromatwistedbodythatlayatherfeet.But
thehovercraftmovedawayandthemomentwasgone.
"Werefertothemas'thekill'."
"Ican'tdoanythingaboutit,"shetoldherselfandrememberedthewordsofa
villageelderwhohadoncespokentotheotherKino:"Traveler,ineveryvillage,
ineveryhome,therearedifferentcustoms.Youknowthis.Inthisvillagetoo,we
haveourcustoms.Thesecustomsarenottobealteredbyanyactionsyoutake.
I'mcertainyouseethat."
"Idoseeit,"Kinomurmured.

Hewasgroggy;heseemedtoneedmoresleepwheneverhesensedKinowas"in
adangerousmood."Shehadtoacknowledgethatshewasinsuchamoodnow.
Hecamewideawakewhenshesaid,"We'regoingbacktothehistorymuseum."
"Areyousureyouwanttodothat?"heasked.
"No.Butwe'regoing."
"Andwhatareweplanningtodowhenwegetthere?"
"Idon'thaveaplan."
"Okay...andIthought'Ihaveaplan'werethescariestwordsI'deverheardyou
say."

o KinothoughtoftheTatanamotherswhohaddiedcradlingtheirchildreninjust
thatway.

o Kinoschooledherfaceandvoicetoshownoemotionandholdnoinflection.

o "YouproposedtheslaughteroftheTatanapeople?Thatwasyouridea?"The
wordsleftKino'smouthbeforeshecouldstopthem.
(OnlyThewordsleftKinosmouthbeforeshecouldstopthemwasadded)

o "Curator,Idon'tunderstandyourreasoning.Perhapsinthenewversionofwar
thecombatantsdon'tdiebutinnocentsdo.Atleastwiththeoldway,thosewho
diedwerethosewhofought.Andtheirdeathswere,inaway,oftheirown
choosing.TheTatanapeoplehavenotchosentofightortodie."

(Modified,originalsimplysaysIdontknowwhetheryouarewrong,orthe
peopleofthepastwereright.)

Shehadmeantonlytobreakthestaff,butthebullethaddeflected.Shestarted
tosaysomething,todenythatshe'dintendedtokill,butshecouldonlywatch
silentlyasthethirstyearthswalloweduphisblood.
"What'sthat?"heasked.
"Agift...forthespiritofthedead."
Kinokneltbythedeadmanandplacedhersilvercuponhisbreast.

Chapter6:Coliseum(JP:Chapter4:Colosseum)

PassageswhichareintheJapversion,butmodified:

o "Kino!"heshrieked."Cutitout!"
Kinoreleasedtheaccelerator,s lllaughing."WhatYou'veneverwantedto
fly?"
"Fly?"fumedHermes."Fly?I'mamotorcycle,forgoodness'sake!Ibelongonthe
ground.Fly,mytailpipe.Ithoughtmyframewasgoingtobend!
(ExpandedfromImnotfine,Kino!Ithoughtmyframewasgoingtobend!)

o "KnowwhattheotherKinosaidaboutamotorcycle'stopspeed?"
Shepausedabeat,thenasked,"No,whatdidhesay?"
"Hesaidthatamotorcycle'stopspeedisthespeedatwhichitcomesapart."
(HermesdoesntmentionanythingabouttheoriginalKino)

o "Idon'tknowwhenthisplacewasbuiltorbywhom,"Kinosaid,coveringhis
uneasewithsarcasm,"buttheydidaterriblejob.Thedesignerhadaslittle
talentasthebuilderhadskill.Shoddy,shoddyworksmanship."
(ItsnotKino,butHermeswhocriticizedthebuilding,andtheresnocovering
ofuneasewithsarcasm)

Names
JP:TheKingandthepalaceguard(nonames)
TP:KingYukioandTaro

SentencesnotintheJapaneseversion

o "Say'hello'totheWoodsman.D'youthinkitqualifiesasaweaponboy?"

o "Yeah.Fun.Yourememberfun?"

o "Sooo,"saidKino,exhalingslowly,

o Iftheawardedpointsforstyle,Kinoreflected,Imightbeintrouble."

o Ooo,thoughtKino.Scary.

o Adarlingchild.Apreciouschild,buthetoldmehehadnomotherorfather.

Awoman'snature.Perhapssheshouldunderstand.Perhapsshemerelywanted
tounderstand.Shethoughtofherownmotherandshrugged.
"Sorry,"saidKino,"onemotherwasmorethanenoughforme."
Isthatthewayofthebeautifulworld?Doesserenityalwaysreturnevenafterthe
mostdevastatingofshockwaves?

PrologueandEpilogue(notitle)(JP:IntheForestb&a)

ThefollowingisanextensionofHermesbloopertime,notfoundintheJapversion:

"Isthatlikeagoblinorsomething?"Shesatup."You'renotafraidthatthere's
somethinglurkingintheforestthateatsmotorcycles?"
"No!Youknow,asyllosomething.It'sasortofargument.Youknow:allpenguins
arebirds;birdsfly;thereforepenguinscanfly."
"Penguinscan'tfly,"Kinoobserved.
"Okay.So,itdoesn'tworksowellforpenguins,butyougettheidea.What'sthat
calledaSyllo"

(ThepunusedinTPissyllogogsyllogism;originalpunisdifficulttopreserve:
sandankenpousandanronpouorinEnglish,threepartconstitutionsyllogism)

Sheneverknewwhenshemightencountersomethinginthedarkofnight,especially
inthegreat,leafy,whisperingwoods.Maybeevenamotorcycleeatingsyllogog.

You might also like