Belt Scale Handbook
Belt Scale Handbook
Belt Scale Handbook
Frank S. Hyer
President
Frank S. Hyer is a graduate of Ripon College in 1956 with a B.A. degree in mathematics.
He earned his B.S.M.E. at the University of Delaware in 1958 and his M.S.M.E. at the
University of Wisconsin in 1968. His graduate thesis, which is entitled A Scientific Approach
to Conveyor Weighing, has been cited on numerous occasions as a reference in technical
journals dealing with the subject of conveyor weighing. He is an active member of the
American Society of Mechanical Engineers and the Instrument Society of America. He
has served as past director of the Process Weighing Committee of ISA, and he helped to
draft the committees input to the National Bureau of Standards Handbook 44. In addition,
he is an active patentee and contributor of technical articles in the fields of weighing and
materials handling.
Cover
Transition idlers
Carryng idlers
Scale
Load hopper
Drive pulley
Skirts
Snub pulley
Pressure
pulley
Bend Pulley
Return
pulley
Snub pulley
Tension pulley
with counterweight
Return
Idlers
Impact idlers
REA
SION A
ST TEN
LOWE
SCALE
FULL LOAD
BELT TENSION
NO LOAD
The first general rule that applies is to locate the scale in the area of lowest tension on the
conveyor. This location is normally near the tail pulley of the conveyor. High belt tension
adversely affects the accuracy of the scale.
IS
MIN. D
TANCE
SCALE
On short conveyors, where the scale may be located close to the head pulley, there must be a minimum number for fixed
idlers between the scale weigh bridge and the head pulley to avoid the lifting effect created by transitioning from the
troughing idlers to the flat or crowned head pulley. The higher the troughing angle, the greater the effect - and the more
idlers needed between the scale and the head pulley.
Horizontal Gravity
Take-up
OK
Vertical Gravity
Take-up
RECOMMENDED
An automatic take-up is recommended to maintain a uniform belt tension. The take-up should not be so heavy as to
introduce excessive belt tension, and should be designed to allow the addition or removal of weights. A vertical gravity takeup is recommended for higher accuracy installations. It is suggested a conveyor engineering handbook (such as Goodyear
Handbook on Conveyor Belting) be consulted for the derivation of the correct weight. If handbook is not available, a general
rule of thumb is: the take-up weight should be no greater than the weight required to prevent slippage at the drive pulley
when operating the conveyor fully loaded. If the sag between the carrying idlers is greater than 2% of the carrier idler
spacing, the spacing between the carrying idlers should be decreased.
If the conveyor is equipped with a manual (screw) take-up, it is recommended the belt tension not be increased beyond the
value that will produce less than 2% (of the idler spacing) sag between carrying idlers.
5.0 IDLERS
Flat single roll, or (3) roll in-line troughing idlers are required on the scale weigh bridge and 2-3 idlers on either side with 5
required before and after the scale on certified NTEP installations. The idler eccentricity tolerance should be 0.015 TIR for
high accuracy installations
3 ROLL IN-LINE
Catenary or cable idlers must be avoided as well as off-set idlers. Training idlers must not be located within 40 feet of either
side of the scale
OFF SET
CATINARY OR GARLAND
TRAINING
.015
Idlers on the scale and 2 - 3 idlers on each side of scale must be uniform and
of the same make, troughing angle, CEMA rating and round (at 0.015TIR) to
meet specified accuracy.
Dial Indicator
Idlers on the scale and 5 idlers on each side of scale must be scale quality idlers
(0.015TIR) to achieve commercial certification per IAW NIST Handbook 44.
Scale
8.0 CURVES-CONCAVE
Straight conveyors are much preferred over curved conveyors. If there is a concave curve in the conveyor, before
or after the scale, the scale shall be installed so that the belt is in contact with all the idler rollers at all times. The
scale must be located at least 40 ft from the point of tangency to avoid lifting effects of the belt.
PT
PT
40 ft
40 ft
point of tangency
Scale
9.0 CURVES-CONCAVE
If the conveyor has a convex curve, the scale should be located:
20 degree Idlers X = 8 feet or 2 idlers
35 degree Idlers X = 12 feet or 3 idlers
45 degree Idlers X = 16 feet or 4 idlers
PT
PT
Scale
Scale
Point of Tangency
40 ft min.
TRIPPER TRAVEL
PT
SCALE
Belt scales require a stable permanent structure for high belt scale accuracy. Any conveyor installed with a stacker/reclaimer
will vary in its incline, elevation or profile therefore this is not a good candidate for a belt scale.
SCALE
1
NO LOAD
MAX
CAPACITY
LOAD
TIME
40 Ft
40 Ft
SCALE
WIND BREAK
NOTE: For outside applications, the conveyor must be fitted with a protective cover.
SCALE
No GOOD
OK
15.00 INFEEDS
The infeed to the conveyor must be interruptable to allow for empty belt calibration. If a prefeed device is used, electrical
circuitry should be provided to operate the scale conveyor independently of the prefeed device. If the conveyor drags the
material from a storage bin, the bin should be fitted with a cut-off gate.
1/64
PIANO
WIRE
STATIONARY
IDLERS
WEIGH
IDLERS
TRANSFER
CONVEYOR
CERTIFIED BELT
SCALE
TRACK SCALE
DISPLAY
CONVEYOR SUPPLY
HOPPER
THAYER NTEP CERTIFIED BELT SCALE
INTEGRATOR
TRACK SCALE
T
E
M
P
E
R
A
T
U
R
E
H35 T 2
H
U
M
I
D
I
T
Y
1
2
3
4
POWER
DISPLAY
CLOCK
SCALE
CONFIG
CHART
SPEED
YES
MODE
ALARM
SET
% RH
7D
F
NO
LIGHT
TICKET
CHART
RECORDER PRINTER
10
To Plant
TRACK SCALE
CERTIFIED BELT
SCALE
CONVEYOR SUPPLY
HOPPER
TRACK SCALE
DISPLAY
T
E
M
P
E
R
A
T
U
R
E
H35 T 2
H
U
M
I
D
I
T
Y
1
2
3
4
POWER
CLOCK
CONFIG
SCALE
DISPLAY
CHART
YES
MODE
% RH
ALARM
SPEED
SET
7D
F
NO
LIGHT
CHART
RECORDER
TICKET
PRINTER
TO PLANT
TRUCK SCALE
CERTIFIED BELT
SCALE
CONVEYOR SUPPLY
HOPPER
TRUCK SCALE
DISPLAY
T
E
M
P
E
R
A
T
U
R
E
H35 T 2
H
U
M
I
D
I
T
Y
1
2
3
4
11
POWER
DISPLAY
CLOCK
SCALE
CONFIG
CHART
SPEED
YES
MODE
ALARM
SET
% RH
7D
F
NO
LIGHT
CHART
RECORDER
TICKET
PRINTER
CONVEYOR LENGTH
CONVEYOR
INCLINE
IDLER SPACING
GRAVITY TAKE-UP
WEIGHT
DISTANCE FROM SCALE TO
TAIL PULLEY
ANGLE OF SURCHARGE
TROUGH SET
ANGLE
BELT WIDTH
12
No. of
Weigh
Idlers
Stringer
depth
(inches)
Belt
Width
(inches
1RF-3A-SG
N/A
18 - 30
1RF-4A-SG
N/A
1RF-4A
2RF-4A
2RF-6A
Idler Spacing
(inches
Idler Loading
Accuracy (%)
FULL SCALE
Accuracy (%)
3:1 Load
30- 60
300 lb max
36 - 48
30- 60
300 lb max
14 - 48
30- 60
7.2 - 300
14 - 48
30- 60
5.4 - 300
1/4
1/2
24 - 60
30- 60
12 - 800
1/4
1/2
3RF-6A
24 - 60
30- 60
8.8 - 600
1/4
1/2
3RF-8A
30 - 72
30- 60
8.8 - 1600
1/4
1/2
4RF-6AR
24 - 60
30- 60
6 - 525
1/8
1/4
GENERAL PURPOSE
RFS
24 - 60
30- 60
4.3 - 400
1/10
1/8
6RF-8AR
30 - 72
30- 60
4.3 - 1200
1/10
1/8
5.4 - 300
1/4
1/2
14 - 48
42- 60
2RF-6ALA
24 - 72
42- 60
4.2 - 800
1/4
1/2
3RF-6ARLA
24 - 72
42- 60
3.2 - 600
1/4
1/2
4RF-6ARLA
24 - 60
42- 60
2.1 - 525
1/8
1/4
6RF-6ARLA
24 - 60
42- 60
1.6 - 400
1/10
1/8
34 - 525
1/10
1/8
24 - 60
36 - 60
NAR-6 (6 stringer)
24 - 60
36 - 60
34 - 400
1/10
1/8
NAR-6 (8 stringer)
30 - 96
36 - 60
34 -1200
1/10
1/8
NAR-8 (8 stringer)
30 - 96
36 - 60
34 -1200
1/10
1/8
13
THAYER NAR Belt Scales are designed to deliver exceptional stability and accuracy for use in applications requiring
verifiable accuracy. They are recommended for applications requiring commercial certification for billing purposes. These
belts have been proven in service demanding 0.125% accuracy through independent certification. The weigh bridge
features exclusive rocking flexure suspension in the approach-retreat configuration. Measurement sensitivity is high,
deflection is low, and the single load cell is isolated from the error-inducing effects of extraneous lateral forces, off-center
loading, foundation distortion, inclination hold-back forces, and high sporadic shocks and overloads. Tare load is masscounterbalanced to create superior signal to noise ratio in weight sensing, orders of magnitude better than belt scale
designs supporting full tare load on the load sensors.
MODEL 2RF-4A
WEIGH BRIDGE
One of the most important components of a conveyor scale
system is the design of the weigh bridge itself. Regardless
of the type of load cell used, a belt scale will not be able to
weigh lightly loaded material and maintain its calibration for
long if certain design features are not in place.
SECONDARY LEVER
THAYER employs a secondary lever system, even though
it cost more to do so, because it permits the following:
MODEL 3RF-8A
MODEL 4RF-6AR
MODEL NAR-6
MODEL 8RF-6AR
14
150%
100%
110%
Maximum Overload
367% of Scale Capacity
40%
10%
150%
30%
Scale Capacity
10%
50%
Maximum Overload
167% of Scale Capacity
100%
30%
Scale Capacity
70%
Tare Load
70%
BELT
STATIONARY
IDLER
PULSER
STRINGER
15
CALIBRATION
A belt scale should be thought of as a precision instrument
and its performance should be quickly and easily checked.
Accuracy and the method and frequency of calibration
are directly related. It is a well known fact that the only
positive way of verifying scale accuracy is to conduct a
material test using a static scale to check the weight of
material passed over the scale. The results of the material
test are used to factor the simulated test device which is
either a test chain or calibrating weight.
Thayer Scale is the only manufacturer that can provide
an accurate reliable calibration using a calibration weight
instead of test chains for all scale capacities. As a result
other manufacturers have had to resort to dummy signals
which (while providing a stable signal to calibrate the
integrator) result in very large scale calibration errors and
a false sense of security due to the fact that the scales
mechanical components are not exercised during the span
portion of the calibration.
CALIBRATE
STORE
CALIBRATION TEST
WEIGHT IN ZERO
POSITION
CALIBRATION TEST
WEIGHT IN SPAN
POSITION
SECONDARY
LEVER
LOAD
CELL
WEIGH IDLERS
16
FREQUENCY OF CALIBRATION
There is a correlation between frequency of calibration,
number of idlers on the scale weighbridge and the
accuracy required. While it may be possible to achieve a
reasonably high degree of accuracy for a short time with
a single idler scale in a good installation it is obvious that
the single idler scale is more susceptible to belt effects
and changes in alignment and therefore the calibration
should be checked more frequently. Likewise, a multiple
idler weighbridge will not have to be checked frequently if
1% accuracy is all that is required.
A common mistake made in the selection of belt scales is
choosing a single idler scale or short weighbridge because
the accuracy required is only 1%. It may be possible to
achieve 1% but it might require calibrating once a day.
HOW OFTEN SHOULD CALIBRATION BE CHECKED?
The frequency of calibration is best determined from
actual operating experience. Initially the tests should be
performed more frequently (once a week) to establish
a confidence level based on accuracy required and the
number of times an adjustment had to be made. The tests
should be based on the As-Found-Error (AFE).
MAINTENANCE TOLERENCE
1.5
1RF-3A, 1RF-4A
2RF--4A, 2RF-6A
% F.S.
3RF-6AR, 3RF-8AR
4RF-6AR, NAR-4
0.5
6RF-6AR,6RF-8AR
NAR-6, NAR-8
0.25
0.1
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
17
1.0
This might lead you to conclude that if you install and calibrate the scale per the manufacturers instructions it will
weigh your material to within the accuracy claimed. NOT
NECESSARILY SO. Better re-read those accuracy claims.
That is not what they say. It is left to you to determine
whether or not you are achieving the expected level of performance or not. One of the ways you can do this is to run
some form of a comparison test which is usually achieved
by statically weighing the material that has been run across
your belt scale on some other reference scale. If you do
find a discrepancy in the results it is suggested that you adjust your standard calibration procedure accordingly. This
is normally done by factoring the simulated loading value of
the Test Weight or Chain that has been provided with the
scale. Once this is done, the scale is said to have been
K-Factored. Unfortunately in the majority of installations
it is extremely difficult, if not impossible, to conduct such a
comparison test.
K = K1 + K2 + K3
@ 200 TPH
@ 500 TPH
$10
$10,400
$2,6000
$20
$20,800
$30
@ 1,000 TPH
@ 2,000 TPH
@ 5,000 TPH
@ 10,000 TPH
$52,000
$104,000
$260,000
$520,000
$52,000
$104,000
$208,000
$520,000
$1,040,000
$31,200
$78,000
$156,000
$312,000
$780,000
$1,560,000
$40
$41,600
$104,000
$208,000
$416,000
$1,040,000
$2,080,000
$50
$52,000
$130,000
$260,000
$520,000
$1,300,000
$2,600,000
$60
$62,400
$156,000
$312,000
$624,000
$1,560,000
$3,120,000
$70
$72,800
$182,000
$364,000
$728,000
$1,820,000
$3,640,000
$80
$83,200
$208,000
$416,000
$832,000
$2,080,000
$4,160,000
18
TANGIBLE RESULTS
USER:
U.S. STEEL
LOCATION:
Corbin, KY
THAYER SO #:
3430A
MODEL:
6RF-4-72
SERIAL #:
1200-885
CONVEYOR DESIGN
Capacity:
Material:
Coal
Bulk Density:
50 lb/ft3
Particle Size:
3 x 0
Belt width:
72
Belt Speed:
550 FPM
Idler Spacing:
48
350
Conveyor Configuration:
Conveyor Length:
Conveyor Stringer:
8 Channel
# of Feed Points:
one
Scale location:
Type of Take-up:
Vertical gravity
# of Belt splices:
One-Vulcanized
Many said we were lucky and that the true test would be if
the scale could maintain that accuracy for a year without
K-factoring.
Model:
THAYER 6RF-4-72
Weigh Bridge:
Weight Transducer:
Speed Pick-up:
Speed transmitter:
Integrator:
SCALE DESIGN:
TEST EQUIPMENT
Test Weight
64.269 lbs
Test Chain:
ACCESSORIES
19
FINDINGS:
TEST #1
TEST #2
TEST #3
THAYER Model RF
973.300 tons
971.200 tons
980.200 tons
973.105 tons
971.895 tons
979.825 tons
Scale Difference
+0.195 tons
+0.305 tons
+0.375 tons
% Error
+0.020%
+0.031%
+0.038%
USER:
DUKE POWER
LOCATION:
Salisbury, NC
THAYER SO #:
7883
MODEL:
NAR-6-72-48
SERIAL #:
1200-5913
CONVEYOR DESIGN
Capacity:
Material:
Coal
Bulk Density:
50 lb/ft3
Particle Size:
3 x 0
Belt width:
72
Belt Speed:
701 FPM
Idler Spacing:
48
350
Conveyor Configuration:
Conveyor Length:
Conveyor Stringer:
8 Channel
# of Feed Points:
one
Scale location:
Type of Take-up:
Vertical gravity
# of Belt splices
One-Vulcanized
* The NATIONAL TYPE EVALUATION PROGRAM (NTEP) is a program of cooperation between the NATIONAL CONFERENCE ON WEIGHTS & MEASURES
(NCWM), the NATIONAL INSTITUTE FOR STANDARDS AND TECHNOLOGY
(NIST), State Weights & Measures Officials, and the private sector for determining conformance of weighing equipment with the provisions of Handbook 44. NTEP
provides the testing procedures for each type of device, oversees its testing, and
issues a Certificate of Conformance (CC) upon acceptance. The range of operating
parameters that a family of devices covered by a single CC can have is restricted and
noted on the certificate
SCALE DESIGN:
Model
Weigh Bridge:
Weight Transducer:
Speed Pick-up
Speed transmitter
Integrator
Series 5200
TEST EQUIPMENT
Test Weight
54.87 lbs
Belt Loading
186.713 #/ft
ACCESSORIES
FINDINGS:
TEST #1
TEST #2
Scale Difference
% Error
20
21
23
24
25
26
SUPPORT SERVICES
TEST FACILITIES:
Thayer Scale operates three fully equipped dry particle
test centers in a dedicated wing of our Massachusetts
facility. A full time staff performs product application and
performance testing with user supplied materials. These
facilities are designed to duplicate as closely as possible
industrial processing conditions.
SERVICE:
Thayer Scale has a well trained professional service
department with an outstanding record of longevity,
experience and achievement. Thayers technicians are
available for start-up support, inspection, diagnosis and
repair service, routine maintenance and material testing
services.
TRAINING:
Thayer Scale offers formal training either here at the
factory in Pembroke, MA or at the customers plant. Each
training class is tailored to the specific instrumentation
and mechanical equipment used in their facility.
MADE IN USA
THAYER and the THAYER logo are Registered Trademarks of Hyer Industries, Inc.
Hyer Industries, Inc. 2004. All rights reserved