COMMINUTION

Effective
liberation

Robert Pell looks at how rising

energy costs and falling ore
grades are driving innovations
in comminution
ost effective and efficient ore liberation is
at the forefront of the current focus by
mining groups on efficiency and economy.
Crushing and grinding represents the most
energy intensive step in the mining process, and
according to at least one source, accounts for
around 3% of total world energy consumption.
Thus the stakes are high to supply larger, higher
capacity crusher and mill solutions to achieve
greater economies of scale but this is limited
by available castings and componentry.
In terms of the wider challenges in furthering
the comminution process, Kevin Graney, Product
Development Manager at Metso discussed the
difficulties faced, stating: A big challenge in
comminution is cost. As more ore is processed,
larger equipment is needed. When producing
such large castings, there are tremendous
pressures to provide products as cost efficiently
as possible. A couple of years ago we
introduced the 60-110E SUPERIOR primary
gyratory crusher. The focus of the 60-110E was
to efficiently use material while simplifying the
manufacturing process in order to lower the
purchase price of the crusher. These
manufacturing efficiencies have been
transferred into the MP2500 project to ensure
the crusher is designed for manufacturing and
Metso can offer the crusher on a cost
competitive basis while maintaining the quality
we are known for.
There are also limitations to how big
equipment can be designed, and foundry
pouring capacities can be a constraint for

20 International Mining | MARCH 2014

machine design. It is necessary to create

crushers that can process more material without
making the components so large that they
cannot be produced. This requires more
creative design processes.

Pushing boundaries
Metso has developed the worlds largest cone
crusher, and supplied two of them to the
Sentinel copper project in Zambia. The
mentioned MP2500 cone crusher is based on
the industry leading MP crusher series, and was
developed to improve efficiency within the
comminution circuit. The MP2500 crusher
dynamics offer an efficient crusher that is
capable of processing more material than ever.
Two MP2500 cone crushers have been supplied
to First Quantum Minerals subsidiary Kalumbila
Minerals, the Sentinel operator, which has a 55
Mt/y processing facility. The new cone crushers
will be part of the secondary crushing circuit
installed to maintain the mill throughput to
offset a harder ore in the deeper areas of the pit.
The crushers will treat a portion of the ore
feeding the stockpile, crushing the top size to
below 40mm.
Metso has also won an order to install a
20,000 t/d crushing and screening system at
Chiles Minera Esperanza, increasing annual
production of copper and gold by 15 to 20%. The
new plant will bypass much of the existing
grinding circuit and includes three MP1000 cone
crushers. Production is expected to start in
2015. The equipment to be supplied for the new

Sandvik are carrying out projects aimed at

improving the lifetime of segments and
crushing teeth for the CR series of roll crushers
in abrasive applications
crushing plant consists of three MP1000 cone
crushers, three multi-flo double deck banana
screens in two sizes, seven belt feeders, two
pan feeders and nine belt conveyors with a total
length of 1 km. Einary Ojala, Senior Project
Manager, Metso said: Metso will provide
engineering and construction of this new
crushing plant from the beginning of the project.
Metso is providing services in all the stages of
design, civil engineering works, installation and
commissioning of equipment. The work will be
done using the highest safety standards in the
industry.
Graney also noted Metso is continually
looking for ways to improve the equipment, but
more importantly we are trying to share our
knowledge with end users about how to
efficiently feed and operate the crushers. With
high turnover in the mining industry, tribal
knowledge can be lost, so it is important to
assist EPCMs and end users with our experience
and knowledge to allow crushing plants to be
designed as efficiently as possible.
He adds: There are also many opportunities
to reduce energy usage with existing equipment
by making minor changes in how the equipment
is operated. Applications in terms of the proper
sizing of crushers, operations and maintenance
practices are all important pieces of an efficient
process.

COMMINUTION
Metso told IM that the BRIC (Brazil,
Russia, India, and China) countries
have been the most popular
destinations for Metso crushers in
recent times as well as a healthy
market in Africa and the Middle
East.
We are always looking at ways to
improve our existing products
whether through cost reductions or
product improvements. We are also
trying to focus on the services
business and how to ensure our
products can be adapted to simplify
maintenance and maintenance
processes, said Graney.

A process plant mindset

One of the major challenges with
comminution is the compartmentalisation of
the complete process, and the sub-optimising of
process steps. Sandvik told IM that it is in a
somewhat unique position in that it supports
everything from drilling through crushing.
We can see the opportunities to implement
the mine-to-mill concept, in particular in
reducing the total cost and energy consumption.
The industry will also have to come to grips with
energy demands. Aside from temporary
fluctuations, diesel fuel will not get any cheaper,
and availability constraints of electric power will
affect both permitting and operating costs.
Emerging markets such as China and India
struggle to keep up with surging demand, and
major mining countries such as South Africa and
Chile fight to produce enough power. In this
environment, mining companies will have to
demonstrate increased energy efficiency and
reduction of total consumption. The European
Union has identified an over-dependence on
import of 14 critical raw materials. If they act on
this, it is quite likely any new mine operations
will have to be extremely energy efficient to be
permitted.
Sandvik also believes that the mining
community would benefit from more of the
process plant mindset already at the mine site:
Mining in the future should be a more of a
continuous process, including consistency in
mine planning and preventive maintenance.
Sandvik are carrying out projects aimed at
improving the lifetime of segments and crushing
teeth for the CR series of roll crushers in
abrasive applications. Sandvik are investigating
a selection of materials and alternative
manufacturing methodologies for components
to improve lifetimes. Some of these
manufacturing methodologies can be displayed
in a matrix with resistance against abrasiveness
and impact on its axis. The identified solutions
are then tested in partnership with actual end

22 International Mining | MARCH 2014

The new Metso MP2500 cone crusher

users to determine the effectiveness and

comparative performance of these solutions
against standard materials and manufacturing
techniques.
As well as this Sandvik are looking to develop
the serviceability of crushers. Fast and easy
service is a key driver of both safety and
productivity. One of the developments here can
be seen with the quick-release system and formfitted teeth for the recently developed CR810
hybrid crusher. The crushing technology itself
facilitates smaller and more mobile units than
traditional gyratory crushers would, and also
has a greater range in the feed materials it can
handle.
The newly developed CR810 hybrid crusher
has one fixed roll and one loose roll which
releases when uncrushable material enters
the machine. In combination with very robust
crushing elements, Sandvik believes that the
hybrid crusher can efficiently handle much
harder materials than in the past. The CR180
hybrid crusher has a design capacity of 11,500
t/h.
Sandviks focus on safe and easy service is
also seen in the latest designs of its crushing
stations. By mounting it on rails, the entire
crusher can be slid out for service, or complete
replacement. An installed crane can be used to
assist in the safe exchange of crushing teeth or
segments during maintenance tasks.
Sandvik says it aims to reduce energy
consumption in the comminution process by
moving the primary crusher closer to the mine.
In-pit crushing and conveying (covered in detail
again by this years IPCC event in South Africa
see http://corporate.immining.com/imevents/IPCC-2014.asp) is often

associated with waste handling. In surface

mining, this usually represents the
largest tonnage of materials
movement. The additional cost of
crushing is more than off-set by the
savings from conveying rather than
hauling by truck. Ore haulage may not
quite have the same economies of
scale as waste haulage, but
primary crushing has to be
done regardless and is not an
additional cost. In-pit crushing
and conveying of ore is simply
a cost comparison of conveying
versus trucking. It is nothing
more complicated than moving
the primary crusher as close to the mine face as
practical, with an extended conveyor to the
processing plant. Sandvik is a big proponent of
this process solution to reduce not only the total
energy consumption, but also cost and other
environmental impacts.

Stirring stuff
FLSmidth is launching its new VXP5000 Vertical
Stirred Mill which has completed internal quality
control factory acceptance testing. The VXP5000
is FLSmidths largest mill and was showcased to
clients and employees in late 2013 at its
Vancouver, Canada facilities. The VXP500 mill
has been designed to have a smaller footprint
than other stirred media mills which is
especially helpful on brownfield projects, where
equipment must fit into an existing structure.
The mill speed is also an important
differentiator between the low (3 m/sec) and
high (15 m/sec) speed stirred mills according to
David Rahal, Product Manager, FLSmidth
VXPmill: It allows the VXPmill to be used in
applications where the design constraints of the
other mills limit their ability to operate at the
optimum stress intensity for a given application.
The VXPmill bridges the gap between these two
extremes.
The VXP5000 mill also has a unique, newly
designed maintenance procedure designed to
increase safety by eliminating workers exposure
to suspended load while changing out the discs
and spacers. Three VXP5000 mills have already
been shipped to the MAK project in Mongolia,
and one is scheduled to go to the Bozshakol
plant in northern Kazakhstan, with
commissioning scheduled for mid-2014.
FLSmidth has also provided Katanga Mining
with a new grinding mill to boost plant reliability
and enable production throughput predictability.
Terence Osborn, Minerals Capital Sales and
Marketing Manager at FLSmidth said: It has
been well proven to be high quality and reliable
equipment, and we have a growing relationship
with this client.

COMMINUTION
Katanga Mining will also implement
FLSmidths proprietary Process Expert system
(PXP) advanced process control mill optimisation
package. This high-level process control solution
is a proven method to simultaneously reduce
costs and improve product quality.
The mill is running in closed circuit with
hydrocyclones, and weve developed software
that takes the milling plant operation into
account holistically, Osborn said. Having expert
knowledge of mill circuits, were in an ideal
position to ensure that the whole system runs in
a well-balanced and optimal manner, harnessing
PXP to achieve a consistent throughput.
Achieving consistency is particularly important at
this operation, since test work data indicates that
the ore from this project will be variable from a
hardness perspective and this always makes mill
circuit control more challenging. The best way to
maximize plant productivity is to maximize
stability. By running the plant as consistently as
possible, the mine will achieve a better quality
downstream product.

New launches and deliveries

Russian mining equipment company Uralmash
has developed a crusher to be used at
Yubileinaya mine of ore-dressing and processing
enterprise EVRAZ Sukha Balkha. The crusher
supplied was a KMD-2200T1-D which is a fine
crusher with a 2,200 mm cone head base
diameter, designed for fine crushing of rock
product and ore mineral resources.
As previously announced by IM, Uralmash also
shipped a primary gyratory crusher of model KKD
1500/180 in November 2013, to ENRCs
Sokolovsko-Sarbaiskiy iron ore mining and
processing production association in Rudniy,
Kazakhstan. This was the second of three
crushers that Uralmash will produce for the
company. The KKD 1500/180 crushers are being
used to develop the Kacharskiy deposit and can
handle 1,900 m3//hr. These KKD 1500/180
models include high-altitude automated
maintenance and grease systems and a PLCbased drive control system.
Andrey Saltanov, General Director of Uralmash
said Uralmash has great experience of working
with enterprises in Kazakhstan and we have got
an order for these new machines in highly
competitive conditions with foreign suppliers. We
offered the best price and delivery terms along
with exceeding their engineering needs versus
foreign products.
Weir Minerals launched its new Enduron line of
comminution equipment, including crushers,
screens and feeders during 2013. The Enduron
range significantly expands Weir Minerals
comminution solutions portfolio, adding to its
range of mill circuit products. The use of KHD
HPGR equipment in conjunction with the new

24 International Mining | MARCH 2014

The new FLSmidth VXP5000 Vertical Stirred Mill

range of Enduron vibrating screens, feeders and

crushers offers an effective comminution
package. Weir Minerals has an emphasis on
enhancing mining productivity and safety, with
the new equipment being designed to maximise
customers operational efficiency.
Screens and crushers are typically the
workhorses of an ore processing operation, said
Ekkhart Matthies, Weir Minerals Global VP of
Comminution. Weir Minerals design and application
expertise, combined with our product support
resources will ensure the new products provide
optimum performance as they cope with the
demands of todays mining industry, and we are
already developing the next generation of
crusher technology for future applications. The
introduction of the new Enduron brand provides
the quality, scale and breadth of product to help
mine operators maximise efficiency and productivity,
while maintaining field safety, said Matthies.
As mentioned by IM in 2013, Telsmith has
developed the T300 cone crusher which has been
engineered for maximum uptime and productivity
while delivering 300 hp performance and a
crushing capacity output range from 125 to 400
t/h. With an emphasis on lower operating costs
and increased safety, the T300 features a large
clearing circuit, which is engineered to safely and
quickly allow any uncrushable materials to pass.
The T300 has been designed with six cylinders,

which is fewer than conventional units, but

maintains the largest crushing force availability.
The unit also offers a new and improved patentpending anti-spin feature that prevents head spin
to extend manganese life. This is mounted on top
of the machine to offer top-service access. The
T300 is also designed to operate with pressure
lubrication oil, while eliminating the use of a gear
box and a separate hydraulic circuit.
The T300 features the largest-in-class, patentpending hybrid bearings and unlike roller bearing
machines, these large hybrid bearings offer both
a static and dynamic lift resulting in far greater
lift to efficiently carry the crushing forces. The
hybrid bearings also have a washer and ramp
design to replace the conventional use of a
socket, socket liner, and head ball all of which
require time-consuming removal when servicing
the machine, and to minimise downtime and
reduce inventory costs, the T300 enables the use
of a single bowl for all liners over its range of
operation allowing optimum versatility,
flexibility, and efficiency in any aggregate
application.
Telsmith also showcased its new hydra-jaw
crushers with their worldwide product launch at
the 2014 CONEXPO-CON/AGG. The H3450 (863
mm x 1,270 mm) hydra-jaw is capable of
processing up to 598 t/h. It also includes a
hydraulic toggle for reduced maintenance, with
fast and safe hydraulic chamber clearing.
ABB recently commissioned an upgrade to
Vales existing Clarabelle dual pinion SAG mill.
The mill is used to reduce the size of the ore at
the companys nickel and copper mines in the
Sudbury area of Ontario. The Sudbury operations
are primarily underground nickel sulphide mines
with integrated mining, milling, smelting and
refining operations. The Clarabelle mill was
designed to accept nickel-copper ore from
various sources and companies and to produce a
nickel-copper concentrate and copper
concentrate for further processing. The size of
the ore is further reduced in SAG mills, rod mills
and ball mills where all milling is done wet.
First awarded in 2010, the project is the
largest of several turnkey projects completed for
Vale in Canada. This complex project involved an
upgrade to a SAG mill of 10 m diameter and 11.2
rpm that had reached end-of-life with a newer,
more robust system. ABB replaced all of the
electrical equipment including 5500KW motors,
converter, transformer, motor control centres,
switchgear and mechanical auxiliary equipment
such as the cooling system pump skid, chillers
and fin-fan heat exchangers. As well as
modifying existing foundation and air clutch
coupling to adapt it to the new motors. A
number of SAG mill applications were
implemented to facilitate the operation and
maintenance of the SAG mill.

COMMINUTION
HPGR and SMMs

ABB synchronous motor AMZ1250 driving the

SAG mill pinion gear at Vale Clarabelle mill

Sizer developments
MMD has installed a pair of semi-mobile systems
at a coal operation in Africa. These installations
are fed by Euclid EH400 dump trucks into a 450
m3 hopper over a MMD D9 Apron Plate Feeder,
which discharges into an MMD 1300 Primary
Sizer with a short sacrificial belt to an MMD 625
Secondary Sizer. The secondary sizer is
positioned in the pit just after the primary to
produce a 150 mm product for the overland belt
(the end user being of the opinion that larger
lumps damage the belt) and the plant acceptance
size. Currently the throughput is constricted by
the secondary to a maximum of 3,400 t/h. MMD
has also been asked to investigate installing
another secondary unit in parallel, to enable
running at 6000 t/hr, as the Apron Plate Feeder
and Primary Sizer can easily cope with this.
This project included a 500 t capacity Crawler
Transporter which is the newest piece of
equipment available from MMD, used initially to
transport the semi-mobile structures from the
construction area, outside the mine, down to the
mine face. Each piece was successfully
transported a distance of over 5 km and
negotiating grades of up to 8% in fewer than 20
hours. The Crawler Transporter will be used to
relocate the Semi-Mobile Sizer Stations as the
mine develops, to maintain a short truck haul
distance of approximately 500 m. MMD stated:
These are believed to be the first two truly relocatable machines of this size in Africa, with all
previous machines by other suppliers using
equipment that was so large, and relocation so
complicated, that all attempts to move them were
abandoned and the plants became fixed.
MMD also provided a Fully Mobile Sizer at the

26 International Mining | MARCH 2014

Pingshou open pit coal mine in China. This unit

is a third generation MMD high-capacity
(>5,000 t/h) fully mobile sizing unit, and the first
fully mobile MMD unit to go into operation in
China, where the group has already been highly
successful with semi-mobile systems. This
machine will process 9,000 t/h of overburden
consisting primarily of sandstones. The horizons
at Pingshou contain several muddy layers and
are expected to get sticky in the short wet
season, when the daily precipitation can exceed
150 mm. The material, produced from 15 m high
benches of up to 1,700 m in length, will be
loaded by 60 m3 capacity rope shovel into the
MMD Mobile Sizer. The Sizer reduces the ROM
material (maximum dimensions 2.5 m x 2.5 m x 2
m) to a product suitable for belt conveying (400
mm maximum). The MMD Mobile Sizer feeds an
independent mobile 70 m bridge conveyor, which
in turn feeds the MMD Hopper car mounted on a
moveable face conveyor. The face conveyor,
subsequent haulage system, stacking and
spreading systems are not part of MMDs scope
of supply, having been the subject to a separate
tender process.

High pressure grinding rolls (HPGRs) and stirred

media mills (SMMs) have been successfully
introduced into the minerals industry as an
answer to the need to reduce energy
consumption. HPGRs have mainly been used for
tertiary fine crushing of competent and hard ores
in order to produce ball mill feed, and are
potential substitutes of SAG mills or conventional
tertiary cone crushers in traditional comminution
circuits.
ThyssenKrupp states: Experience from other
industries suggests that HPGRs could even do
even more to reduce power demand due to their
high energy efficiency and their ability to be used
as dry grinding systems. HPGR systems already
have been successfully applied in the cement
industry for grinding limestone, clinker and slag
to a final product fineness of between 30 and 90
m (P80) without the need to use any
downstream ball milling. The energy
consumption of an HPGR finish grinding plant
has been found to be significant lower than in
ball mill plants. This leads to the question of
whether the same methodology can be adopted
in minerals applications. Such a step would
require the use of dry rather than wet grinding
systems.
The company adds: Dry grinding systems are
so far only an exception in mineral processing,
since most post grinding processes are wet.
However, there are successful mainly ball mill
based dry grinding examples in gold, nickel or
iron ore. A lot of the questions which arise for
HPGR finish grinding systems were already
proven in the field as well as in pilot test work in
the lab. Considering the conservatism of the
minerals industry, a request for extended field
testing at least on a pilot scale will be quite
likely. The basic engineering work for such a pilot
trial plant and even a full scale commercial
installation is already available.
Outotec and Maschinenfabrik Kppern have
agreed that they will cooperate in the
manufacture and supply of Outotec branded
MMDs latest Mobile Sizer in
operation at Pingshuo

COMMINUTION
comminution products as part of Outotec's
the machine without having to extract a top
process solutions. Kppern has experience in
frame or incorporate an extended work platform.
HPGR technology as well as briquetting and
The L-gable incorporates a vertical side pressure
compaction solutions. Kppern's HPGR looks to
beam and a portion of the top frame. It also uses
complement Outotec's comminution
a pinning system, which greatly reduces roll
technologies and services and strengthen
replacement time compared to the conventional
Outotec's market position. Outotec's
hard bolting frames.
comminution product range includes autogenous
However, with plant sizes growing due to
(AG) mills, semi-autogenous (SAG) mills, high
declining grades, more optimal flow sheets with
intensity grinding (HIGmills), rod mills, ball mills
reduced footprints are being implemented. The
and pebble mills.
areas around the HPGRs are more compact, while
"Partnership with Kppern will broaden our
chute-work and conveyors are less retractable
scope of delivery. We can offer our customers a
than in the past. With this in mind, FLSmidth
wide range of sustainable comminution solutions
engineering created the FLSmidth Express Frame,
and tailor the most energy efficient solution for
which is designed and built for the quick
each customer", says Jari Rosendal, President of
replacement of mineral application roll surfaces.
Outotec's Non-ferrous Solutions business area.
"As an independent and family-owned
Mobile crushing
Powerscreen has launched two new tracked
manufacturer and solution-supplier, we are proud
to partner with Outotec on an exclusive basis to
mobile crushing plants within the past 12
enhance our world-wide market potential for
months. The Premiertrak 300 is a new mobile jaw
HPGR applications" says Christopher Schafer,
crusher with a 1,000 mm wide x 600 mm deep
Managing Director of Kppern.
jaw chamber, which can produce up to 280 t/hr
As covered in a recent edition of IM,
of crushed material. The Premiertrak 300 crusher
FLSmidths engineers have improved their HPGR
has been developed with the option of a vibrating
frame design. They not only looked into the roll
grizzly feeder (VGF) or a large fully independent
change out time requirements, but also the
hydraulically driven pre-screen, which improves
actual frame design and steel requirements. The
fines removal and reduces chamber wear costs
traditional FLSmidth cement HRP L-gable has
for the customer.
proven very effective for roll change outs, and is a
To coincide with the independent pre-screen
TWIFLEX
OCT
Pagean1 optional hydraulically folding
unique
system
that09:proof
allows rolls to15/9/09
be lifted out13:06
of
feature,

28 International Mining | MARCH 2014

extended side conveyor with a stockpile height of

3.1 m has been added to the machine to improve
stockpile capacity.
The Powerscreen jaw chamber has
hydraulically adjustable Closed Side Setting
(CSS), which can be adjusted in a matter of
minutes by a single operator without requiring
tools. The hydraulic release chamber option
(Premiertrak R300 crusher) incorporates the
proven hydraulic release mechanism to allow the
chamber to dump and pass un-crushable
material which is ideal for recycling applications.
A hydraulically adjustable deflector plate is an
option for recycling applications. The machine is
highly versatile as it also incorporates a new
lock-out function to allow the operator to work in
hard rock quarry applications with the same
chamber.
The new hopper design incorporates a
complete hydraulic fold and lock system which
removes the need for manual wedges and can be
raised/ lowered from ground level removing the
need to work at height and providing rapid setup
times. The Premiertrak 300 jaw crusher features
a hydraulically lowering product conveyor with
3.5 m discharge height for easy removal of
trapped metal in recycling applications and
features full tunnelling to reducing snagging of
rebar.
The Premiertrak 300 can be powered by a Tier
3 CAT C9 Acer 205 kW or a Tier 4 Final compliant

COMMINUTION
Scania DC9 80A 202kW engine which is designed to run at the most
economical speeds to reduce fuel consumption and noise pollution.
Damian Power, Powerscreen Global Product Director, said: With its
exciting new features and feedback from the testing period, were confident
that the Premiertrak 300 will set new standards worldwide. The machine
was recently showcased at a preview demonstration for distributors and
customers and there was a lot of enthusiasm among the attendees.
Powerscreen has also developed the Trakpactor 320, which is the latest
evolution within the Trakpactor series of mobile horizontal shaft impactor
machines. The Trakpactor 320 comes in both standard and closed circuit
configurations.
The Powerscreen Trakpactor 320SR is a mid-sized horizontal impact
crusher redesigned with some key enhancements to offer operators and
contractors excellent reduction and high consistency of product shape for
performance in quarry and recycling applications. The crushing chamber
features a 1,130mm x 800 mm feed opening, hydraulically assisted CSS
adjustment, four bar rotor and twin apron design, and hydraulic overload
protection as standard. New to this model is an optional fully independent
hydraulic pre-screen which improves fines removal and reduces chamber
wear costs
Damian Power, Powerscreen Global Product Director, said, Building upon
the success of the Powerscreen Trakpactor 320 impact crusher for the
quarry and recycling industry, the new Trakpactor 320SR crusher is set to
establish itself as a class leader amongst its peers and demonstrates what
is possible when we work with customers in defining features and
specifications.
Power told IM: With all the increasing costs associated with energy,
plant efficiency is more important now than it has ever been before. Ore
deposits are becoming more difficult to access and more difficult to process
and transport, this obviously increases the energy intensity of the process.
It is a well-known fact that comminution consumes around 3% of the
electricity produced around the world. Other prevalent issues include safety,
ore quality, sustainability and environmental impact.
Powerscreen has looked to remedy this energy challenge with recent
product developments. Powerscreen has had process efficiency at the heart
of the specification for each machine. Typically using the lower fuel
consumption Tier 4 Final Scania engines, which operate at reduced optimum
running speeds with a direct drive coupling to the crushing chamber to
achieve the highest efficiency possible.

Mill linings and balls

Cherylyn Stewart, External Projects Consultant, Russell Mineral Equipment
(RME) told IM: RMEs abiding focus is the development of methods to
minimise maintenance downtime associated with any comminution device,
including conventional tumbling mills (AG, SAG, ball, rod), HPGR and
Vertical Stirred Mills. RME is the leader in mill liner changeout equipment
and has developed the RUSSELL 6V Liner Placement Mill Relining Machine,
to compliment the RUSSELL 3V Vertical Stirred Mill Liner Handler. The
RUSSELL 6V has been designed to service the new family of large Vertical
Stirred Mills such as Metsos VTM-3000-WB VERTIMILL.
The company also offers RUSSELL Elevating Platforms which surround
AG, SAG and ball mills, allowing mill relining crews to access much larger
areas of grinding mill shell during knocking in and liner bolt fastening and
retorquing without the need to remove safety locks and inch the mill. This
innovation was developed through a constructive relationship between the
Oyu Tolgoi mine, Kaltech USA Relining management and RME engineers.
RUSSELL Elevating Platforms are now in service at Oyu Tolgoi and have
proved a success.
RME has additionally developed the RME Mill Reline Director, which is a
software package aimed at defining the maximum grinding mill relining
performance. The foundation of Mill Reline Director is a database, compiled

Comminuting
your maintenance
expenditure
Kppern roller presses have been proven successful all
over the world in plants for the energy-saving high
pressure comminution of various ores and minerals like
iron ore, copper, gold, molybdenum and diamonds, as
well as cement clinker, limestone and blast furnace slag.
For the comminution of abrasive materials a Kppernpatented wear protection of rollers is available.
Kppern Quality made in Germany.

State of the art technology

Process technology know-how
High plant availability
Quick roller replacement

Pilot HPGR testing capabilities in Australia, Canada,

Germany and South Africa
For further information please contact
[email protected]

www.koeppern.de

MARCH 2014 | International Mining 29

COMMINUTION
from data derived from video recording
blows at one blow per second and has
reduction of actual relines captured by RMEs
been manufactured to replaces manual
specialised reline cameras. The video capture
sledgehammering. It is a useful tool in
allows analysis of that actual reline which guides
grinding mill relining as well as heavy
future equipment and process changes. This
vehicle maintenance.
ME Elecmetals joint-venture ball
data adds to the database, constantly
increasing the accuracy of Mill Reline
plant recently received its OHSAS
Director for its other important use:
18001 certification, a UK Standard for
aiding in the design of new mineral
occupational health and safety
concentrator grinding plants. In this
management
application, Mill Reline Director
systems,
can inform plant design and
which means
equipment selection, all
that the ME
assessed against rate of
Long Teng
return for each
Grinding
investment decision.
Media
The next 12 months
(Changshu) Co
will see the global
Ltd plant, has
rollout of RME
accomplished
Mill Reline
a high level of
Director
safety controls
which, in
in the
turn, will
manufacturing of
The new RME RUSSELL 6V has been designed
liberate the full
grinding balls. The
to service the new family of large Vertical
Stirred Mills such as Metsos VTM-3000-WB
performance potential of
certification was
VERTIMILL
each and every RME Mill
accredited by IQNET,
Relining System delivered to date.
an international network of certifiers that, since
RMEs latest pneumatic recoilless hammer is
its foundation in 1990, has remained the largest
the THUNDERBOLT 250. The hammer weighs less
and most comprehensive network of quality
than 20 kg, and is designed to be easily handled
certification bodies in the world. In the jointby two operators. It delivers recoilless 250 joule
venture ball plant, located in Changshu, China,

ME Elecmetal manufactures its premium quality

ME Super SAG and ME Ultra Grind forged steel
grinding balls.

Brakes and maintenance

Twiflex, which is part of the Heavy Duty
Overrunning Clutch and Brake division of Altra
Industrial Motion, supplies braking systems for
both geared and gearless grinding mills. Twiflex
told IM that their main focus over the last 12
months has been the development of a large
mono spring (floating) spring applied, hydraulic
release disc brake for the dual pinion direct drive
geared mills. The result has been the
introduction of the VMS-FL which is based on
Twiflexs popular VMS range commonly used on
mine hoists. The VMS-FL has a braking force
rating of 460 kN which assumes a coefficient of
friction of 0.4 and 2 mm pad air gap, and the
design incorporates Twiflexs unique safety parkoff feature meaning the brake can be adjusted
so when depressurised there is zero stored
energy for maximum safety.
The VMS-FL is used in conjunction with a torque
limiter fitted between the motor and gearbox.
During maintenance when the motor is shut
down and the torque limiter is disengaged, the
brake is activated to hold the mill drive stationary
and prevent the mill from moving due to the
unbalanced load. The requirement of the brakes
is to hold the mill charge at an angle of up to 45.

www.davidbrown.com

W
When
you need a mill drive system that
delivers reliability, maximum availability
d
aand cost effectiveness to AG, SAG, ball and
rrod mills - look no further than David Brown.
Ut
Utilising
more than 150 years of global gear engineering
expertise, David Brown supplies both fully optimised mill drive
ex
sy
systems as well as individual components:
yGirth gears
y

yMill pinions

y
yMill drive gearbox

yCouplings

yBarring drives
y
Wi mill drive gearbox manufacturing facilities right across the globe
With
we can deliver the local support and technical expertise needed in
the global mining industry.
th

For mo
more information visit www.davidbrown.com or contact [email protected]

COMMINUTION
In normal operation, after the mill controller
receives the stop command from the customers
DCS it starts to ramp down the speed. When
reaching zero speed the drive system slowly
starts in the reverse direction to roll back the mill
until zero torque is remaining in the system and
the motor creates a positive torque to just hold
the mill with the charge unbalanced. By slightly
reducing the torque the direction of rotation is
changed and the mill is gently rolled back until
the charge is balanced.
During a power failure the motors are disabled
so the mill slows to a rocking mode due to the
unbalanced charge. This is a critical condition
whereby lubrication to the mill pad bearings is
limited by the number of accumulators in the
system. To prevent equipment damage the brake
is used to provide a controlled stop (between 10
and 30 seconds).
Twiflex and US distributors Hilliard have
recently completed the installation on both
geared and gearless mills at the Mount Milligan
mine in British Columbia, Canada. The scope of
supply for the 40 ft gearless SAG mill included
two brake stations each with 3 off VMSDP brakes
and a hydraulic power unit to provide controlled
braking functions. For the two 24 ft dual pinion
direct drive geared mills, Twiflex provided VKSDFL (floating) brakes on each mill to provide 454
kNm on the high speed shaft. The brakes act on a
1.778 m diameter disc fitted to a torque limiter.
Steve Powell, Product Manager at Twiflex said:
The increase in the size of grinding mills has
become a major challenge to the suppliers of
drive chain components but particularly to brake
manufacturers. A good example is Twiflexs
braking system on the 11.6 m gearless grinding
mill at the Boliden Aitik copper mine in Northern
Sweden which is required to produce a massive
38 MNm torque. The 8 off VMSDP dual piston
spring applied hydraulic released brakes each
weighing 1,850 kg act on a 13 m diameter flange
and can stop the mill with a full process charge of
1,375 kg in less than two seconds.
Whilst the number of brakes and their size
have increased to cope with the bigger mills the
limiting factor is still the friction material. Twiflex
have installed a dedicated test facility at their Bedford
facility to investigate materials both for static and
dynamic duty with this development in mind.
Powell concluded by saying Twiflex focus is
on developing and introducing new products to
the mining industry and the company have
recently launched new spring applied,
hydraulically released brakes (VBS, VCSD and
VKSD large pad) for this market. We are currently
working on low temperature versions of these
brakes in addition to on-going product
development and improvements. Our intention is
to develop a larger VMSDP for gearless mills.
A number of mines globally protect their

grinding mills with Lubrication Engineers (LE)

Pyroshield open gear lubricant, described as a
long-lasting synthetic solution for high-load,
heavy-shock applications. Its high film strength
allows Pyroshield to redistribute loads over the
surface area of large open gears. The powerful
formulation includes EP additives and Almasol,
LEs exclusive solid wear-reducing additive. The
company states: Converting mills to Pyroshield
is a simple process for mines, with no production
interruption. Pyroshield is also clear during use,
so inspection of gears is easy. Pyroshield
lubricants can be used in automatic lubrication
systems, which apply the lubricant to the bull or
ring gear teeth at set intervals in metered
amounts. Pyroshield lubricants will not clog the

lube system and there are no solids to block or

abrade measuring valves. It also will not
accumulate on nozzles, clog or otherwise
interfere with the spraying process.

Comminution with pulse power

Swiss company SELFRAG AG is known for its
technology, centred on high voltage pulse power,
that is aimed at revolutionising the comminution
process within the mining industry. SELFRAG
has already sold a number of batch units to
institutes around the world, including the
globally-renowned Julius Kruttschnitt Mineral
Research Centre (JKMRC) in Australia, and is now
in the process of developing an industrialised
continuous system for mining applications.

MARCH 2014 | International Mining 31

COMMINUTION

SELFRAGs high voltage fragmentation is a

comminution technique that uses electrical
discharges to weaken and/or fragment rocks.
Specialised high voltage generators are used to
create very powerful underwater high voltage
discharges, resulting in the formation of
shockwaves that cause widespread fracturing
inside the affected particle. Fracture patterns
generated by high voltage breakage resemble
those resulting from normal blasting, indicating
that high voltage fragmentation can be thought
of as a smaller-scale analogue of normal blasting
using explosives.
The company believes that the SELFRAG
method has two major advantages over
conventional comminution. Firstly, the interaction
between minerals and the induced electrical and
mechanical stress fields inside a rock matrix is
highly selective. This makes SELFRAGs high
voltage fragmentation exceptional at liberating
minerals ores treated using between 1 and 10
kWh/t are generally liberated both coarser and
more selectively. This has been shown to improve
concentrate quality for nickel and copper ores.
Alternatively, this improved liberation may be
used to increase the grind size of an ore, which
could represent a considerable energy saving.
SELFRAGs Lab system, sold to geology and mining
institutes, has proven successful in liberating
zircons and other minerals for dating of rocks.
The second advantage is the ability to weaken
rocks using small energy inputs; energy inputs of
1 to 4 kWh/t, have typically given weakening
values of up to 160% and Bond work reductions
in the range of approximately 5% to 20%.
JKSimMet simulations have demonstrated that
these strength reductions can result in significant
overall energy savings. In the case of a SABC
circuit with two ball mills (see above), power
draw of the SAG mill was kept constant to
produce a finer product from the weakened feed;
this change in the circuit power balance was
sufficient to allow shutdown of one of two ball

32 International Mining | MARCH 2014

mills, resulting in significant power savings as

well as considerable reductions in other costs
such as grinding media and liners (see diagram).
At SELFRAG we currently have a pilot plant
capable of processing up to three tonnes per
hour, explains CEO, Frdric von der Weid. We
have been using this plant for internal
development, as well as processing of bulk
samples for mining and exploration companies.
In the last six months, third party projects have
included platinum, copper/gold and silver
applications. We have also already completed
engineering work on a modular 10 t/h pilot unit;
this modular design represents a scalable
concept allowing for throughputs of 100 t/h or
more to be reached. SELFRAG also offers
services in high voltage characterisation of ores
to the mining industry. In addition to mining
applications, SELFRAG is also actively developing
exploration solutions for the diamond market,
machines for the recycling of a wide variety of
feedstocks, and units suitable for ultra-high
purity fragmentation applications such as silicon
rod crushing. SELFRAGs batch lab unit is already
installed in over 20 institutes around the globe,
including in Australia, Japan, China, North
America, and Brazil.

Mill girth gears

Engineering group David Brown is a leading
player in the design and manufacture of the large
girth gears that drive large AG, SAG, ball and rod
mills. IM spoke to Henk du Preez, Engineering
Manager of David Brown South Africa, on the
available technologies. Fabricated steel gears are
becoming increasingly popular and represent a
newer alternative to cast gear blanks, delivering
the benefits of steel gears without some of the
risks of casting steel. Fabrication allows the
designer to use a more cost effective structural
steel where the high hardness requirement is not
necessary, with the structural strength of the
structure being checked using Finite Element
Analysis (FEA) modelling techniques.
Girth gear design is stiffness limited and
deflection should be controlled to ensure good
load distribution over the tooth in contact. The
high hardness requirement for the
rim is necessary for tooth loads only.
Stresses away from the tooth root
and flanks are very low, making it
possible to utilise normal structural
steel for the gear structure. Proven
forging practice and reduction ratios
in excess of 6:1 are already
extensively used for pinion shafts
and gear wheels by David Brown,

Several technologies are available

for the manufacture of girth gears
for driving large mills

minimising the risk of defects. Reduction ratios in

excess of 6:1 reduce segregation, eliminate
centre line defects, refine grain structure and
increase material toughness and integrity.
Commercially proven alloys are used, giving
minimum hardness values from 180 to 340 BHN,
and much higher impact strengths, typically 35J,
but can be as high as 90J. Du Preez comments:
Whereas some fabricated gears have been
manufactured using cold formed ring segments
for speed and low cost, David Brown utilises a
unique hot forming process specifically
developed for girth gears. This delivers greater
material consistency and reduces residual
stresses.
Although fabricated gears are on the rise, cast
steel is the traditional material used for girth
gears and hardness ranges from 180 to 320 BHN.
Although, there are risks associated with large
steel castings, upgrading by means of welding
prior to final machining eliminates the effect on
the final product. Du Preez comments: Proven
David Brown procedures are used to ensure
optimal quality and control any necessary
upgrading. With mill power and size ever
increasing, foundries have to produce larger
castings with higher hardness. A higher hardness
often means richer alloys, which can be more
difficult to manufacture, however technologies
such as liquid drenched castings, as used by
David Brown enable higher hardnesses at
optimum quality. Castings weighing over 20 t at a
hardness of 320 BHN are now being produced for
girth gears by specialist foundries.
Du Preez added that Spheroidal Graphite Iron
(SGI) gears offer further material benefits when
compared to cast steel girth gears. The material
solidification properties allow easier casting,
whilst a sound material choice enables shorter
manufacturing processes and the delivery of a
robust girth gear. A well designed and
manufactured SGI girth gear will prove to be a
reliable component in the mill drive system. SGI
has a lower stiffness, meaning that the deflection
under a given load is more than that for steel
which improves load sharing across the face as
well as between teeth. IM